Hey everybody, this is Brent from Beam Me Up Star Trek podcast. As you may know, Matt and I have finished recording the main run of the show. However, over the course of our three and a half years of recording the show, we actually recorded several episodes that to this point have either gone unaired or they were exclusive to our Patreon page. Well, now that we're on the backside of the main show, we thought that it would be a great time to release those episodes to you guys out there, our listening audience. Plus, you never know when Matt and I may jump in with a random new episode. The final frontier begins. This is about saving the future of humanity. This is a huge victory for the good guys.
Welcome to not just any other episode of Beam Me Up, a Star Trek podcast. No, it's that time of month again where it's time for our special Patreon exclusive extra viewing episodes. You guys know me. I'm Matt. Nope, I'm not Matt. I'm Brent. Switching things up tonight. Well, you know, it's, it's a, listen, you know what I always say? I'm going to look over here and take a drink. I never tell you what's in the drink, you know?
except I just saw you refill it. So you did, you did. And it's nothing nefarious for sure. That's just me getting a little tongue tied, honestly, is all that was. But you know, Hey, it is what it is. I would, I would worry about this much more if this was going out on the main feed, but these are our friends. Like these are our friends who are listening to this one. If they don't know who we are by now.
Exactly. Exactly. And then we're talking about wit and Eric and Kristen, Alexandra, Coriana and Sam. And if anybody else is joining us in the future, you too are one of our friends. And so we'll just get to hang out. You guys are our best supporters. You guys have been, you know what? I'm really glad with this group, Matt. We've not lost anyone, you know, like a lot of times on Patreon, like people come in, they stay for a couple months, they go away. Like this group has stayed pretty steady and you guys are awesome. You really are. So thank you so much for all of your support. And we hope you guys have been getting the early releases when we get those out to you as early as we can. Basically, it's just, am I on top of editing and getting things out there? Hopefully. So you're enjoying those.
you're enjoying these uh patreon exclusives uh matt i did i think i mentioned to you last time i extended an invitation to our patrons to join me for charting the course uh because we have like five episodes five seasons five or six seasons left where we're recording this right now to do but we gotta get sounds ridiculous it sounds absolutely ridiculous but like i was like i've i've already plotted my way through enterprise and i think i know how i want to do it it might make some people mad okay but i i know zero yeah about enterprise like i i think i've mentioned this before recently but i think like we've run across all of the character names that i know yeah so i don't know that i know anybody from enterprise you there might be one You might have heard of the captain, possibly the doctor out of Enterprise, but I don't think you would have heard of anybody else. I couldn't give you the names right now. Maybe you're right. Maybe I have heard them somewhere and just didn't know who they were. But yeah, we have that.
Like I say, I think I recently compared our viewing here to like a bell curve. Like we saw really few of the TOS episodes. Like we got what TOS was about pretty quick, you know, and then we ramped up with TNG, but still TNG was very episodic, you know, alien of the week kind of a thing. And we actually doubled the amount of episodes that we watched from TOS, but then we got into Deep Space Nine and it feels like we've been in Deep Space Nine for a really long, long time. It does. But we have been doing that while we were doing TNG and while we've been doing Voyager. So it's been very spread out, but we have watched more Deep Space Nine than we have anything else, you know, and we're watching.
Like that's like the top of the boat. And then, and when you, when you factor in all the like double and triple episodes that we've done. Exactly. Exactly. And then Voyager is now on the other side of the curve where we're, we're not watching as much of that as we did deep space nine and enterprise is going to find itself at the bottom of that bell curve on the other side, kind of mirroring TOS. I think, I think, I don't know. Our patrons are going to help me figure that out as we get a little bit closer to that. And then that's going to get us to the end of this podcast, like the whole thing, which is, which is kind of crazy. And who knows what we'll do after that. We'll figure it out when we get there. Number five year journey, the five year mission, right? Oh man, this will be like the missing two years from now. It's been more than two.
I think I said, I thought that this was gonna take a two years and it's not, it's taken, taken. Oh yeah. It's definitely over two years. Somewhere around three. Yeah. So anyway, guys, thank you so much for, for what you guys have been doing. Today's extra viewing episode is episode is from season seven of deep space nine entitled after image, or as I like to call it, the one where Esri makes the completely wrong decision in this episode, Esri Dax has to decide between staying on deep space nine or leaving. That's, that's the oomph of this episode. Matt, you picked this episode to watch as extra viewing. We've like in our, in our timeline of everything we've just watched.
The intro of Esri, you know, we had all that stuff with Cisco where we found out Cisco's part prophet and Jadzia dies. And, you know, we get the new deck symbiote. This is the episode that immediately follows that story. Why this one, though, out of all of them? Well, I think partly because you gave it a stronger description than it merited. But I. Well, I mean.
This is that episode that it feels like you read the one or two sentences synopsis and it's like, oh yeah, that sounds super exciting. And then you watch it and it's like, oh, okay. But it's like, okay, I applaud that synopsis writer. They were doing their job. They did it very well. They got me excited for this episode. But it's the main reason I want to watch it is you kind of told me, okay, we get to see kind of what Ezra's all about, how she interacts with the crew, how she comes to stay on DS9. And a big part of that was like, I really like Gen Zia. And so when she disappears and we replace her with this new character, like, okay.
hey, I'm having a hard time figuring out how much I like this character or if I'm going to like this character, how, you know. And so I figured it'd be good to kind of dive into an Esri-centric episode and see, okay, tell me what this character's about. Explain this character to me so I can figure out, you know, start forming an actual opinion as opposed to just, okay, we're going to continue on with our DS9 story and fight the Dominion. Like, tell me about Esri. So that's kind of what I wanted to go into it with. And it has a kind of weird side plot on this that almost became main plot at points. And it's like...
Okay. So, I mean, I definitely see why you, you say this is like Ezra centric episode, but it's almost a Garrick episode as well. So it is. Yep. Yep. It is. And it's, yeah, Matt, I think what you're experiencing, and I'm really kind of glad you picked this one, even though it sounds like it's a bit of a drudge for you, because I think you're experiencing what the fandom experienced in real time is we love Jadzia. Like she really, really grew on us. We love the actress. We loved how she was playing. We love the development of her character. And then all of a sudden she was taken away. And then we're given this real mousy, very quirky, very. Mousy is a good word for it. Yeah. Like, you know.
I mean, cause, cause Terry Farrell, Jadzia was tall and very flowy, very, I don't want to say stringy, but she, and she was very, you know what I mean? Like, like she had big lines and Esri is not. You know, which I mean, I'm guessing it's never going to happen, at least not on the show. But I kind of want to see him standing next to each other. They just how much of a discrepancy there is. Yeah, I don't know. I have no idea in real life, but I think it was good of the showrunners to get somebody who physically looked different than Terry. I'm sure that was very much top of mind when they were going through this process. It's like we can't just replace Jadzia with another Jadzia. Right. Like, right. It has to be something distinctly different about her. So how do we do that? Well, I don't know for sure. It's always felt like Jadzia is a little bit on the taller side. And so I think that's.
that's one of her more defining characteristics. And so like, okay, you want something the opposite of Jed Zia or like said, Terry Farrell, um, like you get someone short. Yeah. And so that's the easiest way to separate them. And I, like I said, I do think you're experiencing exactly what the fandom was experiencing. Obviously it's not what the showrunners wanted you to experience with this character. Um, but I, I I'm with you. This is a rather meh episode of DS nine for me. Like it's, it's an episode. Like, I mean, even more so.
doing this the way I'm doing this, knowing that Esri did continue forward on DS9 already. Right. So like, it's one of those kind of foregone conclusions. I'm like, okay, if I was watching this in the main run, it may have been a little bit more, okay, is she going to stay? Is she not going to stay?
But the only the only thing I could think with that is I would assume that in the promotion for the new season coming up, they have already said there's that there's this new cast member. And then for anyone who's actually paying attention to the opening credits, they see her name in the opening credits. So they kind of know at that point. Yeah. And it's not just like guest starring. Exactly. Exactly. Now, if they were smart, they would have hid that until they got here. But that wasn't that wasn't the thing they were trying to hide. That wasn't information they were trying to pull over people's eyes. That being said, from a story perspective, I think this episode was really necessary. Now, they could have smushed Esri's decision to stay or go into the previous set of episodes, but it would have been.
Like that, that I'm glad they pulled this story out. Well, I left it by itself to some extent, but like I said, like half the episode is a Garrick episode. Well, sure. Because there's not enough of Esri staying or going. And that's what I'm saying is like, they, they did kind of shove it in. So they didn't put it with the previous set of episodes, but they shoved it into the next set kind of episode. But keep in mind, the whole thing about Garrick is it is Garrick's, it is Garrick's experience that Esri is trying to help him through. That also is helping Esri make sense of herself. Esri still doesn't know herself, right? They definitely tied that all together very well. I will give them that.
But there were definitely times in this episode where it felt like Garak's role and can Garak carry out his duties? Like this is going to be more important, more vital. then Esri staying on DS9. Like she could have fixed Garak and then left DS9 and say, okay, there you go. She could have, she could have. And that's why I say, I think Esri made the wrong decision. And we'll get to that at some point. So, but like I said, I think it's a necessary episode. If you're going to have a character get added to the cast like this, especially this late, you have to give them an episode where they make that decision and not just not mush that in. So there is no character actor spotlight there. This was very much a bottle show for them. It all took place on DS9. It was all of their regular people. You know, we'll count Garak as a part of the regulars at this point. So Matt, I'll turn it over. You watch this episode. I'd love to hear your thoughts on what you gleaned from.
Ezri as a character, how you think they're doing, integrating into her in. We can touch on Garrick if you want to. We've already established he's claustrophobic. I think this actually establishes more about his feelings of guilt than it does claustrophobia. Yeah. And we can touch on that. But then I also want to hear, and I want to have your discussion based on, we know she's staying. Her decision to stay. That's the one I personally want to talk about, so I'm going to force us to talk about it. I don't know if you do or not, but that's really kind of the pieces I'd like to hear from you. If you have anything else you want to throw in, please feel free to do that. But I'll turn this over to you to talk about it however you want in whichever order you'd like. We'll be right back.
It's over, Johnny. No! Wow, man. Hey, if you recognize those sounds, then you're probably somebody who would like our show. We are called Did You Hear About This, and we talk about all kinds of news stories. It's like the 80s and 90s stuff that we grew up on. Yeah, this isn't stuff that's getting covered on the 10 o'clock news, I'll tell you that. You can check us out at didyouhearaboutthis.show. We're on every single podcast platform. Go find us.
Yeah. So, I mean, how people handled her was a little bit surprising to me. A lot of people were kind of on edge. And by people, I'm sorry, people, you mean the characters in the show, not fans watching the show. So, like, obviously, Worf. That didn't surprise me. Sure. It surprised me a little bit how skittish, like, Bashir and O'Brien kind of were. It surprised me a little bit for most other characters. Obviously, Sisko being Sisko, knowing...
dax for many uh iterations sure like this is just okay we're doing this again i've been here before i've had to do this already i'm gonna welcome the next dax like let's do this right uh like you know he still still refers to his old man so um which by the way i think that's i think that's bad on cisco's part because because he's calling her old man. Now he would, you assume he called Curzon old man, right? That's where I assume it has started. To call Jadzia old man is, is like a bit of, um, it's like an inside joke to carry that into Esri. Like that to me feels like you haven't, you haven't, you haven't let go of Jadzia yet. Like you're still trying to treat me like I'm Dax and not like I'm Esri, right? Cause Curzon and Esri and Jadzia are all three very different people. Yes. I agree with that. Like it does, it does feel a little odd to, to continue that on. Um, like I think he meant it to be a little more comforting and saying, Hey, I've known.
not only one or two of you now, but now a third one and we're still just as close as we've always been. And I think maybe he was trying to like, almost like trigger something with inside, inside of her and say, Hey, remember me? The one who calls you old man all the time ever since I first met you. Um, so like that, I feel that's kind of the direction he was coming with it, but yeah, it does kind of feel like, yeah, that was an inside joke with Jetsia. You need to find some other connection to Esri. Um, but the one that surprised me the most in the other direction, like not like Worf, who is understandably staying away was Quark. Sure. Like he seems super chipper. I'm like,
what do you have up your sleeve, dude? Like, what are you planning? What are you plotting? And it really just seemed like, no, I have no reason to not be friends with you. So I'm going to continue doing what I've always done with Dax. Right. Can we jump back to Worf though and talk about Worf? Because while we know that Worf, he's a very brooding individual. And I know that we've often said that he is a very bad Klingon. Like Worf is a horrible Klingon. Like he's not a good one, right? This is another mark for me in that category that he's not a good Klingon. Because if you watch some of the previous episodes of, particularly in Next Generation, where they really established this,
Klingons very much consider the body just a shell. And so when a person dies, they do that little yell thingy that they do, which is a warning to Stovacor that are great warriors on their way. And then, and then it's like, they get up and like, do whatever you want with the body. I'm done. You know? And, and, and, and they, they kind of like, once they get their person into Stovacor, which was the plot point of like the last episode, they move on. Worf hasn't like, he's still very brooding about, Oh, I missed, you know? And like, I get it. I'm glad for him to grieve. I'm glad for him to have, you know, the emotions of a human being, but he's not like, this is not how Klingons respond. But still, I mean, this is still a very unique situation.
though, because I don't think you can argue that any other Klingon has ever come back in, in somebody else's body. That's fair. That's fair, Matt. So is Jadzia really dead? I mean, that, that I guess has to be the question. It's like, it's nice that, you know, she's, she's not gone, but like he has this conversation with, uh, was it Bashir or something?
Uh, but, but, but he, Oh, Brian, when he comes to the quarters, right. What the, the drink again? Uh, no, no, it was before that. Okay. Um, but yeah, like he said something to the effect of, it's nice that she's still here, but it'd be easier if she, if she's just gone. Right. And like, I get it. And that's, that's where I think he's struggling the most is like, he can still kind of communicate with like, her memories are still here. Like as he's still there. And so like, she still has all of Jadzia's memories and she can interact with him and, and knows how much Jadzia loved him and all those types of things. And it's like, she's kind of still there. She hasn't.
completely gone. Like her body has changed, but she's kind of still there. Right. It's got to be in a weird spot for her, you know? And this, this is a big part of the reason why there's the rule for trills. You don't go back to your past life. You move on and get a new life because it's, it's bad for you as the joined trill. It's bad for the people you've left behind because they don't have closure because you're still around. Like it's, you just, you don't.
do this. And, and okay, I'll skip ahead. The fact that Esri chooses to stay, even though she was being asked to, even though people said, we want you to stay, she needed to do the mature thing, which I get it. She wasn't prepared for joining. She was, she didn't have any of that stuff. She still should have done the mature thing and said, no, she needs to move on to the thing. And she made the wrong choice to stay. I think the writers made the wrong choice to replace her, you know, because frankly, here's, if this was the final time we saw Dax, right. They, they, they showed us again, I go back to the last couple of episodes. We saw the new person, this, the new Dax symbiote host comes into the picture, helps Ben with one final mission, comes back and, and, and.
goes through a do I stay or don't I like that's a much more interesting I think this would have been a much more interesting story if Dax would have left it would have been a much more poignant story I think if Dax would have left yes and I think what needs to happen though is that you know this was kind of an emergency joining right right and so part of the reason she came here in the first place was to seek out Ben and I think it would be good and I mean they can fast forward this as much as they want to but she hangs around with Ben for two weeks, four weeks, six weeks, something to just help get her acclimated because he has experience with this, right? As much as, like you said, they're not supposed to necessarily associate with people from their past lives. Well, Gen Z already messed that up. So, okay, give Ezra a hand, get her acclimated, let her know what she needs to know, get her in touch with the resources and then send her on her way. So like you said, yeah, whether that's some big mission they have together and then they part ways or however they want to write that.
I think more than anything, it's not so much that Cisco needed closure or anything. I mean, like I said, maybe you could help Garrick along the way with his problems. You could help Worf maybe kind of finalize things or maybe final words to Jadzia that he never got to say or something like that. But then, yeah, I think you're right. It would have been better if she left. Yeah, I agree. And from a fan standpoint, it would have given us closure on Jadzia's death and given us closure on the Dax character. Like, yes, we hate that she went away, but look, there she is alive and she's off doing her thing and that's fine. And maybe we would wonder, hey, I wonder what her adventures would have been like. And that could have been a nice little.
spinoff little set of novels or character or whatever maybe she comes back once or twice over the over the course of the season that'd be fine but she did not need to be because we know like she kept saying she was going back on the destiny and they were involved with the war. So yeah, they can run into her again. Absolutely. Absolutely. Now all of that to say, none of that for me is a criticism on how Nicole DeBoer, who is the actress who plays Esri portrayed the character. I actually, I really like how she portrayed Esri, like with what she was given, the way the, the way the writers wrote her, the way it was written, like her backstory into this whole thing. Like it's perfect. Oh, it's so good. And I really like what she did. And like one of the things that I found, this was interesting in researching this episode, all those little super quirky things that Esri does, like standing on her head because she got that from Eminem.
you know, all those little things, those weren't added to the script until after they cast Nicole in the role. And it wasn't until like, cause the writers are writing these, these first several episodes without knowing who's going to be cast in the role. Right. Sure. So they're just writing the episodes when they saw Nicole and they saw how she was going to portray it. That inspired a lot of these.
Quirky is the only word I can use. You know, yeah, like like those inspired a lot of those things to go in there. So Nicole certainly had a big influence on the character and making the character so drastically different from Jadzia, which was really good if they were going to do it. I just, you know, like I said, I don't think the character should have stayed. That said, you know, Esri Dax is very much a part of the canon, the history and the lore of Star Trek. And I think if if in a main run, you didn't get this episode and all I said was, hey, she's going to stay. And you have we have 11 episodes of the season that we're going to watch by the time this is said and done. You'll see enough Esri over the course of those those things to know who she is. But, you know, this episode.
it certainly grounds a lot of that for you, I think, um, going forward. So anyway, you were talking about Quark. We got on this big rabbit trail. Oh yeah. Let's go back to Quark and how she's talking to Quark. Cause Quark's like, I, do you think, do you think Quark, um, felt like maybe this was a shot at, at Redette? Like he has another chance or was he just, was it just Quark being Quark and Ferengi and however that works with him? Well, and that's what I was unsure of. Like I wasn't, I thought he had some angle going into this. Right. Um, you know, halfway through the episode when he, when he sits down with, uh,
That time I think it was with Bashir. And it's like, they discuss like, so do you think I have a chance with her? You know, like kind of second chance at dating her. It's like, dude, it's not Jadzia. It's like, I know, I know. And it's like obvious, like backing off of his previous statement a little bit. It's like, but it's, it's, I'm not entirely sure what the writers intended. I, while I was surprised, I kind of hope that his intentions were more pure and that he was kind of just in the same boat as Cisco.
And it's like, yeah, dude, we know you, you, you know us yet. So, I mean, okay, we need to get to know Esri a little bit, but we still know Dax. We knew Jadzia. She's still there. So let's just continue on as we were. And like, I mean, like the little interactions that he had, it's like, oh yeah, you used to love this drink. Like this used to be your favorite. And like just helping her along little things like that. And it's like, okay, you don't like it? No, we'll find something you do like, but just kind of playing his part in helping her adjust to being Dax and what that means and what changes and what doesn't.
Apparently she's left-handed now. Right. Which by the way, it makes her just that much more endearing to me. Yes. I don't know. That one, that one surprised me a lot. And I, like I said, I don't entirely know what the writers had intended there. If it was really just Quark trying to weasel his way into a relationship or something. Yeah. Potentially. Or if it was something like said, more, more pure, like Cisco. Well, speaking, speaking of other people, why don't we didn't mention this guy at first. Let's talk about Esri and Bashir. Yeah. What do you make of that whole thing?
you have your mother's eyes. I mean, Jadzia's eyes. Right. Don't flirt with me, Julian. Jadzia enjoyed it. And if Ward hadn't come along, it would have been you. Yeah, it would have been. Like, really? Come on, Ezra. I think, honestly, it's one of the worst things you can say. It is. Like, it's interesting for the audience to watch, but putting myself in Julian's shoes, like, no, that's one of the worst things. So, yeah, I mean, that whole thing, too. Like, we've talked about that before. Like, the whole Jadzia and Bashir and...
was it quirk or brian or someone like everybody like it's just kind of randomly brought up from time to time it's like it's not really a thing but they kind of make it a thing and it's like did you really have to bring it up again now that she's gone and you really can't do anything about it i don't know it felt unnecessary yeah So I figure this is a good time to bring it up. If you didn't catch it, they're setting the seeds here for a Julian Esri relationship that will develop over the course of lots of these episodes you're missing. So I'm just telling you that when you get there, Julian Esri are going to become a thing. And when you catch up to him, I'm not sure if they, I think they already are a thing by the time we catch up. So, you know, don't, don't be surprised, but that's, I mean, that's where this was. And that's, that's where that setting is. Now I'll say this, watching this Bashir talk over things with Esri is way different than watching season one and season two Bashir, who's just super creepy talking to people. Like Bashir has definitely aged and matured quite a bit.
He settled down a little bit. Yeah. Yeah. Like he's not, you know, the frat boy that he used to be. I think some of the, you know, some of the things he said were more innocent this time rather than, than these. So, uh, so yeah. Um, I guess the only other crew member that as we really came in contact with was, um, Kira and that was just a real short scene in the temple, which was nothing like, you know, I think it was just Kira kind of giving Esri permission to be there and to, you know, be herself. So yeah, that's, that's kind of the whole thing. Um, should we touch on Garrick and what's going on with Garrick? I don't know that there's a ton there, but yeah, it didn't turn out to be a whole ton and I can see why, you know,
Like we didn't need to cover this episode. Like part of me wondered that as soon as we get into it, it's like, man, he's cracking Dominion stuff and he's feeling guilty about killing Cardassians. Yeah. What he's doing is resulting in the death of his fellow countrymen and that's beating him up inside. And like, I mean, it almost got to the point like, man, is he going to like defect or something? Is he, is he going to pass along faulty codes or like, like what is going on here? Like, but ultimately like.
feels he kind of got things sorted out at least on the right path i i can see him having further conversations with uh their new counselor esri but uh like yeah it's not it didn't really turn out to be anything it didn't and you know i guess this is where i go those counseling sessions weren't one-way counseling sessions because that the whole point of that was as i said was more about esri trying to figure out who she is through talking to garrick and discovering this piece of her um yeah and he kept saying like how are you supposed to help me when you can't even help yourself And then, and then there's that one time where he just absolutely destroys Esri and leaves her in tears, which honestly made my heartbreak a lot. Like I, like, I just, I feel so like, I feel so bad for, you know, Cardassian. Garrick is still a Cardassian. Obsidian order, man. He knows what he's doing. He may be working with them now, but he's not an idiot. He knows, he knows.
how to hurt people. He knows how to manipulate people when he wants to, when it's to his advantage. Yeah. Even if he just wants to be alone, right? Like he can push people's buttons. Yeah. And I think that's a piece of what makes Garak such a fascinating character is because Garak is not a good guy. Like we grow to like Garak. You know, Garak does some good things, but Garak's still not a good guy. Like he's, he's still very much Cardassian should rule the universe. And he just can't right now because he's deposed from his country. He's an exile from his country or his world. He can't go back. And you know, everything he's doing is to see a free Cardassia, not, not for the betterment of the alpha quadrant, not to stop the destruction of the rest of the alpha quadrant species. It's just to see Cardassia free.
And I mean, that's part of the reason he's having such a hard time killing Cardassians or, you know, helping to kill Cardassians. Right. Right. So anyway. All right, Matt.
As we, as he decides to stay, she's going to be the new counselor on the station, which actually I thought was really reasonable. Hey, we don't have a counselor on the station and we're going through some crap here. So look, you know, and Cisco says to her at one point, you're now responsible for the mental health of everyone on this station, you know, which, which is a tall task. She's been granted a special dispensation or reprieve or something because she, she's got eight lifetimes worth of memories and that's supposedly suddenly make her a great counselor. Which one of those count, which one of those memories taught her how to counsel? Like she's still in training. Sorry. It was just, that's a, that's a bad job. Like she may be wise. She may have some wisdom there, but knowing how to share it in the right way at the right time. Like, yeah.
I can see the argument going either way with that one. Yeah. Yeah. Like there may have been some things that, that she could learn. I'll say this. If one of her past hosts was a, was like a, this big, super great counselor, I could see that. And I almost wish they would have figured out how to make that happen. But, uh, you know, I, I get the argument. You've lived eight lifetimes. What are you going to learn that, you know, school's not going to teach you. I just.
I mean, I'm all for on the job training and just knowing how much on the job training her former wives have had. Right. Like it's there's something to be said for that. But like you said, there is some specialization going on here, too. Well, and like the other two things that I bring up in regards to that is one.
If we're going to live by this rule, then every time we have a neutral host, do they get to skip school and skip the academy and just go straight in as a fully commissioned officer? Because their previous host was a fully commissioned officer and they're not really going to learn anything new in the academy. You know, no, the host still has to go through the academy. Jet Z has still had to work her way up. And then they spent an entire episode called Dax telling us that one trill joint trill is not the same thing as the next joint trill. Like you may possess memories, but you're not the same. So which I think is being seen very distinctly here.
With Esri, it's like, Esri is not the same as Jadzia. Right. And Esri's not ready to take this on. And I'm sure not the same as Curzon or any of them. Exactly. And she's just not ready to take it on. So anyway, I understand they had to do something to get Esri to stay on the station and explain that. Yeah. This one just didn't work. And Rene Traveria, the guy who wrote this episode, he was like, he tried, like, he really wanted to do some good stuff. The script was okay. But by the time it was done, he's like, it just didn't land the way they really wanted it to. Like he even said that. So. Sure. And I agree. It didn't land the way they wanted it to. So. All right, Matt, you got anything else from this episode? I can't think of anything else to discuss about this one. I think I just want to bring up one line that I thought was very poignant
from, I forget who spoke it. I think it was, I think this was when O'Brien came to talk to Worf. Okay. And he asked him, how do you think Jed Zia would want you to treat Esri? Like, I thought that was the best line in this episode and kind of what everybody, not just Worf, but everybody should have been considering. How would Jed Zia want you to treat Esri? So I think that's kind of what I'm moving forward with too. It's like, regardless of what I actually think about Esri. How would Jed Zia want you to treat her as a fan? Yeah, like until she gives me.
reason or cause to think otherwise. I think that's a good place to start. So there you go. And for whatever it's worth, if you, if you want to know what Terry, how Terry would want you to treat Nicole, Terry and Nicole are often together on the, on the convention circuit. And there's lots of hugs and there's lots of sharing of the character in several ways and recognizing that again, the two characters aren't the same, but there is certainly a bond that the two characters have that, that no one else has ever had in the history of Star Trek with two characters. So, um, all right, well, I guess that's it. So now I'll ask you the official questions we ask you at the end of these extra viewings. Did you like the episode? I think I know the answer to that one. Would you want to watch it again? I also think I know the answer to that one. And do you understand why it was?
not a part of our run i think i got you on all three of these but i'll let you give the official word um yeah i mean it was it was okay it was okay like i said it's kind of a mad episode but uh would i watch again i've seen it once don't need to watch again um and yeah i i understand why it wasn't part of the run it's like you said we'll get enough esri as we go along it wasn't nearly as as recentric as i was expecting um and yeah like the garrick thing didn't pan out to anything either so no need to include that. Yeah. So yeah, I totally understand. Let me ask you this because this was one of those episodes that frankly, when I, when I first sat down and started thinking all those years ago, what episodes would be in and what episodes would be on. I sort of started running through, this is one that I was like, Oh yeah, this is the one where I decided to say, so that's gotta be in there. Yeah. Can you understand why I would have had that? And then when I went starting watching it, then I went actually with just that little, little snippet. It's like, yeah, that would make sense to have in there. Like new character joins the crew. We should see, you know, her making the decision to actually stay and connect with these people. And yeah, but then like I said, you go and watch it and it's like, well, no, there wasn't as much substance.
So that is a thought. So well, with that, Matt. That's going to do it for us this week. This month, really, I guess. On our extra viewing episodes. And what's next? Well, I don't know. Matt has mentioned to me we might get a couple more in this particular month. I don't know what's going to happen. If we don't, blame him. I'm just telling you what he said. He's going to pick the ones he thinks sounds interesting to him. So, hey, listen, you guys know all the details. If you want to stump for an episode, Eric sent me an email to stump for an Esri episode later on. So, I don't know. Maybe we'll look at that. But you guys know all the details. BeameUpPod at gmail.com. Connect with us on Patreon. Send me a message there. We'll do that. Until next time, guys. Thanks again. Live long and prosper.