EPISODE · Apr 24, 2026 · 3H 42M
Excessive Force or Justified? NYPD Arrest Sparks Major Debate
from New York’s Finest: Retired & Unfiltered Podcast · host Bleav + John D. Macari Jr. + Eric S. Dym
In episode 61 of the Executive, Ron and Rob explore a viral video of an arrest by NYPD narcotics detectives that escalated into violence when the suspect resisted arrest. They’ll discuss whether the force used was excessive or justified, questioning when the use of force crosses the line and becomes criminal. The suspect was later found not to be involved in the crime the detectives suspected. Consequently, the Brooklyn District Attorney announced he will drop the charges of Resisting Arrest and Obstructing Governmental Administration. Does this change the justification in use of force? What does the law say? Moreover, it prompts discussions on how this incident impacts public trust in the NYPD. The conversation will also delve into the tactics employed by the narcotics team during the operation, specifically the use of an unauthorized text messaging app instead of radios. This tactic raises concerns about officer safety and the ability to seek help for themselves or an injured suspect. The detectives have since been placed on Modified Assignment (guns and shields removed and placed on desk duty) and the entire team, including supervisors and executives have been transferred to other assignments. Was this a justified move by the NYPD? Where does the responsibility lie? Furthermore, the discussion will shift to the comments made by Mayor Mamdani, Police Commissioner Tisch, and several politicians condemning the detectives based solely on the video. This will examine how these comments might influence any future investigation into the incident. Join the interactive chat for a lively discussion on this highly controversial case. With a combined 65 years of service in the NYPD, over 40 of which were in the executive ranks, retired Deputy Chief Rob Lukach and retired Inspector Ron Leyson offer an unparalleled analysis of policy, procedure, and leadership in the NYPD and law enforcement in general. On their podcast, Ron and Rob engage in a lively discussion, debate, and dissection of current high-profile incidents and topics of concern to rank-and-file members from their unique "Executive Perspective." Link to NYPD Force Dashboard: https://app.powerbigov.us/view?r=eyJrIjoiZTRkY2QxYjQtNDI2OS00YzFhLWI2YzktM2FmNDIxNjNhOWU3IiwidCI6IjJiOWY1N2ViLTc4ZDEtNDZmYi1iZTgzLWEyYWZkZDdjNjA0MyJ9 Link to National Institute of Justice (NIJ) Force Continuum: https://nij.ojp.gov/topics/articles/use-force-continuum Link to NY Daily News article: https://www.nydailynews.com/2026/04/19/new-video-shows-another-angle-of-rough-nypd-arrest-inside-brooklyn-liquor-store/ Link to AMNY article: https://www.amny.com/news/nypd-narcotics-division-investigation-tisch-brooklyn-cops/ Find prior episodes of the Executive Perspective at: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PL_YGTl92zUEtavc4-pl83mX4fjhVfv5xr Contact Ron and Rob: On X - @ExecPerspective email - [email protected] ️ New to streaming or looking to level up? Check out StreamYard and get $10 discount! https://streamyard.com/pal/d/5689366474915840 Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.
Embed this episode
What this episode covers
In episode 61 of the Executive, Ron and Rob explore a viral video of an arrest by NYPD narcotics detectives that escalated into violence when the suspect resisted arrest. They’ll discuss whether the force used was excessive or justified, questioning when the use of force crosses the line and becomes criminal. The suspect was later found not to be involved in the crime the detectives suspected. Consequently, the Brooklyn District Attorney announced he will drop the charges of Resisting Arrest and Obstructing Governmental Administration. Does this change the justification in use of force? What does the law say? Moreover, it prompts discussions on how this incident impacts public trust in the NYPD. The conversation will also delve into the tactics employed by the narcotics team during the operation, specifically the use of an unauthorized text messaging app instead of radios. This tactic raises concerns about officer safety and the ability to seek help for themselves or an injured suspect. The detectives have since been placed on Modified Assignment (guns and shields removed and placed on desk duty) and the entire team, including supervisors and executives have been transferred to other assignments. Was this a justified move by the NYPD? Where does the responsibility lie? Furthermore, the discussion will shift to the comments made by Mayor Mamdani, Police Commissioner Tisch, and several politicians condemning the detectives based solely on the video. This will examine how these comments might influence any future investigation into the incident. Join the interactive chat for a lively discussion on this highly controversial case. With a combined 65 years of service in the NYPD, over 40 of which were in the executive ranks, retired Deputy Chief Rob Lukach and retired Inspector Ron Leyson offer an unparalleled analysis of policy, procedure, and leadership in the NYPD and law enforcement in general. On their podcast, Ron and Rob engage in a lively discussion, debate, and dissection of current high-profile incidents and topics of concern to rank-and-file members from their unique "Executive Perspective."
NOW PLAYING
Excessive Force or Justified? NYPD Arrest Sparks Major Debate
No transcript for this episode yet
Similar Episodes
No similar episodes found.
Similar Podcasts
No similar podcasts found.