Skip to content
Hemingway In A Glass episode artwork

Nov 19, 2025 1 hr 9 min

Hemingway In A Glass

from The Scotchy Bourbon Boys Hosted by Jeff Mueller / Martin Nash,

Send us Fan Mail We share a club night full of rare pours and smart pairings, then put Hemingway Bourbon and Rye through a dueling bottle breakdown that challenges price bias and highlights finish, body, and balance. Plans shift as we preview Bourbon History Part Two and extend an invite for a Wild Turkey special with Greg. • Crystal Glencairn Club tasting lineup and takeaways • Cheeses, caramels, and pumpkin muffins as pairing tools • Blind compare of KC21 vs KC9 to reset bias • Red Bull palate test and why context changes flavor • Hemingway Bourbon specs, tasting notes, and value score • Hemingway Rye finish profile with rum-seasoned Oloroso casks • Price-to-performance talk and scoring recap • Upcoming Wild Turkey deep-dive with Greg • Annual club meet timing and participation details Remember: www.scotchybourbonboys.com — follow us on Facebook, Instagram, YouTube, X, and TikTok; listen on iHeartRadio, Apple, Spotify; become a member, subscribe, and leave good feedback because that helps us grow. Good bourbon equals good times and good friends. Don’t drink and drive. Live your life responsibly. Drink responsibly and live your life uncut and unfiltered. A porch, a few cigars, and a lineup that made our whole crew lean in—this one starts with community and ends with two bottles that punch above their price. We revisit our Crystal Glencairn Club tasting where Parker Heritage, Hardin’s Creek, Knob Creek 21, and Cathedral met cheeses, caramels, and pumpkin muffins. Then we get tactical: a blind Knob Creek 21 vs 9-year comparison to check bias at the door, plus a sneaky Red Bull palate reset that proved how sweetness and acidity can tilt a pour into new territory. From there we dive into Hemingway Whiskey. The bourbon, a Kentucky blend aged six and four years at 98 proof, reads like a cinnamon graham cracker with chocolate and a frosted apple turnover vibe. It’s one of the best $40 flavor rides we’ve had, with a soft, medium finish that fades clean. The rye brings the drama: a blend finished in rum-seasoned Oloroso sherry casks, pouring brown sugar, caramel, and sherry warmth without the harsh greenness that turns some drinkers off rye. Thick legs, lush body, and a finish that keeps talking pushed it ahead in our scoring. We also talk brand craft—the Call family’s eight generations, the Ernest Hemingway-inspired design, and why story matters when you pour for friends. If you care about value bottles, smart pairings, and learning how context shapes flavor, you’ll leave with new moves for your next lineup. Stick around for a tease of our upcoming Wild Turkey deep-dive with Greg and a reminder to join the club if you want first dibs on picks and annual tastings. If you enjoyed this, follow the show on your favorite podcast app, subscribe on YouTube, and leave a quick review. Share the episode with a friend who loves a good pour and an even better story. If You Have Gohsts Support the show https://www.scotchybourbonboys.com The Scotchy bourbon Boys are #3 in Feedspots Top 60 whiskey podcasts in the world https://podcast.feedspot.com/whiskey_podcasts/

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Send us Fan Mail We share a club night full of rare pours and smart pairings, then put Hemingway Bourbon and Rye through a dueling bottle breakdown that challenges price bias and highlights finish, body, and balance. Plans shift as we preview Bourbon History Part Two and extend an invite for a Wild Turkey special with Greg. • Crystal Glencairn Club tasting lineup and takeaways • Cheeses, caramels, and pumpkin muffins as pairing tools • Blind compare of KC21 vs KC9 to reset bias • Red Bull pa...

Ready to play

Hemingway In A Glass

0:00 1:09:26

Chapters

  1. 0:00 Warm-Up, Studio Revamp, Show Plan
  2. 4:10 Bourbon History Part Two Preview
  3. 6:25 What We’re Sipping Tonight
  4. 7:40 Crystal Glencairn Club Perks
  5. 9:40 The Tasting Lineup Unpacked
  6. 13:25 Food Pairings That Surprised Us
  7. 17:55 Blind Tricks: KC21 vs KC9 And Red Bull
  8. 24:34 Back Porch Cigars And Cigar Blend
  9. 28:34 Club Calendar And Shoutouts
  10. 32:24 Switch To Tonight’s Flight Plan
  11. 35:04 Gratitude For Greg And Wild Turkey Tease
  12. 38:34 Hemingway Bourbon Background
  13. 43:34 Packaging, Theme, And Brand Story
  14. 46:04 Pouring And Nosing The Bourbon
  15. 51:34 Body, Taste, And Finish Scoring
  16. 57:34 Rye Specs: Rum-Seasoned Oloroso Finish
  17. 1:02:04 Rye Nose, Body, Taste, Finish Ratings
  18. 1:08:04 Scores Recap And Price Talk

No transcript yet.

Requests help us decide what to transcribe next.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of The Scotchy Bourbon Boys?

This episode is 1 hour and 9 minutes long.

When was this The Scotchy Bourbon Boys episode published?

This episode was published on November 19, 2025.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this The Scotchy Bourbon Boys episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.