Hello, fellow youth. This week we're going to be able to live actually pretty much live through Nicole experiencing that feeling when you suggest a YouTube video to someone and you watch them watch it and you realize they don't like it as it goes through and you feel bad. Except in this case. In this case, I hadn't seen a YouTube video either and I'm right along with you going, yeah, this is garbage. This is bad. We can change it, you guys. Except we can't because we locked ourselves in at the last recording. That's okay. I think it'll be weirdly fun to talk about how much we did not enjoy this book. And in an odd turn of events, I am the least emotional about this. Yeah, that never happens. Right?
I'm so filled with emotion. And rage. Just angry. Until it explodes out of me and I start screaming. What color is your anger, Audrey? Oh my god! Anyway, so before we get into just like an hour of screaming from everyone. It's the color of blood and burst eyeballs. Look at that. I'm better at writing horror than she is. Nailed it. Write a book. Probably. I should, obviously. Jesus Christ. Okay, so if we don't, you know, get a cease and desist letter from Stephanie Garber after we discuss her book. Oh my god, it would be sealed with kisses and flowers, so would it even be bad? It would be on gilded paper and it would rhyme, but not very well. Yep.
We are discussing Caravelle by Stephanie Garber. Now to do a too long didn't read because I'm sure everyone here is going to suggest. Oh wait, who are we though? Oh yeah, I'm Kathy. I'm Audrey. I'm Nicole. I hesitated for a second because I'm like, who are we? That is so deep, Audrey. Well, the thing about Caravelle is sometimes it can make you question who you are and also reality. Beware of getting swept too far away. Anyway, so essentially this book, I'm just going to do a quick too long didn't read, is that you have the main character Scarlet.
Probably no relation whatsoever to Scarlett O'Hara. And we have her sister, Donatella, not the Ninja Turtle, but just Donatella. And they live on this island somewhere that they're not allowed to leave, but they tried to escape a few times with a horribly abusive father. And Scarlett's about to get engaged or married. She's engaged to be married to this guy. To an account she does not know. Yeah, to an account. Never seen him. All she knows is that he's a count. So she's like...
this might be better because I won't get beaten anymore. Which technically, I guess, is exactly one step up. Yeah, it's a good step up. But also, how do you know? Yeah, you don't. That's the thing. I was like, are you sure this guy's not going to beat you? He's so nice in his letters. His handwriting's super loopy. That's what she said. But apparently, there's also this weird semi-magical mystical carnival that happens every year that's called Caravelle and it's led by this guy, Legend. So, setting you up for a letdown right there. Yeah, who may or may not be evil and no one knows what he looks like except for the fact that her grandma used to fuck him.
And told these stories to her little grandkids. Don't worry, she changed the names, so, you know, they don't know. But yeah, all this is happening, and then she ends up getting away off the island, and her sister essentially kidnaps her, and they go off, and she enters into this carnival, and, oh no, her sister has been kidnapped! Or maybe she was just having sex with a guy, no one knows! And then it goes on this wonderful adventure with a generic male interest. Yes, kidnapped by a sailor, who's boring. Yeah, and they're supposed to be like...
danger and stuff and they're in this mystical world and they go through and then they all live happily ever after oh my god and that's the book so yeah that's where we are so let me quickly roll through the cast of characters and yeah it's been about a week and a half since I read this book and I don't remember like I literally didn't remember any of their names except for Donatella because I just thought of Donatella Versace every single time and she's not even called that in the book she's just called Tella so it'd be so easy to forget her anyway and for some reason that's the only one like I didn't remember Scarlet who's the main character I didn't remember any of their names it's her name so generic and I forgot it half the time I forgot whether the book was in third or first person because I couldn't remember I was like is it Scarlet are we talking about okay so dull there's Scarlet whose nickname is Crimson from you know the generic interest it's not even a it's a world's worst joke that he never let go of it's not it's like that it's a common joke in shitty romance novels of like i'm gonna call you by the wrong name but it's a creepy not funny power play yeah i'm gonna name you and that will make you love me more that will make you love me i can't remember your name even though we've been trapped on a boat together for a day yeah and scarlet has no dark hair actually probably much closer to you two in appearance i look like the shitty selfish sister she's like with her curly like brownish blonde hair i'm like god damn it that's me i guarantee you that scarlet is a just a little white girl for sure well audrey then fine oh i'm sorry
I'm sorry. She's pale and has dark hair. It's fine. And she's beautiful. End of personality. So she could be anyone with brown hair. She literally could be anyone. She probably was based on at least an appearance on Scarlett O'Hara, if we're going to go with that. There's a theory I have that even her name was maybe just like...
You know how sometimes when you were a kid, you'd write a book, and then you'd be like, no, I want her name to be Jubilee or something bonkers, and you go back with Control Search and change it all? There's a bit where Scarlet's name's occasionally only spelled with one T. I feel like she just went through and kept changing it. It was like, no, I want her name to be Bianca now. No, I want her name to be Scarlet now. And she missed one? Yeah. Because there's one where it's like, Scarlet, two T's. Next sentence, Scarlet, one T. Next sentence, Scarlet, two T's. So I'm like, even you can't really remember what your character's name is? Yeah, that's not good. Also, Donatella calls Scarlet Scar as a nickname, and I have no idea how... I'm sorry. That's the best nickname. That's the coolest her character ever got was when she was Scar. And then maybe one day,
She has cool territory to go, but it doesn't go there. It's another good setup. The Scar makes it sound like she'd be cool, but no, it's just another letdown. It just already was so at odds with her character that I was like... I don't understand how this nickname got started. It's not. Interesting it doesn't say anything about her. It's just a different form of red. She would quite honestly be Letty. Color burgundy too if you want. She'd be Letty. If she had a nickname it would be Letty. She's a Letty character. She'd be like a little prim background character princess in any other book named Letty. That's pretty much it. Then there's her father who I don't remember. He's evil. He's plum colored and purple which is apparently an evil color. Oh yeah. Scarlet sees colors. I forgot about that. She sees colors whenever there's emotions or sense or sounds. Everything has a color and they don't explain this. I remember I went through with some of my friends and I was just like.
Surprise is chartreuse colored. The weirdest thing is kept happening. Nausea is vaguely bluish. Yeah. Or you're just like, I don't even know, but like, I'm terrified. It is purple. And I'm like, that's the color of the book. Like, who does that? Flatiron in books, you need to get your copy editing together and you need to like have someone read the book and then actually do the cover. Like, I know stock images are the thing, but like, come on.
about and then so their father's evil and he's just like kind of an ambiguous faceless evil guy then there's her fiance who you later find out and this is the only other name I remember is Darcy or Darcy so I was like oh yeah I wonder where she got that from yeah really where did that come from oh yeah did you it doesn't matter spoilers but there's also another something it's her really lame way of doing those like I can't remember the words but like scrambled letter names like like Tom Marvel or Riddle with Zion Voldemort yeah that except it was so lame because like there's that guy Daniel at the end Daniel D'Engle and I'm like okay so D'Engle is clearly just legend switched around God I wonder who he is I wonder who he could be Daniel Dangle. Daniel Dangle. Sounds like he'd be friends with Harvey Cable. It was such a good cover-up, but you know what? It didn't quite work on me. What book was it? Was it in the Invisible Library where she's like, fairies just spell their names backwards, and that's what it is. That's their secret invisible thing. That sounds like. It's probably very similar. So then there's Dangle, a.k.a. Legend, who actually wasn't even that guy. We didn't see him over the course of the book, except when he almost date-raped Donatella at the end of the book. Is that the count? Darcy? No, no, no. This is Legend that we're talking about. Okay, yeah, okay. Yeah, he almost date-raped her. Darcy, by the way, also almost actually raped...
Scarlett, because, you know, she has his property, even though they weren't married yet. And he's like, I'm sorry, I had to do this to you. And it's like, no one's fucking forcing it. This book's full of weird, problematic sex situations. There was almost none that just felt okay. Actually, I don't know that there were any that just felt like two consenting people being together. And also in a way that made sense. Because it was always like, the only time she was like, I'm happy doing this were weird times when any normal person would not be thinking about it. We'd be like, I'm about to die. I'm drowning. I should focus on that. Yeah, I should get my life together and stay alive. No. No, there's a lot of her talking about, like, we'll talk about this, but she prioritizes her, definitely her relationship over her life several times. Yeah. She's like, it's okay.
he gave me this moment between us so I could die tomorrow it'd be fine yeah she's just looking she just wants to die I think that's like where she's looking for excuses but then there's her generic love interest Julian who you later spoiler alert find out is the brother of legend The fuck? This elephant plot change could have happened or not happened and would not have affected the plot. Literally doesn't mean anything except that further points home that he is very attractive. Don't forget he's pretty. They're all pretty. And now he's really pretty. Literally every guy she met is pretty. They're pretty and they don't age and that one has a sleeve of tattoos which means he's intense. Yeah, that's right. And she's super into him. And then he becomes a dick immediately. Yeah, as soon as she's not also into him he becomes a massive tool. So many characters that just go whoosh. And you're like, why? The book uses that it's all a game as an excuse but actually it is just kind of like an excuse for really flimsy situations, really flimsy characters. They're like, he's not acting like you'd expect because it's a game. But more it's like, I couldn't be bothered to build this character.
Okay, so under should you read this novel, which is the next thing we have, I'm going to start and I'm going to say you should read this novel if you are a creative writing student. Because I think this would be, if you skip through it, one of the best prompts ever. Just like, you know, this quick creative writing prompt. Like, there's a magical carnival. It lasts five days. And there's something, like, sinister about it. That would be a great fucking jumping off. Premise, solid. I mean, granted, like, you probably could just start with what I just said and just go with that and not actually read the book. And so many people would make it good. Right, yeah. It's like, it's so good. It had the opportunity to be so good. So I think if you're, like, into, like, maybe.
Maybe you want to do a fan fiction, make it better, and do, like, a 50% degree of this. Yeah, hey. Stephen King, one of his actual writing advices, or piece of writing advice, is to read bad books because then you learn, like, what not to do because, like, writing is actually difficult. So, like, seeing how someone does it poorly is actually super helpful. So there's that. I mean, that's a legit reason you should read this book. There were good things, just not nearly as many. Stephanie Garber is a professor. Maybe this was all a big, like, exercise for her class. An elaborate school assignment. It's actually just a compilation of a bunch of creative writing assignments. Compiled. I could see that, yeah.
Like there's probably just like one scene that she was just like, this is my book. And they're like, okay, you have to do like 400 more pages. But it's only 20. What will I write? Exactly. And then so what's your, do you have any reason to read this book? I can't stop screaming about this book. Two people. Read it if you want a conversation starter? Yeah. Well, but not a conversation starter. Just a reason to yell at people. If you're a ranter and you're looking for a thing to rant about. My poor coworker that I like have my desk next to her just has had her hear about this a couple times.
So I can't even think of any reason. No. So it might be just avoid. Just avoid. Just don't do it. Sorry, quick interjection. I just was looking up the book deal. So it's going to be a series. It's going to be a series. She clearly left the door wide open by not resolving anything. Yeah, literally you could just pick up immediately after this and be equally boring. Go ahead. It's a two book deal. The original title was Hearts Made of Black. Son of a bitch. God. But don't worry. Film rights were preempted by 20th Century Fox. Oh, thank God. That's good to know. Honestly, as I was reading it, I kept thinking the only way this would be even a little okay is if it was just...
watching it on TV or something, and all the colors she was talking about were actually visible. This would be a great CW show. It'd be a good visual spectacle, but that's like... She made some weird stage direction-y sentences in there a couple times where it's like, why did you write this that way? Because that makes no sense unless you're making this into a film. Yeah. None whatsoever. Possibly ulterior motive.
Okay, I'm sorry for interrupting you guys. No, it's fine. I'm struggling to think of a potential reason why I should actually read this still. Okay, pass. Great. Well, Audrey and I both agree that at the very least, read this book if you like adjectives. If you like adjectives and you're looking for some new adjectives and you don't necessarily need them to be used in places that make sense, read this book. It's got so many adjectives. If you want to learn the names of colors, yes, Kathy, what do you suggest? I have another reason why you should read this book. Why? Okay, let's say you have a boozy book club and there's just a book. This would be great for a wasted book club. Yeah, a book that you just want to like hate fuck. Yeah, that's true. That's true. It's part of the reason that I'm actually excited about this because this is definitely a book. This is a book you'd love to hate. If you're a person who reads
books in order to get the ones they like done, read this book just because you're a person who can go through it fast. I would say it's a quick read, but it really took me forever because I couldn't pay attention. It just didn't move fast enough for me. It was painful to me, so I kept looking for reasons not to read it. Yeah, I kept kind of getting distracted, and I'm easily distracted, so there's nothing but distracting. You usually don't touch my phone when I read books, and I was constantly on my phone when I was reading this book. Yeah, I read it in, like, one night, but I had a lot of stressful things going on, and I think I skipped, like...
three paragraph chunks at a time, because I was like, well, they're just being stupid here, and I would just pass along. I made myself read every word, even. I wanted to just skip through and just do the dialogue so I'd understand what's happening without having to read it all, but I read every little bit of it, and mostly it was just kind of redundant. She said a lot of the same things at the same time, and she, eh. Read this book if you like adjectives. Read this book if you've got lots of free time. And if you like the premise. The premise is good. It's just not executed great. Not if you like the premise, though, because it lets you down. She lets you down. That's all I can think of. I can't think of any other reason. The premise of magic, game, romance. Tell us about it, Nicole. So this book advertises itself when I've been seeing it about. I've mostly been hearing it called a fantasy and a romance book. And that's why I picked it, because I like fantasy, and I'm a big romantic. I wrote down what those words actually seem to mean in the book. I ran into the word magic a lot. Magic just seems to mean drugs or anything that could be mistaken for drugs. Because there's a lot of mix of that when she first gets to the island.
And she's like, the air is so beautiful. And it's so weird. I'm starting to feel funny. I wonder if it's drugged, the air. And it's weird that that's the first time she thinks it could be drugged. Because there's also a scene where a lady in a shop sprays perfume in her face. And she's like, it must be magic. She just sprayed perfume in your face. It's drugs. Obviously. Drugs. The lady then says it's drugs. She's like, it helps you see what you need to see. And everything in that shop was labeled just enough that it's like, potion of forgetting. It all sounds like, it's like if she handed her the bottle and she looked at it and it was like, magic. And then you peel the label off and it says hypnol. And it's just a roofie. That's what it was like. There was lots of magic, but it seemed a lot like it could also just be drugs. Like they could be drugging everybody. And it over
She talked about them like either would be fine and either would be magic to her. But it's also interesting because I'm like, what the fuck is legend withholding from the world? Because his staff don't age. Yeah. Yeah. So, like, he has some magical drugs there. Yeah. And the magic's not really addressed either. They're just like, don't worry, there's magic. But only when it's, like, convenient and it wouldn't make sense any other way. Yeah. So, like, I can bring your sister back to life. Yes. Exactly. Like, they have control over, like, death, straight up death. And there's so many. It's so crazy. Audrey just gave the most expressive sigh. She just, like, rolled her entire body. Like, inside of just her eyes. I forgot about all the deus ex machina things that happened in this book. As in every single thing.
Every single plot point just like works out and it doesn't make sense. It just magically works out for her. What the characters do does not matter in this book. It does not matter. So it's like, why is Caraval six days long if it doesn't matter? And the second thing is, why is it a game? What part of this is a game? So the book is also described. So Magic was where they used a lot, Magic and Fantasy. They described it as Magic and Fantasy. It's not actually a game because it makes sense to no one. There's not really rules for it. There's not really. And the thing is, what I was disappointed by was like, I get it if the game doesn't look like a very usual game, but there wasn't even anything fun or gamey about it. There were no real trials. There was no real effort. She was just kind of stumbling around. So Caraval, the location of it. Oh, that was a trial. Yeah. I guess it was. She literally stumbles into weird situations because she's like, maybe this is what the cryptic clue meant.
Well, it does now because it's going to work out for you, to be the clue. Because whether she's wrong or right, she just ends up in places. And that's the thing. It didn't feel like a game because she didn't feel like she was actively playing. It didn't feel like anyone was doing anything except the point of the game, supposedly, that they show up and they're supposed to solve a mystery, which is the missing of Tella. Which, it really is barely part of the story. It's just kind of like Scarlet's motivation. They just use it every once in a while. It's almost like the way Emperor in the Ashes is constantly reminding you, like, Darren's still out there as a motivation, but way dumber because that was the way you do that. But this was kind of like, Tella's around. Don't forget she's around. And that's the only reason you're still here. Well, and the impression I got was that even to the players in the game, like the staff people, they a
Sometimes you get rewarded for trying, a.k.a. there's no game. You're just here to do shit. Just stumble around. Do cool shit in, like, a weird magic place. Looking for caraval symbols you can poke and go down secret staircases. That's the only thing that was different. Yeah. They pretty much, like, she went through this game with, like, the cheat mode of white privilege turned on, essentially. Like, she was just like, oh, I worked for this after someone handed her something. Like, it's just not. Yeah. So I decided that game was synonymous, in fact, with gaslighting. It's not a game. It's literally just there to confuse the shit out of you. Yeah. And it didn't feel, it really felt like, I think the definition of gaslighting is, like, trying to make a victim question their reality. Yeah. And it felt like everyone in there was a victim. Like, he had a tiny little, a little game board and he was just, like,
things yeah totally you could die you could die i don't care yeah it definitely just felt like gaslighting it didn't feel like anyone would volunteer for this well i would volunteer to watch because the only people who seem to be having fun with the people who are just shopping yeah just dicking around in stores and the thing that actually i was just thinking about was like there's a way in which like game can become like a twisted and scary thing like saw yeah saw or like that short story the most dangerous game everyone read for like high school english like that's a super scary like concept and it is a really cool idea that this like thing that's supposed to be fun can turn into this really horrifying situation where you're like fighting for your life but this had none of that edginess and all this like it If you die in the game, you wake up at the end of the game. Yeah. Literally, there's no consequences except that, oh, I'm sorry, except the superficial ones, which are apparently the ones that count. You might have gray hairs or Scar, and that's the worst thing that could ever have happened to you. Yeah. But the Scar shows how brave he was and how much he actually loves her. And don't worry. The streak of gray hair is just an accent in her beautiful, long, dark, luxurious hair. So it's not even that big a deal. It could have made her cool, but it doesn't. I don't know if you guys know this, but after the game ended, she actually went on to host What Not to Wear. She took over for Stacey.
She is Stacey, man. Yeah, it just, definitely I decided that, so magic and drugs were mixed together, game and gaslighting is kind of what I thought, and then romance and lust were really mixed up, because romance wasn't in this book. I mean, not really. They did not fall in love. I'm sorry, they did not fall in love. Even she couldn't quite tell if she was in love by the end of the book. No, she was like, I don't know if I know this man. It's like, so you don't, but you have to question it. But she was still saying things like, I think I love him, or I think I love him, or making decisions like she was, so it was like.
But clearly you don't. Also, he hasn't done any. He hasn't. It's another example of nothing different would have had to happen. Julian wouldn't have had to act any differently. Because he didn't do anything interesting. He didn't do anything exciting. He's not that fun to listen to. He has nothing smart to say. He gave her his blood, which gave her one day back. Yeah. I have so many things to say. Oh, and he got those earrings back, too. He got her earrings back for an appreciable reason and also then disappeared and got beat up. It didn't matter. Because she was different, you guys. He could tell from that 12 hours where she was passed out from drugs in the boat that she was different. After he chloroformed the shit out of her, he was like, this girl's different. This is the one I like. This one looks different when she's unconscious. I can tell that she has a good heart.
I hated it so much. So I decided that romance and lust were very mixed up, and I'll talk more about that later because I want to get into each of the scenes that were categorized as romantic and how they were only romantic because a teenage girl was thinking about them. She made them kind of in her head. She's like, this could be romance. It's not. It was lust. Like, she was clearly feeling things. And, like, that's fine if you feel things. But, like, it wasn't related to anything good. And it was in situations where I don't think she would feel lust. I think she'd be like, I think I'm dying. I think my body's too busy trying to be alive. Because every situation either had death or bleeding or being clocked over the head with something. Yeah, there was, like, often violence right next to her being like, oh, I'm turned on. Well, it was always, it was always, they all happened in the middle of violence or some kind of, or right after some kind of violence. Including the very last one where they're being slowly crushed to death in a tiny room. And she's like, I can feel all of his different body parts. You're being crushed to death in a room. But now we're so close together. So we're going to talk about priorities. But if I start now, I'll just rant. So
Okay. To mosey along. Okay. So we'll save that for the end. Yeah. So what do you have to say about the physical abuse? Oh my God. So one of the most important, I guess, aspects of Scarlett's character was that her father is apparently incredibly physically abusive. Like he did this thing where he would like whoever, whichever of the daughters. He killed a boy in front of her. He killed a boy in front of her, which.
As a warning. As a warning. Which, like, no one had any questions about that in this island that he governed because, like, apparently it just went away. Supposedly no one knows, but I don't know how they figured out. But how would no one know? He drowned him in broad daylight in the ocean. So someone maybe should have been paying attention. Yeah, he drowned on his own.
Oh, yes, right. It was a sad accident where that guy held his head underwater until he was dead. So the thing that really bothered, like, there is nothing wrong with writing about a character who has experienced physical abuse, especially from a parent. Oh, yeah. And especially to write it in in a way that actually affects the character. Yeah, definitely. My issue with this book was that it didn't, so the physical abuse was often used as an excuse for why Scarlet was a cautious. Sympathetic. Yeah, sympathetic character, and then also, like, why she was more sensible somehow. Which she wasn't. Which she wasn't. So it just didn't seem like the physical abuse linked up to, like, her actual character, nor was it ever dealt in a way that was, like, thoughtful. Yeah. Or, like.
It kind of did at the end. No. A little bit. In the end, it was even more confusing. He was kind of a nice guy. What I mean by a little bit is she made gestures at dealing with it. It's dealt with in the way that everything is dealt with in this book, which is surface. Too easy. And it also really discounts how difficult abusive situations are. I read Scarlet as a pretty typical heroine, and abuse is a serious thing, and I don't think that this book dealt with it in a way that was meaningful. Or realistic. Or realistic, and that makes me really upset, because it's like, why would you include this at all? The only thing I could think that was even a little realistic was how she like...
she thought that the abuse came out of her father's love that's the only thing i could see as being realistic but at the same time like no one ever was like no it's not yeah yeah no one told her like there might be like teenagers who read this book and think oh maybe he's like hitting me because he loves me and it's like it doesn't even say like no no no no no no what is it florence and the machine said a kiss with a fist is better than none yeah terrible not true people all terrible false um so it just i don't know why it was in this book a separate issue is that like I feel like it's totally fine to write a character that is just by nature cautious and like sensible and like that's fine. And if she was actually sensible I think I would have liked it. Yeah. Better. Yeah. So I and I also feel like it's one of those things where it's hard to criticize because it's it's a good thing that she was talking about it I suppose. But I just wish that she had done it better and not used it as an excuse for like why Scarlett wasn't like more like her like brave or whatever. It just turned into this like get out like get out of situation free card for in terms of like the writing where it was like.
I'm flawed. It must be because of the abuse I suffered. And it's like, newsflash, all humans are flawed. Speak for your fucking self. I am perfect. I am flawless. I don't know if you know that. My t-shirt currently says flawless. No, yeah, Beyonce, she actually wrote to me for advice on how to be flawless. On how to be flaw-free. Yeah, I hear she does that often. I hear Beyonce has to ask for lots of advice on flawlessness. Yeah. Yeah, just a quick thing. Just if you are in a bad situation, the National Domestic Violence Hotline, there's a phone number you can go. They have online, like, chat. They can also forward you if you are under 18 to someone where it's, like, within your family. Just...
Get help. Don't read this book. This book's not useful. You're not going to have some magical legend guy come in and fix your life, but you can be that magical legend guy. And please don't spend your life thinking, oh, we'll be okay as long as I find the right guy to marry. Yes. That's kind of what this book was. Everything will be fine as long as I find the right guy to marry. Also, verbal abuse is also abuse. Heck yeah, Julian does that a little bit too. That's called neging. Yeah, that's what really felt like it. Yeah. So that was my rant about that. I also just feel like the reviews that I read of this book.
nowhere near this issue and that's also super irritating. Yeah. You don't get a free pass just because you talked about a difficult issue if you didn't actually engage with it. If you use it as a prop, it's not helping anyone. No, you're helping no one. And Audrey's mad about it. It just was so gratuitous and it was just like...
Why? And he didn't, they never really talked about his motivation either. That's the thing. Well, that was also problematic because they were like, oh, it only happened after my mother disappeared. And so she kind of blames her mom a little bit. And it's like, no, no. I just put a giant picture of the author up and faced it at Audrey. Fine. Here, I'll look straight into her. Straight into her face and yell. Straight into her eyeballs. No, no. Your father is hitting you because of his own issues. It has nothing to do with your mother disappearing. Yeah, he doesn't turn into an asshole overnight. No, just because your mom.
disappeared. Which, it's nuts to me that Scarlett does not think she's dead. I'm sure she's dead until they bring her back, which they probably will. I think they're going to, but... Also, if she disappears without a sign, she's probably escaping abuse. Let's be back. Wow, maybe... The only thing I could think of was like, wow, maybe if your dad wasn't hitting you when your mom was there, the one he was hitting was your mom! So, to me, the fact that she's like, no, but of course, he couldn't have hurt her because he went crazy after she left. Yeah. I was like, so the fact... That's why you kept saying she was a cautious and sensible character, and I was like, but she made her so senseless in some way. So stupid. That she couldn't figure out some really obvious stuff. I'm not saying that she's actually sensible. I think that she's written as like, she's supposed to be sensible. They mention her sensibleness a lot
She's just not. Oh, my God. All that means is that she has glasses and a ponytail. Yeah. Not really, but, you know, metaphorically. And she's kind of a swear, honestly. That's really all it is. She's not that much fun. Which, like, is fine for a character to start there and go through this experience and become more, like, whatever. But she's not that much fun, and she's also a little stupid. Yeah, and she also doesn't actually go through very much character growth at all. No, there's no character development in this book. At the same time, it's six days, and this kind of goes into my, like, world creation and stuff like that. I mean, it felt like too many because you guys fucking hated it, but at the same time, like, this book, I remember being like, oh, this is short because it's, like, 380 pages.
I'm so used to teen books these days being like 600 to 700 pages and like at least cover maybe a year of the character's life or something like that. So it felt so short to me. And I felt like it wasn't like she like pretty much hindered herself by giving out in the short limit. I mean, would it have changed? It felt so much more unrealistic to me if you had made Carnival six weeks instead of six days. Think about it. Even if you just like, yeah, skipped over the time and just been like week one of Carnival because she does that.
like there's chapters because there's these things for like nights and I'm like and then she has night four twice so I'm kind of like why are you bothering yeah like it doesn't I don't know like it's just I feel like there's so much out there and then like we already briefly discussed it but like the idea of a sinister magical carnival where you're not sure what's real and you're not sure what will like last afterwards but with lasting effects could have been so so cool that's the thing there were so many moments that were set up that could have been good there were so many characters that could have been good there were so many situations that could have been good and it all just kind of like set up I got excited a couple times and then I think by the end of the book I was like I know what this is nothing's gonna come of this I'm not gonna get too excited it was a bummer there was What was it? There was that scene where she... Actually, just Caravelle itself was kind of let down. I don't know if he was still in the middle of things. The only reason why it was supposed to be cool is because everyone told us it was cool. And I guess that would be cool if you were inside, but it was also a starry night with a bunch of canals to go everywhere. It could have been so fucking awesome. But instead, it's just like, tra-la-la-la. Oh, there's so much happening. What's going on? Oh, I'm going to die for two days. It moved really fast, and it was descriptive, but not enough. It was weird. I agree in ways about the books feeling short, but actually, I think the page length was fine. If she'd done more things with the amount of space, it just felt like Caravelle's described, but not really that much. It sort of feels like a weird bastardization of Hogsmeade combined with Disney.
It's Disneyland. It's complete with staff areas. Yeah, it's a million different weird places. Underground staff areas. Yeah, it's Disneyland. But they don't describe it that well. They just occasionally will describe all the, like, knickknacks in the shops and how they're, like, magical knickknacks. That's also the only, like, evidence of magic is that the shops advertise lots of silly magical things. Yeah, it's Disneyland, but way worse. It's not fun. It's the worst Disneyland. It's like Disneyland, the poor man's Disneyland. I mean.
I didn't even see a single dog in Carnival, so you can tell that it's a piece of shit place. Also, I was a little disappointed. Like, she vaguely approaches characters of color, and it's fine, because honestly, I don't think I would have wanted this particular author dealing too much with that, because I don't know how well she would have handled it, but she also, what is it, there are no queer characters in this at all, even a hint of queer characters in this at all, and it seems like- It would have been so easy, because the entire point of fear of all is to, like, let go. And a huge, like, a crowd of open-minded performers, no one queers here, no one, are you sure? And there was no one. So I was like, I was even waiting for, like, in the background, because I'm like, it's okay if you're just making it more visible, like, hey, all kinds of people exist, but mostly she was just like, here's
Oh, yeah. No, all the love interests were white men. No, Julian was brown and golden brown, which I also don't include. He was Portuguese. He was from Portugal, essentially. She made an effort to say brown every time she mentioned his skin tone. I think she did that specifically so it wouldn't be like all white people. But that's just the same as a prop. It's a prop. It's another prop just like the abuse where she's like, oh, crap. It feels like she could have autocorrected. She could have gone back and been like, shit, they're all white. I better go back. He's just a tanner white. Yeah. It's got Spanish hints. I think it's supposed to be kind of like carnival. Is that like what the word is based on? I honestly don't. And there's enough Spanish in it. Like the aileron is like the Isle de los Santos or something like that. So there's hints that it's supposed to be kind of Spanish. So that's what
boats and like italian now so it was so many things that it was more like she's like here's a list of things it could be like and why don't you just kind of make it yourself in your brain yeah which is like why are we reading your book then yeah you do it yeah i'm not here to build the world once again great creative writing prompt yeah seriously and honestly the shops were some of my favorite part because they were like i was like i think this is the part i'd play i'd go in the shops and buy all the weird stuff all the fun hogsmeade shops and like the mirrors that she could somehow figure out would see the darkness in your soul would have a label or something i don't get how you could spot all these weird artifacts that was weird too but she's walking by going oh that mirror looks as if yeah it sees the darkness in your soul that's the thing that was all so like it was like a sickly sweet book and then there are these weird like nods towards darkness that then like weren't substantive so follow through no follow through no follow through no i just i wrote a note before i actually began the book i usually have a shitty map i usually yeah the map there's a map in the front it's not the best map it kind of looks like it was like garbage it's not that great but like i was so excited when i first saw it because i was like a header and haberdashery is a major place in this book this is gonna be amazing and then it wasn't no it was like kind of like oh it's where she meets her like fiance and then realizes that he's actually terrible and you're like
Are you surprised after all this time, day six of Caraval and how much character development? Has happened. There's also only six places on this map, and I feel like I remember visiting all of them, but none of them were interesting. Not a single place was interesting, except Castillo Maldito, which they weren't at for very long. They made out there, though. They kept talking about it. And the only part that seemed interesting was the tunnels, where, like, apparently there's tunnels under Castillo Maldito, and they just go down there and go crazy. But there's tunnels everywhere. Yeah, it's just a stab area. The tunnels were the only thing that I was like, investigate that. That could be fun. But then she's like, let me go back upstairs and just kind of wander around, dick around, stumble into fountains and shit. And just, she wasn't doing it. It felt like the whole book she was just chasing after guys. And that literally was how she got into most situations, was that, shit, it looks like Julia just went out that door, so she'd chase him, and she'd be
enough yeah constantly feeling guilty about her sister and then doing nothing about that bitch yep which i think i like wrote down notes for the first part of reading this and literally at one point i was like why if you're not gonna go after your sister just stop telling me about it yeah i was like even if you're just gonna give up on it which is basically what she did but she kept talking about donna tell is the most important thing in my life and i have to find her and even i was really pleased in the dress shop when she had to pay for one of her dresses with the things she wanted most and she said to find her sister and this guy was like nah that's not it i was like that's right just admit it I wonder what she does want most in the world besides Julian's dick. She never answered, but it's definitely Julian's dick. That's the actual answer. I was waiting for her to have to say it. That seemed like the kind of book where they make you say it. But then she didn't, so she had to die for two days. I think, to be honest, the thing that she probably wanted most in the world is to just be safe. And I feel like if she had said, I want my sister and I to be safe, it would have worked. I disagree, because the only thing that constantly motivates her in this book is Julian's dick. But even before that, though, is she just...
wants to be safe. And to her, safety is a man that is not her father. She definitely talks about that a lot. It makes sense for the situation she's in. It just doesn't make sense for the character that they made her. It's too contradictory. I get it. I certainly understand if you're in an aristocratic, I don't quite get their society, but it seems like there's aristocrats. Maybe marriage is your only option, but it seemed like even when she had other options, marriage is what she was after. Or a boy. Julian in the end is supposedly her freedom.
is to go off and marry julian but like not once did you consider that her freedom was just to be independent and by herself or to even like experience she was just like well the count's a jerk and turns out that guy's a jerk and oh good julian's the least jerky guy i can marry yeah well the thing is like when that scene happened in the haberdashery store my thought wasn't oh she just wants to be safe my thought was like oh my god she's in love with julian and she can't just admit it to herself so like which means like For all intents and purposes, she doesn't want to be safe. She wants to be with Julian. It's three days. Even when I was 17. Like, Jesus. I'm not saying it was a good choice. Oh, yeah. And I'm also, I think we're both, we're all right in saying I do not think she loved him, obviously. And even, even though part of the book, I think page 162 is when she was like, I think I'm falling in love with him. And I was like, no, nothing's happened. He literally like left her to drown once and wouldn't like.
sleep be polite and like we were uncomfortable sleeping in the same bed as him so he's like yeah fuck it I'm gonna sleep in this bed good luck find a place to be yeah go find another place to sleep in this strange place I'm sorry I'm just gonna say it Julian's a piece of shit and I don't like him he's a bad love interest and I don't like him and I did not like that about this book well and I think the other concerning thing was that he was I think she made an effort to write him as someone you should like which is just mind-boggling I thought she was making an effort to make him unlikable and then I got to the end I was like he's still kind of the same she's supposed to be like in love with him he's trash sorry girls if you meet a guy like Julian or boys if you meet a guy like Julian he's trash don't talk to him he's terrible i think it was that whole like he's he's like doesn't commit to her and he's like flighty but then when it really counts he comes through which is kind of like Isn't that how people end up here? He rarely does it. With her, that's the thing. Also, he would show up a lot. She wouldn't bother to write the scenes where he did these things either. He'd show up and be like, I got your earrings back and I'm bleeding from the head. And that was like, he doesn't really talk that much about it. He doesn't talk about his motivations. Like, why did you get the earrings? Did you feel like you wanted to do a thing for her? Wait, you can tell he really liked her because he attacked another man for her. There was that stupid punching scene. That's actually what brought down the bit where I was like, this is the most interesting bit of the book and I'm actually excited. That part, I don't know if we're talking about something else right now. Is it okay if I get into this part where she was in the dress shop and she had to pay with her two questions and she answered the first one, right? And the second one, the scale wouldn't
did that thing where she ends the chapter and it makes it seem dramatic um that was the only time where it tricked me because i was like oh she's gonna die now yeah because you think it's like off the end of her life or something and the lady's like nope right now because how do i know how long you're gonna live and i want to talk about her stupidity with like the feyness of how people said their questions and how she's playing a game and still wasn't paying attention to people's language anyway um but that's exactly what happened she got tricked into they were like okay we're taking two days of your life now you're gonna die for two days yeah so she found she was gonna die not only was she gonna die she's dying right then so like she starts to feel like she's gonna fall down lady's like okay don't don't die here because if someone i don't want to deal with you like if someone finds your body and your body dies you're dead but if it's not if it's somewhere safe you'll come back in two days so like i was is interesting she's gonna die she's running through the city kind of trying to like get back to her hotel and at first I'm like okay this will be interesting and then it's kind of like she stumbles into a dude and then she kind of stumbles into Dante and then it becomes all about Dante again and then Julian shows up to punch him in the face and becomes all about that what did you do to her punch it's like what the fuck man it literally is there's so many good tropes in this book because of that too it was definitely the moment of like get your hands off of her and he like punches him for no reason and then drags her into the room and that's when he does the thing that's supposedly so romantic where he's like I will I'll make you drink my blood and then and then we'll both die for just one day and we'll split it yeah and then we'll spoon
While we're both dead. While we're both dead and dying. And in theory, I'm like, in theory, that could have been a really great sacrifice. You're right. That's a lot to do for someone. Although, that's the most boring death scene ever. Like, I realized after a while that the word death is synonymous with sleep just the way all the other words were decoys. She could have just as easily been sleeping. It was not that interesting. She died, supposedly. But it's just, like, no exploration into, like, what happened while she was dead? Did she, like, go experience, like, some other dead people? She dies, air quotes, and then she wakes up. Oh, no, she has the memories that were from the book. Oh, the dream from the book. Where she finds out that she gets to watch her grandparents make out. Yeah. That was the beginning. I like that. Tell her was like, I don't want to watch this part.
Because she's like, this is our grandparents making out. This is real gross. But it was just such a letdown. Because I was like, because she used the word death. And so I was like, high stakes. This is super cool. It's like kind of creepy. And like, it's weird. It was a really sinister part of like, Caravelle's not here to help you. You're dying. And you better get to your, you know, because everything's wearing against you. Time, everything. And it still managed to be so boring. Well, everything in this book, she went back to the boys. And then everything in this book works out for her. Yeah. Everything works out. So I wasn't even that concerned. I think maybe it's because it was the closest she came to really being in trouble. Yeah. But like.
And the thing is, like, she never even, like, it's fine if, like, the character, like, is challenged and then, like, fails and then, like, figures something out. But it's just, everything just worked out. There was no failure. Even, like, even at the end, after she thinks her sister is, like, dead and gone forever, she's like, I'm going to kill myself, too. I'm like, no, Katniss this shit, get a sword, and start killing people left and right. Like, Jesus Christ, you're in a dangerous place. Like, grab something and just, like, grab that chair. Start beating your dad with a chair. Do something. Jesus Christ. World Wrestling Federation style. Still don't fully understand how her sister came back.
Oh, off screen. Just doesn't matter. Yeah, she like walks into the room and you're like, what? Well, you loved me enough. Yeah, good thing. You loved me enough. And it granted, she didn't even have to say the words, I wish my sister were alive. She's just like, oh, you wanted it. So here I am. Well, I mean, she did go down to the body and like try to give it some of her blood. She gave it her blood. She tried to do the blood thing that Julian did. Yeah, but that didn't really work. But we don't really know what's going on. She didn't seem to find it as sexy the second time. The first time she was way too into it.
She's like, I'm in the middle of dying. I'm super uncomfortable. His fingers in my mouth full of blood. My fingers in his mouth full of blood. This is a sex moment for sure. Neither of them washed their hands. Neither of them washed their hands. Fuck knows what they were like carrying there. It was just, yeah. We're going to talk about each of the romance scenes and just how not romantic they were. Such a turnoff. Okay. Tell us about Donatella. Okay. So Donatella is Scarlet's sister in case anyone forgot. Yeah. Donatella slash Tella. Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtle sister. The bitchy blonde one. The bitchy blonde one. The useless blonde one I think is what I'll call her. She's useless. No, no. She.
We don't see her, but she actually does stuff. She seems like she would be useful. It's just that I found her pretty useless at the end, especially when Daniel Dangle came in and I was like, you didn't figure out the five days that you were with this guy that that's legend. I think that was part of the act. Oh, crap, you're right. I forgot. But that whole end was a little confusing. What is this bait and switch happening? And I did mostly judge her during that, so I'm remembering now. It's dangerous. And that's what I forgot. She was acting. She was acting stupid. But everyone was so stupid. I was like, okay, she's dumb too great. But no, she's the only one who really does anything out of all women. Well, I mean, so...
Caravelle, like, the whole book only happens supposedly because Scarlet has written Legend a letter every year since she was 11, being like, I really want to go, but it's okay if you don't send me an invitation. I just really want to go. Okay, thanks, bye. And then Donatella, at the end we find out, wrote Legend her own letter that was basically like, I bet you're a fucked up shit, but my sister really wants to go, so give us tickets. And then he's like, all right. Well, no, it was more like...
you're into some freaky shit but don't worry I am too let's make something really twisted together and he was like I am intrigued maybe I would have liked this book if it had been written from Tella's perspective but it just seemed like do you guys just want to rewrite the book and also there's a bit in this note I can't remember what I wrote but I wrote specifically about how annoying it was that she was oh yeah this book reeks of date rape and also Scarlett needs to get off her sister's ass Like, she spends so much time trying to protect Hela, and sometimes it's necessary, but most of the time it seems like Hela's doing just goddamn fine. I mean, she did leave when she heard them having really ruckus sex. She was like, okay, fine, you do you, and did leave at that point. But after banging on the door, and obviously she was trying to find her sister, she knew what was wrong with her, but still, even throughout all of it, it was just... I also, I don't know, I don't have a sister. So that's why. So there's probably, I have a brother, though, and I just feel like...
If I was, like, looking for him and, like, that worried about him, and apparently he was having breakfast sex, I'd be like, fucking deal with it. I'm coming in so I can see your face. Shut up. Let me in. It was a weird moment. Cover your dick. I'll be out in a second. Yeah, exactly. For a girl who's, like, obsessed with her sister, it was a weird moment to be like, I will give in now. Because she was embarrassed, supposedly. Although for a girl who's, like, constantly seems to be thinking about sex. Yeah. It was weird for her to be like, this is, she was supposed to be a prude, kind of. Like, she was supposed to be very reserved. I shouldn't say prude. She was supposed to be very reserved. But it still was weird. I was like, you are desperate to find your sister. There she is on the other side of the door. Just, like, touch base. I get it. She's fucking. But
Yeah, I just, like, I don't, I would, even for my brother, I'd be like, deal with it, I'm coming in. But then she forgets about her. Yeah. She just kind of forgets about her. Well, and she, there was, like, a good reason for her to be worried, because, like, supposedly Julian dropped Tella off at the island, went back for, um, whatever her name is, Scarlet. And then, when they came back to the island, Tella wasn't there, and, like, Scarlet specifically notices that there are no footprints left from Tella. So, like.
They did a 101 Dalmatians. Maybe something is wrong. She literally was gone from when Scarlet awoke from her comatose, like, chloroform stupor, so I'd be concerned if I had just been chloroformed and woke up in a boat and my sister wasn't there. Also, she was asleep for two days. Like, was someone monitoring her vitals? God, I hope so, because that's really bad for you. Also, the second that she was left alone in the boat with him, I was like, okay, so he's the guy. He's the one who met him. And, like, from the beginning, I could kind of tell, but I was really, I couldn't tell because he did not see me. He was really, like, the shittiest possible guy when you met him. It was an act. It was an act. That's right. Everything I want to rant about is the romance bit, so I'll just bide my time.
But, so at the end, it, like, turns out that Tella was part of the person that, like, orchestrated this. And I don't understand. She said, like, she wanted her sister to live. Yeah. Or something. The entire thing is just such a strange, like, what did you want to have happen to your sister? You wanted her to see you die? Were they all in on it? In the end. Yeah. Scarlett was in on it, right? Yeah. It's almost like, what was the point of this? What did we learn? Scarlett's in love with this jackass now? But she was supposed to be in love with Dante because he was the one that she was supposed to fall in love with. But she was supposed to be the bad boy. It was such a...
Bad, bad. It was just bad. It was bad. Yep. It was such a bad performance considering that everyone knew that they were performing. Also, can we talk about when she got her fortune read, though, how much of a bro the fortune teller was? He still dropped the work clue, quote unquote, of you have to follow the guy with the black heart, a.k.a. Dante, who has the black heart tattoo. But at the same time, he's like, you think Julian's cute?
You like him? You like Julian? And that was all she would do? I was, like, afterwards looking back, I'm like, that guy was a bro. He was just, like, checking in for his friend. Just like, yeah, you should go for that. You like him? You like him? He's got a big dick. He's a really cool guy. He literally was just kind of like, you're into that guy. Also, have you ever seen how, like, the sunlight bounces off of his hair and, like, you know, the muscles all chiseled there and I'm not crying? You know, just because everyone's straight in this book. You're right. I was like, you're right. Nigel was the queer character he must have been and he was secretly lusting after Julian and he just couldn't express his feelings. That would make me so much happier. Just don't pretend that that's the truth. I mean, he's covered in tattoos, so who knows? Like, I don't know. Nigel seems like
His fortune-telling skill is not that impressive because he's like, I see you're looking at the heart next to my lips and also the lock also next to my lips. I'm like, so she's looking at your mouth while you're talking? All this tells us is that she has social anxiety and doesn't like making eye contact. And also that you're kind of mostly naked and she's kind of looking at your lips. She's looking at your body covered in tattoos. I wonder why. Because you're covered in tattoos. And even his explanations, I can't remember the exact part, but there's a bit where he's trying to explain how the future works to her and he sums it all up, but it contradicts the things he just said, so it's not very well thought through. Well, I mean, there's the things that are actually the truth and then there's the things that he was scripted to say to everyone.
I mean, scripted to say to her to continue on with the shtick. This is also the scene where he asks her what she thinks of Julian, and she's like, he's the most attractive person I've ever met. And you're just like... You haven't been to a lot of places, have you? I told Audrey my contacts dried out because I rolled my eyes so much during this book. I was like, I gotta take these out. God damn it. Yeah, it was just...
It really was just frustrating watching her do these stupid things, because there were so many things that I figured out, like page 50 or guessed page 50, and then at page 170. I guessed about Donna's plot twist letter on page 128. There were so many plot twists that were letdowns. Donna's letter, or Tella's letter at the end where she's like, yeah, Donna would be a better nickname. Yeah! Tella's letter at the end where she's like, where she's the one that wrote to legend, I figured that out on page 128. Yeah, there's so many secrets. What happened? I don't remember, but in my little, like, journal-y thing, I have... Yeah, she leaves a note with a sign, someone leaves a note signed D, right? And she thought it was, no, no, she figured out it's Donatella. I thought it was Donatella. No, it's Darcy.
Oh, you're right. It is fantasy. There was something about, like, I don't remember what happened, but I was like, tell us. So my little note says, it wasn't Scarlet's letter that caught Legend's eye. It was Tella's. Then he went back and compared her letters to Tella's, which told him all the juicy details. So basically, I meant, like, he compared the sister's personalities and was like, this is the one I want to fuck with. Yeah. And then, like, this is the one I actually want to fuck. Literally, that's what he did. And then he arranged things accordingly. I think book two is essentially going to be Legend, like, trying to seduce Donatella. Or Scarlet. One of the two of them. No, no. Scarlet started with Julian, but it's going to be one of those horrible. But he's going to rip them apart. No, it's going to be one of those tropes where it's the brothers and the sisters end up together.
Oh, yeah, I forgot. Yeah, it's the sinister face. I am so not interested in legend. They built him up a lot, and they made him real uninteresting. We don't even know what he looks like. You're boring as fuck. But you never meet him. Technically not legend, but even if I feel like I don't know. Oh, that's right. You never meet him. No, he was the faceless date rape guy at the very end of the book where she's like, I'm really fucking drunk. And then some guy, like, dances to him. She's like, I guess I'll sleep with him. And then he disappears. And that was him. Yeah, that's right. Getting a note. Yeah, because the sinister note. It was heavy enough for her to feel. Yeah, well, obviously, Tella is, like, paying for this whole thing with something, so. Yeah. Yep. Oh, Jesus. Which.
Are you done with Donatella? Yeah, I'm done. And we can go on to Kathy's smut corner. I love the first sense that you have on that line for us. Yeah, it's just the first time. Did we already go through? Missed the boat. Yeah, missed the boat, encapsulated. And I think this is perfectly encapsulated with the kissing tent, which is past when she goes over to bro the fortune teller. Julian's like, OK, I'm going to go over to the kissing tent. And this is the thing. This is a teen book. It could be so much more. Like, the fact that it's only a kissing tent. Like, we probably are. Like, for people who read Wicked, the book. Well, isn't. Oh, yeah, Wicked. When you read Wicked, the book, you're probably a teenager. And you're like, huh, this is a weird.
tiger massage parlor no it's a weird fucking like it's a fuck den yeah it's a fuck den and there's bestiality yeah there's a fucking lot like there's munchkins and tigers and everything's in there and everything's in there and you're like what yeah you're just like this isn't wicked it's like That's what I'm considering, like, the base. Even though it's not a teen book, that's what I'm considering, like, the base. I mean, but a lot of teens read that book. Well, I read it as a teen. I read it as a teen. Can we do this map and just figure out where the sex den would be and write it all down? Because this map is full of so many buildings and there are six boring ones, but, like, I want to know where the sex den is in Caravelle. There's got to be one. There's got to. What the fuck? Yeah, what the fuck is a kiss? Like, maybe kissing tent, quote unquote. Yeah, did you find this? A giant rave, MDMA, flowing through the crowd. Everyone's just making out just, that's probably where you would get your, like, you know, representation of other, you know, pansexuality. Yeah, maybe the interesting people were doing something else. Yeah, like, maybe there was a sick club
So mundane. It's so boring. It's so carnival. It's like a carnival thing. But this is, like, but this is a sinister carnival. Yeah, but this is supposed to actually be. Go, like, take it up. Put it up 1,000. Like, come on. Make it actually vaguely sinister. Make it smutty. That's the other thing. So I think I was really, I think we were all frustrated by the fact that this book was mostly marketed as fantasy, romance, and Audrey, you said even horror. Yeah, some review I read said horror, and I was like.
Are you fucking kidding me? What part of this is horror? I don't know. She dies for two days. That's got to be scary, right? It's very scary when you go to sleep and then you wake up the next day. It's terrifying. There's already parts we mentioned in talking about it where you can see where the horror... There was a horror slant that she was going for that she just shot right past because she was, for some reason, really concerned about also making it... This book is lots of hopes and dreams. I mean, it wanted to be a lot of things. Okay, let's go back to the kissing tent and let's think about how they do... I guess they don't have money there. So think about it. Think about what a more dark, smutty...
over the top sexual like you have to trade something to get your carnal desires and it could be so great sorry carnal desires you were thinking that way i'm thinking more like you have to give up your self-respect you have to give up something like in a weird way yours was darker than mine yeah no like like it's not like like i don't know because i guess i don't want to like conflate self-respect and sex and stuff like that because you know it's all but like yeah it could have gone there's there's so many dark and wonderful things that like could have happened there and i was just like oh it's a kissing booth after watching the anime scale and see how good they were at dark i was like this is really underwhelming well and there was something about the whole thing that like the point of caraval was like let go and like experience your dark side or whatever but then at the very end there was this weird moralization of it where it was like the stuff you do at caraval stays with you and like basically implied like part of who you are yeah and it basically implied like if you cheat on your wife you're gonna regret it or whatever i became pregnant at the kissing dentist yeah i was like if this is a game for adults do whatever they want there should be more debauchery happening there's not enough debauchery Probably just humans. Just humans. Have you read Lord of the Flies? It could have been Hogsme. It could have been Hogsme with a bunch of people just running around by and stuff. It's Disney World. It's Disneyland. It's Disney World, but with enough drugs that I think I wrote down somewhere that it's just date rape in a bougie dress. Oh my god, that is it. That is it. The whole thing is just kind of like, are you having fun? No, here, have some of this. I don't know, it's probably good. And then she's like, oh, it's magic. I'm feeling really lightheaded. Oh my god, can we rename the book Date Rape in a Bougie Dress? Sure. When we rename it and rewrite it, fix everything about it. Oh my god, that's amazing. So that's what it'll be.
The episode titled Date Rape in a Bougie Dress by Stephanie Carver. Oh, boy. Yeah, it could kind of just look the same. I wouldn't have changed the cover much. It's pretty much the same, but I don't know. I'm just...
It could have been so dark and wonderful and smutty, but instead it's just... I think our main reason for being so mad is just because of how let down we were. How much we were, like, ready for it to be a thing that was good. Yeah, the premises were good. That's the thing. I was like, you're starting with so many totally viable ideas. I was ready to question myself and not believe anything, like the inside cover set. Heck yeah! Heck yeah! I was going through being like, maybe it's... Like, that was the only reason I read all the way through thinking maybe it could still be good because I couldn't tell what was real and what wasn't real. And then I got to the end and I was like, oh, it was all just kind of face value. Yeah, it was all, like, the same. Well, and it was interesting, too, because, like, there were... So part of my frustration with this is that she doesn't take the game seriously and acts, like, in the super
Why are you there then? Well, she was drugged and brought there. Oh, that's right. I forgot. Technically, she wasn't actually ever going to go to this. There's definitely a lot of like, this book is full of non-consent in being okay. But it reminded me, when I was thinking about it, it reminded me of The Labyrinth and Sarah's opinions, or the way she acted at the very beginning. I've actually never seen that movie, so we should watch it. Just keep it in mind while you explain. Delightful, it's about the Spanish Civil War. The Labyrinth? Really?
Oh, on Pan's Labyrinth? Yes, wrong one. Also good movie, but much more. Haven't seen that one either. Sorry, not the David Bowie one. I was like, delightful. No, the one where David Bowie walks around in tight pants. I was like, she was murdered at the end. So what you're saying is, we need a labyrinth marathon. Yeah, it's beautiful. Both of them. They're both great new movies. Back to back. That's a lot. But Sarah, the main character of the labyrinth, is kind of like this privileged white girl who's like, my life is really hard because I have a stepmom and my younger brother, and I have to babysit my younger brother. Like, the whole...
First world problems. I know. But, like, the point of the Labyrinth is it, like, challenges that. So, like, her entire thing in the Labyrinth is, like, this isn't fair. And by the end, she's like, it's not fair because life's not fair. And fuck this. I'm going to do what I want. She could have just waited until she was 22 and out of undergrad to learn that. But that, like, I just, like, Labyrinth explored that, like, your problems aren't real. Like, this dude's going to steal your brother and, like, you know, turn him into a goblin if you don't get him back. And there were, like, real consequences and it was, like, a real journey. This, she had, like, she learned nothing. And also, like, I'm sorry, I just feel like if your dad is physically abusive and you watched him murder one of your childhood friends, that you would...
Maybe be a little more realistic about the dark things that exist in the world. Oh, yeah. In general. And she just, like, displays no awareness of, like, people are shitty. Yeah. She's weirdly naive. Weirdly naive for someone whose father murdered someone else in front of her. Oh, yeah. Irritating. Yeah. If you want a good, like, carnival or whatever book to read, something like This Way comes by Ray Bradbury. It's, like, not...
romantic or anything like that, but it's light years ahead in terms of spooky carnival. I'm like doodling it down. I've actually not read The Night Circus. Have either of you read The Night Circus? No. Okay, then I have no idea how close that comparison is, so I won't even bother. But I did just really quickly want to say that one of the things, not just location about Caraval that pissed me off, but like, hey, J.D. Three, the rhyme or whatever it is, the clues that barely rhymed. And then she makes fun of it herself. Heck yeah. But you're like, oh no, honey. Yeah. Like, that was so bad. Like, you shouldn't have. They shouldn't put it in. The clues are really bad and lame. The rhyme's really bad and lame. So that's why I was like, it's not even like...
Like, I remember my note literally says, what a boring Caraval greeting. It didn't even rhyme. J.K. would have had a killer rhyme. J.K. Rowling would have nailed that rhyme. Yeah, it's true. But it's literally, can anyone find the card, too, that she kept looking at that had the rhymes? It starts with, this girl was last seen with Legend. And now, of course, I can't find it even though I wrote down the page. But it's so boring. The rhymes are really like, if a child had to make a rhyme, they would do it this way. So it's like, this girl was last seen with Legend. 131. Thank you. This is your first clue on the road to find her. Others will not be so easy to retrieve. Some will make you question your sanity and all that you believe.
Clue number two you'll discover in the rubble of her departure. Number three you must earn. Number four will cost you something valuable. And number five requires a leap of faith. Most of you will fail, but one will surely succeed. You have five nights to find the four remaining clues, and then the girl, and Legend's wish will be yours. So there was one rhyme. And then the little bit in the beginning. Oh, sorry, the little bit in the beginning. Oh, that's okay. You have a well and hell and rich. And then she literally gave up halfway through. Literally, this girl was last seen with Legend. If you catch her, you'll catch him as well. Of course, you may have to venture through hell, but if you succeed, you may find yourself rich. This year's winner will be granted one wish.
That's really sad. That's really sad. I remember reading through it going, oh, is this? Because I was like, maybe it's like Ridley. And I'll have to figure, I mean, I looked at this for a minute. And before I was like, oh, no, it really is just exactly what it said, what it appears to be. And what it appears to be is really disappointing. Yeah, and there's like, that was the thing. You're like, oh, maybe there's a riddle in it. And then as the book progresses, you're like, nope, it's exactly what it was. So there was no layers to this. The biggest surprise depth to this book was the weird staff tunnels. Yes.
Which we don't even see for the most part. She barely is in them. Like, two encounters happen in them and she doesn't really go that far into them. So it was just, like, even that bit of it could have made it more of a game if you'd even, like, done the riddles better or made it more like Seeky and Searchy because it was, like, definitely more like murder mystery, supposedly. But she didn't even try to go that route. And so, like, I just remember being like, this could have been so magical. And, like, rhymes always give me chills no matter how bad they are.
Unless they're really, really, really not good. And this was so underwhelming. Just underwhelming is my word. It's such a bummer because I don't like to hate on books. And I don't think I would say I hated this book. I just would if I would never prioritize this book. It disappointed me. Disappointed. That's the word. It's like when your mom's like, I'm not mad. I'm just disappointed. It's like that. I'm not mad at you, Stephanie. I'm just disappointed. Before we wrap up, do we want to?
zip back and talk about the boat scene where she almost drowns. I wanted to talk about all the romance, actually. I just wanted to very quickly go through each romance scene and name them and talk about why they're not sexy. First romance scene is the one after she's been chloroformed. She wakes up on a boat and then they have to, the boat's suddenly sinking and they have to jump into the water. Inexplicably suddenly sinking very quickly. In winter, by the way, this water is ice fucking cold. Yep. And so Julian is like, can you swim? You better hurry up because the boat's sinking. You better get all your clothes off. And that's like a moment where they're like, take all your clothes off. And she's like, I can't. I'm embarrassed. I'm a lady. But like, I'm like, priorities. Take them off. Take off your corset. So basically Julian like dives away and she kind of can't get her clothes fast enough. So she's just drowning in her corset.
Like, apparently, I guess it gets to the point where she's like, I guess it's too late. I'll just jump in with my clothes on. With a corset and full petticoats, which if you've never seen like Pirates of the Caribbean or read any book about the petticoat times, you can't swim in those. No, I am sure she sank like a stone. She was sinking and drowning. And then he comes back and he's like, what did he say? She's like, you left me. And he's like, I thought you could swim. And I was like.
She was clearly thrashing around in her dress. Like, whether or not she can swim is irrelevant to the situation right now. I mean, he's been through, what, 40 pages of being told that she's sensible? I think he expected her to be sensible. Well, and to be fair, she was like, can you swim? And she was like, yeah, I grew up on an island. And then immediately the author started rolling that back and she was like, I don't know if I've ever swam that far before. And I was like, then why the fuck did you say you can swim in? Why is this nutty? Also, my mother was born on Jamaica and she and my aunt both cannot swim. So, island does not necessarily mean. They grew up in Kingston. Jamaica's fucking huge. So, yeah. Weren't really near that much water. Also did not like water.
Yeah, I mean, my dad's from Michigan. So she's drowning. He comes back to cut her out of her clothes with a knife. And that's when she's like, this is sexy time. Which also, like, I do not know how the physics of that works. Without him gutting her. Without him gutting her and without her still drowning and sinking. Yes. Because, like, you. I think I pictured them underwater and he just put the lid. But they had just been talking. Yeah. So it sounds like, in a way, she had to be somehow getting some air. Yeah, because she was in the middle of drowning. So here's what I'm imagining. Thrashing. Him with his arm around her waist trying to, like, hold her still so she doesn't drown him. And then the knife, which she said she felt the tip go from her chest down to, like, her waistband. And all I'm like. To her hips. If you can feel the tip and you're in ice cold water and he's behind you
He's going to stab you. My main concern would be being gutted. My main concern would be that the water is negative 32 degrees and like, how can you even feel sexy in negative 32 degree weather? But she was like, all she focused on was that Julian's arm was wrapped around her waist and she just had never been this close to a boy before. I could not fathom. Yep. So like, and also what happens when you shouldn't actually try and rescue a drowning person unless you've been trained because they will try and climb up you. That's why I assumed he was behind her too because if he was in front of her, I assume she would have just been like climbing over the top of the head. No, she would have been so overcome by the fact that she was near a boy that she just froze. I don't know. So first instance of her being like, my life's cool, but mostly this guy, I'm into this guy. Yeah. Second instance of romance, I think it's after he gets clocked over the head by that guy
drink back and he comes back to the room with a head wound yeah and she's like trying to take care of him and he does this weird trick where he's like there's blood all over me better check my stomach wound and like lifts up his shirt and she's like trying to clean off all the blood and then he's like nah I just want you to touch my stomach you don't remember that bit no I remember that bit and I'm like laughing because it's just like That's fucking weird. And she kind of was like, oh, okay. That was another moment where she was like, kind of paid. And that ends up a stomach. And that was like, not enough, like, you're a dick for doing that to me. And also, in that point, I'm like, you're currently suffering from a head wound. I'm just going to focus right now on the head wound. This isn't an attractive time. You're covered in blood. Third one. Some people are into that. Some people are totally into that. Some people are. I'm not, you know. Well, it's just not the first thing I could. Not the first place most people go. Actually, when I was thinking about what to say when you were going to ask why should you read this book, one of my thoughts was if you're like a budding sadomasochist and you're into that, read it. I don't know. Because it seems like during all the violent bits, but it more seems like they're trying to trick you into
her will. The whole point is like, it's against her will. She doesn't want to love him, but she does anyway. But like, it's at times when I don't think anybody. So like, the second time Julian's bleeding, no sexy time. Third time is the time after she's dying where he like puts her bleeding finger in her mouth and she puts her bleeding. There's lots of bleeding and it's almost like empirically dying. Dying, like not comfortably dying. Like they're describing how she's like, I feel terrible. I feel like I'm dying. So she's dying. They're both dying. They're like turning gray. Their organs are stopping. They're in their room lying down. But she is like, boy, I wish I wasn't dying so we could do more. Yeah. I'm spooning.
So, like, that one. And they were just really into the bloodsharing thing. Like, she focused on that a whole bunch. And I was like, I mean, it's not a vampire book. So I'm kind of curious why you decided this was what people were going to be into. Yeah. And then it gave her weird powers to, like, feel or see. Feel his emotions for, like, ten minutes or whatever. But, like, what? Yeah. Then there were more feelings. And then there was the, oh, yes, the final bit that I consider to be. These are all the bits that I think were women's when they focused on Scarlett's feelings of. I'm going to just call it lust because there's no romance. Yeah. It was the time they were in the tunnels. And they had to hide in this tiny room. Very, uh.
Elias and Laya style when they were running in Ember in the Ashes but a million times worse because they squeeze in and the lulls start to like slowly realize that they're slowly crushing them and she's focusing on that kind of but mostly she's like no I'm pressed against Julie in this way and like she's trying to find the dot knob but he's actually like touching her butt and that's what she's thinking I was just like by then I was so sick of Scarlet that I wasn't even giving her the benefit of that but I was like you are the worst you are the worst this is the worst and all of these romance scenes are gross and bleedy and I don't get why you think this is romantic so in the end I would say this book had no romance in it oh yeah zero smut Zero smut, zero romance. They're not, yeah, he doesn't love her. Yeah, there's also no smut. At the very least, I thought that it would be really smutty. I was like, okay, so lust is at least talked about. Maybe someone will have sex later. No, no smut, no romance. It's not for that if you're into that. It's not healthy romance. Yes, so I really wanted to go over that just to be like, I just want everyone to be aware this is not what romance looks like in case you're new to romance. Well, and that's totally fair because this is aimed at teens who are new to romance. And so that's a totally valid thing to be like, this isn't how people who actually care about you should be behaving. Oh yeah, definitely. Because it's not. It's a problematic book.
Yeah. A bunch of children just filed into the other room and are watching us record, which is great. No, really? Yeah. It looks like people from...
The team program? I'm super glad. I can't see them. Yeah, you're hitting me in the corner, so it's just the best situation. Oh, God. But anyway, thank you, everyone, for listening to us rant for an hour plus a few minutes. Thank you so much for all of your patience for our screaming. I'm going to go read, like, 60 romance novels because I just need... Palate cleanser. Palate cleanser. I need fake romance that doesn't suck. Oh, my God. Yeah, you can tell she definitely doesn't have kids looking at her right now if we're saying that. Please rate and review us on iTunes. It'll be really helpful to us just to, you know... Get the word out. Yeah, and we can actually see if people are enjoying it. If you have any books or suggestions for us, fellowyouths at gmail.com. It's...
Really cool. And the next book in line is mine. So I get to choose? Okay. Please let there be some fun in this one. Kind of. It's fine. It's fine. Kind of. Okay. So I have a long-term plan for my, like, recommendations. Long time. Cool. Yeah. But the next book in line is going to be from the goddess Tamara motherfucking Pierce. Audrey is really pleased by that added middle name. Yeah.
Granted, she's problematic. She has her own issues sometimes. I'm talking about New Mare for this. People who know the books will know. I don't know enough about this particular instance. I read her books, but not. Stork Mage. Yeah, the Jeff Goldblum Mage. Let's just know. To be honest. Okay, but anyway, so what I'm going to suggest we read are the first two books in the Song of the Lioness Quartet. It's because they're shorter. This was back before teen books could be long. Yeah, and I think that that one overlapped the tiniest bit with youth, so they weren't sure. It kind of goes a little bit. The second one is her as a teenager. The first one is her as a child. But honestly, if you haven't read these books, these books, I would say, are the canon.
For fantasy teen lit. Every single teen book that has been written after that and has a castle, has royalty, or has magic is going to be in some way based on these books. Or influenced at the very least. I guess not based on it. Heavily influenced. It's crazy. I was, once again, stress-hate reading a lot of books this past weekend. I kept throwing them down because I'm like, this is just an inferior Tamara Pierce book. This is just a terrible one. And sometimes there are other books where the authors do a good job, which is going to be a book series I'm suggesting.
after we read all these. That's why I'm building up to this. Long con for real. I just really think that you need to get this base if you haven't read it before in order to fully appreciate everything that comes later. Everything. Everything. I'm excited because I read Tamara Pierce as a teen and like...
formative. I love her. I'm so ready to be excited as I read a book. I'm so ready to not be reading a book and feeling like I'm just taking a value. Oh, yeah. Also, like, Audrey read This Is Formative Years. I didn't read them until I was 22. And I was like, you should read these books. They're great. Actually, no, I'd already read them. And do they still hold up for you? Oh, yeah. Not all of them. I only read the Atlanta books and then you convinced me to read the rest. The Atlanta books are the Song of the Lioness. These are the ones I'm doing. It's just, it's so good.
This is something, especially if you love Teen Lit, especially if you love any fantasy, this is something you need to have in your back pocket. It's just so good. And once you read the first two books, I guarantee you're going to want to read the next two as well. But for the purposes of our discussion, the first two books. Cool. Yeah. And I'm excited. I'm so excited for this. Going to do it. I'm excited for any fantasy always, especially when the last fantasy book was read with fake fantasy.
Fake magic in it. That was the other thing about magic in this book. Fake fantasy with fake magic. It wasn't real magic. There is no magic in this book except apparently on Legends Island and whatever witch gave him his powers. They're like, what the fuck? And a shape-shifting dress. Literally the only thing. I was going to talk about that too really quickly. I'm not going to, but I was going to talk about the dress as like, that would have been a really solid prop, like, especially for something that's supposed to be so dramatic. Built-in costume change dress, that could have been so great. But mostly what it did was just like, put revealing stuff on her when boys were around. Yeah, try and embarrass her. What the fuck, dress? Be on my team. I know. You're out in the hallway. I think I'll put you in a negligee now because there's a dude around. And like, just the stupidest shit. I just feel like if she was like a real, like one of us,
at and it became slutty we'd just be like the fuck there aren't even pockets in this thing yeah so true but I think so that dress thing though is like part of why this book is fucking creepy and it's because the dress I think after reading the whole thing I was like the dress was supposed to reflect her true feelings so that meant she was attracted to that dude and so like that's fucking weird yeah like it's weird like she then said she was uncomfortable dude yeah that's the thing she spends she spends a lot of time having uncomfortable feelings but then the book is like she's enjoying but actually she likes it I don't like that it's creepy god I mean, one of the benefits about being a girl is that you have no outwardly visible signs that you are sexually attracted to someone. You don't pop a bone. Yeah, that is true, although I've heard that guys have figured out pretty clever ways to disguise. So I feel like if I was a lady and that was a problem, smart ladies would figure it out too. Also, I get pretty sweaty, so I feel like it's really obvious. I mean, I'm just sweaty all the time. Just constantly sweating, so that's how Kathy disguises it. Her natural musk disguises it.
Oh, my God. One of my old roommates, she was just like, she came back and she was just like, her face was lit up so happy. And I was like, what's up with you? And she's like, oh, my God. I discovered extra strength deodorant. This has changed my life. She was so happy. True facts. Real things. I was just like, precious angel. These are real things that people need. I remember getting excited about deodorant to friends at school in middle school. I was like, you guys, we're in deodorant today. And I bet they were like, oh, thank God. Anyway. Sorry, wrap this up. Before we start talking about more stuff that we hate about this book. I think it's best to just let this one go and be like, guys, if you have anything else to do that day, just don't read this one.
have a good one everyone thanks for listening bye