From The New York Times, I'm Natalie Kitrowab. This is The Daily. Breaking news, The New York Times just publishing shocking new allegations made against late-labor leader Cesar Chavez. After a Times investigation, revealed allegations of sexual abuse against one of America's most important civil rights icons. This really is a reimagining of a whole legacy, and it's boy- The entire country has started to reckon with a new reality.
They covered up the late civil rights leader's name with cement, removed the image of Cesar Chavez from several commission pieces of art. A statue at Cesar Chavez Plaza is now wrapped up in plastic, you see here. And a history that's now been rewritten. California is officially renaming the holiday formally known as El Chávez Day, March 31st. Now to Farmworkers Day.
Today on what would have been Cesar Chavez Day in California, we talked to the reporters who broke the story. Manny Fernandez and Sarah Hertz, about the women at the center of it, and what it took to uncover a secret that they've carried for more than 50 years. It's Tuesday, March 31st. Manny and Sarah, welcome to the show. Thank you for having us.
Hi, thank you. So you two just came out with this bombshell that was years in the making, this reporting showing that Cesar Chavez sexually abused young girls and women in his movement. And we wanted to talk to you both about how this story came to be and why it came about now. And Sarah, you were integral to all of this, but Manny, the reporting really started with you. So let's begin there.
How did this start? It starts in 2021. And I was sort of just getting settled as the LA bureau chief when a biographer of Cesar Chavez named Matt Garcia wrote an email and the email from Matt Garcia was basically sort of saying, you know, Hey guys, I didn't really write about this in my book, but there's some things with Cesar Chavez and girls that you guys should look into. You know, he had touched on the fact that Cesar Chavez had had some affairs in his book, but he was hearing from people saying that there was more than that.
And we get a lot of tips. Right. I chase a lot of tips. And what did you think about this one when you got it? I wasn't sure what to make of it.
It was just sort of like, huh, maybe there's something there, maybe not, but it was certainly worth looking into. Worth looking into, of course, because of who Chavez is, this monumental civil rights activist in the Latino community. Manny, can you just tell me what did the name Cesar Chavez mean to you at this point? I mean, I am from Cesar Chavez country. I'm born and raised in Fresno, California.
And you can't grow up in Fresno and be from a Mexican American family and not have Cesar Chavez as just part of the weather of your life. Hmm. Part of the weather. I mean, he's just like, not just like streets, murals and things like that. It's just that there's a, it runs a lot deeper than that.
For me personally, my grandparents on both sides of my family started out as farm workers. On my mom's side of the family, my grandparents, they met on a garlic patch outside of Fresno in the 1940s. And they were both 16. And my grandmother's line that I've never stopped repeating is she would always say, it was love it for smell. Hmm.
And so like, there's just that like, I mean, that backstory, like, I mean, that's part of my DNA. All my life, I have been driven by one dream, one goal, one vision. To overthrow a farm labor system in this nation that treats farm workers is that we're not important human beings. Cesar Chavez is like, is important to the Southwest as maybe MLK is to the South. Farm workers are not agricultural implements.
They are not, be the burden to be used and discarded. We drew public attention to the conditions that farm workers were working in. Thousands of farm workers live under savage conditions. Some of them were living in basically sheds. And amid garbage and human excrement, some of them were being mistreated.
Our underage children. Some of them were not being paid for the work they were doing. No one even knew their names. We had all lived through the fields our parents had. We shared that coming to humiliation.
The only answer, the only hope was in organizing. So he is on the front lines bringing the world's attention to how much farm workers are being paid, how they're being treated. We have looked into the future and the future is ours. He helped create America's first successful union for farm workers. He led pickets and great boycotts.
Boycott against the wine, the yellow wine, the grapes and the lettuce is very technical. And marches. Job is some friends began their walk from the Sun, you see the recorded checkpoints. In a larger sense, he was this symbol, this like spokesperson to tell literally the world. And especially America, the work of these farm workers.
There's a nobility and a dignity to it. Their lives matter in these dreams of these people matter. So all of that to say, this tip that you get, this story you're looking into, is not just another run of the middle story for you. Yeah, I mean, this is important to me. Like the stakes are high.
But again, I'm chasing down a tip at this point. Right. There may be a story here and there may not. But I wanted to talk to the women who were rumored that Scissor Chavez did something to them. And hear from them, what is the deal?
What happened? You know, nobody wants to take down a hero. But I think we need to know who our heroes are. So in this tip from Matt Garcia and in a conversation we have later, he's talking to me about a private Facebook group for people who used to march with Scissor Chavez, people who were former union activists. And they're exchanging memories and they're saying, hey, who remembers the lyrics of that one song we used to sing and things like that.
And shortly before Scissor Chavez's birthday, which is March 31st, and it's a state holiday in California, there's this post. And the post is from a woman named Deborah Rauhas and she writes a message. And as part of that message, she basically says, wake up people, this man you march for every year molested me. And that post stays up for a few days and then she takes it down. And so I called Deborah Rauhas on the phone, but she made it clear that she was not ready to talk.
And then one night, sort of late, I get a call and it's Deb. And what does she say? I can tell that she's been drinking. And she's sort of calling me to say, you know, do you really want to tell my story? You don't want to tell my story. They're going to come after you.
They're going to come after me. She believed that the idea of taking down Scissor Chavez would ignite so much anger that people would come after her and her family. The anger would be so high. From Chavez supporters. The day is Chavez supporters.
Yes. And it's actually even she believed that people close to Chavez did not want this story to come out. It sounds to me like what Deb is doing here is stress testing you in a way. Like she's sussing you out. She's asking, do you have a stomach for what it would mean to tell my story?
Yes, that's exactly what she's doing. And what she's doing is she is struggling with, do I come forward or do I not? And that struggle, I could hear it. I could see it. Do I do I hold this in?
Or do I speak it? And she was struggling with that in that moment. And a short time later, she blocks me on her phone. That sounds like a dead end. How do you proceed?
One of the things that happens is eventually Sarah gets involved. I get a call from my editor who tells me that they want to send me to LA to help out on this investigation. So I work in the International Investigations team. I'm based in Brussels and I have a background in working in complex investigations. And I also have a background in sexual violence and conflicts.
And so I fly to LA. So we were a team and I shared my notes with Sarah and we started reaching out to a number of women. We decided that we're going to broaden the search, just interview as many members of Cesar Chavez Movement as possible. And there's another woman whose name I had. And that other woman is Anamur Gia.
And over time, we went to go see Deb. And then we went to go see Anna. And over the course of the reporting, I start developing that journalistic relationship with Deb. And Sarah starts developing a closer relationship with Anna. And these two women, Anna and Deb, they know each other.
They're friends. They grew up together. They talked to each other when they were teenagers. They know each other quite well. And so after months and months, I'm sitting down with Deb and I say, do you think, would you go on the record if Anna would?
And Deb's like, yeah, I think I would. And that's eventually what happens. Both individually decided to go on the record with their names. So I guess we're going to do it from the beginning. And Anna agreed to have her voice recorded.
How are you feeling? Yeah, I will go. Achy today. So Anna is 66 years old. She currently lives in Bakersfield, in a house with her husband, and she has three children.
And in many ways, her story is tied to a place Chavez established for his movement in the mountains outside LA. A place called La Paz. You moved to this community called La Paz. Yes, I was 10. We were, my dad was in charge of just basically getting the property ready.
La Paz was his movement's headquarters. And Anna's family. They were the first to move there and to set up the place for Chavez. So when we moved up there, my family for a while was the only family there. They had the old hospital and the houses.
It was just this very eerie, isolated place. It was formerly a hospital for tuberculosis patients. It was the closest hospital. So when we moved up there. There was lots to explore and she loved it initially.
I was a tomboy, so I liked doing all that stuff going out and playing in the creek and taking hikes on the mountainside. She loved the mountain caves where she could go by ponds or creeks and play in the water. She also liked how spooky and weird her new environment was. This old desolate hospital was a former wheelchair that she could spin on. It was kind of a wonderland for her, it sounds like.
It was kind of a wonderland. I think she just enjoyed being carefree. She just enjoyed being a child. It was a very good place for me. Were you proud to be part of this union?
Yes, yes. I enjoyed it. It was something I guess that was instilled in me for my dad, going out and helping other people and doing good for people. Her father, he was very invested in Cesar Chavez's movement. In fact, she basically met Cesar Chavez through her dad.
And her dad married a volunteer in that movement. And so Cesar Chavez attended the wedding as her dad's best man. Wow. And she remembers attending that wedding. I didn't know what at the time we was, but that was the first time.
And I just knew that from pictures I had seen. So Anna was very much a child of this labor movement. She understood its significance from a very early age. And she picked up on how important her family's role was in building this community in La Baz. As soon as they moved in, really.
I thought it was a good thing. But three years as I got older in my younger teen years, it got difficult. We felt stuck because there was really nobody there. Now the only thing is that this environment was very isolated. There wasn't much going on outside.
And also not many people living with her. My dad, because my father was always gone. He was an organizer, so he was always gone. Her father, he was never around because Cesar asked him to go on tour with him. He was always on picket lines.
He was always helping Cesar get in contracts, unionized for the farm workers. So her dad was always on the move. Her stepmom was sometimes there, but also gone at times. And she just felt that it became increasingly lonely. Right.
It sounds like she's surrounded by all of these people, including her father, who are dedicating themselves to this higher calling, to this movement that they truly believe in. But what that does is kind of make the child make Anna a second order priority. Absolutely. And she tried to feel that loneliness by working herself as part of this union. So I would go to school and come home and go work.
For a time I worked in the purchasing, making sure that we had enough office supplies, ordering office supplies. I worked in accounting for a while. Then I started working in Cesar's office. Cesar moved in about a year and a half after Anna's family had moved into this community. And she had seen him by then and knew how important he was.
He was often surrounded by his bodyguards, whom he employed after he started receiving quite a lot of death threats. So she could sense the presence of an important man. So when Cesar started asking her to work in his office, that felt very special. When did that start? I think I was like about 13, 12 and a half, 13 years old.
So I would do like basically filing, typing letters, just simple stuff like that that I could do. She was very proud to say that she could mimic his signature to help answer fan mail. Because I would send his pictures. So I would practice writing. And so then I would sign because at one point it got too much.
So I would sign or work on the switchboard. I enjoyed it. It was a board with a bunch of cables and it reminded me of character that Lily Tomman played as a switchboard operator. Gradually, he starts inviting her in his office to just have these one-on-one talks. And Anna says that they talk a lot.
I had a really hard time talking to people. I had a hard time talking to my dad. I had a hard time talking to my stepmother. I didn't have a good relationship with either of them at the time. And he was one adult that I could fight in that I knew he wouldn't tell my father what I was feeling or somebody that I learned to trust.
And so Anna tells him how lonely she feels in this community. Things that went on at school. How lonely she feels at school. Like if something happened at my house with my dad. How lonely she feels in her home.
And how would he respond to those things? He would just listen and try and be understanding. And Caesar in exchange tells her that he too feels lonely. And he would say how lonely he was and how hard it was that he always had to have people with him. And it was so bad that sometimes he couldn't even go to the bathroom by himself.
They would have to be security right outside the bathroom with him. And I feel sorry for him. Sorry for him. That's it. She also feels connected to him.
What was it like for you to have this man share so much with you? I felt very special that he made me feel like I was somebody. And that's something I dealt with. I've dealt with a lot in my life. But yeah, we used to talk.
Just talk. And at the time, Caesar is already starting to be known in the movement as someone who does yoga, who enjoys meditation, but also as someone who sees himself as a bit of a healer. He by then starts going around his community and saying that he can heal people with migraines by putting his hands on them. And so he starts doing that with Anna. He places her on the yoga mat in his office.
He tells her that this is a way to relax. The first time it was like we were talking and he told me to close my eyes and he was trying to show me pressure points and to show me how to meditate and relax. But it starts like that. And then he would start kissing on me. And I was very surprised when that happened.
I didn't understand. It is on the yoga mat while showing her these pressure points on her hands on her body that he starts kissing her. How old is he at this point? He is about 44 and Anna is 13. Did you understand what kisses were or what like how?
Not at that time. It was just, you know, not anything intense at the beginning. Eventually it got more kissing and then pretty soon it moved on to other things. And it transforms into something where he regularly calls her to his office to be physical with her. I felt I felt I had who was I going to turn to once it got passed that.
When it got passed the point when he took me to that mat to have intercourse. I mean, I didn't know who I would talk to. I had no one to turn to. And it kept on. And he would tell me not to tell anybody to keep it a secret.
You know, my friends would be jealous. So I kept it to myself. And where were her parents in all of this? Did they know what was going on? I mean, my dad was gone.
He gave everything to the movement. She says that she didn't feel like she had the space to tell them. I didn't know how he would react because he was Caesar's compadre. I didn't know if he would be mad at me. I didn't even know if he would believe me.
And I didn't want to find out. What about the others that were in this community in La Paz? Did they get suspicious about this? Did it raise any red flags or anyone else? No.
She had to pass by several people to enter his office where he would then lock the door. I mean, come on. I'm a 13-year-old girl going into his office and spending half hour or 45 minutes. And now we're there just when he's supposed to be so busy. How could they not know?
But then one day I was on my way to Caesar's office. And I ran into Debbie because Debbie's. On the past two Caesar's office, she runs into Debbie, who's 12 at the time when Anna is 13. And I ran, what were you going? And I told her where I was going.
And she looked at me like, like, what? I'm like, yeah. And so we started talking. They quickly realized that they're both going to his office and doing the same things. Oh, wow.
We looked at each other and we said, wait, we both said the same thing. Oh, he told me not to tell anybody because they would get jealous. And so it felt really like a sort of relief to have someone to finally be able to share her secret with. You know, her and I would talk to each other because we were the only ones we could talk to. You know, we felt safe with each other.
But it doesn't change Anna's dynamic with Chavez. He continued to keep her close. And over the next few years, he would bring her with him often on tour. And I thought that was a cool thing, you know, because I got to meet John Byers. She is also accompanying him in the summer of 1975, where Chavez and his organizers are preparing this long march, broken up over multiple days through California.
Around those 20 years of union organizing in California, such have traveled as one of his biggest victory. And they call it the Thousand Miles March. It's a very long march and it's going to be difficult that we're determined that we're going to get the message to every single worker. And the goal is to draw public attention to their recent victory, that gave farm workers the legal right to unionize in the state of California. That we have to walk. We can't fly and we can't ride because driving and flying is just too rapid.
And so Anna is joining him in the middle in Fresno with Debbie, her friend. It was exciting because, you know, we were participating to me. We were participating in something really good. Yeah. So Debbie and I, you know, we traveled with Caesar and his guards.
We stayed in the same houses. It was fun. I mean, it was we were always in that circle with Caesar, made us feel very special. It sounds like he's really at the peak of his influence, Chavez and of his movement's success. Like, I assume the girls can feel that as they're with him, that adoration he's being showered with.
Absolutely. It's definitely has an impact on them in the way that their secret is even more tightly held, because here they are, these two girls from farm workers' family who seem to think that they're nobodies in contrast to this great hero of the people. Why would I want to destroy the cause for me, for my life? How it affected my life? I was nobody. I was just a kid.
We'll be right back. Law transforms agreement into reality. A word becomes an agreement. An agreement becomes a contract. A contract becomes law.
Today, Harvey, the AI platform for legal work, is writing the next chapter. More than 200,000 lawyers are building with Harvey, accelerating review, sharpening negotiations, and more. This is how the future of agreements is being crafted now. Harvey, learn more at harvey.ai. Harvey does not provide legal advice.
Users should always independently review and verify any output from Harvey. Hi, this is Sarah Koenig with News About Our Latest Podcast from Serial Productions and The New York Times. It's called Metro. Well, technically, it's called Metro with Sarah Koenig, because the show is hosted by me, but I prefer the name Metro, so let's just go with Metro. Stories about New York City and its most fascinating raw material.
New Yorkers. Each week on Metro, we bring you investigations. Don't tell them to go to jail if we talk about this last night. Personal stories. I don't think this is supposed to be the word you dumb when you're talking about your death.
Essays and interviews. Are you a fan of the mayor? Yeah. I don't hate them. Stories that take the bigness of New York and make it human-scale and relevant, no matter where you live.
See, I consider myself a citizen of everywhere. So come along with me, you two jersey, and let's hang out with the best talkers in New York City. Metro, wherever you get your podcasts. So when does Ana start to break free of Chavez? It was a long process.
It took several years, but it begins the same year as the March. No, it was my 15th birthday. He asked my parents if I can go with him to a fundraiser in Bel Air. And it's when she traveled to Bel Air at a fundraiser's house. I think I was looking for him and I walked into that kitchen.
She stepped in on him kissing another woman, and she tells me that she felt disgusted by that. And had the sense of feeling betrayed. Because he always made it seem like I was the only special one in his life. I finally had somebody there that wanted just me. And why do you think it was this moment that hit her so hard?
What about it do you think really shook her in this way? I think that she realized something that she probably knew, but hadn't quite come to grasp is that she wasn't someone whom he loved or whom he saw himself being with. She was just someone who he was using. And she started pulling away. Our relationship eventually started to break down some, you know, because he, I guess he started saying he couldn't control me as much as I got older.
You know, I would speak out more. She spends less and less time with him. She eventually decides she wants to leave the community for good. I needed to get away. I needed to get away.
So I left. That's got to be a freeing moment for her. But it's not. She ends up becoming rapidly hooked to her in. So while it's supposed to be a moment of freedom, it's supposed to be a moment where she's finally not under the grip of this one man.
She is starting to use. Tried a couple of times even to OD intentionally, then I went to La Paz because my family was there so that I could try and get away and get clean from my heroin use. She decides that the only safe place to go is to the only family that she knows, which is, you know, the family living in La Paz. But also the man whom she had trusted. So she goes back.
And once she arrives, Caesar Chavez summons her to his office. He summons her the way he did it when she was a child. He calls her house and he says, you need to come to my office. And so I went, you know, I didn't think anything of it. I went.
And like all the other times, he's not alone. He's with a bunch of board members who are around Caesar and who all surround her and who started verbally attacking her. Saying what? Saying that they didn't want me there. She's a danger to the community.
They want me to be in drugs there. That she's bringing in drugs. Told me to get out. That she's no longer welcomed. I was devastated.
You know, to me, you know, I gave my life for this cause and I never asked for anything back. And the one time I went to ask for help, I was treated. I was being thrown out like trash. And she never talked to him again. So that is obviously a very devastating story, incredibly difficult to hear and to think about.
I want to just pull back and ask to what extent is on his experience reflective of broader patterns that you all uncovered in this reporting? Because story matched the other stories we were hearing from other women. The way that Cesar Chavez sort of created that special bubble for Anna to make her feel special, to have her work for him and do different tasks and spend time together alone in the office, that matched up with how he treated Deb. The same sorts of things that he was doing with Anna, he was doing with Deb.
So we've now talked to seven women with a range of allegations against him of sexual abuse, sexual assault and sexual harassment. And what we've heard from talking to those women, as well as others, is that he would sometimes have consensual affairs with adult women. And he would have also non-consensual sexual encounters with adult women as well. And one of the most prominent examples of that is Dolores Huerta, right? A civil rights icon in her own right, who also came out to say that she too was a victim of sexual abuse at the hands of Chavez.
This is a 95 year old woman. This is Dolores Huerta. This is Cesar Chavez's top female partner in the entire movement that he created. This is the woman who coined D'Sise Puerta. This is perhaps the most famous Latina activist in America.
We sat down with her for two hours and she told us Cesar Chavez sexually assaulted me. And he also manipulated me into sex in a hotel room. And she told us both of those sexual encounters led to pregnancies. And she had those babies in secret and she has held onto this secret for 60 years. We have not independently verified what Dolores told us.
However, it does match the pattern that we've heard from several women about how Cesar Chavez operated. And what about that concern that Deborah shared with you early on that her story might prompt this wave of anger towards her from people close to the movement? Has that materialized? No, it hasn't really. They've been flooded with support.
I think in many ways, like some of the backlash that they feared in coming forward has actually been directed more towards Cesar Chavez and any sort of public displays of his name and his face. I graduated from Fresno State University. There was a statue of Cesar Chavez on campus after our story published. People at first put a black cloth over it and then they put a plywood box over it to cover the statue and now that statue has been removed. Similar things have happened in other cities across California, across the country.
His name has been removed from buildings, street signs. I have received emails and texts and phone calls from people who are Mexican American who tell me that they were just devastated, that it was a painful for them to read this. It was painful for them to lose a hero. I think the country is in the middle of reckoning with his legacy. Manny, I want to ask, these women had kept this secret for decades and decades, 60 years in one case.
Cesar Chavez died in the 90s. Why did they decide to come forward now after all these years? I was talking to Deborah the other day after the story published because she was hearing or seen in the media this sort of question of why now? Deborah said, why not now? I think her point was sort of like there was never a perfect moment for Deborah to do this.
Deb said he has been a shadow over my life and I wanted to end its time. Sarah, what do you think about that question? Why now? For Anna? I think for Anna, there are several factors that come into play.
It's not just one big reason. The first one is her dad. I didn't want my dad to be so disillusioned by this man that he worked so hard with to help bring about change for the farm workers. About a year and a half ago, her father passed away. He died thinking this man did a good thing.
And so that was one of the reasons why she thought it was okay to tell her story. It made it easier. Oh, wow. And so there's that. And then there's also this one moment that she describes where she went back to La Paz when it had opened as a public monument, as a place where people could visit, learn about Caesar Chavez's life, about the movement's history.
And she had decided to go back. And there she saw pictures of Caesar, pictures of the people in his movement until she came up on his office. And his office, they have it now behind a glass wall. And it was set up how he had it. And as she looked at the office.
Right in the corner was the mat, the yoga mat. She saw the yoga mat. Oh, God. I was like, I can't believe they put that there. It's brought back so many memories.
I was like, I didn't go back anymore. It's just so unique, so rare to have a place where someone was abused, to be on display, to the wider public. At the same time, she also has come to realize that her life didn't necessarily have less value than the leader, than his, than Caesar Chavez. I'm sorry to his family, the Chavez family, for doing this to their dad. And I just want them to know that I'm sorry, but I couldn't hold it anymore.
It's time. People need to know they need to quit worshipping this person. He's just a man. He's not the Galsa. There were many men, women and children that sacrificed for this cause.
And many lives, many lives were changed because of the cause, not because of the man. It's time for the people that he hurt to speak out. Now I don't have to look at his name on his street every time I drive by. Now I can breathe easy. I don't have to carry the secret anymore.
Well, Manny, Sarah, thank you both so much. Thank you. Thank you for having us. Thank you. We'll be right back.
Law transforms agreement into reality. A word becomes an agreement. An agreement becomes a contract. A contract becomes law. Today, Harvey, the AI platform for legal work, is writing the next chapter.
More than 200,000 lawyers are building with Harvey, accelerating review, sharpening negotiations, and more. This is how the future of agreements is being crafted now. Harvey, learn more at harvey.ai. Harvey does not provide legal advice. Users should always independently review and verify any output from Harvey.
Hi, this is Carolyn Ryan, managing editor of The New York Times. At the times we strive to help everyone stay informed. And at this critical moment, we're making all of our election coverage free in our app. We have more than 100 reporters out there talking to voters, seeing what drives them, helping you figure out what's going on. On election night, we are the place to go for race results.
Our maps are updated minute by minute. Come experience all of our election coverage for free right now in The New York Times app. Here's what else you need to know today. If a country wants to send some oil into Cuba right now, I have no problem with it. Do you worry that that helps?
The White House signaled it was softening its effective oil blockade on Cuba, allowing a Russian tanker full of oil to reach the island. We allowed this ship to reach Cuba in order to provide humanitarian needs to the Cuban people. These decisions are being made on a case-by-case basis. The move comes after the administration has been blocking energy shipments to Cuba since January and threatening to punish any nation that sent fuel there. Russia said it had discussed the shipment in advance with the U.S. and that it had a duty
to support Cuba. Today's episode was produced by Olivia Nat, Lindsey Garrison, and Rob Zippko. It was edited by Michael Benoit and Liz O'Bhelan. Original music by Dan Powell and contains music by Mary and Lozano, Pat McCusker, and Alicia Butitou. Our theme music is by Wonderly.
This episode was engineered by Alyssa Moxley. That's it for the Daily, I'm Natalie Kitroweth. See you tomorrow. I'm Gilbert Cruz. This week on the Book Review Podcast, we have a special Halloween treat or treat or treat.
Two hard riders recommend some titles that are sure to keep you up at night. I am a big fan of sentient houses in general. I think this is one of the scariest books I've ever read. Listen to the Book Review, wherever you get your podcasts. That door shouldn't be open.
Who left it open? The Book Review