Skip to content
He Confessed!! - Natalie Holloway Update episode artwork

May 18, 2024 27 min

He Confessed!! - Natalie Holloway Update

from Eye for an Eye Hosted by Eye for an Eye

BREAKING NEWS: A CONFESSION! Join your hosts Lisa, Matt, and our special guest Jon as we traverse the PA Turnpike and discuss further one of the most puzzling and mystifying Blind Eye cases we’ve ever covered. Our prime suspect in the case has come forward and made a startling confession, and we’re here to bring you some updates as well as our thoughts on Eye for an Eye! Blind Eye Episode 4 "Paradise Lost" talked about the case, our follow up tells the story of the 20 years of mystery that would follow… Special thanks to the producers of todays show, your support means the world! : Michael and Carolyn Y. Matt M Kimbrough's Coaching Elizabeth F. Kate R. *Please note all opinions in the show are our own and solely in regards to the specific case we are discussing in this episode* We made a one stop shop for all the Eye for an Eye links our listeners might want to check out whether its where to listen, our merch shop, all of our socials, our email, or ways to support the show, we’d love for you to visit the link below! https://msha.ke/eyeforeyepod/ Tired of Ads? Want to support our show? Please consider supporting Eye for an Eye with as little as $1 a month via patreon.com/eyeforeyepod Enjoy today's show? Don't forget to rate (those 5 stars are waiting to be clicked), review, subscribe and tell your friends! Want in on the discussion?Join us on our Facebook page or group, Instagram @eyeforeyepod, twitter @eyeforeyepod or shoot us an email at [email protected] and let us know your thoughts- does the punishment fit the crime? __ Cover Art Created by: Rachel Gregorino, [email protected] Music: GarageBand Mix made by Lisa

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

He Confessed!! - Natalie Holloway Update

0:00 27:59
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Due to the graphic nature of some of the topics we will be touching on listener discretion is advised. Hello everybody We are back back with a back back with a bang. We are on the Pennsylvania turn white car on this car That's not cool. I'm not cool.

I'm I've read a feeling nice to see a nice to meet you We're here with our bestie beau John and what I like don't know Joel's is off for the day for right now Joel's is off for the baby. Yeah, she's off for the baby If you guys didn't know Joel's welcome to a new member of their family. I miss bridge Shout out to Bernie B But we're here we just thought since we have a long drive out of us We would give y'all some updates along the lands of cases that we have seen new information come out about right because as you guys know We've done multiple blind eye cases where we don't know the outcome We always say those are our kind of coinciding cases with the eye for an eye where we have a verdict We have a guilty party or not guilty party Blind eye cases are where we're like we don't know what the fuck happened. Here's what we think okay We have a couple cases that in just recent history since we have done these episodes Which if you haven't listened go back check them out and check back with us make review subscribe another drill But check back listen to the first case and then tell us what you think because we're gonna give you guys updates as these things progress What's been in the news recently is what we want to talk to you guys about and kind of just come full circle in some of these cases Right least yeah the case we're gonna talk about right now and give you guys a little blurb update because it just broke Yes, cuz they literally just freakin happened yesterday Like one of those things where we couldn't have better is a blind eye case that has mystified American French aruban basically the international community of authorities for over two decades If you know the case I'm talking about it's the case of Natalie Holloway who went to a missing in aruba It was 2002 lease yeah, and we're turning this blind eye for a night, baby Yeah, baby We got honestly now we can look at it and say what do we think we can ask to the punishment for the crime Let's get this fucker sentence on our end.

Lisa won't tell him what happened. Yeah Yeah, yeah, yeah, I'm gonna read it cuz I don't want to get my facts messed up because Lord knows that's not good Just like the source that I know we're not copyrighting for you on nobody. I sure will I'm gonna go through Let's go from NBC. I'm pulling this up to read it, but we have been discussing this for a bit It's been on every social media platform that it's a big news big deal if your part of the true crap We are you already heard about this, but we want to talk based on it.

I lied. I'm not using and you see I'm gonna use CNN CNN sounds good this this happened yesterday and was actually updated today But almost two decades after Natalie Holloway vanish in aruba We've talked about him if you haven't listened to the episode We did on this go back in time I'll find you the episode number and listen to the case We did on our way if you want the ins and outs of the case met at a really good job covering all but basically two decades Later the man long suspected in Natalie Holloway's death has confessed you guys with can fast I don't know if everybody remembers, but I'm pretty sure in the original recording We did regarding this case we left off at Yarn Vandersloot, which is a fucking craziest name on the planet Let's just go there first for years thought his name was Jordan. Yeah, I'm pretty sure you called him that in episode When I first wrote the case I run this Jordan. I'm gonna literally change.

I think Joel's was like not his name It's your and But I think we touched on it in the first case correctly from that that we left off where he was extorting Natalie Holloway's mother Didn't he have her pay an exorbitant amount of my twenty five hundred two hundred fifty $50,000 He I know I know I'm awful with reading price good thing. I am porn this will never be a number I'll see yeah, no is two hundred fifty thousand what happened is urine basically it was found to have extorted Natalie Holloway's mother best They are very well-off-family Yeah, but he was accused of trying to sell information about the location of Holloway's remains now remember they don't know To this day we have not found her remains. We don't know where she is She just kind of vanished off the plate like the face of the earth I read shortly after this like the waters around Aruba are very deep and very heavy currents If you know where a ruby is it not the coast of my country's way on me What's crazy is that they've never found her body and of course biggest thing in true crime We know this families need closure victims deserve that closure We deserve to bring Natalie home and put her to rest with her family where they know where she is I cannot imagine having such a loss and not not knowing where she is is she still out there like without this sounds more But without a body without the physical being it's hard to put to sleep and maybe there is still hope You know she's alive somewhere But anyway, so he basically knew the hallways had a lot of money said to Beth Hey, which is also Matt's mom's name shout out Beth and my middle name shout out but he basically said look I know where your daughter is I'll give you all the details you better paint me and He did that and he never let her do a body He didn't he it just all fell flat and she's made the money and so he was tried with extorting her what the new stuff is that has just come out is Yeah, the developments in the case he pled guilty and federal court Wednesday to extorting and defrauding hallways family now he Did what's called a proffer which I've never actually heard that before did you you know what a proffer was I guess your criminal justice major And I don't know that was like contingent on like a little plea deal He kind of worked up. Yeah, he basically said if you give me less of a sentence be less harsh with me I'm gonna give you all the details about what I know in regards to describe because I have details And I know it's interesting that they trusted him enough after extorting her to give like be lenient and say okay Give us what you know, but I guess they kind of figured at this wait Um what do we have to lose right the man's already in jail for his previous crimes of killing?

You know what exactly would we lose please thousands? If you want to tell them what can he say what he sends was the original because he was also of you guys remember He was convicted of murdering a woman in Peru shortly after he was in Aruba. He went to Peru Yeah, it's five years later. It was convicted one themselves.

This guy's an overall run Fucking psychotic to me about that. He only got 20 years on the federal charges Wait, just getting that was this new one just ignore that part. Um, he got a 28 year prison sentence, but that's still ridiculous That does love us. Yeah, so van They run concurrently already in jail in Peru which I wonder what their jails are like on 28 years sentence for this first murder Then he admitted to he's doing this proper thing right where he is saying Can you give me less time for the charges of extortion if I give you more information that I have about the details of Natalie's Disappearance and and what we will find out now is murder and I think at this point with all the years that have gone by since this crime occurred It is and has been widely associated that unfortunately has never been a question We just don't know where she is or what happened to her because her body has never been sound and this motherfucker has given the run around For years and years and years and years and it's just been the cat and mouse playing with this family Basically he agreed to this proper and he admitted in court and he's now 36 by the way She and Natalie was 18 when this all happens I'm wondering if he was you know around her age will have to look up what is ages he admitting admitted to killing Natalie Holloway with a cinder block on a Reuben Beach after she rejected his sexual advances and this is according to a Transcripts of an interview with his attorney which I'm going to read for you This is pretty awful and pretty detailed.

I I do apologize in advance I just yeah a big trigger warning here. This is awful. I could go on about this forever But this is a Vanderstoot's attorney Kevin Butler interviewing Vanderstoot during the portion of his recorded interview with this proper agreement Jordan Vanderstoot said she asked to go back to her hotel But I was trying to get dropped off a little bit further away from her hotel So we could walk back to her hotel and I make it a chance to be with her and he said that's what I was hoping for His attorney said okay, what happened? She said yeah Deepak drops me off in another place a little right of the of the Mary Marillott Hotel known as the Fisherman's Hut's this place is not So far from you know the next hotel is the Marriott and the next hotel after that is another Marriott Which is a time share and then it's the holiday and and we walked along the beach and then his attorney says Do you teepak and satish get out what happens?

There were two bodies that were brothers they were with Which we knew that was At one point they were questioned and taken in custody his dad was questioned and taken in custody and your and was questioned and taken in Cost of you for all like all these people they didn't know yeah might have been involved I'm reading a transcript. It's not my arms in there This is what this is how he himself is saying this any us and um do here is literally word for word from this transcript after the attorney asks Jordan Vanderstoot what happens next? He says no deepak and satish leave they leave and they go back to their hotel I assume they go back to their home I'm gonna cut out some of these arms because this motherfuckers doesn't a lot they get in their car and they leave I'm actually with I'm actually with Natalie walking along the beach I find a space before we get before we get to the Mary Hot Marriott Hotel where I lay her down We lay down together in the sand and we start kissing each other I start I get her to kiss me again and we start kissing each other I start feeling her up again and she tells me no she tells me she doesn't want me to to feel her up I insist I keep feeling her up either way and she needs me she ends up needing me in the crotch When she yeah when she needs me in the crotch I get up on the beach and I kick her extremely hard in the face She's laying down unconscious possibly even dead but definitely unconscious. I see right next to her There's a cinder block laying on the beach and the attorney says when you say cinder block I'm looking at the walls of this on place is it like those and he said exactly the same cinder blocks It's like the cinder blocks that are at the like the Mary out I guess It's the exact same cinder box.

I see a huge cinder block laying on the beach I take this and yeah, I smash her head in with it completely. Yeah, her face is basically, you know collapses in even though It's dark. I can see her faces collapsed in afterwards. I don't know what you know.

I'm scared I'm scared. I don't know what to do and I decide to take her to put her in the ocean I grab her I have pull half walk with her into the ocean I push her off I walk up to about my knees into the ocean and I push her off into into the sea And yeah, then I get out and I walk home So that was his admission what he says happened between him and Natalie Holloway at the beach that night He said essentially she she tried to hook up with her She said no rejected his advances by the kicking him away Shinde kicking him in the nuts and when he got up from that he kicked her really hard in the face He said he wasn't sure if she was unconscious or if she had passed away from that kick and then he found a cinder block and smashed her face in And then dragged her out into the ocean in a ruba knee deep in the water and pushed her body out to the sea just saying Unimaginably awful way good. It's so unbelievably disturbing and disgusting And just awful awful and like we were talking about earlier in 2012 and Alabama judge did sign the order declaring her legally dead And she wasn't found but it's just oh, Holloway was killed in 2005 and Florida's was killed in 2010 So she's oh five anyways, so the newest sentencing for extortion mind you he cannot legally be tried again for her murder because aruba Unfortunately doesn't have a statue's of limitations law, right? There's no statute of limitations on matter in the United States If you kill somebody you can be prosecuted for it and every given time I think my gun It's interesting moving in law prohibits a prison sentence from exceeding a total of 35 years and less given a life sentence Right now his sentence He will not get out of jail until honor about June 10th 2045 which is 35 years after his original arrest in for real However Peruvian officials did allow his temporary release to the US for this extortion and wire fraud charge Wednesdays plea agreement, which is what brings us to now This was this past Wednesday says his he was sentenced to an additional 20 years of a US federal sentence and it's going to be served Concurantly my car concurrently with this sentence in for real it appears unlikely Vanderstool will return to the US to serve the prison time Let's talk about it What do we think about this he was oh and another little little ditty of information in 2021 Vanderstool was convicted of trafficking cocaine into his prison and was sentenced to an additional 18 years in Peru He has 38 years in Peru or no, what's 28 time plus 18 46 years in Peru and then he's talked to him on an additional 20 years for the US federal Charges basically that mother fucker.

I did not it is why we support us at 66 years. Yes. We went up 66 years likely said this happened He was what 21 I think when he left happen out fine. He's 36 He's currently 36.

Yeah, I was like Yeah, but please we talked about the original And we usually do this when we do a blind on what do we think happened? We all agreed this mother fucker if he didn't do it himself had something to do with it Yep, we all agreed Joel then lease all I think and I think John would also stay delayed. We all died of agreed No, this was the obvious suspect, right? Like this was the guy Okay, it's who she was last season with he killed a woman five years later There was already reports of some suspicious activity going on between them and he's a piece of shit, right?

Like we can kind of see that now But it's crazy that after all these years to me and we overuse that we're crazy But after all these years this guy is just now deciding to come out and give her fairly some closure give her family some peace of mind She is dead. This is what happened because honestly they searched high-low French authorities US authorities her family or schoolmates Aruba authorities for months years Search for her body. They dug up fucking such and such In 2005 and they only declared relief right wow that means all of that time They were falling out whole that she would be somewhere alive. It's it's just so said What do you think about this new sentence?

I mean I am one of those firm believers of guys like him and you guys know what I'm gonna say Hey, if you listen to our podcast before take this mother out motherfucker out back put a bullet in his brain Dick bullet out cleaning off and using on the next sick fucker than each This is one of those guys. This is one of those guys like why are we feeding him? Why is he breathing my oxygen fuck him? He deserves to die.

He obviously does not give him for the life of other people Why do we give him that the opportunity to kill again the chance to breathe free air? Not that he ever will more than likely what he's gonna get out when it is like late 70s early 80s I'm like that's a good place. I won't be probably never getting out of jail. Let's be real I don't know what I've never been to Peru, but I'm assuming jail in any country that nice well We know it's actually nice and and how did that take place?

Thailand is that real? Yes, yeah, she like then funny snack. Yes. What's her name?

When we spent was there's a route rate of sound I remember where she was fucking Dutch people there They're awesome, but now she never hers was like she had a whole YouTube channel when she was a prison. It was like a whole fuck That's true. Yeah, no, you're a youtuber in prison. Well, we also heard the Canadian channels like that But nothing like a crunchable visit with his mother.

Yeah fucking weird But nothing you can't seem that bad to be honest. Okay, but I know John. What are you thinking? What are your thoughts?

I mean? You know, I mean we now we know what he says happened. So now we have the facts, right? What was just speculation?

We really did not know what happened to her. We had no information at all We just see that this motherfucker had killed someone later. But now we know he smashed her face Yeah, I'm with Matt. This guy's he has a history of just being piece of garbage And I mean he's small co-k while after killing all these people like he clearly doesn't care So why why is there funds being spent on his well-being being preserved?

It's like literally boil it down to three words fuck this You're saying you don't believe an eye friend. I was Matt you think he should be on like death row Yes, this is one of those cases where I believe that his sentence will death is adequate I guess but do I believe I for an eye was bad? No, because I would have shot this motherfucker if I was given the chance That brings up. What is the what are the definitions for death?

Well, that's the thing I go on It's by the place, right? Yeah, it's every what car to every country Like this dude literally smashed a person's face in with a Cinderella right? Well, you can't like you can't see outside for 50 years, but no we're just gonna do some you know Honestly, I like I for an eye maybe part yet exactly right? We talk about I for like part of me wishes is to get his face smashed in with a cinder block Like I do I do I'd agree with that honestly I mean it's violent and awful but like you're violent and you're awful and you did it again clearly didn't learn from your your You didn't feel bad You didn't see you just became more of a monster And you know what I don't love and I think should also be part of a sentence of just kind of ridiculous this cat and mouse game He played with her family.

Oh, yeah Storted that for a quarter million dollars a lot of you to supposedly be able to give that information and then waited another what a latin You just actually get away. Hey all that stuff just going. Yeah, fuck this guy. It's just yeah It's awful.

I think it's adequate I do I think like if we look at it He's not getting out of jail until he's crusty and Graham probably won't even know his name probably never for money I mean like it was a serious thing You know like go for like pedophiles and shit and mates kind of take care of it Some like that all happen. I wouldn't shock me guys like him You know that's not bro file people they get put in segregated populations for that reason because they're like We know that somebody's gonna fuck with them. What happened to Jeffrey doppin? Yeah, fuck around with the wrong dude got his face Not but maybe that's what this guy needs Jordan.

You're in you fucking piece of shit. Whatever your name is. Yeah It's just I just find the timing so interesting like why now why 20 some years later why what is what's it to you? That's a good question like that somebody put him up to it.

Yeah, they're a bigger web about to be unraveled Oh my goodness John. He's like I'm just a frontman. I'm just what I'm told We don't understand because okay, so the extortion case happened right obviously was charged for it He didn't give them the information then and then transport now now all of a sudden He's tried for this and decides okay. I will actually give you the information like what is this motherfucker doing?

What are you looking at? They're just these like big ass military lanes just driving driving. Yeah, they play the drive Oh, I'm wearing this too big Like right out of college there's a 130 like transport How do you know that because I think them with all Mac? Which what's called you?

I've never played all day. I speak it for big panting pants. Yeah, so what were you talking about? I for nine.

I agree. We're glad he's gonna be rotting and Joe. I'm glad her family finally has closure the world has closure now Let's do some shit for John Benet. That's what I'm saying.

Hey, but man, if somebody come forwards and something it was peace But no, I wish we haven't had her yet It's just so it's just the longest yeah The longest case on earth so much So much John, let's go on for that. That would be the case Yes, yes, but thank you guys for catching up with us Sorry if the audio is a little wonky this is just some cell phone recording We just wanted to shout it since it's so new and we have a lot of updates for you guys and we figured we'll throw them out and before Do we want to release these part of season four? These are the parties before you're listening welcome season for you. I'm gonna see you some more We're gonna work, you know, we're working on it.

We're working on again. Our jellies. What again? What free W guys are for season?

We had 20,000 listeners this year Downloads thank you guys. We know you are entire existence of this. Yeah, we know sometimes we drop the ball a little bit But we're picking that shit back up and dribbling it away again, you know three pointer running for a touchdown Sports I want to know what you guys think do you think your advantage that you just disappear into the thing like he just keeps making Himself relevant again, and I hate that like I'm out the news. Let's be done with this mother fucker Yeah, do you think that's part of it?

Yeah? I definitely do I think he likes the attention that he gets it Why what the fuck else is he doing? He can't smuggle co-compass ass anymore. He's probably got something he needs to do He's like, you know what I'll put myself back in the media Yeah, well you heard it here first your advantage suit is indeed a van der sloot and talk any guy that thinks that they have the right to Women's body.

Yeah, she's fucking no men do better That's the whole resolution for this out of all of this men do better if a woman rejects your advances don't be a bitch No means no you pieces of absolute shit shit. All right on that note We love you. Let us know what you guys think and rock and roll When it comes to playtime my dog bingo goes all in so he needs high quality ingredients that can do more That's why I feed on blue buffalo life protection formula made with real meat wholesome grains fruits and veggies and all the vitamins He needs for us choosing blue means choosing a lifetime of zoomies long walks and for any of belly rubs Good boy. Love them like family feed them like family learn more at blue buffalo.ca

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Eye for an Eye?

This episode is 27 minutes long.

When was this Eye for an Eye episode published?

This episode was published on May 18, 2024.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Eye for an Eye episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.