This is Believe. One network, every topic, everywhere. From the Homestead Studios in Santa Clarita, California, this is a Headache Soul production. Welcome to Just the Tipsters, America's favorite true crime podcast. I'm your host, Melissa Morgan. With me today is my handsome and talented co-host, Joshua Lion King Bevan. The Lion King. Because he's always lying about the ladies. I just wanted to say ladies, so I had to find a reason. You don't lie about your ladies. You've got a whole lot of girls. I have a friend who used to wear a shirt out. We would go out.
And his shirt says, I lie to girls. And it was one of the girls would walk up to him and razz him about his shirt. Women are terrible, especially in your age bracket. Well, a little younger. Like, so, okay, let me, I have it broken down coming with, with age and looking back on my twenties where, you know, I was married at 22, divorced at 24. My late twenties were, you know, a time of, you know, whatever you're a kid in my thirties before I met Mark.
I had one or two long-term kind of relationships, but I found myself walking into rooms, parties, and I'd look around and go, that guy looks like he hates women. I'm going to make him mine. And I mean, I call that the 30s. Now, I could be wrong, but I do believe that, you know, I'm giving myself some grace here. I went through a stage of dating comics and musicians, and I knew my love would save them. It did not work. You know what's really fun?
finding someone who's good and kind, who's also good in bed. And that sometimes those two things don't always go together. When you find that, that is when you struck old. So you're saying the good and kind people are a lot of times. Yes. A lot of times the good and kind people are, you know, maybe, maybe they are exciting for someone else, but they didn't jibe with me. I, when I found Mark, I was like, Oh, he's, he's way too nice. Uh, I'll run over him like a lawnmower. And I, and I didn't, and it's, I'm going to say this like crass thing, but what men say about women is, you know, you want a lady in the streets and a whore in the sheets. That's what women want too. Okay. I don't want a lady in the streets. I want a gentleman and I want a fucking monster. Okay. And when you find that, that's.
That's the best. All right. Because it's surprising. Usually someone who's good and kind, you're like, well, this is going to be sweet. And it's like, oh, my ankles are around his ears. This is not the sweet romantic. OK, good. This is the good, hard fucking that, you know. OK, there you go. So that I got it. Take it from the old lady. That librarian fantasy goes both ways. It does. I believe. All right. I believe. I mean, I don't know that many girls who want like somebody who's like, you know, a pimp in the streets and a pimp in the sheets. But, you know, a gentleman, there's something sweet and surprising because I think.
you appreciate my 12 year old inner boy more than most people in my life because we are the same inside. Yes. Yes. You, you appreciate that. I am always shocked when grown men, when I say something, they're like, huh? Oh, like it takes them a second to get. Yeah. Yeah. They don't clutch their pearls. No, but they do, you know, like they took them a minute to get what, you know, that it was a dirty joke. So, and then, and then you find out later, you know, when you're intimate with them, that they're going to flip you like a pancake. You're like, Oh, all right. Oh, okay. So they are, they are just surprised.
in that you that you're coming out with this stuff yes in public yes and that that's how i talk right okay yeah that's i think but then in the bedroom there yeah the door's closed they're they're in charge and i'm you know i'm like oh okay i'm clutching my pearls okay i don't wear pearls i hate pearls but am i kind of on the right track like do boys like that i think boys like someone who's i think boys like i guess i'm gonna say you're different you like a girl who is authentically herself no matter what that means that's it no that's that's totally because i mean i also have a you know, there's, there's a fantasy there of, Oh, I'm corrupting her. Yeah. Okay. That's a good one. Like that's like, she's such, she's such a lady in the streets. And then she, before I got here, she was a lady in the bedroom too, but then. Yeah. And then you turned her into, I like it. Okay, good. That's good. Yeah. I don't know how much that's true. That's probably true. I feel like, I feel like we attract the things that, that we think about, or I don't want to call it like manifesting, but you know, it's, it's yeah. Sometimes you're surprised and sometimes you're disappointed and sometimes you're surprised and sometimes you're, you know, overjoyed. So.
I think the element of surprise is probably the best. Yeah, no, I think you said it exactly. It's the authenticity. If you're aligned with who you are or you're striving to be, you're working on yourself, you're growing, that's the attractive bit. I think you're right. Welcome to our side hustle. Relationships. Relationships. Relationships with Mel and Josh. Oh, boy. Yeah. Okay, Lion King. This is how not to murder.
And kidnap and all of the things. And have a relationship with someone who's a lady in the streets and a wizard in the sheets. So I promised Joshua I would talk about bowling because I love it so much. Also, the first thing I want to say is. I apologize for last week's episode, my beloved tipsters. I was still really sick and I have this problem. I can't ask for help. I put pressure on myself. And when you listen back to it, Joshua, you're going to pee your pants because Joshua, I could, he could feel him like trying to come in and swoop in and help. And you finished some of my sentences and you filled in gaps. I was just a couple of times I had to pause because I was coughing. And I definitely, this is the first day, honest to God, in three weeks, I felt pretty good. I walked siren. I hadn't walked her in weeks because I couldn't, I couldn't breathe. If I would walk too much, I would wheeze.
So I am grateful to antibiotics. Do not, I repeat, do not be a Melissa. If you get sick, any kind of sick, please go get checked out. I waited too long. I was exposed to influenza A and thought, I can get rid of this. I will conquer this. I did not, and it conquered me. And I finally went to urgent care, and by then it had turned into pneumonia. I've never had pneumonia. I don't ever want it again. Grateful for antibiotics. Grateful for inhalers. Grateful for IV drips of saline twice. And grateful to face the urgent care.
Who saw me two days in a row and wanted me to check in and I told him no. But that part, you could probably ignore that part too. But I just was like, I want to go home. So I am super grateful. But here's the other thing I'm grateful for. By the end of the day, the coughing still kind of comes back. And the coughing was so bad. I had Michael wrap my ribs with kinesiology tape. Oh, wow. The pain was so bad. The intercostal muscles between the ribs. I coughed so hard. I couldn't take it anymore. I couldn't.
cough or breathe or talk or laugh without the pain being exquisitely terrible. So I had him wrap kinesiology tape around me to hold me in place. And I got cough medicine called promethazine. The first one, oh my God, it is my new boyfriend. Let me just explain. So the first one they prescribed had codeine, I'm allergic to codeine. So they gave me the second one, which is called promethazine DM, which I think means for like, you know, like getting your phlegm out.
Oh, dominant and master. So it's very watery and runny. It's not like your regular cough syrup that's thick. So I would spill it a lot when I put in a spoon. So, you know, I would just take a tablespoon and I finally just got like, I don't know, frustrated. So on Sunday before Michael and I went to bowling in our bowling league, I took the bottle and took a swig. Probably not the best thing to do, but I didn't know that. So I go and it took a.
like maybe an hour, 45 minutes, an hour to kick in. So we're sitting there at the table and I was like, I'm out of my body. I don't know what's happening. And it didn't dawn on me that it was the tough meds. I thought I was getting sick again. I'm like, oh shit, I'm getting sick. I don't know what's going to happen. And I'm like, I am out of my body. It was, and I was like laughing and didn't care about a fucking thing. And here's my bowling scores. 93, 64, 107. So I don't know what happened in the middle. I'm surprised I could still hold on to the ball. And everything was bright.
and beautiful and i here's how i bowl some of you who were in northern kentucky in early january this year saw me and i am a you know consummate bowler i throw the ball and then turn around and walk away because i don't want to see it no i don't want to see it so a few times i got strikes or kind of difficult spares and people would be like yeah i'm like what's happening i turn around and look and then i laugh and laugh and laugh so it was uh an interesting i'm i actually one of my beautiful teammates so it's michael and i and these two young men kirk and devin and devin goes okay nycoyle you're up I'm like, oh, okay. So he goes, I like this, Melissa. I like cough medicine, Melissa. I'm like, all right.
But guess what? I got a refill. So I'm going to be hoarding it. And just like little bits at a time, I will not take a swig again, except for maybe before bowling. But it made bowling, I do not sanction, I don't drink much at all. I don't do drugs. I do not sanction high bowling. But hey, you know what? Sometimes you got to do what you got to do. Hey, why not? Yeah, that's how I looked at it. I mean, it was stellar. It was the most fun I had bowling because I did not care. I didn't care about anything. It was delightful. It was so delightful.
I understand why people become, you know, cough syrup addicts. They were calling me scissor. Yeah. Okay, scissor. Your turn.
Yeah, it was delightful. I'm just going to say that. Oh, so good. Okay. So this is such a fascinating story. And when she first sent that, I was like, oh, she might be out of her mind. So our beloved Emily had sent me this story when I was really sick and I was like, oh, she's crazy. But then I took some cough syrup and I read it. No, I'm kidding. I was not drunk. It's a really good story. And it's kind of what Joshua and I were talking about before we hit record. He was talking about authenticity.
And about one of his favorite broadcasters who was, you know, really on top of all of the Supreme Court stuff. And this story lends itself in my mind to what a little bit about what we're talking about. OK, so this is an old one and I don't like old stories, but I love Emily. And when she sent this, I read it and was like, holy shit, this is fascinating. And I knew nothing about it. Nothing, you know, maybe because it's so old. But what happened, how it was handled, you know.
There are some other podcasts who have covered it, and it's got a whole lot of – it's steeped in folklore. It's been on a lot of ghost adventures and ghost stories on the TLC channel that used to be called The Learning Channel, and now it's ghost stories. And there's actually a song that was – I'm still trying to figure out. It's the – Jaded. Oh, I got to find the band. Because it's a really interesting song. The Crooked Jades. The Crooked Jades in San Francisco. They recorded a song about this case of Pearl Bryan. And in an old style kind of folky way. And they released it in 2012. And we're going to play it a little later. And it's only two minutes and 58 seconds. Like old folk songs are. And it doesn't tell you anything. But it lets you.
It doesn't tell you any new information, but it lets you know people are still thinking about this case. So in 1895, a beautiful girl from Indiana, Greencastle, Indiana, named Pearl Bryan, she decided to go, from what she told her parents, to visit friends in Indianapolis. She didn't go there. And back then, the only way you would know would be to send a telegram. Oh, okay. 1895. Sure.
So Pearl is the youngest child of 12 and born in Greencastle, Indiana. And her father, thank goodness, was a successful farmer because he had 12 kids. So I can't find great pictures, but you could tell Pearl was very kind of. let's call her classy. She was classy looking. She was the baby and from all accounts was really beautiful. The pictures, you know, she doesn't have filters and Kim Kardashian makeup, you know, in 1895. So she looks a little 1895-ish, you know, but for her, you know, time, her genre, she was, you know, thought of as very beautiful. She was also intelligent, graduated like top of her class from Greencastle High. She was a Sunday school teacher.
She was just beloved like the whole family because she was the baby. I'm sure that had something to do with it, but neighbors loved her. She was just thought of as this like sweet, intelligent, beautiful girl. And she was kind of babied by others, even by neighbors because she was the, the youngster. Yeah. So when she says, you know, I'm going to go visit some family friends in Indianapolis. No one has any reason to doubt her. Okay. So, right. So it's the end of January and 1896.
She's like, I'm going to visit friends in Indianapolis. That didn't happen. She ended up going to Cincinnati. And the theory is that she met with a boy who had captured her attention back home in Indiana. His name is Scott Jackson. So Scott Jackson, fascinatingly enough.
had a criminal background, which no one knew. He had moved with his mother to Greencastle, Indiana, and it was like a fresh start because he had been indicted and gave states evidence against his partner as they opened checks and cashed them for themselves from the Pony Express. Oh, he stole other people's checks. Okay. So it's 1895 to the tune of $32,000. Oh my gosh. That's a lot of money. That sounds like an enormous amount of money. In 1895. Business checks that came through the mail. He would open them, he and his partner, and cash them and then go drink heavily and pay for prostitutes. Yeah. Right. So his mother, he does a short amount of time because he turned state's evidence against his partner. So his mother, but none of this is known yet. None of this is known. His mother brings him to Newcastle or Greencastle and he starts to court, sort of.
Okay. Courting at that point meant borrowing someone's horse and buggy and going for a ride. Okay. And spending time with her in the family's parlor. But her parents trusted him so much, they would let them spend time in the parlor alone. Okay. Which was a rarity. Okay. Normally the family would sit there and kind of participate or listen. Okay. They're alone, but they're, I mean, it's. The family's in the house. It's a front room. It's not like they're. It's not like they're. In the bedroom. In the bedroom. Right, right, right. They're in the entryway still. Right.
So Scott and his friend, Alonzo Walling, are both signed up at the Cincinnati Dental College. Now, I'm going to tell you a little bit about that area because I'm from Northern Kentucky where she was found. I thought about being a funeral director because I love bodies. I love physiology. And I love to know what causes someone to not be here and what happens when they're no longer here. I was fascinated by that. Yeah, I know. I'm a weirdo. I mean, it fits, but I totally never knew that. You didn't know that? No.
I was the office manager for T&W Printing in Latonia, Kentucky. And we had, it was a union shop. So we had the contract to print all of the prayer cards for all of the funeral homes in the area. And there were quite a few. So we would print all the funeral, all the prayer cards. And one of my favorite, Bill, Bill, the printer, they were, it was all, I guess it's old fashioned called linotype printing, very big machines. Where you actually have to crank it? Yeah. Yeah. So Bill was hilarious. And he would say, hey, Melissa, we got another order for a hundred St. Francis, the sissy.
Cards. Okay. All right, Bill. St. Francis the sissy. And who knows? He doesn't mean to disparage St. Francis. Maybe St. Francis was like a complete buff dude. I really don't know. I think he was like a patron saint of little animals or lost animals or something. Anyway, I remember laughing my ass off. But they knew how much I wanted to be in the funeral business, so they would let me deliver the cards and get me out of the office and take a break. So I would deliver all the funeral cards to the local funeral homes. And some of them knew. And you got to sneak peeks of bodies while you were there? Yes. Some of them knew that I wanted to be in the industry.
And would let me see what happens to bodies and how they, you know, prop them up on the table, the block under their head, the, you know, draining of the fluid and then putting in the formaldehyde. And I mean, it was fascinating. That's really cool. I would have been fascinated by that. And I mean, there's little tidbits like, you know, back in the, you know, 1700s in Salem, if a body after they died, if their nails grew or their hair grew, they were a witch. And of course, it's going to happen because your body's going to recede because we're 75% water. Anyway, it was fascinating looking at bodies. Respectfully, they always covered.
their, you know, genitals. I mean, it was, they were handled it very respectfully and it wasn't like I was up there touching them. I was just in the room looking and seeing what I could see. Now I would have loved to have done that, but I can't, I could never picture myself alone in a lab. I'm not a lab person. I'm more friendly. I also knew that I couldn't handle the grief. If I had to be a grief counselor to someone who is crying because their family member died, I would start crying and it's the last thing you want. So I knew it wasn't going to be for me, but that long story is to say one of the most esteemed colleges in the country is the Cincinnati school of mortuary science.
It is there in that area. And it was one of the first colleges to teach embalming. I mean, it's a great college. I went and toured. I really did think about doing it, but I just knew there's that feeling, you know, it's not for you. You might want to do it, but you know, there's going to be things holding you back. But my favorite, I know I promised to get back to Pearl's story. My favorite tidbit was a very young funeral director named David who came to our shop to get prayer cards for one of his coworkers. And I'm like, what happened? And he said he had a heart attack.
And I go, how do you know? And he said, well, he walked up the steps Saturday morning to open the funeral home, had a heart attack on the stairs of the porch, fell backward, hit his head on the step, and he didn't bleed. And I go, he didn't bleed? He goes, yeah, his heart stopped. I'm like, Oh, so in my mind, funeral directors can sometimes be detectives, which a corner plays a part in this. So it does. I am leading back to something. I know it's not just stories about me. I promise. But I will. Thank you. I'm sure the listeners are like, that's forward. That's forward. Well, I had no idea that you went that deep into it. I did. I really, I really did. I also like to wear a lot of black, but that's not the point.
The fascination with death and that kind of, that's not surprising to me. I didn't realize how deep you went into that industry. I love physiology. I love what happens to the body. Good, bad, and ugly. You know, just any I'm fascinated by. And this is a little bit layered what happens to Pearl. So she is having a relationship with Scott Jackson. And he is later on.
In a most fascinating way, described as a sociopath narcissist back in the 1800s, which is pretty interesting how this police officer got there. But we're going to talk about that, too. But so she is in her family's mind visiting friends in Indianapolis. They don't hear from her, but they don't expect to. Sure. Fascinatingly.
How she is identified is a little bit crazy. And also it just, it really blows my mind. So what is now the Fort Thomas YMCA was a part of a farm and a 17 year old farmhand named Johnny Hewling found a headless female body in a field, February 1st, 1896. So he runs to the farmhouse and gets the owner of the farm and says, there's a woman, a woman's body, but no head. So what they found in this kind of, let's call it like a gully, is a woman wearing a dress. Part of a man's shirt sleeve is ripped off. She has been decapitated. I was trying to remember. It was between the third and fifth vertebra.
Um, I think she had some stab wounds, um, to her front and back. Unfortunately, this is ugly as shit, but the, um, and she was found hours after she was murdered. Okay. Hours. Like there had not been much time and it would have been cold. Right. Uh, what they look like from, it had been rainy. What it looked like from the footprints is that she had been walking side by side with someone with much larger feet, like a male. And then at some point she broke away and ran and this person chased her.
and decapitated her. Wow. Right. There was blood all around. And we've talked about this before in older cases. I think it's just human nature. You can say true crime podcasts and television shows are entertainment for ghouls. I think the human, I don't know, psyche or curiosity, people showed up. Word gets out, people showed up. They would take leaves that had blood on them as a souvenir.
Seriously, ugly shit. Right. The police tried really hard to keep them from trampling the scene. Right. So they have no idea who this woman is because she has no head. Okay. But she was murdered there. The blood was there. Blood was there. I don't think she could have been murdered somewhere else and then carried there without leaving a huge trail of blood. To me, it sounds like, you know, and we're going to find out there were a whole lot of different theories like, oh, she was murdered here. She was murdered there. I was told to help take care of her body. By the way, spoiler alert, her head's never been found. Oh, still never been found. Nope. Okay.
And there's a list of places where the suspect said they put it or it could be. Never been found. So the coroner at the time, the presiding coroner, takes her and examines her and says there is cocaine in her stomach. There is cocaine in her system and mixed with something else. She is at first thought to be two other missing girls. Both show up alive. Her dress is a nice dress.
But what is very particular are her beautiful shoes. Oh, okay. She has very particular, well-made, classy shoes that you don't find everywhere. Okay. She also has a very small feet size three. Oh. Very small feet. Now, we're talking about an area, Cincinnati, you know, Southern Indiana and Northern Kentucky. They call it the tri-state area. You know, it's all together, right? So a word gets out, right? And a haberdasher in Cincinnati.
says, I recognize those shoes. There's only one place I know that makes them like that. And that's Greencastle, India. So they go, I mean, consider and how quickly all this happened, considering it's 1896, right? The police go to Greencastle, find the shoemaker, show him, you know, like, this is what the shoe looks like. And he said, very few of those were sold. I had, I have names and numbers of everyone except for two, two clients.
Later on, they do find out that Pearl Bryan was actually in his roster, but overlooked. So he's like, I'm pretty sure it's this girl. I don't have her on my list, but I'm pretty sure it's Pearl Bryan. They go to the Bryan's home. Hey, where's your daughter? She's visiting friends in Indianapolis. Oh, okay. Well, you think we can check on her? They send a telegram. The friends are like, she's not here. She never made it. We don't know what you're talking about. Oh, boy. So her mother is tasked with finding a tag inside the dress.
And saying, that's my daughter. Oh, wow. So this happened between January 31st and February 1st. She's found. On February 5th, Scott Jackson is arrested. On February 6th, Alonzo Walling, his friend, is arrested. Oh, that's the friend. Okay. Yes. Now, this case is so ridiculous because these two men spend time pointing at each other, saying he did it. No, he did it. And this is how he did it. This is how he did it. I just helped him.
It's pretty well thought of that Scott Jackson did this because she was five months pregnant. Oh, geez. Right. So there are stories that. They weren't exactly being watched in the parlor then. She. Yes. I think maybe some of the trips with the wagon and the horse. OK. Just, you know, some let's take a drive out to the country. OK. And I might accidentally trip and fall into your vagina. Put a blanket under a tree. Yeah. Sure. All right.
Now the police are saying, you know, Scott Jackson, this girl was beyond reproach. She was a Sunday school teacher, you know, but everyone says when Scott Jackson was introduced to the family, Pearl fell and fell hard. And everyone, you know, I mean, people that are paying attention. And her parents really liked him. They thought dental student, good family, not knowing about the previous shit. He seems to really like Pearl. Pearl seems to really like him. This is a great union. Right. Or he's going to get her pregnant and cut her head off. One or the other. Yeah. One or the other. No gray. There's no gray area for Scott. He is. He's a piece of shit. So, yeah, he's, you know, also someone in dental school would have a better than average view of how to dismember someone between bones. Oh, no. You know.
It wasn't completely clean, but it wasn't done sloppily. You know what I mean? Right. So Alonzo is sort of, I'm going to call him the third wheel. He hung around with Scott and with Pearl. There's stories of two men and one woman coming into a bar in Cincinnati.
The bartender remembers that the two gentlemen had alcohol and the woman had sarsaparilla. Yeah, she's just letting herself go. And that they then hailed a horse and carriage. And I love that they describe Mr. Johnson, Alan Johnson, the cab driver, as a man of color. So a man of color is the cab driver. And he has two men and a woman in his cab. And they say, take us to Kentucky.
So they're at a bar in Cincinnati. They take a cab over the river to Kentucky. And Scott Jackson says to cab driver Alan Johnson, wait here until we whistle. And then you can come and pick us up a block away. And Alan Johnson turns around to the backseat to say, well, I'm not going to do that. And he's facing a gun. Oh, geez. And in his words, Scott Jackson says, you're going to do what I say or I'll blow you to hell. So Alan Johnson waits. But then when he thinks the coast is clear, he leaves. Yeah. Yeah. I'm going to wait around. Right. For a guy with a gun to kill me. Yeah. So what exactly was done and by who? Again, Scott Jackson and Alonzo Walling are pointing fingers at each other. Now, there's some interesting.
At first, it's considered Alan Johnson's testimony is like, well, he is a man of color. I don't know if we should pay attention to that, which I was like, wow, that's weird. So the prosecution, which is actually fascinating to me because who prosecutes the case? A coroner's inquest. The coroner's had an office of attorneys who did. I know. Cincinnati was fascinating back then.
Even though they've arrested Scott Jackson and Alonzo Walling, these two detectives from Cincinnati PD, even though her body is found in Kentucky, Cal Crim and Jack McDermott, they keep investigating. So it's March and they have arrested February 5th and February 6th, Scott Jackson and Alonzo Walling. So quickly, like March 3rd, they are being arraigned like a month later. Now, Scott Jackson's attorney asked for extra time. He was given two weeks, but he said it still wasn't enough.
enough time for him to gather everything, but the police find Alan Johnson and they say, you know, what do you remember? And he said, I remember picking up Scott Jackson, Alonzo Walling and a woman. And, um, he, uh, after they'd had a couple of drinks, he picks them up and the girls seem to be ill now. He says Alonzo and Scott were on either side of her kind of helping her. One of the plans was to give Pearl a lot of meds that would kill the baby. That didn't work. It just made her sick, apparently. One of the plans was to actually perform an abortion. And a friend of theirs named William Wood, they call him Bill, William Wood said that I was asked by Scott Jackson to perform an abortion. And at first he said, a friend of mine, I was asked to find a friend to do this. And then he said, it was asked of me.
So, you know, the last person to see her live other than her murderer is Alan Johnson. And he's on the stand and the prosecutor said, did you murder this girl? And he said, I did not. And he said, do you know who did? And he said, I think from what I've been told, Scott Jackson did it. So the prosecutor says, do you know this body, Mr. Jackson? And he's, you know, got a picture.
of Pearl. And he said, I'm led to believe that's Pearl Bryan. And he said, how do you know this? Because I see about me, some of her relatives and the body of a headless woman, which is said to have been identified as Pearl Bryan. And he said, did you kill Pearl Bryan? He said, I did not. Who do you think did it? I think Scott Jackson did it. He said, I'm reasonably sure of it from what has been told to me. So Pearl's mother makes a personal appeal in court.
to Scott Jackson and Alondo Walling. And he said, she said, I ask you, and her voice choked with sobs, tell me what you've done with Pearl's head. He didn't answer. For the love of heaven, tell me what you've done with my poor baby's head. Think of her mother, if nothing else. I'm going to her tonight and I want to tell her where her head is. They waited two months to bury her because they were waiting to get her head back. Never got it back. Scott Jackson says, I can't tell you anything about that.
So it doesn't take long. They call it a coroner's jury. They returned within an hour. Oh, wow. And the verdict said, we, the jury of Campbell County, Kentucky, find that the headless body of the woman found on the farm of John Locke in Fort Thomas, Kentucky, on February 1st, was that of Pearl Bryan, a resident of Greencastle, Indiana. We further find that cocaine had been administered to Pearl Bryan for some reason unknown. We further find that the decapitation of Pearl Bryan occurred when she was still alive.
We further find that Pearl Bryan, last seen alive in the company of Scott Jackson and Alonzo Walling, the three got into a cab manned by Alan Johnson at Plum, Plum Street in Cincinnati. The saloon at the northeast corner of George and Plum, Cincinnati, and last were seen in the cab turning toward Plum Street. So they were found guilty and they were given a date to be hung. Okay. The both of them were found guilty. Okay. Got it. And they pointed fingers at each other the entire time. Sure. They were hated so badly that they asked for special guards. And there was a prison break and they were so afraid they'd be killed by a mob, they stayed in their cells. Wow. Yeah.
I think that's kind of hilarious. I mean, they were hated so much. And there is a lot more that you can find out about this. It's sometimes hard to find old newspapers. I have a subscription to newspapers.com. But there was, in 1930, a seven-page expose. I mean, here we are, 34 years after her death. There was a seven-page expose in the Cincinnati Post or Inquirer talking about...
the details and about, you know, at the very end, Scott Jackson, before they were about to be hanged said, um, Alonzo Walling had nothing to do with this. Even the governor was called like a, like a last minute, you know, stay of execution. But when they looked over the evidence again, they were like, there's just not enough to say he wasn't involved. Even if he didn't do it, there's rumors that both men were sleeping with her. And then there's rumors that he just helped his friend.
Okay. So, I mean, it's, it's so hard to know, you know, but Scott was at the end was like, he didn't have anything to do with it. So they were both hanged. And what is now, I'm trying to remember, what did they say? Now it's the right behind the Campbell County courthouse on York street. And after that hanging the gallows, which was right behind the courthouse was torn down. That was the last hanging in the state of Kentucky, you know, in Northern Kentucky anyway, it's like such a weird, you know,
popular case i think because of the missing head there was there were stores uh that popped up in newport kentucky where you could buy pearl memorabilia um like souvenir branches from the crime scene. I know it's, and of course it's considered the trial of the century, but every big trial is called the trial of the century. You know, uh, I think that Bobby Mackey's music world has been like torn down and as they're rebuilding it, but that area, and I guess that's wilder Kentucky, um, near Newport is supposed to be rife with ghosts. So many television shows have filmed there and it's like a, it was like a honky tonk. Bobby Mackey was the Bobby Mackey club was where they had, Oh God, what were they called?
an urban cowboy mechanical bulls. Yeah. So they had, he had a big, he, Bobby Mackey was a singer songwriter and he had a place where country music artists would come and play. It's just like a small honky tonk club, but it was built. It was like taken over an old, probably at one point house and it had steps going down to a basement. You know, there's lots of basements in the East coast cause they don't have earthquakes. Um, so every, lots of people said there was a headless woman. I know. So I don't know that, you know, the ghost of Pearl Brian is like hanging around Kentucky. Like I got some scaring to do. I don't know that I, you know, buy all that shit, but I'm fascinated by.
In the 1910s and the 1920s, these folk singers made these songs about her. And this one that I'm going to have Matt play now, it's not great, but it's fascinating. The Crooked Jades from San Francisco recorded an old song and made it sound old. Again, it's only two minutes and 58 seconds, so hang with it. We're going to play that now.
So that's the Crooked Jades. Yeah, you're probably going to yell at me like you do with every time I play music. You guys are like, that was terrible. Don't do it again. But it's two minutes and 58 seconds of your life. I think it's a fascinating take on an old folk song. Sure. I think it's fascinating. So, so many, again, you can find so many.
things that I don't find fascinating, like the untold story of the demonic Bobby Mackey, mystery archives, ghost adventures. My favorite part, I'm going to tell you this, and I wish I'd had time to order it and I didn't see it until it was too late, but there's an illustrated Oracle card deck. called Southern Gothic Oracle. And there's a section called The Haunts. And it's designed by a woman named Stacy Williams Ng. And she has a variety of Southern ghosts, monsters, and cryptids. And she has Pearl Bryan as a headless ghost wandering in the moonlight in Kentucky. If I can find a picture, I'm going to put it up in the show notes because, yeah. So that is the case of Pearl Bryan. Poor Pearl Bryan. I wonder, you know, I mean, the police said that they assumed that.
Scott Jackson and Alonzo Walling had put her head in a furnace that they had access to at the Ohio College, the dental college. Oh, OK. They thought they burned her head. And I think the police largely thought that they thought if she doesn't have head, no one can identify her. And yet here she is identified by her classy shoes. Right. Within days. Within days. I mean, to me, that was the fascinating part. There's also a side note. This police officer in Cincinnati questioned Scott Jackson and did something called the Berton system. Alfonso Berton came up with a system of measuring. Let's call it the.
old school version of CODIS. He measured criminals' arms, legs, fingers, heads, skulls, everything, and kept a quote-unquote database on cards for criminals and repeat offenders. He said Alonzo Walling's head was a typical lower echelon criminal head, but Scott Jackson's measurements showed that he was a sociopath and a narcissist with no way to feel empathy. Wow. I know. And Berton's method is now, of course, considered junk science. But boy, back then, it would be like an older version of fingerprints or something. But they would keep these cards and go through them when someone committed a crime. I know. I love all the old school details. So that is the case of Pearl Bryan. And thank you, Emily, for giving me this because knowing where I came from and all the things that were familiar, I really liked reviewing this. And the thing that Joshua was talking about with the Supreme Court, a woman.
is pregnant and gets her head cut off for it. How far have we come? Sure. I mean, 130 years later, how far have we come? I'm just, I'm just, it's rhetorical. You don't have to answer. Yeah. I just felt like it was important to talk about this case and to think about the fact that people are still talking about it. It does bring me a tiny modicum of hope, you know? Yeah. Okay. That we're still talking about it. That we're talking. Okay. That we're talking about. Yeah. Sure.
Sure. Yeah. I mean, okay. You don't sound convinced, but okay. I get you and I appreciate where you are. It doesn't. Okay. This is one way. It doesn't feel like we've come that far. I know. I get it. And I thank you for feeling that. With all of the things that I've heard in the last couple of months of the barriers that different women in different parts of the country have been facing that.
No, not getting their head chopped off in a field, but certainly not quality health care. Right. Not that far removed. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. That's just one reason why I love you, because you understand. And I thank you. So if you have a tip on a missing person or unsolved homicide, or you just want to suggest a case, please give us a call at 832-TIPSTER. That's 832-847-7837. You can email us at jttipsters at gmail.com.
You can find us on any of the social media platforms, Just the Tipsters Facebook page at JTTipsters on Instagram, at JTTipstersPod on Twitter, and more cowbell. If you would like to support this podcast and get early access and other cool murderous swag, go to patreon.com slash justthetipsters. If you like the show, please take a moment to rate, review, and subscribe. It really does help the show to grow. Thank you for listening.