Hal Niedzviecki: Creativity, Conformity & The Rise and Fall of Broken Pencil | The Canadians Ep. 11

Hal Niedzviecki built the heartbeat of North America’s zine movement — then lost it all for defending free expression.   In the mid-90s, his magazine Broken Pencil championed DIY art, radical self-expression, and underground culture. For nearly 30 years, it gave a voice to Canada’s creative outsiders. But in 2017, Hal published a short editorial questioning the new rules around “cultural appropriation,” and within hours, he was blacklisted by the literary establishment. Then came October 7th, 2023. When he defended Israel’s right to exist, he was labeled a “Zionist” and told to surrender his magazine to activists. Instead, he shut it down.   In this conversation, Hal reflects on founding Broken Pencil and the early zine scene that shaped him, the personal and professional fallout from his 2017 cancellation, and what it’s like being a Jewish writer in Canada after October 7th. We talk about the collapse of tolerance in the arts, the new moral orthodoxies gripping Canadian institutions, and what it costs to stay true to free expression in an age of conformity.   About Hal Niedzviecki Hal is the founder and former editor of Broken Pencil. He’s the author of multiple books, including The Lost Expert, and is currently writing his memoir for Cormorant Books. His Substack, Hal, I’m Special, offers deeper reflections on writing, culture, and identity, and he recently wrote a deep dive, long form essay describing his full story in the Australian publication, Quillette.   Hal’s Links   Substack   Cormorant Press   Quillette Essay     Bad Canadians Website and Zines   Follow us on X   Subscribe on Spotify   Subscribe on Apple    Subscribe on YouTube   Opening Song: Aria 51 by MicroBongo Soundsystem, used with permission.