Skip to content
FBI Interviews & The Cheetham's episode artwork

Dec 16, 2019 20 min

FBI Interviews & The Cheetham's

from Montana Murder Mysteries Hosted by NonStop Local

While we work through some technical difficulties, we bring you an inside look on our recent interview with former FBI agents currently working on unsolved cases in Montana.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

FBI Interviews & The Cheetham's

0:00 20:09
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Welcome everyone to this edition of Montana Murder Mysteries. I'm Angela Marshall. And I'm Blake Simonson. So, you've probably figured out by the episode title that this is not the Murdered Priest Part 2, as promised last week. Well, if you watch our evening news, then you know that our stations have actually been hit by a cyber attack. It happened Monday, very early in the morning. Luckily, no data has been taken from us. Luckily, but we have been locked out of the system, folks, that really help us do our jobs for you.

And that includes the very system that allows us to create our Montana Murder Mysteries podcast for you every week. Yep. And part of that lockout means that I can't access the weeks of research that I put together for the Father Kerrigan and Murdered Priest case. So I'm going to need a little bit of time to get all of that back together and rewrite a script and everything. But in the meantime, we appreciate your patience. And this week, we are looking forward to doing things a little bit differently. That's right. We're actually replaying for you a cold case that we reported on back in September. Blake did it with Kate Whittle.

It was about the mysterious double murder of a Washington state couple near Lake Inez in the Swan Valley back in 1991. Now, this past April, the Missoula County Sheriff's Office announced that two retired federal agents are now offering a fresh perspective and really invaluable experience to uncover new information on the deaths of Kenneth and Ivar LaRue Cheatham. To help gather more information about this cold case, the Missoula County Sheriff's Office also teamed up with the A&E television network show Live PD. The Cheatham cold case was featured on November 30th in front of a national audience. And the Cheatham's grandchildren, is it Ashley LaFranchi?

Yes, that's how you say it, LaFranchi. And Jacob Skilton were interviewed. Now, I also had the opportunity to just recently sit down with a federal agent, as well as a Missoula County Sheriff's Detective Captain, to find out the latest on the investigation into this nearly 30-year-old cold case. And folks, we'll reveal more about what they have to say in upcoming episodes of Montana Murder Mysteries. Just pulling each little thread will hopefully bring us to some new place.

Welcome to Montana Murder Mysteries, brought to you by ABC Fox Montana. We'll take you inside unsolved homicide cases under the big sky and learn where the investigations stand today. I'm Kate Whittle. And I'm Blake Simonson. This week, we explore the case of two tourists found dead near Lake Inez in Swan Valley nearly two decades ago as their case is reopened this year by two retired FBI agents. All right, so Blake, I'm going to set the scene here. So the year is 1991. And is it Ivy or Iva LaRue? Iva. Iva LaRue. Iva LaRue. And I got the impression she had kind of two first names, like Iva LaRue Cheatham.

Yes. Was my understanding of that? Yeah, she went by Iva LaRue. Yes, okay. And her husband, Kenneth. And it looked like there was a little bit of an age difference there. In pictures of them, she looks a little bit younger than he does, or maybe she dyed her hair. I don't know. Don't we all? Yeah, so in the picture of the two together, they obviously went into either Walmart or the mall and had a glamour shot taken. Remember when you used to actually go somewhere to have your photo taken? It was gorgeous. The one that's on my parents' mantle right now, my dad has a really nice mullet, and my mom's kind of matches. Oh, wow, that's lovely. All of ours are terrible because when my mom tried to take me and my brother and sister to get our pictures taken when we were little.

My brother would like cry and hide from the photographer. So all of the pictures by mom looks really bad. So anyway, Iva LaRue and Kenneth posed for a photo. They look like happy people. And they were from Washington and tootling around in a little 1969 Ford van. And they were on a road trip and heading up to meet family in Glacier National Park. We heard stories from all three of their adult children about how lovely these people were and how much they enjoy traveling.

Unfortunately, they never made it to their destination. They never made it to meet their family. The Billings Gazette said that the couple was last seen at Stoney's Quick Shop in Clearwater Junction on July 30th. I've never been to... Oh, that's the one with the big cow outside of it. Is it? Yeah, and I don't know how long the big cow has been out there, but presumably that big cow has been out there for... Is it a bull? I think it's a bull. I think it's a bull. Okay, you can write it if I got it wrong. I mean, I've never looked at it that closely. It's a big cow outside of the road. Anyway, so... So six days after they were last seen at the...

So they were last seen at Clearwater Junction July 30th. Correct. And disappeared. Yes. It wasn't until six days later that their van was found. And it was found at the end of kind of a new logging road that was west of Lake Ulva.

And when investigators went and looked at it, they actually found Iva's purse and it had all been dumped out. But the interesting thing is that none of her checks or credit cards were taken. That's super weird. Also, remember when we used to carry checks around? What are you talking about back when? I still do. Okay, I mean, I guess I do. So at this point, it's what, early August in 1991. They're missing and their van has been found. They were not discovered, their bodies were not discovered until a month later. And their bodies were actually discovered two miles south along Highway 83 by a guy who's out walking his dog near, is it Lake Inez or Inaz?

I've always pronounced Inaz, but someone will write us and tell us we're wrong. Someone will absolutely tell us that we're wrong. But, and I don't actually know this particular chain of the lakes super well. I know Sealy Lake and I know Salmon Lake. I'm from Idaho, so that's all very... If you're from Idaho, so your opinion doesn't count. Correct. But yeah, so then a month later, so I want to say that was early September that the Cheatham's bodies were found. And they had both been shot. Now, Kenneth was shot once in the chest, and Iva LaRue was shot once in the head. Right, and...

An article from The Mazoolian actually said that the shell casings that they found around the bodies suggested that it was a 9mm used to kill the Cheetums. Weird. And so the case went cold for quite a few years. My understanding is that there wasn't really too many new clues in that. But this year, just in April of this year, Missoula County Sheriff's Office reopened with hopes that advances in technology and some new staff could help solve this crime. And I'm going to go on a little tangent about DNA testing for a moment because I had to look this up. Because DNA testing was available in 1991, but the kind of testing that we use today where they compare it against databases of DNA wasn't really developed then. It's still kind of in its infancy even now. The first DNA analysis for crime had started just in the 1980s.

Conviction based on DNA evidence was just in 1987. Pretty recent to all of this. And then one of the second most, the second big conviction based on DNA evidence was a Virginia killer named the Southside Strangler. No one gives them names like that anymore. No, I think that's actually because by giving them catchy names in the media was seen as a way of making them famous and kind of. Oh yeah, that totally glamorizes. Glamorize them and brought about more copycats, I guess. That's why the media has stopped naming them like that. That totally makes sense.

But yeah, back to DNA evidence. I mean, to this day, DNA evidence is not this perfect thing, you know, like CSI, where they're like, okay, it's been 24 hours and we got a DNA match. Because I grew up watching CSI. Same. Like early 2000s, and I was like a preteen to teen. Like, yeah, that was my jam. Something I do want to recommend for people if they haven't seen it is called Exhibit A on Netflix. Have you watched it? Oh, it's amazing. Yeah, it's really good because it's a look at...

Where forensics, you know, really can't always have the right answer. Right. Well, all of these technologies are still being developed. And it's not magic, which a lot of people think that it is. You know, scientists still make mistakes sometimes. And we're still learning to understand all these new technologies and advancements that have been made and all of this. And the science is only as good as the scientists doing it. And sometimes people and science can be manipulated to give an answer. Oh, absolutely.

So, yeah, so I do recommend Exhibit A. Netflix has not paid us to promote that. Just want to note that. Unfortunately. But back to our Iva and Kenneth situation. So authorities are still hoping that someone can step forward with a vital clue involved in the case. And it's a very retro piece of equipment. So in a press conference, this.

Last April. Just this April. Just this April. The Missouli County Sheriff's Office announced that two retired FBI agents would actually be joining their team specifically to look over unsolved murder cases in Montana, which this was huge at the time when they announced it. Yeah. And I think we're going to listen to a little bit of audio from that press conference, I believe. I'd like to introduce Diana Parker and Susan Lane. Each agent took the stand to introduce themselves. The first voice you're about to hear is from Diana Parker. I spent my career with the FBI.

various offices, but primarily most of the time was spent in the Albuquerque Division. And I worked on a violent crime squad, mostly Indian country, violent crime. And I was on a cold case task force working in cold cases and missing persons cases with local and state law enforcement in New Mexico. My background is, I started with the U.S. Customs Service. And you are? Susan Lane. So I started with the U.S. Customs Service as a special agent criminal investigator with them, and that became Homeland Security Investigations. So most of my investigative experience is related to transnational organized crime. I've had general investigative...

aspects and capabilities. And kind of, I think my role in helping out on this is more on the technical side. So with the two retired FBI agents joining the team, they've gotten to look over all of the old evidence and look at all the old interviews and everything. And some new-ish leads came to light. So they set their sights on the couple's van and then what was inside of it. It is possible the van was moved to this location by a person or persons not associated with the homicides. A Hitachi video camera and case was stolen from the victim's van, either by the killer, killers, or possibly by individuals who moved the van.

Now, the sheriff's office is specifically searching for a Hitachi Model VM 5200A video camera. I actually looked this up because you can find these on eBay, which is where I looked up and found pictures of it. It definitely looks a lot like the old video camera that my family had that us kids grew up playing with. And don't worry, like, that is not the video camera associated with this crime. I'm not incriminating myself. My parents bought it when I was a baby, well before these people were murdered. And I was actually just thinking about how that video camera that my parents bought, us kids made home movies with, up until we were, like, I don't know, until I was, like, 15. Because, like, stuff, electronics just continued to work.

after you bought them, which is crazy. You know, I have like phones from six years ago that don't work anymore, but that, if you turn on my parents' video camera, a VHS video camera, it would still work right now, which is crazy. Oh, well, all those like Nokia phones, we're like, we're gonna find them as fossils and they're still gonna work. Oh yeah, your old flip phone, that will still turn on. Your iPhone from two years ago. Your iPhone 7, that's not gonna turn on in like six months, but. Anyway, after that digression, now we do have a little bit of a hint about what may have happened to the Hitachi video camera that was stolen from the Cheathams.

Yeah, so actually the Billings Gazette reported that sometime after the murders, a strap from the camera that Missoula County Sheriff is currently looking for, that strap was found on Highway 80 near Geraldine. Geraldine? Yeah, I believe that's it. Talk about needle in a haystack. I don't know how anyone found a strap from a camera by the side of the road 200 miles away from this scene. 200 miles. Geraldine, I had to look this up. It's in Choteau County, which is the C-H-O-U.

T-E-A-U. So not Choteau the town. Not the same as the town. One U. Choteau County that has two U's. I'm probably somehow mispronouncing Choteau County. Is one Choteau? Or is someone going to get mad at me for saying that? I don't know. I'm from Idaho and it blew my mind when I moved to Montana and there was the county and the town that they were like, it's not the same. I was forced to memorize all the counties and county seats growing up in a small Montana high school. And I forget this difference all the time. So apologies to Central Montana listeners. The first time I pronounced Mar as meager.

Oh, classic. But people love to correct you on that, even though, like, obviously you would get it wrong. See, I do that now all the time to newcomers. I'm like, it's Mar. Yeah. Thanks for staying with us, everyone. So, like, tell me about what we know about this camera strap and a suspect in Geraldine. So, as far as I know, they weren't actually able to connect the strap to any one particular person, but they did end up questioning a guy who was known to be in the Geraldine area around the time of the Cheatham's deaths.

And they just, they never arrested him. Investigators said that they were never really able to place any physical evidence on him. Yeah, definitely one we would love to be able to ask more about who this particular suspect was. Since there's only got to be like four people in the whole Geraldine area. How small is it? I think it's pretty small. Yeah? I mean, Choteau County is definitely one of the lower populated counties in the state.

So as far as our Cheatham case, Blake, you had reached out to Missoula County sheriffs in hopes of talking with the FBI agents, but it sounds like that's going to be no dice for a little while. Yeah, unfortunately, they're not really able to talk about open cases, and since they did reopen it so recently, I can understand why they would want to be a little bit guarded, making sure that they don't necessarily release the new leads and compromise their cases. Yeah, I would make dorky Mulder and Scully references to them and they would be like, OK, I'm over you. But hopefully this means that they're making headway and something can come from it soon. Because, yeah, I was looking over our notes from the press conference that I had watched in April. And they did say that they're reviewing evidence, quote, found on and near the bodies of LaRue and Kenneth, as well as the van. So that's, you know, obviously super interesting, very vague, very intriguing. But just because that's the current information that we have doesn't mean that they're not asking for the public to step forward with anything they might have on this case. Law enforcement.

is aware that there is information that has not been shared. It is sometimes the case that people may have knowledge, don't initially come forward because of their relationship to those involved, concerns for their safety, or they may not realize the information that they have is important. We recognize that relationships change over time, as do people and their perspectives. It's not too late to come forward. So the Hitachi camera that they are looking for, they said that it might have been sold or pawned since then, which would make sense since, you know, it happened so long ago. And those were expensive back then. You know, weren't those like hundreds of dollars? Oh, I imagine so. But they do think, you know, if you're one of those people who knows who has it now or came into possession of it back then.

Police are fully aware that they might not be connected to the murder, but they still do need to know that they had it and came in possession of it so that they can kind of trace back a timeline and make those connections. Even though the camera might be gone, the lead is still there. And so Missoula County Sheriff's Office says if you saw, acquired, or know someone who came into possession of a Hitachi camcorder in the fall or summer of 1991, potentially in the western Montana or central Montana area, I think, you can contact them. You can reach them through, apparently they take tips through Facebook, Twitter, and they have a tip line. That number is 406-258.

33-0-2. Again, that's 258-3302. Thank you so much for joining us on Montana Murder Mysteries. Now, if you like our show, you can help us make more episodes by subscribing and telling your friends. You can find us on Spotify. We got approved for Apple Podcasts. Apple Podcasts, which is cool. So that's like iTunes. Google Podcasts. And Google Podcasts. Very exciting. And then CastBox. Whatever that is. I think one person has listened to us through that, so thank you to that person. Everything counts.

Montana Murder Mysteries is researched and written by Kate Whittle and myself, Blake Simonson, and is produced by Joe Lazar. You can send us your tips and comments through our Facebook page, ABC Fox Montana, and find out more about the cases we're exploring by checking our website. That, again, is abcfoxmontana.com.

4 MT Heads The MT Heads Montana based friends talk about everything from personal, local, and international events and issue's. Admittedly not professionals in any of these areas, just real people talking about real things. Explicit Murder in Miami iHeartPodcasts In the 1980s crime journalist Phil Stanford dove into the decadent and dangerous world of Miami just as the city was becoming the cocaine- and murder- capital of the United States. His path would place him in the crosshairs of a federal investigation focusing on a mysterious and controversial drug smuggling pilot who claimed to be an operative of the American government- all while flaunting his extensive illicit activity. Murder in Miami traces the connection between the murder of a missing Miami private investigator to the sprawling roots of an international money laundering scheme as Stanford tries to make sense of his role in a surreal story of spies, smugglers, killers and corruption. All reaching to the highest levels on both sides of the law. Explicit Suspect Convictions Kast Media Barton McNeil discovers his 3-year-old daughter's lifeless body in her bed the morning after breaking up with his girlfriend. McNeil insists that she was murdered by his former girlfriend after pointing to a cut screen in the bedroom window. Police agree a murder has been committed, but arrest him. Explicit Atlanta Monster iHeartPodcasts and Tenderfoot TV From the producers of Up and Vanished, Tenderfoot TV and iHeartPodcasts present, 'Atlanta Monster.' This true crime podcast tells the story of one of the city’s darkest secrets, The Atlanta Child Murders. Nearly 40 years after these horrific crimes, many questions still remain. Host Payne Lindsey aims to find truth and provide closure, reexamining the disappearance and murder of over 25 African American children and young adults. Explicit

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Montana Murder Mysteries?

This episode is 20 minutes long.

When was this Montana Murder Mysteries episode published?

This episode was published on December 16, 2019.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Montana Murder Mysteries episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.