Hello and welcome to Full The State, a show about journalism. We're coming to you from 2SER in Sydney on the gannical lands of the Eora nation, right across Australia on the community radio network and directly to your device, the globe via podcast. I'm Monica Atard. A week is a long time in politics, as they say, and even during lockdown, New South Wales showed just how true that old chestnut is.
In the space of a few days, New South Wales went from having gladiosphericly and riding high in the poles and on her way to leading her state out of lockdown, to the swearing-in of a new premier and deputy premier. Add to that multiple bio-elections and general confusion. We all know why it happened, but in this edition, we need to ask, do the media play its part in informing the public and holding the powerful to account and why the level of grief at the fall of yet another New South Wales premier, this time to a corruption inquiry. To help us this week, we're joined by Lucy Cormack, who reports New South Wales politics for Sydney Morning Herald, and Troy Branson, who's a senior writer and columnist for the Australian newspaper.
Lucy Cormack and Troy Branson, welcome to Full The State, thank you both very much for being here. Now, a lot of people, and not just in New South Wales, were shocked, no, blindsided, they were even angry, they gladiosphericly resigned from politics altogether after ICAX announcement that it would investigate her after evidence given to an inquiry last year. I mentioned both of you were surprised, but perhaps not shocked that she resigned. Let's just go over, why in the end did you think, not just in terms of the inquiry being announced, but why in the end did she go?
And did she have any real alternative? Lucy, we might start with you on this one. Yes, I think one thing that's become clear, of course, is that this was a huge shock for the public, that perhaps, if you had been paying attention or in following the course of the ICAX investigation and in political circles, it perhaps wasn't as much of a surprise. We knew that investigations were continuing, we knew that the ICAX had delayed its findings on the Darmaguire, as we had expected to receive those earlier, and they delayed those and pushed those out.
So there was sort of this kind of sense of foreboding as something still was to come. And I think that the fact that she's ultimately stood down, I mean, I'm of the view that I don't really see any other way around it, it's the standard that she'd set for every other Premier. I mean, some would argue she should have stood down perhaps sooner, but indeed, I think, given the very serious allegations that have been leveled against her, whether or not she has led us through a pandemic well and led the state, in a way that's seen us succeed through the pandemic, that's sort of irrelevant, I think, when it comes to the fact that these are serious allegations being leveled against her by the corruption, what shock? And she has to respond to that.
So, I mean, in a sense, do you think, because there wasn't an awful lot of reporting at the height of Delta, for example, in particular, when Delta kind of hit me south by it was in a big way, that there wasn't a lot of reporting of what was going on the background with ICAX. Obviously, you as political reporters and Troy, you as a commentator, you would have been aware of what was going on. But what, and then obviously, it's come as a surprise to the public. But do you think that's contributed to the level of shock that we've seen, Troy?
Yeah, Monica, I think it definitely has. There's no doubt facing a one in 100-year pandemic has focused the public's attention, and it's probably drained some media resources away from keeping a spotlight on what was going on at ICAX. But I actually think that what happened at ICAX last year, last October, when the Darryl Maguire relationship with Gladys Buriclian was revealed, I thought they were sufficient grounds for her resignation, and we might be able to talk about some of the aspects of the ICAX act, and what actually took place then, which led me to take that view. So I was not surprised at all with her resignation.
I was only surprised that it took so long. And of course, that inquiry, which is called Operation Kepel, has now been extended into new areas. So the inquiry is ongoing. But Monica, I'd probably want to suggest something in addition to the pandemic.
And that is, I think that Gladys Buriclian was very clever at spinning what had actually taken place last October. And I say that because I think she was very clever in propagating this idea that she had a bad boyfriend, she was unlucky in love, and that won her a lot of sympathy with radio, shock jocks, and some newspaper gossip columns. And so she took control of the narrative very quickly. So it wasn't about potential corruption or pro-vivialapses, it was about her failed love life.
And she leaned into that very shrewdly, very calculatingly. And I think that that won her some support with the public who turned a blind eye to these property failures. Sorry, it's going to seem. I was just going to add to that, Monica, that I think further to what Troy has said there, is that perhaps this time around, I think, part two of this saga is the shock value of that sort of the relationship, if you will, and the love story that she put up as being behind it is.
I think the shock value of that will have subsided, and that the focus will be very much now on what that relationship meant. Did it achieve or lead to wrongdoing? And how did it play out, I suppose, in terms of how she may or may not have used her position of office or whether she breached public trust as a result of that relationship? So to both of you think, then, that when these hearings take place, I think, around October 18, likely to be highly viewed by a lot of people, including ordinary members of the public.
Do you think that that kind of St. Gladys aura might subside then, which is not to preempt what the hearings might unveil, of course, but just the sight of seeing Gladys spiritually and being interrogated in the witness stand with allegations like these being put to her in presumably more detail than they were last year? Do you think that that will impact her public image? Yeah, look, I do 100% Monica.
I think that when voters look at her sitting in the witness box and being asked these additional questions and keep in mind that ICAC usually asks questions they already know the answer to. That is the model. And they've been doing this investigation for a long time. I mean, I was hearing from Liberal MPs as early as January this year that there had been so-called secret sessions going on.
People have been interviewed and that this was very much alive and ongoing matter. And I think people will now start to probably focus a little bit better on what has actually taken place at ICAC and look at the questions being asked, the evidence produced and her responses. But I must just flag something else, Monica, which is I've been disappointed with the quality of some of the commentary that has been in the media. I think the City Morning Herald and the Australian and the financial reviewer have done a good job in terms of their actual political reporters that will be following this matter.
And I don't have any criticism of them. But it's the other commentators writing in newspapers and on television and radio who have come in and criticised ICAC said that they're surprised by the resignation. It was a witch hunt. It was a star chamber.
How can they do this? I mean, I saw the Channel 9 bulletin on Friday night, Monica, and that opened with a statement that the nation was grieving. Now, that is absurd. It's absurd reporting and absurd commentary by people who really don't know what has gone on or how ICAC operates.
And I'm a little bit hot under the collar because it's frankly driving me absolutely bonkers some of the commentary I've seen in the recent week. I'm sure you would have been outraged to see some of the other comparisons, which I saw on Twitter saying it was akin to the death of Diana. And others that said it was somewhat like, you know, if you reminded them of the gunning down of JFK. I know.
And again, Gladys Berry-Chercline has lent into that and fostered that. So, you know, we've seen her on TV, you know, collecting the flowers, accepting the well wishes, the cards that have been left outside her home in her office. I mean, the nation's gone crazy here. And I'm really concerned about the quality of political commentary in this country that we can allow this to fester and become what many people believe is the truth, when it actually is not the truth.
And she is already facing significant allegations. I think some of these things are actually facts about how she has breached the ICAC acts. And so this is actually damaging for our democracy, that we're giving her essentially a free pass. And there's somehow sympathy for someone who could be facing serious, serious implications and possible charges for corrupt conduct.
So, okay, I mean, except all of that, have we seen anything like this before in Australian political life? Troy? I actually can't think of anything like this. 77,000 signatures on a change.org petition saying she should be reinstated.
Has that ever happened before? I mean, not a change.org petition, but this kind of outpouring of grief and outrage. This has happened. I can't recall anything like it Monica.
I've racked my brain trying to think of a historical comparison. I can't think of one, but it's probably worth just briefly noting that, you know, her failure to disclose this relationship with Durham Maguire is actually a breach of the ministerial code of conduct, which sits under the ICAC act as a regulation. So, this is not an allegation. This is not an argument.
This is a fact. She did not disclose what was a close, intimate, personal relationship as required by law. That, I think, is enough to warrant her resignation. But she also did not disclose a potential conflict of interest to the cabinet.
When she knew about his business deals with her, the phone taps, she heard him talk about the money he was going to make. She met his business partners. She met his clients. She received emails from his clients and partners.
That is a clear conflict of interest given that he had a business interest in the second sitting airport, which the cabinet was discussing and making decisions about. And of course, the third thing is that under the ICAC act, anyone who suspects corrupt conduct, or knows the corrupt conduct, has a duty to report it. So, there's some very clear things where I think she has failed. Yet, it doesn't seem to have registered with the public at all.
Lucy, can you see any comparisons to the treatment of politicians in times gone by? You know, got with them, comes to mind. There was an outpouring of grief then. Is this comparable?
Well, I didn't think it quite is. I mean, what's been quite extraordinary for me has been the fact that, because she's worn this halo for so long, no one had a problem with ICAC or its powers or what it was doing when it was exposing Maguire himself, you know, and some of the allegations against him, all the likes of Edio B. You know, everyone couldn't do enough to sing its praises. It's only now that it is that it is glad it's true in their sights.
I feel that that has, you know, the dial has shifted. And I think it's interesting to consider perhaps, I wonder if we hadn't been in a pandemic, if we hadn't been in this situation and her popularity wasn't such, you know, as a result of the pandemic, I wonder if the public reaction wouldn't have been quite the same, because she did not have the same public recognition pre-pandemic, you know, that she became Gladys, you know, by just the singular name, she could be only known as Gladys, and she had such popularity all around Australia. Everybody knew her as a result of pandemic. Would the support be the same without that having happened?
I don't know. Well, I mean, that does take me to the point that I wanted to raise with both of you, and that is that the pandemic seems to have created these, you know, various cults of personality around our leaders, Dan Andrews, of course, comes to mind there as well. Do you think that the pandemic has altered our relationship with the premiers and the territory leaders? Is that kind of support that we're seeing around them, a sign of something, you know, more partisan, or perhaps even a bit more base, creeping into our public discourse?
Troy? Yeah, I think we have seen a shift back to premier power, probably for the first time since the 1930s, and we've become a little bit parochial as well within our states. And I think at a time of crisis, at a time of challenge, people often look to authority figures, and in this case, the premiers who seem to be on their side doing what they can, dealing with a difficult matter. And so people seek reassurance, they seek leadership, and they're founded in the premiers.
And the premiers, I think, have successfully ganged up on Scott Morrison, who, of course, has his own values in the pandemic, and I'm not exempting those. But it's sort of set up a bit of a dichotomy between sort of state-based boundaries against the kind of national political system. So we have seen that. And I think the daily press conferences have created this sort of individual, singularly leadership type figure who is responsible for everything and taking the action and being tough.
So yeah, that's been, that's, I think, been a factor of the pandemic. But related to that, Monica, is also, I think, this idea that because we're in a pandemic, we need to just pause everything else. And there have been a number of commentators, and including some lawyers, have argued that, you know, this is a pandemic, it's a serious time. Maybe we just need to put this corruption here in the side for a little while and just think about that later.
Well, I think that is a ludicrous statement. We can't just sort of pause investigations into integrity and probability. In fact, they're probably more important during a pandemic than not. But we seem to have kind of lost our collective senses with some of this stuff.
And the willingness to give a Gladys Berry-Jigley in a pass for what I think is serious failures is just mind-boggling. And the pandemic itself has probably a big part to do with that. Just back to this point of the change in dynamics of power, though, which I think is a really interesting phenomenon. And I wonder, Lucy, to what extent do you think the media has exacerbated that issue and played into it?
I mean, for example, ADC24 has literally been taken over by press conferences for morning till night. It's extraordinary that every leading gets unlimited time to wrap it on. There was a time when Dan Andrews will get on his feet and talk for two, three hours. And it was all covered.
Has that played into it? Yes, I think so, because I think what it's done for the first time is it's for the public. People who have never seen a press conference in their life are suddenly watching them every single day and it's part of their daily schedule. And it gives them, I think, just sort of speaking to even my friends and family who aren't in the media, they say, it sort of gives them an insight like they have an inside look as to how their premiere is out there fighting for them.
And I think that's been particularly relevant with really contentious issues like the border boards. You know, people are sitting at home unable to visit family in Queensland or in Western Australia and cut off this entire pandemic. They are able to tune in and hear how their premiere is fighting for them. And it's their battle.
And I think it comes a little bit back to that kind of parochialism. I think Toronto, I do agree that that has really been born out at this time. But I think the 11am press conferences, if you will, I think there's been nothing healthy. I don't think about all sorts of things down to sit and hear daily case numbers and daily death tolls.
However, I think there was a shock around the premiere when she announced, if we recall, when she sort of eluded the former premiere, glad it's very jically in when she said she would be stepping away from doing that and pulling back. And it was that really showed the relevance of those daily press conferences, I think, to people because there was a public outcry. People did go, well, hang on, is this the right time to be doing this? Are we opening up?
And now, you know, as recently as yesterday, new premiere, Dominic Peritay has said that the 11am is going to be scrapped. The case numbers are going to be released every morning now, much earlier. And we're moving ahead. We're very much in that recovery phase.
So, you know, I suppose he's really trying to put his mark on the roadmap out of lockdown and to say that he's moving away from that world in which we sit down and consume these, you know, long-running press conferences. Is that a good thing? Do you think it's a good move? Well, I think we're moving into a parliament's returning, you know, parliament will resume again next week.
And I think that's been one of the reasons the daily press conferences have been so important because actually all of this year and all this pandemic, the lockdown at least in the last three months, it's been the only vehicle or the only way to hold the government to account to put questions to them. I mean, this was the only way that, you know, any of the decisions, critical key decisions they were making could be scrutinized. And that public scrutiny, I think, was really important as we sort of move into this next stage. And we have vaccination rates where they are.
And parliament is resuming. I think, yeah, I think there is something realistic about moving away from, do we need to stand up for an hour and ask the same questions each day? I think that the dial has shifted, I suppose, with those high vaccination rates and with, you know, with life returning to some mode to come up normal. Okay, can I take you both back briefly now too?
I came for a moment and a reaction that we've seen in some quarters. And it's been across the board in media terms. I mean, at the Australian, there was a big Sherry Marksman piece that was quite condemnation of the move, the city, Money Herald has run its fair share of commentary pieces as well. And the general tone seems to be this as a kangaroo court that we keep on losing premiers to this body, it's got to stop.
If you think that back to federal politics for a moment, many have been, you know, lamenting the lack of ministerial accountability and the general disdain for the most basic of public standards. Do you think that the reaction that a premier has gone in this way is also a sign that was kind of collectively forgotten what accountability means and what it is to see true leadership? Troy? Yeah, look at there.
Of course, there's been this debate at the federal level about whether there should be an integrity commission, an anti-corruption commission established and the government has said they would do one, but probably not as strong as what what Labor would do. And given the response to Gladys Berry-Jiglion, I think there's going to be some support for that to actually have a serious look at what kind of anti-corruption commission should be established at the federal level. I don't think there's any doubt that there should be one, but there are very, very different models across the nation. I mean, every state and territory has some kind of anti-corruption body, but they operate extremely differently.
An ICAC was the first and it does have this sort of open model where hearings are here in public and the voters get to the idea about it is the voters actually get to follow what's going on and follow the presentation of evidence and follow the line of questioning in the hope that they better understand it. But that actually hasn't happened in this case at all. People in fact have tuned out and have been shocked by Gladys Berry-Jiglion's resignation even though they actually hadn't come down with any finding yet. But yes, there is going to be a continual push I think from Labor at the federal level for a commission of some kind, but exactly what model is.
I don't know that we've actually settled in a position nationally about what he's actually best. So this is going to be something I think to watch in the lead up to the election. So Troy, do you think that the ICAC model needs a little rethink as even as it passed in New South Wales? Well, look, I have some reservations about the ICAC model, but I'm not actually sure about which is the best way to go.
I mean, I'd like to see a public debate. I'd like to see some alternative models put forward, particularly at the national level with some detail before I passed judgment on that. But my concern about Gladys Berry-Jiglion was not so much the model. It was the fact that it had already uncovered that she had kept this relationship secret.
And as I argue, that meant that she had already fallen foul of the ministerial code of conduct, which is a regulation that sits under the ICAC Act. And of course, she hadn't disclosed that relationship and a potential conflict of interest to the Cabinet. So the fact that it discovered these things, without actually making any findings, I think we're of course enough for her to resign, which has actually got nothing to do with the ICAC model, so to speak, because we haven't actually seen where this investigation was going. But the problem for ICAC is that let's be honest, I mean, it has had some high profile failures.
It's made some allegations about people that have been overturned in the Supreme Court, most notably Nick Griner, the premier ironically who set up ICAC in 1988. So ICAC has had some hits and misses. But in terms of Gladys Berry-Jiglion, I think it's a slam dunk that she has breached the act. Lucy, is ICAC doing the job that we need it to be doing?
This is going to be, I think, such a hot topic going forward now, especially as this inquiry kicks off on October 18. What we did hear a lot of in the days following Gladys Berry-Jiglion's resignation, from those supporters of hers who were highly critical of the ICAC statement, people like Philip Ruddock and also even helping us about how that made similar comments earlier this week, which was to say that there needs to be some sort of review or overhaul or change to the way that ICAC is structured. And both of them cited the Hong Kong model. And what they have in Hong Kong is a model in which it remains all behind closed doors until basically a point at which charges can be laid out at the same time.
So basically arguing that the sorts of things that we've seen today and the sorts of allegations that were laid out in a statement released by ICAC last week, that shouldn't have been made public perhaps until now. And that, therefore, challenges exactly what we're talking about here, which is the right of the voter and the public to sit and to watch these inquiries as they play out. And I think that also, I don't know, I sort of feel a bit uncomfortable with that idea as well in the sense that, yes, ICAC has its issues with people who do go and appear as witnesses often get tarnished with the brush of appearing at ICAC and that can be a problem for them and I understand that. But by the same chunk and I also think ICAC hasn't just woken up and written a statement and emailed it out.
And so these are the things we've decided to look at. These are allegations and points of investigation that are the product of many, many months at inquiry. And as everybody says, ICAC asks questions, they already know the answers to, we are going to I imagine see, you know, here and see a litany of evidence at this inquiry and we will hear phone recordings, perhaps we will see documents tended. So they do come out with these statements and these inquiries off the back of investigation.
So I don't think it's necessarily it's not happening in a vacuum and out of the blue as it were. But you're saying that that's a damaging bit, that's what should stop or be changed? No, I'm not saying that all these, this is, I think this is what we've seen a lot of in the discourse. I agree.
I'm sort of, I don't know necessarily what, I don't know enough yet to say probably how the model should be tweaked. But I'd some of the arguments, I suppose from Gladys Buriciculan supporters in the last week have been that it shouldn't have been as public as it has been today. And that maybe we should be looking at models overseas similar to Hong Kong where things stay behind closed doors for longer. Okay, now before I let you both go, I just want to turn your minds briefly to to Gladys Buriculan's replacement Dominic Peritay has been awful lot of focus on his religious beliefs.
Politicians, personal beliefs of course do meet some level of the public interest discourse. But but in the case of a thing like Peritay, many of us know very, very little about him, we're either of you uncomfortable with the level of scrutiny and distrust expressed in the media and sometimes by members of the media and certainly on social media into his religious beliefs. Troy? Yes, it's a good question Monica.
I've actually been appalled by some of the questioning and some of the focus on his personal beliefs. When he was interviewed on the New South Wales ABC news bulletin the day he became premier, the first question was about his religion. Now, I mean, these are personal beliefs. He is a conservative Catholic.
That's his prerogative. I'm not aware that his conservative social views have acted on his public responsibilities in terms of actual decisions being made. Sorry? They could.
Well, they could but he is a part of a very socially progressive moderate liberal government and it should be judge science policies rather than the individual beliefs of ministers. I think he also is someone who has traditionally been very pragmatic and very shrewd and I think that those on the left, and I mean, not so much journalists, but the Labor Party should be very, very careful about going after somebody's personal views because there's a lot of socially conservative Labor voters or swinging voters who would be unsettled by that kind of line of questioning. Let's judge him on what he actually does and whether or not his personal beliefs impact on actual decision making. I've seen no evidence yet that it does and in fact, the other argument could be put for someone who might be an atheist or an agnostic.
I mean, someone might say, don't we need Christian values in public life, but we never hear that kind of questioning. So let's just judge him on what he does, rather than what he believes in his private life. Well, see, isn't the entire point of a liberal democracy to show some tolerance towards personal belief? Do you think the media got the balance right in the coverage of Peritay's ascendancy to the premiership?
I think there was a lot of focus on it, I suppose. And I guess it sort of, it came off the back, I think, people really targeted the fact of his voting record on the abortion bill, which we saw in 2019 and to, you know, he voted against removing that from the criminal code. And that was a conscience vote that was held. He's defended his decision and his faith and said, you know, he's very proud of his faith and that diversity should be celebrated.
I think he said in his first conference and not criticized him. He should be judged on who he is and what he says, not simply on his religion. I think what he was really trying to do is on Tuesday at least was to point out that he would always be committed to, despite his faith, he would always be committed to conscience votes on social issues. And that will definitely play a big role in coming weeks and months over the voluntary system dying, which we know is going to come before the parliament.
And, you know, there's a lot of talk that that was sort of one of the conditions of getting the moderate support in the party for his tilt at the leadership, which was that he would give a conscience vote on that issue. So I think I was surprised with some of the, you know, we have seen a lot of coverage on his on his faith. I think I wasn't entirely surprised at the outpouring of anger in many corners of Twitter and social media, I guess, because I suppose I sort of feel like that was the obvious line that would be followed and picked up on. Yep.
Okay, is that a final question to you both? The next New South Wales title action is Do you want to, I think March 2023. Is the next election of consequence is the federal election without gladdus vera jicqueen around? Do you think that Scott Morrison faces an uphill battle in New South Wales?
Troy? Yeah, I do. I think she was someone of a defender of his against the Labor Premiers in Queensland and Western Australia and Victoria. So he's lost an ally, I think, in the national cabinet, someone who's more sort of open to relaxing restrictions and getting the kind of the state opened up again as fast as possible, getting kids back to school, getting businesses up and running again.
So he's lost an ally there and New South Wales is going to be very challenging, I think, for the coalition. But at the end of the day, I think the voters come the federal election will judge the government on its record and on Labor on its plans and on its policies and also the two leaders. I think leadership has always been important, particularly in federal elections. And given this pandemic, I think that's going to be even more so voters will be looking very clearly at Scott Morrison and Anthony Albanese and making an almost presidential choice, I think, when it comes to the next election.
And Lucy, what do you think? Do you think that he's safe, for example, peritate stumbles along the way of taking yourself Wales out of lockdown, that that will have a federal impact? Look, as we know, the New South Wales is the biggest state. I think this has been the line of the new paratake government, which is that if New South Wales does well, the rest of Australia does well.
So I'll go in the reverse, the same could be true. I think, you know, the two have obviously had a prickly relationship at times, but constructive, I think, the way that Peritate described it this week was to say that his meetings and dealings with Scott Morrison and within the national cabinet, it's not a cool by our session. He's been able to fight for New South Wales, but also work constructively. So I think New South Wales' success under this new parate government is going to be critical for Scott Morrison.
But I think also at the end of the day, people are going to be, when it comes to the federal election, I think people are going to be thinking about vaccine rollouts and vaccines apply and the way the federal government handled that. And I think people understand that that was a federal issue as opposed to something handled by the state government. And I think that anger maybe that remains around the rollout and how things were handled in that regard will play a big role for people when it comes to the ballot box. Okay, and on that note, I'll let you both go.
I thank you both for a fantastic discussion. It was super interesting. And I hope we can get you back on the program again soon. Thanks.
And on that note, I'd like to thank Lucy Cormack and Troy Bramston for being on Fourth Estate. And thank you for listening to the program. This edition was recorded at the studios of 2SER and heard across the country on the community radio network. Fourth Estate is produced with the assistance of the Community Broadcasting Foundation, thanks to the foundation for their continuing support.
Make sure you subscribe to Fourth Estate on your favorite podcast app so that you can hear it, store media and politics and everything in between. We'll be back with more next week, but in the meantime, you can stay in touch with us on Twitter. Our handle there is Fourth Estate AU. Thanks to my producer Anthony Dockall, I'm Monica Atter and thank you for listening.