Hello and welcome. You're listening to Fourth Estate, the show where journalists talk journalism. Coming to you from 2CR and Sydney on Gagielands, the Aura Nation, right across Australia on the community radio network, and directly to your device across the globe via podcast. My name is Peter Frey, the co-director of the Centre for Media Transition at the University of Technology, Sydney, and my producer today is Anthony Dockrell.
Coming up on this edition of the Fourth Estate, we are taking an in-depth look at one of the success stories of journalism, the international consortium of investigative journalists. To do that, I am blessed to have with me its director, Gerald Ryle, who is an Australian with an Irish slight-Irish accent, or an Irishman with a very large Australian one. You can decide that later. The show isn't long enough to talk about Jared's many accolades, but here's a poly history.
I've lost Clarendon, how many walkers, how many? Five walkers. This year's Australian Press Council's Press Freedom Medal. A share of putser, an Emmy, three George Polk awards in the US and an honorary doctorate to boot.
He's been named one of the world's top 100 information heroes by reporters with that boarders, and on top of all of that, he's a nice guy, and I can safely say that. Having worked with him for many years. My first question, Jared, is how can a nice guy like you be a hard-nosed investigative reporter? I guess there are different sides of every person.
When you're working, you become a different person, I think. You realise that if you don't ask hard questions, you're not going to get the answers that you need. If you're an investigative reporter, it's all about asking questions. Will you always ask?
As a kid, will you always ask? Where does the matter? Where does this come from? No, no, I think I don't like hypocrisy.
When I see hypocrisy, it gets me angry. I also have a background that allows me to see things in a certain way. I grew up in a very strange environment where when I was young, I was in Northern Ireland, and we left Northern Ireland down to south. I went from one world into another, and it was a strange experience for me.
I'm looking forward to the book on that one. Let's talk about the ICIJ, which is most famous for the Panama Papers, and then the Paradise Papers, and these are massive data leaks, which have exposed global networks of money laundering, fraud, tax evasion, and all sorts of wrongdoings at the senior levels of government and business across the world. Maybe you should remind us a little bit about the Panama Papers and what it's achieved to date. The Panama Papers was a case of documents from a law firm in Panama called Mosac Lonsiegh, and someone called himself John Dole, who was this anonymous person, had somehow copied 40 years of records from this firm.
Every client file, every email, every correspondent, every email, everything basically for 40 years. It was a unique insight into how the world of offshore works. The one thing that offshore, the one product it has is secrecy. Here you were able to see inside a secret world that no one had ever really seen before.
The documents were obtained by one of our media partners, two journalists from the Sude Ojis Seitung newspaper in Germany. In all the world, about 11 and a half million documents. That's a shitload of work. I mean, terabytes, roughly.
Oh, terabytes, I don't know. I mean, on a scale, it was the biggest leak in history, basically. It was about 1,000 times bigger than the old weeks. We got the documents in 2015 and we published in 2016, so it took a whole year for us to go through the documents.
And we didn't get them all together. I mean, we only had, say, only, we only had a million documents at the beginning. So the first call I got from Bastion Oghammar, the journalist involved, he had a million documents and there were some interesting names in it, and he rang me from Munich, and was trying to convince me to do this as an ICIJ project. What did his own pitch?
Jared, I've got these documents. Well, it was a little bit of a history to it there. We've been working on offshore projects for a number of years. This was actually the sixth project we had to take on.
We had done five others, and they've been aggressively getting bigger and bigger. And as part of that world of looking at offshore, we'd actually come across most of them in our previous inquiries. And we knew that they had really interesting clients, like Mugabe and Gaddafi and people like that. And again, they would just pop up over and over again.
So we had been looking at them. So when Bastion rang, it was like he was saying, here, we have more information on this company. And in fact, we have something new. We have a million new documents.
Can you come and see them? And then the next stop came in as well. Well, what happened then? You jumped on a plane and went and saw them.
Well, I went over to Munich because I figured I had to. I looked at the documents. So we spent three days together, secretly looking at them in a hotel room. And I had to sit down offices and kind of realized that this was going to be a little bit different than we'd done before.
We could see, for instance, prime ministers. We could see mafia figures from Russia in there. We could see people that were clearly of public interest. Because the first thing we have to do is to have public interest.
Because you're getting anonymous documents from somebody you don't know where they're coming from. You don't know what the agenda is. So you have a kind of a higher criteria that you have to apply to these things. You've got to establish public interest at the beginning.
Because you didn't know and you still don't know who John Doe. No, no one's ever found out who John Doe is. Any person who's ever contacted John Doe is Bastion. And they were communicating through the secure channel.
And we could be found out too that these documents had been offered to other media. And they'd be knocked back. Why were they not back? I don't know.
There were some of the, I would say, two of the biggest newspapers in the world had been approached separately. I've got to say. Anyway, that's a thing. I'd say who they are.
But no, I've got to say who they are. But in fairness to the reporters too. I mean, I can see why they would have said no. Because there was every reason to suspect that there was a real agenda here.
Because I think there were a approach for particular reasons. For instance, in America, there was an ongoing court case going on involving a hedge fund that was suing Argentina for what was basically debt. And I would imagine that the first reporter who got a hold of this, or at least was contacted by John Doe, would have thought, hey, it must be somebody from the hedge fund. It must be a private investigator.
Is that all through the initial bunch of documents? It was through the original million that Bastion got a hold of. There was in there there was quite a lot of material about this particular... Yeah, but Argentina actually.
And about the current president at the time of Argentina and the person who was about to be elected president. So of course, when we finally published a lot of papers, there was a lot of documents. But there wasn't anything that really sort of confirmed the original suspicion that this was some sort of scam by Argentina to avoid debt. So tell us how the ICI...
Remind us how the ICIJ works. Because you've got this... You've got this... You've got Sebastian calling in.
Three days in Munich, Hautau, Roman, and the newspaper office. And then what? Well, the first thing I had to do with that point was convince their boss to make this an ICI project. So I sat down with Wolfgang Krak who was the editor-in-chief of Sicha Sicha Sicha.
And of course, he was excited that his reporters had these documents and wanted to be a German story and wanted to be a Sicha Sicha story. So the first big negotiation I had was sitting down with him and saying, we can do a bigger and better if you turn it over to ICIJ. And then he sort of imposed some deadlines on us. This was an April, I think, in 2015.
And he wanted the story out. Like every editor and I will remind you, if you were an editor, you were the same. So they wanted the story right away. And so you had to negotiate a kind of a longer time frame.
We negotiated I think September initially, September that year, which gave me six months. So just again, remind us, what's the pitch? What does ICIJ bring? Yeah, ICIJ should go back and explain it.
So we're a non-profit. We're based in Washington, DC. And what we do is we bring investigative reporters from around the world together to work on projects together. And we're funded basically through charity.
And the way we work is we'll be actually trying to do is find a great story and then parlay the story for resources from various media partners. So we will go to the Guardian and we'll go to Sicha Sicha as we have done in the past, which is how they knew us. And we will say, here's a great story for you. But in return, you've got to give me some of your reporters to run our team for sometimes up to a year.
And we've been in a collaborative way with reporters across the world. We've been pioneers in technology. So we basically use technology and we haven't been used before in journalism. So we build online forums for the journalists to come together.
So we have an online newsroom where the journalists, when they go to their physical newsrooms, they also go to the ICIJ newsroom. And you can see everyone who's there. There might be 20 or 30 reporters or 100 reporters there at the time and you can communicate securely with them on this forum. And you can also share tips and findings and other things.
When we get a document set like the Panama Papers, which is to say was 11 and a half million documents, we had to make a way of basically making all the documents searchable for the journalists. So we put everything up on the cloud. We make sure it's secure and then we give everyone passwords to getting in. So they can search every document if they want to.
You can't just go to a German reporter and say, here are 10 German names and here are 20 documents related to that. You have to say, here's everything. Go for it. And then the two years or so since it was published, Panama Papers, what is the toll?
Oh, it's probably been the next 10 minutes talking about that. But I mean, we brought down the immediately, we brought down the government of Iceland. A year later, we brought down the government of Pakistan. There have been a number of people who've gone to jail, quite a number, the most like one second of the firm at the center of all this is now closed to have closed all the offices around the world.
Governments including here in Australia have covered nearly a billion dollars in taxes. They give you 10% of that. Oh, we should take all that. It's all fine to speak.
Yeah, well, one thing we can't do is take government money. So even if they were offering, we couldn't take it. But you know, I mean, you even saw a story in today's city, Monee Herald, talking about another $14 million that they claim is owed by one person here in Sydney. And they only found out about it through our work.
Is that because the, how does that work? Because the Panama Papers, does it get opened up further? I mean, can I go and have a swil through it now? No, we're very clear that we're not an agency of governments.
We don't give the documents. We've been bombarded by governments for these documents. So how do they get to? Well, what we have done, one of the things we do for the journalists is we use technology to allow them to look at these documents in a very different ways.
And one of the technologies we use is one called Neo4j, which allows us to put all of the names and the addresses and the officer companies into notes. So it's like nodal technology. Okay. And that allows you to look at very complex scenarios.
I'll give you one case in the Panama Papers. We found when we were researching, we come across a number of names in relation to FIFA, which is the world's soccer body, because at the time the FBI began indicting people at FIFA, and we started running those names through the documents. So we found that we had a lot more information than the FBI. And we were able to, by turning everything into nodal technology, we were able to show that these very complex nodes all went back to one law firm.
And by researching that law firm, we found somebody who was sitting on the FIFA Ethics Committee, who was the person who was setting up the officer accounts for the people being indicted. So we had a very good story. We'd never been able to get that story if we hadn't used this technology, because the journalists wouldn't have been able to go through the millions of documents. But once they knew that, you know, no day went down to node Z, they were able to then work backwards and sort of get the evidence that we needed to publish a story.
Do you have to be a particular type of journalist for this work? Yeah, I find that we're, you know, the people we work with tend to be, they're just very dogged, they're happy to look at documents. I mean, you know, people see the success of panel members, but I don't see the pain behind it. There was a lot of power to pay.
And even, you know, even convincing newspapers and TV stations to go with this was also quite difficult. I can tell you right up to the very end, we were trying to convince someone the biggest media in America to go with it. And, you know, and they were saying no. And that's an interesting sort of wrinkle in this.
Is that about the journalistic culture, which is, because what you're offering is this massive collaboration and journalist culture, as you well known, in the way you used to work in the way, very much an individualistic kind of thing. Yeah, it's very much the, I mean, we're all kind of, when we're in Viscuire Board, you're kind of lone wolves. So what you're asking these reporters to do is to sort of write everything they've ever learned and start again. And when you're building collaborations, we're quite careful to build that each organization gets the scoop itself.
So we try not to put two newspapers that are rivals together, although sometimes we do. And so when you work with us, you do end up with the scoop yourself. So when the Guardian talks about Panama Papers, they talk about it as a Guardian story, they're very clear about that over and over again. And that's why this works, because everyone can own the story.
When we won the Pulitzer for it, everyone I worked on that team was able to say, or at least claim the good one of the Pulitzer, which is what you want. Was that the true of the Emmy as well? It's the same with the, with the, with 60 minutes. 60 minutes, right?
Yeah. And it was, yeah, everyone worked on that, of course, claims it. And that's fair enough. And that's why it works, I think, because you're able to give the journalists a number of different things.
First of all, you're able to bring them together so they can learn from each other. And believe me, I've learned an awful lot from working with these journalists. They are very good. And they all bring something to the table.
But you're able to also give them another world, because most of them have, they've won all the walkies in their own countries. They've done everything they can do in their own space. And so this gives them another level to play out. Give them the planet.
Yeah, basically. Yeah. And so they, and they really learn, you know, they're all friends now, they all talk to each other, they swap ideas. You know, that's why I got a call from Bastion's first thing, because he had seen it working.
And so when he got the first set of documents, he immediately, his first thought was, let's make this an ICIJ project, not a pseudo-cyton project. Yes. It's called amplification in other parts of the, sort of the corporate sector. It's a massive amplification of the worker generals.
Yeah, it's like when we did a previous story called Locksleaks, which was about Locksenberg, that story had been done, I think, by the BBC in a smaller scale, and it had been done in France on a smaller scale. And so when we were trying to get media partners involved in that, they were saying, oh, I'm not sure this is going to work. But when we published, it was the Guardian now called the ICIJ effect. It really took over Europe and really put Locksenberg as a tax haven on the agenda of Europe.
And they've been at the time, of course, they, you know. Yes, you know, I hear, you know, I hear. So what does this success is going to approach today about perhaps the future of journalism? I mean, is this kind of one of the models that we can look at?
Or is this sort of, if you like, a high-water mark? I'm always intrigued by that. I think it's only, it doesn't work for every story. And I think that's what you've got to be careful.
You can say this is the perfect model for journalism going forward. I think the reason it works is for cheeries and I mean, I think it's because we have technology now that allows us to communicate in a way, we weren't able to communicate it. We have technology that allows us to get documents and parse them and make sense of them in a way that we couldn't have done that 10, 20 years ago. But also I think that it's the, the, the client of the business model in journalism that is allowing this to happen because media companies that in the past would never have dreamt of collaborating because they were so strong and big themselves are now willing to listen to new ways of doing things.
And that has allowed us to come along, I guess, at the right time with the right projects. But you know, you're only as good as your last project or your next project. Well, we'll get to your next project in a minute. But just talk a bit broadly about journalism because you spend a lot of time traveling the world.
You have probably, I was going to say unique, but certainly if not unique, rare insight into the state of journalism in many parts of the world. Do you think, and the rest is a very broad question. So, excuse me, but do you think journalism is winning or losing the battle against, for instance, things like censorship by governments and attempting to stop what it does, in fact, attempting to stop what ICIJ has done, for instance? I think it's winning and losing, it just depends on certain countries.
I mean, the media is suffering in most countries, but then you've got a few exceptions like India where it's booming and where new models are taking off and people are doing things in a very, you know, innovative and unique way. You've got organizations like ours, you've got also got a organization of France called Media Part, which is a totally investigative story. Yeah, absolutely fantastic, you know. You've got, you know, I think there were some instances, for instance, where we collaborated, where we were able to get stories out that wouldn't have been able to get out of, we didn't do it.
There was one country in particular, which I want to say, where the journalists who were investigating the panel of papers found a great story in their own country but would not be able to publish it in their country. So, they gave it to us at ICIJ, and we published it. And then they ended up reporting on their own story, but that way they were able to get it out. And there was another example where we had the owners of one of the newspapers that we were collaborating with were in the documents and they were refusing to run the story.
I wonder why. And so, as ICIJ, we said, look, if you don't run it, we're going to run it. So, they ended up running it on the front page. About their own story.
About their own story. So, that was like Taxavasion in their own company. Absolutely. It was very embarrassing for them, but they ran it.
They ran it on the front page. Well, okay, interesting, very interesting. In all this sort of, how do you think, I mean, I'm going to be localised here, how do you think Australia figures in all this? I think it still has to catch up a little bit.
I think we're seeing more collaborations here, obviously. I think you see Fairfax and the ABC working together. Where is the sea? Well, I think there's still, there's still, people can see, journalists can at least see the value in this because they're getting twice the audience for their stories.
So, they love it. But whether or not the rest of the media is caught on, you know, the business model here, you know, we will argue very strongly that ICIJ is good for business because when we publish the Alleman, for instance, one of our stories, I think their circulation went up 30%. When we publish, there is a scramble to buy the news, organisations or the TV stations, whatever. The audience goes up.
So, there is a business proposition here. I don't think that Australia is really realised. Why do you think that's the case? I think it's just the isolation.
It's been difficult. It's a large island on a small population. But also a little bit, you know, feel like they don't need it. Whereas, you know, it's a bit like the attitudes of some of the bigger newspapers that we first dealt with, we're first queuing up to try and get them to buy into this.
What's in it for them? They can't see... Well, I guess the obvious question I'll ask is, do you think that's a function of the domination of, you know, very few media big players in this country? It is.
And it's also, you know, I guess it's also a bit of a cultural thing in journalism in that we still haven't, you know, we're so isolated from the rest of the world here. There's no excuse for that, right? I mean, there shouldn't be. The net is free to be collaborating with people anywhere in the world.
Yeah, but you've also got unique rules here that do apply. I mean, the libel laws here are very restrictive, even in Britain. Even in Britain now you have a certain defence that are available here in Australia. You've got to have very deep pockets in Australia to be a media publisher.
It's not necessarily the same case in the world. So you actually have staff here, as one of a staff, but you publish out of the US. Yeah, we publish out of the US. We've got people in seven different countries at the moment.
We have a little office in Paris, the office here. We've got people in Germany and England. Germany staff, a lot. At the moment right now, because we're getting ready for publication, I've got 35 people.
Right, well, okay. And we have, it just depends. I mean, that's the IJ input, but then we would have reporters from media organizations at the same time. So with Panama Papers, we had 400 reporters working with us.
We were paying for about 20 of them. Yeah, I mean, that's also very clever part of your business model. Well, it works. I mean, you say it right across.
I mean, they say they get a great story. They might have given us four reporters, say, from the New York Times for a year, which is, you know, great for us. But they, you know, they, the front pages of the New York Times for, say, Paradise Papers, which was our follow-up to Panama, you know, carried out a photograph from Sweden from a Swedish media partner. You know, they hired a drone, went up and photographed a ship.
Well, it could have happened, but it would have been all their expense. Yeah, it's pretty cost effective way of working. Yeah, you know, I get that. Just tell us a little bit about the Paradise Papers, because I came out of Panama.
Just what was the lead? It was actually a bigger set of documents. We have 13 1.5 million documents, again, from the offshore world. And they were from, mostly from a firm called Applebee, which was much more high-end than Mossek.
So, well, Mossek, Mossek was happy to have dictators as clients. These guys were happy to have, you know, Nike and Uber and, you know, Facebook and people like that for clients. So it was a very different story and a very different way of looking at the world. I mean, one of their clients was the Queen, for instance, of England.
And what was interesting about that was that she, you know, doesn't get taxed because she's the Queen, but she was still investing in offshore entities. And some of those entities, well, one of them in particular, was actually a predatory lending firm. So here we have the Queen of England making money for our own subjects. And then, I bet you did.
Didn't have to be taxed, but was hiding basically through offshore entities. Now, whether she knew or not, of course, is the big question. We don't know the answer then. We don't know, but I guess you could argue that you should have known.
Yes, well, I'll say it's her money. That's her money, but she's also, I mean, you've got to have the moral argument here. She should be benefiting from predatory lending firms. Exactly.
Did that get broken in the UK? It was huge in the UK. We have the BBC in the Guardian in the UK as our, as a media partner. Another argument for the Republic then.
Maybe. But I think it's very important. I mean, this is all a public interest. I think there's no point in us just publishing basic, you know, details.
We get like in these big data leaks, there's every kind of information. There's, there's your passport details. There's your bank account details. There's sometimes there's even your passwords to your bank accounts.
We don't think that that that kind of information should be public. But we do think that very basic information that is in the public interest or to be public. It makes that decision. You ultimately, I too, but we also, because we're working collectively, you also get a much bigger, better perspective for a story because you're able to, people see things differently.
So when you have one reporter working on something, they all bring something else to the table. And I think you do end up doing much better journalism. You know, we have like big debates inside the, the forums about what is the story, what is it a story? Is this person important?
Why isn't that person important? You know, we found Bono from YouTube, for instance, one of our Lithuanian partners, found that, that he was investing through an offshore entity into an avoiding tax into Lithuania. Now, normally you think, well, that's just a superstar. Yeah, what is the world preaching good things and his opinion and what have you?
Well, except that Bono was the head of the One Campaign, which is a global media campaign against offshore tax havens. So here he is again, it's hypocrisy. He's somebody, you know, he ended up having to pay tax. It was very embarrassing for one because they somehow had found out that we were publishing the paradise papers and had organized an entire campaign around it.
But Bono was told that he was asking us questions by our media bar. So just, just those fine moral lines. I mean, how do you sniff out, I suppose? I mean, let's head to the chase.
Some journalists have agendas. If, for instance, you may be a pro-republican agenda, you get hold of everything you've got. The queen is a tax evader, that's the type of thing, or investing in predatory, and from the practice, predatory, landing practices. How do you, and then the temptation, of course, is, oh my God, I've got the queen.
How do you sort of bring that back a bit? Is that the thing that happens? That's a natural... I mean, I'll give you a very good example of that.
So one of the first names that I saw on the Panama Papers in Munich, on day one, was the Prime Minister of Iceland. And so on, the surface, it looked great. We've got the Prime Minister of Iceland here. And I thought at the time, well, there was a big controversy over the Icelandic banks failing.
This is probably a story. But I also looked very closely at it and realized that the Prime Minister, when he registered this particular company, I'm sure, he wasn't a politician. It was before he became a politician. He was a businessman.
So we were also potentially looking at something that wasn't a story. It took a lot of work to get that bit of information into a story. And the history behind that was that we didn't know anybody in Iceland. We knew it was a very small country.
We knew that we picked the wrong journalists, that it was likely to be a straightaway. So we went to our Swedish media partner, so we'd worked with before and said, do you know anyone in Iceland? And they recommended this guy, Johannes, and Johannes, basically, when he was brought into the circle, realized that he needed to quit work for a year and work on this in isolation. Because if anyone found out what he was working on, there were a lot of Icelandic names in the Panama Papers.
And of course, this was the biggest one. And so he basically lived off the earnings of his wife for a year, disappeared from society, had to keep making excuses. So huge risk for somebody. And we were giving him a story.
Remember, and he had a seat on that story. You can imagine if you were in a vestigial reporter having a seat on a story. The one you're going to bring down the Prime Minister. Well, potentially, why it became a story is that he researched this company and he actually went through all of the records of the Icelandic banks.
And he found that one of the creditors of the banks was this offshore entity, Winters. And of course, unless you knew that Winters was the Prime Minister's company, it didn't make any sense. But again, it was a hypocrisy. Here's a guy who's been elected to sort out the bank collapse who has a financial interest in what he's actually doing.
That's why he had a resign. It's very remarkable. Did he get compensated for a year of living in a cave or where we did? No, he set up a little nonprofit for the media in Reykjavik, and that's what he's doing now.
I mean, I'll tell you a better story about him because when he was suffering through this, and we really felt his suffering, and so at one point I flew to Iceland to see him and sit down really, just to calm him down and meet his wife, and ensure his wife that this was going to be worth it. And I was trying to flatter him, I guess, in a way, and I said, you know, Hannah's going to be the most famous journalist in Iceland. He just laughed at me and said, Jared, I'm already the most famous journalist in Iceland. He was turning us into Iceland.
Right, so I'll be the most famous and the poorest journalist in Iceland. Well, he suffered a lot afterwards. I mean, he had people obviously congratulating him on the story, but he also had people chasing him down super regularly at him. So it's a very small place.
You'll listen to the fourth estate where a journalist talked to journalism, and I guess it is Jared Ryle, the Director of the International Consortium of Investor Journalists, famed for the Paradise and Panama Papers, but a lot more besides. So, Jared, what's the next project for the ICIJ, the next big hit? I would imagine you get asked every day to reveal the truth about President Trump's tax, for instance. Yeah, well, I think if I had a story on Trump, it would be the biggest story in the world, and we'd be going after it.
But I can tell you what we're working on, but I can say that we are working at the moment with 250 reporters from 36 countries, from 50 to 50, at different media outlets, and we're working on something that's got nothing to do with tax or offshore. It's going to be anything. It'll be anything. I'm assuming it involves corruption.
It involves something, I think, that is an underreported area that people need to know about. I hate to be so vague about it, but we're really, what we're trying to do this time is do something that does not involve a leak. But to put in practice something that we've been thinking about a long time, there's a novel of information out there in the public that journalists aren't using. And so we are building our own data set, and we've gone through about seven to nine million records that we've now gathered from around the world.
From Freedom of Information Requests, from public sources, other things, and we've turned them into a database. And we've left the journalists go crazy on the database. And also being... The fake subject being...
Well, something that affects at least one in ten people. So it's definitely a public interest. Okay, well, okay. We won't play this game for much longer because the show's not long enough.
But when you go around the world, you know, you spend a lot of time with journalists, how would you summarize the mood of journalism? And on the show we talk a lot about the constant attacks on journalists. We obviously have the United States President says all the time, but he's not alone in wherever you go, really. And what I originally got, Hungary, Philippines, you name it.
What do you think the mood of journalism is, if that's... if you can sort of summarize the activity of several hundred thousand people? Well, there's a lot of concern about some things. For instance, a number of journalists getting killed seems to be, at least in the public eye, is going up.
And it's not that journalists are suddenly being killed when they weren't being killed. I mean, you know, our reporter is in Mexico, for instance. I mean, it's the most dangerous country in the world to be a reporter. But you've seen, and we have experienced this directly ourselves.
And a lot of reporters, well, say a lot of words, at least three reporters are now being killed in Europe. And Europe is not a place you expect journalists to be killed. We have the situation in Malta, which was directly affected us. The, you know, I see, I see, we don't just employ traditions or other people who would say, we also have computer programmers because we really believe in using technology.
And the person who wrote the program that allowed the Panama Papers to be seen was Matthew Cara when I was a mother. And his mother was blown up in Malta. So she, after we published the Panama Papers, she was a very well-known blogger there. She took up some of the information that we published online and also published.
There were some connections we couldn't make. She went and got her own sources and then started publishing further stories. And for a troubleshadow, again, we're not sure it was related to the Panama Papers directly. But about a year ago, she was blown up.
So the mood is defiant? I think, yeah, the other side is, I think Trump, Donald Trump, the US president, is actually major and is more relevant in many ways. Which, you know, even though people might be alarmed by some of the things he's doing, it's really a year where people are also able to see the relevance of news report. Trump is good for journalism.
He has been good for journalism in some ways. Yeah, absolutely. And you can't ignore that. The relevance of, you know, we are now more relevant than ever.
It's just that there are so many problems out there. The business models are broken. Journalists getting killed. There seems to be this, you know, again, Trump seems to be encouraging attacks on journalism, whether it be physical attacks or whether it just be, you know, attacks on the same, it muses fake and other things.
But again, I would argue that working with 400 journalists from, you know, 80 different countries is very hard to argue against what you end up publishing because if they're all looking at the same documents, they'll come to the same conclusions. It's very hard to call it fake news. Oh, yeah. No, and it's one of the ways of beating the bastards as it were.
I'm going to let you go. But I just want to ask you quickly. I see I'm not for profit, as you say. When you travel the world, do you find profitable news media organizations?
Or is it really, are we heading towards this future where not for profit is probably the most successful model? No, I don't think not for profit is the model because you've got to keep looking for a check. And that's very hard. Yeah.
You spend a lot of your time doing that. Yes, absolutely. So I think you've got to. I think what's happening here is that the nonprofit world is experimenting and we're able to, you know, try new things, some work, some don't.
I certainly know of two organizations that are profitable, that media part I mentioned before in France and also an organization in South Korea called News Tapper. And they have convinced 30,000 people to give them a certain amount of money every month. And they're able to, in fact, they're doing so well, even now contribute to ICIJ. They're right as a check every year, so thanks.
But you'll see like the Guardian, for instance, is now going down this way and asking people to contribute. It is kind of an experimental sandbox at the moment. But again, I would say in India, there are very successful commercial models that are going. It's just that it's the old West and the old models that are suffering.
I'm very optimistic that out of this sandbox and great things will come and ICIJ is in a way led the way. That's about it from before the state this week. I can't thank you enough, Gerald, for spending some time with us. Thank you.
No, thanks for having me. So that's Gerald, we're the head of the International Consortium of Investment Journalist. Watch out for the next, oh, by the way, when is that coming roughly the next big one? It'll be very soon.
The next couple of weeks. Okay, watch out. Watch out. And we'll be seeing it in this fine country as well.
Yes, sir. We're at the financial review and the ABC. Oh, excellent. There you go.
Who says it, Fairfax? And won't be cooperating with the ABC now that it's part of nine or almost part of nine. Anyway, that's another issue. Another story.
Again, thank you for listening. Make sure you subscribe to The Fourth Estate on your favorite podcast app, so you can hear us talk media politics and a few things in between Atwill when you want to do. We'll be back very soon. And in the meantime, you can stay in touch with us on Facebook or Twitter.
Our handle is Fourth Estate AU. Another thanks to my fabulous producer, Anthony Docquell. My name is Peter Frey, and thanks very much for listening.