Skip to content
Extra Viewing - TNG : Elementary, Dear Data episode artwork

Feb 14, 2023 56 min

Extra Viewing - TNG : Elementary, Dear Data

from Beam Me Up: A Star Trek Podcast

Did You Hear About This? This humorous pop culture podcast discusses the latest retro stories and pop culture news. Listen on: Apple Podcasts Spotify Support the show

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Extra Viewing - TNG : Elementary, Dear Data

0:00 56:29

Chapters

  1. 17:14 [Ad] Did You Hear About This?
  2. 17:52 (Cont.) Extra Viewing - TNG : Elementary, Dear Data
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Hey everybody, this is Brent from Beam Me Up Star Trek podcast. As you may know, Matt and I have finished recording the main run of the show. However, over the course of our three and a half years of recording the show, we actually recorded several episodes that to this point have either gone unaired or they were exclusive to our Patreon page. Well, now that we're on the backside of the main show, we thought that it would be a great time to release those episodes to you guys out there, our listening audience. Plus, you never know when Matt and I may jump in with a random new episode. The final frontier begins. This is about saving the future of humanity. This is a huge victory for the good guys.

You've never seen Voyager. Commitment to this course of action is not emotional. Johnny, beam us up. Welcome to another Patreon-exclusive extra-viewing episode from the Beam Me Up Star Trek podcast. Matt, today we are going to be going through the episode Elementary Dear Data as an extra-viewing episode for you. But before we get there, I have one question. I sit here listening to the intro to our show every week, and I started to wonder, are we going to actually, I don't know if you've planned this or not, are we actually going to hit the episodes where you've pulled those clips from? Probably. I know we did the Jim Kirk one where he says, Scottie, beam us up. He says some version of that a lot, I feel, and so I don't know if I can pay an example.

which episode it was from. We got that one. We have not got the one with Picard saying, I was pretty sure we didn't. Yeah. And it's going to be a while before we get there, but we will get there. It's not actually an episode. It's from a movie. And then we will do the one that Cisco says, I have no idea who that is. And then we'll do the one where Janeway is talking and hopefully we'll, and I'm sure we'll get to the one with Burnham talking there at the end. So if you have no idea who those people are, which I love, that's crazy to me. You don't know who these people are. I know the name Janeway and I know that's the female voice in there. Sure. But yeah, the other two, I honestly be a 50, 50 shot. Yeah. That one might be my favorite one. She goes, you've never seen.

And I like, you've never seen the next iteration. You've never seen. Yeah, I have not. I'm assuming she's on Voyager then. That's what she says is you've never seen Voyager, but maybe she's not. I don't know, Matt. You'll find out when we get there. I don't know. Yeah, she might be. That might be from a movie too. You never know. You know, we've never really talked about that intro. Like, I really like the way that intro goes because part of the premise of this show. Hey, and listen, this is what you get when you're in a Patreon exclusive and talk about this stuff. Yeah, we don't use it, but yeah. Right. But like that whole intro was a, oh, Archer's in there as well talking about Starfleet. But anyway, the premise of the show is the idea of

like getting you beamed up into the fandom and i talk about why it's a cultural phenomenon but we talk about like why the world needs star trek like how the world or how star trek can save humanity and like when you look at each one of those lines like it's it's almost like like burnham says uh uh you know this is but it's okay uh she's the one who says this course of action is is logical or something like that sure like taking this course of action is logical and uh i think picard says you know this is about saving the future of humanity and um i forget exactly what i listen to it all the time anyway but it all is in that vein of like this this is about you know uh undertaking something big and it actually makes a difference and it matters and i like the way that it turned out i really do it's trying to pull those individual lines was a much bigger feat when you're trying to i need one little bitty line in the entire catalog of what you say i will tell you this the people who that you hear speaking are the the captain or the main character of each series like what you hear is a is a representative of all of the different existing series of star trek i think you you did kind of mention that to me when you were creating it yeah like offline who you're trying to pull from yeah so anyway i think um extra viewing episode this is exclusively for our patreon supporters matt uh so if you're listening to this episode thank you uh this one is really just for you we're not releasing this out to the

general wide public. Uh, the episode we're doing today, Matt is elementary deer data. Uh, now full disclosure, cause I think it may or may not come up once or twice. We are recording this right after we've recorded the episode, the measure of a man for the main show for the main. Um, so just so you guys know, as you're listening, put this in a little bit of context. That is the conversation Matt and I are just coming out of, uh, as we attack this episode. Yeah. And it turns out, uh, you know, the two dovetail quite nicely into each other. And this was completely unplanned. Like when we decided to do these two shows, kind of recording them together, uh, that this was not, we, we didn't pick these two to go together. It just happened to work out and we like, wow, these two. Wow. Um, so, and I do certainly hope that, that one impacts and affects.

our conversation today um so i'm really glad to get into this but matt uh we'll go through this kind of like we just do a regular episode um i don't mind telling you this episode though was really really really close to being part of the main show okay and like in the end it covers the same subject matter as measure of a man and other episodes we're gonna get to yeah yeah like i can see why i mean i think you made a good choice in pulling it yeah yeah i just i think i think measure of a man probably from a one episode point of view does a better job of making that point sure like this one kind of makes the opposite yeah yeah i guess you could say that um but same generic subject matter right and so if you're gonna pick one i think you made the right choice this is this is as i talked about many times before one of those fun episodes yes and i'm glad to hear you say that because i was gonna know those overarching thoughts on this episode because i like this episode i enjoy watching this episode every time i see it yeah like it's still maybe when we got into the you know there is a heavy section to it especially car gets involved because for the longest time like i i didn't even think about it until like two-thirds of the way through the episode and they jumped to wharf on the bridge and like wait oh yeah we have just been kind of spending this entire episode with two and a half characters

Yeah. Yeah. Wow. Okay. Yeah. They're still there. Okay. They didn't take the week off. So, um, well, why don't we, why don't we go ahead and get into this? Um, we're not going to do any, uh, casting notes or anything, but one, one fun production note that I did, that I did to reference actually to, um, the budget for this episode got way out of control. All right. Uh, basically because they had to build all these new sets. Like these were not existing sets. They had to go in and build them. And I can think about how they do like, yeah. So you're thinking with today's technology and like, yeah, this is just a big green screen. You know, we can totally do this. We have no problem. Like, but no, back in the eighties.

probably had to build a lot more. Right. I mean, they had to build the street. They had to build the warehouse. They had to build Moriarty's deal. They had to build the 21B Baker Street deal. A lot of it is just like not necessarily that they didn't have the technology. It was just, you know, at that point where it wasn't cheap. It was cheaper for them to build the sets. It was to try to use that technology. Right. So to try to compensate for the added set and costuming budget in this particular episode, the production decided to basically just squish the filming by one extra day and just remove an entire day out of filming, which did not make the actors or the director very happy at all because they still had the same amount of work to do.

They were just forced to do it in a more compressed time. And so, yeah, yeah, yeah. They weren't really happy about it. But everybody who was involved with this episode really liked the way this episode came out. So I would imagine now it seems like you'd have a lot of fun with it. Now, more money issues to talk about real quick. When they filmed this episode, they the production crew believed that the Sherlock Holmes characters were public domain. It turns out they weren't. So it wasn't until after the episode had already aired. OK, some copyright. Yeah. Yeah. That the estate of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle was like, excuse me, we still own at least a percentage of the Sherlock Holmes characters. And you're going to owe us some. And I.

If I got it right, they didn't like backcharge them for what they just did, but they said, if you want to use these characters again, you're going to have to come back to us. Now, spoiler alert towards the end of the episode, it's obviously left open for a potential sequel. And there was very much intended to be a sequel to this episode, but because of these issues, the plans for the sequel kind of got delayed and kept getting delayed and delayed. They did eventually get it figured out and we did get that sequel, but it wasn't until season six. So lots of seasons later. And we will do, I'll just go, we will do that episode when we get to it as an extra viewing episode, because it's a good episode as well. But there's even like a meta joke inside the episode about how long it took to get back to this character.

So like I said, don't worry, we'll cover that next year when we get there. But it just, you know, oops. So speaking of which, by the way, I may cut this out later. Did you know that the song Happy Birthday, which has not been Public Domain, is now recently gone Public Domain? I didn't know that. Yeah, I just know that. Public Domain is always an interesting person. All right, enough about all that. Matt, why don't we do this? Why don't we go through the episode and you stop us? We'll just sort of do it the way we normally do it. All right. Elementary Dear Data. Prologue. The Enterprise is three days early for a rendezvous with the USS Victory, a ship whose captain Geordi has served with as an ensign. First of all, I want that as either another episode or a movie. Geordi is an ensign.

Yep, Jordy's backstory. Love to see that. Anyway, who arrives three days early? I mean, this is 100% plot reasons. It's like, we're going to park the ship and we don't need to do anything so we can have this other, tell this other story. Like, cause otherwise you can't tell me at the speeds of your ship travel, but you could carry out some other mission in three days. Maybe not. I don't know. It's weird, isn't it? Or, I mean, I did this the other day. Like I sold an expensive item on eBay. It's heavy. I didn't want to ship it. So I was going to meet up with this guy and it's like, okay, I can meet with you in Chicago.

And I'm like, okay, I'll drive down there. I got down to our meeting spot and he's like, he called me. I'm like, yeah, I hit some traffic. There was an accident. I'm like an hour behind schedule. I'm like, okay, I pulled up a map and I will.

drive further and meet you even closer to where you are. Right. You know, I got there early. I have this extra time. Let's do this. Like, why not change the rendezvous point? It's like, we're here three days early. How about we come to you? Yeah, we got it. We got to use you guys. Something. Yeah. I mean, they could have explained it with like, hey, we're actually going to do this and use this time to make some repairs or make some upgrades or test some new equipment or shore leave or something. Exactly. Like stop at a space station and oh, we're just going to play on the holiday. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. It is 100% plot reasons. We're here three days early. Just to explain to us why no one seems to rush to do anything or go anywhere.

Like, we can run the ship without Geordi and Data and the Doctor eventually. Like, you know, you can just go off on your adventure for a whole day and no one's going to miss you. Geordi has a present for Captain Zimbada, a model of the original USS Victory, an old Earth sailing vessel. This isn't just a computer recreation, but it's something you do with your hands. Data doesn't understand. But hey, Geordi, you said this was urgent. Ah, yes. We're three days early, so now there's time to go indulge in one of Data's fantasies. Geordi hands him a Snarflak, volunteers to be his Watson. To rush off, you can find us at 221B Baker Street. Yeah. So that got me thinking about the ships, though. Okay.

are all of these ships named after actual ships? Like, I don't actually know if there was a victory in the first place. Yeah, no, it's actually a fairly famous ship. Not that I'm a ship sailing history aficionado. I just knew that from research in this episode. Sure, but I mean, that made me wonder about the rest of them. It's like, did they just take names of actual ships? There's actually, there's a whole, there's like books you can get where they talk about the various ships of Starfleet that have been like mentioned or referenced or you've seen, you know, throughout the various shows. And a lot of them are references to various literary people and things like that. So not all of them are, but.

You know, the Enterprise definitely is one. The Victory is one in this case, but yeah, not all. So, shoot, that makes me wonder even more about, do you remember the one, I'm not gonna be able to come, let's go, how that should never be the name of a ship. Oh, oh, oh, oh, yeah, the Repulse. Yes, the Repulse. But like that one sounds more spacey sci-fi in the first place. I have a really hard time believing like there was a naval vessel named the Repulse. I really hope that there was. At least I don't think so. I don't know. Like I said, I'm not a sailing naval history aficionado. But no, apparently the Victory was.

an older sailing vessel and something to the effect, if memory serves, it is like the oldest or the longest running mission ship. Like it's still a commissioned ship or something like that. So yeah, I'm not entirely sure. You guys go look that up out there. But man, that was a beautiful model that Geordi had.

That was fantastic. I, it almost makes you like, it wasn't a computer model. So I actually wonder if that's one of those things, like one of the, the directors or writers or somebody working on set, that's their hobby. And it's like, Hey guys, look what I finished. It's like, Hey, you want to put that on set? Right. I mean, it does thematically go in with the rest of the show, right? Like there's that data that the fun is in the doing it, not just making it happen, which, you know, certainly the fun is in the mystery, not in solving. Like my point being, it looked like it was actually there. Like someone.

actually built it and like that doesn't seem like something you just build as a prop right right like it's like this was somebody's hobby and they had it and said hey could you bring that in today yeah i don't know like it makes me think of uh we've referenced on the show a few times uh the big bang theory that episode that show they had an episode where they had the lego model of the death star which apparently is like the largest lego build that has ever existed or something like that and they talk about how like at least was for a time yeah and they talk about like how the crew like just had a ball like putting that thing together over the course of however long it took them to get it together and somebody still had it you know it's like i have the lego hogwarts castle right And that thing between my wife and I, it took us almost a week. I think it was like four or five days. And I mean, that's working on it many hours a day to get that thing together. Yeah. So I'm going to do the bad comedian thing. Hey, did you hear my joke? Did you hear my joke? Jordy hands him a Snarflack. I did. I did. I caught on to that. Don't worry.

Thank you for getting it. All right, anyway. Act one, Data and Geordi are all dressed up and headed to the holodeck. They marvel at the detail of the holodeck recreation of Holmes and Watson's living abode. Data is pretty familiar with all things Sherlock Holmes. The two settle in throwing themselves into their roles. Data is a little better at the game than Geordi is though, but he also seems to know what's going on before it even happens, almost as if he's read the end of the book. Geordi's a little more than perturbed at the lack of fun of playing with Data and he storms off the table. We'll be right back.

Hey, if you recognize those sounds, then you're probably somebody who would like our show. We're called, did you hear about this? And we talk about all kinds of news stories. It's like the eighties and nineties stuff that we grew up on. Yeah. This isn't stuff that's getting covered on the 10 o'clock news. I'll tell you that you can check us out at, did you hear about this dot show? We're on every single podcast platform. Go find us.

yeah oh okay yes okay um in any case yeah he they they are cosplaying here oh absolutely yeah like it's fantastic and but it got me wondering like and maybe you've answered this before But where do they get these outfits? The replicator. Okay. Because in my mind, the replicator is for food. That's what I've seen it used for, right? But I think you've told me before, it can replicate anything. That's why there's not a need for possessions and stuff. It's like it can make these things. So, okay, I just want to double check on that. There's a really cool scene in one of the new tracks that's on right now that they're making right now, which I think is just a product of special effects ability these days, where they actually show you a replicator replicating a uniform. And they show you how it pulls the atoms from the air and puts them together.

and turns it to thread and then it all starts weaving and, you know, it basically builds this thing just out of nowhere. Like it's a super cool effect. Yeah, that's 100% because they can. Sure, right. Like that's one of those you go, yeah, they wouldn't have done this for TV budget. All right. Jordy is trying to explain to Data how he took all the fun out of the mystery on the holodeck. At the next table over, Dr. Bones Pulaski overhears and interjects. Data can't not win. He's just a computer after all. He's not human. He can't feel the thrill of victory and you, I'm sorry, you can't feel the thrill of victory if it's impossible to lose. So now Pulaski and Jordy are talking about Data as if he isn't even there.

Data is like Holmes in many ways with great detective reasoning skills, but Pulaski asserts Data lacks the basic understanding of that human element. And her bet is Data can't actually solve any Holmesian mystery that he hasn't already read the ending to. Data may have already read all of the Holmes novels, but he accepts the doctor's challenge, the return to the holodeck, and he'll dare it to defeat him. And you, Dr. Pulaski, are invited to be a witness. Yes. So a couple of things. I did want to go back a little bit to the first scene where they're in Holmes's place.

we see data playing violin yeah and it got it got me yeah really well and jordy was even kind of surprised which got me thinking it's like okay it's his ability to play the violin from being an android is it part of the simulation like can you just say well you know when i pick this up and move it like this it's gonna play a pretty song like it's halideck right anything can happen i don't know Has he over time actually learned how to play violin for whatever reason? Well, I don't know that Data learns how to play violin as much as he downloads it like it's a file program out of the Matrix. There is a future episode, and I don't think we're going to watch it, so I don't mind talking about it right now. But I always think about it when I see this particular scene where Data is, I want to say he's playing an instrument. It might actually be the violin. And they're kind of criticizing Data because he's like, he plays the piece perfect with no mistakes. But they're like, yeah, but Data, you're missing the oomph. You're missing the human part of it. You're missing the little tweaks and stuff that make it unique and something to you.

understand on the last episode with poker right exactly exactly it's that human element right it's the human element thinks he can play the game perfectly but he still loses right and it's because yeah there's that human element to it so like yeah you can play the song perfectly but there's someone who like if you play two pieces side by side and they both play all the right notes that can still sound different so i always think about that because you know here's jordy going wow that's so amazing that's so great you're doing so good at that and i'm like yeah but we have this conversation later you know like maybe he shouldn't be that great at it but yeah no it's i think too in a long ways answer your question no that's that's data playing sure uh and then yes you're saying no mystery no game no game no fun important to keep in mind but seeing this this type of thing on holodeck when they're just kind of stuck in one room and they're there to solve a mystery like this is an escape room in a sense right yeah you're not trying to figure out how to get out of the room necessarily but i i'm wondering just how long it'll be though before we have enough of this technology like you could do this with vr right now sure like you could probably even put multiple people in a room with vr but it's still not quite on the level of like holodeck obviously but i could totally see this being

the future of escape rooms yeah so as as late as um 2017 there are a lot of articles out about the holodeck being technologically possible and people creating now what we're what you're obviously not getting because we don't have this technology yet is the um being able to touch and interact with the items and have them just appear out of anywhere but to have yeah hollow imaging around you to where it's it's really that immersive it's vr technology without the goggles right sure it's just a lot of projection right right uh now have they have you been in an episode yet where they kind of explain how these items work and what happens i believe we hit one because we talked about it a little bit. I'm really bad with remembering which episode is which.

But, um, I remember Wesley came in and he gets, he falls in the water. Yeah. So the, for, for whatever it's worth, and there's, there's a couple of different ideas going on with it, but the idea is it's light in photons surrounded by a force field. So that's why like you can sit on a chair on a table is because there's, you know, it's a force field, like holding it in place. But some things are also literally like just replicated or in theory replicated in the, in the room. Like, so if you're eating food or something, you're not just eating force field, you know, when he fell in the water, he got wet. Exactly. Exactly. Um, you know, but that's why you can pat somebody on the back. That would be light holographic.

surrounded by force fields, which gives you a tactile type deal. And they explain even in this episode, like, hey, you'd actually have to go touch that wall. You know, you're actually near the back corner of the wall. You wouldn't know if you didn't touch it, you know, in these things here. Basically all that to say, hey, in Star Trek, the next generation, we can go anywhere and do whatever we want. And space isn't an issue. It's just a hologram, right? Like we can put ourselves in whatever period setting we want. It's just a hologram. It's such a great out, you know? It is, absolutely. But the application of the holodeck as an escape room is fantastic. That's a great idea. Yeah, like I would.

love to see that like because i i have you have you played around vr very much at all very little very very okay i mean like i i know they have games already where you can you're standing in a room and like you can interact with things you can pick things up now granted you to do that you still need to be like holding a controller of some sort or you're gonna have some sort of glove on that has something or yeah some kind of glove that so the glove is closer so you're not actually you don't have to have it something in your hand already you can kind of just naturally grab something grab it something but you're not going to feel like if you reach out to grab an apple you're not going to feel the apple in your hand the biggest barrier that's what we're not gonna be able to get to yet well i mean it's tactile you know what if within the glove you got the tactile response that made it feel and that's what um i think we brought this up on the podcast before actually ready player one yeah yeah that's that whole deal that's that's what they're getting at it's yeah you you you have you're obviously not actually interacting with the things that you're seeing but you're getting enough enough haptic responses that it feel your body thinks you are right holodecks are cool man i want one in my house someday yeah

We're going to get a lot of holodeck over the run of this podcast. I'm good. Yeah, no, it's great. It's great. I do want to talk about Dr. Pulaski here for a minute. This is one of the most Bones-esque Pulaski moments that I've ever seen. You know, and I think I mentioned to you on either the last episode or maybe two episodes ago, when they brought her in over Gates McFadden as Beverly Crusher, they really wanted that Bones McCoy to Jim Kirk type foil, really for Picard, but also for the rest of the ship. And, you know, I think she really exudes this a lot in this particular scene, where she just, and really through the whole episode of like, look, he ain't gonna get it. He just ain't gonna get it. Yeah, as you pointed out, they start talking like he's not there. And it's like, yeah, it's like, I know how he acts. I know how he responds.

Like he's, he's not going to be able to do this. And like, I can see that. Like, I, I mean, I, well, you want to compare her to bones and I've always compared him to Spock. And it's like, I can see that interaction. It's like bones just sitting there poking the bear. It's like, no, you're not gonna be able to do this. Nope. Nope. You can try all you want, but I know better. All right. Act two data programs, a holodeck to give them a home style mystery, but not one that's written by Sir Arthur Doyle. Pulaski now also in cosplay. She isn't so sure. It's her first trip into the holodeck and she's more than impressed with the imagery within. Of course they're only actually inside a room. Some techno babble that explained why they fit the entire city of London inside that said room. And we're off.

our adventure in character data quickly solves yet another mystery before it even begins pulaski calls foul foul what was the actual it wasn't foul what was it it was uh oh fraud fraud yeah yeah yeah whatever it was i thought it felt awkward sure yeah foul foul would have been better rather than fraud um you know but the computer hasn't really come up with a new mystery it's just recycled elements of existing stories and data happened to recognize them and put it together pulaski still says data circuits would short out if he was presented with a real mystery okay says jordy let's try it again computer arch uh a character uh what do you call those matt the characters that are within the game that don't NPC? Yeah, yeah, one of those. The NPC, the non-player character? Is that what that means? Either non-player or non-playable. Yeah, yeah. So an NPC sees the arch and he is intrigued. Computer, Jordy says, create a mystery to defeat data. Create an adversary capable of defeating data. There's an odd power surge detected on the bridge, but it's gone pretty quick. Back in the holodeck, the arch disappears. It's the same London, but there's something different and a new mystery is afoot. They walk away, but back at the site, that NPC who noticed the arch feels like he's a new man. He also calls for the arch and begins to interact with the computer. His name, Professor Moriarty. He is a lady. All right, so much to unpack here. Yeah.

throughout this entire sequence i kept having to just remind myself this is a fun episode not everything is going to make 100 sense you just have to roll with things a little bit more attention to disbelief because like sci-fi actually it is it is but so much of this either by this time you know we've proved we just talked about the holodeck it's could just about be real but so much of this other stuff just didn't quite hey i i couldn't accept it right i i need i needed a better explanation like like as soon as jordi starts programming this thing i'm like yeah that that nope that done seemed like a good plan like even in the confines of the holodeck i did not like i i heard it right when he said it i'm like like an enemy that can defeat data i'm like nope nope nope don't nope like maybe tell the program to shut down the instant before data would be defeated but like so if there's absolutely zero data can do to to resolve the situation to fix the situation the program just ends or something like that like later on i come to find out you know they're supposed to have a what they call it like a anti or non-mortality

thing built into the system the safety protocols yeah that's overridden but like i i didn't know about that at this point i'm like yeah that would have been a good thing to have but in any case like that that that was just bad on jordi's fault which he admits later but then we get moriarty and the fact that an npc took notice of anything the players were doing that's not how npcs work not at all yeah and then the fact that well but then even more so i mean because he should have still been working off of his programming from the first program while jordy was reprogramming stuff he shouldn't have been paying attention to them at all so the fact that he was paying attention didn't sit well with me and then when he pays attention to what they're doing with the programming and like in my mind as soon as jordy hits like enter or okay or go whatever the final keystroke is in that pattern everything that was in the old simulation anything that npc had seen or whatever should have been wiped and the new scenario is laid down and so he should have zero knowledge of what just happened and so like i see what you're saying yeah like that that in between time if he was conscious or cognizant of that at all it shouldn't even mattered i mean he should have been in the first place because he's still running the old inferior program and they do they do establish that in future episodes maybe even a little bit in this one that you know npcs i guess

call them they they're they shouldn't be able to call for the arch they really shouldn't notice the arch they shouldn't actually even really notice what you're wearing or like like if you're just in starfleet uniform if you're in period costume costume is really all for you i got that they were doing that just for themselves to get into character and because before they went in they're like you know and today starring as sherlock holmes is data and as dr watson is geordie laforge and that's like they told the computer that so the computer knew to program all the people that way and so they were going to refer to them when they you know saw them yeah it should have mattered But, you know, I think this is for the production. This is maybe their, like, third or fourth time doing the holodeck. And it's, I think, their second, like, actual, like, holodeck episode, right? So in many ways, as a production, they're still writing the rules. But as you said, it's still an episode. The first holodeck scene that we saw together, I don't think that included any people. Wasn't that the one where Data was, like, whistling and stuff and Riker went into the holodeck to find them? Oh, yeah. I mean, it was people, only people from the Enterprise. Oh, it didn't include, like, characters, like the NPCs. Yeah, NPCs, yeah. And so we didn't have to.

about those interactions in that episode. So this is actually my first time I think seeing it with NPCs. I should give you another. Uh, yeah, yeah. So yeah, no, I, all of those things are valid. Uh, and it's interesting you say that because you're talking about rules that the, the writing staff is just now like kind of beginning to create for the, for the holodeck that they're clearly breaking. But I know because of my knowledge of future Trek, like those become rules of the holodeck. So, uh, yeah, you're right. They'll fix it in future episodes. But now it's just a fun episode. This is essentially just like season one of the holodeck, but the pilot of the holodeck where episode three, but still it's a season one of the holodeck. They haven't figured everything out yet. Yeah. So, all right, well, back to.

the episode here um data and jordy are trying to figure out what has changed with their new programming thing and they suddenly hear a distant scream dr pelaski has been adopted abducted i'll say that word eventually data has deduced a lot of it right away and again the game is afoot act three back on the holodeck echoing foot stall footfalls still abound data does the holmes thing while chasing after them before turning into a dead end they bump into inspector lestrade who brings them to a dead body lying in the middle of the street data doesn't care this has nothing to do with pelaski's abduction but jordy wants to give the whole deduction thing a whirl at which he fails miserably Gets it all wrong. It's just good comedy at that point. I kind of feel bad for him, though, because he's trying. He's really trying. At the same time, honestly, no, I guess maybe I have read one or two. Have you actually read any Sherlock Holmes? Yeah, I think high school English. I've had to read some.

I mean, I've seen a number of like movies and short films and that type of thing. So I'm familiar with like the characters. I'm kind of familiar with how Holmes and Watson kind of interact. And I mean, I guess that's kind of the character of Watson anyway. He's always trying to do what Sherlock can do, but he just gets it wrong. Yeah. I mean, well, I do think Dana here or rather Brent Spiner gives us a pretty good take on Holmes. I think he does kind of almost take it too far. Although I will say the more I think about it now.

He's a fantastic actor. Brent Spiner or LeVar Burton? Yes, Brent Spiner. Oh, yeah, he's great. He really is. We've already talked about and seen him doing both Data and lore, but now this is Brent playing Data, playing Sherlock Holmes. Right, and sliding in and out of Data and Data as Sherlock Holmes.

Yes, but like when I was just saying, like he took the Holmes character a little bit too far, but I think it's because he's playing it as Data would play it. Exactly. And that's why it feels like it's going a little bit too far, not necessarily like taking into consideration like how Watson, quote unquote Watson, would feel about how he's handling the situation. But the more I think about it, yeah, that's perfect. That's Data. I love it. Off in the distance, Data spots Moriarty and heads off to find him. As Geordi follows him, he realizes the computer is in fact running an independent program and Data really doesn't know what's going to happen next. Score. They find a secret passage which leads them into Moriarty's personal lab in quarters.

where they meet the good professor. I want a secret passage. Yeah, that'd be so cool. I'm just, I think I'm going to put it at the top of my stairs, like into my office here, like just a bookshelf, but I'm going to attach it to the door so I can literally just, you know, people are going to be at the bottom of my stairs and go, why do you have a bookshelf? Oh yeah. And that's a great part. Like I've looked into it. Like there are companies out there that specialize in this stuff. I mean, it's super expensive, but I mean, to get just like the bookshelf door that you're thinking of is probably, you know, I don't remember now. I would have guessed probably like two, three, 5,000. No, I'll just build it myself, man. I'll take a door. I'll get a, I'll get a target bookshelf, you know, cause we're target class. We're not Walmart class here. You know, I'll

to the door and I'm good. Good luck. Hang it from the door and there we go. Put casters on the bottom of the bookshelf so it can stop. Moriarty seems to know that Data and Geordi are not Holmes and Watson. He knows about the computer and he calls for the arch, something that no holographic character should be able to do. He has developed a consciousness, a self-awareness, handing Data a mysterious drawing, which causes the pair to run out of the holodeck simulation. Data calls for the exit and tries to shut down the holodeck, but he is unable to. On their way to see the captain, Data shows Geordi what's on that paper. It's a drawing of the Enterprise. This is not good. Dr. Pulaski is in rape. So I was very glad to hear that Geordi agreed.

with me that the holographic image should not be able to call for the arch. As soon as he did, I'm like, no, please don't let that work. Oh, it worked. uh so yeah because that opened up a whole nother can of worms just like what what's gonna go on here what's gonna happen like i i started kind of wondering like is can moriarty like what can he do now that he has this ability like can he uh could like i i even went through the process and wondered if he would be able to escape the holodeck which i mean we kind of start discussing later but by the way i've got a fun production note for you on that which i don't think you're gonna okay when we get to that spot though make sure i tell you this yeah um but yeah it's It just had my mind racing. Like at this point, I'm like, I had fully accepted. It's a fun episode. So I'm not going to question things too much. But what are they going to let him do? Welcome to watching Star Trek, Matt. This is a good part of Star Trek, right? Yes. It's not always that. My mom made me some old routine. It's not always that idea that sometimes people think of when they think of Star Trek. Like, no, it's actually fun, good episodes. And again, this one almost made the main show because I do want you to watch the good episodes too. But it just. Yeah, I totally understand that. Like this episode was well done if you let it be what it is.

Yeah, so I mean, as for the paper, as soon as he handed to him, I'm like, yeah, the way he described it, like I'm a black speck riding on the back of this turtle or something. That was a drawing of the Enterprise. You told him about the ship. Right. But they made you wait for it. And they finally gave you the payoff, but you had to wait for it to see. But then what still made me think that eventually Moriarty was going to get out of the holodeck was they brought the paper out of the holodeck. Right. Because they showed it to the captain outside of the holodeck. And I'm like, so you can bring things out. Like, I don't know if they changed that rule later, but they took that piece of paper, which I believe, I mean, it had to be part of the hologram and they brought it out. So again, I have a production note for you when we get to the end of the episode. And it's going to very specifically deal with what you're talking about right now, but I don't want to get there just yet.

I don't, I don't want to want to get in that because I want to wait. The, the, the only other note I'll make before I like to continue is apparently they have multiple holodecks. Oh yeah. Yeah. I think the, I think the enterprise D has four holodecks on it. Okay. Cause this episode they kept referencing and you had this holodeck too. I'm like, I mean, I think about it. Like, so you have over a thousand people on this ship. It is one of the chief ways of recreation. You know, and Jordy talks about like, he has to book the time and set it up, go through these pieces. Like you'd hope they have more than one. Cause that thing would never shut off.

Well, I doubt they, well, maybe, yeah, they probably have like a rotating, you know, today, holodeck one is down for maintenance. Yeah. All right. Well, act four, the senior staff are meeting in the conference room. The computer confirms that the holodeck can't be shut down because the override protocol has been initiated by Geordi. Done. The whole thing is a result of Geordi asking the computer to create an adversary that defeats not Holmes data. There's some talk about what to do. Each seemingly places Dr. Pulaski at more risk. Deanna is even beginning to sense a consciousness coming from the holodeck, which, you know, we go back to measure of a man. All right. Let's bring that, you know, what constitutes life? Are we dealing with a new life form? Like we have to.

start having that conversation, right? Self-aware consciousness. There you go. He certainly seems to be good. And I would even add in the other aspect that I was saying on Measure of a Man, a desire for self-preservation. Yeah, very much so in this one by the end of it. Right, right. I mean, we know the intelligence is there because like he makes a point, you know, I am your equal, Holmes. Right. Self-awareness is obviously there. Consciousness, you know, Deanna is beginning to sense.

You wonder if the innocence is anything at all, you know, ever with Data. That would have been the answer to that question. Exactly. It was in the other episode. Good job, Picard, not bring her in because maybe she really can't. He checked off screen. Yeah, let's not go there. Suddenly, the Enterprise lurches, and it seems that Moriarty is beginning to gain more and more control of the ship. So finally, Picard's had enough. He's going to go back to the holodeck with Data at Worf. Back on the holodeck, Moriarty is having tea with Dr. Pulaski. They seem to be getting along, but when Moriarty reveals what he knows so far, Pulaski just continues to play dumb, tries to excuse herself to get away. But Moriarty intends to use Pulaski as a lure.

Captain Picard. Yes, I know who he is too, he says. A cosplay Captain Picard, Data, and Worf enter the holodeck where the program looks as if beginning to break down. Hologrid starting to show through the illusion. Act 5. A small little mugging scene lets us know that the mortality safety protocols are off. People can in fact die inside of here now. I...

I mean, they wanted to make a point. I understand, but no one actually got hurt. It was, it was kind of a way, like it was an exposition of a scene. Yeah. You know what I mean? Like, well, like it would have been better if even like he poked him with the knife a little bit and he started to bleed. Like maybe that's not even that much isn't supposed to happen or something like, so, you know, and I don't know, maybe, maybe that's something they initially tried and that was a TV censorship thing. I don't know. I doubt it, but like, I would at least take it into that step, you know, like maybe like shoves his knife, shoves a knife in his back or something like, but he didn't even touch the knife.

clothes or something. Yeah, he pointed a knife at him and was like, oh, I guess we can die now. Data did the, what's that thing from Kung Fu Panda, the finger pinch? Yeah, something. Skadoosh. Picard and Data enter Moriarty's quarters, where Moriarty flexes his power by shaking the Enterprise again, calling his visitors by their real names. It's time for a real talk. He threatens the Enterprise and the people, but what he really wants is to survive, the same as anyone else. Some more techno babble about how Moriarty is real, but he's not alive, but he can live on the holodeck, but not outside the holodeck. Moriarty pushes back on the idea. He thinks, therefore he is, and he has changed. He has grown beyond his creative parameters. He is.

aware and yes he is alive yeah this uh i mean this is measure of a man all over again right exactly it's measure of man like it because this is like except we're like seeing the creation of this happening not not just trying to determine whether or not a being that's already there or a machine or whatever you want to call it is already there if they are you know if they have rights and stuff so it's because Thinking again about measure of a man, how they kind of go about resolving this and saying, well, we'll save you in the computer. Well, isn't that going to run into the same problem we had when the same reason why data didn't want to be shut down? Because they were saying, oh, don't worry, we'll save you in the computer and re-upload you later. But the whole thing was, it's not going to be the same. Right. And it's an interesting thing because the difference between data and the computer is data has a positronic that cannot be replicated. Moriarty, for all of his consciousness and self-awareness and his aliveness, he still does not have that. And so there is still something.

different between him and data does it mean that he's any less of a life form i don't know i guess it can be replicated because they like it came from the computer came from the ship the first time so why can't that they do that again but i i still wonder like they they say like they they they will save it to the computer But when they run that program again, run the Moriarty program, is it actually going to start where it left off or is it going to have to go through that entire process again? Right. Yeah. Does it just reset them back? Yeah. And it's interesting. Matt, did you ever watch the show Westworld on HBO? No. It's kind of the same. I mean, we're kind of getting into this territory of what do you do with AI when it resets, you know, like when it goes through a reboot, like and how do you use it? Like, does it have to continue to relearn, you know, the things that it learns every time and what happens if it can take that, you know, forward? Where do we go with it? So it's definitely interesting. This is a different life form for sure than what data is. Just because I don't know exactly.

understand your reference um i mean i i just start thinking about like uh like groundhog day yeah it's it's that same basic idea uh excepting groundhog day like he has to like go convince people what's happening that's that's kind of wonderful because like he retains like he knows what's gonna happen like he has that that memory that like he has a memory of everything that has happened everything that he learned but everybody else got rebooted right essentially and lost everything that they may have known yeah and i mean in westworld i mean just a brief synopsis the idea is you have these um these ai androids that look and feel human and like they pass the turing test like you can't tell the difference between them and real whatever and and they've set them up in a theme park type idea that's modeled after the old west and people can pay money to go into these theme parks and you basically can do whatever you want to the to the androids you can you can shoot them you can kill them you can punch them you can be intimate with them you can befriend them you can be enemies with them and like at the end of the day everything just resets well what happens when those androids or those ai things start carrying the memories forward day after day sure you know and i mean actually this gets back into the idea of what we talked about with measure of a man of like yeah you can just send them out you can do whatever it doesn't matter uh you know how are you gonna treat them so it goes back to that idea but you know with moriarty so what you know does he remember every time he gets shut down comes back gets shut down um yeah it's it's definitely a thing uh fine so picard picard might might agree that moriarty might be alive but there's still an issue here of basic physics how does this character live beyond the holodeck moriarty understands and finally returns control back to captain picard picard promises to

save the program, and bring him back when they have the technology that will allow him to leave the holodeck. They'll bring him back, he promises. The good news for Moriarty, time won't pass for him while he's deactivated. It's true. But my big question, which I have a feeling the writers didn't really have an answer to, they just made it happen. Why is Moriarty allowed to cancel the override? Well, because he was the one who activated it in the first place. So he locked everybody else out. Do what? Because when they asked the computer, they said the override was initiated by Geordi. Well, yeah, that was when Geordi said create a character that can defeat Data. Yeah. That initiated the safety control override or whatever.

control override for the holodeck right so you can't shut this off until until he's defeated but that guy then through i mean i guess it's because he's part of the computer system right like he's literally on the inside right so yeah i mean i just always took it as that like he i think it's you figured it out yeah i'm not gonna harp on it too much but it it just felt a little a little bit weird i mean other than saying well he is the computer he can do whatever i think that's the answer for a lot of it though and like he's become so sentient if you will that he but but at least But at least it wasn't like he just immediately had full access to all of that knowledge. Like we saw him kind of go on a journey of understanding more and more. Although it really just seemed like as time passed, he just gained more rather than learning it. He didn't learn it. It just suddenly available. I mean, it's kind of like we said with data. I think it's more of a matrix type of thing where you just plug into the program and given enough time, you will learn it. I think that's what that's kind of what was happening with him. And I like I honestly had less of a problem with that a little bit in how they displayed it. Maybe like the one time where, you know, he called out the arch and he started pressing the buttons.

what's the last part of this? I'll figure it out. Like, it'll come to me eventually, you know? And like, yeah, they wanted to drive across it. Yeah. Just as time goes on, he's learning more and more, but yeah, it felt a little awkward. All right. Here's that note that I wanted to give you. Sure. All right. So this is where the scene cuts, you know, when they have the technology, they'll bring them back. All right, cool. And Picard deactivates them. And we sort of in that storyline in the original script. And I actually went and found the script and this is 100% true. In the original script, there was actually an extra little scene past that point between Dr. Pulaski and Data and Captain Picard. And in that scene,

What was revealed was that Card was actually lying to Moriarty about not being able to live outside the holodeck because of that little piece of paper. So the little piece of paper could exist. So could Moriarty. So Moriarty really could have left the holodeck. It's just Picard lied to him to get him to stay in there. And when Picard gave his reason, he said, look, alive or not, he's still Dr. Moriarty or Professor Moriarty. And I haven't him run around my ship. Yeah. Right. And so there were supposed to be like a little smile back and forth between everybody. And this whole idea, though, was nixed by Gene Rodden. He came in and just sort of laid the law down and said, no, this basically makes Picard a jerk. He is cruel if you do this. You know, the other guys were like, hi, you know, it's just going to show how.

much smarter Picard is than everybody because he pulls the wool over. Gene just said no. Now, you remember, Gene's not necessarily running the show now. He's just that executive consultant. But I really like these little snippets when Roddenberry sort of steps in and makes these, I call them course corrections. You know, like, no, no, no, this is not what we're doing in the future. You're getting too far off the path here. So anyway, I just, so anyway, to answer, to go back to the whole piece about like the paper, leaving the holodeck and Ken Moriarty and all these kinds of things. Well, originally, yeah, he could have, supposedly, but they changed rules. Yeah. All right. Finish up the episode. Back in engineering, Geordi is looking over that model of the USS Victory. He's feeling a little down on himself for misspeaking such a single word.

putting the entire ship at risk. The guard says, hey, don't worry about it, Geordi. We're all good. What we do see, though, is the USS Victory, the starship, arrived. I want a better look at that ship. Oh, yeah? Yeah. We only get to see it from the front, I think, as it's flying at us. And it looks a little more unique than some of the other ships that we've seen. I know I made comments about how they're all very similar but different, but I'm pretty sure this one had four engines.

Yeah. It had the four nacelles. Yeah. Whatever, whatever you call them. Like there are two above and two below the saucer. Yeah. I want that. That's, that's a ship. Yeah. I'm looking at a picture of it right now online. Yeah. That's, that's a weird looking, weird, weird, weird looking ship. All right, man. Well, that's, that's really it. Elementary deer data. Any, any final thoughts on the episode here as we close this out? Keep them going. All right. Well, Matt, we, we don't really, you know, the, the way we do these extra viewing episodes, they're sort of just.

went off. They're not in order, you know, for Matt. So I don't know which one we're going to do next, but hey, you guys stay tuned to the Patreon feed. You'll find out what that is. You guys know how to get in touch with us. If you're doing this part of the show, you know how to get in touch with us, but it's gmailpod.com. So Matt, with that, I guess we'll just say thank you to all our patrons once again, and we'll see you guys out there on the main feed. Live long and prosper, guys.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Beam Me Up: A Star Trek Podcast?

This episode is 56 minutes long.

When was this Beam Me Up: A Star Trek Podcast episode published?

This episode was published on February 14, 2023.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Beam Me Up: A Star Trek Podcast episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.