Great Lakes Mysteries, Elmer McCurdy, Vodou & A Real Life Oddity

This week on The Oddities Department, history gets wet, explosive, misrepresented, and unclaimed.In Episode 22, Gavin and Lindsay take you through four bizarre oddities from the stranger corners of history. First, we head to the Great Lakes, where freshwater looks calm from the shoreline, but underneath the surface, things get cold, violent, ancient, and deeply suspicious. There are vanished ships, missing planes, singing sands, underwater stone formations, ghost ships, lake monsters, red goblins, and one very important reminder that “it’s just a lake” is how people end up in the footnotes.Then we meet Elmer McCurdy, a real-life outlaw with a tragic beginning, a drinking problem, bad instincts, and just enough nitroglycerin knowledge to make every robbery worse. Elmer wanted fortune, glory, and a place in outlaw history. What he got was loose change, destroyed money, poor planning, whiskey, bloodhounds, and one of the most embarrassingly unsuccessful criminal careers the American West ever coughed up.From there, we pull apart what people think they know about Vodou. Zombies, dolls, curses, demons, possession, and scary movie nonsense all go under the museum lights, and what we find underneath is older, richer, and far more human. This exhibit digs into Haitian history, slavery, survival, resistance, ancestors, religious camouflage, and the way fear can turn someone else’s sacred tradition into a horror prop with bad lighting.Finally, we end in the back room with A Real Life Oddity, a story that starts with a dead man no one came to claim and spirals into funeral homes, sideshows, carnival theft, wax museums, exploitation films, amusement parks, glow-in-the-dark paint, forensic investigation, and one deeply unsettling question: who the hell let this happen?This episode has everything: shipwrecks, outlaw stupidity, cursed freshwater, spiritual misinformation, singing beaches, missing planes, train robberies, bad explosives math, mystery bodies, carnival chaos, and just enough education to make the whole thing legally defensible. Content warning: This episode contains discussion of drowning, shipwrecks, plane crashes, death, body parts, human remains, slavery, colonial violence, religious discrimination, corpse exploitation, mummified remains, gun violence, alcohol abuse, illness, tuberculosis, profanity, and historical mistreatment of people and bodies after death.Send us Fan Mail