You're listening to the Money Web SAFM market update podcast. The company known as Ferroglobe decided that despite the electricity reprieve granted to them by ESCOM that they would continue with the plans to mothball their South African smelting furnaces. They've cited weak demand from local steel makers and this has made the business or the restart of these smelters far too risky. Now this puts 350 direct jobs at risk alongside all the other indirect jobs in that ecosystem. We're going to take a closer look at this and see if we can make sense of it with...
met with energy expert Prof. Vali Pariachi joins me on the line now to see what we make of this. Prof. Pariachi, lovely having you on the show as always. Thanks so much for taking the time. Your initial thoughts on these developments? I remember when we initially looked at ESCOM's granting of that reprieve, these concerns were raised, but they didn't seem to be this significant at the time. Good afternoon, Jimmy, and thank you for inviting me to your show. Yes, this matter, this subject...
has been in the landscape for some time now, a year, two years. And unfortunately, it's become a very complex subject matter because especially if you look at the economy, you look at ESCOM, you look at the, in this case, Federal Globe, you know, the challenges that does not allow each one of them to come up with a... what's the word, a proper solution, has been hanging in the air for some time. And I've been quite close to this. Obviously, if you look at what I call the energy-intensive user group companies, and Federal Group is one of them, their input costs paramount to be competitive, together with, on the output side, having the proper demand. Now, on both those fronts, it's been challenging. And also, although ESCOM and government have been trying their best.
to alleviate this. They can only go so far to me, you know, because there are unintended consequences for this. Now, I'm also very close to the municipality, which is ESCOM's number one customer, and they're not very happy. that these companies get these discounts, although I support the discounts because of the economy and they create jobs. But in life, there's no such thing as a free lunch. And when you give discounts on one end, that company needs to survive. They need their balance sheet, etc. So there's a view that it could be offset by making other customers pay. So that's why I say, Jimmy, it's a very complex subject. And unless there's a very carefully thought of strategy on all fronts, this matter is going to continue. And my final point is, I go back to the 90s.
early 2000s when I was still at ESCOM. And there ESCOM made a conscious decision when there was excess supply, excess supply available to offer a significantly discounted LCCD price, which was, for recall, 45% below inflation. And this increased the demand. And we had a number of energy intensive vehicle companies that came into the country. But that was not sustainable. And I would argue that ESCOM is playing catch up now.
I want to take a look at the implications for a company like Ferret Loeb. They recently concluded a Section 189a retrenchment proceeding, and that affected some of the jobs. This mothballing of these smelters, rather, these smelter assets, has the potential to put in place more job cuts or to put more jobs at risk. From Ferret Loeb's perspective, they, as I mentioned earlier, have cited weak demand. Eskom's perspective has also said that the smelters are necessary to keep running for their own demand reasons, and it seems as though the common solution here that resolves the problem is the steel side of it, the infrastructure side of it.
and the demand that needs to come through from there because all the other players in the ecosystem then are able to get something done in their own businesses. To your point around being able to understand the longer-term implications or having more than just the standard implications we see, how do we see this decision by Ferrod Loeb potentially affecting other areas of the markets? Yes, to answer your question, it would affect other parts of the market. I mean, as indicated, these companies, they create a lot of jobs. They contribute to the economy. They've been doing so for many years. And also, ironically, they're big, what I call, guzzlers of electricity. So they would actually create a lot more significant revenue stream for ESCO. So by not boiling, etc., then all of these are cut off. Now, also, these companies are capital-intensive, asset-intensive, and they need long-term...
stable supply of electricity, which hasn't been the case. As you know, for the last few years, we had significant load shedding, which I would argue exacerbated and put these companies in the state they are. And going forward, I think, has come from tearing the leaf. But the other parts of the economy are not doing well. I mean, our GDP is about 0,5%. At the moment, it needs to be 1, 2, 3%, so that the demand increases for these kind of companies. And given the erratic nature of the economy...
these companies can't factor that or can't mitigate that risk to the extent that they could continue. So it's a significant impact on their business. And to your point, it impacts on other aspects of the economy, taxes and all of that. And more importantly, job creation, Jimmy. Prof. Paryachi, before I let you go, I want to take a look at what this then means going back to the drawing table, I suppose, for the likes of ESCOM. They were dependent on this revenue, as you alluded to, as this was one of their big...
potential sources of revenues. And you touched on the fact that they'd have to explore new markets around this. The broader implication on that, if they're unable to find those new markets, we know there's a new pricing policy plan in place from an electricity perspective. The Minister of Electricity confirmed that. But to be able to lose such a significant player as the Ferroglobe business at an industry level, what does that then mean for the broader South African economy and ESCOM in particular?
I think being long in the sector and industry, the greater challenge is that I think these companies, the ERUG, energy intensive user group companies, require more price certainty. I'm reminded of an example a few years ago where one of the big binding houses had relocated this military to Malaysia because they could not get a... long-term price certainty trajectory path from ESCO. ESCO could only give them a three-year in terms of the PFMA, etc. So this company went to Malaysia, KL, Kalalempa, and located the smelter. But they got, if I'm correct, a 20-year price path, but it was not a cheap price path to me. It was a price path that gave them absolute certainty to budget properly, although it was expensive. So it was expensive, but it gave them price certainty for 20 years, which they were able to manage their risk.
and their budgets, and they're relocated. So what I'm saying is that price certainty, which I think is embedded in the new draft energy pricing policy you've alluded to, all the day they talk about 10 years, maybe I would still argue that we should go for 20 years. And so that should be critical over and above. to also having cheaper prices. And of course, that must also come with a reliable network, resilient network, stable network, so that these customers can do that. And also government policy must facilitate the landscape. And I gave you an example where the 90s government, albeit it's come back to buy desktop, but at least they've created an environment with 5% below inflation at the time. So I think there maybe have to be some give and take here and there.
without throwing the baby away with the bathwater. So in finality, this cannot continue. This data cannot continue because we will continuously have EIUG companies mothballing. But the final point, I understand that in the 19th century, 2000, we had 80 smelters that were thriving, vibrant, in the economy. I understand now we only have 11 because of the reasons that we're talking about. Jimmy.
Some serious implications of decisions that affect economic growth. They affect jobs. They affect all manner of conversations within the South African economy. And we'll have to see how it is that Ferroglobe navigates this challenging time from their perspective. For the moment, we'll leave this conversation on that note. Energy expert Prof. Vali Pariyachi joining us to take a look at Ferroglobe's decision despite having reprieve from ESCOM to mothball their emalatleni smelters. You've been listening to another MoneyWeb SAFM market update podcast, uploaded weekdays at 7pm.
For more MoneyWeb podcasts, go to moneyweb.co.za or the app and follow MoneyWeb News for daily updates.