It's here. The Ford is a big deal. Not yet. The Ford is a big deal.
Oh, guys, just wait. The Ford is a big deal event is on. Really? Now.
Until June 1st, Lisa, 2026, Maverick XLT hybrid all-wheel drive for $197 by weekly at 5.29% APR for 60 months with $29.95 down. That's like $99 a week. The Ford is a big deal of fans. Visit your Ontario 4 store or 4.ca.
I think there tend to be two ways to know the novelist George Saunders. One is through his amazing novels and short story collections. Link in the bar now is I think one of my favorite books of all time. The other is in his public facing role as one of America's leading profits, cross the ties of kindness.
And this role is built on the virality of his beautiful commencement speech he gave some years ago about kindness. What I regret most of my life are failures of kindness. Those moments when a young man was right there in front of me suffering, and I responded, says to me, reserved with me, my way. I've talked to Saunders about that speech.
He was on the show in 2021 in an episode that many people tell me is their favorite. I mean, I think one of the things that the left has to do is recognize that we really are at a very basic level, you know, defending virtues like kindness and decency and equality. That's to me, that's the thing we have to concentrate on. That actually we're the true defenders of the constitutional ideas that say we really are hopeful that we'll have a beautiful country where everybody is equal.
That's actually what we're working for. And don't get too distracted by the small storms. And I've always thought of Saunders a little bit in that mode, the kindness guy. But reading his new novel, Vigil, which is about an oil tycoon on his death bed, being visited by angels and people from his past trying to get him to reassess his own life.
I kind of realize that Saunders is more interested in something else now, not kindness, but the question of judgment. Not just how do we treat others, but how do we understand our own lives? In this book, you can feel Saunders searching for bigger, darker game. There's a book about sin and judgment.
It's about free will and whether or not we have it. And in it, there's a very fundamental tension between the side of Saunders that does not want to judge, it wants to explain who we are in terms of the conditions we came from, which is a stance of very deep compassion and the side of him that thinks judgment is necessary, that sin needs to be recognized and that you cannot have truth. If you are not willing to open up to ideas of fundamental wrongdoing. And so I want to renegotiate some of these questions with Saunders.
I wanted to see for him right now in this moment what lies beyond kindness. As always, my email as a clown show at mytimes.com. George Saunders, welcome back to the show. It's so nice to be here.
Thanks for having me. So there's a moment in your new book, Visual, where one of the main characters is on his deathbed and he offers this prayer. He says, thank you, Lord. Thank you for making me who I was and not some little squirming, powerless and in the kampoop.
Thank you for making me unique, one of a kind, incomparable, victorious. Tell me about that prayer. Well, he's a guy who has been driven by ambition his whole life and it's served him pretty well. You know, he's a big, really powerful, oil executive and he had some, as I imagine, had some early kind of insecurity instillers and then his whole life, he was working against that to try to sort of assert himself and give himself enough power that he never feel that again.
And he did it. And I think he's just kind of turning to God and saying, I'm correct. And I like I did it right. That's why you gave me all this power.
Yes. He hears God saying you did great. You know, so it's from my perspective, a moment of extreme delusion, you know, where he's getting exactly the wrong message from the moment he's in. But, um, you know, from my own experience of being a person, you develop a certain approach to life to kind of keep anxiety at bay, uh, to sort of solidify your view of yourself, to make it easier to get through life.
And then it's really hard to peel that away. He had an opportunity to maybe have a different perspective on his life and he just passes. Do you think there's a question inside of that? A question that maybe feels very culturally relevant to me right now, which is whether the greatness at the world rewards, the power that the world offers is something to be lauded or is actually something to be feared and ashamed of.
Well, I think it's something to look at scans that even if I mean, I think everybody to a greater lesser extent is involved in that of trying to get over in some way, you know, you know, trying to push back on the natural fear that we have of being out of control and being like, but I think what should be becoming clear to us is that if you say power is everything, if I get that power on safe, that's completely BS. And there's not a world where one person could have so much power is to be above suffering. It just isn't. So I think our culture is in a particular moment where we have sort of forgotten that for various reasons.
So it's easy politically and maybe personally to think if I just get enough of this thing, this power, then I'm safe, but that's, you know, clearly delusional. And at this validation, I was thinking about reading that. You have a safer form of social acclaim. You're a novelist and a writer and a beloved and people quote your work on kindness.
And so there's a lot of social praise that has come into you. I have my own version of this. And it can be, I think pretty easy if you're having a moment of self doubt to fall back on these things, the world has told you about yourself. So I wondered when I read this, whether any part of you identified without prayer or the feelings within it.
Oh, I mean, when you write a book like this, everybody is you and you both believe them and you think they're full of it. That's the whole game of, you know, novels. So in that part, I remember thinking, okay, to order fewer on your deathbed and some evidence was presented that you wasted your life. What would your response be?
And of course you want to think it would be, oh, I am corrected. But in fact, what you double down, you say, yeah, but you know, I wrote books, you know, and so that's a big, big danger, I think, for anybody. And certainly for me, the praise comes in and you accept it very happily and it inflates you. The blame comes in and you don't accept it quite so easily and you deflect it.
I find it to be opposite. No, right. That's right. The praise goes off the back.
Well, that's true. It's off the back and then it's like you got one being commented. Yes. You're thinking about it for two weeks.
Yeah. But for sure. And one of the cool things about getting older actually is that you realize that everything in the universe is giving you the memo that you're temporary, you know, and that you're on the way out, your hairline, your body, your way, feel. But then in a moment where you get praised, that information contradicts that somehow.
And the ego goes, Oh, we are important. You know, we are permanent. I'm still growing in important, you know. So I was actually thinking about a different moment in your life as I was reading the book because obviously it's about Kijubun, an oil company CEO.
But you work early in your life as a geophysical prospector. What is a geophysical prospector? Well, I was trained at the Colorado School of Mines and Golden. And what we would do is we'd go into an area where there might be oil and then we plant a dynamite charge 10 or 15 feet on the ground, blow it off.
And then with a sort of sophisticated system of sensors, we would record the sound waves as they came back up. And then that could be used in these complex computer things to predict the sort of three-dimensional topography underground, which then in turn could be used to locate wells. No. How did he get into that?
Well, I trained for it. I mean, it was a geophysics. Yeah. I mean, I just want to try to find out.
They don't just send you out with that. No. And that was at that time in the 80s, that was kind of what they were teaching at the school in geophysics. So you have highly mathematical and technical.
And it was kind of one of the things that happened that was kind of life informing was I was kind of a trainee. And I was in a room and they're having a meeting in the next room with the kind of higher ups and it became clear, I could overhear it, that the grid that we were using to submit our drilling recommendations and the grid that the National Whale Company of Indonesia was using were different. So we would say drill here and they would take it onto their map and drill in a completely randomized location. And so as a conversation unfolded, everybody's getting kind of awkwardly quiet in there, you know, and then there was a kind of a group agreement that this was unfortunate, but it could be overlooked and we wouldn't, it wouldn't go any further up the line.
So for like 10 years, they've been drilling, they've been spending millions of dollars on this information and then randomizing it and drilling anyway. And then we just, they decided to see a quiet. So what was that? So what wasn't what is your relationship to oil, to energy, to this fundamental engine of human existence and use that product and destruction?
Yeah, I mean, I have a kind of a, at that time, it was very simple. I mean, it was just an adventure. And at that time, I think people weren't really talking climate change month. There's some sense that I saw firsthand of the that we were kind of running rough shot over the environment in that area and also kind of over the culture, we were just sort of imperialist, you know, but mostly for me, it was just thrilling, you know, to be going to these rainforests where no one had ever set foot and we drill these, or not drill, but we have the local guys cut a very narrow path and we go land and they were tigers and it was, you know, for a 22 year old, it was a thrill.
So, you know, I use that in the book just to get away into his mind, like somebody who feels positively about this endeavor. And I could see if I'd been a little more talented at it, I might have, you know, become an executive and those early feelings of tribal pride would probably have just grown and grown, you know. So KJ Boone, all companies, CEO's I mentioned, did you research him? Is he based on anyone for you?
How did you put yourself in the mind of a robber bearing of sorts? All right. What I do is I research a bunch for a month. I just read everything I can find and then I take notes and I just put it away.
The purpose of that is not to ever give someone biography or to have a real life basis, but just so that the invention is within the realm of applause. And for the voice and the attitude and fiction, I'm always trying to find a corollary to that person in my mind and then try to build that corollary out. So with him taking that early oil experience, also kind of superimposing my writing life, the pride I feel in that and the investment I have in that. And then just sort of growing that outline by line.
And so the game is to kind of make sure that with each one of those, you've done them the service of really listening and really trying to inhabit the world through your point of view. That's what are the years you're writing this book. What are the years? Yeah.
Well, you're running. Kind of the last three, the last three years, I think specifically, have been a fight over what we should think about the quote, unquote, great men of history. You know, what should you think about? And this goes back before the last few years, but the last decade, let's call, which is certainly, I think in your head, what should you think about the founding fathers of this country?
What should you think about somebody with a personality of Donald Trump? Really, I'm a man who has bent the river of history himself, Elon Musk, Mark Zuckerberg. We got just the Frick gallery. And I mean, what a beautiful gallery.
And then you read a little bit about Henry Frick and, you know, there's a lot of it's built on some blood, you know, that incredible museum. And there's both the critique of them. And then also in the period in which you're writing specifically the backlash to that critique, the backlash to the idea that we have swept away the need for these conquerors, these human beings who are engines of a certain kind of progress. And you may not like what that progress requires, but that is how we have America.
That is how we want to go to Mars. That is how we got to the moon, that it's not all nice. And, but there has been, I think, a cultural five years ago, 10 years ago, I felt like the critique was winning. Now I feel like a very joined battle.
And I'm curious how, how this was sitting in your mind during it. I must be a very disquestion. No, because for me, that kind of question puts my head in this pin, your question is very good. And it is in my heart, but for me to work it out is on the page.
So the thing is, I think a person can access more truth with, um, as he seeks greater specificity, specificity has to be in a locale. So when I think about the great men of history in general, I don't come up with much that any drunk uncle at a party couldn't come up with. But if I, if I locate in the person of this K. Then I can kind of work through it.
Well, let's talk about the way you work it out on the page, because I think we're not saying something different. I just see you working out what actually feels to me like a very live social argument on the page. I'd like to read much of the book is an argument between Boone and his critics in the form of angels and visitations at the time of his death. And I want to read this section on page 18.
There's a story often told. Perhaps you've heard this one. Don't stop me if you have, though. I'd really love to tell it.
Little boy's browsing doesn't like cars because of the pollution. You know where this one's going. The father pulls the car over to the side of the road, then I suppose you'll want to walk end of objections from El Kiddo, your choice shock dying in the back of a horse cart stuck in the mud or zinging toward help air comp blasting anyone with a lick of sense, which used the latter we had the world had. That was what was so damn stupid about it.
People forgot the empty larder forgot drought, forgot famine, forgot what it was like to be at the mercy of the world. Forgot what it was like to be at the mercy of the world. This is part of his self conception. He is one of these people who have removed to some degree humanity from the mercy of the world.
Tell me about the feelings that the argument, the life experience, your channeling there. Well, there was a time when I was in my twenties that my dad had a restaurant and it burned down. So things were rough and we were living in Texas. And I just got that first sense that in our country, if things got tough below a certain level, nobody was coming, you know, except your friends and family.
And that landed on me. I mean, I was kind of a upbeat, optimistic at that time in Rand kind of guy, but still it landed. And then many years later, when we had our family, you know, we didn't have any money safe, we were just kind of going paycheck to paycheck. That feeling kind of came back almost like a flashback.
Oh, God, you know, for all of the kind of surface glitter of the culture, if you drop a certain level, you're an embarrassment and no, the cavalry isn't coming. So I think, and now that a third thing, there was a, when I first got out of college, there was a friend of mine from high school and I went to visit him and he was living in his mom's basement and he had a good job and very like attractive, intelligent guy. And the question kind of hovered up like, why are you still with your moms? You know, and he said that he'd had certain experiences when he was young and they were very poor, that were quite humiliating for him.
And he didn't turn like him and he said, I'm not moving out of the space man until a million. And it really struck me because he was not somebody who was at all off center or deficient in any way as a high achieving guy, but that early pain had stolen. You know, so I think that's what this guy's tapping into. Maybe in a more general sense, I think that's what I mean.
That's what capitalism is about, really. I mean, it's beautiful if you're above the line, an infri-ballotal line, capitalism, with a line that carries you on capitalism, plunders, essentiality of the body. So that's, I thought, well, if I want to have a motivation for him that isn't easily dismissed, that's a pretty good one. And I could feel it.
I could really feel it. Let me actually try to argue that even more strongly than you did that. Last line, you just maybe think about it because I actually agree that capitalism can plunder the centrality of the body. I think if you're working in lithium mining, in unsafe conditions, to feed the world's desire for various electronics, the centrality of your body is being pretty plundered.
On the other hand, plunders the centrality of the body is half of all human beings dying before they're 15 years old and a quarter of them before they're one year old. It was interesting to me that in that answer, you sort of went towards a question of money in the social safety net, right? Which I even understand the way you wrote this, you're talking about something much more fundamental, which is to what degree do we live insulated from nature by technology versus to what degree are we at the mercy of nature? To what degree do we control the world?
Which is what we're always trying to do as human beings for better and for worse versus to what degree does the world control us? I mean, the lines are dying in the back of a horse cart stuck in the mud or zinging toward help, air con, air conditioning, blasting. Your book talks a lot about the death of natural disasters that are worse than by climate change. But I think the numbers are something like we have a fifth as many.
That's from natural disasters to the 1960s. That's partially because we are so much better at building and getting emergency response to places and telling people where to go. And so there's this really deep, Janice-faced nature to this modernity we've built. And I think we also look around it and think something's gone terribly wrong.
Yeah. Yeah. I mean, again, I for in the local sense, I think about when our kids were low and I was working, I know it was a great job of a typewriter, you know. But this is maybe a fact of my entire life.
For 10 hours a day, I was doing something that had no relation to anything that I cared about except providing for, you know, so within that workspace, I would do whatever. I was photocopying. I was, you know, mopping up spills. I mean, what I didn't really matter.
Writing, technical reports. And so when I think about that, thundering of the body, I think of that. Now, again, it's part of this huge system that you're alluding to. But I think for the individual, the journey through capitalism, especially, I think, in my life, it's become one of increasingly handing over everything to sustenance.
And as corporations become so powerful, the feeling that one should naturally give up more of one's private space, more of one's peace of mind in order to sort of live within the system. I feel that's something that's really happened in my lifetime. I want to have you read one more part from actually that same page that I think also gets it an interesting way to make this argument through his voice, right? Whereas nowadays, folks patted past climate controlled cases of odyssey and vegetables and fish from faraway seas and meat from animals who fed in metals under mountain ranges whose names a person could hardly pronounce, thinking, yap, yap, yap, big deal, pork from Denmark, salmon from the Bering Strait, loaves of woven bread from Ferrara.
All of this is my right. When what it was was a goddamn miracle. How would that bounty made its way here? Did it walk?
Just magically appear, go walls on someone else's feet on me. I was just struck by that phrase. All of this is my right. And I feel like the thing you do really effectively when you're inhabiting Oon's voice is get a idea.
It's not a right. It's not a miracle. We want it to be a miracle. What it is, is a supply chain.
Right. And nobody wants a supply chain. Right. Right.
I was thinking when our kids were a little bit of a little bit of a circuit and there's this incredible circle, a segments and you'd go in there and it was just, it was like Bosch painting of bounty, you know. And so, yeah, I mean, I'm big into contradictions. And so the idea that all of that, you know, it doesn't just magically appear. I agree with them.
You know, the part of me that I saw in there was the part that says, yeah, well, okay, let's let's get rid of oil. Let's see what happens. You know, and you know, and these, the real like corollars of these guys, they made a lot of hay out of that idea that if we eliminate oil, which I don't think anyone's really calling for that, but if you do that, you end up with a punishment of the poor primarily. That was one of the big lines in the 90s, you know, the who suffers the most poor.
If you disrupt the supply chains, disrupt things as they are, the rich people are going to know, okay, but the poor are going to suffer. That was that was a line anyway. One of the things I thought about reading that because I struggle with these questions, I wrote a book about abundance, which is all about technological prosperity, but also about in some ways it can go wrong. You have the abundance of the wrong thing, right?
The abundance of fossil fuel you will choke on the air. One of the things that makes my stomach turn, right, is you're usually not getting animals feeding in meadows under mountain ranges, you're getting animals in a hellish industrial factory that you cannot even imagine and we have to make it illegal to look into because people knew what we were doing to the animals we kill for food. They would stop eating that meat. But I thought the thing you were playing with, and you can tell me if this is right or wrong, it's not just complicity.
I think that's too small. It's desire. We talk about the great men of history, but at least under capitalism, you have the great wants of society. There needs to be a match between what is provided and what is desired.
But somebody thinks about some of those questions. You're so often dealing with the power of what we want, even if we don't really want to know how we get it. Yes. And let me, okay, so I think we have maybe different approaches based on our abilities and my ability to think larger and more abstract is not so good.
So for me, when I think about, I agree with what you say about wants. And so what I think is within the individual person as a person, by any character or just the individual person, when I say I want, there's a lot of errors in that already. You know, what's the eye? If you look deeply into it from any of the great traditions, the self is a temporary illusion that appears at maybe at birth or maybe a little after birth, some people think, you know, and so from the very beginning, if you define I, the way we can eventually do from the minute we open our eyes in the world, there's a problem.
Because my wanting means at some level, I'm taking from you or it could mean we're cooperating, but mostly it means I'm protecting that perimeter that makes I makes me. There's a great error in that from the very beginning. There are courses that are winning and we can't, we can't get around it. But when you start from that point of view, all the problems come from that.
Wait, but hold on. I want to know what the error was. The error is that in fact, you know, when you go looking for what that eye consists of, you, there's nothing there. It's an illusion that we create with, I think philosophers and Buddhists, who say thought you make you reify Ezra by thinking, I got to put a sweater on, you know, and I like this one and whatever.
I'm going to do my show that you think that so it's totally natural and you know, you can't get around it. But from the minute you have that construction, you were making a fundamental error because you're not, you're not central, not permanent, but also the construction of the eye is a neurological thing that is very fraught with illusion. It tells us that we're perceiving correctly, but we're constructing in every instant. So I mean, it sounds very woo, but the truth is that that's where a lot of the, the big problems come from because that central delusion gets multiplied.
So when we think about power, okay, what is, what would power look like if we had the correct understanding of our, our sort of being? Well, it would have a lot to do with cooperation first because the idea that you and I are separate is actually demonstrably false. If you look on a small, a cellular level, it's just a bunch of molecules. So I think the big struggle of the human race is, can we figure out a way to make an accommodation with the essential truth that actually the solution of self is true?
What, what would that community look like? And so that, so when I'm thinking about characters, I'm thinking about that, really, you know, this person has certain desires. How does those desires square with sort of metaphysical reality? And then how does that character's actions get him into trouble because he is acting on that delusion of a central self?
Does that make sense? How do you think about that? And I'm not, not let it get treated to the Buddhism here. Yeah.
And I don't really know that much about it. I love talking about the Buddhist about, I'm going to take it in another direction in a second. But as you were saying, as you were saying, when the empty self that is Ezra puts on the sweater, he looks good in it. By the way, it's okay.
It's not, I need some sweaters. Uh, I am cold. You're not cold. The other people in this room are cold that, you know, myself might be empty, but it is me, you know, that wants to not be cold.
I am having an experience that the other selves are not, and as interdependent and connected to everything as I may be, I do want things. I want them all the time. Right. So that's really what the book is about.
There's a relative truth. Of course, you know, we want what we want and it's beautiful to one what we want to a certain extent, but on the absolute sense, it isn't true. So to the extent that we go through life embracing that illusion whole heartedly, I think we cause suffering. And of course, there's a position where you can go, yeah, I want to wear my sweater.
And also I recognize that this self is something that my mind is creating. And I think that's where we get into spiritual ideas and. Well, let's do that. Okay.
Because one thing that's talking about this book, you were talking about the great traditions a moment ago and in past conversations, we've talked a lot about you and I meditation and Buddhism. There was a deep Catholicism in this book and you grew up Catholic, but you said that the central problem of the book is what to do with the center in the bed. You say in the book that boons, quote, sins were grievous. And so I want to start with the word sin.
How do you understand sin and what is your relationship to the sin? What we're just talking about. This is not the Catholic understanding, but my understanding is sin just means you're out of step with truth, whatever it might be. And the world has a way of either internally or from outside of punishing sin in that way.
You know, so again, if I think I'm a really tough guy and I'm still me and I go out and challenge somebody and I get my ass kicked, I've committed the sin, the sin of misunderstanding who I am and then there's a punishment. So for me in the book, the sin is just being out of touch with the way things actually are. That's it. You know, and so, so the, again, in Buddhism karma, but what that really means is cause and effect.
So basically the view is cause and effect is absolutely undeniable. When you do something, there's a reaction. Now, this sort of comic tragedy part of it is that we don't, we aren't very good at predicting causes from effect. We think this action will cause this reaction, but we're often so wrong.
So cause and effect is God basically God acts by cause and effect. And in every moment, if we're out of alignment with cause and effect, we suffer. Some, you know, we may not be overt, but we suffer. That's what my idea of sin is now.
I'm thinking about your idea of truth. It sounds like what you were saying. So I want to be, I'm just processing what you just said. Cause and effect is God cause and effect in this vision of the world is also a form of truth, right?
There's a truth to cause and effect and if you're out of alignment with it. Yeah, truth would be just what is. So whatever you do, whatever your action is, the universe reacts to it as it, however, it likes it. And to the extent that we can posit what that is, we're in alignment with truth.
And if we're not, then we're out of alignment with truth. It's interesting because it did feel to me that there was a tension in the book between a much more traditional idea of sin and choices made and repentance needed. In fact, particularly repentance needed through good works. And then by would call a more Buddhist concept of everything is cause and effect.
Everything is karmic and conditioned and must be looked at non judgmentally, compassionately that the other big idea alongside sin that keeps coming up in the book use the phrase, an inevitable occurrence seven times. And there's this one in which the angel Jill describes looking at the soul and the life of the man who murdered her. And she says, he came to seem, if I may say this way, inevitable, an inevitable occurrence upon which, therefore it would be impossible, even ludicrous to pass judgment. Who else could he have been, but who he was?
And I feel like there's this tension between there is sin and we should pass judgment on it and people should be judged and they must repent. And who could we be, but who we are? How can you ask somebody to be anybody but the person they become? Yes, that's exactly the tension of the book.
Thank you. So, yeah, so Jill had an experience at her own death and the experience was that she spontaneously inhabited the mind of the person responsible for her death. So this was kind of like, she's had on the costume of her Jill's self for her life. And of course, like we do, she took that for the universe.
Things are her qualia was the universe. Then in that's what second she took that costume off, put on the costume of this kind of repellent person who was quite, it would have been really, would have been quite disgusting to her. And from that point of view, she's like, Oh, okay, I understand him. I am him.
And so this leads to this idea that from his point of view, and given the time only goes in one direction, how could he be indifferent than he is? It's kind of an absurd thing to say. He's done, you know, so if he could have been more understanding, why wasn't he? So again, time going in one direction, he's finished.
He was what he was. And that kind of complexity is what she feels that in a certain way, you're, you're, we understand that height, for example, is not negotiable. You didn't choose to be the height you are. I think we also understand intelligence.
You've got the intelligence you want. But then we get into some murky areas when people say, well, you could work harder. You could work at it and freedom of choice, you know, which is true. But even there, there's a limit to it.
And I would say, if you think of it in sort of calculus terms, if I want to improve my physical shape, for example, which would be a good idea. Oh, thanks. Yeah. Don't say this.
That's hilarious. It's hilarious. But, but if you, if you want us to do that, okay. So you know, you have to go to the gym.
You're going to find out that you're, you have certain built in limitations, your body and your muscles, like all that kind of thing, but also your willpower, your interest. So my thought is that even those things are kind of pre given to you at birth. Now, I think people sometimes struggle with this and I struggle with it. But the idea is this, if you, if you could imagine somebody that you cared about and maybe you had a fraught relationship with that person, they just died and they're lying there in front of you.
And you say, ah, I wish he'd been more X. I wish he'd been more understanding. If he should have been more articulate, why wasn't he? And I think if we dig deep enough into it in this absolute sense, you'll find that there is a kind of inevitability to that.
Now, that's Jill's point of view. What she's doing is saying it's fine. Whatever you did is fine. Just leave the self and all is forgiven.
It's kind of my point of view. But as I wrote the book, I got more and more skeptical about it as I examined. This guy in the book called the Frenchman, his point of view is bullshit. Don't give me that.
You know, when that guy was alive, somebody could have kicked his butt enough to get him to be more of quantity X. So he's urging her to get after Boone and do whatever's necessary to get him in relation to truth. The Frenchman's saying he's still breathing. So you have a chance, if you approach it skillfully, to put him in alignment with truth.
And that's that's where the salvation would come from, even though he can't move, he's never going to move again. If his mind could be correctly aligned, you save them. You believe in free will depends where he put the point of view. Do you believe in free will?
At this moment, I mean, in terms of like, I don't know what I'm going to do when I leave here. That feels like free will. I think if you could run the whole clock of reality from the beginning, you'd see that the decision I made was of course pre encoded by everything that came before. So the book was me kind of looking at a question.
And I don't know. I mean, except move the point of view around. That's the book. Some people that I've talked to, they're reading the book and I think I'm endorsing Jill's position, which I'm 100% not.
I'm a fan of free will for a moment. You know, seven years ago, my oldest son is about to turn seven. I would have told you that I believe that the space of decision making, they can truly be called free will is not absent, but is incredibly more narrow. Then we like to think of this.
And now having had two kids and seen how much they were themselves from the first moment, I believe it is even more narrow than that. And it's not that we don't make choices. But as you were saying, when you were saying, if you want to change your shape, you go to the gym and you know, you're limited by things like willpower, willpower does not seem to me to be something that we choose to generate. And again, it's not that I make, I feel like I make a lot of decisions in a day that I could make better or worse, but the me who makes them is much more conditioned.
Yeah. And I think when you love somebody, like you love your kids, that it becomes kind of beautifully true. It's beautiful. Yes.
If you're the person that you love has this tendency, the judgment kind of goes away. It's just something to accommodate and even be fond of. You know, so I think that's that's kind of Jill's thing. And she came to it in a moment of kind of trauma and inspiration.
And you know how sometimes you have such a peak experience that you attempt to recreate it or you think, well, that felt so deep to me, it must be true. And that's why I understand her. She's got that. She's had that experience.
And now in her horror really to find that at 22, she's dead, you know, she's clinging to that idea and she's in a sense hiding behind it. So I think that's why I kind of loved about her was that she she's in a real fix, you know, but I see her as primarily kind of fearful, you know, fearful to come out of that position. Notice how some homes sell faster in your neighborhood? It's not luck.
It's local know how. Relax agents know their streets, schools and communities inside and out. And with three max, those local pros are everywhere, which means when you're ready to buy yourself, you'll get trusted neighborhood insight that puts you a step ahead. Reach out today.
Relax. The experts closed home. Each office independently owned and operated. Last summer, the coolest place in the house was in your freezer.
This year, it's time to level up. Reliance HomeComfort has over 160,000 five star reviews for delivering the type of outstanding customer experience Canadians have counted on for over 60 years. Right now, don't pay for 12 months on a featured air conditioner or heat pump. Calling the experts that know how to beat the heat.
Conditions apply. See website for details. It's here. The Ford is a big.
Not yet. The Ford is a big deal. Oh, guys, just wait. The Ford is a big deal of vent is on.
Really? Now until June 1st, Lisa, 2026 Maverick XLT hybrid all-wheel drive for $197 by weekly at 5.29% APR for 60 months with $29.95 down. That's like $99 a week. The Ford is a big deal of fans visit your Ontario Ford store or Ford.
Joe's fundamental purpose is comfort. She is there to comfort the mission she's been given to the salvation. She's been given this to comfort. What does comfort mean to you?
Truth. You know, if you and I are in a cabin and we can hear their wolves outside, you know, if I say, it's cool, they're probably popping, you know, dogs, that's not comfort. But if you look at each other and go, fuck these, there's wolves. That's that's comfort.
But she doesn't have the capability to communicate that to him. Very skeptical of this. I'm trying to think about this. The comfort is truth.
Yeah. I don't want to say I've never been comforted by the truth. Oh, but you know, I have more often been comforted. But you see comfort for it in your work every day.
You come into work and you try to get to the bottom of complicated things and you're seeking comfort. I don't find it comfortable. No, you're seeking in, you know, biological country, you're seeking homeostasis. You know, you know, you want, you want to, you want to calm yourself, comfort yourself by getting in closer relation to the truth so the world doesn't seem so in our, I think comfort.
I'm just thinking about this now. I'm just mentioning this topic. I was going to ask you in a moment about the idea of grace and your relationship to grace. But I think for me, I think about comforting my children.
I think about being comforted by my mother that comfort seems closer to grace to me and, and, and, but you'll find great. It's fine. I think of grace and I'm not Christian. I'm not Catholic and grace is one of these ideas that I find very beautiful without feeling like I have a deep understanding of it.
So I want to be honest about where I'm coming from here. But I just think grace is for as at its core that there is a love God or the universe has for you that has nothing to do with what you've done that does not judge you, that exists despite all the reasons you may not have earned it. And it will always be there for you. And that's the inverse or the shadow side of this elevation idea.
Do you believe in that? Why do you believe in the elevation? I'd like to hear your, your description of what will do elevations and how Jill refers to this luminous event that she had and her death where she understands people as, as inevitable occurrences. But that is another way, I think, I haven't really thought about saying grace, that everything is okay, that ultimately you're not to blame and you're not to praise, you're just an embodiment of God's will.
It's something like that. You know, I guess I took elevation. It always had a coldness to it that this year, an inevitable occurrence is right different than you are loved. I'm not sure because if you think of, none, this is getting a little deep, but I think if you say, I hope, yeah, yeah, here's the question.
Have you ever been comforted by a falsehood? Yes, which one? When I was young, I had a terrible fear of honor and night after night, I'd ask my parents to promise me before I went to sleep that I wouldn't throw up. And in that time, I was comforted by that.
And they work. I did not throw up in those years, so they were telling me the truth. Although right now, one of my, you know, I never even made this connection till the second, but one of my sons asked me to do like a little spell every night to keep away bad dreams. And it has not always worked.
It's just a little like a rhyme. But I think, but he's comforted. He asked me for every night anyway, because you're working on it together. In a sense, what you're saying is, I will be well, you know, and I think that that's the form of you extending grace to him, which isn't exactly truthful.
The spell isn't exactly truthful, but the substrate or the sort of foundation of the spell is true. I think to bring back to comfort, which again, I think is related for me to grace, but here's how I describe comfort, the fundamental exchange of comfort. When I think of my children, when it's been offered to me or when I'm for it is somebody sitting there, no matter what is happening with you and saying, I am here and I love you. Yeah.
That's it. Yeah. That is what comfort is another human being. And I think of Jill doing that in the book, right?
You were dying and I'm here. And on some level, I love you. Yeah. And it's not that it is.
I mean, the love has to be true. Or it's better if it's true, I think. But it's not so much about being in a space of truth or a space of falsehood, so much as a space of there's presence here. There is, but where she gets into trouble.
And again, I discovered this over half way through. If you are beating a shit out of another human being and I said, you, Ezra, I'm here and I love you, that's bullshit. That's false. So so you I think in her situation, she says, I'm here and I love you and I don't care what you did.
Okay. Now from his point of view, I'd say, he knows what he did and he cares. And as a book goes on, he's increasingly tormented by the stenial. So I think there certainly saying I love you.
I'm here is 100% beautiful in the right condition. But it also, her problem is I think she's got a bit of denial built into herself too. So, you know, for example, the end condition, let's say that he was a murdering rapist and she came down to his bed and said, I'm here, you know, that somehow doesn't seem sufficient, although by her definition, it is. So this is where the book really exploded into being interesting to me, because I don't really know the answer to these things.
And of course, that murder of the rapist and inevitable occurrence and so cannot be judged. Right. Right. And she would say in her peak elevation, she'd say, yeah, yeah.
But we feel, I mean, I think in the book readers have talked me about in the middle section, like, God, Jill, you're pissing me off. You know, that's a result of the fact that she isn't really giving comfort. She's doing what in Buddhism with idiot compassion, you know, where, like, somebody drives a spike to your head and you say, thanks for the Colerack, that, that's. So she's not really doing what she claims to be doing.
That's, I think that the kind of, her kind of sin or her tragedy is that she, I think she had a genuine insight. But when you go to apply it, it's going to take a little less autopilot than she's on. You know, this is a weird thing to say to a person sitting in front of you. You heard something a while back in a sub-stack conversation you're having.
You were talking about what we should be judged people who write books and what we should, their moral failings change the way we read the book. And I wish I had the quote in front of you because I love the quote, but he said something along the lines of the person who wrote the book doesn't exist. Whoever even that person was in the moment they were writing that book is gone when they look up from channeling that moment of inspiration. Yeah.
Who George Saunders is right now is different than who George Saunders was when he was writing page 112 of a vigil. Yes. And it's interesting because I'm hearing you talk about sin and talking about it as being out of alignment with truth and just what is. And the book is, I read it certainly had a much more traditional view of sin.
I mean, the question of what is truth and what is that's, I mean, who among us is capable of understanding what is actually unfolding in time. But the book is very concerned. I mean, there is Jill who has this elevation and this belief that everybody's exactly who they are. And then there is this idea of sin that is you chose, you did horrible things, you denied what you knew, you fooled other people and you justified it to yourself.
That's the hinge. Yeah. Yeah. But it feels like more than being out of alignment with truth.
I mean, I feel like there's a world as it is, could be all kinds of different ways. But you believe in morality here. Yeah, it was good and bad and evil and in any specific situation there is because in this particular book, this guy spent many, many years knowing the truth and denying it. Now, the mechanism by which he did that or the rationale is interesting, but he knew that, you know, that climate change was a thing and he consciously or unconsciously denied it.
That's where he was out of synch with truth. One of the books I had in mind while I was running this was Death of Ivan Eloh by Tolstoy. And in that book, it's a much more modest center and his sin is just that he he lived his life by the credo that I just want to do what everybody else is doing. I want to be normal.
So at the end of his life, he gets stomach cancer and was based on a real thing that Tolstoy's neighbor supposedly screened for four straight days at the end of his life until he heard the story of like, wow, what would make you do that? So in the book, the guy has this intense physical pain, of course, but Tolstoy has layered in this idea that Ivan is starting to realize that he wasted his life by this idea of being normal. And there's a beautiful moment where after many, many days of saying, why am I suffering so much when I lived the perfect life, he finally says kind of to God, all right, maybe I didn't, you know, maybe I didn't, I lived out of line with truth. And at that point, he begins this rapid transformation.
Salvation in that moment is align yourself with what is actually true, the truth is you lived your life in the wrong way. And at some point says, all right, I can't, I can't go back in time, but I can start now essentially, I can start being in line with you. I didn't live in the right way. And you can feel the pain start to go out soon.
So, so the idea that there's there's physical suffering and then there's the suffering of denial on top of it. You know, and we all know that, like if you were like her, but you can't let it hurt, it kind of hurts more, you know. So I think that's what in the book, the French were incorrectly posits that if they could just get boom to say, yeah, I lied, I really did. I'm sorry, that that would represent a better state of being for him than the one in which he actually dies and which he continues to deny it.
So that's the truth. So before there's repentance, there has to be acceptance. I think there has to be, yeah, you have to be in relation to what you actually did. So sin, I mean, it's a word I brought from my Catholic childhood.
But now I understand it is, I mean, it can be so infinitesimal, you're feeling X and you say you're feeling X prime. That's going to cause you a little pain. You know, that's the idea. And yeah, that's sin.
And that's the sin. Now the characters will use that word. The Frenchman, you know, he died in 18, nine years, something. So he's using it in a traditional sense, but I think it's compatible with this.
I feel like the Frenchman was too hard on himself in his character. He is somebody who helped invent the engine. Right. Right.
And now he's haunting the world, trying to make everybody aware of how much energy engine is done, but yeah, no, you're exactly right. Yeah. And so does Jill. But one of the fun things about writing a book for me and in this method, I use it.
It's very iteration. And, you know, so I think early in the book, I thought Jill was kind of right. You know, and then as I kept revising it, the Frenchmen seemed to be right. And then I started to see, oh, they're both kind of other minds.
They're dead. So the Frenchman, he's very much kind of erotic in that way. You know, there's these manic spirits who aren't quite focused on, they've got some truth in them, but they're expressing it kind of inefficiently. And poor K.
Jay Boone is, you know, these are two guardian angels and both kind of mess ups, you know. So I think that in the final analysis of the book, I'm like, oh, it's so sad. You know, he doesn't need some help. But neither of these people is willing to give it to the Frenchmen content so hot and so angry that anybody would resist them.
And Jill is so in such a cozy way that nobody could take crush him from her either. So Boone floats through and then since he's not safe, actually. Last summer, the coolest place in the house was in your freezer. This year, it's time to level up.
Reliance HomeComfort has over 160,000 five star reviews for delivering the type of outstanding customer experience Canadians have counted on for over 60 years. Right now, don't pay for 12 months on a featured air conditioner or heat pump. Call on the experts that know how to beat the heat. Oh, yes.
Conditions apply. See website for details. It's here. The Ford is a big.
Not yet. The Ford is a big deal. Oh, guys, just wait. The Ford is a big deal event is on.
Really? Now until June 1st, Lisa, 2026 Maverick XLT hybrid all-wheel drive for $197 by weekly at 5.2,000, 8PR for 60 months with $29.95 down. That's like $99 a week. The Ford is a big deal of fans.
Visit your Ontario Ford store or Ford. Hi, I'm Solana Pine. I'm the director of video at the New York Times. For years, my team has made videos that bring you closer to big news moments, videos by times journalists that have the expertise to help you understand what's going on.
Now we're bringing those videos to you in the watch tab in the New York Times app. It's a dedicated video feed where you know you can trust what you're seeing. All the videos there are free for anyone to watch. You don't have to be a subscriber.
Download the New York Times app to start watching. I was thinking about this, this tension in the book because I think it is one that we exist in a very intense way right now, the both in our own lives, people around us, but also politically, internationally between what is the path of truth, of kindness? Is it to be judgment or is it to be understanding? Is it to look at JD Vance and his cruelties and I'm not asking you to comment on JD Vance and think, well, I've read your book and I see how much trauma you went through as a child and I understand it on some level that all made you who you are today and the cruelty you were inflicting on others comes from insecurity and fear and a or is it to say, you're an adult man, an impute of enormous power who claims to be a Catholic, like shape up, be who you claim to be.
And that's the book. That's the book. Yeah. And I think the answer is yes.
You do have to do both. There's a beautiful Buddhist teacher named Francesca Fremantle and she has a talk. It's on the book of the dead and she has the most mind-blowing answer because what she says is, there's no difference. If you have compassion for the victims of this cruelty, that's important, of course, protect them.
But if you run on the other side of the table and you say, she says, when you think about the karmic consequences of the sins they're committing, the harm that they're doing, she says, I wouldn't wish that on my worst enemy. So if you want to help them, if you have any bandwidth for that, then what you do is stop them within your principles, within your nonviolence and you stop them, then you save the victims and you save the perpetrators. So I think in a high realm is an identical act. It's also true, as you said, that these people aren't doing these horribly cruel things out of nowhere.
But again, I think we want to avoid that in a compassionate way and somehow in our attempt to understand them, we enable them. That's that's also a danger. We're excuse them. Excuse them.
Yeah. You've aligned. Well, and forgive me because I don't have an infront of you. It's something like specificity.
It's a specificity and judgment or opposed to each other. But what is the idea? And again, I get this from writing workshop and then from writing. If you move towards specificity, the facile judgment goes away.
So in a workshop, for example, somebody will say, oh, I think your story is boring. You can't work with that. So then you ask, be more specific. Where is it boring and what do you mean by boring?
And as you go through that process, it becomes diagnostic. You know, it's actually there's a thought that's repeated three times in the paragraph on page six. Oh, okay. Could you choose one of those repetitions and a writer can hear that.
They can hear, eliminate one repetition. That's all good, whereas your boring is less appealing. I mean, the example I've thought before is if you had, you know, five Republicans and five Democrats on the town board and you asked them to discuss immigration, you're going to get a fight because they're all pre-programmed with their media inputs and it's going to just be just turn on MSNBC and Fox and let them and everybody can go and have lunch and the TV is going to fight. But if you said, okay, we've got $10,000 to fix potholes in our little town and we've got $20,000 to potholes.
What do we do? Suddenly the politics is gone. You know, you're like, well, we should probably fix the one in front of the ER. And then as you start talking about individual potholes, it's just science.
You know, so I think that's what I mean by specificity, sweet is out. Facial judgment. I mean, you don't want to squeeze out judgment, but you want to squeeze out that kind of quality of empty agitated abstract or pining that seems to be prevalent right now, which I don't think really produces much except angst. Yeah, it's one of the reasons I loved the central tension of the book, because I feel this tension every day right now that there is wisdom and grace and a path at times to a higher version of myself in trying to understand.
And I took the specificity point differently, the specificity of other people, how they became who they are, how they're doing things that I cannot imagine or supporting things, right? You forget the people doing it, who I think are much more culpability, just people who are just voting for it. Yes. And I'm angry at some of them and I love them.
I love some of them individually. And then also as my neighbors and my countrymen, but if you go too far down that path of just trying to explain how everything becomes an inevitable occurrence, I do think your ability to make judgments and to work for a different world can become compromised, you know, Buddhism, Catholicism, all of them, in addition to having practices of how to make a possible love by enemy. How do I understand that everything has interdependent arising? Also very tight moral codes about what is right and what is wrong.
But I think also things are compatible. If you, if you, I think the problem is when you start trying to understand your enemy, I come from a scientific background. So for me to say, can you understand a geological problem? Of course, there's no problem and there's no limit to the length you can go to understand the problem.
It doesn't incriminate you. It doesn't involve you. So likewise, if the goal was to try to understand your enemies, I think the point of that is it's kind of strategic. I mean, if you're a football coach and you're playing, if you could inhabit the mind of the other coach for five minutes, that would be unbelievably great.
I deeply agree with that. Yeah. So the problem, but the problem is I think in that process of trying to understand there's something I certainly have it where as I try to understand, I think I'm trying to quote unquote empathize. That's where I think it gets a little, for me personally, it gets a little mushy because then you start to feel a kind of over investment that then interferes with the judgment that you have to have.
Like this guy in the book, he kind of is a pretty good father, I think, pretty good. Maybe we don't really know, but he would say he is. Well, yeah, she does. And she disappointed in him.
And he seems to love her. If I had said, well, he's evil, I don't want him. He's gonna be a terrible father. I think that's a less convincing portrait of him.
So for me, the empathy thing, both in a book, but when we're imagining our political enemies, it has to be scientific. It has to be objective. And then you can get to where you need to be emotionally. But I think that the feeling maybe on the left, especially is I'm going to understand the Trump supporters.
And then I won't have this anxiety about disliking them, but you can understand somebody deeply and dislike them or let's say oppose them. And I think at the highest level, you can oppose somebody in this way we're talking about, which is lacking fast judgment, but very firm. I think one of the strangest political delusions that I see, this does not seem to go away, is the idea that people who do bad things will present as bad people. Right.
It's the Corella de Vil falsity. You know, one of the things that affected me a lot over the last year was I read this book by Flipsands called the East West Street. And he was on the show and it's a book about the development of the concept of genocide and war crimes and it's a book about the Holocaust. And he's writing a great length about among other people.
The man Hitler puts in charge of governing Poland. And this person has an incredible artistic sensitivity. He truly loves art and music. And he's a beautiful player of the piano.
And you know, you read so much, I mean, you've made arguments like this, but I wasn't thinking about it here about the way art is supposed to, you know, enlarge your soul and then, you know, the Nazis really care about aesthetics. Yeah. Well, but I think I don't think I've ever made the argument that art enlarges everyone's soul and will therefore solve everything. I think more like if you say, you know, somebody went into a gym and said, this doesn't work.
There's still chubby people in here. You know, it's just from my own experience. I'm not a case of give that. Like what I'm saying more is it.
And I've seen so many people go and meet with Donald Trump and come and be like, Oh, he's really charming. I'm like, of course he's charming about his own. Like what were you expecting? Right.
But this is where the science comes in because if you go in and you see charming person, well, you just add it to your data set. Okay. Note it. He's doing these incoherent things.
He seems to be kind of largely incoherent in his, in his views and in his plans. He seems to have a terrific mean streak. And when I talk to him, he's so nice. Okay.
So now we have a new portrait of the man, you know, and I think that would totally enable one to oppose him better, better than if you had a character of him that didn't comply with truth. I don't, to me as a scientist, I'm going, yeah, of course you want all the information you could have. And if it's hard to process or it's complicated, that's okay. That's just part of the game.
Maybe the, um, there's so much emotion right now, so much agitation and fear. And that, I think that somehow for some reason, that makes people crave autopilot, you know, a set of beliefs that's very simple and is sturdy in every circumstance. And that's not really what human beings are good at. I mean, we like it.
We like it. And, but out of that comes violence and extremity. And I would say that's what the right is doing right now. They're, they're, they're somehow, I think they know they're looting the house and they know the time is limited.
And so they're agitated and they're on autopilot. And anybody who opposes them is a leftist lunatic. You know, you have the evidence of your senses says this and Minneapolis is a murder. They fictionalized the fact that he would go brandishing a gun.
That's panic, you know, that's panic, but it's also autopilot. Because a person not on autopilot would watch the video, you know, and would adjust their viewpoint according to what intelligent people do. Or it's funny. I wonder if it's autopilot or.
But one of the things it is, it is autopilot. It is a, it is an attempt to impose the domination that power can have or other people on reality itself. Yeah. When I see that, when I see, when I am lied to in that way, I understand it as an active domination.
A hundred percent. They do not expect me to believe it. Right. Well, you know what it's like?
It's like, if you went into a really nice restaurant and somebody, the way it brought you three turds on a tray and put it down, enjoy. There's a kind of a disbelief that he just did that. If you don't stand up and say, get these turds out of here, you know, bring me like my lasagna, then he's one. And if he keeps bringing the turds and you don't call them on it, then you, you erode your belief in truth erodes and you start to shrink and pretty soon.