Skip to content
Florida Hearing in Trump Classified Documents Case Devolves Into Shouting Match episode artwork

May 23, 2024 46 min

Florida Hearing in Trump Classified Documents Case Devolves Into Shouting Match

from Anderson Cooper 360 Hosted by CNN Podcasts

A shouting match broke out today between attorneys during pre-trial proceedings in the Mar-a-Lago classified documents case. The disagreement was over a long-disputed 2022 meeting between a prosecutor and an attorney for former President Trump’s personal aide Walt Nauta. Plus, Judge Aileen Cannon seemed skeptical of arguments to dismiss charges against Trump and his co-defendants. But, she has yet to rule on the motions she considered on Wednesday. Former Trump White House communications director Anthony Scaramucci and former U.S. District Court Judge Shira Scheindlin talk to Anderson about the case. Also, in a 360° exclusive, CNN’s Elizabeth Wagmeister talks to a woman who alleges Harvey Weinstein assaulted her nearly a decade ago. The woman also says she was the target of a "catch-and-kill" effort by the National Enquirer, similar to what's been described in the former president's hush money trial.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Florida Hearing in Trump Classified Documents Case Devolves Into Shouting Match

0:00 46:05
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Tonight on 360 Breaking News, no trial date, but already a fight between prosecutors and defense attorneys, the classified documents case where FBI Director James Comey joins us ahead. Also, breaking news tonight in New York Times report on a second controversial flag flown at the home owned by Justice Samuel Alito, the reporter on both stories is here. And Nikki Haley, she called Trump a unhinged, but now says she will vote for him. Well, the Republicans who voted for her do the same.

Good evening, thanks for joining us for shouting match her up to today in a federal court in Florida during the first of a series of pre-trial motions in the long-delayed case against the former president from his handling classified documents. There were two pre-trial hearings today, bids by the former president and a co-defendant to throw the case out. The classified documents case no longer has a trial date, as you probably know. The judge in the case, Eileen Cannon, has allowed a number of pre-trial motions to stack up and delay proceedings.

Just last night, we reported on these photos, which we'd not seen before. They were the co-defendant, while Nada Trumps former Valley from the White House who still works closely with him. The photo showed Nada moving boxes around Mar-Lago on June 1st, 2022, just before a Trump attorney was supposed to search for those boxes at Mar-Lago for classified documents, something he had to do under subpoena. Prosecutors say that Nada moved the boxes as part of alleged conspiracy to conceal classified material from federal investigators.

Now, the photos were part of a federal judge's opinion, saying that investigators had strong evidence that the former president intended to hide classified documents. She also noted that an empty folder marked classified evening summary was discovered in this bedroom months after the FBI search. That same filing from last night also included the standard operating procedure for when the FBI conducts a search. Agents, as they are always are in such a search, were armed, which has led Trump and some of his supporters to suggest that the agency was out to kill him.

Trump actually posted on his social media site, wow, I just came out of the Biden witch on trial in Manhattan, the ice box, and was shown reports that Cricket Joe Biden's DOJ in their legal and unconstitutional rate of money. The FBI, the FBI, to use deadly lethal force. Congresswoman Marjorie Taylor Greene said the FBI were, quote, planning to assassinate President Trump. They weren't.

Again, the agency was following protocol. Man's Secret Service was made aware of the search in advance and Trump was not there. There's still no trial data classified documents case and based on today's hearing, no indication of when a date will be set. Evan Perez joins us from Florida outside the courthouse.

What was the shouting match about? Well, Anderson, this was a hearing in part to hear these arguments by Walt Nada and his attorney to Stan Woodward. They were arguing that Walt Nada is the subject of selective and vindictive prosecution. And one of the things that Stan Woodward, his attorney, was arguing today was that he recounted an episode where he said prosecutors were essentially trying to pressure him to try to get Walt Nada to cooperate with this investigation.

He said there was this meeting where prosecutors mentioned the fact that he had applied for a judgeship and the chances of getting that judgeship. Now, that prompted a very sharp reply from prosecutors David Harbuck stood up and said that his interpretation of those events were fantasy. The judge at one point had to tell everybody to calm down because things had gotten so heated during this hearing. These were two hearings Anderson that took over five hours for the judge to hear again.

She didn't rule from the bench. That's usually doesn't. But she did seem skeptical of these efforts by the defendants to try to dismiss these charges Anderson. So what is the latest on when the trial might actually happen?

We still don't know. I mean, every time we come down here, we show up thinking that perhaps this is the day we're going to hear of a new trial date. That did not happen today. And look, today's hearing was an example and sort of exemplified why this case is moving so slowly, so ploddingly.

The judge allowed and sort of indulged the defense to go down a number of rabbit holes. There was one point where the defendants were arguing that there was a discussion to delete video. If you recall, as part of this case, this is part of the obstruction charges. They said that just having a discussion about deleting surveillance video, including that surveillance video that you showed there, the clips of Walt Nada moving boxes, that does not indicate a crime.

Again, the judge indulging a lot of these things over the course of five hours. Again, she did not rule from the bench on any of the motions. And a reminder that we have probably at least another eight motions that the judge is planning to go through with hearings like this one. And Perez, thanks very much.

I'm going to get some perspective now from former federal prosecutor, Ali Honig, former US district court Judge Ashiras Shendlin, former Trump White House communications judge, Anthony Scaramucci. He's also the author of Wall Street, the White House in back, the Scaramucci guide to unbreakable resilience, also with his current free magnific agnifola, former Manhattan chief assistant, he is now a criminal defense attorney. Anthony, I mean, even for President Trump, the idea that he's claiming, you know, the FBI was out to assassinate him or shoot him as bananas. Well, it's bananas.

Everything was handled appropriately in standard operating procedure, but there is a little projection in that. You see, if he says that about the other side, he thinks it takes a little bit of heat off of him and the unified right rap and all the other things that he's doing on his side to try to galvanize his base. So that's a typical classic Trump projection manipulation move. I can tell you everything is in the playbook if you have time.

Karen, what do you think of the judge? I mean, what are the chances this is going to happen? The trial, you mean? It doesn't seem like she is poised to have a trial anytime soon.

There's critical hearings that need to happen today's hearings were just too many that have to happen. And the fact that she won't even set a trial date, I don't think she has any plans or any intentions of seeing this case go to trial anytime soon. Judge, I mean, on the search warrants, I mean, you've signed off on plenty of search warrants. I have.

And it's not that hard. You look for probable cause that a crime has been committed. You look for probable cause that material or evidence of that crime will be found in that location. It's presented to you by an agent.

If you find it, you signed up. And if you're wrong, there's still a good faith exception. It's called. So there's no way that this search warrants got to get suppressed.

But that's the way Trump's handling it. They make motions of every kind repeatedly. Don't really expect to win them, but they want to tie her up. That's how I look at it.

If they make 30 motions, then that means 30 more reasons to delay. And of course, she should be ruling from the bench on some of these. They're just frivolous. And there's no reason to hold back on them.

Just say denied. What does that mean ruling from the bench? I mean, she should be able to just make the ruling there. Absolutely.

They present the arguments that probably letters or briefs just decide. There's no reason to hold off and reserve on every single motion. Say, deny, deny, deny, exactly right. I mean, she should know on some of these that they're frivolous.

Just frivolous. Why would she not be ruling from the bench? I mean, is it just not? I answer is insecure.

Absolutely. She's insecure. A secure judge who knows what they're doing. Like Judge Kaplan, like Judge Mershan, the two judges who were able to control Trump, they know what they're doing.

They're very experienced and they're confident. So they rule. We called it rule and roll. But we did.

And she doesn't rule and roll. She rules and reserves. Or she reserves and doesn't rule. And that's not the way to move a case along.

Let me just bow to having Ben ruled and rolled by your honor. Judge She doesn't know how to move a case quickly. I think it's important that we call out again this lie that is spreading now alarmingly quickly that there was some effort to, I hesitate to even say, but to assassinate Donald Trump. It's so ridiculous.

But I think the most important way to understand is if we see where the lie comes from. So in the search warrant documents and federal search warrant, and I think we have this and we can put up on the screen, there is a standard piece of paper that basically says here law enforcement officers of the Department of Justice may use deadly force only when necessary. That is when the officer has a reasonable belief that the subject of such force is spreading imminent bodily harm or imminent death to another person. In other words, it is limiting.

It says do not use your gun cops FBI agents unless it is absolutely necessary to save a wife. And then the document goes on say, and here are all the circumstances. You cannot use your weapon if someone's fleeing, if someone's in a car. So this is a standard form.

It correctly states the law. And if anything, it is narrowing to a very tiny sliver. And it doesn't happen. And it doesn't happen.

Search warrants go down all the time without violence. And it's boilerplate language. And they made sure Trump wouldn't be at Mar-a-Lago at the time. They actually did the search warrant.

And they went in wearing shirts instead of uniforms to try to keep it calm. I mean, they did the coordinated with Secret Service in advance. But we're talking about it. And the fact that we're talking about it, Trump is winning because he has a trigger brought in.

And he says, what can I do today on Truth Social that's going to trigger people to talk about this? And it galvanizes his base. It may upset the people that want to vote for Joe Biden, but it absolutely galvanizes his base. No, his base is there.

What about those voters who are not yet decided, I don't think this plays well to the independents. And Biden is trying to assassinate Trump. That's ridiculous. It's over the top.

Nobody's going to believe that. Who's undecided. But it is one of those. But he needs money right now, Your Honor.

And so what's happening to him, he's flying around the country, he's landing a place like Texas. And he's projecting. He's saying all the things that he's going to do if he were to win. He's not going to win by the way.

But he will do. And it galvanizes his base. And he'll open up their checkbook and they start writing checks. Because he's way more money.

Why does he kill you? Well, he's definitely not going to win, Anderson. We got to snap out of the fever that he may win. He's not going to win.

He doesn't have money. Number two, he's not going to have the operations set up properly in these swing states. Number three, I want you to identify the people that are going to now vote for Trump. Maybe there's a few on the margin, but there is just not enough to bring him to an electoral college victory.

And the last thing I know with the guy, he's going to implode himself as we get closer and closer. And we also know that President Biden is way more together than the right-wing media suggesting or even the Trump campaign is reinforcing with Donald Trump. And I think he gets his clock cleaned in these two debates by President Biden. So he's not going to win, but he needs money.

And that's why he's pressing the trigger buttons right now that the president was trying to assassinate me. Even though I wasn't in Mar-a-Lago, it was a threat to my life. Karen, just in terms of the documents case, have you seen judges like this before? I mean, because Judge Shulman was saying it's an experience, essentially.

I mean, there is also the other option which is that it's intentional. She has made a lot of rulings that have caused a lot of people to question her fitness to sit in this particular case. I mean, she is really, even from the beginning at the time of the search warrant that was signed, she appointed a special master, which is totally inappropriate to do. She got reversed by the 11th Circuit.

So it's hard to know I've not seen a judge. Frankly, this ill-equipped handle a case such as this, it's really highly unusual. She actually comes off as a rookie. It's insecurity as well as an experience.

You have to be secure to rule promptly and to rule from the bench. You have to believe in your ruling. She doesn't have a confidence to do it. She's really the wrong judge for this case.

Judge, if you were calling me insecure, I'd be going in for life coaching. I mean, the one to say it is very powerful, Your Honor. Judge, thank you very much, everybody. Thank you.

Appreciate it. More breaking news than New York Times is reporting on a second controversial flag that's become a symbol of the stop the steel movement that flew above the home of Justice Samuel Alito, plus the 360 exclusive. Harvey Weinstein accused her speaking out for very first time about what she says happened to her and why she says her story was silenced. I'm CNN tech reporter Claire Duffy.

This week on the podcast in terms of service, the idea of writing a car with no driver can feel daunting. And this technology raises questions about safety and the future of transportation. That's why I'm here with Nicole Gable, head of business development and strategic partnerships at WeMo. We've always been about safety.

No distracted driving, no drunk driving. We may have fallen as the rules of the road. Listen to CNN's terms of service wherever you get your podcasts. I've got news for your ears, the podcast.

I am your host, Michael Ian Black. His latest thing you see this yesterday was he finds the peace talks boring. Not my favorite guy, but I gotta be honest with you. I know exactly what he's talking about.

He's not negotiating. He's not in the room. But how do you think he receives the information? Sir, because they all saw him.

Sir, would you like to hear the latest update? They should make a comic strip out of it. Have I got news for your ears? Check us out on Apple, Amazon Music, wherever you get podcasts.

Even though you can watch the podcast on Spotify. More breaking news the New York Times is now reporting on a second controversial flag flown above a home owned by the family of Justice Samuel Alito. This flag, known as the Appeal to Heaven flag, was seen at the Alito Home on Long Beach Island in New Jersey last summer. The Times reports the flag dates back to the Revolutionary War and fell into obscurity until it was resurrected recently as a symbol of support for the former president by a religious faction and the so-called Stop the Steel movement, which falsely claims the Biden lost the election.

This follows a separate New York Times report last week about an upside down American flag flown at the Alito Home in Virginia in 2021. Justice Alito said it was raised by his wife during a clash with a neighbor who had cursed at her. Both stories come as Alito and the Supreme Court are due to rule on cases related to the January 6th riot, including the Question of Presidential Immunity. Joined by Jodi Cantor, who reported on both stories at the Times and by Norm Eisenhower's former counsel, Taos Democrats during Trump's first impeachment.

Jodi, can you just walk us through your reporting about this flag at the beach house? This appeal to Heaven flag? Sure. So actually, it's similar to the Virginia story in terms of I think it's helpful to start with the neighbors.

This is a popular beach destination. There are a lot of boaters. The Alito House is in a pretty prominent place. And last summer, neighbors and boaters are just going by and they're saying, well, heck is this flag and they're googling it.

And it turns out it's something called the appeal to Heaven flag, which as you say dates back to the Revolutionary War, but in the last decade has taken on a really freeded meaning and became very associated with the Stop the Steel campaign. It popped up a lot in the crowd at the riot. Now, Anderson, as you know, it's just a baseline kind of bedrock rule that judges are not supposed to have political displays. So the question becomes, what is just a Samuel Alito doing displaying this flag, which is so politically sensitive, which appears to connote an opinion, although we don't know that much about the particulars of exactly who raised it and why he didn't want to answer questions.

But he's doing this first of all last summer as the obstruction case that is so key to the prosecution of January 6th is arriving at the court. And now we're finding out about it just as these opinions are going to come out in a few weeks. And clearly somebody in the Alito household knows enough about flying an American flag upside down, they would know the meaning of this flag and the current incarnation of this flag. I mean, Norm, with Justice Alito now facing two flag controversies, how much of an ethics problem is this for him and more broadly for the court?

Anderson, I think the court is in an absolute ethics crisis, this latest expression of an apparent opinion, siding with the far right activists, including those who flew this flag on January 6th, comes on top of undisclosed luxury vacations by Justice Alito, also Justice Thomas, Justice Thomas's wife, a witness in the January 6 cases. And now these two flag photographs, expressing that opinion under federal law. If there's a reasonable basis to question, just a question, Anderson, the impartiality of a justice, the law expressly mentions justices of the Supreme Court. They are supposed to step aside and given the situation that we're in, it's not just the coming decisions.

The January 6 case was set for trial at the beginning of March. We know from the questioning that Justice Alito and Justice Thomas are entertaining this absurd idea that SEAL Team 6 is allowed under presidential immunity to commit political assassinations. We're already in crisis because of the delay of that case. And the Chief Justice and Congress must act.

Jody, what I don't understand is the first flag, the upside down flag outside the Alito home. He said that was in response to a neighbor using a nasty word to his wife in an argument. Was that an argument about an anti-Trump sign on the neighbor's law? I think we just lost our norm.

There are a lot of people who view the Supreme Court from a different lens in recent years because of ethics issues like this that keep happening. Has the court faced anything like this before? Justice Abe Fortis, during the 1960s, Johnson administration, he was a Johnson confidant who was put on the Supreme Court, stepped off the Supreme Court because he had accepted a retainer. About $20,000 from an individual who had been accused of securities wrongdoing.

He was not actually accused of wrongdoing himself, but he had a sense of shame Anderson. This is the Fortis scandal on steroids and the combination of undisclosed substantial luxury vacations from those with interests, ideological or business before the court. And the spouse is, Alito is going to his spouse on that upside down flag. Janie Thomas, we know, was a witness.

And now a second expression of a political opinion, a constituting apparent bias. We don't have to find bias. The Chief Judge has the power to investigate. Congress has the power to investigate.

It is an epic crisis. Jody, can you hear me? I just want to ask you, sorry we lost you. I was sorry for the problem.

The upside down flag of the Alito home, that was in response to a neighbor who had put an anti-Trump sign on their lawn. Is that correct? And words were exchanged between that neighbor and Alito's wife? That's what Justice Alito says.

But part of what's so interesting about this new flag story is that we have pictures of this flag up in July, in August and in September of last year. It was up the whole time, but it appears to be a kind of sustained period. So even after taking down this upside down flag, this other flag, there was there already or then popped up. Jody can't appreciate her pouring warm eyes in.

Still ahead after suspending her presidential campaign in March, Nikki Haley's announced she'll vote for former President Trump November. One of my upcoming guests says he's not surprised. I'll ask him why next. In her first public speech and leaving the Republican presidential primary race more than two months ago, today former South Carolina Governor Nikki Haley finally announced who she will be supporting in the election.

Trump has not been perfect on these policies. I've made that clear many, many times. But Biden has been a catastrophe. So I will be voting for Trump.

I stand by what I said in my suspension speech. Trump would be smart to reach out to the millions of people who voted for me and continue to support me. Since leaving the race, Haley served as Trump's US ambassador to the UN has avoided endorsing him or directly telling her voters to oppose him. She didn't hold back and went after him during the primary campaign.

He is unhinged. He is more diminished than he was. The reason that America keeps losing is because of Donald Trump. And the most harm he's ever possibly had is getting hit by golf ball when he's sitting in a golf cart.

Chaos follows him. And we can't have a country in disarray and a world on fire and go through four more years of chaos. We won't survive it. America needs a captain who will steady the ship, not capsize it.

That's the chaos that comes with Donald Trump. That's the offense of this. It's going to happen every day between now and the general elections. Which is why I continue to say Donald Trump cannot win a general election.

He won't. With me now, senior day reporter Harry Ensign, senior political com chair, former Republican congressman Adam Kinzinger. I saw you tweeted after Haley announced she's going to vote for Trump. He said not surprising, but pathetic.

I certainly get the pathetic part. Why not surprising to you? Well, let me first off say she said in the thing you played that we won't survive four more years of Trump. She said we will not survive four more years of Trump and just endorse it.

Well, technically she didn't endorse it. I'll give her credit for that. She just said she was going to vote for him. It's not surprising Anderson because we've seen this playbook over and over again with very few exceptions.

That being somebody like Chris Christie, where people will go after Donald Trump, look at Bill Barr. All these terrible things that Trump is going to do to the country. But when it comes down to it, party over country. And so that's why I'm not surprised about Nikki Haley.

It's disappointing. She said in another one of those sound bites that Trump needs to reach out to her voters. I'll also say Biden needs to reach out to her voters. I don't know what the Biden administration or the Biden campaign has been doing, but they're not reaching out to those voters.

It clearly seems she wants a future, some sort of political future or some sort of future on the lecture circuit in front of Republican audiences and knows if she's going to do that, she has to at this stage continue to bend in need to Trump. It seems like just purely a political calculus. It is. And that's 100% true.

If she wants a future in the GOP on this trajectory, I happen to believe the GOP will be fixed someday. The superpower of Donald Trump and frankly kind of the Maga call is they welcome anybody back, right? Just like any good church that says if you repent, you can come back. She will be walking back even if there's some tweets against her for now.

And that's the superpower of Donald Trump. And so yeah, she knows that if she wants a position in the administration, maybe if she wants to continue to be seen as a Republican in good standing. But as she said in the very clip, you played four more years of Donald Trump will destroy this country. So she is putting her career and her interest over the country.

I know it sounds dramatic. I'm just so passionate about the fact that Donald Trump would be nothing but terrible for the United States of America. Harry, she's, Haley's continued to do relatively well in races, you know, even though she's not in the race anymore. However, numbers have been.

Yeah, you know, I think it depends on the contest, right? You know, if you go to Kentucky, like that, she didn't do so well. She got in the single digits. You go to a place like Maryland, she's getting 20, 25% of the vote.

But, you know, I like to look across the Republican contest. And at this point, in the average Republican contest, since she's gotten out of the race, she's got about 14% of the vote. That's not bad, right? You know, 14% of folks voting for someone who's not even in the race anymore is something that obviously both campaigns, both the Biden and Trump campaign should be interested in going after.

I think I've heard over and over again people sort of saying, oh, Nikki Haley is getting these large shares of the votes, even though she's not in the race. I should point out that four years ago, Bernie Sanders was getting about the exact same vote in the Democratic primaries after he dropped out of the race. So this isn't something to me that's terribly unusual. The thing that would have been unusual was if Nikki Haley decided not to throw a support behind Donald Trump, then it would have been very interesting to see what happened to that 14% of voters.

But at this particular point, this isn't something that's historical anomaly. It's something well-aligned with history. Congressman, do you think Haley gives now permission to Republicans who may have been on the fence about voting for Trump? I mean, the people who were voting for her in Maryland?

Yeah, she does. Yeah. I mean, there's going to be a lot that's still either vote third party, don't vote or vote for Biden. But she does, because if you think of it, if you're a Republican and you hold strong to your values like I do, but you're sitting around saying, gosh, I just can't bring myself to vote for Biden, but maybe I will because Trump's so bad, I really respect Nikki Haley.

When she comes out and says, I'm going to vote for Donald Trump, despite everything she said on the campaign trail, it does give you permission to say, oh, good. And I got to tell you, that would be a relief. Like if all of a sudden, I could say, for instance, I'm in on the Trump train now, I'm a good Republican again, it would be a personal relief because it takes that pressure off. So I think she gives a lot of people license to go for Donald Trump.

This is again, the Biden campaign has got to be doing a lot more to go after these kinds of folks. There are so many Republicans that are ready to endorse Biden and haven't heard a thing from the campaign. And it's not it's political malpractice, honestly. Adam Kinzer.

Thank you. Harry Antone as well. Coming up next one on one with former FBI director James Comey on the breaking news about the controversial flags that were flown into Supreme Court Justice Alito's homes in New Jersey and Virginia. Also, it's taken the former president, falsely claiming President Biden tried to have him assassinated during the Marlago search and details of Mr.

Comey's new novel coming up. More now on our breaking news from earlier this hour, The New York Times reporting a second controversial flag was flown into the home owned by a family of Justice Samuel Alito. As we mentioned, the appeal to Heaven flag was seen at the Alito's New Jersey Beach home last summer. According to The Times, the flag dates back to Revolutionary War and has become a symbol of the stop the steel movement that falsely claims Biden lost the 2020 election.

This follows a separate New York Times report last week about an upside down American flag at the Alito home in Virginia two years ago. Joining me is former FBI director James Comey, who's the author of a new fictional crime novel called Westport. I want to start with Justice Alito. There's reporting now that he flew or his family flew two different flags that are associated with January 6 over his life.

Is that at all acceptable? No, it's deeply concerning. I don't understand enough about this second flag. I'm no expert in extremist flag waving, but they're both very concerning for someone in his position because public trust and confidence is everything in the institutions of justice.

As you know, Marjorie Taylor Greene and others are now accusing federal agents of seeking to assassinate former President Trump during a search at Marlago. They cite this document that was unsealed by Judge Cannon in the classified documents case. It's entitled policy statement. Use of deadly force.

We're putting it up there. Do you know what this can you talk about what this document is? I'm smiling because it's so crazy. If you put this in a novel that would get rejected by your editor, it's not right.

This is the standard FBI protocol that applies to every search and simply reminds the participants in the search of what the rules are around the use of deadly force. It's not specific to Marlago. It's not specific to any search. This would be in any search.

Any search in every search. With the criminal trial in New York, where do you think this is headed? I think it's highly likely to result in a conviction. You do?

Oh, yeah. A small possibility. I think of a hung jury. I think there's almost no possibility of acquittal.

Again, I've tried a lot of cases. You can't know a case fully unless you've tried it or been in the courtroom for every second. Hung juries are rare. They're rare, but it only requires one juror to say, I'm not quite there and to hold out.

So that's why I say a small possibility, but not a real possibility given my experience. Over, I would say, 80% chance of conviction given the case they put together. You think they did their job even with all the weaknesses and some of their witnesses? Yeah, I think they built a case that was not subject to cross-examination, really.

It's based on documents and texts and emails in the words of the defendant, and then they presented their most controversial witness, the cooperating bag man. But the case, I bet they even talked about whether to call him given the strength of their case before they put him on. I can see why they decided they had to put him on and look to me like the evidence crossed over, which was a term used by one of my colleagues. You think they might not have even needed to call Michael Cohen?

No, I think they probably discussed it whether they'd gotten the case in so smoothly and so many bricks to build a conviction building that they might have hesitated to call him. Do you think if the former president is found guilty? I mean, do you worry about what the response to that might be? No.

No, I think it's... I continue to worry about threats against individual poll workers and council people and that sort of thing. I'm not worried about an uprising of violence on Donald Trump's behalf. I don't think you've seen the crowds anywhere he's gone.

I think a message was sent to January 6th that your life will be ruined if you engage in that kind of behavior. And his crowd are not jihadis looking to die for the Orange God. They are people who are attached to him as a cult leader in a way, an entertainment figure, but they're not going to lay themselves down for him. Nikki Haley now says she will vote for Donald Trump.

What do you think the... If there is another Trump term, what does that mean for the Department of Justice, for the rule of law in this country? Die your threat to the Department of Justice's autonomy and independence and to the rule of law generally. And that's why I keep saying to people, I don't know what your concerns are from left or right about Joe Biden, but a vote for anybody but him is a vote for a threat to the rule of law.

That's how serious it is. Is the institution not strong enough or the pillars of the foundation of justice in this country? I mean, are they strong enough to withstand a Trump term? I guess it depends on what you mean by withstand.

Yeah, the institution would exist four years. If he left it after four years, would still be there, but it would be severely damaged. And maybe a cultural change will have been worked that would be very difficult to undo. And that would be by filling it with people who are doing his bidding, who are not following the rule of law above loyalty to a president?

Yeah, people, he'll have to scrape the bottom of the barrel to staff the political positions, but there's plenty of scrapies at the bottom of our national barrel. And so they'll put people in position who are willing to use the power, the investigative and prosecutor power, to go after the president's enemies, to have people they don't like. And that's a very dangerous place to be. I want to talk about your new novel.

You and I spoke about it a year ago. You were already writing or had written this book. It's called Westport. What I liked about it is that it's...

I mean, it's a blend of financial crimes, but also a murder mystery. Yeah. And you're right. I had written it the way fiction works.

I didn't know this before I started doing this. You're right. Well, I'm writing the third book. It's the same protagonist in the book.

You don't need to have read the first book in order to enjoy this one. That's right. Nora Carlton was a federal prosecutor in the first book, and now she's working in the financial industry. And it's a murder who'd done it that I think that puts Nora at the center in the crosshairs that I think will be a pretty good summary for people.

And the protagonist's main character, Nora Carlton, how did you create her? What was the inspiration? Inspiration is my oldest daughter who's a tall federal prosecutor, currently a federal prosecutor in Manhattan. And I put in other elements of my four daughters, so if they don't like it, I can say that's your sister.

But I can close my eyes and picture my oldest girl when I write Nora, and that makes it easy on a labor of love. And is there already a third in the works? Yeah. The third is out for loving but brutal feedback from my family right now.

So it'll be out this time next year. Jim Snowy, thank you so much. Great to be with you as always. Go ahead for next.

The 360 exclusive. You'll hear from a woman that says, movie mogul Harvey Weinstein assaulted her nearly a decade ago. As part of an investigation into that alleged assault, she wore a wire and got Weinstein on tape, giving an apparent admission to groping her. But the prosecutor's never brought charges.

Now she's sharing details about the parallel she sees to the Trump hush money trial, saying she was also targeted by a catch and kill operation in the National Choir. Now, 360 exclusive. Harvey Weinstein, the accuser is speaking out as the former Hollywood producer waits retrial in New York in a sex crimes case after his conviction was recently overturned by an appeals court. The court said the trial judge wrongly admitted some testimony and incorrectly allowed prosecutors to question Weinstein about verbal abuse.

And the woman you're about to hear from tonight had nothing to do with the case. Prosecutors never brought charges based on her accusations. She says Weinstein assaulted her nearly a decade ago. She also says she was silenced by a catch and kill effort by the National Choir.

She's like the testimony in the former president's hush money trial. Now she's talking exclusively with CNN's Elizabeth Wegmeister. Almost like a gut punch. Why is that happening?

Ombre bought to Lana Gutierrez stunned after a New York appeals court overturned the sex crimes conviction against a trace movie mogul, Harvey Weinstein. The Italian model giving CNN a wide-ranging interview and new details on previous efforts to keep her silent after she worked with the NYPD on a sting operation in 2015. War a wire and caught this on tape. Why does the day you touch my wrist?

Please, I'm sorry. Just come on. I used to that. I do use to that.

No, man. I'm not used to that. Over the damn one. Despite an apparent admission of groping her, New York prosecutors never move forward with the case, a decision that raised questions, which we'll get to.

Adding to her suspicions, someone was leaking her allegations to the press, leading to tabloid headlines like, Grop Gal asked for movie part and secret life of Harvey's giant user. I was 22 years old, and I was put under accusation of not being truthful and to be a prostitute or not perfect victim because I am a model. But to Lana Gutierrez believed then, and now the Weinstein machine was behind it all. Because it wasn't just him.

I know there is more people behind him that have positions of power that he was using as well. But who? But to Lana Gutierrez believes part of the answer can be found here at former president Donald Trump's hush money trial. That's where former national enquirer boss David Packer testified to paying off sources to protect Trump's reputation by preventing negative stories from ever going public.

While Weinstein's name didn't come up on the stand, this tabloid news organization became a protection racket for the rich and powerful. Lachlan Cartwright, a former editor for the Inquirer who now writes for the Hollywood Reporter, claims the Inquirer protected Weinstein too. Cartwright claims he was instructed by an editor who worked under Packer to buy bought to Lana Gutierrez's story. Later learning it was to keep it from being told and to protect Weinstein, who had a business relationship with the Inquirer was parent company.

Initially, Amber Bellano was offered $20,000 by the national Inquirer. They were trying to say like, how much you want? And I kept just answering nothing. I wanted to tell my story, but I wanted to trust someone.

Cartwright says he was told to raise the stakes to $150,000 for a story that the tabloid could have had for free. Bata Lana Gutierrez is go between text and back. She says no. Don't ask again.

Cartwright alleges he later learned that a top lawyer for the Inquirer spoke to the Manhattan DA's office in an attempt to disparage Bata Lana Gutierrez's credibility. And telling them that Amber Bellano was trying to sell her story. It was a complete opposite of what was actually going on because we were inducing Amber Bellano. She wasn't trying to sell her story.

I felt sick to my stomach. The decision not to prosecute came from previous DA, side-ants, no longer in office. He told CNN, I have no information that I recall presently that the national Inquirer or anyone representing it spoke with our office about selling a story to the Inquirer. Weinstein told CNN through a spokesperson, the DA's office knew all the facts and passed on this case.

Had they felt they could pursue it, they would have. Neither Packard nor the Inquirer's new parent company responded to requests for comment. Bata Lana Gutierrez says she also turned down hush money from Weinstein's lawyers. They went up to 300, 700, a million, and I still turned down every time.

And then, Gutierrez, as her brother back in Italy, was approached by someone asking about her. I got so scared. I remember that I called my lawyer right away and I just said like whatever they said, just do it. She finally gave in and signed a non-disclosure agreement, receiving money and agreeing not to talk.

Weinstein told CNN of the NDA, Ms. Gutierrez's lawyers controlled those meetings and set the terms for it, adding, his legal team later raised reasonable doubts about various aspects of her story during cross-examination in his Los Angeles sex crimes trial. He never faced charges and bought Tylana Gutierrez's case, but she did tell her story to a jury in 2022 as a supporting witness in Los Angeles, where Weinstein was convicted on three of seven charges and sentenced to 16 years in prison. And at the end of the trial, I spoke to one of the jurors and I remember he said to me, if Ombra was tied to charges, I would have felt that Harvey Weinstein was guilty 100%.

I was going to be getting emotional and if you want to take a moment, it's okay. I know. Knowing that if maybe I could have just found the right person to release those recordings, you know, I wouldn't lose everything I lost. And many people would have not been in the position that they are in right now because I could have just finished everything in 2015.

Elizabeth Weicmann's her joint test. Now, so the current Manhattan D.A. is about to retry Weinstein. Will Amber Gutierrez be involved in that trial?

It's a great question, Anderson, and no she won't. Amber told me that she is thrilled that they will retry this case, but Ombra testified in Los Angeles as a supporting witness, and these are the exact type of witnesses that are at the crux of why this conviction was overturned. The New York Court of Appeals says that there was too much evidence, too many women who testified because their testimony did not directly tie into these charges. So, Ombra is actually part of a network of accusers and survivors of sexual assault who are working towards changing these laws because they feel it is important for a jury to hear a pattern of alleged behavior.

Now, by the way, Anderson, I do want to let you know that Ombra is still under that non-disclosure agreement, but she broke that million dollar NDA to speak to us in this interview. Elizabeth, thanks so much. And that's it. It's been nearly two years since 19 children and two teachers were murdered in the Uvaldy school shooting.

Now, the families of the victims have reached a settlement with the city over the shooting response details ahead. As we approach the two-year anniversary of the Uvaldy mass shooting this Friday, 19 families of the victims announced today that they've reached a $2 million settlement with the city. The families also say they're suing 92 officers and the school district over the failed shooting response. Now, this comes just a day after the new Uvaldy school district police chief submitted his resignation.

The man who held that position during the massacre was fired months after the shooting. As you may know, 19 children and two teachers were killed at Uvaldy's Rob Elementary school after the shooter barricaded himself in a classroom and took 77 minutes for officers to breach that classroom door and kill the gunman. That's it for us. The news continues.

I'll see you tomorrow. The source of Kaitlin Collins starts now. From the descendants of history makers involved in the Louisiana Purchase to the Lewis and Clark Expedition, discover the untold stories of American expansion in the CNN original series this land, premiering June 7 on CNN. Hey, I'm Anderson Cooper.

My podcast, All There Is, We Explore Grief and Loss in All Its Complexities. As Ken Burns said on an earlier podcast, the Half-Life of Grief is endless. Mariska Hargate knows that very well. Jane Mansfield was killed in a car crash in 1967.

Mariska was in the car with her. After decades spent coming to terms with her past and wanting to learn more about the mother she doesn't remember, Mariska has made a remarkable documentary called My Mom Jane. Our vulnerability is our greatest strength and our greatest connector. And so in telling the story, I don't feel vulnerable.

I feel free. We all have a story and you never know what somebody else carries. Talking Grief, Building Community. That's what the podcast is all about.

This is All There Is. Listen and follow wherever you get your podcasts.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Anderson Cooper 360?

This episode is 46 minutes long.

When was this Anderson Cooper 360 episode published?

This episode was published on May 23, 2024.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Anderson Cooper 360 episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.