Skip to content
Flannery O'Connor and the Moral Imagination episode artwork

Nov 27, 2023 37 min

Flannery O'Connor and the Moral Imagination

from Center for Evangelical Catholicism Hosted by Center for Evangelical Catholicism

Timothy J. Nielsen discusses the work of Flannery O'Connor as an exemplar of the Moral Imagination. (Special Thanks to Fr Thomas Joseph White OP, whose insights I borrowed!)

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Flannery O'Connor and the Moral Imagination

0:00 37:18
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Tonight though we're going to talk about Flannery O'Connor and I will premise with saying I am not an expert on Flannery O'Connor I have no graduate degrees in Flannery O'Connor Tony Owens has been telling me his awfully pretentious for a man from Arizona to talk about Flannery O'Connor in the South But actually I would point out that the last time I spoke about Flannery O'Connor was right outside of Atlanta Which was even more pretentious being actually not far from her home, but that's okay. So all difficult questions are to be geared towards Tony He's got the accent answer to properly. Alright, so what I wanted to do was not get into a super deep dive But try to for especially anyone that has not extensively read Flannery O'Connor Hopefully get you to want to do so so that you actually do do so and hopefully help you to understand her a little bit better So that you don't pick it up and go like what the heck did I just read? Because that can be a natural thing and actually as an interesting side note There's actually a biopic movie that's supposed to be coming out about her either I think it's next year With actually there's a great interview with what's his name Ethan Hawke is that the actor?

Yeah, and his daughter who even hawks the director and extremely interesting person They have a great interview Bishop Barron that I highly recommend So there you go prepare you for that too now feel free to interrupt anytime to get more refreshment anytime etc etc alright So the title when I talked about Of the talk as I said Flannery O'Connor and the moral imagination and part of that is the moral imagination part I want to start with the second part first and then get into Flannery O'Connor So part of it is for understanding like well Why should you be reading fiction in general and then Flannery O'Connor specifically and last time I spoke when I said this actually I started by saying and we'll do it again That if you want to evangelize the best thing that you could probably do is read more fiction and less apologetics And the reason why if nobody has ever been argued into the faith period and However, what you're trying to we are trying to do ultimately is get people to actually believe a true story Of something that really happened that it was I mean ultimately That's what the faith is is it is this true great grand story It's the greatest story that ever happened and for someone to actually believe that and have the faith like they have to actually have a spark of Imagination within them you can't just like you have logical syllogisms to say therefore it is proven that Christ died on the cross And therefore you need to believe for all of those things like that doesn't work So anyway, so stirring the imagination is important and we all know that the imagination can stir like the heart in ways that Sermon can't there's a reason why Christ gave Lisa the Synoptic gospels over 30 parables But only one sermon because you can actually teach a lot more about the human condition about ourselves in deeper ways in stories than you can in sermons That's not to say that sermons are bad the so they sort of on the mouse the heart the gospel but But there's a lot that can be learned just through story now using the term though the moral imagination is trying to distinguish the fact that not all stories are created equal that there are some stories that are inherently good and ones that are inherently bad and So that's where the term the moral imagination comes from that is actually a term that was first invented or first used by Edmund Burke He was a 18th late 18th century English Statesman and member of parliament, but then there's been other writers that were written a lot about the concept I mean the idea goes back all the way to like Plato like what is a good moral story? But just say T.S. Eliot was particularly wrote a bunch about it JR. Tolkien but actually one of the simplest ways to I think to understand it comes from the contemporary actually a modern-out French philosopher named Jean-Luc Merrion who's actually written a lot about the difference between iconography and ideology and where he points out that ultimately like T.S.

Eliot he wrote a bunch he said that the moral story moral imagination is one that focuses on the permanent things and those are the permanent things that cannot change like goodness is always good like evil is always evil that you can Mess with all the accidents like turn the grass blue and all that but you can't change those permanent things and likewise John Luke Merrion when talking About that interesting iconography and idolatry he talks about how openly actually I'll just have quote So I should summarize let me summarize after you go that the idol if he says the idol is a mirror of our own desires never letting us transcend ourselves Whereas the icon is a visible mirror of the invisible leading the viewer into a true encounter with the divine that Let me explain that that an icon is something that actually takes you past the image to something deeper and ultimately those permanent things that he's L.A. was getting it while And so you could say like good art is stuff that takes you like beyond just the image a good book is something that takes you beyond those eternal permanent things while idolatry is something that just leaves you at the image and ultimately the image as reflection of yourself So that's the big difference and there's I was gonna say the simple down-to-earth analogy I like to use between Imagination that is moral ultimately because it's rooted in the permanent things an imagination that actually That TSL it would call idyllic meaning it tries to To basically transcend the permanent things like we're not bound by the mores and everything of of tradition and all of that is the two I like to distinguish between the two television shows assigned to friends that sign felt is the moral imagination and the reason why is Because there is eternal truth present throughout the entire show meaning every time they make a bad choice It makes them miserable and there's natural law that always reasserts itself as opposed to friends Which not saying it's not enjoyable show or anything like that But their sin makes them happy and so there's a fundamental difference between the two is one is like this idyllic Imagination where all right you can somehow escape the more the mores and the morals and the world of tradition and that is gonna end up okay And the other one says like no you're gonna end up miserable and probably in jail Um, so but it's an entertain so anyway those are that's my my simple breakdown between the two now getting to Then finally your connor all right I thought a good way is to give sort of a premise not gonna get a lot into her life other than to say you can go visit her House it's not that far away is around three hours away in millageville outside like an hour and a half outside of Atlanta I have not been there. I know my father a lot my wife have gone there that told he's been there and some other people It's cool. She was writing in the mid-century in America she died young she had lupus was dependent upon her mother and she wanted to be a great writer and she became a pretty darn good one and The sort of the key themes to remember in her books before we sort of break down is the first is someone once called her a hillbilly Nihilist because her books always have like these grotesque violence within them like the genre often described as southern grotesque Because there's usually some sort of shocking violence that happens in most of the stories and she said she said no I'm not hillbilly Nihilist.

I'm hillbilly tomes and the reason why is that she was writing first and foremost She thought fundamentally happy stories like they're happy stories and the reason why is because every one of them is a story of redemption It's kind of like the old difference between like a comedy and tragedy is a comedy ends happy So you can have like the divine commies called divine comedy because you have to go through the inferno and all this misery and everything But it ends happy. That's why it's a comedy. So Shakespeare everything the tragedies and the comedies highly end So anyway, she thought her their comedies So they're happy stories But they always have usually this like shocking violence, etc and part of the reason why for that is that she thought that we lived in a course in the world and often it takes something sort of Shocking to sort of get us out of our false view of ourselves and also you see that within her characters that they often have this sort of False view of reality false view of themselves, which I mean that's We can say what we all things with sin is we sort of write the rewrite the narrative of reality in our own head There's a great line also going back to Seinfeld where George Gisanza is trying to explain to Jerry how he beats a lie detector test and he says remember it's not a lie if you believe it And so likewise That's what we do with all standards We rewrite the entire narrative to make ourselves a hero and it's amazing how you can do that with something where you know You're in the wrong But you sort of retell yourself how it happened and after a while you actually start to believe it that we end up with this sort of False view of reality of ourselves and sometimes it takes them in shocking the sort of to push you out of it That's why you end up with these sort of these violent episodes within a lot of the stories but or other thing is being a tomeist that St. Thomas Aquinas was very one of the key themes within all his work in his philosophy and theology is the sacramentality of reality meaning that we are These unions of body and soul like we're not we're not just souls and trapped in bodies But we are unions of body and soul that that we're Hylomorphic creatures is the word for that and as such we experience reality we learn things through our physical senses Like even actually this is a kind of cool thing that St.

Thomas when he breaks down the senses you have the external senses But you also have your internal senses like your imagination is actually an internal sense your memory Etc, but the internal senses are still dependent upon the external senses meaning you can't imagine actually This is a kind of a cool proof of God's existence. That's a take off of the ontological argument that you can't In your mind imagine something that you have not experienced with your senses in some way meaning You couldn't like close your eyes and think up a new color that you've never seen you couldn't do it And so that's part of that argument for God Well, you can't just come up with the idea of their being is all power will eternal being therefore there must be God Because you can't just come up with something that you haven't experienced with your senses But anyway, it's all dependent upon that Use of our senses to learn truth etc. So likewise I mean this is the sacramental nature of the church that God is also a tomeist that when he gives us Grace he does so in physical ways because he's the one that created us as this union of body and soul that he created us to experience The all of the best things all of the most eternal truths in physical visceral ways Went through the use of the sacraments especially and so one of the key themes of flander and connor is yes physical ways experiencing truth in reality, but how do you experience a grace back in 1950s south the 1950s south There's not a lot of Catholics and therefore there's not a lot of sacraments It basically they have one sacrament baptism and so how is it that grace still breaks through even when you don't have those sacraments? So that's another key theme throughout all of her Books so Any questions about any of that before I move on?

Because if I keep moving on then sometimes you'll forget the questions Alright, so I was gonna try to touch in the time I have on four stories Which could be four stories that you can start with if you haven't read or you go back and reread I have they also have some good like audio book versions and those are good if you get someone with a nice like southern accent It just makes the stories all the better So you cannot ask me questions about any stories that are not those four stories because I might not remember the answer You ask only you get the hard questions Alright, so the first one that I want to talk about is one called revelation and It's a particularly I mean there's a reason all four because they're particularly good But I think they show plenary upon her schemes that I mean you can get with a lot of them But they for particularly so in the story of revelation. You've got this woman Mrs. Turban who is highly racist highly Class conscious so she sort of looks down upon all the rednecks and everyone from every other race and she says not a great lady But she thinks she is She has a very false view of herself and she looks down upon everyone else and what happens is she goes to the doctor's office And you've got that shocking moment of violence where through through Discussion like there's another lady that's in there who's this young lady who's the student and she's reading this big book called on human development and finally like She has enough and she throws the book and hits her in the face and then it's like tries to choke her out the young lady of Mrs. Turban and ends up calling her a warthog from hell and Because hell is a place where you don't there is no love and she has no love in her so she's a warthog from hell So what happens she gets this head injury and she goes Home and she's out by the pig pen so I'm sort of where her soul belongs and she ends up having this vision of purgatory and in purgatory She sees like all these people that she like hates and look down upon all entering heaven before she gets it and Anyway, so you get sort of like the violent breaking through and you and she's sort of taken out of her Her her situation and it's also actually very domestic in that God using the natural for the supernatural like she So they doesn't make it clear like she has a head injury like is it a vision or is it like an illusion of her head injury?

Well, babies both maybe God uses the head injury and uses that give her the vision So so that's a good one to start with and the first two I'm telling you I'm quickly cuz I want to save most of the time for the last two So that's why giving you the very abbreviated version so The second one that I highly recommend that actually like even better is one called the enduring chill And what it is oh, it's not Tony's you can't remember what it is. All right, let's see back there All right, so at the enduring chill is it's about this college student who he's from the south and he goes up north and And as most college students do he tends to think himself smarter than he really is and particularly he leaves sort of this his redneck family behind And he goes up north and he has like a natural disdain for all of the hillbillies of the south and the uneducated And he goes and he makes a lot of poor choices because he thinks himself were deliberated from that It's actually not that different than a lot of college experiences people often have now Like the college student that goes and starts to think how stupid his Christian parents are etc And what happens is he ends up getting this terrible disease and he through his own bad choices and he becomes sort of bedridden And not only bedridden actually he ends up like finding out later that he has like a permanent disease and he's stuck in bed for the rest of his life And he's gonna be dependent upon his redneck mom and part of that was a little bit of Autobiographical in that like the fact of college you about what goes to was actually similar to friend of Connor who went to the secular writing college up in Iowa and then she ended up getting lupus and being dependent upon her mom too and She actually talked about actually there was one point She says that probably the biggest grace of her life was to die slowly from a sort of a painful disease Meaning that this is a sort of a key theme that That grace requires oftentimes like sort of other dependable like us taking up a real cross and Recognizing that ultimately what we're trying to do in the Christian fight is become utterly dependent upon God So anyway, there's a great scene though where he his mom She's a redneck and she's actually an atheist and so just to make his mom sort of mad to stick it to her He asked her to please get him a priest so even though he doesn't really believe any of the stuff He asked for a priest just to stick it to his redneck mom And so who ends up coming is this sort of this not super well educated Jesuit priest from Savannah with one eye and So and actually this is kind of a cool thing in that you supposed to represent the cyclops because in particular if you remember in the Odyssey you got the scene with the cyclops where You always you listen he's in his men or in the cave and the cyclops was trying to spear him But they end up lying in the cyclops But then James Joyce in his book Ulysses that his sort of like climactic chapter in terrible book because James Joyce is terrible human who actually died as a Catholic though that that he tried to go be basically do a parody of the cyclops and But in his book the cyclops represents basically like the old Morais It's only be able to see with one eye as opposed to like the enlightened man who's gone beyond those Morais like the ideal Imagination going back a little bit for friends there that that's the two-eyed person So anyway, the the priest is supposed to represent the cyclops in this sort of this Joyce sort of way except This time the cyclops actually wins with the spear like spear in it So the the cyclops priest takes out like his penny catechism and to start asking questions It basically like nails into his bed where it actually ends up happening in effect He's like doesn't can't have the answers so ends up basically being the means by which he slowly like Hopefully the starters of his redemption the cyclops priest and the dependence upon dependence upon his mother Yeah, I thought that big one Alright, so those are the two shorter ones now the two longer ones that are probably hurt too most famous and the first of these That was a good man. It's hard to find that this is her most famous short story and And basically give you the short version and then explain a little bit about it You have this family out on a car journey And if you actually if you look up flainer connor like images all paintings are of a good either a peacock or images from the story I know this because I'm trying to make a little poster for the picture or for the flyer for the talk and So anyway in this door you've got this family they're going on a little trip and you've got the grandmother her son His wife and some grandkids and the grandmother is extremely annoying and so she just keeps causing all sorts of troubles She's she in the entire time. She can't stop talking about this escaped convict called the misfit and These out on the loose and notorious and she just doesn't want to meet this guy etc And you know what she's talking like they're gonna meet the miss fit all right um so Long and short the grandmother gets them lost with bad directions and then her cat which she wasn't supposed to bring into Causing a car accident so they end up crashing and another car comes across long and it's the misfit and his man and And uh, long and short is the misfit and his men kill them all one by one take the the son and the wife and the grandkids and take some of the woods Shoot some one by one by one and till last with the great one But so it's really interesting is with all flainer connor you have to go back to um The idea of images throughout it because she was actually a big fan of there was an English Dominican priest Who was also like a psycho analyst like who he was close friends with Carl Jung And they actually have really interesting letters back and forth where he like takes basically addresses Jung and his use of images But with like to mystic theology of lossy um and so he basically takes that idea of of symbols Like that symbols and then like applies it to christian theology And so she does the same thing So she'll have certain things that are always symbols of certain things like the sun and all of her is all in all of her works It's always got so the sun always represents the sun you remember so whenever there's trees So this is actually a good like primer when reading the stories when there's a forest or trees It represents the other world like heaven like after death And so as such also like the tree line is also like basically the borderline between like heaven and earth So that's why it's important that like even within it that it's they take the family like one by one to the trees Um for for the killing and the the misfit is an interesting character because he actually is truly like a hillbilly nihilist Like so he's what she was accused of it and there's a couple passages.

I do want to read from this one So All right, so he's a hillbilly nihilist who actually sort of takes it He don't believe in like god to its natural conclusion that um, I remember back when I used to be a history teacher Telling my students that could give Joseph Stalin one clap because he at least took atheism to his logical conclusion Um, so anyway, so here's the misfit talking to the grandmother after he's already killed everybody etc And he says that Jesus was the only one that ever raised the dead the misfit continued and he shouldn't have done it He had thrown everything on the balance if he did what he said then it's nothing for you to do But to throw away everything and follow him and if he didn't then it's nothing for you to do But enjoy the few minutes you got left the best way you can by killing somebody or burning down his house Or doing some other kind or some other meanness to him. No pleasure but meanness he said um And so anyway, there's like a namological conclusion like well if she's didn't rise on the dead like why not Um, why not take people out and kill him in the woods? Um, etc and Anyway, I'm gonna continue with it that Maybe he didn't raise the dead the old lady mumbled not knowing what she was saying and feeling so dizzy that she sank down in the ditch Her legs twisted under her. I wasn't there.

So I can't say he didn't to the misfit said I wish I hadn't been there. He I wish I had been had a been there He said hitting the ground with this fist it ain't right. I wasn't there because if I had been there I would have known listen lady He said in high voice if I had been there I would have known and I wouldn't be like I am and his voice seemed to crack and the grandmother's head cleared for an instant And she saw the man's face twisted close to her own as if he was going to cry and she murmured you're one of my babies You're one of my own children And she so it's interesting like she sees his vulnerability and she actually has a moment where she's like oh even you can be redeemed And so he was she reaches out and touched him on the shoulder And the misfits spring back as if a snake had bitten him and shot her three times through the chest And then he put down his gun on the ground and took off his glasses and began to clean them So it's interesting that Story you have like the grandmother's redemption right there at the end and what happens she gets shot and hurt her blood splatters on his His glasses, but you start to see actually in the next few paragraphs the start of his redemption like literally through her blood Um that is like the blood right after so in describing Sort of right after actually there's a great line when he's talking to his colleague I don't know if you call him a colleague his compad right there I go When he says that she would have been a good woman the misfit said if she had had somebody to shoot her every minute of her life Um, you know what's the great line? So anyway, but it goes it's interesting then continue some fun bobby Lee said shut up bobby Lee the misfit said It's no real pleasure in life that you've got this moment where you can tell he's got one It's like a little sorrow there and was leading it's like all right So like Christ got the grandmother right at the end and then maybe the next story Which she's not gonna actually write you'll get the misfit So you've got like that happy moment in the middle of killing the entire family.

So anyway, I'm missing anything over there here Tony You think that The happy story All right All right, and then my favorite of all of her stories When we get into four questions and comments of Snyder marks is um one called green leaf And This one I will just give you the spoiler alert In the very beginning is that she gets gored by the bull. So anyway, that's the spoiler alert that So what green leaf is is you've got this woman mrs. May who she's a little bit like mrs. Turpin and that she is looks down upon sort of everybody else and thinks that she is Um way better than everyone especially there is a family that works for her called the green leaf family And she really looks down upon that So what happens is she wakes up and it starts with there the bull that belongs to the son of mr Greenleaf who works for her but his his son has their own farm and his bull is on her land So it actually starts with the bull like looking through her window and Spoiler alert that the bull actually represents Christ throughout it So there's actually um a sort of a matrimonial aspect of like Christ like pursuing like wedding us Which is interesting so actually the great line to start when it says mrs May's bedroom window was low and face on the east so facing east is interesting because that's the son and the bull Silvered in the moonlight stood under it his head raised as if he listened like some patient god come down to woo her for a stir Inside the room and then it goes on describe it that the bull he appeared again in the same spot chewing steadily with a hedge Reef that he had ripped loose for himself caught in the tips of his horns But he has a matrimonial wreath and his horns so it starts with that and then the this so this family she comes out And there's this bull and you get into a little bit of the story goes on Why does she hate the green leaf so much?

And so like I said mr. Greenleaf works for her and who she especially hates is his wife Who she totally looks down upon because she is as redneck as they come and she is this redneck back this who likes to Basically roll around in the dirt when she prays because she has this like visceral need there's no sacraments remember So she has this visceral need to like experience god in this physical way So she does so she like has these fits where she like rolls around in the dirt as you as you praise and In this offensive sensibilities and actually there's a great line where she's where mrs. May winced Actually actually I'll go back a little bit so um So mrs. Greenleaf raised her head her face was a patchwork of dirt and tears and her small eyes the color of two field keys Were red rind and swollen for her expression was as composed as a bulldogs She swayed back and forth and her hands and knees and grown to jesus jesus And mrs.

May winced she thought the word jesus should be kept inside the church building like other words inside the bedroom She was a good christian woman with a large respect for religion though. She did not of course believe any of it was true Um So anyway, she looks totally down upon them and what bothers her more than anything is that the greenleaf sons went and fought in world war two They met these beautiful french women that they married and they came back and they both became extremely successful And her sons turned into losers. Um So that particularly bothers her that these guys that came from this woman she looked so down upon would actually turn out successful So as it turns out this bull belongs to those sons it's it's um one of mr. Greenleaf sons bull And so long and short is as you go through the relationship with her sons and how she looks down upon them She looks down upon everything greenleaf mr.

Greenleaf her family It's such that she decides that you know what she's going to make mr. Greenleaf shoot the bull That she and she takes like this bizarre pleasure in it and trying to make him shoot her own his own son's bull Um and so he doesn't want to do it And but she takes his pleasure this meanness about it to make him go shoot the bull so finally At the end, this is a little bit of a longer one Um Actually, there's an interesting line where it says when she is trying to get make mr. Greenleaf To send him off after the bull with the rifle it says for a few seconds She looked at the disappearing son and mr. Greenleaf examined the palms of his hands and presently it just occurred to her Um, she asked you know the real reason Okay, actually I'm going past it but that the moment she had told him to go kill the bulls She sees the son disappearing so like the map like God leaving as her mallets has come um so anyway But so she finally she comes out She's he goes in the woods looking for the ball to go shoot it and she's standing there waiting at the edge of the woods And a few minutes them there's I'll just read actually and in a few minutes something emerged from the tree line A black heavy shadow that tossed its head several times and then bounded forward and after a second She saw that it was the bull he was crossing the crossing the pasture toward her at a slow gallop A gay almost rocking gate as if you were overjoyed to find her again So you got to think of this as the bull is christ Um, she looked beyond him to see if mr.

Greenleaf was coming out of the woods too, but he was not there Here he is mr. Greenleaf She called and looking on the other side of the pasture to see if he would could be coming out But he was not in sight and she looked back and saw that the bull his head lowered was racing toward her She remained perfectly still not in fright but in freezing unbelief She stared at the violent black streak bounding toward her as if she had no sense of distance As if she could not decide at once what his intention was and the bull had buried his head in her lap Like a wild tormented lover before her expression changed and one of the horns sank until it pierced her heart and the other curved around her side And held her in an unbreakable grip. Um, so it's a very like matrimony all like Christ coming after her And there's the mr. Greenleaf actually comes out of the woods and there's any c-zart and the description is great When it says that that she she did not hear the shot, but she felt the oh, yeah, mr.

Greenleaf came in She was capable that she felt the quake and the huge body as it sank pulling her forward at it on its head So that she seemed when mr. Greenleaf reached her to be bent over whispering some last discovery into the animal's ear Like so it's finally like um anyway the moment of her redemption right at the end. Um, it takes that violence So anyway, that's a great one for sort of summarizing like yeah, that's what you're trying to get at with the end for works So that's only four. There's a lot of them You can read them and you can look for some of those same things in different ones All right, so I will stop there because I've talked for almost 45 minutes and I wanted to leave time for questions and comments So yeah, I'm not sure if I say the redemption well the redemption is like You could run for Christ's skill gets you um that that's sometimes that grace is like overpowering Like it's not an act of like god cooperates He still gives us free will but sometimes despite all that he will over power and keep coming after you And so like even the most like harden center or whatever Is not immune to grace So it's like literally at the moment as she's being stabbed as she finally gets it And that's why she's whispering that last secret she finally knows the secret right there at the moment of her death Yeah A lot of them I mean and there's lots of different um like interesting ones.

There's just a lot of super interesting things about the human condition There's one i'm having a brain camper what it's called where there's this there's woman who basically She's there sort of very sort of pure tanningful Christian and there's this guy that's trying to get her to fall in love with her But he's like covered in tattoos and he thinks that oh best way to get her to fall in love with him is he needs to get a tattoo of jesus Um, so even though she hates tattoos And but even getting on like to the idea that like oftentimes the way like we try to show like affection love towards people isn't how they actually receive it But rather how we would receive it so sometimes it doesn't really work Um, and you have to think about well, how does that person actually receive? So

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Center for Evangelical Catholicism?

This episode is 37 minutes long.

When was this Center for Evangelical Catholicism episode published?

This episode was published on November 27, 2023.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Center for Evangelical Catholicism episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.