Hello everyone, welcome to Take Aurelie. My name is Jamie, one of the teaching fellows in emergency medicine. Remember you can find me on Twitter at McDreamy. This is a Take Aurelie special. We've got a couple of special guests here. Hi, it's Colin Gilhooling, one of the paediatric emergency medicine registrars here in Nottingham. Hi, my name's Shana. I am a paediatric registrar, but I am currently out of programme working as a clinical oncology education centre at the Children's Research Centre, which is basically the University of Nottingham. And do you have a choice to handle, Shana? I don't.
Colin, still no Twitter handle. Still no Twitter handle, I'm afraid, James. Oh, that's a shame. And so these special guests have gathered here today to discuss HeadSmart, a charity looking at the early diagnosis of brain tumours. Sian, would you be able to just tell us a bit about how HeadSmart came about? So HeadSmart essentially is a national awareness campaign. It addresses the signs and symptoms of brain tumours in children, and it's both a public and a professional awareness campaign. So it was launched in 2011, and really it was because the oncologist here at Queen's Medical Centre...
were seeing children who had been diagnosed with brain tumours and their parents. And as families were coming in, they were describing long delays in getting to the diagnosis, mainly because most of these symptoms are non-specific. And looking at literature, they found that actually a study that they did showed that in the UK, it was taken on average three and a half months from first symptom to diagnosis, whereas published literature in places like Israel was taken five weeks. So clearly there was something that needed to be done to address it. And the team got on and developed a guideline, which they then amplified using this awareness campaign.
And was it found then that the delay was both in the recognition then of the symptoms, but then also with, so from the parents' point of view, but then also with clinicians not having clear guidelines? Yeah, so the terms that we use are total diagnostic interval, which is the time from the first symptom to diagnosis, and then you've got the patient interval, which is from when they have their first symptom to when they go and see the doctor, and then you've got your system interval, which is when you've already seen the doctor to your diagnosis, or the first book called to diagnosis. So there were delays across the board, really, and so it was trying to address that public point of view, as well as educating healthcare professionals to get a quick MRI for those children that need it. And Colin, in the emergency department, is this something that you've encountered? Is this querying a paediatric brain tumor? I think all of us, all of the time when we're working in the emergency department, are always scared of what we might miss. Especially when people present with common symptoms. So things like headache, maybe lethargy can be quite vague, not quite sure, not sure how long they've been going on for, how significant they are. And so I think from that point of view, I've certainly seen lots of children with headache in the emergency department. And just on the odds, if I think of every child I've seen with a headache...
some of those children will have a brain tumour because that's the odds so having a way of being able to not just make a decision based on my bias but actually something based on good research good systematic reviews that have been done as part of head smart allows me to have a stratified approach but as well as that it also allows me to be able to give information to parents in order that we can tell them about the worrying signs and symptoms that may develop so that they can be safely netted to make sure they come back and it also means that all of us are doing the same thing all of the time which obviously reduces the chances of error and risk So, Ms. Sharno, brain tumours in children is a rare occurrence. Do you have any numbers? Yes. So, we have 10 children per week diagnosed in the UK with brain tumour. And actually, about 50% of those are diagnosed in the emergency department. Oh, wow. So, that's five children a week that are being diagnosed in our emergency department. And, you know, you have those who are coming in with your raised intracranial pressure, your focal neurological signs, who are...
very quick to be scanned within the emergency department because it's clear there's something neurological going on. They may have your Cushing's Triad, but actually at that point it is almost too late. That is the end stage where they've got such raised intracranial pressure that it is causing problems. And actually the amount of brain injury leading up to that point can sometimes not be reversible. So visual impairment, even if the brain tumour is benign, when they take it out they may still have visual impairment and long-term disability. So our aim is really to pick up these symptoms earlier and think about those children that attend the emergency department with these very symptoms like, like Connie just mentioned, a headache, nausea and vomiting, visual signs.
head circumference, making sure we are measuring head circumference in children under two, so that we can safety net these children and ensure they get appropriate review, whether it's by the GP or in rapid access clinics or op clinics, so that they're diagnosed as early as possible. So, I mean, the guidelines for adults look very much at the red flag, so a new headache in an older person, focal neurology, as you talked about, signs of raising cranial pressure as well. So obviously, patients, adults can be much better at communicating what they're feeling, certainly. But you've given a very nice handout here, sort of breaking down the different symptoms based on the different ages of the patient. So shall we just talk about that for a little bit? So babies under five years, Colin, what are we looking at there? So I think for those children, persistent or recurrent vomiting, that's obviously, again, a very vague symptom because how many children under the age of five present with vomiting whenever they're unwell with any reason? I think the key things there are to point out that it's persistent.
Often it will be without the presence of any other illness. So the presence of persistent vomiting with no other symptoms would be unusual. I think other problems would be looking at the development of the child. Out with HeadSmart, the loss of a skill for any child is always pathological. So children do not learn to do something and then forget how to do it. If they do, they have a problem. Now that doesn't matter about HeadSmart, that's for any condition. They need their head scanning. So if a child can walk and can no longer walk, there's a problem. And so that would be an interesting one. And then as well as that, personality and behaviour will change.
that parents will pick up is a good one and another obvious one is probably seizures are fitting I think obviously some of those children may just have epilepsy but if it's particularly a focal seizure or no fever associated with the illness then that's a more worrying condition and in a small baby you've got to think about the head circumference as well So there are obviously centile charts for children that are produced by various people. So you can find them on the RCPC website, you can find them on the WHO website, the World Health Organization website, which allow you to have a look at what's normal. And it's changes in head circumference. So a rapidly expanding head crossing the centiles would be what's worrying in those under fights. And so the idea is you're looking, Shana, for two or more of those features and then you need urgent referral. Yes. So the guideline suggests that if you have two or more, you'll require an MRI scan, an urgent MRI scan. Now, there are some conditions where just having one...
So if you had, like we said, regression in motor skills, if you've lost a motor skill, if you've got a facial motor weakness that is not a Bell's palsy, if you've got swallowing difficulties that have no local cause, or any focal neurological signs, you would expect to have an MRI scan more. But yes, in general, I've got two or more symptoms and that's why the symptom card that we've got, which you can find on the Headsmart website, which is www.headsmart.org.uk, comes in really handy because it's a really quick checklist for you to, if you're seeing a child with a headache, for example, just asking all the other symptoms that are listed, which are there's only seven or eight for each age group. You're quickly then identifying whether there are important negatives or indeed positives that require further action.
And it seems looking at this handout, there's much the same symptoms for the children who are 5 to 11, and I suppose by that point their personality is more fully developed, they can obviously verbalise better, so you may get more history from them as opposed to the parents, and it might make it a bit easier in theory. Yes, yeah, and this is where diagnosis of brain tumours is so difficult, is that they vary on the age of their presentation, so children under 5 will rarely compare to a headache, you know, babies in particular, because their sutures are not fused, their fontanelles are open, they really accommodate to their raised intranial pressure, so their head will just get slowly bigger, and they may not have many symptoms. other than that. Whereas in children, you will find that, like you say, in the 5 to 11 year olds, they might be able to tell you that they've got a headache or that their eyes are blurry or they can't see something quite properly. And then in your teens, you've obviously got things like delayed or rested puberty, which you would have in your younger children. And so the nature of the headache, Holly, what sort of features are we looking for in that headache? If a child, say, early teens, who can give good history, what sort of red flags are you looking for in that headache to point towards a brain tumor as opposed to, say, migraine or something else?
Yeah, so I think having an idea of the diagnostic criteria for things like migraine can be quite useful. It's not probably something we can talk about too much here, but there is a paediatric classification of headaches for migraine. The other thing is to remember just because someone has migraine doesn't mean they can't get a brain tumour. So a change in their normal headache would be one, and I think that's something that's true for adults as well. Yes, it is. And I think persistence of the headache is another one. It's unusual for children to have persistent headache, and I think it's lasting longer than four weeks. Yes. So a headache for longer than four weeks would be unusual. Regardless of how it's described, if it's longer than four weeks. Yeah.
And then children often are very poor at localising pain. So if they're very specific about where that pain is, that would be unusual. And so generally children will just say it's all over the front or it's all over my head. They rarely will tell you that it's one specific area. So I think that would be something that would worry me as well.
And is it similar to adults where it's worse in the morning about headaches, that's also true? Yeah, absolutely. So all the same things that go along with raised intracranial pressure, so worse in the morning and better when you can stand up would absolutely hold true for a child as much as an adult. Waking you from sleep, so that's the best one. And in particular in children, any child under the age of four who's complaining about an assisted headache, it's not common and it's not usual, so there's nothing wrong. So usually those children straight away, and if they have no other symptoms, would want a head scan.
And so, and you mentioned there was delayed puberty, so anybody coming in with query delayed puberty, brain chambers are considered as part of that whole work, even if they're maybe seen by an endocrinologist rather than yourself, an oncologist. Yeah, so in terms of the enterprise symptoms, it's probably not as common to be seen within the emergency department, more GPs, but we've worked together with the paediatric endocrinologist here to come up with that part of the guideline. So any child with a combination of growth failure, delayed or rest of puberty, and polyuria or polydipsy, which would be indicative of diabetes insipidus, require early specialist assessment. So whether that's by an endocrinologist or by a general pediatrician, then either or.
and then those children who have got growth or endocrine symptoms with one or more other symptoms, like if they've got two symptoms, they would require an MRI scan. And as part of the HeadSmart guidance, we've come up with common pitfalls where we've seen children who've had very, very long delays. And so one of those is failing to consider a central cause for those children who have got weight loss and vomiting. So I noticed looking then at the guidelines it mentions, about abnormal eye movements or suspected loss of vision. I find that difficult enough in adults. Sometimes I imagine in little children it could be nigh on impossible. I imagine that's a common pitfall. Yes, yes. So all children who come in with a headache or any of the symptoms listed on this card should have a full visual assessment as part of that so that you can rule out any other symptoms. So the visual assessment requires visual acuity, eye movements, pupil responses, optic disc appearance and visual fields in those over five years old. Now that can be really difficult to do, especially in the emergency department when it's hard enough.
to find a quiet space, let alone a dark space, to be able to look at the back of their eyes. Let alone a Fandoska be something. So I think in this instance, the important thing is, if all of us, or many of us find it very difficult to look back at child's eyes, if you can't see anything or you're not sure about what you see, you just always get someone else to do it. So either whether it's referring to eye casualty or whether it's a child that's coming with headaches that has not quite got up to the four-week mark, it's about two weeks, you're not quite sure, but you say, actually, on your way home, can you please get your child looked at the opticians so they can have a full visual assessment? And just ensuring that that is something that will take place and has been arranged is probably the key point. You're nodding along there, Colin. Something you agree with then? Absolutely. I think we're very lucky here in a large university teaching hospital that we've got a very large eye casualty that can provide us with a good service. So it's something that we're very lucky that we're able to do. I think what Shana raises is a good point is that actually there are opticians out there and having your child's vision checked regularly is probably something that should be done anyway and they will be happy to do it. So I think there's always ways around these things. So don't think, oh, I don't have an eye casualty that can see small children. Opticians can.
How confident are you with examining young children's eyes? I think it's very hard in those younger than the teenage years. I think over fives are probably a little bit easier than under fives, obviously. And part of that is that you can have a logical conversation with them and explain to them exactly what's going to happen. But it's hard. It is challenging. And I think in terms of it, there's two choices when something's difficult. You can either do it a lot and try and get better at it, or you can not do it. And I'd encourage everyone to do it a lot so they get better at it. And it's always a situation where, even if you're not sure of your findings, you can send them to someone.
and then they can tell you what they are and you can correlate what you thought you saw with what's actually there and actually maybe get better at it. And I suppose there's the idea that you have a lot of insight into what you're good at and if you feel that I can't see anything but, there's a caveat, I'm an emergency medic physician, I'm not an ophthalmologist. Correct. Tell mum and dad that caveat, safety net them. And like you said, either optician or ICADS, make sure somebody who is much more specialised can do that for you. Correlate that. Excellent. I suppose, Charlotte, there must be children whose siblings may have had brain tumours or maybe something in the family. Do you see that family history element to this as well? Yes, so family history is really, really important. And actually...
As Colin mentioned earlier, this guideline is based on a systematic review and meta-analysis. It is evidence-based, it's been accredited by NICE. So it brings together a lot of high-quality information, and we have found that there are really common predisposing factors that need to be asked about, and things that actually surprised me when I started doing this work. So things like if there's a personal family history of a brain tumour, sarcoma, leukaemia, or early-onset breast cancer, that gives you a risk factor for developing a brain tumour in the family. Things like neurofibromatosis in the family, tuberous sclerosis in the family, and other familial genetics in the family. So just asking me for that.
if there are any other genetic syndromes that run in the family and now these children would all have a lower threshold for scanning so if they had come in with one symptom and they've got a personal history of early onset breast cancer in the family they would actually require an MRI scan which when I first started was actually quite surprising to me because it's not questions that you would normally ask I wouldn't normally ask if anyone had a family history of sarcoma but actually this is where the guideline really is helpful and there's this what we're looking at is the quick reference poster which is also on the website which is easy to print out and has all the information that you need on an A3 sheet. Excellent. And so you mentioned, so if we're in the emergency department, if we're the GP and we're seeing this patient, you mentioned MRI, so that's an urgent referral within four weeks, is that right? So those children with high risk need an urgent MRI. And generally, I mean, I know how we work here, if you were, say, the GP, you would pick up the phone.
You pick up the phone, you speak to the paediatrician on call, and you would explain to them the symptoms and the story, and they would assess whether they would like to see them today or whether they would like to see them in a rapid access clinic, which is a two-week wait. So they will assess based on history. If you're in the emergency department, you would just pick up the phone to the paediatric registrar and explain the situation. And actually, if you can quote the HeadSmart guidance, you can say, as per, I've looked at the HeadSmart guidance, this child has got nausea and vomiting and blurred vision for more than two weeks, more than three weeks. So if they need a scan, it's really easy to accept that patient.
The really important thing in the emergency department is the safety netting. So these children that come in that have had one week of this, you need to come up with a plan of how that child is going to be reassessed. And on the website, there is a section for health professionals which has a decision support tool. So it allows you to reassure, review or refer your patient. So you go on to that and it's got three different sections where you will read those sections for headache, for example, and it will say headache for more than four weeks with...
associated symptoms scan or headache for more than four weeks with no other symptoms because there's a headache in isolation where there hasn't been a progression of other symptoms because with brain genus you can imagine as it's growing you're going to get more and more symptoms coming along so that review process is really important because every time you review them you ask them the questions on the checklist and you find out whether there have been more symptoms developing in that time and so it's whether you ask them to go and book an appointment with their gp since they've had one week of symptoms can you go and see your gp next week yeah to review all these symptoms and you can say to the parents they need to ask these questions or you might want to refer them So there's two ways of doing it, depending on how.
And Colin, is there any advice you have when raising the subject of potential brain tumor with some parents, they've not thought about it, they've no family history, they've brought in their child with a headache, when you've detected some visual problems as well, how do you go about bringing up the potential diagnosis of brain tumor? So I think any time you're dealing with something that is potentially quite a severe or a devastating potential diagnosis, we get just as scared and sometimes more scared than the parents do or the family do or the individual does. And so I think it's important from that point of view to understand that actually we need to... to put our fears to one side and remember that we have a duty of candor to all of our patients and be honest with them and upfront. And actually getting this out early in the conversation and making it unequivocal is probably more important because then that allows you to have the rest of the conversation where you're explaining things properly. If you start off trying to...
pussyfoot around the issue and spend half your time doing that and don't actually get to them, you can confuse the parents. And so I think it's important to be upfront and honest and say, you brought them here because they're worried. Parents bring their child to the emergency department with symptoms like that, they're worried about something. That is why 50% of brain tumors are diagnosed in the emergency department. Because they brought them there because they're worried. So we might not think they're worried, but they clearly are. So I think that's important to remember. So be honest.
tell them what you're thinking early, and then explain it carefully. And get help from headsmart.org.uk. If you're not sure, if you don't think you've got much knowledge about this, there's an education package for professionals on the website. So that website's headsmart.org.uk, where you can go and improve your knowledge. And if you've got a good knowledge and you're confident in what you're saying, that confidence comes across. You can reassure the parents if that's what you should be doing, but you can certainly give them a good explanation. I think honesty and being upfront is key to this situation. And saying the words brain tumour and not using vague euphemisms? Yes, absolutely. Absolutely.
And I find that sometimes just asking them. So you've come in to what you wanted to do. Yeah, they may say it themselves. And they will say. They've read it in the newspaper. They've seen those children that come up in the news all the time. And they will usually say, I'm worried about bone tumor. And you can say, that's one of the things that we are going to rule out.
So Colin preempted me a little bit. I was going to say the website, so that website once again is headsmart.org.uk. There is also a free phone 0808 800 0004 and there's email support at thebraintumourcharity.org. So finally, Shana, I suppose you've put in this amazing charity, amazing learning packages. You mentioned at the very beginning the delays that we'd seen in diagnosis. Have we seen a reduction? Yes, so the whole team.
started off at the Children's Radio Research Center with Professor David Walker and Sophie Wilden. At the start, like I said, the median time to diagnosis was 3.3 months in 2006, and since the introduction of the guideline and then the application of HeadSmart, it is now at 6.5 weeks. So we have more than half dip, which we're really, really happy about. The aim is four weeks. So the Department of Health, the latest cancer strategy is that all cancers, adults and children, will be diagnosed within four weeks. And that's our aim, really. And the next step is putting together a new awareness campaign for all the other cancers in childhood, which will be called BodySmart. And that is in the pipeline. So watch this space. It takes some years to develop, yeah.
You must be very proud. It's brilliant. It's a brilliant campaign. Thank you very much for coming, Shannon. Thank you. Thank you very much for coming, Colin. My pleasure. Get on to Twitter. I'm surprised you're not on Twitter. I've just never quite got there. Soon, soon. When you become a consultant. Yes. Make sure you're on Twitter. A PTD consultant. Exactly, yes. Thank you so much, guys. Cheers, thank you. Thanks for listening, guys. Bye-bye.
That was the Take Orally Headsmart special podcast. A reminder that Headsmart campaign was founded by the Children's Brain Tumor Research Centre and Brain Tumor Charity. For more information, you can visit headsmart.org.uk, free phone 0808 800 0004, or email support at thebraintumorcharity.org. For more information on research and education opportunities within emergency medicine, acute medicine and major trauma, remember you can find NUH Dream on both Facebook and Twitter.