Skip to content
Facebook, Sunrise and a wedding cake episode artwork

Mar 22, 2018 29 min

Facebook, Sunrise and a wedding cake

from Fourth Estate Hosted by 2SER

As the world reacts to the Cambridge Analytica scandal, we look at the lessons to be learned from the group’s data mining mistakes and ask if it’s time to get off Facebook. We also discuss the Sunrise segment that had Australia up in arms and Indigenous rights groups accusing the show of racism. Plus we look at the cake that didn’t sit so well with ABC Audience & Consumer Affairs. To discuss these issues we were joined by Myles Morgan (SBS), Miranda Ward (nine.com.au) and Ketan Joshi (CSIRO’s Data61). This episode was hosted by Ninah Kopel. Fourth Estate is produced by 2SER 107.3 in Sydney and is broadcast across the Community Radio Network in Australia.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Facebook, Sunrise and a wedding cake

0:00 29:18
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

A safer Ontario means more police and prosecutors making sure my card doesn't get stolen. It means building new jails to keep criminals behind bars. And it means there's no need to worry when I play at the park. We're making every corner of Ontario safer to make all of Ontario safer.

That's how we protect Ontario. For all of us. Learn how at Ontario.ca slash saferontario. Paid for by the government of Ontario.

Here we go. Someone's already claiming this is our year. Someone else said that last year too. A round of Jameson ginger and lime arrives at the table.

Smooth enough for kickoff, smooth enough for extra time. New friends pulling up a stool. Debates about whether that was a handball. Cheers rising like a roar around the room.

Because match days are about the shared moments. Add Jameson to your match day lineup. Jameson, it's what you bring. Please know your product responsibly.

You're listening to Plot Estate, the show where journalists talk journalism. Coming to you from 2SDR in Sydney on Gadigal lands of the Eora Nation. Right across Australia on the community radio network. And directly to your device across the globe via podcast.

My name's Nina Kopel. Coming up, the world is reacting to the Cambridge Analytica scandal. And we'll look at the lessons to learn from the group's data mining mistakes. We'll also discuss the sunrise segment that had Australia up in arms and indigenous rights groups accusing the show of racism.

Plus we look at the cake that didn't sit so well with the ABC editorial. Joining me in the studio is Miranda Ward, journalist from 9.com.au. Kitan Joshi from the CSRIO's Data61. And joining us on the line from Canberra is Miles Morgan, politics, defense, and indigenous affairs reporter for SBS News.

Phrases like black market data, infiltration of the online community, and shadowy online propaganda have all been used by the media this week in its coverage of the developing Cambridge Analytica data scandal. The story broke up to Christopher Wiley, a whistleblower from the British data marketing firm, revealed that information from more than 50 million Facebook users was breached to harvest information and target consumers leading up to the last presidential election in the US. This information was harvested from third-party platforms like games, quizzes, other applications on Facebook, which shared not only the users' data with the marketing firm, but all of their Facebook friends' data as well. This was part of a service they sold around the world, with US President Donald Trump and the Brexit campaign having used the service as part of their marketing strategies.

I want to come back to the political side of this and how important our data is to those who are trying to win efforts or trying to sell us products. But first, I want to talk about what this all means for Facebook and social media, and for us as people in the media. I'm curious to know if anyone on our panel tonight has decided to delete their Facebook account after this. Miranda?

No, I think my employer might suggest that's a weird thing to do as we use Facebook every day at work, but I think it would just be an emotional reaction to something that I'm still getting my head around. In a few months, I might think, yeah, you know what, it is time to quit, but right now I'm just adapting to all the information. I saw you put something interesting on Twitter that was kind of an alternative to getting rid of your Facebook account altogether. Can you share what that was?

Yeah, there's a few things you can do to basically short-circuit their data collection while retaining the utility of the service rate. So you can feed it noise, you can tell it that you're in funky locations, you can tag faces the wrong way, and you can go about systematically unliking all of the things from 2008 that you smashed the like button on when you were 10 years younger and that you now find completely embarrassing and probably don't define you as a person. It's not easy, but there's a few tools you can use to go through and cleanse your profile of information. But is that something we should be doing or are considering because we're worried about how it's appearing online, or is this something we should be taking seriously from a security perspective and in the way our information is being used?

It depends on your personal preference. So a lot of us, I think, would find that we have a lot of information there that is quite old and probably slightly embarrassing. I clicked through to my apps today and I found a whole bunch of them from quite a long time ago that I'd completely forgotten that were still there. So I would recommend that that's something that you should at least check.

You can also check your advertising preferences, so all of the information that's using the target ads do you as well. Miles, Mark Zuckerberg has been called before the British Parliamentary Committee to explain how this breach of privacy occurred. Facebook's total market value has dropped by more than US$40 billion or AU$52 billion in just two days. Is this something that's going to change the way you do your work as a journalist?

Yeah, look, I think it certainly makes journalists more cautious about how they approach their work and just realising the fact that whatever's on the internet, nothing ever really disappears and if someone really wants to access it, they likely can. So it'll be interesting to see how Mark Zuckerberg answers to that call from the British Parliament. And I think it's sending reverberations throughout the whole media industry as well and including social media. So I think it's a bit of a wake-up call for everyone.

Should we really be worried about this? People, especially in the media, have reacted like this is an extreme violation of our privacy, a breach of our personal information. Hasn't this been going on for quite a while and why are we suddenly so concerned about it? Yeah, I think, especially with my generation, I think we accept nowadays that we give up some of our privacy when we go online.

It's just part of the deal. But I think the fact here is that people didn't consent to this sort of data being harvested makes me certainly feel uncomfortable and I'm sure if you were one of the 50-odd million people, and just think about that for a second, 50 million people, that's twice the population of Australia. It's a huge number. And if none of them or a majority of them didn't consent, then it's deeply unsettling that this sort of thing, this sort of data can be harvested.

So yeah. Miranda, do you agree? Are you concerned about what the implications of this could be into the future as we continue to put more and more out there and as we continue to rely on social media platforms to communicate? Definitely.

I think people in the media have actually been probably more aware of this as an issue than, say, my mum and dad or my siblings who use Facebook because we all mind Facebook for stories and we are more aware of how that information gets filtered through the internet. But I think now we're all going to be a little bit more cautious about putting our own information on there and also taking others' people's. And we're going to start to have a debate around the ethics of that. And it's a big concern that in 2018, we haven't quite worked out yet around is privacy a human right?

Does everyone have the right to it? That really needs to be determined now moving forward after this. I think that's something that journalists have been talking about or thinking about for a while is how we use Facebook as a product. So people often think of themselves as consumers on Facebook, like they are getting a product from Facebook.

But I think what's really been revealed this week is that in a lot of ways we are the product and we are providing something that is worth value to Facebook. Kitan, is that something that you think people will come to terms with from this development? I think it'll take a while, but no one really likes to see themselves like that, I think. So perhaps that isn't a point that people will reach, but hopefully it'll change the way that we input information into sites like Facebook, right?

So we'll probably think twice before we signal to Facebook that we like a particular page or we post something with a certain collection of words in it because you can infer things about someone's personality from that and hopefully more people become aware of that. Yeah, I think it's a brutal reality, but it must be acknowledged, especially from my point of view in the media, that if you're on Facebook and you have some really lax privacy settings and you don't care what you post or who sees it, then you're fair game. And that may make everyone comfortable to hear that, but you look at a lot of news websites and the articles and the stories they use about maybe someone that has passed away or died or someone who's committed a crime and you'll see pictures of them just straight up listed from their Facebook account because they didn't care enough to change their privacy settings or they weren't savvy enough to do it. So yeah, in the same way that when you walk down the street you have a reasonable expectation that you'll be filmed or photographed by, say, a passerby or a surveillance camera, I think the same goes online in that nowadays you can expect that if you aren't clever enough or careful enough to protect your privacy, that can be used by certainly people in the media but anyone who really wants it and yeah, it can be disconcerting to some people.

One of the things I found interesting just from discussing this with people here to SCR colleagues is that this is really about who is vulnerable and who isn't. I think as people who work in the media and who are thinking about this perhaps we're less vulnerable to these types of systems but people who are less informed or who are politically ambiguous they don't know who they're going to vote for the next election. Maybe they're people who are more at risk. Miranda, do you feel like that?

There's something to who's being targeted here and who isn't? Yeah, I think it's something we can't let the market dictate on who we're going to access this because as you say there are people at risk and it will go to those sort of vulnerable people because the people who are more educated and have a more understanding or have more access to the information they will make decisions to protect themselves and it will leave the people not in those groups exposed to being manipulated in this way. I want to, if I can, read a tweet to you all that I found quite interesting. It's actually from Edward Snowden and he wrote it on the 18th of March and he said that businesses that make money by collecting and selling detailed record of private lives were once plainly described as surveillance companies.

Their rebranding as social media is the most successful deception since the Department of War became the Department of Defence. Does anyone think there's anything to that? I was just going to say I think Mark Zuckerberg with his whole move towards social good would be quite upset by that but I think there's a delicious irony in it. It's interesting thinking about that in terms of intent and you mentioned how Mark Zuckerberg would feel about it.

You always get this impression that he has a pretty clear understanding of his own intent. He thinks he's doing a good thing for a very large number of people but when you look into the details of the story through omission and kind of looking the other way a lot of information was passed out to third parties when it should have been carefully controlled. Yeah, I think that distinguishing between who is actually to blame in this is quite confusing and if you haven't spent all day or the past week thinking about this it's like there's Cambridge Analytica there's a third party that they then sent out to make this quiz and generate this data and it's quite difficult to understand how this all ties into who's responsible. Miles, do you think that is one of the reasons that we haven't dealt with this yet?

Yeah, well as we sort of alluded to before privacy advocates have been saying stuff like this has been happening pretty much since the advent of Facebook and social media and I think there's also so yeah, I think the Guardian some of the reporters there were sending out some really interesting tweets in the lead up to the story when it first broke and as it was breaking with all the legal threats that had been made against them by Cambridge Analytica and even by Facebook in terms of trying to shut down or lessen the impact of the story of those tweets are to be believed so it sounds like there was a monumental effort behind the scenes to try and get the story shut down or lessened in terms of impact even before it was published but as I said privacy advocates have been saying for years that this has been occurring I think there's also a bit of a care factor for people because as I was saying before when you go on the internet when you use social media I think you accept that you will give up some of your privacy and people will try to mine your data so it's the same with the way that people in the West sometimes don't care as much about famines or wars occurring in the Middle East or in Africa because there's a bit of a care and desensitization to it and that we're bombarded with these messages and concerns all the time sometimes it's just hard to care and you just get sick of hearing about it so you just get on with your life and you don't really pay attention until something huge and monumental like this pops up Well that brings me quite well to the next thing I wanted to pose to you all and that is the role that journalists have had in really uncovering the story and to read you another tweet Carol Cadwalda from The Guardian and The Observer in the UK who's been really instrumental in breaking the story and the reporting that has been going on for this series of reporting for the past year she tweeted basically calling out for support for The Guardian because they ended up giving the story to Channel 4 News the New York Times really as a way of breaking the story and getting it added to the world and then she then had to go out and say please support us because we're the ones who are on the ground covering the story and we really need support from people so we can keep doing this is it a problem that you had to go and actually ask people for this kind of funding after the fact? Miranda? I guess it comes down to The Guardian's funding model which is to ask the audience for money in forms of donations and a membership program if it had been news call it would have been all behind a paywall so perhaps she wouldn't have had to do that I think it is tragic that she has to go and say we had to let other outlets in because we couldn't afford to do it completely by ourselves but it's also something that's the beauty of journalism we all want to help each other break these important stories and this story is really important and it shows the importance of public interest journalism which is under threat in Australia as well Miles do you agree? Yeah absolutely and hats off to the journalist behind the story it was a great effort it was really solid journalism and you can just tell by the shockwaves it's sending around the world that's the sort of journalism you dream of doing and the fact that they had to essentially ask for a bit of a handout for doing it is unfortunate but it is a reality of our industry today that funding is drying up the media is averting and splitting in so many ways and as Miranda said if they had been behind a paywall maybe they wouldn't have had to have been asking for money but they've obviously decided to do this in the interest of the great good and all I can say of that is good on them You're listening to Father State you're with me and I'm speaking to Miranda Ward from 9.com.au Ketan Joshi from the CSRIO's Data61 and joining us on the line from Canberra is Miles Morgan Politics Defence and Indigenous Affairs Reporter for SBS Breakfast television show Sunrise was met with outrage last week after that all-white panel made inaccurate and offensive comments about the adoption of Indigenous children the panel was discussing statements made by Federal Assistant Minister for Children and Families David Gillespie who suggested Australia should be reconsidering its adoption process for Indigenous children at the moment when an Indigenous child in Australia is unable to remain in the care of their parents their removal must occur in accordance with the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander child placement principle the principle says that Indigenous children should ideally be kept within family and kinship networks failing which they should go to non-related carers in the child's community and then as a last resort carers in another Aboriginal community the policy started from a grassroots political movement acting to prevent the reoccurrence of a stolen generation which resulted in psychological emotional and at times physical and sexual abuse of many of the children who were removed from their families Assistant Minister David Gillespie's argument was that the more open adoptions would increase chances of the children finding permanent and stable environments to live in rather than cycling through foster care to discuss this issue Sunrise had an all-white panel none of whom had any specific expertise related to child welfare or Indigenous affairs Miles I'm going to start with you because you do have that background in Indigenous reporting where did Sunrise go wrong?

Look in areas of fact essentially there's been a lot of outrage about this story a lot of it understandable however I don't think we should be trying to shut down these kinds of debates I wasn't particularly offended by any of the opinions apart from some truly outrageous one calling for another stolen generation but I don't think the fact that we had an all-white panel was necessarily a bad thing because as Australians we care about our first Australians and Indigenous people and they're entitled to their opinion as much as I'm entitled to mine as an Indigenous affairs reporter so their opinions well while I didn't exactly agree with them I think it's breakfast TV they're all getting up at 3 or 4am to plan their day they want to get some sexy headlines in there and get people talking but when you just go into the gutter like this and talk about the front page of the Daily Telly which in itself wildly extrapolated the Minister's comments it's not good journalism it's not good for democracy I don't think anyone was the better for having listened to or watched that debate areas of fact which I can go into more detail but broadly speaking there were just areas about the laws regarding Indigenous children and what families they can be placed with numerous areas throughout so yeah disappointing I'm not totally surprised it has to be said at sunrise this week you have an all-Indigenous panel to talk about the same issue after a lot of protests around the nation Was that them reacting to the anger though and the frustration that people felt at what was not just a white panel but also a very unqualified panel of people who didn't have expertise in healthcare and Indigenous affairs or was that them trying to equal the playing field Look I think it was a bit of all of the above you know one of the trends of journalism is balance in terms of our reporting so I think Sunrise realised there was a deficiency in terms of balance there and having all white panels talking about all Indigenous issues essentially so to have the Indigenous panel was a welcome addition in terms of balance we know there were a lot of protests in Martin Place behind the Sunrise studios which Sunrise conveniently blocked out with a pre-recorded background so there was national and national conversation about this which in some ways is a good thing because it's a very serious issue there are nearly 20,000 Indigenous children in out of home care not with their families so it's a very important issue so when we start talking about these things sometimes it doesn't really matter how you start talking about them as long as you are talking about them so when I see something on Sunrise an all white panel talking about about Aboriginal adoption. I'm not immediately outraged. Of course, when I hear these opinions, sometimes I am, but I'm glad that we're having the conversation. Yeah.

Miranda, do you feel that sense of responsibility to make sure that, as a journalist, we're kind of getting these stories right, especially when we don't necessarily have the perspective or the background that these stories are coming from? Definitely. You're always wanting to present a balanced viewpoint, and the pressures of breakfast TV, I imagine, are quite immense. And Sunrise, as Miles said, they did follow it up with an all-Indigenous panel, so they did attempt to do the right thing in the end.

But there were crucial errors made in that first broadcast, which are a little bit unforgivable from a journalist's perspective. You're listening to Fault in State. You're with me, Nina Koppel, and I'm speaking to Miranda Ward, journalist from 9.com.au, Keetan Joshi from Adato 61, and on the line from Canberra is Miles Morgan, politics, defence, and Indigenous affair reporter for SBS News. The ABC's Independent Audience and Consumer Affairs has upheld a complaint to the story that aired on Radio National's Law Report was two-one-sided.

The story was about a court case currently before the Supreme Court in which the US is looking at the right of a baker to refuse to supply a cake for a homosexual wedding. ABC's Law Report featured an interview with James Essex, a lawyer working on the masterpiece cake case. While ABC's Independent Audience and Consumer Affairs said the story was timely and newsworthy given it aired during the Australian same-sex marriage bill debate, it failed to provide proper context. It was found that the interview was not in keeping with the ABC's editorial standards for impartiality and diversity of perspectives.

I'm going to open this up to the panel. Do we feel like this was a fair conclusion to draw? As much as I'd like to say, no, I think it was a fair conclusion. It's a topic that I would find hard to cover myself as a journalist because I wouldn't necessarily want to give someone fighting against that situation airtime, but you do have to give both sides of the story their right to voice what they want to say.

Keetan, do you have any feelings about how that was portrayed and whether or not the response was, I guess, fair? I imagine it's a constant struggle when it comes to determining what's balanced and what's giving airtime to someone with horrible views and perhaps something that can be used to guide decisions is the person who's giving me an alternative view being rational and giving me a clear-headed perspective or are they kind of just spouting hateful garbage? And perhaps that was part of the calculus behind this decision. I hope it was.

Miles, you probably have the most insight you've been in a position where you've had to think about ABC editorial guidelines, I suppose. How did you feel about the response? Yes, I did used to work for the ABC. I now work for SBS and they're both public broadcasters.

I'm going to say I've listened to the segment in question in which the law report host spoke exclusively or only to the lawyer representing the same-sex couple in the case in the US Supreme Court, I believe it was. So I listened to that and I looked up the ABC's editorial policies which are very similar to SBS's and the issue here is a balance, I think, in that according to the ABC, that segment didn't give another viewpoint any time to air. I believe, honestly, I think it's a bit of a harsh ruling because having looked at the editorial policies, the same with SBS, balance is critical to journalism but according to the ABC's policies, not every, I'm quoting directly here, a story doesn't require every perspective receives equal time or every facet of the argument is presented. So that to me says you can't achieve balance within every story.

Think about the same-sex marriage debate. Think about the 90-second television story that you have to do for television. You can't present every viewpoint. If you try to do it every night, you're just going to get a shemozle of a story.

So you want to achieve balance across your news service, across your bulletins, across your website, 9MSN, for example. You can't do it in every single story. So to me, to hear a podcast with a lawyer representing a same-sex couple, it's not necessarily unbalanced. It should have probably given a line or two to the facts of the case, what was alleged, maybe what the defendant or the plaintiff, whatever the opposite side was trying to say or what they were arguing in court.

I don't necessarily think it was an unbalanced segment. I think the ABC was a little harsh there and I think the expectation can be a little unrealistic in trying to present balance in every story because you can also end up achieving a bit of a false balance if you give, say half the segment was on pro-same-sex marriage and half of it was anti-same-sex marriage, then if you do that constantly, you give the impression that there's a 50-50 split in an opinion. But there's not, there's not, it never happens. There's no 50-50 on any issue in Australia or the US for that matter.

So yeah, I think the umpire might have erred on the side of caution there. Randy, you're kind of nodding along. Do you agree? Yeah, definitely.

I think it's just making sure you give context to the argument, making sure, as Miles said, you don't necessarily need to go and interview the other side, but making sure you might read out a statement or give a little bit more context to their point of view. I think especially with court and legal reporting, the whole fundamental principles of court hearings is that there are two sides or two or more parties. So yeah, as I said before, it should have included at least a reference to what the other party was saying or arguing. I think that's essential, especially when it comes to anything to do with legal reporting.

So yeah, I think the argument could be made for that. As I said, though, you try to do it every segment, you're just going to drive yourself nuts trying to balance that elusive thing sometimes. And that's it for Fourth Estate this week. I'm Ina Kobol.

Thanks to my guests, Miranda Ward, Keitan Joshi and Miles Morgan. Don't forget, you can subscribe to the Fourth Estate podcast so you never miss an episode. This is my first episode of Fourth Estate, so thanks for joining me. Next week's show will be hosted by Peter Frey, so make sure you listen again then.

We'll be right back. We'll be right back.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Fourth Estate?

This episode is 29 minutes long.

When was this Fourth Estate episode published?

This episode was published on March 22, 2018.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Fourth Estate episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.