EPISODE · Sep 19, 2025 · 56 MIN
Fox Hollow Farm: America’s Most Terrifying Murder House | True Crime & Paranormal
from Retraced Echoes Podcast · host Retraced Echoes
In the early 1990s, young men began vanishing from Indianapolis. Their disappearances all pointed toward one man… Herb Baumeister. Behind the gates of Fox Hollow Farm, police would later uncover over 10,000 human bone fragments. Some say the property is still haunted, not only by his victims but perhaps by Herb himself. In this episode, we retrace the echoes of America’s most terrifying murder house. From the chilling encounter with “Brian Smart,” to mannequins staged around an indoor pool, to the shocking discoveries on the farm, this story blurs the line between true crime and the paranormal. Stay tuned until the end… because the haunting continues in Part 2 on Heather’s channel, Tell Me A Scary Story. 👻 Watch Part 2 here: https://open.spotify.com/episode/2YBgS92wRgtSaUeDz82hLJ?si=chUyTXHYR1aYsbQy22eBKg Heather's TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@tellmeascarystorypodcast?is_from_webapp=1&sender_device=pc 💀 Subscribe for more true paranormal and chilling mysteries: @RetracedEchoes 🐦 Follow on Twitter: Look up RetracedEchoes
What this episode covers
In the early 1990s, young men began vanishing from Indianapolis. Their disappearances all pointed toward one man… Herb Baumeister. Behind the gates of Fox Hollow Farm, police would later uncover over 10,000 human bone fragments. Some say the property is still haunted, not only by his victims but perhaps by Herb himself. In this episode, we retrace the echoes of America’s most terrifying murder house. From the chilling encounter with “Brian Smart,” to mannequins staged around an indoor pool, to the shocking discoveries on the farm, this story blurs the line between true crime and the paranormal. Stay tuned until the end… because the haunting continues in Part 2 on Heather’s channel, Tell Me A Scary Story. 👻 Watch Part 2 here: https://open.spotify.com/episode/2YBgS92wRgtSaUeDz82hLJ?si=chUyTXHYR1aYsbQy22eBKg Heather's TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@tellmeascarystorypodcast?is_from_webapp=1&sender_device=pc 💀 Subscribe for more true paranormal and chilling mysteries: @RetracedEchoes 🐦 Follow on Twitter: Look up RetracedEchoes
NOW PLAYING
Fox Hollow Farm: America’s Most Terrifying Murder House | True Crime & Paranormal
No transcript for this episode yet
Similar Episodes
No similar episodes found.
Similar Podcasts
No similar podcasts found.