Skip to content
Haunted Montana episode artwork

Aug 19, 2025 36 min

Haunted Montana

from Supernatural Hour Hosted by Brett Smith

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Haunted Montana

0:00 36:54
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

In the dead of night, as people sleep, that is when the spirits creep. As the bell tolls three dark things take power, we like to call it the supernatural hour. Hey, welcome to the supernatural hour. This is your host Raven.

This is Chad. This is Drake. And we have just a lot to talk about today, so I'm super excited. So first of all, we've got so much coming up.

Chad, do you want to talk about a little bit? Hey, we got some things coming up. We've got our insider Chingit Dig. That's going to be coming up at a secret location.

You can find out more about that. If you're not an insider, you can be coming out on Patreon. So we'd love to have you right up until the event. Go ahead and be coming in.

Also, we have a new investigation that's going to be at the stagecoach Inn at Camp Floyd and at Old District School. That's out in Fairfield. So we're excited about that event. It would be on Friday, August the 29th.

We're super excited. When we're out at Fairfield, we're actually going to have some new stuff that you haven't seen before. If you want to see what that's all about, grab your ticket, come out. We'd love to have you.

I think as a group, we've only investigated this venue one time. And it's pretty spooky. Right? Did you?

Were you able to come with us when we came? When we went the last time? Yeah. I thought so.

I thought so. Yeah, I think it'll be fun to go get that one again. I had to stay out of the general store. Yes, you did.

I remember that because there was something in there that wanted to wall keep pretty good. Yup. Alright, and Chad, who was this sponsored by? This is sponsored by Castle Photo Art.

So go to Castle for all of your photo art needs. He has great photography. We've got some new pictures coming up. And then we just want to give a little shout out to our patrons.

But just to get a big thank you to you guys, we really couldn't do what we do without you. And I still have a couple of boxes left for new signees. So if you've been thinking about it, I haven't quite wanted to pull the trigger yet, or if a friend that's listening that wants to now is a perfect time because there's not many of those boxes left to grab those. We are just going to jump right into our main topic.

First, we have a little bit of news, but I don't want to give that to you yet because you hold up some suspense. That's how it works, right? So stay tuned and we're going to tell you what that is a little bit later. So we are going to do one of our most haunted states again.

And this time we're going to do most haunted in Montana. If you've ever been to Montana, what's called the Big Sky date? A lot of abandoned areas, a lot of just big open areas. And some of these abandoned areas, if you've ever been to one, you know that they can carry a lot more than just wind memories.

Somewhere in Montana, especially, there's some gold rush fever, frontier justice, long winters. So you've got a lot of stories of restless that have rooted themselves into those towns and buildings. So as you go through in Montana, if you're from there or you're close or you're going to go there, they've got just decaying boom hounds frozen in time. They've got institutional complexes that just have all sorts of energy that you get from those.

They call it the treasure state. There are ghosts, there are just kind of a blend of tragedy, legend. In some cases, just things are a little bit inexplicable. So tonight we're going to talk about six locations.

Each one of them has a little bit of different flavor. We'll get into some frontier justice, some vigilante lore, mining town hauntings, some institutional torment, and just some curious tension between folklor and skepticism. So let's just jump right into this. The first one we're going to talk about is a ghost town in the Dillon area.

It's called the Bannick ghost town. This was founded in 1862 after a gold strike. Grasshopper Creek. I think that is a fantastic name for a creek.

I kind of want to go there, just to see it. Especially if it's actually shaped like a grasshopper. Is it really? You just want to look?

Let's look. You look, let me know when you find it. So Bannick briefly became the first capital of Montana territory. And as most boom counts are, the boom was rapid and its decline was equally fast.

As activity would move from the mining area. By the mid-20th century, it was for the most part abandoned and later they came in and preserved it as a state park, which I think is kind of cool. It had a really, really violent frontier past. We had a lot of vigilante hangings, most notably, a man named Henry Plummer and his alleged associates.

There were saloon brawls, drown deans, mob justice. So this is just going to be fertile ground for a ghost lore. That would be a negative one. Oh man.

Maybe they just had a lot of grasshoppers. Yeah, it was worth a look. So some of the sightings and stories that they have here, there's a story about a gal named Dorothy Dunn and she drowned. She's 16 years old, she drowned in 1916.

And a lot of people say that they see her apparition. She's dressed in a distinctive blue dress near the hotel need and what they call Dorothy's hold, which is, I'm assuming, where she drowned. Witnesses in the area have claimed cold spots. They've seen spectral figures and the feeling of being watched.

And they say that the feeling of being watched is especially strong around the old hotel in the courthouse. Henry Plummer, we talked about him. He was a vigilante hanging victim. So visitors and paranormal investigators that have gone there have claimed to feel oppressive energy near the sites that are tied to the village, vigil ante group.

They say that they have seen shadow figures, disembodied sounds, and the disembodied voices that they hear, they have interpreted as lingering unrest from the hanes and maybe not so much an intelligent hop and maybe more of a residual kind of a thing. And then just a lot of your general and English is very hard to dig in general anomalies, just your typical ghost thing, so cold spots, unexplained footsteps, voices. Some people have said that they've seen moving objects, especially by people that are on ghost doors. And then there are some independent investigators like if we were to just go up and investigate for fun, they have annual hot focused events, which I think is awesome.

And they've claimed to see some living things there as well. A rival hometown to Banach is Virginia City. It surged with gold discovering in the 1860s. Unlike some ghost towns that emptied Virginia City survived as a preserved historic town doubling as a tourist destination while carrying deep layers of lurk from gold rush.

Hey day. This is a Virginia city in Montana, not the Virginia city in Nevada, which we've been to. But I think that sounds like a great place to go. It's a bannack in Virginia City up into those gold rush gold towns.

Some of the sightings and things that are going on, there's Ellinghouse and other residences. There's known for a spectrum of ghosted presences. From benign to unsettling, local lore includes apparitions of passive happiness, unexplained noises, and feelings of being touched or followed in historic building. Kind of that creepy feeling being one.

There's a local legend of Virginia's ghost riding furiously towards town in a black skirt, her present, accompanied by screaming winds. Her backstory involves tumultuous personal life and dramatic romance, giving her vector of tragic and symptomatic quality. And then there's a fair weather in which was built in the eighties. This historic includes where people had suicides, personal tragedies, and shifting ownership, guests and staff report childlike apparition, gold spots, residual energy, suggestive of the town's gold rush hardships.

A lot of guests and paranormal enthusiasts drive shadow figures and voices, ghostly comforts, like a female spirit reporting to Sue that they're distressed. So there's a lot going on in a lot of activity here in Virginia City. So we've talked about two ghost towns, and I'm just wondering if you think about it. We did a podcast on Ghost Town's not.

It's been a while ago. And a ghost town, for those of you that don't know, is either a town that was there, and then it's gone. Ooh, fish, just ruins. Or it can be a town that was really, really bustling and was just seriously diminished.

So I think one of the examples it gave when we did that was Detroit, when it was at the height of car manufacturing. It was huge. It was booming. And when all of the jobs moved overseas, a lot of people left.

And so it's just as population is seriously depleted. It's difficult to think about. It's in Utah or helper and Eureka. Yes, absolutely.

Those two towns are both still there. They're just a portion of what they used to be. And a couple of years ago when we went to Piaotia, Nevada on an investigation with a lot of historic stuff, it had that historic opera house and the courthouse. We stayed was at the stagecoach Inn.

I think so. No, thanks. Stagecoach Inn. Where we're hunting this?

Yeah, it was a terrific place to ghost in. They had the old tombstone, the boot hill. Yeah, cemetery. So when Raven and I first went out there to explore and find out about it, we didn't realize we went down to Cedar City and got our lodging there.

And then we went out thinking that it was one of these abandoned ghost towns. And when we got there, it was, you could tell that it wasn't what it had been at one time, but it had some nice little shops and historic district, a good little restaurant. We wish we would stay there. And then we did book it when we came into the actual ghost location.

I've got a question that we can talk about for just a second. If you think of a living ghost town, such as Piaotia, where there's still people living there, still people working there with a lot of tourist activity, and then you think of ghost legends, do you think that human presence amplifies these hauntings, dispels these hauntings? How do you think? And you guys feel about that?

I think it adds to it. I think the energy of having people there helps provide or the spirits. I think, and again, this is just my personal opinion. I think spirits, if things just are settled and quiet, they may not be as active as when things change.

Kind of like when you do renovations in your home. Well, things start seeming to happen where it's different than when it's just at a steady state. I think the disruption increases perinol. What about you, Drake?

What's your opinion on that? Pretty much the same thing. I believe that it feeds off of it. It's got to have, they can't just have just stagnant energy to feed off of too.

Whether that be people passing through, people living there, just something for it to feed off of. Electrical lines, something that can get geothermal, water, different things, but there's usually an energy source of help. In my opinion. I think I agree.

When you look at the people, there might be the introverted ghosts that don't like it. Like, probably people doing. But I think in general, just the energy there, the extroverted ghosts, the spirits that want to talk, they want to be heard they want to be seen. I agree.

Okay, so let's move on. So the Old Montana State Prison, it's the Montana Territorial Prison. It operated from 1871 until 1979 when they had a newer facility and he replies it, we know because here in Utah, our prison just got replaced a few years ago. The old prison is in Deer Lodge and it housed some of the state's notorious inmates, considering it was the state prison, that makes sense.

It's a book of those times and now there's overcrowding, there's harsh conditions. In 1959, there's an infamous riot that was there and this is where inmates were able to get out and they held parts of the prison. It led to deaths, just very, very ugly, very nasty and it actually prompted the National Guard intervention to come in and take care of it. So as you can imagine, this would leave all sorts of psychological and physical scars and that even of itself is going to feed its haunted reputation and any spirits that are lingering there.

So some of the stories that we've heard from the Old Montana State Prison are investigators who describe communication via trigger objects. And when you trigger objects, sometimes they work, sometimes they don't, and it depends on the day, on the spirit, on the trigger object. But they have said that they get choice lighting up in response to questions, so they like to be there. They've heard disembodied footsteps in empty cell blocks, they've gotten conflicting messages from residents, spiritual residents, about whether they want visitors.

So probably this depends on who they're talking to. So locations of most of the activity when you go there is going to be in maximum security. If you think about it, that's where there's going to be probably the most violent criminals, so there's going to be a little darker energy there than maybe other places. In the chapel, in the general population cells, and what they call the death tower.

And those are the hot zones, which means sounds like probably the majority of the prison. But they get unexplained pressure changes, they've gotten EDPs, got an audio, and a lot of feelings of being watched. They say that there's a lot of residual energy from the night that was there in 1959. They're emergency sites, hostages, just a very ugly little moment in history.

And so they say because of that residual energy, they get a lot of stories of people who are in areas that their mood suddenly gets really oppressive, but it's sudden chills and apparitions. And the way this describes, they say apparitions, described as carrying institutional weight. I'm not entirely sure what that means. But I think just heavy apparitions that are just very heavy, very dark, probably whether it's an intelligent aunt or a residual aunt from that time period, it would be heavy regardless.

So this seems a lot like the Rawlings, Wyoming territory, as far as a lot of the activity. But we've been there a couple of times. We actually, I haven't for the Montana period, territorial, but you can coast in Dear Lodge. It's one of the most active haunted sites in the West of the West.

And some of the things that says makes it most haunted, it was built in the 1870s, we've said, fortress of sandstone that has seen over a century of violence and tragedy, paranormal investigators have reported full body apparition. Cell blocks, visit contact from unseen forces, clear EVP recordings, echoes of chairs, footsteps, embodied voices, and you can go and stay overnight if you want to with groups in haunted rooms of America, different ghost groups that, and so it is one of those sites which is great because they embrace their paranormal activity and make it available to people to go and visit. Before we move on to our next location, really quick, what do you guys think of how ethical do you think it is to do a commercial ghost hunt in an area where there's some real suffering like in this prison with this riot? I think it's ethical, and I think that experience and getting out there has done it for me being able to learn more about the paranormal experience that I don't see an ethical problem.

How about you, Jake? I think it depends on how much suffering there was in the main cause of it. If the suffering was done by the prisoners themselves, then only I had to have the call. But if it was prisoners where hurting visitors or the staff, then yeah, it's a little fun ethical, but it helps to learn what actually happened.

We've talked a little bit before. I was all excited to go, ghost hunt the mommy who said the feeling of no, leave us alone. I wanted to ghost hunt down on the catacombs and I got the impression no, just leave us alone. So for me, ghosts hunt at enough in different areas that their spirits really want to talk to you and their spirits really don't want to talk to you.

So for me, I think it depends on a lot of things. I think, listen to the spirits if they want to talk to you, do. If they don't, don't. If you're going there for the right reasons and you're being respectful, I think it's fine.

If you're respectful in their space, I think that's fine. So for me, yeah, for me, there's a couple of different factors, but I think in general, it's ethical. Would you do a tour at like the Rawlin Star Tour? What would be your feeling there?

Because I think this would be very similar. Yeah, I think it would be fine there. And especially where they actually provide tours. I don't think it's unethical because the territory of prison itself offers ghost tours from 8 p.m.

to 2 a.m. They do all those different. So to me, it's one of those missions of it would be it. It wouldn't be on it.

I agree. Now, next up we have the Copper King Mansion, which is in Butte. It was built in the 1880s for one of Montana's copper barons. The mansion is the lavish Victorian structure now operating as a bed and breakfast in a museum.

That's just, there's got to be stories that like, Lizzie Borden's that stuff happens that no one really wants to talk about. But as Optulants and Layers of Wealth's Death in Daily Life have created fertile ground for ghost lore, and some of the stories are there's cold spots and washable presences. Guests have reported sudden temperature changes at the sense of being watched and they feel that unseen hands are tidying or moving objects. There's apparitions of poltergeist-like activity, misty figures, especially in the basement, trunks opening on their own, doors locking and unlocking, and playful jokes from its chibi's spirits contrasts with the more subsided presence to simply enjoin the house.

Folklore claims that no nonsense owner, whether they're living or have passed on, keeps routing your spirits in check, adding a layer of personality to the haunting, some ghosts supposedly avoid certain caretakers. What about even the house itself keeping spirits in check? Ooh, ooh, I've never thought of that before. What are your thoughts on that?

We've written into stuff like that before that the land or the building itself has kept certain spirits in check or just out of the way to not do anything. Or other entities there keep things in check. Kind of like the skinwalker of the family tree where we've had some experiences with that. Yeah, or just like Drake was saying that sometimes the spirit is held to the area by the land or by the home.

Maybe they've got an attachment to the home for some reason whether they built it or it reminds them of the grandma's house or whatever. Yeah, that's an interesting thing to think about. What do you guys think about the spirits being put to work? Do they, do you think in a home like that, do they help preserve it or are they there more to haunt it?

I think it's maybe a little bit of both. Like maybe you have spirits that were staffed from the baron that was there, that are tied there because they were there for so long or it's because it's a bed and breakfast now that they think that, oh, because it's actually something to serve people, that they have to do that now. I would agree, probably a little bit of both. And as far as preservation, they maybe help protect it in some ways.

To the best of their ability, they can't do much except scare people away. The fact that they're there and staying there for whatever reason is holding them there, I think in a way that helps preserve memories and keeps the magical life. I think of a better way to say it. And then next up we have Helena, which has the last chance coach and the city itself.

So Helena's Gold Rush origins made it a boomtown that didn't die. It's contained civic importance layered public buildings, theaters, alleys and institutions over a history of vigilante justice, civic drama and personal tragedies. Locals and tour companies have embraced and curated its haunted reputation. Stories that we've got are the goals coach haunted pub trolley tour, hellbound ghost tours, created experience that leaves together tales of children's laughter in the readers alley, a minor's unresolved murder, a mischievous cat spirit of the governor's mansion, and hauntings at theaters and churches.

These tours frame the city as an active, spectral narrative, a cat that haunts the governor's mansion. I need to go see that. I'll see if it actually wants to be like a full body apparition. Okay, and I have to tell you, my little dog died, my little dog died in March.

And three of us have seen or felt him probably a total of a half a dozen times since then. He's so sweet. He comes and visits. So I'm all over the cat spirit.

I'm curious. If it belonged to someone or if it just kind of wandered in. And then local legends we have. Stories that include persistent sounds and historic theaters, apparitions and narrow alleys, and the way to vigilante justice lingering in locations tied to early law enforcement in front to her worn out.

Born to hear more alleys. So what the hell it was? I didn't know it was so exciting. Sorry if you live in Montana.

I don't know. I don't know if I live in Montana. It sounds like a city in Montana but this sounds cool. So you see this in a number of cities.

I know San Diego's got some ghost tours in different places in the south. And sounds like Helena's embraced their paranormal also. Yep, absolutely. There's the Garnet ghost town, high in the Garnet Mountains.

The once thriving gold mining town boomed around the turn of the 20th century, then dwindled after fires and depletion. Revived in preservation efforts in the 1970s, Garnet is claimed as one of the best preserved ghost towns physically but its haunted reputation is contested. haunted reputation versus skepticism. This is not an isolation.

Go ahead, what? I was just going to say, it's haunted reputation is contested. This sounds like some intrigue going on. Yeah.

Garnet's isolation, preserve decay, and atmospheric silence makes it a perfect setting for spooky stories and some visitors report peak activity in winter. The lead park ranger public states that he has never experienced genuine hauntings, framing a place that is more historical preservation than paranormal hotbed. Here's the contestation. Yes.

I'm not going to believe one guy over a whole bunch of people that have been there. Yep. And he thinks may have been going on all around him. He's just not sensitive, not looking for it.

Not, you've got people that just know it. Yeah. Just because you don't see something doesn't mean it's not there. And me, I'm not nearly as, I don't get the feels nearly as much as some of the other members on the team.

I've, I've seen a lot of things and I've been around it, especially things with K2 meters and those kinds of things, that kind of evidence. I'm not nearly as, I don't say, susceptible and is receptive to some of the paranormal feelings as like Raven is and Drake. And others in the group doesn't mean that I don't believe that they're feeling it just because I don't feel it the same way. And just opposite, just because it's an old ghost town doesn't mean that there's necessarily going to be ghosts there.

I believe that there would be, but just because I believe that there would be doesn't mean there's going to be. So, yeah, this would be an interesting place to go and investigate and to see if we were to get anything. Yeah, I've got something in the middle of my screen that I don't know what it is. Okay, some bloggers and past visitors, spectral activity seems to intensify in the dead of winter.

I don't want to be there in Montana in the dead of winter. I mean, that's way too cold. You can keep it wet. Not just that, there's no mountains, there's no trees, there's nothing to keep the wind out either.

Yeah, I'm good. I'll stay home. Winter is bad enough here and you talk. Yeah, things seem to intensify in the winter.

Quiet snow luck, isolation amplifies in the mind's tendency to feel presence. So that's where I push the paranormal out of that and be like, it's more of the mind-pleaning tricks on yourself. If it's winter time, you've got wind, you've got chills, you've got shadows that are different. Snow everywhere.

Yeah, and that's a long cold winter. An isolation. You may be much more susceptible to things too. Absolutely.

Alrighty, I think we covered Montana and you know, if you live there, if you're familiar with Montana, we know that there's a ton more places there. We know that there's a lot more haunted stuff. So we just don't have time to talk about everything. So, as we talked about, not every month, Hannah Haunting is after oceans in candlelight, some are residual based on greed, loss, justice, survival.

There's vigilante stuff. And then we go to just the stillness of Garnet. But if you think about it, the line between history and haunting really can kind of get blurry. So each location that we've talked about, any location you've ever gone to, offers a story that really boils down to history, human drama.

You know, spirits were once humans and they lived and they had lives like we did. Part of why we investigate is to try to find out their stories, try to make them remembered, get right to their emotional core, lost youth, justice gone awry, the weight of it being incarcerated in prison. Just in a way what we do as investigators kind of gives the supernatural heartbeat. So that's one reason why we do it.

Alrighty, so the Jungkor is brought to you by Otayo. And he was performing arts and cultural at center. We forgot to mention them before. Otayo has a new location.

They haven't opened yet, but Chad and I drove past it. They've got the words on the building and everything, so it's coming soon. And we're excited because it's really close to our house. So today in the Jungkor we are going to talk about a golf, a ghost who saw the dumber.

Have you guys heard of this one? Not that I'm aware of. Not this story, but... So it's called the Hammersmith Ghost of 1803.

So in the winter of 1803, there were in this little city in London. Well, London is not a little city. In a little borough of London called Hammersmith. They were terrified of a ghost and they said that this ghost haunted the churchyard.

So witnesses claimed it was the spirit of a man who had committed suicide and was assumed to wander. So one night there was a man named Francis Smith and he decided he was going to catch the ghost. And so he armed himself with a shotgun of all things and went out into the cemetery. So I don't know, I don't know what you think in 1803, but with my modern mind I'm thinking, what are you going to do?

Kill a dead person, kill a ghost with a shotgun. You guess it makes you feel better? I wonder if there was also a bunch of alcohol involved. Probably.

So he was wandering around the cemetery and that's kind of misty, it's kind of dark. And he saw, well, not too far in the distance, he saw a white figure moving. He shot it. Turns out it wasn't a ghost.

It was bricklayer named Thomas Millwood who just happened to be wearing white. Work close. So here's a test though. Soon after the shooting, there were some sightings of the real Hammersmith Ghost that continued.

So some of the locals swore that they saw a translucent man in white roaming the same churchyard. And rumors spread that this ghost was the actual murder of Victor Millwood, now haunting the streets to point towards the injustice of his death. Because he just walked through a churchyard. So this case caused such a stir that it changed British law about whether killing in a stake in belief, like thinking someone's a ghost, counts as a murder.

I guess what? It does? It does. I would not turn the hope that it would.

Right. So was there really a ghost? Or is this just an example of superstition gone tragically wrong? So who knows, but...

Maybe both. Exactly. So in any case, there was a second ghost created in the process. Alrighty.

We are super excited for a couple of things I told you at the beginning. There's a couple teasers at the end who are excited about our investigations coming up. We had a little meetup with some other paranormal groups at Salter recently. They had an investigation afterwards and Chad and I weren't able to stay because we had to get home to pack to go to Hawaii for a wedding.

But we are looking forward to investigating there sometime in the future. And we are also going to have a new podcast personality starting the next podcast. And we are not going to tell you who you will just have to tune in and find out. That's all that we are going to discuss tonight in our journey of this strange and unusual.

So, just a reminder, ghosts are only scary if you stop listening to their stories. So until next time, keep it creepy my friends. Hey, have a good night. We'll see you next time.

You've been listening to the Supernatural Hour at eventsperonormal.com. The Supernatural Hour is part of the Radio Ronin Network found at Radio Ronin.com. Copyrighted by Advanced Paranormal Services.

Paranormal-Spirits Mike Black Come get your Boos on with the crew from Paranormal-Spirits. Are you ready to get spooked and sloshed at the same time? Then grab a drink and join three hilarious friends, who also happen to be true believers in the paranormal, as they delve into the world of the supernatural in "Paranormal-Spirits"! Booze, Boos and My Favorite Boos! These three night stalkers have all had their own terrifying encounters with the unknown and are not afraid to share their stories. In fact, they've even conducted their own paranormal investigations and have captured some truly hair-raising evidence that they can't wait to share with you.But it's not all serious business – these three love to have a good time. Join them for a drink of the day while scare you with their own ghostly experiences. They'll share their creepy cocktails and horror movie reviews and shocking stories that will have you screaming...with laughter or fear!And if you're into keeping up with the latest in paranormal events, they've Explicit Unhappy Hour with Matt Bellassai Pineapple Street Studios From professional whiner and award-winning drunk Matt Bellassai comes Unhappy Hour, the podcast about everything we love to hate. Join Matt, his co-host Bari, and their special guests as they vent about all things political, personal and cultural. Because nothing brings people together like good complaining. Leave us a voicemail on our rant hotline at: (601) 600-RANT (7268). Support this pod and wear your unhappiness LOUD and PROUD by buying our merch at unhappyhourshop.com. Explicit

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Supernatural Hour?

This episode is 36 minutes long.

When was this Supernatural Hour episode published?

This episode was published on August 19, 2025.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Supernatural Hour episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.