Skip to content
Fighting News Fatigue episode artwork

Jun 23, 2022 31 min

Fighting News Fatigue

from Fourth Estate Hosted by 2SER

This week we are discussing news fatigue and what the Digital News Report: Australian 2022 results say about Australians' trust in the media. Marlene Even spoke with Dr Kieran McGuinness, the Digital News Report Postdoctoral Fellow at the News & Media Research Centre at the University of Canberra.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Fighting News Fatigue

0:00 31:31
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Hello and welcome to Fourth Estate, a show about journalism. We are coming to you from 2SER in Sydney on the Gadigal lands of the Eora nation, right across Australia on the Community Radio Network and directly to your device across the globe via podcast. I'm Marlene Even. We all have moments where the news can feel overwhelming.

You might even have friends and family that downright avoid the news. Some add a fatigue, others add a frustration, and of course there are some that are just not that interested. In the annual Digital News Report, more than two-thirds of Australians surveyed are actively avoiding the news. So what implications does this have for the media industry?

The Digital News Report is a comprehensive global study that comes out of the Reuters Institute for the Study of Journalism at the University of Oxford. In Australia, academics at the University of Canberra's News and Media Research Centre unpack the national findings. This week we are asking why some people are tuning out or avoiding the news altogether and what the Australian Digital News Report findings say about Australians' trust in the media. To answer all this and more, we are joined by Dr.

Kieran McInnes, the Digital News Report postdoctoral fellow at the News and Media Research Centre at the University of Canberra. Kieran, welcome to For The State. Thanks very much for having me, Marlene. Now this report is a big annual event for media research.

So can I start by asking for a bit of context on the Australian audience? Are we heavy news consumers or light news consumers and how do we compare to other countries? Australians are among the lightest news consumers in the world. But we have slightly improved from last year.

We're no longer the lightest in the world. We do tend to linger down the bottom. We are less interested in news generally, but that's part of a global declining interest in news across many different countries. In terms of the media report, can you give us a quick scope of what this report is?

Across 46 countries, how is it put together? So the Digital News Report project is a survey of audiences and it asks questions about news consumption, media use and perspectives on journalism. So this is the eighth year that we've conducted the survey in Australia, in collaboration with the Reuters Institute for the Study of Journalism at the University of Oxford. And it's been running since 2012.

So the Australian survey is an online sample of about 2000 individuals with a panel being provided by UGov. And we wait the sample by age, gender, region and education level, as well as voting history, so that it is a representative cross-section of the community. And the report found that more than two-thirds of Australian surveys are avoiding the news, which is quite alarming. Do we know why that is?

So news avoidance is quite high in Australia and it has been increasing over the years. So we asked this question before in 2017 and 2019. And then in 2017, only 57% of Australians said that they often, sometimes or occasionally avoid news, that jumped to 62% in 2019 and it's jumped to 68% in 2022. So the number one reason why people say that they avoid news is because there's too much coverage of subjects like politics and coronavirus.

This is followed very closely by people saying that the news has a very negative effect on their mood and that they are worn out by the amount of news there is these days. Women and younger people are slightly more likely to avoid news than other demographics. And in general, under 35s are the most likely to be avoiding news. And there are some sort of important differences in reasoning between men and women as well.

So women are much more likely to say that they are avoiding it because there is too much coverage of subjects like politics and coronavirus than men. Whereas men are more likely to say they're avoiding it because it is untrustworthy or biased. That's really interesting that there's that disparity between men and women for these different reasons. Is there a difference in generations?

So yeah, absolutely. Gen Y are the biggest news murders. About 79% of Gen Y say they often sometimes or occasionally avoid news. And the least likely to avoid news, although it's 76 plus 79% say that they avoid using that generation.

And I wonder, is this necessarily a bad thing? I mean, over the last couple of years, we've seen a lot of attention towards recommending people to limit their doom-scrolling for the sake of mental health. So is news avoidance necessarily a bad thing? I think it's quite difficult because as researchers, we don't want to make qualitative judgments about whether any particular choice a consumer makes is good or bad.

Certainly, I think in my personal view, it may be a bad thing in terms of people's knowledge and awareness of an ability to participate in communities and societies and ability to participate in democracy. There certainly is some issue there that may cause concern, particularly for academics and politicians that more and more people are actually switching off and not engaging in public discourse. And it's such maybe less likely to have an informed opinion when they go to the polling booths. And have we seen a shift in Australian news consumption over the years?

You mentioned there at the start that Australians have quite light news consumption. Has it changed? And could you tell us about that COVID trust bump? Yes, and news consumption increased quite significantly in the early part of 2020.

So we did another study in April of 2020 that saw general trusts in news rise to 53%, which is quite high. News consumption also really skyrocketed in that period of time. And this was a time when there was more or less sort of a consensus in politics. And a lot of the news reporting was quite informational and focused.

A lot of the reporting was about ways that you could stay safe from COVID-19 and stay healthy and do social distancing and take care of yourself. But when we looked again in 2021, as things were starting to return back to COVID-normal, trust had decreased quite significantly, as well as a news consumption decreased quite significantly. Trust would return back to 43% in 2021 and is 41% now. Right.

So we are going back down then. The trend is decreasing back to pre-COVID levels. Yes, that's correct. We are sort of returning to the long-term average, which is a sort of slow decline in trust in Australia.

The interesting part about this study is to think about with the news avoidance, what is in the media's control and what is kind of outside of the media's control? What is it about the way that the media is reporting? And what is it just about the fact that we've got COVID, we've got natural disasters, we've got all these big events, we've got all these events happening. So in terms of what the media can control, does this news avoidance reflect a disconnect between the media and their audience?

I think it represents a disconnection that may have already been there, as well as a growing reliance on social media and people sort of naturalizing into an environment online, which is a very low trust space for news. Certainly, when we look at trust overseas, some of the countries with the lowest levels of trust and news are the ones that have the most partisan and polarized media environments. Finland has a very, very high level of trust, 69% of people there say that they trust news. And something that's characteristic about Finland has been very consensus-based media and consensus-based politics, with very few instances of people saying that the media, disparaging the media as being fake news.

Whereas the USA has the lowest level of trust in news and world, 26% of people there say that they trust news generally. And it's particularly low because those right-wing audiences are very, very low in trust, only about 14% of right-wing audiences in the US say that they trust news. However, there are other factors that I think are more within the control of individual journalists than just the broader political and partisan environment. Certainly, journalists need to think about two sort of factors.

One is, are they providing the news that people are most interested in? And the second is, are they providing news that reflects the audience that they are speaking to? And this is sort of something that has come up in terms of motivations for accessing news and data for this year's report. And in last year's report, we looked at diversity in representation and perceptions of trust as they're related to people seeming themselves to be adequately and fairly covered in news.

And that's interesting because when you look at the groups that are avoiding the news the most, you mentioned the women and Gen Y, Gen Z, is that the disconnect with those particular audiences? Is that possibly why we're seeing them avoid the news? I do think that there is a very strong possibility. So we do know from the data from last year's digital news report that women were much more likely to say that they weren't receiving enough coverage and very particularly young women said that they weren't being covered fairly, much more so than men.

People of particularly from regional areas said that they weren't receiving enough coverage and that they weren't being fairly covered either. The interesting factor is that those who did feel that they were being fairly covered by age, by gender or by ethnicity were much more likely to say that they trusted news. Those who thought that they were being unfairly covered, particularly people who thought that their gender or their ethnicity was being unfairly covered, were more likely to distrust the news. And I think it's also a great opportunity to reach those audiences.

What comes to my mind is thinking about the Guardian Australia's use of TikTok or the Daily Ours using Instagram to get to their audiences. And that's like a gap in the market where they are providing explainers and information to particularly young audiences and providing that content to those audiences where they are. So effectively going to the audience rather than asking the audience to come to them. Yeah, we have been doing a fair bit of research in the last 20 years on diversity and representation in the Australian news industry.

And it is sort of a case of repeatedly people saying again and again, particularly for senior management positions, there is low representation for women. And in the newsroom, there is an underrepresentation for people from culturally and linguistically diverse backgrounds. And many of us sort of scratch our heads and say, you know, what's the issue here? We have 50% of Australians, more than 50% of Australians are women.

And on the 30% of Australians are born overseas. Why doesn't the news industry reflect the population that it's actually supposed to be serving? You're listening to Fourth Estate on the Community Radio Network. This week we're talking about news fatigue and the annual digital news report with Dr.

Keiran McInnes. Now I want to touch on an interesting finding in that report, which is one of the topics that Australians are most interested in, which is local news. And that's actually above the global average. So can we dig into that for a bit?

What impact does that have on, I guess, our national media identity? I think it's quite tough because in recent years we've seen a slow centralization of news production, particularly as regional newsrooms are closing and more jobs heading to the metro and the urban areas. We also see a consolidation of brands and a consolidation of certain jobs within the newsroom where you're seeing certain roles being combined into one overarching role, rather than being split out into different beats that would be able to cover more specific parts of the community. It is quite interesting that local news is still sort of king in Australia.

That seems like it might be a remnant of the print and television broadcasting era when we talk about social media also rising in the ranks. But if news outlets are not offering local news, then people will find alternatives. And that's kind of where alternative news sources and social media have really broken in and started stealing a fair bit of the market by providing local news alternatives that the national coverage do not. And I suppose with the future concentration of media in this country, we are seeing local news and news choices actually decreasing.

So if the trend showing many Australians are switching off from the news continues, is the media industry shooting itself in the foot? I wouldn't necessarily say that they're shooting themselves in the foot. I think it has a lot to do with their choice of which business model that they want to and each outlet, which business model they want to actually adopt in the future. Certainly, some outlets have gone down the route of targeting smaller but very loyal groups of audience members and others have decided to go down a route that is more generalist approaching as broad an audience as you possibly can.

And there are varying opinions on whether either route have been financially successful, particularly given that paying for news in Australia is very low globally speaking. It did increase this year but still only 18% of Australians say that they pay for news. We are still very much dependent on advertising dollars and advertising is something that has changed irrevocably because of the dominance of digital giants such as Google and Facebook. Everybody at the moment is sort of holding their breath, particularly with the introduction of the news media bargaining code to see what will happen yet and to see how that code will actually reshape the landscape in the media industry.

So I don't think that anyone can say at this point that anyone has shot themselves in the foot because there's so much changing in the industry right as we speak that's calling me three or four different reports later and I might be able to give you an answer but right now we don't really know. And I suppose coming back to that idea that Australia's interest in the local news is above the global average. Why do you think Australia has this interest compared to other countries? I think that there are two factors.

One is obviously to do with how regionally distinct Australia is. I think newsrooms have always been dominated by cities rather than by national sort of mastheads. We've always had major news outlets headquartered in Sydney and Melbourne and that sort of filters down to the lower levels as well and it used to be that every country town in New South Wales and Victoria had its own masthead. So there's a long tradition of isolated regional areas and very long geographic sort of jumps in Australia that would lead to a sort of disparate media system.

We also have a very strong tradition of public broadcasting which is somewhat unique in the world. Not every country has a strong public broadcaster and a broadcasting system as Australia does and our public broadcaster has made a lot of effort to sort of go out into local and regional areas and set up branches in those areas and in particular for radio that's still a big source of local news in regional areas is ABC radio. And where does this fit in with Australian's trust or the media? Because I noted that in the report local and regional newspapers as well as ABC and SBS are among the most trusted news brands.

So I suppose I'm wondering if covering local issues is a part of that trust. I would certainly agree that given that Australians are saying the top reason that they're most interested in news is local news that they're going to be most trusting towards the outlets that give them what they want and right now those outlets that are working the hardest to produce local news tend to be the smaller town and smaller regional area local broadcasters and local newspapers and public broadcasters. I think another factor as well is that when we look at the Australian media landscape as a whole it is actually much less polarized than the United States or even many other countries in the world. We have a relatively centrist population and most of that centrist audience is consuming the mainstream 6pm bulletins on TV and the larger online news outlets and the larger public broadcasters.

And for the most part we don't have large media outlets that are appealing to the fringes in a heavily polarized media environment in the way that you would see in the US. And because we know that there is a link to partisanship and polarization and trust in media that sort of leaves Australian opposition where we are actually much less polarized than many people think we are. And this does lend to more impartial and nonpartisan reporting which does have a link to trust in news as well. I do want to go back to the basics now and the fundamental question of why do we listen to the news?

Why do we keep up with the news? And Australians mostly feel a duty to keep themselves informed and to learn about new things. And this idea of consuming news due to a sense of duty is fascinating. I find that's really interesting.

Is that reflected in other countries? So it's interesting Australia is actually one of the highest in the world to say that we feel that we have a duty to keep ourselves informed about the news. There are a few countries that are higher than us. Portugal for example 55 said that.

Denmark 48%. But Australia is pretty high at 45% of the population saying that there's a little bit of a contrast where many of the countries that are not higher in saying that they have a duty are slightly higher in saying that they feel it's more about entertainment and fun. For example Taiwan and Thailand in Taiwan 37 said that they find it often entertaining and fun while only 22% said that they felt they had a duty to keep themselves informed. In Thailand 36% said entertainment and fun.

Only 17% said that they felt a duty to keep themselves informed. I think there's a lot of factors that could explain this but my personal view is that it may have a lot to do with established habits of consumption. So Australians are very sort of rusted on to our habits and one of the things that's a core habit for Australians is switching on the 6pm bulletin on TV in the evening and sort of watching through that before we actually move on to the entertainment and the fun of light TV programming afterwards. TV is still one of the high the top ways to get news in Australia and I think it's something that people often forget.

And radio as well as an important small way of getting used. It's less than much less than TV but people stick to those routines of listening to the radio in the morning when they're driving to work and watching the 6pm bulletin when they get home before dinner and because they do it on a regular day on a daily basis I think it becomes a routine and people associate those routines with feeling the need to stick to that duty and keeping themselves informed. And you mentioned there that that traditional way of getting used the 6pm bulletin turning on the radio on your way to work. What about the I mean less traditional news?

Are we seeing a rise or a decrease in getting used through social media, through podcasts? Are we seeing any surprising statistics in that sense? Yes one quite interesting finding this year is we found that Gen Z are actually slightly reducing their reliance on social news. The use of social media as a main source has fallen a little bit this year so it fell by 4% from last year and in particular so young generation so Gen Z it's still social media is still their top source for news at 46% but there was an 8 percentage point drop from last year and that's quite a significant drop in the number of Gen Z saying that they're using social media as their main source of news.

Instead for younger people, TV and online news consumption increased so there are signs that young people are switching off social media partly because of that fatigue and partly because of the avoidance strategies and seeking use more directly and actively through other platforms. And according to the report if we can just touch back on Trust and Use almost half of Australians believe news organisations in Australia put their political views and commercial interests ahead of what is best for society. How does that link with Trust in the media? So it is an interesting key factor here is that audiences who believe that news organisations are putting their own commercial interests or their political interests first are much more likely to say that they distrust the news generally and there's sort of an instance here where the bad behaviour of some news outlets is resulting in lower levels of trust for the industry as a whole.

I think one important factor here to point out is that audiences often don't make the kind of fine distinctions that academics and journalists make say for example between different news brands between opinion and news produced by the same brand or even between news brands and brands that aren't really journalistic in their approach to the production of news. So there is an effect here where the industry as a whole is sort of tied with the same brush as a minority who are actually working in their own political interests or their own commercial interests and that people encounter those hyper-partisan outlets on social media or they encounter misinformation and disinformation on social media and this has a net decrease in their trust overall in all journalism. That's such an interesting point of it being tarnished with the same brush but I guess in terms of being the devil's advocate for the savvy news readers there's a really interesting point that was made at an international journalism festival and they had this really interesting conversation about news fatigue and one of the points that was brought up was when people talk about news fatigue they tend to look at it as why aren't people listening to us? Why is everyone tired?

Why isn't our news reaching the people we want it to reach? Instead of looking at why we are what we are not doing that is going to break through to the people that we want to serve in a way that will be useful to those people and that's a quote from one of the speakers in the international journalism festival but I think it's a really interesting point about looking at it through that different lens. Yeah I think there's some really interesting sentiments in that one certainly that there is a degree of complacency as I was sort of talking about earlier one of the critical things that the industry needs to address is a lack of diversity, a lack of diversity on screen, a lack of diversity in the sources that they use, a lack of diversity in terms of the people in the newsroom who actually should be more representative of the community and while that's been on the agenda for decades very little has changed and very little movement has actually been made within the industry to make a serious effort to address those lack of diversity. So there is an issue here where you know certain outlets have become slightly complacent in that they've taken their audiences for granted and said you know we've always enjoyed high levels of popularity and consumption and assumed that these levels of consumption would go on forever and they have left a precious little time to act and to actually change their industrial and commercial behaviours in a way that would actually win people back on side and demonstrate that they are speaking as a voice for the community and reflecting that community that it serves.

I think that is a really a strong point to end the discussion on. Karen thank you so much for joining Fourth Estate. Thanks very much for having me. On that note I'd like to thank Dr.

Kieran McGuinness for being on Fourth Estate and thanks for listening to the program. This edition was recorded at the studios of 2SER and heard across the country on the Community Radio Network. Fourth Estate is produced with the assistance of the Community Broadcasting Foundation thanks to the foundation for their continuing support. Make sure you subscribe to Fourth Estate on your favourite podcast app so you can hear us talk about media, politics and a lot in between.

We'll be back with more next week but in the meantime you can stay in touch with us on Twitter our handle is Fourth Estate AU. Thanks to our executive producer Anthony Dockrell. I'm Marlene Even thanks for listening.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Fourth Estate?

This episode is 31 minutes long.

When was this Fourth Estate episode published?

This episode was published on June 23, 2022.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Fourth Estate episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.