Skip to content
Fox On The Run? Maybe Not episode artwork

Apr 20, 2023 36 min

Fox On The Run? Maybe Not

from Fourth Estate Hosted by 2SER

This week we turn our attention to the biggest defamation payout in US history. Fox News has this week agreed to pay 787 Million US dollars to Dominion which supplied voting machines to the 2020 presidential election. To discuss what this means we spoke to Paddy Manning.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Fox On The Run? Maybe Not

0:00 36:54
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Hello and welcome to For For State, a show about journalism. We're coming to you from Tiresia in Sydney on Gadigal lands of Euro Nation, right across Australia on the community radio network and directly to your device across the globe via podcast. I'm Anthony Dockwall. This week we turn our attention to the biggest deformation payout in US history.

Fox News has this week agreed to pay $787 million to voting machine company Dominion. Dominion was one of the providers of voting machines during the 2020 presidential election, which former President Donald Trump claimed was rigged against him. Fox News, watching its writing slide in the aftermath of the election, supported these claims, even though internal communication within the company showed many senior people did not believe the claims being made about the election and the way the election was stolen were true. To unpack this, we are fortunate to have the one person in Australia across the case and the workings of the News Corp and the Murdoch family.

Patty Manning is a journalist and author. His latest book is called The Successor, The High Stakes Life of Lachlan Murdoch. Patty Manning, welcome back to For For State. Thanks very much Anthony.

It's great to be here. So Dominion's defamation case against Fox News has been settled for staggering $787 million US dollars. It's reported to be the largest deformation payout in US history. Patty, were you surprised that Fox settled?

To be honest, I was because for months and months, I had made the assumption that look, there's no way at the end of the day, either Rupert or Lachlan Murdoch wants to take the stand in a court case and this will be settled. And it just got closer and closer to and I was kind of being backgrounded that actually Lachlan Murdoch, who hasn't actually appeared in a courtroom since the days of the one-tail collapse 20 years ago, which some of you listeners might remember. But yeah, that actually Lachlan was quite prepared to take the witness stand in that they saw Fox saw this as an important First Amendment case, which it undoubtedly was, and they were determined to fight it. And most importantly, in February, when we saw release hundreds of thousands of pages of documents, all sort of internal emails, correspondence, text messages from the Murdochs, key executives like Fox News Chief Suzanne Scott and talent like Tucker Carlson, Sean Hannity, Laura Ingram, all the prime times stars of Fox News.

And we also saw a sworn testimony from Rupert Murdoch himself, and from Lachlan and from other executives and talent at Fox. Once all that damaging evidence was out, which I'm sure we'll get into. But once all that evidence was out, I thought that the incentive to settle was gone. The brand damage effectively was done, and that Fox News will be best served, and Fox Corporation will be best served by going into defend itself.

And another kind of qualification there is that Fox had a pretty good chance that it could appeal any decision that it lost at the first instance in the Superior Court of Delaware, which I was told the company regarded as a shitty jurisdiction if you don't mind my language. But they expected they could appeal it to ultimately all the way to the US Supreme Court. And as we know, the Supreme Court has a conservative super majority 6-3 at the moment, partly as a result of years of campaigning in particular by the Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell, who as it happens, the Murdochs have donated Rupert and Lachlan a million dollars each to the Senate leadership on that Mitch McConnell runs. So they're close to McConnell and remember his wife used to be on the Fox Board.

So Fox had a pretty good chance that it could appeal and prevail on a very conservative leaning Supreme Court on First Amendment grounds. And so that's a long answer to your question, Anthony, but that's me saying that I had come around to the view and so had most commentators who were looking at this case that Fox and Dominion were both determined to fight it out. And every indication was right up until last Sunday, remember the hearing was due to start this week on Monday, US time, until the judge Eric Davis announced that there was an attempt to settle, a last minute attempt to settle, and he put the opening hearing back a day. And so we're all on notice as of last Sunday, US time that there was a last ditch effort to settle.

And I suppose settling on the courtroom steps, that's a long tradition, and plenty of people do it. But not when all of the, you do it because you're trying to protect the brand and to prevent a whole bunch of evidence coming up that might be damaging. But in this case, the evidence had already come out as far as Fox was concerned. So I thought the incentive to settle had gone.

Well, there's a lot to unpack there. So, but it does seem that there was an urgency to settle to avert the case. You've mentioned that Lachlan was comfortable going to court, even though he's obviously forgotten his performance in the one-tail inquiries. But do you think it maybe it was Rupert and the Fox talent that was the ultimate reason why this case was settled?

Well, I do think that's a clear part of it. It's one murder of what you said to me, you know, who wants a 92-year-old wildcard to go into court? What might Rupert say? Now, you know, personally, reading the depositions, I was struck by Rupert, his kind of mental agility at the age of 92.

I think it's incredible. There he is, going toe to toe with the minions lawyers and arguing the toss over which prime-time anchor among Fox News and Fox Business stable commentators, which one had given more or less endorsement to Donald Trump and his base on stolen election claims, including the defamation, the fammetry claims against the minion. And trying to argue for a distinction between the claims that some of those prime-time host might have made and any endorsement of the stolen election claims by Fox News itself. And I think for any 92-year-old to be having an argument like that is pretty remarkable.

On the other hand, I think there is a view, there was certainly a view inside Fox that some of that evidence was probably Rupert being a little bit too frank and admitting too much when he said, for example, on those, that he wished in hindsight that Fox had been more strenuous in denouncing the baseless claims that the 2020 election event stolen. Well, I suppose as a journalist, I'm reading that and going, that's commendable honesty and there should be more of it. But at a corporate level, I think there was concern that Rupert would not be told what was advisable and what was not advisable to admit and what else might he admit in open court. And so, now that was compounded, I think, at the last minute by a discovery by a Dominion's lawyers that Rupert Murdoch in fact had an executive role as executive chair of Fox News itself, the subsidiary company that runs the News Network.

So all along, Fox had been arguing that the Fox Corporation executives and directors should not be required to appear in the Dominion case because they were not directly involved in the coverage that went to air. So that was a responsibility of Fox News, which is a subsidiary company and it's got its own management, including Suzanne Scott, who I mentioned before, who's the chief executive and Jay Wallace, who's the editorial vice president and a whole bunch of other people. But the people who work for Fox Corporation, and that's where Lachlan Murdoch is the CEO and executive co-chair and Rupert Murdoch is a non-executive co-chair. And other people like Viet Din, the chief legal officer and others, now on there's the chief operating officer and financial officer and etc.

Those people had no role in the coverage. But then at the last minute, it was discovered that, oh, they'd forgotten Rupert was actually the executive chair of Fox News itself, the subsidiary company. Now they say that was a kind of honorary thing. It was some hangover from a previous structure or a role that he had bearing in mind that he founded the network more than 25 years ago.

But according to the court, the judge said Fox had a credibility problem and that he was very uncomfortable that perhaps Rupert Murdoch and Fox had avoided their obligations under discovery. And he appointed a special master to investigate this discrepancy just on Tuesday in the first hearing. And that might have provided an incentive to Fox to settle. There might have been more revelations to come out.

Well, that's right. That's right. He especially investigated who was appointed, had the power to again call for depositions. And so that's right to be another kind of painful process.

Yeah. And you've got to bear in mind, this is all happening as another voting machine manufacturer, Smartmatic, has brought an even larger defamation claim against Fox on $2.7 billion. And so everything that happens in the Dominion case is forming a precedent for Smartmatic. And so you can sort of see how there might have been a desire to split the difference, even though $787 million in US dollars is the largest defamation payment that's ever been made in US history.

It's still only a small amount for Fox, which generates something like $2 billion of free cash flow every year and has $4 billion on its balance sheet. The stock has barely moved in response to the news in the last 24 hours. Were you surprised that there wasn't even a small blip to the stock price? Absolutely.

Yeah. I really did think there will be something like a 10% fall or something would have been what I would have expected, just based on the size of that pay out. But it's all happening at the same time as a very important carriage fee renegotiations that Fox news is involved in, which I mean, I'm a little bit complicated for an Australian audience, but they're an important source of revenue for and profit for Fox. And they're happening right now this month, three of the biggest renewals that Fox has to negotiate.

And these three-year deals together are worth $3 billion. And if they're trying to renegotiate at the same time as they've got a messy six-week court here and going on a Delaware, you've got $3 billion on the one hand and $800 million on the other, which is greater. So I think Fox just came to the view that they would have to just have to lump up this payment. And they can afford it.

There's no expectation from any of the people that I've spoken to or seen quoted in the meeting in the last 24 hours that Fox is going to go broke or anything like it. And partly that's because its ratings have held up even through all of the terrible headlines that we've seen about Fox in the last two months. They're ratings in some demographics have actually improved. And certainly in the important prime time slots, they're holding their ground.

And that's because of the nature of their audience. Their Fox news audience does regard the rest of the media with some hostility. By and large, they think of other news channels as unreliable fake news media. And they're incredibly loyal to Fox.

And they're not really in New York Times. I want to get to their audience a little bit. But one point I want to raise here is, you know, frankly, if this was a normal media company, when something like this happens, the largest defamation payout in US history heads would roll. And a lot of them, however, this doesn't seem to be a normal media company, the internal communications at Fox make it pretty clear that we're in a local and we're in the loop across the details.

So how do you think recommendations are likely and how do you think they may go? Well, it's a delicate situation clearly. There are, there are shareholders suits on foot. There's one at least that's been filed already.

And apparently there's another eight law firms recruiting for, recruiting for clients to back a shareholder action alleging negligence on the part of Fox directors in allowing all this false defamatory content to go to air. And the, so quite apart from the two cases brought by Dominion and Smartmatic, where liability could exceed easily exceed a billion dollars, which would make it sort of the worst financial crisis in terms of a financial impact that Fox has ever suffered. Or the Murdoch's ever suffered if you go back to phone hacking and, you know, other close shareholder class actions that have been brought. So, so but then yes shareholders were not only looking for some compensation for their losses bearing in mind, all of these payouts are shareholders' money that's going out the door.

They will also be looking for, I think you're right, management change and or change to the editorial practices. And now if Lachlan has even in the wake of the evidence that was revealed in Discovery in the Dominion case with all those emails and texts and, you know, depositions and everything, Lachlan has stood firmly by the Fox News and Chief Suzanne Scott because she's the one he appointed. I mean, for a whole bunch of reasons, probably, but also because she is the one he appointed when after the downfall of Roger Ailes back in 2016, you know, in the middle of all those bombshell accusations of sexual harassment by Gretchen Carlson. And at that time, Lachlan made what was, you know, a pretty well received appointment of the first woman to run Fox News, Suzanne Scott.

And she has been in the chair ever since. And he stood by her only in February at an industry conference in the States of Wherry, where he said she thought she was doing a great job. I think there will be some focus on the role of yet Dint, who is the second most powerful person at Fox News, sorry, at Fox Corporation, and the second best paid after Lachlan himself, because Fox's legal strategy has got everyone kind of scratching their heads here because it seems to be a bit of a lose-lose in the sense that both the, you know, normally if you're going to settle it because you want to keep stuff confidential. And that's the benefit of not going to court.

In this case, they've had the damaging evidence out and also paid handsomely. So, you know, I think there are going to be questions about, I mean, there's a bit of speculation ramping up about whether the Murdochs will make a sort of blood sacrifices, you know, that you might hear in succession. They've kind of, they've done that before when they, in the phone hacking scandal. Well, James Murdoch, James Murdoch fell on his sword over phone hacking.

Do you think it will go that high or they'll keep it away from the family this time? Well, I think it's too early to say. If I think if there had been a bloodbath in the share market today and, you know, there was really clear that, you know, Fox was in deep trouble. I think, you know, the reaction might have been more kind of punitive.

But as it turns out, you know, I think over two years of litigation in this Dominion case and, you know, with America as polarized as it is. And, you know, I had to say it, but Fox News profiting as much as it does from a, from that polarization, you know, in a way that is part of their business strategy. And so I think that, you know, Fox investors know what kind of ride they're in for in a way and they're sticking by the company. And they expect, you know, given the balance sheet strength at Fox, they expect that it's going to survive.

And so it may be that there's no need for heads to roll. Although, you know, time will tell it's only the settlements only, you know, less than 48 hours old at this point. So this is a really interesting point though, and it's not one that I would have predicted yesterday. So, you know, Dominion's attorney, Justin Nelson after the settlement was made, said truth matters, lies have consequences.

Today's settlement of 787 million represents accountability. It doesn't seem to represent accountability at all in the parallel universe of Fox News. They don't have to apologize. They haven't had a, their share price hasn't been hit.

They clearly aren't going to radically change how they operate or potentially even how they run the business. Does it surprise you that at this stage, it does not seem to be any form of accountability when you have the largest defamation settlement in history? Yes, it does. It is surprising.

But, you know, I suppose we are used to seeing the Murdochs weather all storms, you know, and it doesn't matter whether it's the phone hacking scandal, where, you know, I think the accumulated total over the lease of now exceeded $1 billion since 2011 when it first broke and in terms of payouts, the people whose phones were hacked. And then also, you know, for example, the payout that was made after Shout of Suetov and Hepatism when news corporation bought Elizabeth Murdoch's shine, television production company for best part from memory of $600 million or the one tell scandal when, you know, that was one of Australia's biggest corporate collapses at the time and news got Shout was lost more than half a million dollars in that collapse. And that was all Shout as money in the Murdochs. You know, Lachlan Murdoch certainly emerged unscathed, although we did have to give evidence and say I don't recall 800 times, that was the worst of it, as far as he was concerned.

And, you know, I think there's been a long standing kind of criticism, I suppose, of the Murdochs that they control the company with an economic interest of something like 12%, they have the voting, you know, through their two classes voting and non-voting shares, they have a voting stake of 40%. And they've been able to kind of insulate themselves from the normal standards of corporate governance that, you know, you would expect of a such a major listed company and that I suppose in this case, we're seeing another example where maybe it is obvious that you would call for the CEO's head. But the CEO in this case, the Fox Corporation happens to be Lachlan Murdoch. And there is no prospect that, you know, Fox is going to round on the son of the founder.

And the designated successor who is taking over from Rupert at the who is now 92. You know, so I think that whether, you know, perhaps there's already some speculation I mentioned about a blood sacrifice, which, you know, might, you know, maybe there's going to be a focus on someone like Vietnam who's responsible for the legal strategy that has seen Fox come up with such an inexpensive payout, you know, maybe. That's a big stretch in itself because Lachlan appointed via den. He is very close to him.

He is Godfather to Lachlan's eldest son. You know, this is someone who has worked hand in glove with Lachlan for more than a decade. So, so... And loyalty is a big thing in this family as well, isn't it?

It is until it isn't. You know, Rebecca Brooks had to resign. Liz Hinton, who worked for Rupert for decades, had to resign as the then head of New Zealand International. These are people that Rupert Murdoch, they were loyal to Rupert and he was loyal to them, but they still had to resign in the middle of the phone hacking scandal.

So, it is quite possible that this scandal, which is, you know, ultimately had such a huge, I mean, it is a global story and, you know, the 2020 election and Donald Trump's stolen election claims and January 6 and the whole fallout. I mean, obviously, it's still continuing. And I should say, it's not resolved even now as we speak, how Fox will handle Trump in the run up to 2024 if he continues to make these claims. Are they going to air them?

Which he will, he will keep doing it. There's no question that he will stop. But this brings me back to a lot of commentators, quite angry, but the court case isn't going ahead saying that US democracy is the loser. But do you think a six-week court case would have been a pivotal moment for democracy and media in US?

Or do you think it would have been what you unpacked earlier, a long process for Fox News taking this to the Supreme Court? Well, I suppose that there's no question about the importance of the case. You know, the case that Dominion brought was very strong. And so some legal experts were saying, and so just to be clear, it's very hard to get a defamation case up in the United States.

The A.K. doctrine set out in the case of New York Times, where he's selling in 1964, ruling by the Supreme Court there requires that a defamatory statement, not just be false, but that it be knowingly false or made with reckless disregard as to whether it was true or not. And that is described as actual malice. So you can't, you will be protected by the First Amendment, which guarantees freedom of speech and a free press in America.

You'll be protected if you are a journalist trying to establish the truth and you make a mistake, you make a false claim. But if it was a mistake, you're still covered. And the Supreme Court has upheld that right. But if you knowingly make a false statement, or you do it with reckless disregard as to whether it's true or not, and that's what Dominion was alleging in this case, then you might not have the protection of the First Amendment.

And so the stakes in this case were incredibly high, because if, according to media lawyers that I was reading, had been quoted in the media during the coverage of the case, they're saying if this case didn't meet the test of actual malice, then nothing did, because all of the emails and text send correspondence that we discovered through the Dominion case showed that everybody from the Murdochs down, including the prime time host, knew that the claims that the election was stolen, and that Dominion had been as a voting man, a machine manufacturer, flipping votes from Trump to Biden, they knew those claims were false. There are some caveats there because a presenters on Fox Business like Lou Dobbs or Maria Bartiromo, there was no evidence that they ever disbelieved the claims. But just about everyone else knew that it was rubbish. Sean, how did you know it was rubbish?

Rupert Murdoch knew it was rubbish. Tucker Carlson knew it was rubbish. They all knew Sidney Powell was, you know, could not be trusted. She had no evidence that the claim she was making did over Rudy Giuliani.

But that's not what they said on air. And so if they have said those things on air, then surely that meets the test of reckless disregard for the truth of these defamatory allegations. And they are defamatory. There's no question about that.

And that had already been ruled by Judge Davis in this case. He'd already said, these are defamatory per se. It's crystal clear that they statements were false. And, you know, if you read Dominion's writ, it's painful reading because they wrote to Fox News multiple occasions, multiple executives saying what you are putting to air is wrong.

More than 20 times the claim was made that Dominion was part of a conspiracy to flip votes from Biden to Trump. And so there's plenty of commentary to say that if this case didn't meet the actual Malas test, then nothing did. And you could lie with impunity. So do you see this as a wasted opportunity for a cleansing moment in the political climate in America?

You know, I could wish for a cleansing moment, but I don't think I could say that this case would have provided it any more than the astonishing evidence that's already come out would provide it. You know, I mean, unfortunately, this case leaves America just as divided as it was, you know, in 2020 or in 2021 when it was launched. So I don't know whether, you know, the case I also had risks. And that was the other point I wanted to make is that there were, you were just starting to see, you know, legal experts saying, for example, in New York Times, I've had last Friday that there are risks, you know, people should be, you know, wary, they might be cheering on the demise of Fox News because they don't like Fox News, but they should be wary of any decision, which limits the First Amendment and protection of the free press.

And I suppose I always, as a journalist, are towards favoring freedom of the press. And I think there were dangers, there was some merit in Fox News's argument that there was a chilling effect to a case which, you know, sought to limit their ability to report on, intrinsically news where the allegations being made by the president of the United States. Now, there's a whole lot of counter arguments to that, which we could go through because ultimately, surely, if you're a news company, you've got to report the truth. That's your fundamental obligation.

And Fox News fell short of that in this case, and that was already established in the pre-trial hearings. So, but I'm just saying there are, there is a counter argument that there was a danger out of this case that, you know, you know, free, the free press would be kind of constrained by any ruling that resulted. Yeah, what we have, I mean, even plenty of people wanted to, you know, we're looking forward to the trial. I wasn't, I suppose, in a way, because I would have to sit up, you know, turn nocturnal and sit dialing from my study in Sydney to listen to six weeks of, you know, scratchy phone line.

So, I wasn't looking forward to that, in a sense. But the, but it was the media, it was going to be the media trial of the century. And what other chance do you have to hear from Rupert Murdoch himself and all of those stars about how they, how they, you know, do, you know, justify what they put to where? It's been a pretty bumpy couple of months here for Rupert Murdoch.

There's his on and off marriage, and obviously what we've just been talking about. But there was a recent Vanity Fair article inside Rupert Murdoch's succession drama. It painted a pretty sad picture, I have to say, of a pretty broken family. What did you make of it?

There's a lot of well-known, and I've reported on some of it, you know, well-known feud still between Lachlan and his brother James. And, you know, presumably some of the, you know, more carnival kind of stuff that Gabe Sherman reported in Vanity Fair was coming from, you know, one of those two quarters. I, I, I've thought it was a great read. Sherman is a fantastic journalist, his biography of Roger Ailes, his absolute must read.

Don't just settle for what's in the movie, go back and read the book. It's fantastic. But I, for example, you know, where there's a suggestion that Lachlan Murdoch was hospitalised, hospitalised, having a panic attack over the course of the negotiation of the sale to Disney in 2017-18. I'm just not sure that that, that wasn't corroborated.

And I'm not sure that that, that rings true. And in fact, I'm told that it absolutely isn't true. So, you know, I think there's always a tendency with the, with the Murdochs to err in favour of the, the colourful, but because of the nature of the family and the fact that they are so well guarded and so well versed in, you know, all the tricks of all, of the, of journalists, everything comes on background. It can be very hard to, you know, sort through what's true and what's simply juicy.

And I think, yeah, I think I suppose I just wasn't sure about whether it was all true and that's what I, that's the way I felt about it. And that's why I asked you the question because I know you're the one person who's probably in a position to, to confirm that read because it was a pretty eye-opening read, I have to say. Well, let's, let's wrap it up with a final question. This is obviously an extremely big deal.

A settlement of this, as I mentioned, that Smart Madica also circling for even a bigger potential defamation payout. There's a lot of this still to unpack, but News Corp is an international company. Do you see any of this getting beyond the, the, the shores of America in the sense of, having flow and effects? And one of the things I'm thinking about is the Lockland's defamation case against Crikey.

Do you think there could be other flow and effects that we haven't actually unpacked here or thought about? From the settlement? No. For Crikey, that's really complicated.

And I think there are too many people making the assumption that what we've seen in the Dominion case means it's a slam dunk for Crikey and the legal system is completely different. We don't have a right to free speech in Australia, anything like what, you know, the rights they have in the United States and where the defamation capital of the world. And, and I think, so I don't think that there's any automatic translation of a payout from Fox in the United States to therefore a victory for Crikey in Australia. On that note, I'd like to thank Patty Manning for being on For State and thanks for listening to the program.

This edition was recorded at the studios of TuroCR and heard across the country on the community radio network. For for States produced for the assistance of the Community Broadcasting Foundation, thanks to the Foundation for their continuing support. Make sure you subscribe to For State on your favorite podcast so you can hear us talk about media, politics and a lot in between. We'll be back next week, but in the meantime, you can stay in touch with us on Twitter.

Our handle is for For State AU. I'm Anthony Dockrell. Thanks for listening.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Fourth Estate?

This episode is 36 minutes long.

When was this Fourth Estate episode published?

This episode was published on April 20, 2023.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Fourth Estate episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.