“Hard-to-reverse decisions destroy option value” by Stefan_Schubert
from EA Forum Podcast (Curated & popular)
This post is co-authored with Ben Garfinkel. It is cross-posted from the CEA blog. A PDF version can be found here. Summary: Some strategic decisions available to the effective altruism movement may be difficult to reverse. One example is making the movement’s brand explicitly political. Another is growing large. Under high uncertainty, there is often reason to avoid or delay such hard-to-reverse decisions. Table of contents Introduction What is reversibility? How to choose Fundamental considerations Secondary considerations Where do all the social movements go? Introduction The importance of option value is widely appreciated within the effective altruism movement. In an uncertain world, keeping multiple paths open can be very valuable. One aspect of option value is reversibility. When we consider a change from the status quo to a new state of affairs, we risk losing option value if the decision is difficult to reverse. If we have a white cloth, we can dye it black at any time. However, once we have dyed it black, it would take much more work to make it white again. The effective altruism movement faces many similar strategic situations, where it is easier to leave the status quo than to get back. For instance:(1) The effective altruism movement is currently not strongly associated with any political party, or with any of the mainstream political ideologies. In that sense, the effective altruism brand is relatively apolitical. This could easily change, e.g., if the movement allied itself with a certain political party. However, once that step has been taken, it might be hard to go back to an apolitical brand. The effective altruism movement is currently quite small. The movement may try to grow big, but if it does, it will arguably be hard to reverse that decision. Shrinking the movement in a way which does not cause serious damage is presumably very difficult. The effective altruism movement has invested in acquiring a reputation for integrity, rigour, friendliness, and other kinds of prosocial behaviour. It may, however, decide that such a reputation is too costly to uphold, and that some level of dishonesty, lack of rigour, or unfriendliness is acceptable. Since it is easier to destroy a good reputation than to build one, it is plausibly hard to reverse such a decision.(2) What is reversibility? To understand the notion of reversibility, let us first look at the notion of option value. It can be defined as follows. Option value: The option value associated with a possible choice is the expected value of having this choice available. To use a standard example from the literature, it can be in your self-interest to support a tax for the maintenance of Sequoia National Park even if you are not sure that you will ever visit. The fact that you might some day choose to visit the park, and can expect the visit to be worthwhile if you do, gives this possible choice option value.(3) The concept of option value is frequently applied within the effective altruism movement. For example, [...] --- First published: March 17th, 2017 Source: https://forum.effectivealtruism.org/posts/eyDDjYrG3i3PRGxtc/hard-to-reverse-decisions-destroy-option-value --- Narrated by TYPE III AUDIO.
Embed this episode
No transcript yet.