Hello Roy here, I just wanted to let you know that you can listen to the Roy Green Show ad-free on Amazon Music included with Prime. We're gonna be talking about the study that was done at McMaster University, which shows and suggests very strongly, it's a two-year review by researchers at McMaster of COVID-19 in schools and daycares. It shows that schools and daycares were not a source of significant virus transmission when infection prevention and control measures were engaged. What's the prescription for phone failure, Dr.
Ra? What's the prescription? What would you... It's because it's turning into an infectious disease here.
Well, I succeeded. What's that? At least I succeeded. You did succeed.
Thank you very much for playing ball with us and changing the time of our interview. So I was just saying that through your review by researchers at McMaster University of COVID-19 in schools and daycares, as shown schools and daycares are not a source of significant virus transmission when infection prevention and control measures were engaged. Engaged on this was a study that was published on Thursday in the Lancet Child and Adolescent Health and included more than 34,000 references in child care settings in schools worldwide. You're with us in infectious diseases specialist at Halton Healthcare in Ontario Assistant Professor of Medicine at the University of Toronto.
You repeatedly told us during the pandemic and you wrote up ads on it that disclosing the schools, not the answer. They should listen. I know it's an... I told you so side to this, but I want to reflect a bit on what made people do this.
And the other thing I wanted to reflect on is, are we going to do the same thing again with the next one, say an influenza pandemic. So looking back at the rationale, it was about trying to stop the virus transmission. And the argument went that, wow, if kids are the vector of this virus, even if they're not sick and quiet, but if they are spreading this virus, if we close schools, we are going to somehow stop the circulation of the virus. And by stopping the circulation of the virus, we'll have fewer cases in adults and elder adults, which in turn will protect the health care system from spring.
That's very, very indirect as a way to solve a problem. And it's what Jay Baddatria has called trickle down epidemiology jokingly. But there's an element of truth to it. We were very indirectly putting kids on the ultra sacrifice to try and stop the circulation of the virus amongst a more vulnerable other population to provide this indirect benefit.
The problem with the strategy is that the collateral damage to these kids is phenomenal and is long lasting. And you have kids in their formative years, we're teenagers were trying to finish high school. And who are already potentially vulnerable to being disengaged, you know, with the attention deficit disorder, trouble focusing. And then you create a situation where they can attend school in person and they fall off zoom as their parents are engaged, also working on zoom and they can't really hold their hand and get them back under the computer.
And then the consequences are quite huge after the levels from the pandemic. Some kids last and others lose interest and have their mask or fall backwards or they're cheap and fall backwards and they never recover it. You don't get a retake with parenting. They don't get to retake great 10 11 12 second.
I'm not even discussing other sociological consequences, having poor people unable to work because their kids can't go to school, school doubles as they care for some people, to some degree. So all those things go to do not get taken back. Those are the things that really worried me through code that we were doing some things or a group of people being named the kids, provide an indirect benefit to another group and also to maintain health care capacity, which could have been solved by just improving health care capacity. And then after the vaccine was available, it's even more amazing to be at school closures.
We had a population that was protected by the vaccination from severe disease, even if it didn't stop transmission of the virus. Why did we keep doing it? That's a big question. And then why the disparity between Ontario where I live where we had 360 days of school closures, which is more than any place in Canada, and one of the longest in the world.
And what made that happen? And I think the media isn't part of blame. I use the word media in a very broad way, but some mainstream media outlets covered only one side of the story and didn't allow politicians in the room, the pivot space to change policy. That's my guide, Treb.
Yeah, no, it's good. I mean, I spoke with Dr. Bhattacharya on several occasions and with you and with Dr. Fulford and I read the off heads and we talked about it on the air.
And when I first saw the story about this McMaster study and it was conducted over two year period, I thought, well, that started over two years ago. And so somebody had those thoughts more than two years ago. We better have a look and see whether we did the right thing or not. So there was an element of doubt that really wasn't publicly expressed in the greater arena, don't you think?
Well, it was seen as heresy to say what I said. I faced a calamity for that. There's no question. The interesting thing about this study, it's actually a review of the available literature as it has become available.
So the authors of that. Reasons paper review would say that look, they were analyzing the data that couldn't make decisions in real time and you'll always hear this pandemic fog of war. Defense, you know, we didn't know we were doing, you know, shooting in the dark, etc. It's forgivable to a middle degree before we had a vaccine.
It is absolutely reprehensible that this continued after we had a vaccine and as we knew more about the virus and it's impact on kids. What is concerning to me in that review is that the authors do say that listen, vaccination helps to press transmission and better ventilation helps prevent transmission potentially. That may be true. But what if we had a virus that did spread amongst kids for which we didn't have a vaccine say it was influenza, a new version of influenza and say that we couldn't put the best propeller fans in every single public school, you know, classroom.
Does that mean we then just close the schools again? And my answer is I don't think we should. I think this should be like an essential service. If you keep the crystal open and you keep all the Amazon warehouses open and who keeps coming and grocery stores are open, you're not completely shutting those things down.
Why are we shutting down schools and look at the nefarious consequences for kids after the fact that you don't get to take back? Something that the hamster wheel has to continue. You know, I've opened the phone lines in the past and we've talked to parents about what they see different in their children. After not attending school, after not socializing with their friends after being isolated for almost a year at a time.
And the change in, you know this better than I, I start to people on the air and I talk to people personally as well of course. And parents almost start, one parent actually started to cry about the changes in her children's lives. And she said, how am I going to fix this? And how do, I mean, you're an infectious disease specialist, not a psychologist or psychiatrist, but how do you fix this for the generation that's undergone this?
Yeah, so I speak as a parent, that's a problem. I don't think it's easy. I got lucky as a parent as a single dad. I was able to have a signing focus, but that's not what happened to everybody.
You know, I, the problem is you don't get a second chance at this and you do your best. I think people who are well resourced kids in private school or a stay at home parent, highly educated to kind of take over. They did better. I mean, we didn't even talk about sports training and sports achievements and loss of sports development, physical development, theatrical development, you know, the whole generation of artists or art would be artists who were stunted as well.
I mean, you know, imagine if you're a high level athlete and you can't do your training. They tried to make exceptions, but there was still a bit of this. Let's just stop everything to stop the virus and there's no proportionality. And unfortunately, no one looked at other jurisdictions.
I kept talking about, of course, evil Sweden. And they're not so evil anymore. But I kept talking about Sweden. We even talked about some of the states in the US that were led by Republican governors.
Republican jurisdictions did not close schools to the same degree as Democrat jurisdictions. Dr. Brown, we have to stop here, but this conversation cannot end now. This conversation, this issue doesn't get put to bed with this report from McMaster University.
It has to continue. There has to be something. There has to be a policy that is cast in stone. But this is what we're going to do next time because it's an infectious disease specialist.
You're going to tell me and I'm going to believe you. There will be next time. Leave us a review and tell a friend. I'm Roy Green.
Have a great weekend.