Welcome to the Daily Standard Podcast. I'm Eric Felton, joined by Michael Warren, senior writer for the Weekly Standard. White House correspondent who's here to tell us about something that happened at the White House today. I know, Shocker.
Yeah, there was a big celebration, a big essentially a party on the White House lawn for congressional Republicans. I think I don't think they had every single congressional Republican up there standing behind the president, but it sure seemed like it. The president gave a big speech sort of touting the success of passing tax cuts, which the House did this morning, after the Senate, the second time. For the second time, after passing it yesterday, went to the Senate Tuesday night.
The Senate had to take out three elements of it based on these arcane parliamentary rules, voted it out, and then went back to the House this morning. The way things have worked, legislatively for the Trump administration on Capitol Hill, you'd think that having to send it back to the House again, because of a parliamentary quirk, would have been just when it would have fallen apart completely. You would have thought that, except for this one, the House Whip team was pretty confident. I mean, very 100% confident, I would say 99.999% confident.
They knew exactly where their votes were. They knew they had the votes. The real question was actually in the Senate, so even up till the last couple of hours, but that was pretty secure. And so it's very atypical of this administration so far.
They haven't had a lot of big piece of legislation, even sort of get to the stage of getting a vote. And of course, they had the big failure with Obamacare. The vote on the vote on the vote failed. Exactly.
So, but this one passed. And I think Republicans are breathing aside relief that they were able to do it. And of course, that's what you saw in the South Law today. It was just lots of lots of smiling faces.
People excited as the Vice President said, Merry Christmas, America, people are going to be getting a big tax cut. And at the moment, at least that's what Republicans in Washington are celebrating. Does this reflect in any way, Republicans on the Hill or the Trump administration, having learned from earlier failures and figured out how to do this? Yes, it does.
If you, if you talk to people on the Hill, leadership on the Hill, as I have, what they'll tell you is that one big lesson from the Obamacare repeal failure, which was a real failure, was that they were better off doing things, sort of leading things from Congress, allowing the tax writers from the committees or in Hatch and Kevin Brady in the Senate and the House, respectively, to sort of lead that effort, have leadership lead the effort and being communication with the White House and the White House team. But to really take the lead. And I think that's what happened. You were sort of hard pressed to find any, you know, the people I talked to at the White House in the administration, if anything really substantial and substantive, that they influenced in this tax bill, this really was a congressional driven bill, despite what you heard at the South Lawn, which is, you know, every single member of Congress who got up to speak after the president had, you know, really, you know, high praise for the president for the White House.
It's deserved. He's obviously the guy who's able to sign the bill when they do sign the bill, whenever they're gonna sign, whenever he's going to sign the bill. But the people in the know on Capitol Hill, perhaps a little self-interestedly say that this was really driven by Congress. And that's different than it was during the Obama Care Appeal debate, when you had multiple factions within the White House sort of negotiating on different aspects.
And so everything was very confused throughout that processing was getting changed throughout the process. Was the important thing leadership in the Senate and the House, or that the president got out of the way? Both, I think. The president getting out of the way, he made some sort of perfunctory efforts at bipartisanship, you know, trying to get Senate Democratic senators from red states that he won on board kind of early on.
There really was never any chance that that was going to happen. West Virginia's Manchin said, I was I was there for the taking, but they didn't come and get me. Yeah, I mean, they tried, but there's no, look, they're saying what you want about Joe Manchin, but he he's right. I mean, he's sort of, he could have been, I think gotten off, you know, picked off from the Democrats.
If perhaps this was a different Republican administration, if this were somebody who was not so absolutely toxic to Democrats. But for the most part, Trump stayed away from, you know, a lot of the details. If you remember doing the Obama Care repeal debate, particularly after it passed the House and went to the Senate, you heard things from the president like, you know, this, the bill has passed out of the house. It's cruel.
I mean, it was, it was really damaging, I think. It gave Republican senators who were on the fence enough, you know, sort of cover almost to abandon it. He really didn't get involved too much. And if there were any, if there was any involvement on the White House's part, it was pretty behind the scenes and quiet.
For the most part, this was something you want to talk about a group of people or somebody who who did have influence on sort of what the final bill looked like and sort of pressed hard, something that you would expect the president to be able to do to get something out of it, where Michael Ian Marco Rubio, the senators from Utah and Florida, who pushed a kind of inch up the child tax credit as well as to expand it to payroll taxpayers for a little bit, and they were able to negotiate and convince Republican tax writers to up that, up that corporate tax rate, just a tiny, tiny little bit from the low rate that they wanted to make it. But you really saw none of that from the White House, and it was probably for the benefit of the whole bill. For their GOP, one cannot overestimate the importance of just blowing away a bit of the stench of failure. Yes, it may not save them, but it was certainly better to pass something like this than to not pass anything at all.
And I know there's some that view this as, you know, passing tax cuts like this could come back to my Republicans. This will be something that they'll hang around a Republican candidate's neck. Look, they've already got Donald Trump, who's at 36% approval rating. They've got a generic congressional ballot, they've got something like, it certainly has double-digit democratic advantage going into 2018.
Republicans are already in a very difficult position. The question is, are they going to be able to make an argument over the next 10 months to the American people in their individual house districts and these important Senate races that there is a reason to vote for Republicans in Congress? It's hard to make that case when you don't have anything to say, here's what we did. You know, judges, that's in the Senate's purview in the Senate's wheelhouse.
Nothing a House member can really say about getting Justice Gorsuch on the court. Tax reform is something. Maybe it'll turn out to be as unpopular as it is now. It's very unpopular right now in large part because of a sort of media environment that has treated these tax cuts as absolutely worsening ever.
But the economy's doing pretty well in a lot of ways in anticipation of these tax cuts. If the Republicans can make the argument that they've done something to help that along, they're better off than if they had nothing. That being said, there's still a really difficult position. This could end up being sort of an Obamacare type piece of legislation, big sweeping, not as big as they wanted it to be, but big sweeping legislation that accomplishes a Republican goal, a longtime Republican goal, but ends up hurting them at the ballot box or at least not saving them at the ballot box a year later.
I don't see the bill hurting Republicans if, as has been projected, the majority of people get a break that is sizable enough that they've noticed that they actually got a tax break. You don't generally get a lot of people getting furious and angry that they saved money. Right. Yeah.
The question is, can Republicans make that case sort of, will people feel that they have more money in their pocket? Will, you know, the tax return that we're going to fly out by April 15, 2018, of course, is for the old, under the old tax regime, will people be able to feel that before they go to the polls in November? And will Democrats be successful in sort of, in a politics of resentment about the rich or getting a bigger tax cut than you did? I don't know.
I think it's been a mixed bag for Democrats over the years. Sometimes it works and a lot of times it doesn't. The big tax cuts of 2001, 2003, from George W. Bush, very, very popular because people felt like they had a boost in their income and their take-home bag.
We'll see if that works. We'll see if the stock market continues to react this way in the UC more investment. That's what Republicans are hoping for. But if they didn't pass this bill, they'd have no argument.
So they're in a much better position now. But I'm just not sure if it's enough. Michael Warren, White House correspondent and senior writer for The Weekly Standard. Thanks for joining us on the Daily Standard podcast.
Thank you, Eric.