EPISODE · Mar 5, 2026 · 1H 2M
FIRST DEFEAT UNDER CARRICK! | Newcastle 2-1 Man Utd Review | The 10-Man Struggle ⚪️⚫️
from The Fellow Reds Podcast - Manchester United · host Fellow Reds
It had to happen eventually, but it doesn't make it any less frustrating. Welcome back to the pod with Spen and Chaz as we digest Manchester United’s first defeat under the new era—a 2-1 loss away at St. James' Park.Despite Newcastle being reduced to 10 men after Ramsey's second yellow for diving, the Reds couldn't capitalise on the advantage. We’re breaking down why the performance felt so "sluggish" and "pedestrian" from the first whistle. Was it a lack of desire, or did we just play right into Eddie Howe’s hands?----------------------------------------ON THE AGENDA:* 📉 The Performance: Why are we starting so flat? We discuss the "energy dust" that seems to be affecting the squad in early exchanges.* 🛡️ Mazraoui Starts: A big call from Carrick to start Mazraoui over Dalot. Was it the right move despite the result?* 🟥 The Red Card: Ramsey's dive and the 10-man "Kryptonite" for United. Why do we struggle more when the opposition goes a man down?* 🪄 Bruno & Casemiro: A rollercoaster night for our midfield duo. From the penalty error to the equaliser—we rate their impact.* ❌ The Mbeumo "Sitter": Breaking down that massive chance. Was it a poor strike or just a bad bounce?* 🧤 Ramsdale's Heroics: Aaron Ramsdale put in a shift for the Magpies. How much did his saves cost us?----------------------------------------TIMESTAMPS:00:00 – Intro: Feeling the frustration after Newcastle. 02:40 – First defeat on the pod. 04:50 – Prediction Recap: Chaz goes positive (as always). 06:50 – Line-up Talk: Mazraoui in for Dalot. 08:45 – Newcastle’s Bright Start: Gordon and the physical battle. 14:30 – The Dan Burn "Double Elbow" & Referee Consistency. 18:15 – Mainoo's Chance: What a save from Ramsdale. 20:45 – The Ramsey Red Card: Dive or harsh? 24:40 – The Penalty & Bruno’s "Saviour Mode." 27:10 – Casemiro’s Equaliser & The Half-Time Mood.----------------------------------------GET INVOLVED! 📢We want to hear from you. Was that performance just a blip, or are there worrying trends starting to emerge? How would you have changed the tactics against 10 men? Drop a comment below and let’s get the debate going!* SUBSCRIBE for more Man Utd fan content and match reviews! 🔔* Follow us on WhatsApp for instant updates.* Watch and listen on YouTube, Spotify & Apple Podcasts - https://youtu.be/I9kiIQXdb0Q#MUFC #ManUtd #NewcastleUnited #PremierLeague #CarrickBall #BrunoFernandes #Casemiro #Sesko #MatchReview #StJamesPark #FootballPodcast
What this episode covers
It had to happen eventually, but it doesn't make it any less frustrating. Welcome back to the pod with Spen and Chaz as we digest Manchester United’s first defeat under the new era—a 2-1 loss away at St. James' Park.Despite Newcastle being reduced to 10 men after Ramsey's second yellow for diving, the Reds couldn't capitalise on the advantage. We’re breaking down why the performance felt so "sluggish" and "pedestrian" from the first whistle. Was it a lack of desire, or did we just play right into Eddie Howe’s hands?----------------------------------------ON THE AGENDA:* 📉 The Performance: Why are we starting so flat? We discuss the "energy dust" that seems to be affecting the squad in early exchanges.* 🛡️ Mazraoui Starts: A big call from Carrick to start Mazraoui over Dalot. Was it the right move despite the result?* 🟥 The Red Card: Ramsey's dive and the 10-man "Kryptonite" for United. Why do we struggle more when the opposition goes a man down?* 🪄 Bruno & Casemiro: A rollercoaster night for our midfield duo. From the penalty error to the equaliser—we rate their impact.* ❌ The Mbeumo "Sitter": Breaking down that massive chance. Was it a poor strike or just a bad bounce?* 🧤 Ramsdale's Heroics: Aaron Ramsdale put in a shift for the Magpies. How much did his saves cost us?----------------------------------------TIMESTAMPS:00:00 – Intro: Feeling the frustration after Newcastle. 02:40 – First defeat on the pod. 04:50 – Prediction Recap: Chaz goes positive (as always). 06:50 – Line-up Talk: Mazraoui in for Dalot. 08:45 – Newcastle’s Bright Start: Gordon and the physical battle. 14:30 – The Dan Burn "Double Elbow" & Referee Consistency. 18:15 – Mainoo's Chance: What a save from Ramsdale. 20:45 – The Ramsey Red Card: Dive or harsh? 24:40 – The Penalty & Bruno’s "Saviour Mode." 27:10 – Casemiro’s Equaliser & The Half-Time Mood.----------------------------------------GET INVOLVED! 📢We want to hear from you. Was that performance just a blip, or are there worrying trends starting to emerge? How would you have changed the tactics against 10 men? Drop a comment below and let’s get the debate going!* SUBSCRIBE for more Man Utd fan content and match reviews! 🔔* Follow us on WhatsApp for instant updates.* Watch and listen on YouTube, Spotify & Apple Podcasts - https://youtu.be/I9kiIQXdb0Q#MUFC #ManUtd #NewcastleUnited #PremierLeague #CarrickBall #BrunoFernandes #Casemiro #Sesko #MatchReview #StJamesPark #FootballPodcast
NOW PLAYING
FIRST DEFEAT UNDER CARRICK! | Newcastle 2-1 Man Utd Review | The 10-Man Struggle ⚪️⚫️
No transcript for this episode yet
Similar Episodes
Mar 26, 2026 ·1m
Mar 19, 2026 ·34m
Feb 18, 2026 ·11m
Feb 11, 2026 ·45m