Skip to content
Fact Checking The Election episode artwork

May 23, 2019 39 min

Fact Checking The Election

from Fourth Estate Hosted by 2SER

This week we have an expert panel of Fact Checkers and we ask them just how toxic was the election and should we chuck our opinion polls in the bin. To help us with this and much more we spoke to Lucinda Beaman from RMIT ABC Fact Check, Anne Kruger Editor of First Draft News and Michael Hopkin acting Editor of Fact Check at the Conversation.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Fact Checking The Election

0:00 39:12
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Visit BetMDM Casino and check out the newest exclusive, The Price Is Right Fortune Pick. BetMDM and GameSense remind you to play responsibly, 19 plus the wager, Ontario only, please play responsibly. If you have questions or concerns about your gambling or someone close to you, please contact the next Ontario at 1-866-53-1-2600 to speak to an advisor. Recharge.

BetMDM operates pursuant to an operating agreement with iGaming Ontario. Hello and welcome. You're listening to Fourth Estate, the show where journalists talk journalism, coming to you from 2SER, in Sydney, on Gadigal lands on the Ora nation, right across Australia on the community radio network, and directly to your device across the globe via podcast. My name is Peter Frey, I'm the Co-Director of the Centre for Media Transition at the University of Technology Sydney and my producer is Anthony Dockrell, and many thanks for this episode for Julia Carcadsel for helping out with the research.

So, how was your weekend? It's fair to say the election on Saturday night was one of those rare moments when our nation came together and shared many of the same thoughts and emotions, namely surprise and disbelief at the result. Labour went down in flames and Scott Morrison was reborn victorious like a male Daenerys tailgarian, or to use a sporting analogy in a solo effort with no time on the clock, the big bloke ran down the line and scored the seemingly impossible try to win the game. So, the pundits give or take the odd Janet Alperson or Chris Kenney and three years worth of polling were wrong, wrong, wrong, wrong.

What a waste of money. Just think how many journalists could be employed if we ditched the polls and spent it on the report. That's another story. Now we can look forward to Skomo versus Albo, but before we get to all that, and I'm sure we'll do that in another show, there's some unfinished business about this election.

Last week on Fourth Estate, we asked, was news corporation putting its finger on the scales in favour of the government? I think we have seen some pre-reasonable explanations about that. The answer is probably yes. Anyway, but tonight, let's look at the election proper and ask the vexing question, did facts matter?

To answer this question and many others, we are joined by a fantastic panel. Drum roll. Lucinda Beeman is a journalist and now she is a professional fact checker. She works at RMIT, ABC Fact Check.

Before that, she worked as a fact checker editor at the conversation. Welcome, Lucinda. Thank you for having me. My pleasure.

The crew has worked at CNN, Bloomberg, ABC Landline. She has hosted a classical music show. She has recently returned from a long stay in Hong Kong to run the APAC Bureau of First Draft News, the International Collaboration between universities like UTS and RIT and news media organisations against the Internet of Misinformation. Welcome, Anne.

Hello. Good to be here. Good. And branding out this team of fact-finding, true-seeking warriors is Michael Hopkins.

A journalist who has worked for the Western Australian newspaper, he's written for Nature and is now the acting editor of the fact checker at the conversation. He's online from Melbourne, which by the way, from the Melbourne office of the conversation, which by the way is on a bit of a reader revenue drive and if you want to check that out, go into the conversation website. Hello, Michael. Hello.

Thanks for having me. It is a great pleasure. So let me open with an open-ended question. From your perspective, how clean was the election?

Was it to use a very obvious word, toxic, Linde? Listen. Lucinda first. What did you think?

No worries, Paul. It was a toxic election campaign, unfortunately. Obviously not what we want to see coming from that fact check and verification space, but toxic nonetheless. The really interesting thing about this election, because of course misinformation and disinformation has always existed to varying degrees.

But the role of social media in the amplification, a lot of that disinformation is something that we're all turning our minds to now and how to tackle that. And the fact that anyone can spread disinformation now. Someone can put up a post, target it to certain people, it can go viral. That's very hard to tackle, hard to find and hard to refute.

If we had a toxicity index, what would just stay with you, Lucinda? What would the rating L10B you think? On an Australian scale. Yeah, Australian toxicity election index.

I'd say it's up there. I'd say it's in the nines. Nines, gosh, okay. I'm not saying that there haven't been elections in the past that have been that high, but probably the number of people who that kind of disinformation was disseminated to will get bigger and bigger every year.

So if we look at Facebook with 18 million active users in Australia and in the knowledge that so much of the disinformation was spread through Facebook, people don't have to be reading the newspapers or listening to the news. They just need to be looking for photos of their friends' babies and they'll get here with them. And I'll be pops. Well, that's a great segue.

I couldn't have done better myself for you. You came out to this country from Hong Kong. First I have to dream job. I remember you telling me.

And so did that dream get tempered by the level of toxicity you saw? Well, I do think we have to clarify and distinguish between Australia and say Asia where I have seen toxicity boil over really and it becomes really dangerous for people's day to day life. So I would agree with Lucinda about this scale. Maybe I wouldn't put it in quite a nine.

Maybe an eight, but there's the potential of it being a nine. I do think there was shock and awe, polarization tactics used in the election campaign. So you've got a political campaign. You've got an election that's being used as a platform here.

And some of the tactics really were shocking and awful. And in particular, I'm thinking about your phrase and it's, now he didn't get in and he didn't get a seat, but his support group is strengthened. And he has his official sites, his official pages, but then there are the offshoots of that as well. And when they were all starting, you've got 20,000 followers here and 20,000 followers there.

It begins to add up. So I do start to wonder what is circulating around there. Okay. We'll get to the more specifics in the same.

Michael, you stood in to Fat Check, if I'm wrong, you stood in to check Fat Check after Lucinda jumpship. Is that right? That is exactly right. So you were a newbie.

The reason I mentioned that is because you were a newbie to the fact checking thing. So were you surprised at what you were finding? I was surprised. I mean, I was obviously following politics very closely even before I picked up the fact checking role.

And I think on the subject of how toxic the campaign was, I was almost maybe even expecting it to be worth certainly given the Parliament that preceded it and how rancorous things got there. The one thing I've only noticed though is that because of this, you know, what we've been talking about of this sort of diffracturing of the electorate and the ability of everyone to silo themselves on social media, it's almost as if the two major parties can get away with sort of not being as toxic themselves. They're probably operating at about a six or seven out of ten and the knowledge that other people are going to take up the cause for them and not be afraid to hit them in sort of nine out of ten. Yeah, that's a great point.

So did you see, for instance, this question to you and whether the misinformation, the lies and essence, were they coming from particular groups, the hard right, the file F, whatever, you know, where were they, who was doing the bad stuff? Well, it seemed to me that, yeah, there were these sort of special interest groups. I mean, one of the big kind of outright lies that came up during the campaign was the sort of, you know, the death taxes stuff. And so, and that I think was based on a press release from a few months ago that came out from the government where I think Dr.

Eichryne went hinted at the idea that it might become a Labour policy at some point down the track. And then all these people kind of gleefully took it up on Facebook and I was getting loads of emails saying, I've heard about these death taxes and inheritance taxes and, you know, so I think once stuff gets put out into the social media, you know, bubbles and echo chambers or whatever people call them, that's when I think they can sort of take on a life of their own. And then if it suits a particular minister to not really, to just let it run and run and not correct it when it needs to be, then they'll just let it go. Yeah, I mean, that's your point, isn't it?

I mean, there's nothing new in scare campaigns, you know, scare for instance in the previous election. But there's nothing new in scare campaigns, but it's the level of how they can be weaponized. Yeah. I mean, we did see some MPs elected MPs sharing that information as well.

For example, LNP, MP George Christensen talked a lot about death taxes and Pauline Hanson also went there, right, throughout the campaign. So, you know, started off with that suggestion. It was continued by some conservative MPs and then it amplified to a huge extent by interest groups and viral misinformation. And so maybe it's a good point in the show for you to explain a little bit more about first draft because I think, you know, most people understand fact checking has been ran a while, but first draft is a kind of newish concept for this country.

What is it? Well, first draft aims at finding best practice in the online and social media space and in particular it's been focused very much on social media verification. And there's a strong emphasis on collaboration, how to discover misinformation, but not only to just that, but then how do you present that responsibly and ethically to the world? Because you have to be careful, you know, something might be swirling around in Fortun and, you know, what's that tipping point where you go, okay, this is going to be a risk to greatest society.

If we start to, you know, spread these sort of beliefs and ideologies as the Fortun moves into your more open social networks, you know, and get into the Facebook sphere where there are people who, you know, like you say, listen, you know, they're scrolling through and they might come across some information, some, you know, a bit of propaganda from a bit of a, you know, far right or a bit of an out there type of group. And they wouldn't otherwise be searching for these, but they come across these. So how do people, you know, in a way that information and do they have time to do that? And that's where we try to enter that space.

So let's briefly talk us through that process a little bit more. Okay, well, so what we've been doing is, and certainly for the Australian election, we held a pilot cross-check Australia and that involved, we had about 40 students that we trained up in advanced verification techniques and we had about three media partners as well. And we have a very large, crowd-tangle feed that we were populating with a lot of different book pages and groups as well as Instagram and a little bit on Reddit as well. And that's a lot of the heavy lifting there.

So you're looking at, you're uploading all the different groups and things like that. And you're analysing what is gaining traction. And it's not just because something necessarily happens to be going viral, but just, you know, what is new when you're looking at different search terms and things as well. So, you know, so we might see, you know, with the 40% death tags, we might see, well, who else is sharing this and how is that?

Who else is liking these pages? How many likes? What sort of traction are these positive? So it's your trigger moment just going on like that texting.

So it's the trigger moment when you're pulling hands to chairs in or George Christensen shares it. And I don't know where the, well, you go, oh, yes, we must do something about this now. No, we actually saw before that. So we had our students that came across it and that was being shared in Messenger posts, so Facebook Messenger posts and people were just sort of sharing it to their smaller groups.

And our students found instances of that. And then we saw how that message then really took on a life of its own. And then you seem to have some of your politicians like you're pulling hands and got on the bandwagon after that. Okay, so you started looking at it right when it was then when it was bubbling away in Messenger.

That's right. Just on the side here, perhaps. How do you feel about the digital platforms and their responsibility? You mentioned Messenger obviously and that's a whole new show.

That is a whole new show for sure. I mean, that's a lot of the experience of the last few weeks to show you that more needs to be done. That's the basic question, I guess. Yeah, well, you know, I'm also looking then at the powers of the AEC today.

So we're looking at problems with political advertising and it really appears that the AEC has quite limited powers. They can, they give a lot of warnings to people and that's, you know, so your actual political parties have to have authorized advertising. That's fine. I think that's not the support groups that are then spreading that, that regulation is just not there.

Okay, all right, well, as I said, probably the whole new show. I want to get to one of the central questions of this and whichever one asks, fact checkers, and I know from my experience on that, is which party told the most fibs, Ms. Inda? Well, I don't think we can say that definitively, which is a very frustrating fact checkery quite a type answer.

I can look at the analysis that we did over the course of the campaign at RIT, ABC Fact Check. So of about a dozen, a couple of dozen, sorry, fact checks. So broadly, we found that around 50% had an in-between type verdict, so with this an elementary- So have truthy type vote? That's right, which is very common in Australia or coming from Australian politicians.

Around 38% were in the red and around 13% were in the green. In terms of the coalition and labor, they were pretty similar. So we had fewer, you know, broadly green or correct verdicts. Most of them were more towards the red side, but between labor and the coalition, they were relatively close.

So equal offenders? Broadly. In this particular very small, non-scientific sample sort of... I know, I know, but you can fact check that out on it.

The conversation find. Something similar? Or were you at it? Disappointing it was very similar actually.

I mean, I would echo all of the caveats that Lucinda has just given and say, you know, it does seem to be... There certainly wasn't one side or the other. That was, you know, really kind of playing fast and loose with the truth. And in terms of the actual categories of, you know, sort of true or false verdicts that we were coming out with, by far the most common verdict we were reaching without Fact Check was the kind of category of yes but, which, so you know, the actual claim itself that you're checking is true.

But the wider context kind of tells a more important and interesting story, which obviously whoever it is that's made the claim is perhaps happy to gloss over. Yeah, I mean, this is very common in the work of Fact Checking, right? Do you find that the politician has gone from A to C and forgot to get to B? Yeah.

And I think a lot of politicians are... They're probably doing it deliberately. They're kind of sailing close to the winds, so they'll come out with the fact that they know to be true. But of course, there's a more nuanced and wider sort of debate to be had around it, or there's some context that is gloss over.

We might go back to that sort of what that doll tells us, but just to give our listeners a better understanding of what Fact Checking does. Lucinda, maybe you can talk us through this. So Bill Shorten joined the campaign and said that millions of Australians were underemployed and working two jobs, RMIT, ABC Fact Checker actually checked us. What was the process?

How did you go about that? Well, with all of our Fact Checks, so our remit at the moment is to take claims made by politicians and other leaders in Australia, and then take that claim and test it against the best available data or evidence. So in true journalistic fashion, we will go to the person who made the claim and ask them if they can provide us with their sources. That doesn't affect our verdict at all, it's just part of the good journalistic process and information gathering.

We will then go and find out what is the best available data source to test this against, and we will do our own extremely forensic and detailed analysis. We'll also go to experts in that field who we trust and ask them if there's any other context or analysis that we may have missed, humble journalists as we are, and put that all together. It then goes through a very extensive Fact Checking process within our unit as well, so we're all holding each other to account. Before coming up with a verdict, which is debated in a group, so it's not one person coming up with a verdict, and then we will publish that.

So in this case, it was firm to be correct, I think. Yes, that's right. But I believe correct, but nothing new here. Nothing new here, nothing to see, please move on.

Okay, tell me, one of the central things about both verification and fact checking, which is always vexed me, I suppose, is how other journalists use the work, right? So in my wildest dreams, so journalists following the Prime Minister around, and there's a bog-standard sort of door-stop, and the journalist, instead of asking some sort of question which might get a great quote, ask the question, Prime Minister, what you've just said has been fact-checked by the conversation or R&T fact-checker, ABC fact-checker, and they found it while you said it's a load of hooey. How do you respond to that? Very, very really happens.

Is that a frustration for humble fact-checkers? That would be beautiful. Do all the journalists looking, please, please do it. Well, why don't they do it?

It's because it's an interesting point underneath that, is why they don't do it. My argument would be that they're there for the grabs rather than the facts. Look, I think it is improving on that front, because during the election campaign we did see other journalists pointing to RMIT, ABC fact-checks, as evidence for an argument or a question they might be pointing to a politician, and we saw the Guardian republishing our verdicts. So I think there is increasing engagement between the media organizations, and hopefully that will continue.

Michael, did you have experience with that? You've been a reporter on the West Australian in your face with the chance of talking to the Prime Minister, either getting a grab that might support a new story or asking him or her about a fact-check. What would you do? Well, if it was the right place in the right time and the fact-check was the killer question to ask, then I would like to think I would definitely ask that.

I think this is kind of touching on perhaps a wider problem with political journalism in general, is that a lot of the political reporters absolutely run off their feet when it's campaign time, and they're kind of on the campaign bus, or these days it's the campaign plane. Not really knowing where they're going to be or what this sort of issue of the day is necessarily going to be when they get there. So yeah, it is a thing that I would really like to see lots more reporters doing, but it's the kind of thing that takes the background reading and the kind of pre-research that in an old school world everyone would be doing, but these days often it's a five minutes pitch up. That's why you're doing that work.

That's why you're doing that work. I mean, that's the whole point of checking, isn't it? To do that work for them? Yeah, we hope we're doing it on their behalf.

And yeah, all that stuff is free to republish. Okay, and just on that point of impact, what needs to improve or do you think there's a cultural thing here about getting other news media organizations to kind of delve into these things? This sort of model of journalism as opposed to give us a great quote, trigger-fix kind of model. I mean, verification is actually quite new as we know it now.

I mean, it feels to be like first draft has been around for years just because we've done so much and we've discovered so much in recent years, but really they came into their own in 2016 on polling day for the US election. And they were actually collaborating with media organizations and universities and they were looking at influences on voters on polling day in the US. And it's a massive lift. It's a massive task.

And they followed that in 2017, looking at the French elections and shortly after in the UK. And I think there's the idea of collaboration with media, looking into verification is actually a very, very new concept. And I think it takes a bit of time, but once the organization has been a part of this kind of experience this properly, realize that there is so much to gain when everyone collaborates together. There are so many benefits when everyone collaborates.

In particular, when you're looking into social media into areas that are actually quite closed sometimes and quite difficult to discover, you know, the messages that are swirling around your messenger, your WhatsApp, that sort of thing. So it's still a new concept. But I think the fact checking verification that we've seen so far has been solid in Australia, has been reliable. I know there have been other issues, obviously, there's this collaboration of fact checking that's kind of blossomed in recent years as well.

But I do think what we've got here and what's coming in here is solid. And I think it's a matter of taking the time with the media organization. I don't know that it's solid. I mean, I think it goes to cultural practices and the normative factors of journalists is to get a great quote.

Not to worry too much. I think fundamental problems may be with journalism. More interested in getting a great quote, and literally sometimes sacrificing that great quote for the facts. And you're right.

And you know, this 40% death tax just swirled and swirled and it was quite apparent early on that it shouldn't have had legs, but it did. So why? You disagree with me. I hope.

I'm just having a think about this. I actually think, you know, obviously there's not one story about the media. I think we're seeing in some areas more engagement with the facts. A lot of reporters actually not being afraid to delve into that kind of detail, which, you know, maybe will lose some readers.

But there's been, you know, during the campaign, great, not fact checking a kind of formal fact check journalism sense, but just general, you know, really good forensic fact checking journalism, you know, from the Guardian, from Fairfax within other units within the ABC, even the Australian, you know, great piece into the death tax issue by Alice Workman. So I think it's getting better. Okay. All right.

I'm going to give you a school project. This is a little bit cheeky, but if you if you were fact checking the assertion that the political polling was broken, is broken, how would you go about that? I would not do that. Why not?

Because I don't think, I mean, from RMIT, ABC, you fact check perspective, I don't think that would work for us. So you take that question. Is it broken? So where is the evidence for that?

They were wrong. They were wrong, but can we point to a data set? Can we point to? I think we need to think about the entire ecosystem of journalism.

So what different roles do different journalists play? We wouldn't see that as our role, because we wouldn't want to dilute the kind of absolutely factual, can stand up in court, absolutely defensible kind of verdict that we deliver. And we would see that as the role of good journalism to go out there, look at the history, exactly point out how many incorrect news polls there have been, make a list of it, make an assessment about whether it's broken. And there are lots of journalists who are well placed and well equipped to do that.

Okay, Michael, how would you go about fact checking the assertion that the polls are wrong? I think Dennis Miller did a quite interesting piece in the conversation today. Along those lines, not exactly a fact check on my opinion, please. Well, I'm agreeing with this and all the way through this, but as she rightly said, it's a difficult one to fact check on formalized basis because the first step of any fact check article is identifying the precise claim to be checked and then seeing whether or not it's checkable in a definitive way.

So I think that's a good question. So to say a statement like the polls are broken because they were wrong, how do you indicate whether that's right or wrong? I mean they were wrong, but is it because they're broken? So this is the kind of story.

I think that benefits more from kind of a contextual analysis and explainer. So you see a lot of journalism these days on the conversation and elsewhere. It's a kind of a growing genre of journalism with just explainers on complicated issues. And so why did the polls get it wrong?

I think that's a more relevant question than is polling broken and useless. So you want to know what the fact is at play? I was reading some stuff earlier in the week that we were saying. It's because you can't just look people up in the white pages anymore and call them at home.

Which is fun, right? It's all this robo polling and the technology has bugged up the polls to put it. And you haven't done this, don't you? I do.

And I think also people don't consider just how does a poll work and any even simple academic approach to how polls work and surveys work will always state that you have to think of the margin of error. And not once has anyone really even mentioned margin of error, survey sample size. And as you mentioned before Peter, how is the polling conducted? It used to be considered it was a little bit more thorough when everyone had a landline.

But we don't have that anymore. So I think it's a reflection on our new digital society too. How do you poll people? And I think this is something that's never mentioned.

And people are so surprised when the polls are out. And I think, well, really, you need to think about how each poll is constructed. And this is basically news literacy as well. When have you seen any sort of poll or statistics, we always have to think, well, how has that been collected?

Well, stick with you for a second and then to listen to what contention I would put to you is that polls are, again, sugar fix for the news media. They are guaranteed lead story or lead of the bullet or whatever. And so news media in this country and others are addicted to polls. Doesn't matter whether they're right or wrong.

It's not responsible reporting. And we've got to get over this and consider more, one of the actual policies and one of the actual people, the constituents, one of their concerns and we have to get back to that. And so it's a bit more of a public journalism angle that needs to be taken rather than this constant two-horse race. Yeah, I'll ditch the poll, spend it on journalism.

I would completely agree with that. More focus on policy and more focus on what Australians want to hear about. I think there is a lot of self-reflection going on now about polls. It's just the time to do it.

This is the time overdue. About the polls, about whether or not they should be relied on, probably not, and how to report on them exactly bringing in things like how they were constructed. There is always going to be a desire to predict an outcome and to, I guess, take the temperature of the nation and the lead up to an election. And it may be now that looking to social media might be a way to do that.

So looking at sentiment, expression online, looking at, as you said earlier, the engagement of different pages from different groups and Google searches, which are very revealing. Sure. And octopus would probably be just as much better money spent. At least you can eat it afterwards.

That's right. Octopus. Beautiful. Great.

Every newsroom, I apologize to anyone if they're offended with me saying you can eat octopus. And I apologize for octopi. Nick Eveschade. Nick Eveschade in the Guardian, right?

Very interesting article in the instance of the election. Looking at the breakdown of the election result through data. And one graph, I think, captured the problem for the Labour Party, but also, I think, in a way, for fact-checkers. And it was this, that the booths where the level of education and employment were highest, where the booths where Labour did best, and as education and employment engagement dropped, so did their vote.

So I guess the question, you know, the slightly rude question, though, is fact-checking cutting through into where it really matters, whether you're just preaching to the choir. I think that's a very valid question. Oh, thank you. Yeah.

And I think there is something to that, I mean, journalism is only worthwhile in as much as people read and take notice of it. So the challenge is to try and reach everyone. And it's not, you know, disparage the sections of the media that are widely read in, you know, different areas or others. There is a lot of media that probably know that they are basically monopoly on their readers or viewers, and, you know, therefore can kind of do what they want to an extent and know that if they deliberately or otherwise report stuff that isn't correct, then they know people are just going to read it and then think that.

Okay. How do we fix this in this question for a listener, and also for Anne, in terms of verification? If it is really preaching to the choir, what needs to stop, what needs to change for it not to be? In terms of preaching to the choir, our readership is just booming.

And I think that's... You have a big choir, the ABC. We have a big choir. But I think that's evidence just of how much people are hungry for fact-checks and that type of accurate information.

So in the first five months of this year, we've had more than three million views, huge, huge numbers. And the average number of readers this year is more than double what it was in 2017. So we're cutting through somewhere. That information is increasingly getting out.

Okay. That's good news. And I think in terms of impact, yes, we need to get that correct information out to people. And clearly we're reaching bigger audiences.

We also need to hold the politicians to account. And we are saying that although some politicians are repeating incorrect information time and time again over time, we have seen them start adjusting their behavior after they've been treated. Okay. I'm going to go to you, Anne, one second.

But this is Michael. Let's presume, and this is a plug for the conversation, let's presume the conversation's read a revenue drive is wildly successful. And you bring in $30 million. How much is that successful?

That would be successful. How much would you spend on improving crack checking? Well, with an amount of money like that, it would be great to spend a decent chunk of it. So what would you do?

Well, I am more people. I think the answer to fact checking is resources. Because it's a really resource-intensive form of journalism to do. And I can't speak for all media organizations, but I think that might be why we don't see as much of it across the media landscape as we might like to.

I mean, imagine if someone like, imagine if seven news had a fact checking unit and then every day on the news they could have a truth-tellerman layer of the day. They did when I ran for any fact for them. Well, there you go. And I tell you what happened at the end of the 2013 election that the channel seven news said, we don't need fact checking anymore.

And I said, why not? They said, well, the election's over. And I said, what? Politicians have stopped lying.

Well, that's a good point. And it's a real shame to hear people sort of seeing it as something to view in those terms. But yeah, just to come back to, I mean, the more people you can have in a unit checking facts and the more you can do it, the quicker you can turn stuff around. And there's that old catchphrase about the truth.

What is it nonsense around the world before? Yeah. Often it can take a week to check something that somebody just throws out as a line on Q&A on Monday night. So being able to do things fast and still just as rigorously as they need to be done is a big challenge.

I'm going to bounce off to it. Listen, then, the last one is going to be with Anne. Do you think A.I is the answer to that? It's not the answer, but it is part of the answer.

Is that what you were about to say? No, I was about to say something about the choir. OK, go on, tell us about the MC choir. That's a little bit unfair, perhaps, to Australians, assuming that they are all one way or all the other.

I think there are a lot of Australians who maybe undecided about what they think about politics or politicians or move between each election. And those people, I think, are hungry for the facts and do want to take on the facts. OK, fair point. The final question is with you.

How do we make everyone all the lecture? How do we improve? How do we rise the level of literacy about facts, and verification, and misinformation in the Australian public? So we have a less toxic election in three years' time.

Oh, well, it's multi-prolonged. I mean, I think you've got to start this in school with media literacy and news literacy. Teenagers are amazed when online influencers are getting paid to be telling them these things. They don't even realise that.

I mean, so the basic news literacy media literacy there, and understanding of what actually is the difference between journalism and promotion and what is the role. But I wrote a media article recently called Less Elephants More Ants, and so it basically means more journalists, the journalists are the ants, you know, with apologies to elephants now. That was because I'd just been in Indonesia and listening to UNESCO and the issues that they had there with media ownership and elephants, so the media owners and the pressures that are happening. And we have this in Australia as well, instead of more ants, more journalists doing the work.

And we need a more salient message with the fact checks, with the verification, and it's got to hit in social media as well, and it's got to be in those news feeds, and people have to bump into that as well. Okay, wonderful. There's one for the ants. We're very proud on this show.

That's all we've got time for. We've been talking to Linda Biman from the RMIT ABC Fact Check. It's such a long title. That's us.

Yeah, and it's not short of a much shorter APAC boss on the first graph news, and Michael Hopkins acting editor of Fact Check at the conversation. Michael, you're returning to your day job after this, or what's the plan? I will be returning to my day job as the environment and energy editor, and there are plenty of facts to check in that area, so I'll still be keeping a close eye on the police. Okay, and just a hand, I've had a Fact Check update on the contribution from tonight's panel, and they were found to be correct and trustworthy.

Well done, panel. All green. Thank you. Thank you so much for listening to The Fourth Estate.

This edition was recorded at the studios at 2SCR and heard across the country on the community radio network. Make sure you subscribe to Fourth Estate on your favorite podcast app, so you can hear us talk about the media and politics and a few things between at your leisure. We'll be back next week with more, but in the meantime, you can stay in touch with us on Twitter, where our handle is, Fourth Estate AU. Thanks to researcher, Julia Katsal, thanks to my producer, my name is Peter Frey, and thank you very much for listening.

A safer Ontario means more police and prosecutors making sure my card doesn't get stolen. It means building new jails to keep criminals behind bars. And it means there's no need to wear me when I play at the park. We're making every corner of Ontario safer to make all of Ontario safer.

That's how we protect Ontario. For all of us. Learn how at Ontario.ca.ca. Pay for Ontario.

Pay for it by the Government of Ontario.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Fourth Estate?

This episode is 39 minutes long.

When was this Fourth Estate episode published?

This episode was published on May 23, 2019.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Fourth Estate episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.