Skip to content
Heroes or Villains episode artwork

Jul 25, 2019 41 min

Heroes or Villains

from Fourth Estate Hosted by 2SER

The media and the world seem trapped in a binary world of heroes and villains - why is that and can we break free? This week's heroes and villains include a look at press freedom, George Columbaris on the Good Weekend cover, Channel Nine and the ABC wreck their brands on conspiracy theories, Facebook and yes Julian Assange. To discuss this and much more our host Peter Fray chatted with Sarah Elks, Simon Crerar, and Wilson Da Silva.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Heroes or Villains

0:00 41:22
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Hello and welcome. You're listening to For The State, the show where journalists talk journalism, coming to you from two S.E.R. and Sydney on getting a lens of the coronation right across Australia on the community radio network and directly to your device by the – across the globe, by a podcast. My name is Peter Frey and I am the co-director of the Center for Media Transition at the University of Technology Sydney.

And my producer today is the Ever-Wonderful Anthony Dockro. Today's show has been inspired by two non-related things. The Prime Minister has reported desire to get politics off the front page, best of luck with that scomo, and the media's never ending ability to reduce – well, to reduce complex issues to a simple choice – hero or villain, which incidentally is the title to the two part four corners investigation into Julian Assange, who is either a courageous journalist, revolutionary, an ill-princable hacker or an attention-seeking narcissist, or even a threat to U.S. global supremacy.

More about him in a minute or two. Seeking to answer whether Assange is a hero or zero is certainly a fair quest, and if anyone can now let the ABC's Michael Britain is a good pick for the task best of luck for the next episode. But in this social media age where shares and likes are the currency of the day, is news media addicted to reducing every subject to good, evil, black, white, winners and losers? We seem to be trapped in a binary world.

Take the celebrity chef George Converis as media watchers, Paul Barry noted the other night. He was already known to have underpaid his workers many millions before he was revealed he owed even many more millions than was first thought. But even so, he was given a sort of saintly pictorial treatment by the Sydney Morning Herald and Good Ages Good Weekend magazine. Maybe it was just a design thing, but it wasn't a great look, was it?

And of course George and the rest of the MasterChef Gang are now looking for new jobs, though we are assured by Channel 10 that the two issues are unrelated. Or the anniversary of the moon landing this past few days. Why would the today show and the ABC's yes, yes, still the most trusted news organisation in the country give airtime to the conspiracy theory that the landing was faked? Why is that even a thing?

So to channel my original question is, is this what we get when as an alternative to politics on the front page? It seems like we will have to rely on journalists making the news themselves, like the French film crew getting arrested for filming at the Adani mine protest or the Australian journalist Primro and refusing to shake their hands of a prominent pro-Chinese Hong Kong politician. Many, many things to talk about and to help me way through these and related questions I am joined by a stallopan, including Sarah Alksi, esteemed Queensland political reporter from the Australian on the line from Brisbane. Hello Sarah.

In the flesh we have Simon Korea, the former editor-in-chief of Buzzfeed Australia, who may or may not be cooking up his re-entry into the journalistic fray. Hello, Simon. Hello Peter. And whilst in December, the long-serving editor and founder of the Science Magazine Cosmos, who now applies his trade in the freelance world.

Hello Peter. Welcome one and all. Before we get to heroes and villains, can I quickly ask each of you for your reaction to the news that there will now be two parliamentary inquiries into press freedom. One by the Parliament's Joint Committee on Security Intelligence backed and controlled by the government.

And the other passed recently, last night or two, in the Senate, with support from Labour Greens and across bench. This latter one is a broader affair looking at whistleblowing, defamation and other aspects, which impinge on journalists doing their job. I guess my questions are, one, what do we want out of such inquiries? And two, given the government didn't support the Senate Committee inquiry, what hope is there anything meaningful coming out of it rather than lots of well-meaning talk?

Wilson over to you first. What do you think? I actually think that having two inquiries is a good idea. We can't necessarily trust the intelligence and security committee to necessarily do a thorough job because let's face it, the secretive and punitive regime that applies now to media with the whistleblowers was largely created by that committee, whether that committee had a hand in creating it or whether they just waved through.

Well, it's something that it's impromatly. Yeah. Yeah. So they might have just waved it through.

But anyway, that's the creation. So to expect them to apply a real focus to this is a challenge. The other committee on the other hand is you said it's not a government committee. So how much can it achieve the Labour Greens Committee?

I'm hopeful because if we get enough embarrassing skeletons in the closet, if we get enough examples like the banking royal commission, it creates its own steam and finally they might have to do something. So the atmospheric sort of thing. Yeah. I think it's a bit of checks and balances in the government approach and then there's the rest of the parliament.

I think that in an ideal world, this committee would have a combination of those voices within it. But we know that the Senate inquiries have become incredibly politicised and then have been stacked in a way that has pushed the legislation which hasn't been given the detail for forensic analysis, that has created opportunities for departments of state to move in ways that retrospectively the Prime Minister and the first Minister said, no, this wasn't our intention at all. So I think at this stage, in an ideal world, we roll back and start again and look. That's not going to happen.

But at least it's the counterbalance of this other committee to weigh against it. So, Sarah, you're there at the cold face. And if you had a wish list, your first one or two, what would you want out of these inquiries? What would make your life your job that much easier?

Well, I think firstly, yes, as a working journalist, you want some sort of comfort that we won't be prosecuted simply for doing our job. And the people that we speak to, the people who trust us, we're telling their stories or we're telling the stories based on information they might supply us, are also not going to be prosecuted for doing things in the public interest. So I think, like you said, the second Senate committee is going to be focused on whistleblowing and also our defamation laws and that kind of thing which haven't been talked about particularly favourably in terms of comparison with other parts of the Western world. I think on just some comfort that we're not going to be prosecuted in the course of our duties.

And that, like you say, that whistleblowers won't be as well. I agree with Wilson that I think, yes, we could be quite pessimistic about what might come out of it. But if the witnesses or people who choose to testify and give submission to these inquiries make their case low enough, then perhaps public momentum could swing behind it and the government could sort of be shamed into doing something about it. I agree with you on that.

I mean, certainly the moment seems to be here, the press raids, for instance, the debate about the impact of the digital platforms and many other issues, all kind of in the defamation. We're going to talk a little bit about the Rothman decision in a minute. All this seems to be adding in some momentum. You do worry, I worry that there's so much noise around this.

You worry how much of this noise is people within the media are very interested in the media. How much have you stopped, like on the street walking down the road and asked them, what do you care whether they're performing, kind of adds to the kind of confusion? That's a great idea. Next, Anthony, can we do the next for the state, just on the street asking people to give a shit about journalism?

What else is there to get Wilson? I don't think we'd get many answers in the same way that most people are not politically engaged. They're probably not overly concerned with the role that media plays. I don't understand, but it's actually the fabric, the infrastructure of democracy.

I was thinking, Sarah was talking that this sort of slow death by 1,000 kurtz, that is occurring to journalism in its role in democracy, which is important, its role rather than the attacks, that why not just outlaw journalism from the start? If that's their ultimate thing, it's kind of like they're trying to destroy, they often argue that the liberals are trying to destroy Medicaid. As an argument, are they trying to destroy journalism? At every stage of the last five or six years, we've seen constriction around the role of journalism.

Politicians would prefer that they didn't have to have that robust inquiry into what they do. I don't know whether it's actually that system. How can we push this industry into the grave? Well, talking about restrictions on journalism, Sarah, this week we saw a French TV crew at the journalist Hugh Clement and his crew arrested for covering a protest about their Dany mind, which appears to me, I'm not in Queensland, I'm just going from a trusted media reports, but it seems to me that he was just doing his job.

The arresting journalist was doing the job as it seems a bit of a throwback to Joby Alki Peterson days. Is it getting tougher in Queensland or is this just a sort of one off or is there this high sensitivity about Dany? What's really going on? Yes, welcome to North Queensland, where international film crews are arrested as you watch on before the best book for the Queensland police, which as you mentioned, has a bit of a story passed with cracking down on protests and the media.

That's obviously a long time ago. I think there's quite a regional divide here. Like I don't think that the arrest happened in Bowen, which is in North Queensland. It's right near the other point where Dany owns that port and it's going to ship out the coal bound for India when it starts to get up coal from the Galilee basin.

So it's been a bit of an epicenter of protest and there's been quite a lot of sort of intense feeling on the ground from North Queensland locals about the Dany protest. Most of the people aren't from North Queensland. I mean, I'm a reason why you can't... I get all that and we saw that during the federal election campaign, for instance, in the whole Bob Brown thing and what have you.

But this French TV crew just seemed to be filming it, right? Oh, 100% and don't get me wrong, I'm not the police. The police did the right thing in this scenario. I think the journalist even said, look, where the media, you know, we're just doing our job.

So I think the police in North Queensland probably made the wrong decision. I don't think you would see the same thing happening on the streets of Brisbane. We've had a lot of... We've had a lot of anti-Zany protests and I think they're called extinction rebellion protests in the CBD of Brisbane recently where people have been trying to shut it down.

And obviously there's been a lot of media coverage of that. So having protested the rest of it for glowing themselves onto the streets in peak hour, but so far the media has not been touched. And I can't recall the last time a journalist was arrested in Queensland for doing their job. So I would suggest this isn't anomaly, but it's certainly not a...

It's a French. I know. It's the signal. It's the signal.

I think the signal, it's sense is really bad already. I certainly... You guys probably did too have, when the AFP raids were happening around the corner, ABC here, had colleagues of mine in the US in the UK saying, look, this is really terrible. What's happening in Australia?

You know, showing concern for practitioners of the craft. And then to have that already happening and then to have this thing happening where people are really... Sometimes it's a Jason Seagrind that you're covering a process where they might be deploying paper strain in the streets of Melbourne, for instance, and people actually get sprayed in general. So we're trying to take photos together.

But actually to get nicked and to be put at Paddy Wagon, simply for recording what's actually going on, when, as the footage shows there saying, hey, we're journalists and I think the signal that sends and now reinforces this message that something has changed in Australia where I simply doing our job simply reporting what's going on is somehow not OK from our kind of government perspective. I think it has changed. And it's perhaps the consequences of those raids that you mentioned at News Corp and... Open season.

Well, it's starting to... Think about this. The very action of the raids is sending subtle messages to everyone, any authoritarian bureaucrats or whatever. It's OK to be consular.

It's creating an atmosphere where it's OK to strong arm reporters, rest film crews, deny media information and a more authoritarian and hawkish elements of society will feel more comfortable. OK. We're going to go to the moon now and we're going to hold your horses one second because I know this is a very suspicious area for you. So we all know the story.

It's 50 years since Human Set Foot on the Moon this past week or so. Neil Armstrong's first set is brought to the world via the edition of Canberra. Kind of didn't really get mentioned in the movie that much. And then much more famously and mentioned in the movie than when the eparks in yourself.

Well, I am going to go to you in a second, Wilson, but Simon and Sarah, what do you make of all this anniversary journalism? I've been really obsessive about it. I think I went to see in the City Film Festival the amazing CNN documentary, which was really tremendous archival footage with any other voice in there. I took my five-year-old that he was super energised by this amazing achievement and I think to be able to look back and be nostalgic about it about this moment where America and its amazing race did this incredible thing on behalf of humanity's fabulous.

I think then every single aspect of the story has been unpacked again. And certainly the hoax, which I understand are the great thing that Daryl King and Australian journalists wrote from Medium, this new publication, Jen, about Bill Casey, who's the guy who wrote the book in 1976, We Never Went to the Moon, America's 30 Billion Dollar Swindle, which was basically bar and bonkham where I made the bet to him, hey, why are you writing a book about this crazy thing? And that then kind of weaponised it. And I think if you fast forward 40, 50 years, what's happened in this area of social media where fake news is like this huge circulating global phenomenon, it's much easier to find currency for this kind of narrative.

So there's this questioning of every single thing that we know, maybe all the breakdown of it. So the fact it's come up again, I think it's part of the environment we're in where people are looking at things and saying, well, even the moon landing was affected. So Sarah, can we blame Donald Trump for this? I think we can blame the climate in which Donald Trump arose, this post-backed world where experts and researchers are distrosted and conspiracy is kind of a bound.

I think part of the coverage about the moon landing conspiracies was a little bit of journal thinking we've got this huge expanse of newspaper space or television space about the moon landing, let's have a tiny segment on conspiracies. But yes, I don't think people should be giving any kind of credence to the might, I guess, it's independent of the time in which you cover it. So Wilson, look, we have journal nine today, shows up, perhaps they're in the breakfast space and maybe you'll have to get away with it. But ABC, the most trusted news organisation in the country, I agree with you.

Why are we got to this point though? I mean, yes, Trump, maybe and yes, you'll be able to see both of you and Simon. There's something else going on. And there's something else going on in media generally, I think.

I know it's the section we're talking about as a four-minute segment, an otherwise nice package celebrating the 50th anniversary. But that event, it's to, and I know they were trying to counter conspiracy theories by going through each one and then saying why it's not true, but it's moronic. It paints conspiracies as just something that people believe and maintains this chatty, as in own. It does nothing to assert what is empirical fact and historical knowledge, you know?

And versus spitball conjecture say, even a ten-year-old, it wasn't all that very well done. But it's not uncommon in ABC coverage. It's the sort of reality television approach that we've been seeing. So the ratings kind of are...

Yeah, I don't know if it's ratings, I'm not in there, I don't know what the discussions are. But you just see it as somebody who's just seeing the content coming out over the last six, seven years. There's this real kind of master-shift. The master-shiftization.

Back to George Connely, is that the way today? It's affecting it. And the Today Show piece was completely well-witched, actually today, extra, which is even more... Magazini, if you would be a word researcher.

It's sort of new idea to women's day. And it went over the top. And this poor young PhD... Yeah, yeah, that's just...

You had to answer these moronic questions. Like, why is there no gravity on the moon? Can I ask you a bigger question? Can I ask you a bigger question, which is science literacy in the general news media?

I mean, is this also at a lower level now than it has been? It's easy to kind of lament how great it was back then. But the science literacy of the general news reporting public asks, in other words, is this where the problem lies? Two things are happening at the same time.

Number of science journalism is decreasing. But there are a lot of science graduates going into journalism, because they're like communication. I try my best to tell them, then don't expect it, and a great deal of money. But apparently science...

You don't know they've got a great amount of money either. So that's encouraging to see that happening. But on the other hand, we don't have the kind of discipline coverage that we had. I remember Deborah Smith used to be the editor of the City of the City of the City of the City of the City of the City.

Sorry, the science editor. She used to say that most of the time we spent putting out stories, making sure they didn't get a run, because there'd be discussions internally. She was a gatekeeper. That is a valid role that happens, but that's not happening anymore, because there are so few science journalists working.

On the other hand, we have organisations like the Science Media Centre in Adelaide, which keeps track of emerging issues and then sends general journalists lots of information on background things, whether it's vaccination or whatever, moon losses, and gives them solid people to quote rather than just ringing some nut job and asking them for a quote. So the two are happening at the same time. Does it feel like it's good in evil? It is a funny, it's good in evil.

I just think very quickly last year we worked with the A&U and the Science Centre on an experiment, a six month experiment to fund a science reporter in our newsroom. And I think the issue was a graduate science graduate, a very good communicator, did great reporting was part of the Bussy Global Science team. And I think that there is somewhere where we've seen the conversation, we've seen innovative attempts to take the academy into the public sphere. And I do think that's where universities perhaps will work, figure out models of getting rather than those science graduates going off and not working in journalism because it feels that the fact that every, my said has lost their science reporter, there's a gap there that we need to start off.

I followed that, I thought she was a progress professor, but she was very close because she was also a UTS person. But it all strikes me that there's a paradox here, which is that science stories always are very popular. And yet news media organisations don't invest in less and less in science journalism. What's that about?

In fact, the two CSIRO mass studies have been done on what people want to read more of. At the very top was science, well, actually was medical research and in science astronomy, etc. At the very bottom, they want to read more of was finance and politics. And yet we've got the exact opposite delivered to our audience itself.

I think it's very potentially that the vast people running newsrooms and historical run-users are kind of arts graduates and are focused on politics and government and those kind of conversations. We had an issue with thinking about how you commercialise around that. I felt very strongly that there was a lot of opportunity there, in terms of finding out the things we'd like down the line to support that. Could you find out what does in dollars?

We were trying to find traction, yeah, sure. I think the mindset of the sales teams to focus on that was hard. Right, OK. All right, let's move on.

Sarah, I'm going to blame you entirely for this, OK? Do you political reporters have to blame for everything today? I don't know if you know Primrose, Roward, and Reardon. For me of the Australian now, reported financial times in Hong Kong.

Did you ever work with her? Not only know her by reputation in the Cheeseball Good reporter and wasn't surprised to see her holding a nerve in the situation that you're about to describe. Yes, well, it was very much holding a nerve. So she's created a bit of a storm in Hong Kong, where she now works with the Financial Times, for refusing to shake the hands of a very influential pro-raging Hong Kong politician, Unius Ho, at a press conference.

And before that, Ms. Nub Ho had been shaking the hands of the white T-shirt in Marbury with tax civilians on a Hong Kong train. So really, I'm basically declined to shake the hand, the same hand that shook the hands of the attackers, if you like. So we think so.

Is this the right thing to do? Or is this kind of a problem because it's the journalist becoming the story rather than reporting it? Well, I mean, I think she did exactly the right thing. And I would hope that I would react the same way in that scenario.

She was asking why he had shaken hands with the white clothes men. And then I think he had extended his hand to her to say, I presume I've got to shake hands with everybody, or I shake hands with people no matter who they are. And she managed to resist that kind of intrinsic human urge to shake her and outstretched hands and do a very good job surrounded by other reporters and television cameras and all that kind of thing. I think she probably would be mortified to think that she has become the story.

I think she was just doing what she had to do to ask the questions. And if she had shaken his hand, it would have almost eroded to the perception of impartiality and all that kind of... Who's hand would you not shake? Well, it's sort of a similar thing where I never, this might be why I'm not very popular in the world.

I'm political, I never clap at a speech by a politician. I'll never stand up when other people give a standing ovation and I never clap. Listen, the reasoning there is that you're doing your job, you're not there to be... Well, that's right, we're not there to literally applaud or shake hands.

We're not there to be anybody's friend. So, OK, Wilson... I've always found it weird how in the White House the journalists stand up and clap the president. And if you see them travelling in the White House, correspondents have ever traveled, they do exactly the same.

It's very weird. So, would you shake Donald Trump's hand? I wouldn't, because if I'm interviewing him, I'm performing as a journalist. You've got to remember what your role is.

And you're playing in the case of that legislative hand. It seemed to me like he was a stunt and she was goading her into doing so it could make a point. And if she had succumbed, then she would have ceased to be a journalist. What do you think so?

Well, I think it's my association with the bloody time that was involved in beating these protesters up. But I think that maybe it would have been a bigger story she had, actually, shook his hand. I think sometimes I feel that particular imperialism, that there's a proximity. The reason people end up in the lobby, they're seducing some kind of way by closest to power.

And my sister's a political journalist in the UK and I've always felt uneasy to go into her bathroom and see photos of her and Blair and Brown in those days. And I know there's a photo of her with Boris when she was on a junkie with him and that proximity, she's not looking too happy seeing next to him. But there's a bit of a celebrity, we're looking at an age of celebrity selfies, right? Yeah, exactly, but that closeness of, and obviously they work in the same buildings and they have that closeness of other, my philosophy has always been that, like, let's assume that their lying bastard's trying to, you know, and maybe they have human beings, of course, and they often try to do good.

But like, let's just distance ourselves a little bit from that sense of... Maybe she put it in the toilet for a particular reason. Maybe, and we'll find out in the next few weeks. That's right.

Sarah, going back to you though. I mean, one thing that visitors to this country have remarked on, you know, is the proximity of Australian journalists to politicians. You know, Canberra is very close. Other state parliaments are very close in.

Do you find, you know, sometimes that you prefer to be out of the building rather than in the building? I do. In both a physical sense and probably a metaphorical sense, I think, particularly after sitting with a parliament, I'm here, you often see politicians kicking back with a beer in their offices and they're going to my colleagues, go and have a drink with them, but I just feel a little bit comfortable about that, actually. I think we need to, without a lot of what political strikes they are, I think we need to create a really clear distance.

I'm not sure it would stop them. Any of my colleagues are reporting on those politicians without beer or favour. But I think just from my own self-personally, my terribly want to be friends. The question that leads us to is this.

Journalists, you know, form relationships with politicians because they get leaks from them. So do you think you're disadvantaged in terms of, you know, getting a drop or two? Like the fact you don't have a beer with the politicians? Well, potentially on a surface level, I prefer to get my stories rather than being dropped certain things by the government, perhaps, you know, the angle that they want, I prefer to get my stories the whole fashion way, I suppose.

Although maybe that is the old fashion way, the system of drops in leaks. Well, it was one of the old fashion ways, I suppose. I mean, of course, you're never going to say no to a leak, but you've got to kind of look at the context in which you're being given it and make sure that you're not being used as a tool by whoever's given it to you. I think, obviously it's a real temptation to, and I'm not saying I'm not saying I'm going to cultivate sources.

I'm not sure you do. I have politicians, but I think that, yeah, there's a very, I think that they have to be aligned between being friendly and being cultivating your professional sources and then sort of getting a little bit too close and maybe pulling a bunch of free of favourite politicians. Okay, well, let's move on. Back to our Saints and Sinners theme.

The Good Weekend, I mentioned in the introduction, the Good Weekend stories about George Colin Bouss and how he was coping with his public shaming over underpaying his work as some $2.7 million was on one level, and I'm fortunate at piece of timing, and I feel empathy for the editor of the Good Weekend about that. I mean, the Good Weekend wasn't to know that after it went to print that the Fair Work Ombudsman was going to reveal that the actual underpayment was more like three times on the map. But, and but, what about portraying him as a saint with us, a word halo around his famously shaved bons and his eyes turned down as if he was a performer, holy miracle, some sort of redemptive pose? What do you think about that part of its own?

I think, you know, I understand, as you do Peter and the situation that Katrina there was in, but I think the way she defended on Instagram is actually, you know, when you read the piece, it's certainly not a piece. It's all not all about him at all by any means, and there's a huge amount of other things around the pressure of being a chef and how that impacts on people's lives, and it's, you know, begins with a suicide. It's a really, you know, a deep piece of quite broad reporting and it's self-aware in that the reporter loop, then it is just actually, you know, questions whether this is a PR move and looks at it and things, but like, based on all that, and based on knowing when this was coming down, the perfect storm was, they could have anticipated that, I think, and certainly they didn't need to, that design treatment, which I think was the thing that people were responding to on Saturday, was like, how bad does this look? This is the thing that falls out of the graphs first, out of the package in Sydney or Melbourne, and, you know, the news report in the last 24 hours has been, how bad this finding has been.

So I just think they could have anticipated that, you know, they could have still had him in there, if he didn't been part of that story, but to put him in this, in this treatment, I think they were painting Cross and Urban Bags. Yeah, well, as it turns out very much so, I guess in part, and you know, this is what was never explicit in that story, of course, was that the final season of the story, this, the final, in the time, right? So George Gomez, it wasn't a coincidence, it wasn't a mistake. But so, Wilson, does this go to this kind of whole issue of the news media needing saints and sinners, you know, winners and losers?

I don't know, I've noticed that the celebrity adulation thing has been growing every year, I'm wondering if this is the marker of peak celebrity adulation, because it's, you know, we've seen everything, it's now, we cover everything from Instagram followers to wellbeing gurus, even when it turns out that they're total fakes. And yet, we all go, and then find another one and do exactly the same things. Repeat. So why can't we, you know, it's not just the hardest story, it's also, try and find, celebrate people, which is what celebrities, how they're created, why don't we celebrate people who have actually done amazing things with an international aid or an area that I like, science and research, make a way, so, you know, there are heroes to be found, but we go for these easy.

I mean, look, you know, I don't take the, I don't disagree with the point you're making, that, you know, it can be difficult to be a chef, but really, come on, the chef, you know, saving, saving people from cancer or something, you know? Well, he might be, you know, he might be helping people eat better, which in itself is a good thing. Yes, nutrition, but really, we've created chefs, this whole, the number of cooking programs, I remember before Delicious Magazine came on, there were no cooking magazines of any kind, now there's so many, there's so many programs, it's an easy journalism, stuff, it's easy stories to tell, harder stories need, more effort. All right, Sarah, I know we're running out of time, and I know you may have to leave this, but before we do, I wanted to get to two quick things, again, two names, two heroes or villains, depends on how you look at it, Julian Assange and Dylan Voler.

I mentioned Voler, of course, because it is his legal action against media companies, which prompted just to Stephen and Rossmann to rule that media companies were liable for, defamatory comments made by third parties on their Facebook pages, even if they don't know, even if the companies themselves don't know that they are there, and that it's basically Facebook that controls those pages. So this judgment has been appealed by News Corp and several other media organizations. How big a deal is this, do you think, Sarah? I think I'm potentially huge.

I sort of shut up the humble reporter, Simon, we're probably no far more about this than me, but I shut up to think about the breadth of news companies' responsibility, if we had to be somehow legally responsible for every comment that was posted on Facebook pages. I see comments on the news stories on companies' own, whether or not and sometimes shut up and think, I'm not sure that that should necessarily be up there and think that there's a defamation risk there. I think News Corp and Lodging, it's appeal, has said that this is another reason why we need to have another look at Australia's defamation laws that were out of step with the rest of Western democracies, basically, because in other places, media companies have the defense of innocent dissemination, if an offensive comment had been published without their knowledge on a place like Facebook. I think it's probably making media executives very nervous, because it just comes up entirely large can of worms that we don't need to deal with when there's already cost-cutting pressures and all that sort of thing.

Simon, when you were with BuzzFeed, you've danced with Facebook in the Pale Moonlight, is this just another example of how we don't fully understand how immeshed news is with digital platforms? I think in this example, and previous examples we've seen over the last couple of years, it shows, Sarah says, how far our legal system is behind the reality of how people are consuming and engaging and commenting on news. And like any of you spends a bit of time on Facebook, you've got your comment and it's there immediately. It's not obviously being moderated in any kind of way.

So then all of a sudden to hold the person who set that page up, that set the page up responsible, those things, when there's not the ability to pre-motherate those comments, it shows a bit of a lack of understanding, I think, and just how they work. And I think that that's been proven in other examples in other cases, and that's where we really do need some urgency, I think, to take stock of how these platforms work. This, again, was a thing that creates ripples around the world, that is creating this particular judgment with the moment when there's huge amounts of interest and focus on how these places operate in the future. Well, yeah.

So we're interested to see, but I do think that we're long over due look, and every executive in the country has been calling for a good look at defamation. And we are in the near future about to have the ACCC's reporting on to the digital country, the ACCC. So I'm going to jump forward to the final question, because I know Sarah has to go. I want to just ask everyone a very simple question.

It's not only you, Wilson, Julian Assange, a hero or a villain? I think the foregone is facing it nicely. To some, he's a champion of free speech to others. He's an irresponsible anarchist.

I actually suspect he's both. At the same time. Yeah. You can't take back what some of the incredible stuff he's done about, particularly the beginning of WikiLeaks, the revelations and the disclosures.

But you also can't take back the guy's ego and he's an ability to see himself from the outside. OK, Simon. I love the rockstar combined with James Bond type of vibe, the reckless narcissist, the most haunted man on earth. I mean, it was gripping.

But I do think, I think really, what we need to look at is this, is that news is in danger. That news is a person. It's a process. And that process needs to protect it.

And we can all agree or disagree about the ways it works. We're at some very New York Times, the Guardian, huge global names who put the reporting under immense rigor. And then all of a sudden, he's kind of like person, no, no gratis. And we kind of want to wash our hands on him.

So whether you feel that he's a great crusader for truth or you feel he's an anarchist or somebody who's collaborated with Russians to impact the election, whatever those things, it's probably truth in all of those things. At core, the news media, it's under threat everywhere. And this is another way that governments are really putting what we do under threat. Just on that point, do you think he's a journalist?

I would not call him a journalist. OK, Sarah, what do you think? Here are villain and do you think he's a journalist? I don't think he's a journalist.

I think he's potentially a vehicle for whistleblowers. Sorry, but over that position, potentially it needs to be protected. But also, I don't know, whenever he's worried about Julian's fans, I can't help remembering the fact that he's still under all his under renewed investigation in Sweden over some fairly serious way of delegation. And I know that there's obviously huge media freedom and national security debates about Julian Assange.

But I think we should also not forget that there's that concurrent investigation that going on, or at least has been re-enlivened since he's emerged from the embassy in London. It'd be interesting to see how that plays out. It'll be interesting to see what Four Corners does with it next week. Yeah.

That is about all the time we have for this week's show. I think we have a funny feeling we could be talking for another hour. What a wonderful panel. I'd like to thank Sarah Alks, the Queensland correspondent, political correspondent for the Australian.

Thank you, Sarah. Go back to estimates. Much less interesting than this. Well, can you tell the Palishe government that?

That's our hour part. I'll pass on that message. It's more interesting. Thank you, Simon Kerer, the former editor-in-chief of Buzzfeed Australia.

So, Simon, I mentioned it right at the beginning of the show. What are you going to do next? I've been spending some time doing my new baby and thinking about what's next. I'm actually having worked as a journey for 20 years.

It's going to be an opportunity to really reflect on where our industry is at. I believe that despite the climate, I think there's really a need for new fresh approaches of innovation. I'm working on a journalism startup, which I'm going to watch next year. Okay, we'll get you on the show when you're ready to talk about that.

Okay, great. And Wilson, the founder, the editor of Cosmos, but you are going for hire. I'm going for hire. Give us your pitch.

Come on, here we go. Nobody has the experience in science journalism that I have across all mediums, television, radio, print magazines, online. And no one can do it with a smile like I can. And I can all test it.

We can all test it. Thank you all three. Thank you so much. Fantastic episode of the Fourth Estate.

This edition was recorded at the studios at 2CR and heard across the country on the community radio network. Make sure you subscribe to Fourth Estate on your favorite podcast app. So you can hear us talk about media and politics and a few things, and even science in between at your leisure. And we'll be back with more next week.

But in the meantime, you can stay in touch with us on Twitter, where our handle is Fourth Estate AU. Thank you very much to my producer, Anthony Dock-Roh. My name is Peter Fray, and thank you so much for listening.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Fourth Estate?

This episode is 41 minutes long.

When was this Fourth Estate episode published?

This episode was published on July 25, 2019.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Fourth Estate episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.