Thanks for downloading and welcome to Take Orally, the podcast from Dream Queen's Medical Centre at Nottingham. In this episode we'll be discussing heart murmurs. As ever, any and all information mentioned is correct at the time of recording. Any and all guidelines mentioned are correct for Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust. Other trust guidelines may vary. All views and opinions are the speaker's own.
Hello everyone and welcome to Take Aurelie. Amazingly a non-Covid episode for once. We are looking at heart murmurs today. I'm delighted that we're joined by Ruth Au. Hello, Ruth. Hello, thank you for volunteering me. No worries, Ruth. Thank you for accepting being volunteered. You are a senior ACP in emergency medicine at Queen's Medical Centre. Yes. And heart murmurs for me, I don't know how they were for you. This was one of my areas I really had to focus on as I was studying. It's kind of osky bread and butter to expect you'd be maybe hearing a murmur. Yeah, I think particularly known as a nurse in an ACP.
This is like really you're going into the realm of a doctor. This is what a doctor does. So yeah, it can definitely get a schism in your head. Cool. We could focus all day on every type of murmur and everything. So we're going to look at four main murmurs today. Aortic stenosis, aortic regurg, mitral stenosis and mitral regurg. If that's okay. Sounds good. So shall we start first with what a heart murmur is? Have an idea of a definition. Yeah. So as the non-expert. As the non-expert. Survival guide approach. For me, a murmur is probably best to find as turbulent blood flow.
However, the underlying cause of that, I think it's the top of the blood flow, the secondary to the valve, the secondary to the flow, but there'll be some aberrancy there, but what you're hearing is blood flow. Just hearing that blood bouncing around instead of going in at least one way. And you mentioned the non-expert thing, because as we were discussing beforehand, there is a grading to murmurs, whereas one being like, only the expert can hear it. Indeed, yes. So if one is your consultant tells you you can hear it, and you go, okay. Six is you don't need a stethoscope to hear it, so it's clicking.
essentially is a metal heart valve. And then sort of between two and five is everything in between. So generally, one for three. Excellent. Or read, if they've had an echo before, have a look at their report. Yeah, it can sound very impressive. So yeah, this is the survival guide, really, to kind of think about some of these murmurs in a clinical context as well, in terms of the clinical presentation of the patient as well. So where shall we start? Shall we start with, shall we go alphabetically? Yes. Yeah, sure.
So, aortic regurgitation is a class of an early diastolic murmur, so that means it should occur after S2, before S1, in the cardiac cycle. She'd hear it on the left stonal edge, classically radiates to the apex, and essentially this represents a backflow of blood travelling through the aortic valve. They classically describe it as a deprescendoing echo echo a decrescendoing murmur and so apparently if you whisper the letter r out loud this is kind of characteristic of the murmur so r i wonder how many people are currently whispering r as they're listening to this So yeah, confusing me, often has an ejection systolic murmur attached to it as well, which we're going to talk about in a second. What would make your aortic bowel be sort of regurgitative then? What causes it? So obviously being sort of emergency focused, like the acute side of things, kind of the key ones really to think in terms of acute AR, valvular pathology, would be infective endocarditis or aortic dissection. Those would be the two that would sort of highlight high up in my head. Also kind of have in the background that aortic regurgitation is not just...
an issue with the valve itself, it could be the aortic root that's the problem in the context of the aortic dissection, and that leads you to think as well you respect between collagen vascular disorders or what have you. So the classical, I don't know how your exams were, but our medical exams are very, shall we say, biased sometimes. So a gay man constitute with a cough. it's PCP. It's that kind of, a sailor comes to you with a strange rash, it's syphilis. I think most medics would agree with me, these are these exams. So there's always a basketball player who is that foot tall comes to you and you notice a murmur. What's the most likely murmur? Does he have a high arch palette? There you go, exactly. Okay, fine, yeah. More classically though, it's a more of a chronic presentation. So I think rheumatic fever globally is the leading cause, with sort of complex depositions essentially on the valve cusps.
Other than that, by Cuspid Valve, which I think is the leading good general cause. I think it typically is prominent around age 40. If you're thinking about somebody who, say, has an injecting drug user with a fever. I think it's Duke's classification technique. That's further down the line. But I think from an AD perspective, you've got, in an acute context, you have an incredibly unwell patient in cardiogenic shock who you hear a new murmur in. They're injecting IVDU with a new murmur. You'd be silly not to be saying, could this be an effective endocrine like this? Murmurs are heard relatively early. Picked up clinically with good practice. Echoes are done quite early on, and disease pathology is not left.
Brilliant. Did it all. Absolutely. Well, as you said, rheumatoid fever, luckily, is a very rare thing in the UK. Yeah, yeah. So, yeah, we talked there about a leaky aortic valve. Let's talk about one that's gone narrow and aortic stenosis.
Good, okay, yeah, so aortic stenosis is defined as an ejection systolic murmur, so you should hear it soon after S1, and then crescendoing and decrescendoing before S2 comes in. Quite musical, often it's described as a whoosh, best heard over either the aortic valve area or the apex, and classically will radiate to the carotids, obviously, if you consider where the blood's traveling to, that makes sense. Obviously, left hearts are best heard in expiration and leaning forward helps as well. And obviously, as we said, this represents turbulent blood flow, so coming out of the vessel through a really narrow, non-compliant valve. can also be confused with the flow murmur so you know if you hear it also it's reasonable to think hypertrophic cardiomyopathy obviously pulmonary stenosis as well um and generally any sort of increased cardiac output state so so a relatively young person with fever um or or a severe anemia and with a corresponding high cardiac state they talk about listening for an ejection click um which would suggest i think it's around the jugular notch suggesting bicuspid valve so again if you've got a 40 year old who's sort of you know coming in with you know history of exertional syncope funny on chest pains you hear this kind of erotic stenosis ejection systolic murmur that's a reasonable go-to point yeah so they're the ones who are going to be presenting that bit earlier than those who've got the degenerative yeah absolutely yeah so it's a classic I think the age of presentation is somewhere I think it's around your 40s to 50s so something to look forward to
And so, I mean, the classic kind of over 50 syncope chest pain dyspnea, it only presents in around 30% of patients. As a good rule of thumb, though, if you hear an aortic stenosis murmur and your patient's coming with chest pain, there's sort of like a good corresponding, I think something in the region of two-thirds likelihood that they've got critical stenosis going on. And I was always taught that aortic stenosis, you need to consider that this is not an isolated finding in a heart. There will be, this is not a happy heart at the best of times. Cool, yeah. And there will be underlying disease. As you talk about, obviously, congenital, and then you mentioned sort of the calcifics, you know, sort of degeneration, which I think is probably a leading cause overall.
And so this is, I think we're talking about A&E, a collapsed patient, a patient like you said with chest pain, with shortness of breath, with features of heart failure, it's an important moment to listen for. Absolutely, and I think this is probably the first murmur I managed to hear. Agreed, same. Not the first murmur I've listened to, but the first one I identified. Agreed, yeah. And so the kind of, really what you're looking at is, you're looking to find this murmur. So you're obviously examining the patient, looking for pathology to suspect. So this is the sort of patient that presents with sort of typical left and ventricular tract symptoms. So exertional dyspnea, exertional syncope, importantly not post-exertional syncope.
exertional syncope and obviously as we talked about angina and chest pains and just having a high index of suspicion and if you hear something there then you know that that's a good requirement for an echo. ECGs typically will show a left LVH strain type pattern if it's become severe. Because that left ventricle is trying to overcome that narrowed valve so it develops. And this isn't a disease of acuity. This is something that compensates, compensates, compensates, fails. And it's the exertion component where you start to see where the failure kicks in. It's one of those, it's that thing, that caveat to always think about in patients with heart failure if you're thinking about giving them a GTN or a vasodilator if they're unknown to have the aortic solution.
to have a think about that yeah and hope someone's given GTM before yeah yeah so there's definitely um aortic stenosis just makes life a bit more tricky in terms of management i think in the context of active ongoing cardiac sounding chest pain you just have to bite you know hold your nerve and decide that it probably is worth giving it to them and keeping a close eye on them but um but on those side rounds it's really case based and the reason for that is because they have this narrowed aortic valve they need that preload in order to even get open it and if you give them a load of GTM yeah and i remember because it's left ventricular tract obstruction actually there's not much capacity they've already got reduced So yeah, this was my modern myoski. I remember I was very pleased when it was aortic stenosis because it's probably the one I'm happiest and most comfortable in identifying. So let's go over to the mitral valve now and let's go to mitral regurg.
Yeah, so mitral regurg is described as a pan-systolic murmur, so occurring between S1 and S2, and classically is heard on the apex, radiating round into the axilla, and this represents backflow of the blood through your mitral valve enduring bossy systolic. It can also be associated with mid-systolic click if there's prolapse, but I think if you hear this also you can be thinking VSD, essentially pan-systolic murmurs, there's more than one constant, commonly mitral regurgitation. Cool. And again, your connective tissue disorders? Mimitoid heart disease. Yeah, yeah. So kind of all of the above, really. Anything that's going to dilate the annular ring, and that could be LVH, so what they call like a secondary MR, so LVH causing that, or if somebody stays in the form of collagen disorder. Rheumatic fever, I think, is still the leading primary cause, and probably globally, and then degenerative, obviously, as well. I think it's worth talking about mitral regurgers in the context of an acute setting, in so much as, again, endo-infective endocarditis is a key stuff.
can deposit here and give you this acute picture and classically certainly one of my teaching was papillary muscle rupture yes yeah secondary to mi yeah and these patients are dog sick there's no other way about it acute you know valve failure This is a very, very unwell patient. Hello, cardiology. Well, yeah, cardiac surgeons. Yeah, this is a patient who's lost. So it's only an acute phase. It's slightly different when they have chronic, and so they've had a degree of LA compensation. But in the acute phase where you've got a non-compliant, as in a normal, LA, and then there's suddenly this backfilling of blood going into the LA, congesting the pulmonary bed, giving you acute cardiogenic pulmonary edema, plus the corresponding fall in cardiac output. You have this patient who's just in horrible cardiogenic shock, and the only thing really that you've got is to fix that all.
Absolutely. So papillary muscle rupture up there, the Dresla's syndrome of those weird and wonderful MI complications. You get to know, but very rarely see them. And again, that effect of endocarditis. So again, I think the patients who are at risk, you're directing drug users are always at the front of our mind. But patients who, obviously your dental work patients are the ones classically, as you mentioned. Patients with non-native valves as well are at risk. Just to always have that in the back of your mind. And I just want to remember a bit that, as you said, non-native valves, prosthetic valves can also fail as well. So again, if you think that you're dealing... The presentation can be different because there's probably a degree of their LA's had time.
had a degree of compensation to be a chronic MR, but yeah, certainly, you know, anyone that's been in cardiogenic shock with a valve, it's a bit of a, with a prosthetic valve, you need to be, there needs to be a strong reason why you're not questioning why that valve's not working. And then on to a narrow mitral valve, so mitral stenosis. Mitral stenosis, I can't, I must confess, I can't really say that I've heard this all that regularly. So this is a mid-diastolic murmur, and it comes in, so after S1 and preceding, obviously, S2.
It's in the apex. It doesn't really radiate anywhere. And again, this is just flow of blood through a narrow valve. And what you're hearing is the jet of blood hitting the ventricle. You can also hear an opening snap if you've got quite stiff cusps.
The best way I got heard, I got told about listening for this. So firstly, this is the left lateral position, apex, using the bell of your stethoscope. And for your roskeys, consider that this is how I'm listening for mitral stenosis. But they talk as well about listening for the absence of silence. So I think the analogy would be, you know, if you're in a pub, obviously pre-COVID, don't do that now. But you can hear the conversation with the person in front of you, but then you can also filter that out and listen to the conversation going around behind you. And then you can...
I find people often do that to me when I'm in the pub with them. Sorry, what? Sorry, don't joke. But yeah, and so kind of really good piece of advice to listen to, just listen to what you hear in clouds, listen to S1, and really focus on S1 and what abnormalities you can hear. Listen to S2, and then the third, and kind of the probably most useful, is to listen to that absence of silence. So actually there's a point where you should be hearing nothing, and hearing something, because these are not easy things to pick up. You're hearing something, then actually, you know, go look at the echo. Excellent.
Again, I've got down for these guys, because they can have a degree of CO2 retention, they get like a malar flush, it's called. So a redness to their cheeks. So yeah, definitely malar flush. I think you can get malar flush with tricuspid as well, regurgible. But yeah, risks really, again, globally, it's rheumatic fever. I think it's something ridiculous. 99% of all cases are rheumatic fever. Degenerative and senile. Again, effective endoparditis, particularly if you think of that jet of blood causing a patch where the bugs can sort of...
So effective endocarditis, that's what can come up into there in the right clinical context. And I think it's associated with autoimmune disorders. Yeah, and mucopolysaccharidosis. I was about to say that. Of course you were. And a left atrial myxoma. Of course, we've all seen them, haven't we? The plop. I really want to hear a plop. I think it's your duty as a clinician if you ever hear an atrial myxoma plop to make sure every other person on shift hears it. That patient is immediately being signed up for... Cool. Anything else through?
I think the last thing, really, is just to be really, really focused. I think there's a very flippant attitude nowadays of, oh, just do an echo. And I think there's probably a degree where that's appropriate. But actually, you can get a lot of information from members, and particularly in the acute stage, it's all about clinical context. So a crescendo-de-crescendo member in one clinical context is not even going to investigate that further. A crescendo-de-crescendo member in a different context is incredibly concerning.
So I think, you know, in the context of an acutely unwell cardiogenic shock patient with murmurs, you have need to be getting an echo. So if you hear an echo, if you hear an echo. Any tips for students who are starting out cardiovascular examination on the best way to hear murmurs? Yeah, so as we kind of indicated already during the discussion, the key thing is to know the timings of them and be able to, so the best way I was taught for timing was obviously listen for lub, listen for dub. When you think you've heard lub, correspond it to a central pulse, so classically.
one parotid or subclavian aperture. And then listen for systole, you should feel a pulse on systole and that's if you hear a heart sound and you feel a pulse at the same time, by definition that is low. And then we talked about sight, again we've indicated various sights and radiations. Often, again, I don't know about you, but the ejection systolic murmur, to me, when I hear it, it seems to be pretty much everywhere throughout the pre-cordium. Yeah, generally. But essentially, radiation is pretty key in terms of presentation, and there's not much that radiates corotically. So if you hear that, you can be fairly confident what you're looking at. Loudness we've already spoken about, and we've kind of indicated occasionally on posture and respiration, so left heart's best heard in expiration, right heart you can enhance during inspiration, or of a salvo manoeuvre as well. And there's other, probably more than this podcast needs.
There's other sort of features, you know, Hockham won't get louder with. Valsalvum, what have you. And the last thing is not to be too tied up and not to be too kind of, oh my God, if I miss this, the patient's going to die. You know, this is not stuff that is, will completely change your management. You know, if you've got a chap who's running for the bus and collapsed and doesn't remember collapsing and wakes up on the floor, whether you hear a murmur or not, that's cardiac syncope. Absolutely. So again, it's about history and taking a meaningful history, not a collapsed recalls. Oh, I've heard a murmur. Yeah, absolutely agreed. And spot on. Cool.
Any resources you know over Final Post 2? Probably showing my age, but I quite like books. Books, children! Things made out of trees! I'm sure you can nick them on Napster. Is that what they use? Napster. Oh my god. The fact I don't even know what Napster was. Oh, I feel so old. What do you mean was? Imagine an app printed on a tree. That's a book. So joking aside, I think MacLeod's is very good. He's Scottish or was. So that's a good one to look at. Oxford Handbook of Physical Examination gives a very...
concise way of looking at it. And Davidson's, I think, is a really reliable, useful resource that doesn't complicate matters too much. And I think there was an app when I was in med school. There were apps when I was in med school. That's amazing. Shut up. Shut up. That has recordings of them. There are those on YouTube as well. So for the...
blog for this episode I will signpost to that where you can listen and actually have a listen. And the Twitter. And the Twitter. It'll be on the Twitter as well. The Twitter and the Facebook. Brilliant. And Ru very kindly has given me a slide set which we'll put on the blog as well which will go through some of the more mechanics and the physiology behind the stuff we've been talking about. Brilliant. Thank you very much, Ru. Thank you. Cheers. Bye.
That was the Take Orally Heart Murmurs episode. You can find a blog for this podcast containing resources on aortic and mitral murmurs at takeorally.com. We've also released separate podcasts containing just recordings of aortic and mitral murmurs for you to listen to. Remember you can subscribe to Take Orally on Apple Podcasts, SoundCloud and Spotify. Take Orally is on Facebook, Twitter and Instagram where you will find an infographic for this episode. For more information about research and education opportunities with emergency medicine, acute medicine and major trauma, check out NUH Dream on both Facebook and Twitter.