Hey everybody, this is Brent from Beam Me Up Star Trek podcast. As you may know, Matt and I have finished recording the main run of the show. However, over the course of our three and a half years of recording the show, we actually recorded several episodes that to this point have either gone unaired or they were exclusive to our Patreon page. Well, now that we're on the backside of the main show, we thought that it would be a great time to release those episodes to you guys out there, our listening audience. Plus, you never know when Matt and I may jump in with a random new episode. The final frontier begins. This is about saving the future of humanity. This is a huge victory for the good guys.
Welcome to another extra viewing episode of Beam Me Up, a Star Trek podcast. This one is exclusively for you guys, our Patreon listeners. Thank you so much for your support of the show. As you guys know by now, I'm Brent. I'm Matt.
And we are here to do a few extra viewings. And this is going to be a special extra viewing that we're doing today, Matt. We're doing this one in a bit of a new way. The last one I think we did in a new way. We're doing this one in a bit of a new way. This is the first extra viewing where we're doing multiple episodes. Yeah. And not just two multiple episodes. We're doing three episodes all today. This is going to be quite the experiment. Yes, yes. This is a little bit of an experiment, but it's also, it's part of how the, I think, I think this fits very well with an extra viewing episode. Now, those of you guys out there listening, I'm sure you've already read the show description. You know, we are going to be covering what Matt and I have kind of come to call the three C's. These are all.
bottle episodes like mad i don't know if you've uh if you caught on to the idea like the events of these episodes don't affect anything in the larger star trek world like it's just there's a bottle episode well yeah because they forgot about them right right um they all kind of sort of have i feel like they're they're sort of similar they are when you told me you're gonna do three episodes i i and you pick these three and like oh i'll start with c that's cool let's do those and it's like okay i i guess we can do three random episodes together i think it's gonna end up being a really long clunky show but we can give it a shot yeah but no there's actually kind of a common thread that runs through them There is definitely a common thread. It still may wind up being a clunky show. Sure. But we are here. So we're going to be doing it from was it season four was clues. And then we're doing conundrum and cause and effect from season five. Now, Matt, I'll tell you one of the one of the background ways of how I decide what shows we're going to do. There's there's a Star Trek podcast out there called Trek Geeks. And they have they have a series, an episode that they do called see it or skip it. And they'll do they'll do them like by seasons of individual shows. So like one of the things is they'll go through and say, OK, you see this episode, skip this episode, which you might can understand is pertinent to my task here.
Yes. You know, they have a completely different reason for why. So I have to take that with a little bit of a litmus test. But if the two podcast hosts both say see it and the guest host that they have on because they always have a guest host. And then they also have like a Facebook page that's got like, I don't know, six thousand people on it. And those guys vote. They have like a poll. And if the Facebook page, like if everybody says see an episode, that's going to weigh pretty heavily for me. All of these episodes were see it all the way across the board. At the end of the day, I had to say no because of the larger run. But.
But ultimately, you know, when we sat down and said, OK, we're about to turn the page with Next Generation and Deep Space Nine and a bunch of different things. If you want to get any of these extra viewings and do it, you looked at me and said, OK, well, which one should I do? Because I think I gave you like 30. Yeah, we have a huge list. I started like my third sheet of paper. And we're not going to do all 30. But, you know, if you had to boil it down, I was like, you know, these three are kind of fun and should kind of wrap in. So, Matt, the episodes, like we said, are doing clues, conundrum and cause. I have a very short description of each episode. So let me read that. And then we'll just sort of we'll get your your overarching thoughts and we'll just sort of bounce around and see how this this goes. All right. All right. So clues.
case you guys didn't watch it first you guys should uh the crew of the enterprise wakes up in an apparent after apparently passing through a wormhole but they find mysteries surrounding their blackout data is acting suspiciously prompting the command staff to wonder if he has been compromised conundrum was after the crew's memories are mysteriously erased there's a little bit of tie-in the computer right the computer records indicate that the federation is at war with a group called the lycians and the enterprise has been in order to attack their command center and they've got to figure out what the heck is going on and then in the episode cause and effect the destruction of the enterprise nears a distortion in the space-time continuance and it's caused by a temporal causality loop trapping the ship and crew in time forcing them to relieve the events that lead to their deaths and they have no memory of each loop before except for a little faint deja vu pieces so with that matt a lot of people not being able to remember what just happened or what's going on um what were your kind of i guess overarching thoughts on i don't know if you want to take these each individual episode if you just sort of i mean there will be some things that you know tie together and we'll talk as the episodes as a group but otherwise yeah i'll probably be kind of starting at the beginning because like i said that's just how my notes go there you go a to z so do mine so i
I do want to throw this out there because it's come up a few times. This whole Dixon Hill thing. Yeah. Card. It's really my favorite. No, I've never really been like big, you know, film noir guy. So it's just kind of setting that time frame and not really my thing. I mean, whatever is what it is. I understand why they used it because they're setting up. Oh, mystery, mystery, mystery, mystery. Sure. Okay, sure. And like it's Picard's thing. Yeah. Yeah. Like it's his. Yeah. Even more because they're like, hey, they really hammered home at the beginning of this episode. We're having some downtime. Right. Reminder, the Enterprise is not always in the middle of a battle.
Right. We're all bored. Cause like, yeah, there's a whole bunch of them like doing yoga or something. Oh, can we talk about that just for a second? Sure. If you want, there's a name for that. That is the, the, and I hope I'm saying it right. The Mokbara class. And this is the first time that we have seen war leading this Klingon Kung Fu Tai Chi. I don't know. I don't know what it, I mean, my son takes karate. I did karate for a while back when I was younger. And as part of that, you have to do a form. And so this kind of has that feel to it. Um, but yeah, it's, it's definitely kind of yoga, yoga ishy. Um, it's, it's martial arts, but it's some sort of training, but it's just, that's about all you ever see is you just see them doing it. It looks weird. And then they break and they start having it.
conversation. Yep. So, but this is, this is the first episode where we ever see that. Well, it will crop up a handful of times throughout the rest of the run. Sure. I don't know if you're ever going to see it again, but it'll be there. Okay. Yeah. Uh, yes. I mean, okay. I do want to make sure in the Dixon Hill part though, that was Guinan, right? Yes. Okay. No, that was Gloria from Cleveland. Well, yes, but she, she, she was part of it like.
Like I understand she was trying to take on like what was going on here. And it was her first time in that simulation or whatever. Fine. But it just felt like for how much knowledge like Picard has of the past and stuff. And maybe this is my lack of knowledge of, you know, what or who Guinan actually is. But I feel like she would have a better grasp on some of these things. And so it felt weird that he had to explain to her. It's like, you know, this is a mystery. And now we have to go search for clues. And this is what we call fun. I'm like, oh, OK. I would think Guinan understands that. Like she's the wise one that, you know, explains things to other people, not usually the other way around. So that was a little weird. But I feel like you are.
how should I say this? Almost relating to Guinan a little bit though. Like, okay, this is fun. Like I get it, but like, really, this is what you call it. Come on, come on, Picard. Yeah.
Yeah. And by the way, I mean, this is the first time we've seen. So this was season four. This is the first time we've seen Dixon Hill since whatever last episode you and I did. Yeah. Season three, which was right before. Yeah. I wouldn't expect them to revisit it super often. No. Well, there's a line where she's like, I haven't seen you in a year or something like that. Oh, yeah. Like, it's just like, it's just a reference. I don't know if this is the last Dixon Hill shot. I don't, I don't recall it coming up again. Okay. But that doesn't, when you've seen these episodes as often as I have, it just sort of all starts running together every while. I understand that. Like, it can be something that's only in like two episodes ever, but you rewatch the series.
so many times it feels like it's all over the place. Yeah, right. Exactly. Exactly. Now, Voyager is a little bit different when they get to their holodeck stuff. And we'll talk about that when we get there. All right. So then we jump into this like time lapse memory forgetfulness stuff. And like we're saying before, I did not expect all these episodes to kind of be tied together with like if I had to give it a theme memory loss. Right. Right. Right. And I guess I never realized how.
how differently you can approach solving memory loss or, you know, even portraying memory loss or whatever, however you want to put it. Because these three episodes are distinctly different, but all kind of have that thread running through them. And I'll put it out here. I, the first episode, Clues, was the most surprising as to like what was actually going on and how they handled that. But I think the third one, Cause and Effect, was actually the most entertaining for me. Yeah, I can, I can 100% see that. And I think, I feel like, and you can correct me if you have a, well, don't correct me. This is my opinion. I feel like almost in order, the.
the mystery level ratchets up in each one. Like you talk about how you like a good mystery, which is one of the reasons why I wanted you to see these episodes. Sure. They all have that mystery aspect. Like what the heck is going on? Yeah. Like there's clues. Okay. What the heck's going on with data and what happened? Why is everything looking just a little bit weird? It's just a little bit off. And then you get into conundrum and everybody's jacked up. And then there's this weird dude on the ship. Who's he? And we're about to go do something that is not us. And you know, is that unfold? So that, that ratchets up. And then you get to cause an effect where you have, we see the enterprise explode like seven times throughout the course of the episode, you know, I mean, I think it's one for act, including prologue. So yeah. So that'd be six. Well, mine is the last one.
Oh, yeah, they don't do that. Which, when we get down to that, I have a fun little note for you. Sure, sure. We'll be right back. Slugans. Shall we play a game? It's over, Johnny. No! Oh, wow, man. Hey, if you recognize those sounds, then you're probably somebody who would like our show. We are called Did You Hear About This, and we talk about all kinds of news stories, like the 80s and 90s stuff that we grew up on. Yeah, this isn't stuff that's getting covered on the 10 o'clock news, I'll tell you that. You can check us out at didyouhearaboutthis.show. We're on every single podcast platform. Go find us.
But yeah, so like, I think the beginning, you know, I said that it was most unexpected. Like I, I didn't have it figured out. I'm like, okay, a phenomenon or a species or something attack them. And it affected everybody, but did it because he's an Android. He's not a life form. Right. In most respects, I guess. Right. Um, so that made sense. Cool. We have, have a problem we have to solve. Uh, but then like I said, the second one was conundrum. Like I noticed that extra guy pretty quickly. Cause I'm like, who is this random red shirt guy on the bridge who they're actually giving lines to? Okay. So I have a question about that. Cause I wanted to know, like, like my note is, Hey, who's the new guy? Is he just a random red shirt?
Like there are people that we don't know who serve on the bridge. Yes. Like there's that, you know, we always talk about that rotating seat and like, even in the old series and this one now, like we still get that from time to time, you know, especially since like Wesley's gone, like, and okay. And somebody is like, I see Rose there, but yeah. Like there have been other people, but this guy was a little more prominent. And like, like I said, the big distinction for me was he kept getting lines and not just like, Oh, we're on course captain or, you know, whatever, just a quick report or something. Like he started like giving suggestions or like different, like an actual bridge member crew. Yeah. You know that.
the top level members of a crew that, that I didn't know. I'm like, who? I think that's exactly what you were supposed to feel when that happened though. Yeah. I think you experienced that in 100% the right way until you get to that spot where they're reading the crew manifest. And it's like, Oh, whatever his name was. I forget. McDuff. McDuff. Thank you. I was gonna say may, but McDuff. And he's the commanding officer, the first officer on the ship. Yeah. They listed him as, yeah. What was it? Was it just commanding? Commander, commander, whatever. No, no. Executive officer. Right. You're in McDuff. Right. Which is Riker's title.
had to think about like because he always like calls him number one or you know so i think like first officer usually i think how we often refer to him and so i'm like okay executive officer but then right after that is like second officer and like okay so that's not right right okay so something's funky with that guy yep right right yeah and i will be honest after i finished the episode i rewound to the beginning and said okay where does he first show up how how soon did they actually put him in there and and so i watched like the first minute or two of the episode again actually i had to get a little further in because they have some weird intro in that one actually but um they when they counter that first ship you're like there's one life form on board and like i didn't catch that the first time through that oh yeah there's a ship with only one life form aboard that's kind of weird in the first place too like okay but then you know that ship's gone and like we still get a couple of shots where he's not there he's not there and it's right before they go to credits you see him in the background oh is it really yeah i've never done that but yeah that's cool but like he they they pan from reicher over to picard and like over picard's left shoulder you can see him standing there kind of nonchalantly and it's like oh nobody noticed me yeah i really thought what you're gonna say is like the first time like the camera pans to him and
And he has like that line, whatever that first line is. I thought you were going to tell me that's the first line. No, it's not. It's not. Okay, I like that. I like that. I'll have to go back and definitely look at that. I got to tell you what, though. The Paxons, the aliens from the first episode, you know what they need? If they need the technology that that dude in the second episode has, they can also wipe out Data's mind, too. Exactly. And that's why I kind of liked how this played out. And that's what made these episodes so different. It's like the first one can't wipe out Data. So those aliens had, the Paxons had to deal with that. And then the second one where they could wipe out Data. So it's like, okay, these are stronger.
more advanced in some form or fashion. And so that's going to be a new problem for the crew. But in every instance, you still kind of get, you know, those, those lingering effects, those things that they didn't erase or couldn't erase or like even getting into the third one. I mean, the groundhog is a deja vu type of thing going on. And it's, it's, I think that's my favorite part about memory loss episodes to see how that plays out. Right. Cause they kind of address it in, uh, let's see, these are all going to run together for me already. And I'm going to have to sit here and scroll through all my notes, but, um, I think it was, it must've been the second one where it is the second one in conundrum.
Was that where Riker and Roe? Yes. Got together kind of? Yes. Yes. And we have to talk about that. Yeah. First of all, let's just put this in context. These two episodes that had Roe in them is the first time you've seen Roe since that introductory episode. Since she got hired? For you. Yeah. For you. It's the first time you've seen her. I think she's only in a total of like nine episodes or something. And so it's not a lot through like the last three seasons, especially for somebody who was supposed to be like sort of the replacement for Wesley. They just didn't get her in a whole lot. So, you know, here you're seeing these two. And I like in the beginning of that episode how we get a whole walk and talk of Roe and Riker just bickering.
remind us. We hate each other. Right. Because then when we wipe your memories, what happens? Love each other. Well, cause yeah, they're standing right next to each other. They must like each other. Right. That's how things work. Right. But I mean, I mean, that brings it to the end of the episode where Riker kind of gets ambushed by the two of them. Yeah. Yeah. And it's like, you know, I, you know, I read something about, you know, how you, you do things that you really want to do. I forget how she worded it, but basically said, you know, you've always kind of wanted to do something with Ro. You just, yeah. Right. But you kind of get like, I don't know. This is where I, huh?
They're messing with him, right? Right, right. But there's a little bit of Deanna in here, though, that you go with the, okay, her and Will are not together. And they both understand that about each other. But it's like neither really like that idea because I think Deanna, at least I get a vibe, Deanna's still a little like, mm-hmm, mm-hmm, I told you, like, you know, you better probably make an appointment with me, son. If you apply the logic that they just used with Riker and Rowe to Riker and Troy during the memory loss portion, it's like something was about to happen with Riker and Troy if Rowe hadn't come in. That's right. So, I mean, it's all right there.
It's the same thing with both of them. It's just in one case it happened in one case it didn't. So speaking of Riker, we get all the Riker info that we've ever known before. Yes. I made a note of that. It's like, wow, 10 second rundown of all things Riker. That's all you need to know. Everything from the trombone to Alaska to. Yeah. Yeah. He can get any woman he wants. Right. There's also another another thing.
Do you remember our discussion about, oh, he likes to take his vacations on Ryza. Oh, yep. Do you remember our discussion about Ryza? I told you there's like a little statue thing called a Horgon that like when you're out on Ryza, like you display it. It just means like, oh yeah. On Riker's like nightstand next to his bed where Rho, remember like he rocks in like Rho sitting on his bed or in a chair or something. The Horgon's right next to her, right next to the bed. I believe it. So yeah, Riker and Rho.
Hey, back up to clues real quick before we move on from that one. Two things that I had from that. Well, three actually. One, that story was a spec script story. Like people, like they had an open submission policy and people could send in a script. Like random you and me could send in a script. It was a guy sent in the script and they gave it to a guy named Joe Minoski who's going to become a writer on the show after this point. And he does a lot of the stuff and he does a lot of genre work after Star Trek. But the only thing they really changed from it was there was apparently a lot of Wesley in the original script. But Wesley's departure, which was like just a handful of episodes before this one, like kind of threw a monkey wrench into all that. So they had to go over.
How is the common folks supposed to know that? Exactly. So, uh, so they had that, but I mean, they still, they bought the script. They liked it. They thought it was really good. Uh, a little, a little, a little mistake in it though. When I think it's in the flashback scene, when Picard is giving data, the order to not reveal the Paxons to anyone. Okay. He calls them. Don't reveal the existence of the Paxons. They haven't said their name yet. Like nobody knows their name yet. They haven't, they haven't declared that. Uh, and then, uh, Dr. Crusher's nurse, nurse Ogawa. This is the episode where we first get her first name, which was Alyssa. I don't know if you picked up on that.
Okay, I wanted to ask you about that when we got to, I think it was cause and effect because she calls in as Agawa. I'm like, wait, who's that? Right. And I wasn't sure who that was. Like, yeah, I heard Alyssa in the first one. They at least gave me a face to put with the name. Then I just had the voice and like, is that what we had before? You've seen her a handful of times already in the main run. I don't know if they've referenced the name though.
Maybe I know I have. I don't know if they've done on the show, but I know that I have referenced it in my own recaps. I've had to write it a few times. But one place specifically, actually, I think this was another extra viewing we did when we did the game with Wesley. She was the one in the elevator, the turbo lift that just went, I'm on level 47. You see, that would be a thing like outside sickbay. I don't know if I'd recognize her. Right. But Nurse O'Galit. So this is the episode where we get her first name, Alyssa. Okay. Cause and effect to the note that maybe you're going to ask me about. That's the very first time we actually got her last name. Okay. So, so yeah, I did not plan for that to happen at all. It just happened in this run. That's what I'm saying. Like I haven't gotten her name much.
before yeah because we haven't done a lot of those right i find it interesting we got her her first name first and then her last name because like you remember with o'brien miles o'brien we didn't know who he was for the first couple of times and then they gave him a last name yep and then they eventually and when uh warf's parents came on board is when we got his and then later we get his middle name which is edward i think for the most part it makes sense that we're gonna get a lot of last names first right because that's how a lot of the crew like the captain in particular references people sure so and i think we would in the real world mostly too uh well i don't know i don't call you sonnenberg all the time yeah but i have friends who do i mean my last name is a little bit tougher because it's longer and more multiple syllables and stuff. But I mean, I, we're gonna call you Sonny. Oh boy.
I think like when I played football, it was everybody always called me by my last name. They didn't coach never. I don't even know that he knew my first name. Tell you the truth. Yeah. So I mean, it's in a situation like that, too, where you have a team or something. It's going to be should be more unique most of the time. Yeah. Unless your last name is Smith. But otherwise, you know, if your name is John and there's three other Johns on the team, that's not going to work. That's why I think a lot of times in football, you hear just numbers. Right. There's no duplicates there. Right. It's not supposed to be. Yeah. Maybe in practice. It happens in preseason every once in a while, but not very often. All right. So clues. All right. I have all my notes out for clues. I don't know if you have anything back there that you want to hit before we just kind of put a bow on that one. I.
think that's about it yeah okay um and then conundrum we've talked about so i want to know about conundrum um so you see roe they're going through this whole one last thing with clues yeah i i did find it interesting that at the very end when paxans uh are kind of agreeing to picard's plan mentioned that you are a most unusual species worthy of a second chance yeah that's an interesting way to put it and all right all right i'll take it but yeah yeah i don't think there's a lot of other species that would usually say you're you're worthy of a second chance humans well do you remember way back when we did i want to say it was the gorn episode in fact i'm sure it was the gorn episode and you had the Metrons, um, which some people think were, were the Q continuum. Sure. They called them something different, but they said, um, they said to him like, huh, you're like after Kirk chooses not to kill the Gorn. Yeah. Right. And he, and they're like, huh, you guys are young, but you're kind of cool. Maybe like 5,000 years we'll be friends or something like that. Like it's, it's kind of that same, same sentiment, just, you know, a little, a little, a little more time constricted, I guess.
they're the fifth race anyway you're saying conundrum conundrum um so they're going through conundrum uh before they figured out who everybody was and everybody was all mixed up like wharf was thinking he's the captain yeah picard's at the helm which is like only the third time we've ever seen him piloting anything yeah that was weird to see him sitting down like at a console right that was weird but picard is still leading like he's still he didn't initially but yeah like just over time you saw that shift it's like he's gonna make these suggestions and then like there was one spot in the middle like he he was started just like giving orders to i don't remember if it was reicher or whoever but like Worf was like standing in between them and just kind of looking back and forth. I'm like, Oh man, you're starting to realize maybe, maybe this isn't your role, man. Right. Right. Um, so you have that. And then, and then I just, I got to talk about Picard or Picard handling Worf's apology. Yeah. Like once they figured it out and he's like, no, captain, I, um,
I'm going to go hide in my room for the rest of our journey here. Sure. It's like, look, we're all trying to do the best we can. Don't worry about it. We're good. It's fine. Yeah. But also how about data as a bartender? I think he could do very well. I mean, it's kind of like Guinan, like you almost go like really a bartender. That's what you're going to spend your time on now. Like, I don't want to say beneath. That's not, that's not the thing. It's just his training does not necessarily lead him to the bar. Like, I mean, I think in Guinan's case in particular.
It's kind of like Picard wanted her on the ship. It's like, you probably could do any job, but I kind of want to leave you open to do any job. So we're going to give you a kind of menial task over here as the bartender. So you have enough free time to do other things when you need to. I got to tell you, though, I don't know that I've ever met a bartender, like a true bartender who doesn't kind of consider themselves a little bit like a guy. And like I tend to bar and I listen like they're almost like a like a on what's the word, like an unlicensed counselor, you know, that there's just the wisdom. You know, it's I think most bartenders far more consider themselves more like Guinan than they do like Moe.
Yeah, you know, I think that's fair. I mean, it's kind of the stereotype. And I don't know if it's more so those are the type of people who go into tending bar or if it's the other way around. It's like you learn it at the same time you're learning to make drinks. You have to listen to people because that's what you're going to do. That's hard to make your money. Yeah, I mean, I've got a good friend of mine that that's his girlfriend is has been a bartender and just makes really good money at it. You know, to the point of I think she's trying or maybe she's just like she's she's working on it right now of opening her own bar. Wow. You know, so that's I mean, that's that's you find something you're good at. You find something that makes you happy and that you can make a living out of it.
reading to society in that way. And all of a sudden you become a business owner and you rock with it that way. And now you're employing people and, uh, you know, helping out training the next generation. There you go. There you go. And, uh, so yeah, anyway. All right. So clues conundrum. Um, I had one more thing I want to talk about conundrum, but I'll, I'll pass it to you for anything else. Uh, I just made a note, like everybody got flashy things, but in this case, unlike, you know, our favorite men in black, there was nobody to give them a new memory, right? They just zap away their memory completely. And it's like, okay, now you figure it out, which like I said, what was different from the other two episodes. But I, I also liked that they made a point of, but we still have our skills.
our abilities like they didn't turn you into you know baby brain right right it's just we well we find out later it kind of removed who you are and we remove that information from the ship as well so it's yeah yeah i think conundrum of these three episodes to me conundrum has the most rewatchability factor to it um because clues is pretty straightforward you know like yeah once you know what's going on it's pretty straightforward but like when you go back and rewatch it there's there's not much new that you're that you'll see you'll just be like yeah okay well i understand why data is being obtrusive right now i understand you know but there's not much uh there's not much you didn't see the first time yeah Cause and effects is kind of the same way. Like you're just watching the crew uncover and it's something new, like with each iteration that it goes through. But Conundrum has a great rewatchability factor because as you, once you know what's going on, you go back and watch it again. Even when you see things like, Hey, Beverly's come up with this way to restore everybody's memories. And Macduff is the first one who goes, I'll try it out. Yeah. Completely faking. Exactly. Like I knew that was going to be a thing because like he, he didn't actually have a problem with this memory loss. Right. And so like the machine one can be able to fix him. So he's going to be able to do what he needs to do just to, to basically stop this solution that he came up with. Yeah.
Yeah, so he's – I like the rewatchability factor of it because you get that. I can see that. Like I think – as he's going through it. The only reason I put the other two ahead of it in my first run through was because the problem was very visible, right? The first one, I didn't know what was going on. I couldn't figure out what was affecting them or how they were going to solve it. But then the second one, it was immediately like, who is this guy? He's the problem. I don't know exactly what he did or what's going on, but he's the problem. They need to solve that problem. And so he was there throughout the entire episode. I'm like, don't listen to him. Whatever he says, don't do it. Picard, use your better judgment. I got to a point where it's like, there was one scene where it was just Picard and McDuff.
And McDuff would not look Picard in the eyes. Like Picard was talking at him or he was just talking. And it was just the two of them in the room. And McDuff was sitting like looking off into space and he would occasionally like glance over at Picard and he would stare at him for like two seconds until Picard looked at him and then he'd look away again. I'm like, that's not natural, man. Like if you're trying to play it cool, play it like an average human being. And when two people are in a room alone having a conversation, like it's not even like, oh, I'm looking at my phone or, you know, whatever electronic devices they have on the ship there. You know, you're not distracted by anything. He was just like staring at the wall. And I'm like, if you're trying to act natural, look at the guy. Unless there's something, I mean, they didn't like bring this up. So I don't think there really was.
Like you could, you could see it in his eyes or, you know, once again, men in black reference, he has a second set of eyelids or something like, right. That's going to give him away. We don't see or hear about anything like that. So it's like, I, I didn't quite understand it unless they were, you know, they're just trying to tell us once again, you know, Oh, he's the bad guy. He's the outlier. I think we've all realized that by now. Right. Especially once you give us his name, like McDuff, one that doesn't really sound like a Star Trek name to me. That sounds like, Hey, I'm bogus.
But it's just not a name you've heard before up to this point. If you're any kind of a Star Trek fan, I'm pretty sure, right? I'm wondering, and I don't know this because this occurs to me right now, is, you know, Star Trek is often quoted to be more Shakespearean in nature. Okay. Like it is. And it's like, I wonder if there's like a Macbeth reference here with McDuff. Yeah, I don't know enough. I'd have to go look and see. I don't know if maybe they did that intentionally. I'd have to go look that up. One thing I want to point out about Conundrum before we move on. And by the way, I think the way that I'm interpreting, the way you're interpreting, it might be the difference of somebody who's watching for the first time and somebody who's seen them multiple times. I think it really comes down to that, which is why I love doing the show because,
you're watching it all for the first time. And I don't remember what it's like hearing it for the first time. Anyway, in Conundrum, when we get to the very end and McDuff like goes crazy and tries to take over everything and like he throws Worf to the floor and Picard and Riker get up and turn around. And then all of a sudden you have what I like to call a great example of the amazing appearing phaser. Suddenly Riker has one in his hand. And suddenly Worf has one from halfway across the room. Yeah, because they're always so big and clunky when like they go down on a landing party and always notice them there. But yeah, you never noticed them here on the bridge. Why would they have like... I get that they have them like there's one stowed like by Worf's console.
There's one stowed by Riker's chair. Okay. They never grabbed them though. Yeah. They always just have them at the side. Yeah, exactly. So anyway, anyway, cause and effect. I want to talk, I want to spend a little bit of time talking about cause and effect. Um, but you haven't talked a whole lot about this one. So let me, give me, give me some cause and effect stuff. Does the enterprise really have escape pods? Yeah.
it seems so weird and then like he calls it like abandon ship and stuff and like it just feels so wrong to abandon this giant ship but it's about to explode well yeah but we've seen like you know detach the saucer like the back end was damaged so detach the saucer and fly away or i i don't know like that seems better to save half the ship than just like the whole thing explode but the only thing i problem with that i have a big problem with yeah is the warp nacelle gets scraped by bypassing ship sure the idea that that would cause so much of a cascade failure to cause the ship to explode especially as fast as it did yeah is where is where my knowledge of star trek stuff goes now wait a minute they're better than that in the future there is where my lack of knowledge you know like okay i have to believe that's there just to get through this episode yeah it's still a fun episode but that's my biggest complaint about the whole thing is yeah if that's such a big flaw like why doesn't anybody who attacks them just attack those cells it's like Perfect. We're done. Right. Right. But yeah, I was gonna say, I'm pretty sure that I've seen warp nacelles get blown off and it hasn't destroyed the ship. Yeah. You know, like at some point. So, um, I, I think a lot of it had to do with like, because I, I think it was because they were so close to that, that, uh, the rift or whatever. Um, it was causing all their other systems to fail and they couldn't do it. Like they, they had backup solutions and other things they were trying to do, but it's just like, no, that's not working. Nope. That's not working. Nope. That's not working. And so.
I kind of wonder if that played a part in it. I'm not going to get into the technical side of what made it happen, but it's, yeah. I get what you're saying, though. Of all the things, it's the thing I have the hardest time believing. Fair enough. My biggest complaint about this episode was in the, so it must have been the fourth and fifth times, or no, it would have been the fifth and sixth times through because the sixth time they fixed it, but where going into it, they had that meeting either late night or early morning where Jordi, I think it was Jordi, the Jordi or Data played, they had those three clips from the voices, right? The echoes. Right. And so they had those three lines. It's like, you know, we've said.
these things like war first says you know uh i don't remember what they were now there's the one line warf has that oh that tells him about the the space-time continuum and then the one about hey we're on a collision course in 36 seconds and like as soon as warf says his line no one reacts to that either time like after they they've said hey this is what's happened in the past and then he says that line like that should click right then and there hey this is when when things start off i should start paying attention and maybe not do what first comes to mind. Well, like that's my biggest problem with Picard in this sequence. And thankfully, like he only like messes it up once, I guess, technically. No, he really messes up twice, I think. But he has that information and he hears these phrases and still goes ahead with the plan because it's data that fixes it in the end. It's not Picard. But like my thought is like, Picard, you're smart enough, I feel, to say, all right, here are my options. He has for suggestions. Here are the options. This is my first reaction. If that's your first reaction, it would have been your first reaction time before that and the time before that and the time before that. So maybe don't go with your first reaction. Right. Like just try. Like if truly this thing just keeps repeating, try.
something else maybe it'll come out with a better solution like what can go wrong if you just keep doing the same thing over and over though you always go with your first reaction from what you guys can tell that has happened so far like it's nothing has changed so that was my biggest complaint i mean i'm still okay with the way they they resolved it because like reprogram everything yeah like like i'm okay with that yeah um i just felt like the the the resolution of that always felt a little uh beneath the setup of the episode, like how glorious it really could have been to have them come back from it, but it was okay. I, I still liked the time loop. I liked how they kept redoing it. Um, one thing about this particular episode, this is a Jonathan Frakes episode. Okay. So he's directing. Um, and he talks about how, like when he got the, uh, he got the script and he reads like act one and then he reads act two. He's like, you guys are screwing with me. Come on guys. But, but no, I like, I was thinking about that like first run of this, right? Like this must've been crazy to, to, to watch on TV because I, cause I, I tried to think about it. Like knowing the way people watch TV back in the nineties, especially right commercials. What are commercials? You don't watch commercials.
Commercials are your chance to go up and get a snack. Commercials are your chance to get a bathroom break. Change the channel. Go see what else is on. Not necessarily from, I mean, depends what you're watching, I guess. But yeah, I think it's got to be the craziest thing, especially like before DVR, right? Yes. And so, because you can't even use that as an explanation that, you know, someone's messing with you. So it's, you watch this scene.
get up, go to the kitchen, come back, sit down and watch the same thing. Oh, because that's what I appreciate. Like the first two are almost identical, like all, almost shot for shot. Not quite. I think they even started using a few different camera angles there. But as we go through this, obviously more and more changes in the lines, change the camera, those changes stuff. But like the first two times are very, very similar. And I appreciated that. And so fun fact. Yeah. One story. When this episode first aired, local affiliate stations got phone call after phone call from viewers who were so confused.
It's like, you guys are playing the tape over. You started it over. What did you do that for? Yeah. Yeah. I mean, it threw people, a lot of people for a loop. I'm glad you heard that. On regular broadcast TV. And they have, like, I love the fact that people called into the station to be like, what are you guys doing? Well, I mean, just think about if this aired today. I mean, because I, okay. You know what I would do? If this aired today, it would either be on DVR or I'd have it on demand. And the first thing I would do is I would pull up the little, like, the time thing that goes across the bottom. Yeah, the timeline, time stamp thing. Let's go back to the beginning or am I just like minutes into the show? Okay. That's what I'm saying. Like, it's not as much.
for a problem today because like when i watch it on streaming or uh like i was saying like back in the early to mid 90s they didn't have dbr so that wasn't an option for people to even consider at that point right and so that's why they call the tv station and blame them but i kind of wonder like i don't even remember where i was going with that it's oh i I was going to ask where, what year did Groundhog Day actually come out? No, good, good point. A lot of people, Brandon Braga, who's one of the guys made this, this episode, one of the writers, I think he was the writer on this episode. Okay. He talks about how everybody calls us Groundhog Day in space, which if this is a regular episode, that's exactly what I'd call this. This would be my AKA in space. He's like, just remember Groundhog Day was written and produced well after this episode was made. Okay. So Groundhog Day in space, Groundhog Day was on earth. Yes. Yes. So that was my other thing. It's like, you know, people can't blame DVR. People didn't have the experience of watching Groundhog Day yet. So like, like maybe this was the first episode.
of its type. And so we didn't have any experience with that and didn't have any reference material to say, oh yeah, I've seen this before. Because if an episode like this came out today for any series, people instantly, yeah, this is Groundhog Day. And now I have another reference point. Oh, Star Trek did this too, by the way, even before Groundhog Day. It occurs to me, Matt, as we record this episode right now, Groundhog Day is about 26, 27 years old. That's ridiculous. Okay. Which is ridiculous. It is. But everybody talks about knowing what Groundhog Day is. For the younger listeners out there who may be listening to this episode one day, Groundhog Day is a movie. It's well worth a watch. It's very funny from back in the early nineties, but effectively it's Bill Murray reliving the same day again and again and again and again and again and again and again.
And when people talk about Groundhog Day, just for you guys, Groundhog Day means when people keep repeating the same day over and over and over again. Yes, very good point. Thank you for bringing that up because, yeah. It's some of these references that I'm like, wait, wait, do younger viewers get what this means at all? It depends, one, how young they are, and two, if they had good parents. You know what it is? Because in my head, what I hear is Peter Parker in Captain America Civil War going, hey, you guys have heard this really old movie called The Empire Strikes Back? Yes.
Yeah, reference like that, get me. It's like, man, kids these days. You ever heard of this other really old movie called Groundhog Day? Yeah, I get it. But yeah, so I mean, I totally get why the first run of this episode was even more unique, but I think there is something that just, even though it's kind of repetitive, and I don't know if that made it easier or harder for them to shoot, because do you have anything, like, did they actually reshoot this, or did they reuse footage for parts of it? I don't know what they did in the final edit, but there is lots of literature. There's lots of stuff out there about the idea of how they shot these scenes multiple times.
with little changes here and there. You pointed out earlier, they moved the camera angles. a few times um and part of me says they they well they either could have shot from two camera angles at the same time and just use different ones different times or part of me wonders they purposely change the camera angles so if other things were off during this recording it's harder to tell right you can't go side by side shot for shot they and it wouldn't surprise me to know that they did both yeah each each scene they shot from multiple angles but they you know shot the different takes and then each cut they did multiple takes of um in fact i'm sure that's probably what they did and all that stuff on the editing room floor somewhere um but yeah i could i could certainly i could certainly see that i got to imagine this was a bit of a um a juggling i don't say night That's probably not the right word, but like this had, this was a, a, not as straightforward of an episode to direct, you know, like, like, cause you're having to work with like your, your director of photography and your lighting and then all your different people and having to keep straight of what's happening when, and then when you get into the editing room, like I'm going, okay. The editing has got to be the hardest because it's the same lines over and over this. Like you can't, you don't have.
and stuff to tell them what's sure but but if you go back and like reshoot things it's like then that's on multiple things it's it's not as easy to to say just like visually or audibly even say okay that yeah this belongs here because it's like well where do we actually shoot that why we should shoot that um but yeah i was gonna get at like even though this episode is kind of repetitious i think that's part of the reason why it was more entertaining yeah is because it kind of in a sense it requires less focus or less brain power because i as soon as you realize what's going on which is you know after the first maybe second time whatever then it's like okay when we come back from the next commercial i know what's how this is going to start i know what's gonna happen so now i'm just watching for what's changing right like i don't actually have to pay attention to them playing poker game as much because i've seen this three times already speaking of the poker game one of my favorite moments of the whole episode happens the first time they go around the poker game is data's dealing out the cards and he gets to wharf and he flips something over i forget what card it was data goes no help for the klingon it's like i'm gonna pop your circuit son yep yep well because because when he's dealing like that for everybody else it's either like by name or by rank and then all of a sudden he's like for the klingon i'm like
data's getting into this into this role a little too yeah um another thing a little kind of i guess mcguffin through the series that poor drinking glass in beverly's quarters yeah no chance Yeah. And I wonder if that was going to play a bigger role in some way. Like she actually had to prevent the glass from being broken or something. Cause the glass is the butterfly flipping its wings. Yeah. I mean, something along that, like efforts, I thought like the glass breaking is what stopped the voices maybe, or maybe like the voices were in the liquid that she was drinking. And so when I don't know, I had some weird things going on because like that, that seemed, I guess it was more coincidental, but that all seemed to coincide the way, like she knocked it over when she turned the lights on and voices stopped. And then, I mean, a couple of times.
through then yeah the voices stopped she recorded them but then she still knocked over the glass i'm like okay what is it with that glass and so i yeah yeah that's like i said it didn't really play out to have any bit of importance it feels like something they thought about using but ended up not using but still left it in takes the only thing that i can pull from it and i think this came out of the mission log podcast as i talked about the idea of fate that sometimes no matter what happens something is certain things are going to happen faded to happen and that glass was faded to break and i don't know that they were ever making that as an actual statement but you know it certainly i think is something you could uh you could pull from well yeah it's um shoot there's that that whole series of movies Oh, final destination. There you go. Yeah. Yeah. That's the one I'm picking up. Right. That's it. That's strangely another series that like starts really good. It's really good again. I can't say that I've seen all of them, but yeah, I've at least seen a few of them to understand the premise. Right. Um, I've got, I've got just a couple more notes on cause and effect. I don't know what you have. Um, go for it. The last one I have here is, uh, what I'm going to term. Okay. Let me back up. When I say the phrase, the Picard maneuver, do you know what I'm talking about at this point? Uh, that's the shirt thing. Sure. Right. Okay. Now, if I talk about the Riker stance, do you know what I'm talking about? Yeah. I saw him do that. I saw him do that particular episode. Yeah. That where he goes right up next to, uh,
David? There was no reason to do that. It's just like a straight up power move for Riker. Or at least he feels it is. It's a stage blocking thing. It's how do we set the camera and then put everybody where you're not blocking each other? But there's a reason why that happens so often. That happens throughout the run of the series a lot. It's not just something he randomly started doing? No, Frakes has a bad back. And where he would have to stand there for hours on end doing take after take after take after take after take. He had to start putting his foot up there so he could take some pressure off his back. But that's also like, you ever seen him walk in and he flips a chair and he sits backwards in it? A lot of it's because of that.
that like so it can help him like sit up it has more to do with the actor than it does uh that's one of those things where you sit back and as a director you look at an actor and you go make it part of your character yeah that's fine make it part of your character you know you absolutely did he absolutely did um so there's that i do want to point out the discussion the real rather intimate discussion i found between picard and beverly okay did you did you particularly the one they met a couple of times throughout this yeah they did but and then like we saw earlier like picard and beverly having breakfast way back when when loxana was like trying to do a bunch of stuff you know and um but there are these these little instances throughout star trek the next generation and i felt like this This might have been really one of the more intimate conversations we've had between Picard and Beverly in this episode. Not romantic, but two people who view each other more as equals than they do as captain and subordinate confiding in each other, you know, or being vulnerable with each other a little bit, I guess. Did you pick up anything with the Picard-Beverly relationship here at all? I mean, I definitely didn't make any notes about it, so I'm just curious. I'm really just curious where that's going, because it's one of those, like, they can't ever go there because of their relationship. Picard is the captain. He can't have a relationship with people, right? Yeah, yeah.
But there's, you know, and remember, Picard is responsible for the death of Jack, you know, wife, husband, late husband. So, you know, there's a little bit of all of that that mixed into that. So it's one of those. This this Picard Beverly thing, which is way more muted than the Deanna Riker thing, like way. But it still kind of has this thread that I will just say is is a part of the next generation. Like, is this right crusher? Sorry, Picard crusher sort of thing. All right. The only other thing that I have here for you on this is the big guest star that pops up on the show. Is it the captain at the end or something?
Do you recognize who that was? I don't think so. I don't pay attention to people that much. I try to pay attention to the story and what's going on. Do you know the name Kelsey Grammer? Yeah. That was Kelsey Grammer. Should have paid closer attention. This is another example of a Star Trek fan using their leverage to get onto the show. However, this one was a lot easier. Do you remember back when we did.
First contact. And they wrote a specific scene for one of the aliens that wound up having sex with Riker. Sure. Riker captive. And they said, hey, we're going to go get this lady who does a comedy thing. And we're going to bring her in. We're going to write this scene for her. And she's going to hold Riker captive until he gives her what he wants. And then she'll help him escape. Do you remember what show she was from? Nope. She was from Cheers. Okay. Cheers happened to be filming two soundstages over. Well, so was Kelsey Grammer, who was filming two soundstages over. He just had to come over after work one day and shoot the scene. There you go. Also, on that soundstage over there was a lady by the name of Kirstie Alley. How do you remember Kirstie Alley? She played someone. She played Lieutenant Sam.
Savick, Wrath of Khan, which was then recast in the next two movies. But they were going to have her come back as Lieutenant Savick as part of the bridge crew of the Bozeman. They just couldn't work out the timing and contracts. I mean, she was right there. She could have slid right in. I tend to wonder, and this is my own personal thing, I don't know that it was necessarily just a timing thing. I really wonder if there was just a, she didn't want to do it. And so, yeah, we can make the timing work. No, she just said no.
Anyway, Matt, I'm so disappointed that you're not like, that's Kelsey Grammer. I am really bad with people and faces. You will learn this if you have not already. You just learned it now. I'm really bad with people and faces. Come on, Matt, his voice.
I don't know, man. I am very, very aware of who Kelsey Grammer is and what he has done. Hey, best Kelsey Grammer movie ever. What's that? Down Periscope. I don't think I've seen that one. Never seen it. Go see. It is hilarious. It don't don't take any serious like with a stupid mindset and just let it let its humor just be its humor. It's hilarious. Down Periscope. You're welcome to everyone out there listening. All right, Matt, I'm done. Do you have any other notes you want to go over before we're done? I mean, the only question I had was about the end there because like they gave us a date. And so I'm just assuming I don't know if it was exact or not, but like.
we're supposed to assume they've been in that loop for like a hundred years or something like that. Yeah. Something like that. Yeah. Yeah. This is, I mean, this is not quite enterprise B territory. Like we're on the show right now. We're like 23 something, right? Yeah. We're 23, like late sixties, early seventies. Yeah. Cause I think they gave us like mid 22s as, as the date of.
when the captain thought it was. Right, which would have been post the original series, but during the original series movies, which was about 15, 20 years after the series ended in their timeline. So yeah. I just want to make sure I wasn't confusing things. The Enterprise was stuck in it for 17 days, 17.4 days. Makes me wonder what they were doing for 80 some odd years before the Enterprise got there. Or was the Enterprise just always there as part of their time loop?
Hmm. Yeah. Hmm. That's the problem with time travel, right? Yes. Yes. I, I would argue that the enterprise was always there because they always, they always came out at the same point in time, which would be like a hundred years later and longer than these guys did over here. Yeah. Yeah. But they didn't realize it for whatever reason. Yeah.
I get it. I get it. All right, Matt. Well, that is going to do it for us for the three C's. I'll give you a chance. Any final thoughts on these particular episodes? Kind of wrap it all up for us. Did you did you enjoy it? Did you at least enjoy this this little trilogy of episodes? Oh, yeah, absolutely. I mean, I think just the way we did this, I kind of got to express that more throughout and I kind of put it out there at the top. Like I enjoyed them. I, you know, like I said, the first one was most confounding. The third one was most enjoyable. But yeah, overall, I definitely enjoyed them. Do you understand, though, why these maybe didn't make the cut on our main on our main show, though? Well, yeah, once again, like they're good episodes, but.
what else do they bring to the table? Exactly. I mean, like there's, and so much of it is a, because a part of what I want you to experience is I want you to enjoy the episodes that we have as well. And I want you to know that there are good episodes. And if there's anything that you take out of, out of these extra viewing episodes, it's fun. It's fun. And then I'm leaving a lot of stuff for you for, for when you go back to redo your rewatch, which you will do your rewatches. I remind you every single episode we do when you do your exhaustive research that you're, there's still a lot left to enjoy. There's, there's a lot of threads that I haven't picked up that I've had to choose to just sort of let go and be okay with, but you get the main thrust of everything.
So, all right. Well, Matt, I think that's going to do it for us for today out here on our extra viewing episodes. Once again, I want to say thank you to everybody at Patreon who are supporting the show. You guys really help keep the show running and you keep the show moving. So thank you guys so, so very much. Look, if you guys want to get in touch with us, one of the things that you guys, I guess, kind of get to do is you can help coordinate what shows we're going to do. If you have thoughts and we're about to enter into this whole Deep Space Nine next generation, you know, deal. Email us. Let us know what you guys think. We'll get there. Until next time, guys. Live long and prosper.
Beautiful. Got it. So the next thing we're doing, so that's two extra viewing episodes we've got. The only, I was kind of looking through it. I mean, there's lots of extra viewing episodes I'd love to get you in, but. I mean, we have two more earmarks if you want them. Which were Time's Arrow and Relics. Okay. Do you still want to do both of those? I mean, I. Which one, are you intrigued by them? I mean, the Time's Arrow, you have to be. It's hard to say. Sure. I mean, I have nothing other than. My word. The title, your word saying, yeah, it's good. It's worth watching. And if you maybe told me something about it, but I don't actually remember. Time's Arrow is the one where we get a little bit of the backstory to Guinan. Sure. Like we see where Guinan and Picard finally meet. Yeah, I. It's kind of goofy. It's a two-parter episode.
episode, but it's, I mean, it's, it's, it's a, it's a fine episode, but it's something I keep asking about. So, yeah. So why don't we do that one for sure? I guess this is what I would say is we want to, if we're going to do these, we want to do it before I hit chain of command. Right. So we're not going to do extra viewings later. It just, this will give it, this will pretty much. Sure. Sure. Yeah. Yes. So my point being is if we can get these in this week, I think.
because we have this week full week before we get into our Facebook lives and stuff. So I don't really want to be doing them that week. And then after that, you know, other things, if things go well, if things go the way we want to, like we'll have other things on our plate as well. So I'll still have to push forward with the other show, the actual show. Exactly my point too. It's like, there's only so long we can keep doing extra viewing, extra viewing, extra viewing before we have to say, hey, we're out of regular episodes. So like if we had, if I hadn't blocked out that week, basically, I'd say, hey, we have two weeks where we can do some extra viewing stuff and then we should probably get back.
to regular episode but because i have that we blocked out i say if we can get these these two episodes done this week which i think should be possible yeah um then even if we we don't shoot any regulars this week and we don't shoot any regulars the week after when we're doing other guild stuff yeah um then the week after we can get back to regulars here's what i'd like to do i think i'd like to do it this way let's do time zero because that's that's an episode you have overly expressed interest in yeah over the course of our time relics is good it's fun it can wait for any time there is no i mean time zero could too but there's there's no like it's the one that scotty turns up cool episode neat concept sure do that anytime you say so i would like to get i would like to get you through chain of command though okay so why don't we do time zero next and then plan for chain of command after that and at least try to get those two knocked out here in the next bit. So you want, you want to do chain of command this weekend? I would like to, if we could. Yeah. Okay. Yeah. Um, who's that thread of what we're doing? Um, and we can just kind of let relics just sort of, that'll be one that we may come back to. Um, cause there's a couple other extra viewing episodes that I know you're going to want to do, um, or that I'm going to want you to do, but we haven't got there yet. So, um, it's fine. That's fine. Um, so when do you want to plan for the next one?
Well, I'm ready to go. So I can't do it right now, but like tomorrow or Monday would work just fine for me. Anytime this week. Yeah. I mean, I like to say smile a little bit. So yeah, I push for Monday. Monday. Okay. Yeah. Let's do Monday. Is there a chance of you being available during the day or it can be nighttime again? There's definitely a chance of being available during the day. Okay. Evie has camp and Jude very well could be at his grandparents. So yes. And Penny will be sleeping on me. So very much could do probably during the day on Monday for that one. The rest of the week will probably have to be nighttime. I just want to try to be prepared and more prepared than it was today. So yeah. Sorry for the late minute text. I just, I didn't expect to be free today at all.
of forgot like when you we do these during the day like how early is your earliest but um yeah right so okay cool man well uh so we'll plan on monday daytime worst case scenario just to the evening but we shouldn't have to yeah all right man i'll talk to you later all right we'll do good weekend happy