EPISODE · Apr 16, 2026 · 12 MIN
Gary Never Removed His Turtleneck and We Finally Found Out Why
from The StoryKeeper's Spooky Stories · host Robert Jerome Pagan
Turn off the lights… and turn on the dark. Steven always thought his dad was weird. Not “dad joke” weird.Not “embarrassing at the pool” weird. Something else. Because Gary never—ever—took off his black turtleneck. Not in the heat.Not at the pool.Not even at night. But when Steven’s mom finally decides to find out why… Something comes loose. Something that should have stayed… tight. This is Gary’s Turtleneck Terror — a Goosebumps-style horror story with a much darker twist.Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/the-storykeeper-s-spooky-stories--6839607/support.Family Friendly, Kids Horror, Scary Stories for Kids, Robert Jerome Pagan, Goosebumps Style, Clean Horror, Spooky Stories, Audio Drama, Ghost Stories, Storytelling, Road Trip Podcast, Teens, Halloween, StoryKeepers
What this episode covers
Turn off the lights… and turn on the dark. Steven always thought his dad was weird. Not “dad joke” weird.Not “embarrassing at the pool” weird. Something else. Because Gary never—ever—took off his black turtleneck. Not in the heat.Not at the pool.Not even at night. But when Steven’s mom finally decides to find out why… Something comes loose. Something that should have stayed… tight. This is Gary’s Turtleneck Terror — a Goosebumps-style horror story with a much darker twist.Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/the-storykeeper-s-spooky-stories--6839607/support.Family Friendly, Kids Horror, Scary Stories for Kids, Robert Jerome Pagan, Goosebumps Style, Clean Horror, Spooky Stories, Audio Drama, Ghost Stories, Storytelling, Road Trip Podcast, Teens, Halloween, StoryKeepers
NOW PLAYING
Gary Never Removed His Turtleneck and We Finally Found Out Why
No transcript for this episode yet
Similar Episodes
No similar episodes found.
Similar Podcasts
No similar podcasts found.