Hard Times Or Great Expectations?
from ANGLES. Hosted by Simon Brady CFP® CETF®
Last week was a busy one with plenty of economic data to chew on and lots of soundbites from International Monetary Fund (IMF) officials and Federal Reserve presidents. It also marked the opening of the Q1 2023 earnings season. Monday started out mostly jittery and trendless as the stock market tried to digest the Jobs Report from the holiday Friday before. Interestingly, the laggards were stocks in the defensive sectors like Utilities and Consumer Defensive that had outperformed the previous week, as worries eased about the prospect of an economic “hard landing” (i.e. inflation is only finally killed by a nasty recession). The IMF said that the rampant inflation around the world of the past year or so, along with accompanying higher interest rates, will turn out to be just a blip on some charts. The recent banking turmoil (I think it’s generally agreed now that the term “banking crisis” is an overblown description of what happened and needs to be downgraded to “banking turmoil”) illustrates the concerns IMF economists have been voicing for a while as central bankers continually tighten monetary policy and raise interest rates. “Downside risks dominate and the fog around the world economic outlook has thickened,” wrote IMF Director of Research Pierre-Oliver Gourinchas, bringing to mind the writing style of Charles Dickens who was, of course, the author of both “Hard Times” and “Great Expectations” - which, when combined, seem to conveniently express the two ends of the spectrum of the economic outlook right now. The Consumer Price Index (CPI) measure of retail inflation came out on Wednesday and showed a rise of just 0.1% from February to March, lower than the expectation of 0.2% after the previous month’s 0.4% gain. Annualized inflation in the US is now running at 5.0%; below expectations, the lowest level since May 2021 and down from 5.5% the month before. Inflation might be cooling according to some metrics, but it isn't completely going away. Excluding volatile food and energy components, Core CPI actually accelerated a bit, ticking up 0.4% month-to-month and is up 5.6% year-on-year vs. 5.5% the previous month. Rises in the cost of housing and shelter was the largest contributor to the monthly increase. The good news piled up the next day when we saw the Producer Price Index (PPI) measure of wholesale inflation affecting manufacturers (which is kind of a leading indicator for retail inflation). PPI fell 0.5% from February to March after being unchanged the previous month. The biggest factor was a sharp decline in gasoline costs. The annualized reading was up just 2.7%, falling precipitously from 4.9% the month before. The fact is that many categories of goods have now returned to pre-pandemic levels of inflation and many commentators believe that is a good enough reason for the Fed to stop raising interest rates immediately. Futures markets are currently showing that probability as being 22% with a 78% chance of a 0.25% increase at the next meeting in early May (see FEDWATCH TOOL, below). This heightened expectation of a maximum of just one more interest rate increase was also fueled by a slate of speeches midweek from Federal Reserve officials. Minneapolis Federal Reserve President Neel Kashkari said that he foresees headline inflation falling to the “the mid 3’s” by the end of 2023 and move closer to the Fed’s target range of 2.0% by next year. New York Fed President John Williams spoke about how he believed that the recent failures of Silicon Valley and Signature Banks were “unique” and “unlikely to reflect the broader trends in the financial system.” That helped ease some of the lingering market angst about the health of the banking sector. The newly-released minutes from the Fed’s most recent policy-making meeting revealed that members anticipate a mild recession this year in the US partly because of the fallout from last month’s banking turmoil. They also projected that the unemployment rate will rise another full percentage point by the end of the year — an event that historically has only ever occurred during a recession. Friday’s much better-than-expected Q1 2023 earnings from some of the big box banks was swiftly overshadowed by the release of data that showed consumer spending falling twice as much as expected in March. Retail Sales declined by a full 1.0% last month, much more than the expected 0.5% decline, as consumers seem to be increasingly keeping their hands in their pockets. It’s yet another sign that it's probably only a matter of time before a recession of some kind fully engulfs the US economy and the stock market ended Friday on a downbeat note, although the headline indexes were a little higher for the week overall. The biggest question for markets is now not so much “will there be a recession?” , I think everyone now assumes that there will be - and pretty soon. It’s more about whether the recession is going to be an extended, deep and painful one (“Hard Times”) that results in sharp equity market losses and broader turmoil across financial markets or a shallow and relatively short-lived one (“Great Expectations”) that markets will be able to weather fairly well. The answer to that question still remains to be seen, but we are definitely getting closer to learning which it is. The rally in March and April in stocks and bonds has been driven by anticipation of a“Fed hike, pause, cut” narrative, not actual hard improvement. That doesn’t mean it’s wrong (these expectations could end up being entirely accurate), but it does leave markets vulnerable to disappointment and if that disappointment comes about (a delayed pause? No prospect of a cut this year?), a 5%-10% pullback in stock prices shouldn’t surprise anyone. Watch this space. OTHER NEWS .. Stamp-flation .. The price of postage stamps is poised to increase again in July for the second time in 2023 and the 17th rate change since 2000, under a new proposal by the US Postal Service (USPS). If approved by the Postal Regulatory Commission, this would be the shortest time between increases in history. Rates last went up just three months ago and before that, in July 2022. In contrast, between 1970 and 2000, rates only increased once on average every two to three years. The Postal Service said the proposed increases raise first class mail by approximately 5.4% to “offset the rise in inflation” and are needed “to address continued elevated inflation and prior years defective pricing model”. With the proposed rates, postage for a first class 1-ounce letter will go to 66 cents, up from 63 cents and 2x the 1999 rate of 33 cents. The Postal Service said it is also "seeking price adjustments for Special Services products including Certified Mail, Post Office Box rental fees, money order fees and the cost to purchase insurance when mailing an item". Much less swiping going on .. Office vacancy rates hit a record high in New York and rose nationwide as tenants cut back on space they don't need because so many employees are working from home. In New York City, the office vacancy rate rose to a record 16.1% in Q1 2023, representing more than 76 million square feet of empty office space, according to a report by commercial real estate firm, JLL. As office leases, which typically run 10 years or more, expire, companies are reassessing their space needs and not in a good way for the commercial real estate market in New York. That vacancy rate means about 84% of available space is theoretically being leased but that absolutely does not mean that it's all being used. New York's actual office occupancy rate is more like around 49%, according to Kastle Systems, which tracks card swipes through its security systems. Careful what you wish for .. If history is any guide the market may be overestimating the positive effects of interest rate cuts, if they happen. The previous occasions when the Fed has embarked on a meaningful rate-cutting cycle have tended to work best (i.e., resulted in very positive stoc… This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit simonbrady.substack.com
Embed this episode
No transcript yet.