Skip to content
Extra Viewing - DS9 | Dax episode artwork

May 9, 2023 1 hr 1 min

Extra Viewing - DS9 | Dax

from Beam Me Up: A Star Trek Podcast

Did You Hear About This? This humorous pop culture podcast discusses the latest retro stories and pop culture news. Listen on: Apple Podcasts Spotify Support the show

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Extra Viewing - DS9 | Dax

0:00 1:01:06

Chapters

  1. 15:52 [Ad] Did You Hear About This?
  2. 16:30 (Cont.) Extra Viewing - DS9 | Dax
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Hey everybody, this is Brent from Beam Me Up's Star Trek podcast. As you may know, Matt and I have finished recording the main run of the show. However, over the course of our three and a half years of recording the show, we actually recorded several episodes that to this point have either gone unaired or they were exclusive to our Patreon page. Well, now that we're on the backside of the main show, we thought that it would be a great time to release those episodes to you guys out there, our listening audience. Plus, you never know when Matt and I may jump in with a random new episode. The final frontier begins. This is about saving the future of humanity. This is a huge victory for the good guys.

You've never seen Voyager. Commitment to this course of action is not emotional. Beam us up. Welcome to another episode of Beam Me Up, a Star Trek podcast, but not just any episode. Oh no, this is a very special Patreon exclusive extra viewing episode. You guys know me, I'm Brent. And I'm Matt. And if you're listening to this, that means that Matt and I owe you a huge, great, big thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. You guys are A1 supporters. You guys have been out there helping us out. Matt, our Patreon thing has been a little funny. Like we had like a couple of patrons and then, you know, different things happen. And so like some people fall away or credit cards get expired and they never get renewed or whatever. And then like we kind of have like a lull where like we didn't have anybody and like you're...

lately like it seems like in the last like month or two we've picked up several so so to those of you guys who are new and so we're like hey we got to do these these extra viewing episodes again because like we owe them to people and it just gives us more excuses to talk about star trek yep there you go there you go so uh so you guys will be getting these these guys these will come out generally about the fourth or fifth week of the month so towards the end of the month uh for those of you guys that are just kind of looking for it and expecting it man i actually have we've we've got like a calendar set forth uh that's trying to keep us on schedule and like we're already scheduled out through like the end of the summer already which is weird and crazy to me, Matt, that we're that far out on the schedule already. Hey, I'm not complaining. Yeah, hopefully that'll make sure that we are on time with what we're doing, the things we're supposed to be doing. But to you guys out there that are patrons, thank you guys so much. If you guys have been getting the early release episode, you guys should be. Those things are on our schedule. Getting them almost a full week, Matt. I don't know if you know this or not. They're getting them almost an entire week before the podcast go live for, you know, the people out there. Sure. I'm not a patron, so I don't get notifications about that. We should probably put you in there. I probably should. You can do it for as low as a dollar a month. A dollar, yeah. But thank you guys.

You know, so hopefully you guys are enjoying that sneak peek of the episode that is coming. Make sure you guys, you can always send us feedback on the episode even before it ever actually hits the air. We would love to take that and receive that from you. And then there'll be some other things we've already got recorded. We've got recorded our charting the course episodes for Deep Space Nine season four and Voyager season two. Those episodes I've never heard, but I always forget that you do even. Right. Yeah. And like within like the first minute, it's Matt, you're not allowed to listen. Shoot, go away. But you guys will be getting those as early releases as well. I'm also probably going to post it up at least in the Patreon feed. Here are the list of episodes that we're going to be doing, at least as it stands right now. I always maintain the card. Like I can change it at any moment that I want, but.

do sometimes i do sometimes you know when i do though matt it's because there's usually something from our conversation that we're going through that that kind of tips me one way or the other then okay fine we need to do this or we got to go back and hit this other side over here that's usually what it is sure um you know it's not an exact science but i like the starting the course episodes those are fun episodes to me because you know all i mean all throughout the original series and throughout the entire run of next generation it was just me you know and i sometimes get these tweets or emails from people and like why did you leave that one out and why did you how come you didn't do this one or why did you put that one in and i just thought it'd be fun to listen to so it's good to be able to bounce that off the last one just behind the scenes curtain matt like i have my list of where I think the episode should go before going in because I tried to be prepared sure the last one I went into like my list hit exactly as we wound up like I was right like like it was like nope that's exactly how the list should go and I went oh okay pretty cool usually there's like one or two changes and I'm like 90% right but that one was like just nope this is the list it's pretty clear so you'll catch up on that eventually Matt you'll go back and listen to our old episodes as we go through sure all right well why don't we get into this episode Matt Dax today's actually viewing episode all the way back in season one of Jesus Space Nine Matt and I have pulled back the curtain just a little bit we've just recorded our season four premiere the way of the warrior and so now we're going all the way back to Dax or as I like to call it the episode that every good side

show does, because this is the one that, like I said, it seems like every sci-fi show does this particular episode. This is the one where Gen Z and Dax goes on trial for the crimes, or the supposed crimes, of Curzon Dax, and we have to answer the question, what makes a person a person, and can the current host be held responsible for the crimes of a previous host? Now, Matt, when I said to you last week, I said, Matt, we owe our patrons an extra viewing episode. You have a lot. I've given you several extra viewing episodes over the past couple of months. Yeah, just a few dozen. Yeah, and you and I, we've watched a few just, like, the times we've been together, like, let's throw in a Star Trek episode, and there it is. We just didn't record after it. But, you know, I said to you, which one sounds most, you know, familiar to you?

sounds most appealing to you and you pick Dax why Dax I think the easiest answer is I think Dax is getting to be one of my favorite characters in the show so if they took the time to title an entire episode after that character I think I want to know more whether that's I mean you kind of warned me ahead of time that it was gonna be a trial episode but still I think you told me it was a trial episode but I mean past that didn't really know anything about it but it I think that's the easiest answer okay that's the easiest way to explain things is is Dax is one of my favorite characters and so anything that going to focus on Dax I would like to learn about I would like to see so did this help your fandom of the character like did it did it expand that for you at all I don't I don't think I can say it necessarily helped it. It didn't necessarily hurt it. But yeah, there's I mean, you know what's in the episode. So it's it definitely gives me a different it gives me things to think about. OK, fair enough. Well, let's think about some of those things, Matt. And we'll kind of just run through this the way we normally do. Well, actually, let me hit a couple character actor spotlights real quick. Sure. This show is actually full of them, full of recognizable faces and names. If you know what you're looking for, the first one I'll bring up is Gregory Itzen. He's the guy who plays Tandro or Ellen Tandro, I think is his name. I don't know if you ever recognized him before. He's one of those. I've just seen him again.

and again and again over the last 20 some odd years i remember him most from the show 24 which i feel like we just had somebody that i mentioned from 24 and i don't remember we did have someone in the main show and i i told you i don't watch that show oh oh um was it penny johnson yes yes penny yeah cassidy yates yeah she she was in 24 um there was another i told you i knew her from other things i mean like i know her most from 24 i haven't seen that and then and then the girl who played roe laran if you remember roe laran uh she also she was in a season of 24 okay that was a while galacta uh so yeah so a couple a couple of 24 uh characters popping up here but he's been in a lot and he always kind of plays the same shmarmy type character, you know, like, like, like he's not necessarily good. He's not necessarily bad. He's just sort of, I don't know that I would like this guy in real life, kind of a character. And I don't know how you feel about Ellen Tandro, but it's just kind of whatever. Now we will see Gregory Itzen back in a couple of other Trek episodes, a couple that I know for sure we're going to do over the course of this run. So, uh, so that's Gregory Itzen, the judge. I want to talk about the judge. Did you recognize her? She felt more familiar than Tandro. She's one of those, that girl, that actor type characters for me. Like I know I've seen her. Uh, her name is Anne Haney and I got to tell you, Matt, she had the exact same role in the exact same episode on Stargate SG one. That was.

She was the judge in a trial about whether or not the host of a symbiote can be held responsible for the crimes of the symbiote. And it was the same role. And oh yeah, in that thing too, that world, if you remove one, the other dies. Of course. Sadly, we lost Anne back in 2001 at the relatively young age of 67. So, you know, I mean, I always had to lose an actor like that that's so recognizable to me anyway. But she is, she's just one of those like, and she would have kept working, I think too, you know, just very recognizable to me. All right, moving on. Mama Tandro. Nina, I think was her name. I'm not going to be able to pronounce this lady's name correctly. Fionnula Flanagan.

It's about as Irish of a name as you can possibly imagine. Oh, yeah. Very recognizable character. She was actually in an episode of Next Generation, Matt, where she played Data's mother. Now, we skipped that episode. That episode was called Inheritance. If you want to go back and watch it, there's a little twist at the end. But, you know, her and Data's dad, Dr. Soong, were married. I think they were married. How does Data have a mother? How does that work? Yeah. So anyway, but I'll leave that to you. But she'll come back and she'll do a couple of other episodes as well. I kind of like Gregory. It's a very she's got a very recognizable face that like when you see her like, hey, that's that lady from that other episode. So yeah, now with all that, Matt, there is one person that I really do want to talk about that.

going to spend a long time on it, but I do have to bring it up here, but it's not someone that you saw on screen. I don't know if you recognize it or not. Okay. The person I really want to talk about is the person who wrote the teleplay for this episode, or rather I should say co-wrote because it was partly written by Peter Allen Fields, who's been around you. If you pay attention to the credits at all, you've seen his name in just about every episode. You know how much I love my DS9 credits. Oh yeah. So this would have been like while the show was playing, like those credits that kind of pop up like as the show's, as the show's playing. But this was co-written.

by our old friend, DC Fontana. I did see your name pop up. I had some brief questions, but then I was focusing on the episode again. I'm like, wait, that was a long time ago. We haven't talked about it in a long time. I guess my main thought was I don't connect her with DS9. Well, this is her only credit on DS9. We haven't actually talked about her since season two of Next Generation. That's how far back that goes because she kind of stepped away from the whole Trek thing. But this would be her final Star Trek credit. So not only is it her only DS9 contribution, it's her final Star Trek credit. She doesn't do any Voyager Enterprise or anything like that. But that is DC Fontana. I just had to point her out for this particular episode. With that being said, Matt, why don't we get into the episode?

So let's talk about it a little bit more. Uh, Matt, typically I would already have asked you your overall thoughts on the whole episode, but I just want to, I just want to stop and find out like what, what's, what are your overall thoughts on this episode? Did you like it? Did you not like it? Like, where, where are you on this? I think I would have to say I liked it. It's a different type of episode than we've watched. Typically. It made me think a lot. And I kind of mentioned that before, but like, I think more than anything, it just made me think. And sometimes I think that's what some of the best Star Trek does. Right. Absolutely. It makes you think because at the end of this thing, they still never really answered the question. They solved their problem, but they didn't answer the question.

So they just basically started a discussion and said, all right, that's enough. Now you deal with it. You come to your own conclusion. Right. So, I mean, like I said, I think I liked it overall, but yeah, it's different.

I got to tell you, Matt, this is actually one of my favorites of season one from Deep Space Nine. And it hurt me in my core to not watch this episode with you. Well, there you go. You know, it did. Like, I really hated losing it. I don't know how most people feel about it. I can't say what the fandom really typically thinks of this episode. Personally, I love it. I've often said, like, I remember my first watch of Deep Space Nine and those first couple of seasons, particularly season one and season two, but even in through season three, it can get to be a slog sometimes going through those episodes. You know, you're just trying to figure out the characters. The writers are trying to figure everybody out. The acting is kind of meh. The effects are meh. The first three seasons of any series are going to be like that. Usually, yeah. No matter how.

much you like the series, even on a rewatch, they can be tough. Yeah. And, and, but what would happen is Deep Space Nine would like every once in a while, there would just be this really fantastic episode that would like hook me back in and be like, okay, I'll give it a couple more episodes and I'd watch and kind of, okay, I'll give it one more episode. And if this one's not good, I'm done with the series. And then it'd be like a really good episode. This was the first one of those for me. This is episode seven of the series. So there was a pilot, which I thought was my first reaction was, okay, I don't really get it, but okay, sure. Fine. And then the next bunch of episodes are just, okay, I'm struggling on this series. And then I watched actually like, okay, I love, I like, I love these courtroom episodes. Like, I don't know. I don't like courtroom dramas. Like I don't love where they.

do every single episode every week it's it's not the best but yeah i'm right there with you and i i mean i i'm the kind of guy who who loves watching all these documentaries they have out now about like the oj trial or um ted kaczynski and that type of stuff and when they get in the courtroom to actually see the stuff that went on and it's like huh okay interesting right so yeah so i i love this episode quite a lot i really really do uh to do that so matt let's talk about how Okay, we're still figuring out this new method of how we do it. We've got like A plot, B plot, special character moments, but then we've kind of flipped that. You want to do some of these special character moments first? Yeah, I think that's where I'd like to start. Okay, great. So what do you got for me? What stood out to you as you were watching this episode? I think you've tried to tell me this before, but I haven't really seen it until now. Okay. Julian really tries to be a player.

julian's creepy yeah like early seasons julian super creepy yeah yes because like i finally got to see here like at first i just wrote down like is he trying to hit on dax yeah and then like she gets up and leaves and it's like no i'll be fine and he sits there talking to himself like you don't need to follow me but you didn't forbid it What? Right. I mean, dude. Okay. I mean, props to the actor for playing the lines that were written for him. But wow. Yeah. Wow. Yeah. And he's not good at it. He's just not good. He's not good at hitting on people at all. So, I mean, if nothing else, this episode has given me the portrayal of Julian that you've been trying to describe for me. Yeah. We'll be right back.

Oh, wow, man. Hey, if you recognize those sounds, then you're probably somebody who would like our show. We're called Did You Hear About This? And we talk about all kinds of news stories. It's like the 80s and 90s stuff that we grew up on. Yeah, this isn't stuff that's getting covered on the 10 o'clock news. I'll tell you that. You can check us out at didyouhearaboutthis.show. We're on every single podcast platform. Go find us.

Yeah, so, I mean, more than just Julian, though, because they hinted at this with Quark a little bit later. I feel like the people that were writing the show early on, especially, were really trying to show that, like, everybody on the station had a thing for Dax. Like, they all did. All the men, especially. So, like, Quark had a thing for Jesse. Well, yeah, because later in the episode, I think, they, who was Odo? Odo was blackmailing him to use the bar. Yeah, and it's like, I forget exactly what he said, but it's something like, oh, it's for Dax, or Dax will be there, something along those lines. It's like, oh, really? And then, like, his money took over, and, you know, even that wasn't enough to get him.

who else is there? There's Cisco. It's not O'Brien. O'Brien's married. Julian. It's not Odo. I don't know, but like they're, they're pining over, over Jensia. So anyway, it's not like Garrick or something. No, it's no, no, no, it's not Garrick. So anyway, there really is this thing where they're, they're just sort of, it's never super overt, but it's just sort of this underlying thing. But yeah, Julian's super duper creepy, especially in those early seasons. And he kind of goes on like that. You remember like, I think we've most recently started talking about Lita, the new character they brought in, the new Bajoran, the double girl, you know, and I was like, you know,

julian's hitting on her and trying to you know like if you remember the episode facets that we just recorded that actually went out the week this this episode will release um the the start of it lita and julian are like sitting like super close to each other in that conference room at the beginning of the episode so sure anyway yeah julian all right i don't remember if this was a conversation you and i had on your offer but one of the last times you're talking about the drill like you mentioned to me that everything is trill yes like the people are trill the planet is trill so i found it interesting and maybe they changed this later on but they referred to it as the trillion government yeah yeah I thought we determined that trillion was not the word, not the way to go with it. Yeah, it's not the way to go with it. Yes, you're right. It is one of those things that they sort of, I guess, change a little bit. And we've seen them do this in Star Trek before. We saw them do this with Vulcan, which was an episode we watched from the original series where they called them Vulcanians in your Vulcanian mind. We actually also saw this in The Next Generation when they first introduced the Bajorans and they introduced them as a terrorist group. And it's like something happened and you heard this audio message come over to the Enterprise and it says, we are the Bajora.

you know it's no you're not the bajora you're bajorians and yeah yeah well i mean i think it's even like you told me there are like one or two actual recorded in episode times where they call it like the voyager the voyager yeah and it's like yeah things change they fix things over time they make sure things are the way they want them to be but i think part of that is a balance between just figuring out what you want and they have so many writers like do they have some like fact checker going through these scripts and saying hey this is i mean i it could be the you could put that on the actor somewhat too but i think this one in particular was one of the guest actors so yeah it was weird just to hear because we kind of just had that conversation i think about trail trail trail and it's like a trillion wait what but like we went we went back three seasons and this is what we get yes we we definitely went back three seasons and i mean it's it's not just uh it's not just the name but it also is even with the makeup. Like they've changed the makeup over time. And because this is not the first time we've ever seen a trill. Jadzia is not the first trill that we've ever seen. We saw one back in the next generation and I am scurrying through Google right now trying to find a picture of that person, but I'm not seeing it. But I did find this picture of an early makeup test of Jadzia where they did, they did the original makeup for the trill. Okay. Okay. And so I'm going to show it to you here, Matt. I don't know if you can see that or not, but this is an early makeup test for Jadzia where instead of having the spots, she has this weird, like.

almost what i call like a bird looking thing like a forehead crease yeah yeah like a yeah that is kind of weird that almost looks more like uh whatever race it is we ran into this time In this episode, actually. Yeah, whatever. Not Kelpians. Kelderians or whatever. Claystrom. Claystrom. Yeah, yeah. Something along those lines. So anyway, all of that to say, even the makeup has changed for the Trill since we very first saw it. I think I'm correct. I think what you just saw there for Jadzia was the original makeup they used when we first met Trill back in Next Generation. And they tried it on her and went, no, that doesn't look right. And then they gave her spots and were like, that looks awesome. Go with that. Yeah. So in this episode that we just watched in Dax, she has some kind of spots, but I think they change over the years.

years because in the episode in the main run this is weird to be jumping back and forth but her spots seem much darker and maybe a little more solid and more pronounced I would say yeah in season one here like some of them were almost just like line drawings as opposed to like spots yeah and I think that's just Michael Westmore getting to a spot where he's more comfortable you know because he eventually got to a spot there we go But Michael Westmore, the makeup artist, he eventually got to a spot where he just hand drew them onto her face. I already mentioned that before, which seems ridiculous considering how many there are. How many days of shooting they have to do. It's not just one per episode. Yeah, you don't get a full episode in a day, probably. Exactly. And they talk about how just below the collar line or wherever he would stop, he would sign it or put a number or something. Nice. Yeah, he would certainly get to... I think they've done that even at the conventions and stuff before. Sure. He would go in and just like Terry Farrell's there and he's like, sit down, Terry, and he just starts putting spots on her again. It's like several times. Yeah. But hey, speaking of makeup, though, can we please talk?

about Odo's makeup. Okay. That was the other one I noticed too. Okay. Yes. Cause it freaks me out every time I restart the show. Like I, I mean, I didn't notice it changed like over time. I mean, I don't know how many episodes of DS9 we've actually watched now, but like, I can't say I noticed it changing over time. But when we jump back from what we're in, what season four now, we jump back to season one. I'm like, Whoa, um, your face is missing.

like like you i think you could actually like see his actual cheekbones almost and i'm like that i mean it feels wrong like i never realized how much either makeup or prosthetics he's actually wearing i don't know actually but it feels like he's missing some of his face yeah it's it it gets much more smooth as i go on like like you can you can kind of see the the wrinkles and stuff and actually i swear there's a little bit of me even right now where i feel like i can see the edges of the make of the mask it's very possible yeah i mean i mean i think they're trying something new like they haven't done anything quite like that that looked kind of looked human, but not really. Whereas, I mean, they're very good about head ridges. They've been doing that for years. They can get those down.

But when you want it to be nice and smooth, kind of like a human, but not look human, what do you do? And it's, I mean, but you even mentioned the head ridges. And this is where I get into, Matt, like as a fandom, and the more you watch Star Trek, the more you'll see this. As the shows, as New Trek continues to get created, they will continually like reimagine what a ship looks like, or they'll reimagine what a race of people looks like. Sure. Trek has a history of doing this. Most recently, it's been, I think, the Romulans. They've kind of reimagined a little bit of what the Romulans look like. It's also happened with the Klingons, with New Trek. That's not what the Klingons look like. And I'm like, okay, do we need to go back and show you photos of the original Klingons and then what the next generation era Klingons look like?

They change. Can we go back and show you what the very first Romulan looks like to the way the Romulans look like now? The makeup changes over time, guys. It's just a part of shows moving forward. And seriously, go back and look at the human race 100, 200 years ago. Sure. Do we look the same as those pictures? No, I guarantee you. I'm a tall guy. I'm a big dude. My great, great, great, great, great grandfather was not this big. Guarantee you. I don't know exactly how tall he was. He was not this big. I'm a runt in my family right now. That's what I've been told.

It's a scary thought, but. By my wife, not even by me. Anyway, yeah, so Odo's makeup's different. Jadzia's makeup's different. Yeah, Odo's is the one I think that gets me more than anything, though, you know.

I just watched it and go, ooh, that's... I think the two that get me all the time, it's Odo's makeup in the first season and how young Jake is. Because even now, like, in the run, you're starting to see, like, Jake's getting towards adult age. Yeah, but if Jake had been in this episode, yeah, I'm sure that would have been a little bit of a shock. Yeah. But he wasn't there, so... Right, because you've even been saying... Because you've even... You said it on a recent episode, like, man, Jake and Nog are really... Exactly, when he interacts with Nog. Like, because it feels like Nog hasn't grown up and Jake has. I mean, personality-wise, sure, they both have, but the height difference is just so different now. Mm-hmm, yeah. And I'll give you one more makeup change I think that has happened. It may be... This one may be a little...

less noticeable you might need like side-by-side comparisons to really see it but it's actually in quarks makeup his nose in this one is very bulbous it's very big it's very wide very round it's it still is going to be big and round later on but it's not nearly as much as it was in this particular episode yeah i wouldn't notice that as much trying to still trying to work out all the i mean the other big change was we just got into bald cisco yeah and now i came back to season one cisco oh i hate this look for cisco ate it ate it bald goatee cisco is the best cisco just hawk he's gone full hawk and i appreciate it but yeah that's all i really got so I'm sorry, I just have to call this one out. The opening scene where Jazzy is getting kidnapped. I still don't understand why people in the future can't fight. Nobody can fight in the future. I understand the script calls for it, but my God, these guys do not know how to fight. This is supposed to be a military organization. They can't fight. They have the weirdest form of fighting, and I just don't understand any of these fights. They fight like they did back in the 60s. It was one thing back then because I don't know how many scripted fights there were on TV back in the 60s.

that fighting style feels has, has carried through all of Trek. And like, it's not really, there's that one fight scene. I think I complimented once, but the rest of them, no, not so much. Yeah. Yeah. It just, it gets me every time. It gets me every time. So, all right, Matt, let's go to the A plot. Talk to me about the A plot. What did you like? What did you not like? You know, what are your thoughts on, on just the overall Jadzia's on trial? Can she be held responsible for the crimes of a previous host? Is it the symbiote or is the host? Is she a new person all the way around? We had the same similar deal back in TNG when we did the measure of a man when data went on trial. So what, what's what man talks to me, but like you said, this one made you think, what'd you think? So back at that fight scene, Julian was.

There, he starts to initiate a fight, but then like pulls the hood down from that first person and hesitates. Sure. Like he's about to hit her and then stops. I'm like, why? Like my first thought was like he recognized the people for some reason or something. And so he didn't want to hit someone he knew. But then I'm like, did he just stop because she was female? Is that what we're supposed to get out of that? Was it because she was female or because he thought she was pretty? It was like, oh, hello. I think it's just female. Seriously. He pulled the hood down and was female. He's like, I can't punch him. They're trying. They are actively attacking Dax. Sure. You don't care what's under that hood. That's where I was confused. I'm like, he was all after Dax. And then it's like, oh.

She's getting kidnapped. I'm going to pause and look at this other girl. Really? Man, Julian's, I don't know. I want to like Julian, but actually now that I start talking about it, his opinion, my opinion of him is going down. I'm not sure I can get on board with him right now. So then the next portion of this, like every time I wrote down a comment, we'd jump to the next scene and one of the actors would say exactly what I'd written down. Something to the effect of like, they seem to have a pretty good knowledge of the station. Cut to Kira. They seem to know where they're going on the station. I'm like, really? Okay.

It's going to be that kind of episode. Got it. I guess I don't have to make too many notes. Can I talk about that moment real quick? Sure. Because it might be my favorite Kira moment of the first season for sure. Okay. Maybe the whole series. And it just, you know, look, I'm with a whole lot of people on their criticism of Nana Visitor's acting in the first couple of seasons. I don't know how much of that's Nana Visitor, how much of that's the director, how much of it's the script. I don't know, but I have trouble, like a lot of people, I have trouble connecting to Kira, particularly in the first bunch of seasons. I connect with her much better later on, just so you know. But I love when Sisko kindly, like he kind of figures it out and he tells him like, hey, listen, yeah, we're Federation. You have this treaty with the-

federation but this is actually a bajoran station and you know and like kira says something he's like uh i'm talking to commander cisco and cisco's like actually you need to talk to her because she's the bajoran representative on the station not me and she like she goes back and forth and she's like so you've got this thing and obviously you you're friendly with the cardassians which just really and i like what she should have said was which just really pisses us off now she couldn't say it because 90s and tv and whatever so they changed it to just really annoys us like i love that moment for kira like she's so over the top with it and it's played to perfection in my opinion it's just a it's a fun moment to me that i love every time i see her do it sure what i did like about this whole opening chase scene if you will is that little override device that they have yeah i haven't seen anything quite like that before and i don't know exactly how it works but i kind of want to know i mean i don't need to know but i think that'd be interesting to dive into like what that device is actually doing like it seems like it might just be like we have devices or at least we see them in the movies which i'm sure It means they exist somewhere in top military bases that you can stick on a digital lock of some sort and it'll decode the thing. You see the numbers like flipping back and forth. Yes. It gets digit by digit. It'll figure it out. Yeah, exactly. And like, I kind of figured that's what it's doing because they use it in so many different instances, like wants to open the doors, wants to take down the force fields, wants to, and like, it feels like you can just stick it anywhere on an electronic device and like press a button and it's like, okay, and we're good. Just a master key to the station. Yeah. I got it from Gold Dukat who had one in his pocket. Well, exactly. Like that's kind of what I thought after they explained the whole Cardassian connection and stuff, but.

why would the Cardassians need something like that? Well, they used to be in charge of the station. Well, yeah, it was their station. Why would they need some kind of override? Like to me, it's the master key. Cause you, you know, I, I haven't told you the story format. Maybe I would think a master key would just be their voice the way most of their stuff works. That's fair. That's fair. That's fair. I'm going to not tell you the story. It's wasted time, but anyway, it could be their voice. But to me, that's just always what I've, in my, in my extra Star Trek headcanon, the dude got that little device from Golducott. Okay. And you know, here's the password we get you. It will literally do everything in the station and take down everything you want. Yeah. I mean, it worked for the purposes of this episode. I'm like, that's why I'm not going to question it too much. It's just like,

I think it was kind of cool device though. Sure. So as this scene was wrapping up and like, they're about to get away instead of trying to fix the tractor beam, which obviously since it worked, it didn't matter. But my first thought would have been instead of trying to rush and fix that, why not send out a ship to follow them? Ooh, that's a good question because remember all they had then was runabouts and they were in like an actual ship that like could get away. All that the station had was little runabouts. They did mention that there were like five ships or whatever in port that.

had warp speed capabilities. Yeah, they'd have to come near one of those ships. Exactly. Odo will go and say, hey, security purposes, we need to come near this thing. I don't know if they could or not. Isn't that in the terms and conditions you sign when you dock at Deep Space Nine? You know, Matt, I've never actually read the paper when I dock. So I agree and move on. Yeah, exactly. I couldn't tell you. I don't know. I'm not up to date on Bajoran law either. So I don't know.

But it made for a cool sci-fi moment on TV. It's true. I do like the fact that they got away. I do like the fact they got away. And then they reached out and grabbed him and had to pull him back in. Like, that was a cool moment. It worked. It worked. But when Dax comes back on the ship, I guess we find out it's just she knows kind of why they're there. She's figured out, so she's starting to feel guilty and stuff. Well, she doesn't figure it out until he says his name. Well, because when they first come back off the ship, she's all kind of like, she looks kind of loopy. She's kind of drunk, yeah. It's almost like they drugged her. Exactly. Because my first thought was like, why did they give up so easily? Why are they just coming off their ship now? Shouldn't they have to break down the door?

you know bring them back by force but no they're just like no okay here we are here we are oh yeah okay and here's dax here you go yeah okay here's who we are like i i'm kind of what cisco gets to in a minute like why don't you just tell us in the beginning all right but i thought they had done something to dax at that point like i thought like i said they had drugged her or something along those lines and that they had enough time alone with her on their ship that they weren't worried about it anymore so whether that was they had implanted something in her or they had drugged her and she's going to die in an hour. Like, I don't know. Obviously that didn't happen though. Now you talked about earlier, not liking Tandro. Yeah. And I think I'm right there with you. Especially when like, he's this type of guy who builds up something in his head and just, he has a vendetta, right? Like that's what it is. Because as soon as he says, we're putting her on trial or whatever, or we want to convict her for the murder of my father. My first thought is, if it's the murder of your father, you should not be involved in the arrest or the warrant or whatever this is.

you are too close to the situation. Like, I don't care if you are actually the authorities in charge of bringing people like this in. I don't care if you are a bounty hunter or whoever would be in charge of bringing people in. You should not be able to take this case. No, no. It's a thing that has always bothered me about this episode. I get that it makes it more personal, but yeah, you have to recuse yourself from this case because you're not objective. You can't be objective. He could be along for the ride, maybe, but someone else needs to be serving this warrant. I agree. I wholeheartedly agree. Okay, I'm glad I'm not crazy. I wholeheartedly agree with you on that. It bugs me to no end every time I watch this episode. Awesome. Now, while I don't like Tandro, I actually have a bit of...

of a problem with Cisco in this episode too. I was hoping you might get here because I think I might know where you're going. Go ahead. Cause I'm on the other side. If you're where you're going, where I think you are. Okay. I appreciate when a captain or in this case, commander yet, whoever's in charge is willing to stand up and defend their people. But when he gets to a point where he says, if you find something that goes against what I just said, it's wrong. I don't know how I feel about that. That doesn't seem right. Yeah. So I'm with you on that. I'm with you on, on where you're going with this and I know where you are, but here's where I come down on that. Cisco has made his decision.

that ultimately the host, the current host cannot be held responsible for previous host actions. Okay. And I think what he was saying was if you find anything to the contrary, not that it's wrong as in it's incorrect. I think he's saying it's wrong as in it's morally the wrong answer. And we have like, it's not an okay answer. And because he then stops and he goes, and if you do find something, let me know because I can't, and this is the, this is the line that does it for me. I can't fight what I don't know about. You see, I liked that follow-up, but I think I was still stuck on the lines before that.

and, and maybe, maybe misinterpreting them. But yeah, I think your explanation helps a little bit, but it just felt wrong and dirty. And like, I, I, if that's the way you're going to be, I don't want to follow that. Yeah. I don't, I don't think it was, it was as much as a, Hey, we're not going to bring that up because, or, you know, it's wrong because we're just going to declare it to be wrong. Like, I think he's saying he has made a, a, like I said, that judgment and he's just saying it's morally wrong. It is not the right answer. And even if somebody did it before in the past, it doesn't make it right now. And I'm not going to accept it. Yeah. And I think even just the way you're wording it now, kind of on the spot.

is better than what was written. I think it could have been written better to help me understand that. Rent for Star Trek writer. Call me Alex Kersman. Call me. So yes, with that explanation, that helps a bit. I'm glad that at least you think that's not where Cisco meant to go with it as just a poor interpretation. But through all of this, I was still a little bit confused and I guess it kind of gets cleared up by the end. But why is Dax so silent? Like the whole time it felt like I don't want to be saved, which I loved by the end of this thing when Cisco finally put it to her and said, hey, you're basically committing suicide. Don't do that.

And I think that's kind of how I felt about this too. I'm like, it's one thing if you did commit some sort of crime or something, but don't just lay down and let them kill you. Like do something, say something, explain something. And I mean, that's one of the mysteries, I guess, of the episode is why, I mean, why is she so silent? She's covering something up or something's obviously off. She feels some sort of guilt or something. Turns out it has nothing to do with, you know, what actually happened. It has to do with something else.

And maybe they just want to hold on to the suspense a little bit longer. I think they could have done it throughout the entire episode. I think I would have rather, though, had the truth come from Jadzia or come from Dax, as opposed to Odo's investigation. Having to find it out. Yeah. Like, I feel that...

Dax would have confided in Cisco, at least by the end of the episode, after all the talks they had. And, you know, like, I think they could have gotten to that point. And I think he like, I think Dax should have like sworn him to secrecy and said, fine, I'll tell you what's going on, but you can't use it in trial. And then he has to find a way to work around it without revealing that information in the trial. Right. I think that would have made just as powerful an episode and just like, we would have gotten to the same place. I get where you're going with that. I guess the only thing that I, that I could say like in retort to that is that by doing it the way they did it, it really showed that Curzon specifically was very serious about keeping secret.

the affair that he was having with Sandro's mom, with Mrs. Sandro, right? Well, like his best friend's wife, which is not okay. But it wasn't so much to protect his own self. It was really to protect her. And that he was very serious. And that that, the other side of that was those feelings and those commitments and those desires translated through the symbiote to the new host, right? To which I think this might even go a little bit into the favor of the case that Sandro himself was arguing was that the symbiote still feels like he was trying to say, you know, you're guilty because you feel guilt. You're guilty because you remember it. You're guilty because whatever reason.

And he wasn't wrong. That's like, I think he might've been wrong to say you're guilty because X, Y, Z, but he was right. And she still did remember it. She still did feel it. She felt the commitment for, you know, and, and the, she felt, she felt like she still had an obligation that her past host had made to somebody who was still around, which by the way, we also saw that in the episode that we did called a blood oath. If you remember where she met with the three past Klingons and they went off on a mission and went to go do something. We saw that there too. So, you know, I think this really establishes that part of Jadzia. Like he's not wrong in that. I think he's wrong in this conclusion that that automatically makes her guilty because that's ultimately the message of this episode, right? Like that's the thing that.

you thinking is well is the current host in symbiote responsible for the past actions of previous hosts in symbiote i think most of us go no like that's an easy question to us no but isn't it actually a little more complicated than that? It is definitely more complicated. And I don't think I'm necessarily ready to give an answer, but I would say the strongest argument in the other way for me was when they're like, this happened 30 years ago before she was born. Yeah. Right. And so I'm not a hundred percent sure if this is how everything happens, but in my head, the thing happened in the past before she was born, she gets joined up with this host or with this symbiote. And it's not until she's actually joined that she's actually made aware of the past, whatever this other host had done. Right. Yeah. And not only that, but like it wasn't even in her lifetime. So there's nothing she could have done.

about it. She couldn't try to stop it or intercede. She didn't have an active knowledge of, oh yeah, this just happened in the past five years. I saw this guy do it and now I'm going to take over the symbiote. It wasn't anything like that. And on top of it, I mean, it was something they were keeping secret. So no one knew about it. So what that all comes down to in my mind is she didn't have any knowledge of it prior. She didn't have any way of knowing about it until she was joined. So now she's being tried for a memory, basically being tried for a memory that was implanted in her. And that's something I have a hard time getting over because she didn't do it. The symbiote was also there.

us we get that was part of and yeah that's where they get into well are they one or are they two they have two brains and all this other stuff but it just feels really weird to think about it like that like she is being tried for a memory that was implanted in her and to me that seems messed up so yeah i mean okay so let's dive into this was it the symbiote that had an affair with his best friend's wife or was that more the host my instinct says the host but i i will go along with the arguments that they they put in this episode it's like how connected are they because once they're joined they're joined and they are one they can't live without each other after 90 three days, which I was kind of sad that they said 93 days instead of 94 because 94 is two times 47. But I just find it hard to really come to a conclusion, I guess.

See, here's the thing. And this is, this is coming from our episode facets that we just did. When I look back and I think about all the previous hosts of Jet, of the Dax symbiote, here's what's clear to me. The Dax symbiote is not what influenced Curzon to go do that. Okay. Like that was something that was unique to the host of Curzon. And I'm not saying that all the other ones, all the other hosts before Curzon were infallible, but that was definitely Curzon's personality was to go out there and be a bit gregarious and to be a bit of a ladies man. It does feel more like the host brings the personality. It does. And so, and so with that, and whereas the symbiote carries the memories. So, you know, to me, I think a lot of it comes down to that, but I even like the other argument.

soon as that that symbiote is joined to a new host it's a new entity it's it's a new thing and you know there's almost even a piece of me that says okay if if a joined trill commits a crime and that the punishment for that crime is execution should we not maybe remove the symbiote first so the symbiote can move on to be implanted in someone else and you know if execution is even okay and i'm not making an argument for that one way or the other i'm just saying you know that there are places out there where execution is a thing you know what i mean like it would almost like i think you actually have to have that question is should you not remove the symbiote first so the symbiote can live the symbiote can move on and maybe even carry these memories in these uh lessons learned you would hope one would hope you know sure so i mean if whoever's putting them through this trial believes that the symbiote is part of the problem and that that's going to carry over from host to host then i mean yeah why would you release the symbiote i mean that that's i think that's all questions that have to be brought up during the trial is oh what if putting this in this person makes this person go do that well i mean honestly though like unless jadzia could get a different symbiote like i i would think that would be the solution is to actually execute the symbiote because that's

All that's left of, you know, curves on Dax that actually committed, well, supposedly committed the crime. And so you get rid of that. And like, Jad Zia had nothing to do with it. And I mean, that's even what the judge said. Splitter in two. Well, you can't do that because, you know, they're inseparable. And well, the hosts are hard to come by. Or the symbiotes are hard to come by. Symbiotes, yeah. Sorry, no can do. And in their culture, the life of the symbiote trumps the life of the host. I don't know if you know that or not. I think we've kind of mentioned that briefly because we talked about how hard they are to come by and why it's such a big deal in like the application process and stuff.

Now, this leads me to one thing that I kind of wanted to say. Like, I picked up on it watching this episode for the first time this time. the Gregory Edson character, uh, Tandro, I was reading Tandro, particularly in the beginning of the episode, whenever he's referring to Dax, he never says she, he never, he never humanizes Jadzia. It's always this creature, the trill, the, the, this thing. I don't know that I picked up on it, but it doesn't surprise me at all. He, he, he very much dehumanizes the person and only goes after, you know, it's not Jadzia Dax. It's just Dax. Are you Dax? Dax? Dax? I'm, I'm, I'm focusing on Dax. It's the creature. It's the trill. Exactly. Right. Um, it's the creature. And it really got me thinking like, and it was, it's juxtaposed to Cisco, especially in the open.

arguments of the, of the trial or the hearing, I'm sorry, it's not a trial, it's a hearing where Cisco was saying she and Jadzia and he was, he was putting a human person right there. And I think this is a very Star Trek thing to do. And this is a very DC Fontana thing to do as well. And I mean, you mentioned like, this is one of those kind of Star Trek episodes that makes you think, well, DC Fontana wrote it. So it would make like, she's pretty good at it by now. Yeah. Co-wrote it. That's true in life. Whenever you take a person or a people group and you dehumanize them and not refer to them and not think of them as people, but you think of them as that group, you give a new name to them.

Usually it's a derogatory name. And I'm not going to repeat any of them here on this podcast because that get us in trouble and they're not worth repeating. But you guys know what words are out there that take a group of people and lump them into one derogatory term. And when you start calling them those things, that dehumanizes them. And all of a sudden you can be better than that. Or you can just kill it. You can execute it. You can be dispassionate about it because they're not people anymore. But as soon as you start seeing it as a person, it makes it harder. And you actually have to recognize the humanity that is there. And you can't just flippantly behave with it. And we saw the same thing happen back in the episode, The Measure of a Man, when Dado went on trial.

for his personhood. And Bruce Maddox, the guy who was on the other side, kept referring to Data as it. It wouldn't even look Data in the face, would really only, or in the eye, wouldn't look him in the eye, wouldn't communicate with him. He was always talking to everybody else about this thing until later in the episode, he started actually kind of referring. I think that was the tipping point was like, ah, that's interesting. That's the first time you've called me he, or you've used a personal pronoun for me and not said it. But it's not super overt in this episode, I think as a message, but I do think it's something that they put in there. And it's one of the things I love about Star Trek is they show you that. And I think it screamed loudly to me watching this episode. The fact that he refused.

to refer to Jadzia by any personal or human pronouns, but only by, you know, impersonal. Or by her name. Or by her name, exactly. Refuse to acknowledge her. And I mean, that's something you see in TV movies all the time. It's usually like in a hostage or kidnapping situation where, you know, they're demanding a ransom. And, you know, the first thing the negotiator has to do is establish that, you know, this is a person, this is a human life that we're dealing with. We gotta, like you said, we gotta humanize them. Gotta humanize the person that kidnapped so they don't kill them. If it's just a thing that they took from you, they have no problem getting rid of it. But as soon as the person, it's someone's dog.

or it's someone's son then you get those feelings and you can you can do something with that so yeah i get that and and that's i also like that they put that in there i can't say i noticed it my first time through but i believe you and that that is good good writing there matt did you have anything else about this episode one other thing i realized i probably should put back in the character notes section but that other trail they brought on oh yeah yeah um I don't know what his name was, but it mostly referred to him as Trill. But after meeting Jadzia, and then you meet this guy who is just like super dry and boring. And here's your Harry Potter reference, man. This is if he would have made the movies, this guy should have played Professor Binns. Wow. Like, I mean, I'm sitting there like every time he was asked a question, it's just like gave the slowest, driest, most boring reply. I'm like, really? Really, dude? I'm guessing they probably told him to play the role like.

you're not on anyone's side play it as neutral as possible don't try to lean one way or the other towards the trailer away from trail or towards whatever just you know stay neutral and like that's what we got and like huh now now i want i need to meet a third drill to find out who's the outlier if jed z is that the outlier being that outgoing and that friendly and that much of a people person and happy and bubbly and most of most of the time not so much this episode but or if they're more dry like this guy i'm like huh it just was also another very stark difference between the two yeah It definitely is. And we'll see if we come across a third trill out there somewhere. They exist. I promise you that, Matt. They definitely exist. And we'll see. We will see. Anything else from this episode you want to talk about? I think that about covers it. All right. Well, I got one little production note that I want to put out here for you. Sure, sure. Actually, I have a couple here. Robert Hewitt Wolf says that this was the episode where he started to get the show. He didn't fully get it until he got to this episode. And he says it was here that he realized that they could drive these characters and that our heroes were fallible, but they were also interesting and complicated. Those were three words he used. They're fallible, they're interesting, and they're complicated. And he's like, I could do something with that as a writer. This feels like a weird episode.

Yeah. Like, I mean, cause like I said, it's a courtroom episode. It doesn't really. drive any of the rest of the story we barely see the rest of the station like i guess we're in quarks but we're not actually like it's not quarks at this time like if they hadn't told us i wouldn't have been able to pick it out sure i want to talk about that in just a minute because i found that as a production note as well why they used quarks and it wasn't just to save money in fact it specifically wasn't to save money because that's what i would have said ah it's an existing set they can just you know refit it and there it is um but no but like i get it on his side because suddenly our characters have depth and there really is this well is he guilty is she not is what is the background what is the baggage you're bringing into this and where could you go with that and what does this make your character? One of the things they talk about, Irish from Bear says, this was the episode that established Jadzia as the sort of fun loving character, this party goer kind of person. And that part of her backstory, which actually really came from Curzon, really like this, this kind of helped lifted her into this sort of the Jadzia we know and love today. You know, I was going to say programs and playing Tongo. That's kind of weird to, to, to hear right now, because I need to remember that we're jumping back three seasons. And this is the very beginning where I was like, I said, I've kind of seen some of that already. I've seen more of Jadzia. And so it's, it's, I guess it is something that maybe you could have.

gotten from this episode back to me, it was just like, yeah, that's who she is. I've seen that. So the thing about the Quark's bar is it was not to save money because that's what I would have said. You know, they only have so many sets. Just redress the set and boom, there you go. But basically what the writer says and says they just thought that the Quark's bar set was a really interesting set. They thought it looked really cool and they wanted to show it off. Also, their thought process was, look, the station is mostly closed off. And even though there's all this unused space around the station, you can't just go in and flip it on.

for whatever reason, like it's still destroyed. They're still putting things together. So they really had a rather limited space because remember there's only seven episodes in, you know, and the Cardassians destroyed the station for the most part. So, so they're still, you know, fixing all that up. So here we have Quark's Bar, which is the only place that was big enough that was fully functioning on the station where they felt like they could logistically hold this, this meeting. And so that's why they use Quark's Bar, but they also really wanted to show off the set. So, you know, there's like, they actually had money to build a new set if that's what they wanted to do, but they opted not to. They wanted to use Quark's Bar because it just made, to them it made the most sense. I never had that translate in my mind before I read this note. I understand it now. Like I really get where they're coming from in that thought process. I just.

thought about it like that before sure speaking of the other courtrooms you know i kind of want her gavel yeah if they even call it a gavel yeah they do their world that should be a great like just put it on your desk kind of item exactly i mean that is like one of the ultimate, I mean, even if it's only used in this episode, like that is a collector's item right there. Sure. If I've ever seen one. And it's like, only if you've seen this episode, do you have any idea that it's even Star Trek related? But like, I would actually probably buy that if it was available, which now I'm curious, but. I need, what's the name of that company that does all the replica stuff? The Noble Collection? I need Noble Collection. Yeah, I need Noble Collection to make this for me. For sure. For sure. All right, here's the only other, this was the actual production note I wanted to mention just because I thought this was cool. Jadzia Dax in her quarters on a shelf actually has a replica of a fertility idol that was featured in Raiders of the Lost Ark. Okay. So I just, I thought that was neat.

That's interesting. Yes. Yes, very much so. Very much so. So, all right, Matt, well, I guess that's going to do it. I think we've exhausted this episode, Dax. Give us your final closing thoughts. You said you like this episode. You think you do. Any final closing thoughts as we get out of here? Yeah, I mean, I like the episode. I don't think it really changes my opinion too much of Dax. I told you, I think Julian, my opinion of Julian may have taken a dive a little bit.

But, and I was prepared to, you know, take a dive on Cisco a little bit too, but I think you talked me out of that one. So I think we're doing pretty well overall. I think we're just getting more on track with where everybody else probably is. Sure. Just cause I have more information now. So there was one line about Cisco. You mentioned Cisco. There's one line about Cisco where he gets in there and like, he blows up at Jadzia for like not helping. And Jadzia looks at him and goes, you know, Curzon always told you to watch your anger. And I was like, Ooh, Cisco has an anger problem where he gets really forced. I'm like, like, I'm thinking of what all I know out of Cisco. And I go, that's an interesting thing to say this early. Keep an eye on that, Matt. Cause I think it's.

of what makes Cisco I wouldn't call it an anger issue I wouldn't that's not what I would call it but Cisco's got some fire to him that doesn't really exist in like say you know Picard or someone else like that so uh yeah not Picard I could see that name come out of Kirk but yeah yeah uh we'll do that so all right Matt well would you like to know what our next episode is uh Do we do that? You don't know. We don't know because extra viewings are up to you, Matt. You get to pick the ones that sound interesting to you and we'll pick one out here in about the next three weeks to do our next one for our patrons out there. Big thank you to the patrons who are out there again for everyone. This episode was especially for you. Now, listen, if you guys would like to stump for an episode for next month's extra viewing, you can do that. You can send us an email. You guys know the email address by now. BeameUpPod at gmail.com or you can even head over to BeameUpPod.com and there's a way to connect with us over there as well. Well, guys, that's going to do it for us. Thanks again so much for supporting the show. Until next time, guys.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Beam Me Up: A Star Trek Podcast?

This episode is 1 hour and 1 minute long.

When was this Beam Me Up: A Star Trek Podcast episode published?

This episode was published on May 9, 2023.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Beam Me Up: A Star Trek Podcast episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.