This episode is brought to you by Octavia. You might already be eating yogurt, but not all yogurts are created equal. Octavia contains over 1 billion probiotics per serving to survive and reach the gut alive. When it comes to gut health, Octavia is the number one family doctor recommended probiotic yogurt brand.
Choose Octavia. Feel good from the inside out. Visit Octavia.ca for more details. Hello and welcome back to Fourth Estate, a show about journalism.
We're coming to you from 2SCR in Sydney on the Gadigal lands of the Eora nation, right across Australia on the community radio network and directly to your device across the globe via podcast. I'm Tina Quinn and as always it's a pleasure to have your company. Freelance journalists are a crucial part of the media industry. We're seeing many journalists work as freelancers, some proactively and others in response to the casualization of media work.
In fact, in 2022's Australian Media Landscape Report by MediaNet, it found that many journalists stated that they either freelance on top of their regular employment for additional income or are considering doing this in the coming year. There are benefits to creating independently and flexibly, however Freelance workers often insecure and has less protection. The media and entertainment arts alliance found over 60% of freelancers and less than half the average weekly Australian wage. So how has freelancing changed and what can the Fourth Estate do to support them?
To discuss this and more, we're joined by Katherine Boris. She's a freelance journalist and editor. Her work has appeared in the Centre Day paper in Junky, the City Morning Herald and pedestrian TV. That's just to name a few.
Katherine also created the Young Australian Writers' Facebook group, the space for young writers to network, gain advice and learn about the industry. Katherine, are warm welcome to Fourth Estate. Thanks so much for having me. And Bianca No Gradius also with us.
She's a freelance science journalist, broadcaster and author. Her work has appeared in outlets like The Atlantic, The Scientist, Australian Geographic and The BBC. She's also the founding president of the Science Journalists Association of Australia. Bianca, welcome to Fourth Estate.
Great to be here. Thank you. So I'm going to jump right in. What do you both enjoy about freelance journalism and what attracted you to becoming a freelancer in the first place?
Kathy, I'm going to go to you first. Well, what I enjoy, I guess, is the flexibility. So, prior to the pandemic, freelance journalism was one of the only ways to do journalism while also working from home or travelling, like being a given time man, for example. And also for working in and around other jobs or four times study, which was what I was doing in my case.
Bianca, what about yourself? I love the flexibility and the variety of freelancing. So, particularly being a science and health journalist, there's not really a lot of outlets in Australia that will certainly not have to sustain the right for outlets around the world. I get to write about a huge diversity of subjects and for a range of different editors and audiences.
I like that I've been able to work from home, work around having two kids. Yeah, the independence is really good for me. Kathy, can you tell us about the Young Australian Writers' Facebook group? What motivated you to create the group and what sort of resources are available through it?
Yeah, so I created the group in 2016 after writing an article about coming at age online in a particular era where first-person essays were particularly encouraged, especially from younger writers who made an attitude to experience. So, basically, how I saw it was editors are being pressured to find a very unique, it happened to me, type stories. And this would result in relatively young and different experience writers, you know, bearing their souls for all of like 50 American dollars, type things. And so, I wrote a front outlet which is to function now, but it was at Fairfaxville, the vocal and their whole thing was basically encouraging people to look for ways to implement change.
And so my editor was like, well, like how can you as an individual, like kind of address this issue of young writers being exploited? And I was like, like make like an online community. And so I did. And now 60s later, it has 8,500 members.
And yeah, so it's definitely grown over the years. And resources, well, like anyone can post an ask for advice and there's just a really good like brain stress going on in there. There's also like a job for everyone to share jobs. Like basically the group itself kind of serves as a board for people to share opportunities or pass on opportunities that they've been approached with, but can't take up.
It really provides an amazing space for for aspiring writers and journalists. Through that Facebook group or that Facebook page, you created a space for freelance writers to be able to connect and Bianca, you do a lot of networking with freelancers and science journalists. Why do you think it's important for freelance journalists to have a community network at Bianca? I'll go to you.
It's so important and the Science Generalist Association of Australia, even though obviously we have a mix of in-house of freelancers, a lot of the interaction will actually, I should say, in people who are working in house of science journalists, they're often one of the few, if not the only, science journalists working within their organization, within their newsroom. And so, you know, if they want to have a big no doubt about some weird kind of biological phenomena, then we like to think that we provide the forum for where they're going to be surrounded by like-minded nerds, and we can all kind of no doubt about it together. But I think especially for freelancers, we don't have that supportive network, I'm assuming that newsroom is a supporter, but I've never worked in one. So that may be a dangerous assumption, but having that supportive network of people to encourage you to help you make your work better, to bounce ideas off, to share tips with, you know, that's really important for journalists generally, I think, to have that.
And particularly with freelancers, we're all dealing with these whole set of other challenges around word rates, around dealing with editors and pay and accounts departments at different publications, and even just something like dealing with what's a WAB inform that I've just been asked to fill out by this US publication. And so I keep posting a group of those, anyone know what the hell this is? And it's that, I mean, I think it's a fantastic environment. It's certainly the most collegial kind of professional environment I've ever encountered, even having worked within a publication, medical publication.
And freelancers, we do talk. And so I think it's something that just sometimes forgets is that freelancers talk, and we network and we share information, and that really makes it stronger individually. Earlier this year, the MEAA developed a charter of rights for freelance journalists, which it's going to be used to pursue collective agreements with media outlets that outline minimum rates of pay and deadlines for payment. Bianca, can you tell us about that charter?
Yes. So I have to say upfront that I haven't been involved in the development of this, and I think there's been some phenomenal work by people at the MEAA, for example, frame Malloy and Marissa Wicram and I'll probably thinking of this whole plot of other people who I can't remember their names, but who've really put years and years and years of work into trying to actually bolster the rights of freelancers, bolster the recognition amongst editors and publishers that freelancers are important. We are worthy of respect. We deserve respect.
We deserve to be treated the same as in-house staff. And not only that, also recognizing that freelancers aren't just journalists who aren't in the office, we are also running our own businesses. We're dealing with all the sort of things that, you know, and publishers, accounts, departments, takes care of or in-house legal teams or whatever. So it's about acknowledging freelancers.
And I mean, the collective bargaining aspect has always been problematic because we're all viewed as sole traders. And so there are, I think, laws in Australia that actually make it very difficult for freelancers to bargain collectively. And so this charter, I think, really overcomes those by really setting out what freelancers expect from editors and publishers. And, you know, it's not a lot.
It's really just we would like to be paid kind of decent rates. We would like to be paid shortly after publication, if not on, you know, preferably even an acceptance of copy. We would like to be paid within a certain timeframe after that. We'd like to be paid on time.
It's a really big one. You know, we would like to not be forced into contracts that require us as these individual sole traders to identify a giant publishing company against any kind of legal action that might stem from an article that we actually have no control over after we submit it. You know, there's a huge number of, I guess, challenges that freelancers face, which I suspect most editors and publishers don't realize or even an issue. I mean, I've chased a payment for six months, $150 payment for six months, just simply because people just kept forgetting to put the invoice in them.
And they kept doing, you know, and I think, you know, if you're a publisher, if you want to advertise, it doesn't pay up. You go after them. You don't just let money slide. And as freelancers, we're individuals.
We've got, we've got, you know, there's no buffer zone here. There's no big bank account that we can kind of insulate ourselves against a late payment. We still have to pay bills on time as well. So all of those considerations need to be kept in mind.
And I think really what this charter does is spell those out for editors and publishers. And hopefully, you know, we just want equal recognition. We just we don't want to be treated as kind of this outsourcing afterthought that we are actually, we are actually a pillar of Australian journalism and we need to be acknowledged as such. There's often a lot of questions among freelancers about freelance rights and payments as you've just referenced.
What's your advice to other freelancers about getting paid fairly and knowing what is a fair payment? That's a really tricky one to answer. I would say to general, all Australian word rates are pretty appalling compared to international. You know, it's often one of the first questions I get asked when I've run kind of workshops and freelancing people say, what should I charge?
And my answer is generally whatever the editor is going to pay you. But because, you know, it's pretty rare in some ways to negotiate upfront, not impossible. There's not a bargaining power, basically. There's not a lot of bargaining power, particularly when you're starting out with the publication.
And I also say this is somebody who's terrible at asking for more money, but leaving that aside. You know, I think it's, you know, the freelance charter, I believe it doesn't specify a minimum rate, but you know, it's hard to put a figure. I'm interested to know what Kathy thinks. But to my mind, you know, Australian rates, if you're only less than 70 cents a word for, you know, a piece that's professionally written, it's not something that, you know, kind of an AI could knock out, then I think you're being underpaid.
I mean, we deliver a service that's professional service. We bring to that experience and skill and discipline. And, you know, that should not be devalued in the same way that anybody working in houses subject to kind of wage negotiations and I can't think of what the term is, but you know, contracts that set minimum wage. So we deserve the same.
Kathy, what's your take on that? I mean, how do you have any good advice for other freelancers about getting paid fairly and securing of their payment? And, you know, as Bianca's just referenced, when it comes to bargaining power, do you feel like, you know, the bulls not exactly in your court? Yeah, I do feel like freelancers are at a disadvantage because it's very difficult to kind of act collectively, although the union is doing this, uh, pre-lensors especially with regards to the Guardian, for example.
But my attractive advice, I would say, sniff around, try and find out like what other people have been paid by that outlet so you can gauge whether they're like trying to maybe take you for a ride or not. I mean, I think most editors are operating in the States, but sometimes they're external pressures that put them in a tough spot. But yeah, so I'd say... To be a business model, I guess, yeah.
Yeah, so I'd say like, the MeArt collects rates, so that information is all on their website. You can also like use Twitter or just like talk to people. You can also do my group. But yeah, I would definitely say try and find out what other people have been paid by that outlet.
And also, I mean, just be upfront with the editor, like, how much, what can you pay? You're listening to Fourth Estate on the Community Radio Network. This week we're talking about freelance journalism with Bianca Nogradi and Katherine Boras. When it comes to strengthening the mindset as a freelancer, that you're basically running your own business.
You are your own business. You're your own boss. I guess your own accountant. I guess you're not your own...
You're not exactly payroll. But how do you sort of strengthen that mindset and take that sort of ownership? Bianca, I'll go to you. That's an interesting one.
My experience is it's kind of fairly straightforward once you get those systems in place. You just to start with, there's all of these kind of fundamental things you do. Maybe you get a good accountant or you at least learn how to use an accountant, good business and accounting software. Understand the tech system and make sure that you're not going to do anything that's going to land you in court.
That side of things, I think once you sort of get the principles established, then it, I wouldn't say, takes care of itself and I'm conscious of the fact that at the end of financial years, just roll by and that I probably had a hell of a lot of paperwork to manage. But it's not too arduous. For running your own business, it's not too arduous. I think the sort of running your own business disadvantages are around things like a sick leave, like a holiday pay, lack of superannuation being covered, lack of no severance pay, there's the insurance issue is a massive one, that kind of identity insurance.
So it's more things like that that if you're working in a house at a publisher, those are taken care of. You know, you know that you're going to get a certain amount of holiday each year and you're going to get paid during that time to take that holiday. You know, you know that if you're sick, you can take time off and you're not going to lose you. Well, maybe you will lose your job.
I guess these things are a little unstable at the moment. So it's those kind of things I think are, for me, certainly the biggest challenge with freelancing is that there's no safety net here. If I get sick and if I get really sick and I can't work, then I, there's no money. There's nothing that comes in and, you know, similarly taking holidays off is really, really hard.
So if those disadvantages, I think that I am most evident, but I have to say they are more than outweighed by the advantages and the perks of being a freelancer. Do you agree with that, Cathy? Yeah, I'd say having to be your own boss kind of, like, along with yourself can make things difficult, which is why I appreciate spaces like my group and organizations like me offer trying to do more to help freelancers work collectively. But even then you still have to deal with everything you have to describe on your own.
My biggest issue is knowing when to switch off, especially if you're working with American publications. Like I've had to have having a few fun calls like 11.30 p.m. my time, because it's 9.30 a.m. in New York.
And it's the only time that there's like really in the crossover that works in both of us. That sort of thing, like doing work on weekends when I probably shouldn't be. That sort of thing. Trigger.
Trigger. I think you can relate to that, I'm sure Bianca. How has freelance journalism do you think changed over the last five years? Have we seen an increase or decline in freelancers?
And do you think many journals are purposely choosing freelancing or joining as a response to precarious employment? Again, I tricky one to say. My gut feeling is I mean, I certainly do see an increase in freelance writers for an ex-journalist in the science and health space. And I think that's partly a response to just lack of outlets in Australia, which mean that there's basically very, very few in-house jobs.
And those that do exist are highly sought after. So if you want to be a science and health journalist in Australia, for the most part, freelancing is actually your best option at this point in time. And also having said that, I think it's a really good option. It's a really great niche to freelancing because there are so many specialist publications around the world.
And it's just a great niche. I feel like I've certainly steered more than a few people in the direction of freelancing. So if I'm nobody's come back up with a baseball bat, I take that to be positive sign. But in terms of mainstream, we've seen so many redundancies in newsrooms, and which is just such a sad loss of journalism talent in Australia.
And I think a lot of those people I think have gone and pursued different careers, maybe they've gone into comms or academia or who knows a number of professions. And I suspect that this is probably a global issue. I mean, we have seen so many closures of small local newspapers, newsrooms, regional publications that I mean, yeah, there's also perhaps less demand from publishers at least for content. But then we also have the rise of online publishing.
Kathy, do you think media and editors have a role in supporting freelancers? And what role is it? Yeah, I think I do. And I think a lot of them do a great job in my experience talking to friends who I think a lot of them put in difficult positions, my budget constraints and all that.
Yeah, I think they do have a responsibility to do the best by their freelancers, like try and ensure the rates aren't completely depressing. Ideally, I guess I have a responsibility to get back to everyone, but that's not always feasible. But if they can respond briefly with just a polite rejection, that sort of thing. So people aren't left hanging and they can quickly shop the piece around, especially if it's a news piece.
That sort of thing. Can I jump in as well? There's something else I feel that it's with freelancers, because we're being paid by the word, we're not being paid by the word, most of the time we've been paid by the word, not by the amount of time that we put into a thing. And so I've had situations where it's sort of a 300 word news story and I've ended up doing 10 interviews for it.
And it's a huge amount of work because the editor keeps like, oh, can you check this out? Can you check this out? And I think there maybe does need to be a little bit of understanding. Like it doesn't happen often, but a little bit of understanding that perhaps the dynamic, the way that freelancers work is a bit different, or not a different, but it's sort of that idea that there's really high effort, low rate, low return pieces.
Ideally, those should be done in house. I'm sure in house, I'm sure in house, Joe, and I was like, no, God, please, we don't want to be enough. But that's very difficult to really kind of make money on the sense that the amount of effort that goes into a store like that is disproportionately high relative to the amount of payment. And I think this also comes down to experience as a freelancer and being able to kind of look at a brief and go, you know what, I can't do that for the amount of money that you want to pay me.
It just is not viable when I know that I could work for that same amount of time and make three times as much. So it's sort of that idea that we are also an independent business. And so we do have to make a profit that sounds very hard, hard and catalyst, but we do have to make a profit. So I think there's also a need to be maybe a little bit of more understanding of what it means, and it comes back to that idea of understanding that we are also running a business.
Do you have any advice for how freelance journalism can become more financially sustainable here in Australia? Bianca? Pay us better. That'd be great.
Yeah, look, I think it really just comes down to better pay conditions, but also not just pay, but also conditions as well. We hear stories about freelancers who are kind of commissioned to do stories, but then they're not treated with respect by editors. They work as a treated with respect by editors. Everything gets changed and rewritten with no consultation.
And I know that happens in house as well, but we're not in the office. We don't have the opportunity to go and look at the pages or see things as they kind of float past. We're not there on the spot to be able to make sure that our work is good. It's not being altered to introduce errors, for example.
So I think we do really need editors to perhaps work with us a little bit more and keep those lines of communication perhaps open a little bit more than they might do. We're not just sitting at a desk next door, and I recognise that everybody's been working for home for the last two and a half years, but I think that would be really useful to just have that understanding. And the other issue, which I keep banging on about is just payment times. They can be really, really long when you do a story that for publications got a lead time of four months and then they pay you two months after it goes to print.
That's six months before you see a cent. And so something like, for example, in New York, there's the freelance isn't free act where I think any kind of freelance work has to be paid within 30 days of acceptance of work. And something it's so simple and it's so small that gosh, it would make a world of difference. When you know you've got a situation where I've had $25,000 in invoices out there in the world waiting to come in and the credit cards are maxed out and all of these bills are coming in.
And you know, it is going to come in, but you also know it's just working its way through the bowels of the accounting department. And you've got no way of speeding that process up. So yeah, I mean, it's that would be really great if they could be an understanding that freelancers, well, like any small business contractors really do need to be paid promptly and as quickly as possible. Cathy, what about yourself?
Are there any sort of challenges specific to freelance journalists that they're facing that you'd like to see more attention and advocacy towards? So I definitely second time I've heard of publications in Australia that take several months from data publication to pay and that just isn't acceptable. I think 30 days is kind of a max before you're just kind of being unfair and not respecting the person's time and work. I think things like the Freelances and Free Act are really good.
I think what me does is good, but the way the union approaches things just because it's how they've always done it is they approach things on an outlet by outlet basis. And I guess that's the most practical way they found to affect change, but things like the Freelances and Free Act in New York and California, like they're from the top down today, apply to everyone. I think changes like that would be really good because some outlets are just quite resistant to union involvement. What's the practical advice that each of you would give to other Freelances, be younger to you first?
Well, first I'd say do it. Just do it and aim high. If you've got a great story and you think, you know what? I'd really love to be published in the New York Times more than monthly or the Griffith Review or the Atlantic.
Just do it shoot for the moon because you never know. Certainly I often find that I think maybe Freelances or the sectorically, women Freelances probably underestimate themselves and their ideas. So I kind of always encourage people to actually know who just sees the day. Because this is the wonderful thing about being a Freelances is that you can pitch the New York Times.
You can pitch these incredible outlets and it might just be your day. And then seeing your name with a byline in a publication like that is just the best feeling ever. And I think the other thing that I, which probably goes a little bit towards what you were asking earlier, is to just say, yeah, Freelances journalists, first and foremost are journalists. And it's interesting because a lot of the surveys put Freelances journalists in a different category to journalists.
It's like, I have journalists and then they have Freelances journalists. No, we're journalists. We're just not based in-house. First and foremost, we are journalists and we want to do journalism.
We want to do good journalism. We want to do interesting journalism. And certainly, happily in the sights and health arena, there's so many opportunities to do that. And that's one of the reasons why I love this and I have been doing it for nearly 20 years and I suspect I will still be doing it on my deathbed.
But yeah, it is a really great career path. It's tough. And I also must acknowledge that I have a set of privileges that mean that I have been able to make my way in this. I've had safety nets.
And I kind of recognize that it can be really difficult if you don't have those safety nets and you don't have those privileges. And I would love to see that change. I would love to see there be more support for Freelances from people of color, from refugee backgrounds, from marginalized backgrounds, disadvantaged backgrounds. I would love there to be more support, but mean that we can actually have a more diverse freelance journalist population in Australia.
And yeah, I do hope that that will happen. And for example, besides General Association of Australia, we run a grants program and so we've been able to give out $9,000 worth of grants this year for reporting and professional developments. And I think programs like that really, I hope, help to give more freelance journalists just that little leg up that so many of us need, particularly at the start of our careers. Kathy?
I'm probably biased, but I think my best piece of advice would be to find a community, whether it's young Australian writers or the science writers association or in America, they've got study hall or if it's a union. Just find a community, like even on Twitter, but find other writers you can consider it with. So you can, we ask if you can find opportunities with, so you can ask like a citizen or a K with, yeah, I'd say that absolutely helps. Because otherwise freelancing can be feel at least quite isolating at times.
And it doesn't need to be. It doesn't have to be. And I think it should be. So yeah, find a community, find other people in your position and make room.
Well, on that note, I'd like to thank both of my guests today on Fourth Estate, Bianca Nogrady. Thank you so much, Ben, lovely to be here. And Catherine Poress. Yes, so much.
And thank you for listening to Fourth Estate. This edition was recorded at the studios of Tua-Zia and heard across the country on the community radio network. Fourth Estate is produced with the assistance of the Community Broadcasting Foundation, a big thanks to the Foundation for their continuing support. Make sure you subscribe to Fourth Estate on your favourite podcast app, so you can hear us talk about media, politics and a lot in between.
We'll be back with more next week, of course. But in the meantime, you can stay in touch with us on Twitter. Our handle is Fourth Estate AU. A big thanks to my producer, Marlene Evern and executive producer Anthony Dockrell.
I'm Tina Quinn. Please do stay well, stay safe and catch us next week on Fourth Estate.