Skip to content
General Introduction to Psychiatry episode artwork

Feb 16, 2018 54 min

General Introduction to Psychiatry

from Take Aurally Hosted by Take Aurally

Psychiatry and Mental Health issues are important considerations in Emergency Medicine and part of the Clinical Phase 2 curriculum at the University of Nottingham. Therefore we were delighted when Dr James Ellison, Consultant Psychiatrist with a special interest in Substance Misuse joined the pod in DREEAM to record with us. This first podcast looks at a general approach to patients with a Psychiatric condition with focus on patients with: Depression Psychosis Personality Disorder As well as useful advice on talking to patient with these conditions James gives a nice oversight of an approach to mental health in general. Remember to check out www.takeaurally.com for the blog entry for this podcast and follow Take Aurally and DREEAM on both Facebook and Twitter.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

General Introduction to Psychiatry

0:00 54:37
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Thanks for downloading and welcome to Take Orally, the podcast from Dream QMC Nottingham. In this episode we'll be discussing general introduction to psychiatry. As ever, all information is correct at the time of recording. All guidelines mentioned are correct for Nottingham University Hospital's NHS Trust. Other trust guidelines may vary. All views and opinions are the speaker's own.

Hello, welcome back to Take Aurelie. James Thomas here, a teacher fellow in emergency medicine. I'm delighted to welcome Dr. James Allison to Take Aurelie. Welcome, James. Hello. And you work in psychiatry, is that not right? I do indeed. What's your special interest? Well, I'm trained as a general adult psychiatrist, but I have an endorsement in substance abuse psychiatry, and that's the area that I currently work in. So I'm the local consultant with the Nottinghamshire Dual Diagnosis Service. So it's a team that works with people with mental illness and colonel with substance abuse. And I deal with the substance abuse side of things. Okay.

So in this podcast, we're going to just have a bit of a general introduction to some of the concepts and diagnoses that there are in psychiatry. This is obviously a very great subject. We could do a whole series of podcasts on each topic. We're going to try and keep this as brief and general as possible. So mental health issues, something we see very commonly in the motor department. In every shift, I think I'll see at least one patient who's got some aspects of mental health that's being at least a part of the reason to come to motor department. In your training, you must have had a lot of reason to come down to various A&Es. Yeah, so throughout my training, I was in and out of A&E.

to assess patients who were peculiar and well, who were suicidal, basically any sort of distress that they were... Express, I often got referred to the Liaison Psychiatry Service, and as a junior doctor in psychiatry, you cover that service and hours. So I've assessed countless patients in only, both as part of their emergency assessment and also as part of mental health assessment, which I think we'll be talking about later. So this original podcast is aimed at, here at the University of Nottingham, psychiatry is part of the fourth year, clinical phase 2, CP2, but also for anybody who's starting in emergency medicine who wants a little bit of an introduction into what it is like to look after a patient with mental health issues.

So we'll just start with a few definitions, I suppose. First one being depression. There's a very big difference in depression as an illness and what we hear, we may say to our friends, I'm feeling depressed today. Yeah, so depression is something that we'll all be familiar with and have an understanding of, either through personal experience, experiences of friends and family, or just from our understanding of everyday sadness. Depression is what used to be termed a neurosis. And the defining feature of neurosis is that they are conditions that feature problems that we all experience.

but which are exaggerated to a degree that they impair function. So everyone experiences sadness at some point in their lives, but when that sadness becomes so extreme and out of kilter with the context of your life, then it represents a diagnosable and a harmful condition. So yeah, depression is... sadness is at the core of it and that's a low mood as we would term it in psychiatry but there are a lot of other things that come in with depression to make it into an actual condition that's distinct from just being sad. So what other things might the patient be complaining of or what would you want a junior doctor or a medical student to ask in their history if they were considering a patient with depressive illness? I think the main thing really is when you're approaching any patient with mental illness really is just to be curious and to find out as much as possible about

that patient's experience of what they're going through in their own words. There's not any question that you can ask that's going to make things worse, within reason. But in terms of depression, I guess obviously you want to know what that patient's description of their mood is like. How do they feel? And you want that in their own words. And really, it's good to describe that. Often that will include expletives, but it's helpful to know what that patient describes their mood as. But then there's also the pattern of the mood. So if someone is...

feeling very sad, but then an hour later they're feeling very happy, that would work against a diagnosis of depression. Likewise, if someone is feeling sad for a day and then they perk up the next day, that's not consistent. So we're looking at the pattern throughout a day, but also the pattern over a number of days and weeks. If we're looking at the IC10 diagnosis criteria, then you need to have a period of low mood for at least two weeks. So we're looking at how long the low mood's been there for.

what the pattern is like throughout the day generally people with depression will feel worse in the morning and it will get better throughout the day so that's called diana variation and then there's Aside from the actual mood itself, there's other symptoms that can come along with depression. So I guess really important is sleep. Sleep is disturbed in most mental illnesses. It's a bit of a chip in the next thing, which disturbance came first. But in depression, the typical sleep disturbance is that people will be waking up really early. So as he says on the tin, it's called early morning wakening. And they're looking at someone waking up at least two hours before they normally would wake up naturally and not being able to go back to sleep. And that's actually, it sounds trivial. It's actually really distressing, especially if...

If you're awake and anyone else is awake, there's nothing to talk to, you're alone with your thoughts, you're stewing on things. So that's something that's what their sleep pattern is like. I guess that leads on to another feature of the way that people think when they're depressed is that often they will ruminate and stew on negative thoughts. It's very hard to see the trees when you're depressed and you often will only see the negative things and you'll think about those and those will snowball out of control. So negative ruminations and negative thoughts are something that you need to ask about, what they tend to think about. I guess also

People with depression are often hopeless. They don't think there's any way that they're going to get better or they feel helpless. They don't think anyone can help them. And just asking, do you feel hopeless? Do you feel helpless? Those are really helpful questions to ask in your assessment. Other things, just a lot of patients will tell you these things without coming to ask them directly. But we're looking for things like self-esteem, tearfulness, feeling guilty. Often people will feel guilty about things. And they haven't necessarily done anything, but they'll just feel a general sense of guilt and trepidation.

People can be intolerant or irritable. And also, it's really important to ask about what people's days are like, what they do with their time. Often people won't have the motivation or the interest in doing things. Patients with depression often suffer, or usually suffer, what we call anadonia, so an inability to enjoy things. And often you'll find people, it's useful to say, what did you used to enjoy? And they'll tell you about the sports or the hobbies or the things they used to enjoy doing. And if they don't enjoy doing those things, if they don't get any joy out of those things, that's an important sign to be aware of.

Obviously, although we talk about depression as an illness that's mainly about mood, anxiety often comes as part of depression as well. So they're often intertwined and people will be very anxious. And I think the one that people most often worry about is suicidal thoughts and thoughts about self-harm. And that's always something to be aware of and to ask about. And also be aware that asking about it doesn't increase the risk of someone harming themselves. It's really important that you are not going to be the first person to have...

introduce a concept of suicide to someone. They're not. You're not going to plant that in their mind. So you need to ask that. Ask it in a sensitive way, but you do need to ask it. I often find it's useful to normalise those thoughts. So to say, well, when people are feeling very sad and very down, sometimes they think about hurting themselves. Have you ever had thoughts like that? So you're sort of saying, look, I've seen other people, they're in this position, and they're thinking like this. Do you feel like that? It's an easy way into asking it rather than just blurting out your own thoughts. Yeah. And

Should we be prepared ourselves as the clinician, as a student, talking to somebody depressed that they may provoke feelings in ourselves? Should it be things we should be aware of as we can talk to them? Yeah, well, I think it's important to realise that all our patients provoke feelings in ourselves. And it's something that perhaps isn't thought about enough outside of psychiatry. But, you know, we all have feelings that are brought up in us by our patients, either positive or negative. And, you know, it's important to be aware of those and listen to those emotions.

not necessarily so you act on them often so you don't act on them so you may have a patient you find quite frustrating or who makes you feel very sad and it's important that you understand that that is you know that's separate to how you treat the patient you don't let those emotions affect how you treat the patient it may be distressing to you to speak to someone who's depressed especially if they've been through a lot of trauma and things like that and perhaps that may touch on sensitive things from your life and I'm not at all saying you shouldn't be aware of that, but you should make sure that that doesn't come into the consultation. You don't reveal things about yourself. You don't self-disclose to a great degree with that patient. But also that you address those things, but afterwards in a safe space, perhaps you'll talk to a colleague or a trusted friend or friend member to sort of de-stress in the mind, obviously without divulging patient details.

but it's really important and this is something that we do as psychiatrists we will throughout training have an hour of protected time with our supervisor every week where we can talk about these things and that to a lot of people seems a bit frivolous and you know a bit of a luxury but actually it's really important because dealing with other people's distress all the time can be quite distressing for you and so it's good to have a pressure valve to let that off to some extent and i mean i suppose it sounds a bit um a bit just to say, be nice, be sympathetic. Any other sort of tips when we're talking to somebody who is depressed? Any other tips on how we can come across as a communicator and as a clinician? Well, I think that it is just about your core communication skills and being an empathetic, kind human being, really. Now, it's important that you don't They're too far into mirroring their behaviours and becoming very quiet and closed off yourself. But equally, you don't want to be brash and in your face with the patient. So it's just that they're judging the situation and communicating with the patient on a way that's going to be sensitive to their emotional state. As I said, there's not really going to be anything that you're going to... Unless you're very insensitive with the way that you ask questions, there's not really going to be anything that you can make worse. There are certain topics that are difficult for anyone to discuss. So that would be things...

And this may not be as applicable to someone taking history in an emergency department setting, who's really looking at here and now and what the symptoms are. But as a psychiatrist, we were looking at people's pasts, often traumatic incidents such as childhood abuse. And those can be really upsetting things to talk about. So if you do talk about that, or if the patient talks about those things, I often think it's best to use ways into that conversation, to couch it in a way that normalizes it and doesn't come across as accusatory to the patient. So it might be, I need to ask these questions. It's quite difficult for some people to talk about this before and I'm aware of what's happened in childhood. Have you experienced anything that has said to be abused? So it's not going in and just asking me abused questions. But you do that in all sorts. So, you know, a young lady comes in with abdominal pain, I have to ask, HR2 might be pregnant. I mean, we do that in it. Exactly. But I think that often...

Because it's outside of your effort zone, people will go into questions in a clumsy way. I think the other thing is, it's not a bad thing to take a step away. And to just say, I just need to go and check some notes, or I just need to go and sort something out. If you need to gather your thoughts, or you're getting distressed, or you just need a breather, there's nothing wrong with taking it, as long as the patient's safe. there's nothing wrong with taking a step away. Because it does take quite a lot longer to do a psychiatric history than it does to do a simple history for shots of rattles and like that. So there's nothing wrong with taking a step away if you need that, rather than carrying on down a difficult path when you're not prepared for a T. There's nothing wrong with taking time. And maybe then if the patient becomes that they're not very forthcoming or something, you say, well, we maybe need to take some time out here. So, I mean, just my experience, Naini, if another common psychiatric presentation will be...

patients who are either known to have or are querying psychosis. So these could be the patient who is coming in confused, talking to themselves, has done, you know, has been acting strangely for the family. We've ruled out organic causes if they're not known to have a psychiatric condition or they've come in previously with a psychiatric condition. So what is psychosis? What sort of things are we thinking about when we talk about psychosis? Psychosis is, again, a broad umbrella term for a group of illnesses or conditions. Essentially the opposite side of the coin to neurosis.

So whereas in neurosis people experience those emotions in their everyday life, like mood, anxiety, those kind of things, or happiness, which is, you know, expanded mania. In psychosis, the symptoms that people experience are unusual. They're things that most people wouldn't experience in their everyday lives. So those are things like hallucinations, which are the experience of the stimulus without physical stimulus there to do that. So it's a perception without physical stimulus. And those could be in any of the sensory modalities, but most commonly auditory. It's very unusual to see a patient with visual hallucinations without an organic cause there. So visual hallucinations make you think organic. So patients will experience, or may experience hallucinations, which is

these perceptual abnormalities without stimulus. And right to thinking the auditory hallucination isn't their own voice, it's somebody else's. It could be. It could be someone else's. I think the thing about hallucination is it has all the characteristics of a real perception apart from the stimulus. So it will come in through your ears if it's an auditory hallucination. And there are lots of weird and wonderful things. It's not a voice in your head, it's not thoughts. Yeah, and the patient will...

Especially a first-time presentation of psychosis, they won't describe it as a voice in their head, it is a voice. And often they will go looking for the voice. They will say, oh, it's my neighbour, I can hear the neighbour talking through the walls. It feels like it's outside of your body. There are lots of weird and wonderful types of hallucination that we see very rarely. Extracampine hallucinations are hallucinations outside of normal realm of human ability. So I might think I can hear someone talking to me on the moon. They're quite rare, but there are things that...

As you say, it could be their voice, it could be someone else's, it could be a known voice, it could be an unknown voice. That voice could be coming from part of their body, it could be coming from an object, it could be coming from something that they identify, so they could be saying, the devil is talking to me, or they could have no idea what the voice is, but it's just very distressing. If you can imagine that yourself, you're hearing noises and voices that you can't explain at first, especially, it's extremely distressing, no matter what the content is. And patients often do become used to them and find ways of dealing with them if they have a long-term psychotic illness. But it is a really interesting thing to experience. And the thing that I was saying about it having all the features of a real perception is that the patient believes it's real. And that's... Insight is an issue. Yeah. They completely convinced it that it is real. Now, you will meet people who have...

voices in their heads but they know the voices inside their head or they have what seems like hallucination but there is one of the features of a real perception that isn't fulfilled and that's what we call a pseudo hallucination and often pseudo hallucinations are seen in people with personality disorder which we'll talk about later but in terms of hallucinations that's a really important thing to ask about and it can be really difficult to ask about because If the person thinks it's real, and you say, have you heard any voices that aren't there, then they will answer no, because the voices definitely aren't there, aren't they? So there's ways to ask about that. We often say things like, have you heard anyone speaking or any noises and voices when other people aren't around? Then they will say, well, yes, I heard this voice, and I couldn't find anyone that was saying it. So that's important to know about. Also, if it is an auditory hallucination, the content's really important.

So it might be positive content, it might be negative content, it might be about the person themselves, or it might be about the people around them. Sometimes people will experience negative comments about those around them. It's helpful to know if there are commands in there, so if the voice is telling people to do things. That does happen at times, and sometimes those commands are quite difficult to resist, so it's important to ask about when the voice is telling people to do things. Again, it's about being curious and just getting a flavour of what that person's experience is of that symptom. Other symptoms that people will experience, the main group of symptoms in psychosis are delusions, and those are fixed, unshakable, abnormal beliefs that aren't consistent with the patient's religious or cultural background.

So it's about, and again, how do you ask about that? Because you can't say, do you have any abnormal beliefs? Because the patient, they're completely unshakable. Any evidence that you give to the contrary, they will argue against. And I think the other thing to be aware of is just because it's improbable. It's not impossible. So I've met patients who have told me quite outlandish stories about having dinner with pop stars, but it's turned out that that has been true. So don't assume that something isn't true because it sounds strange.

But the delusions that people have, there's a variety of different kinds of delusions. I guess the most problematic are persecutory delusions. People are out to get me, there's a conspiracy against me, people want to kill me, those kind of things. So the way that you kind of... ask about those is if you're just with the patient on their own you can say are there any things that other people have said are quite strange or if there's someone that you can speak to a collateral history that's really important really helpful because you can ask family friends is there anything odd that the patient has said and the thing is though a lot of patients will be very very welcoming and it's important that you explore them, and don't just take them at face value, and we don't collude as well. So if someone told me that they thought that there was a conspiracy against the MI5 going to assassinate them.

I don't want to find out why the patient thought that. We want to gently challenge it to check whether that wasn't unshakable. So it seems a bit strange that MI5 would be out to get you. Why would they be interested in you? Because it doesn't seem that you're a significant political figure or something like that. And just gently pushing to see whether the thoughts and the delusion unravels or whether it changes. And the patients will often have an answer, you know,

for those things because often these delusions are part of the system. Because I know the secret. It all makes sense in their world. So a patient I saw recently was telling me that the queen wants to kill him for his organs because he's secretly, no one else knows this, but he is related to the queen. And then drawn into this were conspiracies with the IRA. So it's a real system that this patient completely believes.

And you can see delusions and hallucinations together, and then often there'll be a delusional explanation for the hallucination. So the voices are something that someone experiences, and then there is a delusional explanation attached. So the voices are, the voices are aliens, or those kind of things. And then that may be systematized, they believe further abnormal things around that delusion. So again, it's just about being curious and asking.

questions to kind of explore and get an idea of what that experience of that is. So what are you hearing, when do you hear it, how do you feel when you hear it, and going on from there, and a collateral if possible. Yeah, collateral is always really important. I think one thing as well to be aware of, we all have to learn this, and learning stability, is that there's a concept called diagnostic over shadowing, and it's really important to be aware of this, because if someone has a history of psychosis and they come in and they're complaining of abnormal pain, Obviously, in an emergency situation, it's really important that you need to rule out what kind of causes for that abnormal pain or for the symptoms that they're experiencing. But sometimes what we see happen is that this diagnostic or shadowing kicks in and a patient comes in and they complain of a certain symptom and if they have a mental illness or alerting disability, it's assumed that that is the reason that they're presenting the way that they are. So it's really important to actually remember that and to treat any patient you see.

regardless of whether they have mental illness or not. That can be really difficult and really frustrating for staff and it can be a strain on service. So if you've got a patient with anxiety who keeps coming in thinking that they've had a heart attack, but actually they've had a panic attack. Well, obviously you need to rule out something about panic. It's a fine line to track because you need to do it in a way that doesn't add to their health anxiety and reward that behaviour. But equally, you need to rule something out and not just assume, oh well, this patient's anxious, they have panic attacks, the chest pain must be a panic attack. Because you know what, one of these days you're going to miss something. So it's really important to think about mental health and physical health. I think that's something I talk to my students about a lot, the psych-out effect, the fact that people are labelled...

see this patient make sure say you know rubber stamp them as medically fit and then we can get them into seeing psychiatry or something you know and the nurses can actually say that to you come in jamie you know see this patient they have depression i think it's a panic attack and then send them on their way and you've already gone in you're prejudiced you're loaded and even if you don't think i'm not pretty nice human being but you can't help it and a great example of a patient who their opening line was i'm having a panic attack i'm wasting your time i have anxiety this is a panic attack And they were very short of breath, they were also needing a lot of oxygen, and you don't need that with a panic attack. And in the end, they have to actually say, can we please stop calling this a panic attack? Can we please start saying shortness of breath? To take myself out of that, and that patient had several PEs that could have been very easily missed. I'm not saying that's a pat on my back, but as a very useful learning exercise. No, definitely. I remember seeing a patient as a registrar who had come into A&E brought in by concerned relatives with a short period of an agent.

and was very quickly referred to psychiatry with no investigations because this patient had a history and had been seen many times before and never presented like this but it was assumed it must be because of the personality disorder to get a psychiatrist to see him and you know what they were right it was to do with her personality disorder she was going through something stressful in her life and had decompensated him and that is how she presented but If my mum had come in with a three-day history around Asia, I'm pretty sure she'd have got a scan. And the problem is, 95% of the time you'll be right, but it's that 5% you've got to be aware of.

And it isn't a black and white thing. It isn't that some people have mental health problems, some people have physical health problems. They're always overlapping. And even patients who you see with what seems like a completely physical health condition, there's going to be emotional and psychological symptoms and effects there. So I think it is really useful to try and think about everything. Just think about and treat patients realistically. Absolutely. So we sort of touched a little bit on personality disorder there as well.

So I think it leads on to our obvious next question, a very broad term, what is a personality disorder? I think these are patients we do see as well in the most part, and very often having performed deliberate self-harm, borderline personality disorder is a label, something like that. But what do we talk about when we talk about personality disorder? We don't call it deliberate self-harm. Okay, a portion of blame. So self-harm. Yeah, personality disorder is a really broad concept, as you said, and it's a really tricky concept to get your head around.

So it implies there's something wrong with your personality. Yeah, it does. And it can be quite a pejorative term. In just that, you know, everyone has a personality, and if you're saying that I'm a personality disorder, that means there's something inherently wrong with me as a human being. So it's quite a pejorative. But also, in the healthcare service or healthcare environment, it has quite a negative connotation attached to it, because often people with personality disorder are quite high-volume service users of both mental health and physical health services, and it can be quite difficult for staff to see people coming in

over and over again. Perhaps they think about their recent services or why they're presenting like this. But I think the thing I always try and say is that if someone is having such a terrible time of things that they're having to present in that way, they've self-harmed or they're having to present threatening self-harm or those kinds of things, that's really, you know, put yourself in their shoes, that is really not a nice state of affairs for that person to be in. And no matter, you know, what behaviour, it's just got to take a step back. The other thing I say is that, you know, People with personality disorder, and I'll explain my understanding of it in a second, but they can be very difficult to spend time with. Because they bring out, as we were talking about earlier, they bring out quite difficult emotions. Frustration, you know, you can get quite annoyed with people. And sometimes we react to that. We will treat people differently because we're annoyed by them. And the thing I always try and remind myself is that if it's that distressing and that frustrating to spend 10 minutes with someone, imagine what it's like to be in their head 24-7. Yeah. So...

And even as a psychiatrist, I have to keep resetting my compassion in us. So it's important to remember that, that this person's life is not good. Especially if they're not being nice to you at the time as well, if they're swearing at you. Exactly. We're human. Yeah. And I think there's this concept, which I know we talk about in psychiatry, and I think it's there, maybe not using this terminology in other fields of medicine, but we talk about unconditional positive regard.

It's really difficult, but it's treating all our patients in a positive way. Even if they are swearing at us, even if they are trying to assault us, they're a patient. It's not our job to punish them, it's not our job to judge them, it's our job to treat them. So it's a difficult thing to achieve, but unconditional positive, regardless of what we should be aiming for. New Year's resolution. Yes, every year. But yeah, in terms of what a personality disorder is, the way I explain it to patients is, well first of all, let's start by explaining what a personality is. We've all got personality and we can describe what people's personalities are. We've all got friends who are highly strong, we've got friends who are chilled out, we've got friends who are X, Y, Z, and we all know what someone's personality is like. Absolutely. But when you try and describe what a personality is, it can be quite difficult. It's quite a nebulous thing.

The way I think about it is, it's like a membrane between you and the world, and everything you do, everything you say, every way that you interact with the world goes through this membrane, so your personality. It's pretty much set from late teens, early 20s, and that's the kind of person you are. And therefore, that governs the way that you interact with the world, with other people. Your reactions, your actions. And that personality does change in stress. So there are only people who are quiet, chill down, but then if they're put in distress, they might snap or they might down here. And that's if you have a, inverted commas, normal personality. Normal personality. Although I've never met anyone with a normal personality, but we've all got our quirks. So that's what personality is, and we all have one.

And that develops around our childhood and, as I say, sort of settles down in our late teens, early 20s. Now, if you've had things that happen to you, especially in your former years of your childhood, it may well disrupt how your personality develops. Yeah. The way that I describe personality disorder is I think about a normal distribution. We've all seen a normal distribution. Most patients are aware of that. So I actually end up drawing a normal distribution for them. And I talk about that there are hundreds of different characteristics that make up our personality. And they're all on that normal distribution. And for most things, most people are pretty average. We might have a few extreme things. We might be talkative or we might be very lazy or those kind of things. We might have a few extreme things. But because we're pretty much average for most things, they sort of buffer the...

The extremists? Yeah. So we get on following most of the time. Under really extreme circumstances, our personality mainly causes differences. But for a normal personality, we're pretty much average. Now, someone with a personality disorder, in the way that I think about it, they have a cluster of really extreme personality traits.

and what's worse is, under stress, those personality traits become more pronounced. So, the most common personality disorder that you'll see in the emergency department is emotionally unstable personality disorder. It used to be called borderline personality disorder because there was those old labels that stick with you. Yeah, and it's a really bad label. It was because people thought it was the borderline between psychosis and neurosis, but it's not, but it stuck. The problem is people come away thinking, oh, it's only a borderline personality disorder, it's not that bad.

but it ruins people's lives, so it really is quite bad. So when they feel something, they really feel it. Yeah, so if we look at the cluster of symptoms of people having people like personality disorder, they will, well, sorry, emotionally stable. And that is what it says on the tip. They are more emotionally unstable than I'm dying. So the person with EPD will react more intensely to things that have a very changeable mood perhaps, and often people will say, oh, I think I've got bipolar.

uh which is a mood disorder where you have significant periods and depression significant periods of mania but someone with the upd their mood will change like that they will have several fluctuations in the mood throughout the day yeah um and then they're very they're very difficult to live with they're very difficult to be you know if you have an emotional state because it's really difficult to be that person i'll talk about some of the other disorders that we see but you do sometimes see those kind of thoughts mainly people with emotional stable personalities sort of think about killing themselves or hurting themselves um and there's a very um Often there's lots of dichotomous and contradictory things in someone with emotion-stable PD. So, for example, they may be very clingy with those around them, but also push people away, which seems contradictory. Often that stems from a fear of abandonment. So they think that those around them are going to either betray them or leave them or, you know, they find it very difficult to trust other people. And that stems often from experiences in their childhood, often abusive situations where they haven't been able to trust people. And so they find it very hard to trust.

Therefore, they experience rocky relationships, and that's not just romantic relationships, it's relationships at work, with family, those kind of things. They find it very hard to keep friends. They can be quite impulsive, and act without thinking, and that often can lead to things like self-harming, especially if they've got this chronic sort of hatred of themselves, and chronic thoughts about hurting themselves, and then they act in an impulsive way and hurt themselves. So that's something that you often see. And this chronic suicidality is something that's very, very common. It's been there for, you know, since their late teens, early 20s, they've had this thought on that suicide there. And it's very distressing for them. And it's very distressing for people around them because they're expressing this. And it obviously causes a lot of anxiety for people around them. And it's not enough to say, well, they've never done it before, so they're not going to do it. You know, you need to, each time there's a distressing episode and someone presents to health centres, we do need to think about... Not the boy who cried wolfly scenario. Exactly. Exactly.

And there are some, you know, sometimes like, you know, apply for help. Some patients will use that themselves, but it's not really a helpful way to talk about these kind of acts with a patient. The other thing is often you sort of harm themselves. It's important to find out what they wanted to do, what they thought they'd get out of it. And I always ask that in a really sort of, I don't know, you know, you tell me sort of way. And often the response will be, you know, what the hell do you think I'm meant to do? Yeah.

because they wanted to end their life, but you can't assume that. Often, people will self-harm for relief. They experience a sensation of release and relief from harming themselves. Sometimes it's about converting emotional pain into physical pain. Sometimes it's about punishing themselves. Sometimes it's about they have very close self-worth and therefore think that's what they deserve. So you really need to explore why it's in terms of. Because self-harm is so central to

many people's lives with emotional state of post-natal disorder. It can become that that's the main thing that we think about. But there are some other things that you need to ask about. About what their emotions are like. Do they have explosive emotions? And they'll recognise that if that frame's true for them. Another thing is, and people who don't experience this will find this difficult to identify with, but for people with emotional state of post-natal disorder, this phrase sort of hits the nail on the head is, do you feel amputable?

And often they'll feel emotionally empty. They are numb inside. It's very difficult to explain that to someone who hasn't experienced it. But when someone has experienced it, they're like, it's like a memory. It really doesn't look true. If you've got EPD, you can find it very hard to control your emotions or control your endorses. So you might get very angry easily.

And that then can lead to that impulsive behaviour that we spoke about earlier. And you do also see people, and these are often worse when people stressed out, is paranoia, and sometimes pseudo-psychotic experiences, so voices, negative voices, usually negative voices, inside the head, making disparaging comments about your appearance or your self-worth and those kind of things. And often the content of those voices rings true to that person's own deep down view of themselves. So it's useful to know what the content is because that gives you a little bit into what they really think about themselves. But I think the important thing to remember, as I said, is, you know, it's really distressing to have this kind of condition. It's a lifelong condition and it is usually brought out of really distressing things in early life. So I think really it's important to be compassionate for people with these difficulties, even though that can be difficult, you know, when you're stretched and you've got other priorities and those kind of things. I think the other thing to remember is that although emotionally stable personality disorder is the...

personality disorder you'll see in the department there are other personality disorders that you will never see so you have sort of a schizoid personality disorder which is someone who spends all of their time alone won't leave the house and has a very restricted range of interest and actually that person is never going to come to AD because they you know that they are kind of a hermit type person so it's impairing their functioning and it's causing distress but it's not the kind of distress that is dramatic attention of services. We might see them in psychiatry but you very rarely see them as a presenting complaint in A&E. The one that you might well see, the other personality disorder that you might see in A&E quite commonly is dis-social personality disorder or anti-social personality disorder. Essentially these are usually men, whereas people with emotionally stable personality disorder are usually women, although men do experience it. Dis-social personality disorder is usually male and it's characterized by someone who

They break social boundaries, they break taboos, they commit crime. And it's a very, especially a very angry, abusive type person that you see in A&E quite frequently. People that have this diagnostic label of dyssocial personality disorder make up 50% of the prison population. I was going to say, they are very often in the company of a police officer, a prison officer, if they have a dyssocial personality disorder. And I think the thing to remember about dyssocial personality disorder, but also emotionally stable personality disorder, is that Although the disordered personality, the difficulties that someone has in their personality can be an explanation for their behaviour, it's not an excuse. And what we are very clear about, one of the messages that we give to people with personality disorder is that it's important that they take responsibility for their own actions and for their own safety.

And so someone with a social personality disorder who comes in and assaults a nurse or assaults a receptionist, they can't say, I did it because of my personality disorder. They still have control. They're more likely to do things that are harming other people or breaking the rules. But they can still choose whether to do it or not. So it's not an excuse. Likewise,

it's important for someone with an emotionally unstable personality disorder it's important to empower them and say that they need to take responsibility for their safety especially because they often want to absolve themselves of responsibility they want to say someone else look after me someone else solve this it's not my fault it's and it's not about fault or blame but you know they will try and they'll try and make their problems someone else's responsibility because they're so difficult to deal with themselves and often if you're discharging someone from especially in the ED to someone who's come in having self-armed, you may well get threats such as, you know, I'm going to go and take an overdose and if I die it will be your fault. Yes, sadly I've heard that quite a few times. And the important thing to remember as a clinician is, no, it's not your fault. If you have done a thorough assessment, you've involved the right people, so if mental health services have been involved, if that's, if layers of services, if that's necessary. I think if you've documented your assessment, if it's very clear what the rationale behind discharge is, then that's absolutely fine. If, you know, you can never rid a situation of risk, but as long as you've done all the right things. I always like to think that I've got a little coroner on my shoulder, everything I do, I document as if a coroner is going to read it, if the worst happens. Yes. But, you know, you will get this, you know, if you discharge me, I will do this. And, you know, as I said, conditional threats are

always something to be aware of. An emotional blackmail. Exactly. It's unusual for those conditional threats to be followed through. Sometimes they are, but as long as you've done everything correctly, you don't need to worry too much about that. And I think that there's a four-word description of personality disorder in general, emotionally stable personality disorder in particular, that Nelson Colley has told me, and it is...

I think it really sums up the kind of conflict because that's what it's all about really it's about all these conflicting emotions in someone's head and this forward phrase really sums up the experience of emotional personality sort of in quite a kind of boxy way is it's help me your bastards yeah so it's somebody who desperately wants to be helped and desperately wants a hug and wants to be cared for and wants you know wants that that care around them may not receive it but will also act in a way that sabotages that help people make you know they will push people away yeah so it's that it's a it's a it's a syllable phrase but actually it does sum up the um the way that the people with personality disorder especially interact with the world it's a very difficult conflict that they struggle well thank you very much i think that's a very broad sort of introduction to a few bits and bobs um anywhere that you'd recommend for further reading because i think we've glossed over quite a lot so where's where's some good places to look so the um the mind website is excellent um there are some really good um

leaflets you can download there. So that's mind.org.uk. MIND. MIND. And I particularly recommend they have a booklet called Understanding Borderline Personality Disorder. Although it's got the old-fashioned title, the content is fantastic. And it's a really helpful thing for clinicians to read to get an idea of what the UPD is all about. But it's actually really helpful for patients as well. You know, to give them, to read through and to actually understand that there's other people experiencing those kind of things. Yeah. But what I find is that actually because

There is this pejorative connotation to personality disorder because in the past it was treated only as a diagnosis of exclusion. Often the way that it was disclosed to patients was very poor. Or sometimes it wasn't being disclosed at all. You'll have patients who have it in their notes historically and they're not being told what the problem is. And actually being told your diagnosis, there are advantages and disadvantages to it. But if it's done really well, it's actually an empowering thing to understand what your difficulties are. So I think actually disclosure of diagnosis...

is really important. That's not something I'd expect someone who isn't a psychiatrist to be doing. But actually, it can be an opportunity in the university environment to get me as a psychiatry down. And if that is a good experience, actually, that sets the patient up to have a better experience of health services, mental health services, rather than having a label stamp on them. So I find that giving that leaflet is really helpful. The Royal College of Psychiatrists have some really good leaflets as well that are helpful to both clinicians and patients. And that's rcpsych.ac.uk. Thank you very much, James. Thank you for listening. Bye-bye. That was the Take Orally General Introduction to Psychiatry podcast.

remember you can find the blog entry and the take visually for this podcast at www.takeorally.com you can also find takeorally on both facebook and twitter for more information about research education opportunities within emergency medicine acute medicine and major trauma remember you can find nuage dream on both facebook and twitter

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Take Aurally?

This episode is 54 minutes long.

When was this Take Aurally episode published?

This episode was published on February 16, 2018.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Take Aurally episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.