Welcome to the Practice Leadership Podcast from Evidence and Motion. This season we're going Beyond Clinical Work and Beyond the DPT to answer burning questions about the PT industry. Join Dr. Larry Bens nationally recognized for his expertise in private practice physical therapy and occupational medicine as he tackles the issues facing every future and current PT.
Hi, this is Larry Bens with Evidence and Motion EIM's Practice Leadership Podcast, adding value to your practice. We're in the middle of a season on how do I stay relevant as our burning question. It's a series around burning questions in physical therapy. Today we're fortunate to talk to Dr.
Corey Zimney. Corey received his master's degree from University of North Dakota and eventually his transition DPT from Des Moines University in 2010. He's currently enrolled in the candidacy phase of a PhD PT program at Nova Southeastern University and his dissertation is focusing on the construct of trust as part of the therapeutic alliance and its relation to outcomes and persistence in low back pain. Corey, hi and welcome to the podcast.
Thanks Larry, it's really great to be here, appreciate it. Corey, I want to start out, we're going to go into our burning question of how do I stay relevant in a minute. I want to first by asking about your dissertation and your research. What a wonderful topic of trust in the therapeutic alliance and how that impacts outcomes in low back pain.
What are you finding out? Yeah, so that's a good part. I was able to pass through the candidacy. I'm actually done.
I got done last year. Now it's a matter of, I was just talking to a colleague that I got the dissertation wrote but nobody reads through it 200 page dissertation. I got to get it published. I'm currently working on that so hopefully by the end of the year they'll have a couple publications so people can actually read it.
It was really interesting. Obviously the idea of trust being a portion of the therapeutic alliance has been known and other people have looked at that but we've really never been able to, in the physical therapy world, have never put the measurement tools to it. I took a few of the measurement tools that have been used in the physician literature and applied those into physical therapy practice, especially just looking at chronic low back pain. What we found out when we did the regression analysis and all that, that somewhere between 30 to 60% of the outcome could be related back to what levels of trust that the patient had in the therapist.
The tools, like I said, seemed to be able to measure that. They did match up to things like therapeutic alliance. Reaffirm the trust is a major component of the therapeutic alliance. Meaning that the functional aspects as far as how much patient got better with their osswestry score had more to do with the trust at the end.
So a patient with a high level trust at the end of the treatment, that seemed to be the bigger predictor. Then those that actually pain, though, it was interesting that from the beginning of the treatment to end the treatment, how much that trust developed and how much that got bigger. That actually correlated stronger and was a better predictor as far as the outcome goes. Really it was a combination of growing trust and also getting to a high level of trust both had depending on the outcome seemed to play into that process.
Now that I know I got a good recording tool future research will be actually looking to see how we can mess with some of the things that we do in therapy and as there are ways that we can boost that trust with our patient with the therapeutic alliance. So, yeah, definitely it was a fun project. It was fun to see it come to and reconfirms. I think we all, and we think that trust is important, but it's kind of neat to actually see that the research definitely back that up.
That truly those things that we think about how well does a patient believe in me as a therapist and is the things that I'm giving them that they can trust me that they're going to get better actually did play out in the research world too. Great. So let's say on this for a little bit because this is a topic stood here in my heart. Talk about trust as a construct.
The unique thing about trust is I think sometimes we equate it to patient satisfaction and it's different than that because patient satisfaction is looking backwards. Obviously they're related, but patients have actually more looking backwards, the patient looks back and did I get what I thought I would get and did everybody meet what I was hoping to meet where trust is actually a forward looking process. You're looking forward to determine is this something that could benefit me or that relationship that I can trust somebody going forward, that it's going to be a mutual beneficial kind of relationship or the process that they're going to do. So it is a little bit different in that aspect.
Plus trust itself has different components because there's what we call group trust and individual trust. And I think that's something obviously in general, most people in healthcare, the good thing is we have overall pretty good general trust in our profession. Individual trust pretty much everything is always higher than the group trust that we'll see across the board. But I think it's something in our profession we always need to be aware of.
We talk about things such as ethics and looking for people that might be doing things that aren't appropriate. I recognize that does have an effect on you individually when a patient comes in and sees you because if you erode some of that kind of more global societal trust in our profession, that is when a patient comes to you that they're going to be eroded in their general trust in you which could eventually as my research kind of showed that can affect your outcomes just because patients maybe don't have trust in our profession. And so that's why things just the ethical behavior and ethical billing practices and having good evidence based treatments and all those kind of things are key for the long term benefit of our profession to make sure patients trust us from a global aspect but then also from an individual aspect. Are there enhancers of trust that physical therapists can learn?
Yeah, I mean again, we haven't looked real specifically in physical therapy and that's obviously where I want to go from this and that's why I wanted to develop the tools to how to measure it. But there are certain things that obviously it seems like generally the concordance, so the more matched your our sex and gender and things like that typically will build and develop trust because you already have a little group trust from a person within your group a little bit higher. Unfortunately with my study, I didn't have enough patience to look, if they'd seen you before, is that something that develops over time? I couldn't really parse those numbers out.
And we have seen that obviously once you can develop that relationship and maintain that relationship over time, I think in the Physician literature it showed that people held that trust over a longer period of time, which makes sense if you don't trust somebody or you're going to go see somebody else until you find that person. So again, building that communication skills obviously are huge. I mean, that's probably one of the biggest predictors is how well you can communicate and communicate in a way that the patient can understand the way the patient can appreciate what you're saying. And I think sometimes too, your competency level plays into that because you have to have a certain level of competency that they know that you have the skills and abilities for the reason for them to be there that they can trust you, that you're going to provide them the best care possible and that you know what you need to do to take care of them properly.
So those are some of the bigger ones that kind of jump out in the general literature in regards to trust. Well, it's fascinating. I actually just to learn more about it. I do know some of the stuff around proxy efficacy and self-efficacy and they're matching based on the literature.
And I focused a little bit on that in the call to care book and that is that we all want our patients to believe that they have the best therapists for them and your belief that you're a good therapist and how to measure that and all those things that have to do with self-efficacy, there's some matching there. So that's really good stuff. You know, as we migrate into some virtualization aspect of our healthcare experiences with perhaps some visits being done to be a telehealth and those kinds of things, the trust, efficacy, self-efficacy, proxy efficacy, empathy, high quality connections, all those things are going to have their fair share of challenges in those environments. But they could probably be overcome with low back pain in particular.
That is an incredibly high correlation between trust and outcomes. So it would do as well to learn some trust components, right? Yep, yep. I mean, obviously what we do clinically definitely always makes a difference.
Obviously, it's not 100% either direction. You know, it's not just developing trust. It's not just doing the right exercises, but we got to appreciate that it's really both. And I think so many times clinicians, you see clinicians fall one direction or the other.
You know, they get so concerned about getting the right exercises, doing the right manual technique, you know, learning their skills, which again, those are important. And then they forget the importance of just the personal aspect. And then you see other people that just really strive on creating this great personal relationship with a patient, but they're just not delivering the right kind of quality of care. And really to be a great clinician is you need both.
You know, I think it's something that we get stuck on is this or that. It's obviously it's a case of it's both. And you need to be a really good clinician with good clinical skills and good clinical decision-making. And you've got to have these personality traits that allow you to connect with patients.
And when you put the two together, you can really get some good outcomes and make a difference in patient lives. Well, that's fantastic. And a good launching point for the burning question, which is how do I stay relevant? And we're going to attack that in multiple ways.
Perhaps let's rephrase it for our first set here. And how do I stay up to date with information? There are, I don't know, hundreds of daily newsletters you can read. There are tons of, you know, there's no barriers to entry to news or media or information.
And being able to sift through it is more challenging now than at any time, not only sifting through for what is fake news and what isn't, but what is reliable and what is worth my time to spend on. And what is the right part there? What are some thoughts you have? Yeah, I had such a great question.
And really, I almost take a correlate to what we're finding, again, going back to our back patients, you know, like, you know, what's the right exercise to do? And it costs the board, you look, whether it's yoga, Pilates, whether you do a course ability, whether you do general, whether you just have a walk on a treadmill, whether you go outside and ride a bike, whether it's swimming in a pool, in the end, it really doesn't seem to make a big difference, you know? But what makes a big difference is what's important to what works for that patient, you know, which one do they enjoy? And when it comes to, I think, all, like you said, all the different avenues, I don't know if it matters where you quote unquote get it as long as it's in a system of a format that works for you individually.
And I think as an individual, that's our key role is to figure out, you know, try something and say, is this something I can keep up with? You know, do I like it coming through my email? Would I rather see it on Twitter? Would I rather go to a website and get a newsletter?
Is it journal articles? Do I prefer reading through abstracts? Is it following a few key people that I know treat the way I do? And I'm just going to follow their inputs.
So there's so many different ways. And I think some of it's, yeah, finding it within your lifestyle, your schedule, what you can do to be the most efficient because you can drown yourself out and try to take in so much information, you never actually get out actually using it. But you have to gather that information, but then also be able to use it with your patients and define that right mix. That's an individual personal question that really a person has to just spend some time in reflection and put the time, just like in business, you know, you got to put some time into planning and that strategic planning and process and all that because that's where the outcomes are going to come.
And the same thing is done on an individual basis is looking at how do I best get this information that works for me, my schedule, and then again, how do I then be able to relate that to the kind of care that I do and really that's strong individual reflection that each person has to do on their own? That's interesting. So let me stretch this a little bit. One of the ways I kept up with lots of information during COVID was a Twitter list of those who I trusted, you know, MDs, folks that were doing research, those that had, you know, were doing clinical trials.
And it was a very effective list. Are there other mechanisms other than, you know, influencers and certain types between Twitter and other social media that allow you in a more efficient way to stay up to date with clinical information? Yeah, I think, you know, I think that is one of the better ways just because of the stream that the information comes through. And again, that way you said you don't have to vet it.
If you already know it's somebody that's reliable, you don't have to, they've kind of done that work for you. So I think that that's advantageous to some degree. What I would challenge people to every now and then to just from a thinking standpoint is every now and then look at somebody that you maybe don't agree with and listen to their argument and then try to figure out why they might be coming from that direction and what are the other alternative hypothesis that they can, why they might be thinking that way and why you might not want to go that direction just to constantly always challenge ourselves because then sometimes we can get too much into a single group think. I'm not saying I would do it, you know, only listen to the other side, but just occasionally do that to kind of challenge ourselves to, you know, look at that one or that person that kind of goes against the grain.
And at least looks down and say, why would they even think that, you know, a lot of times will come up. Yeah, it's a personal, you know, avenue that they're taking to get gain and we quickly realize, yeah, that's not a direction I want to go. But I think, you know, again, different people I know sometimes even just some of the main journals that you might be interested in, you can get their abstracts, you know, dump immediately into your that's a way to keep up on those things, you know, your state associations, you know, people within your state or if you're, you know, even within your clinics, you know, creating those discussion groups that because if you get like minded clinicians that work together well, you can have each person search out and then you guys share individually together in your groups in a clinic of three, four, five therapists, whatever your clinic is, or other avenues, you know, that, you know, the beauty here at the university that I teach at, I go down the hallway and I chat with my fellow colleagues and I get great input from stuff that they're learning from other people. So yeah, it's that personal connection with other people, whether it's through the social medias, the Twitter's Instagram accounts, YouTube videos, wherever they're posting and stuff.
But also don't forget those other personal connections just to people in your area, people that might be in your clinic, those might be avenues to if you had to, if you're advising a new graduate PT who is just inundated with development opportunities, both in classic sort of continuing education, consideration of residency, what journals, research articles, what would you advise them would be a good framework for staying relevant and more importantly staying up to date with clinical information? Yeah, I think you need to find a method, some kind of process that fits to the way that you think I know early on I kind of did the potpourri where I took a course here and of course there and of course there and it just, it gets you confused as a clinician because you recognize that it seems like they're speaking different languages. Yeah, I can look back now 20, 30 years later and recognize, oh, they had these similar principles of mind, but that took me a long time to get there as a newer grad, I would find a system that seems, you know, logical within the way that you think and the way that you want to practice and really kind of dive into that. But also, too, like we already talked about previously is recognized, especially from the clinical skills that's valuable, but in the personal skill area, take time to read books.
I can't overemphasize them if I have our students in our business class, they have to read a leadership book and usually they come back and tell me that's one of the more enjoyable things, they actually got to read a non-PT book and they learn a ton and it's like, yes, you can learn so much about and there's, you know, and I said, well, what book to pick? And I'm like, that's the beauty of leadership and personal development, because there's so many out there, you will never run out and you will gain information from everyone that you read. So I mean, most entrepreneurs, they'll tell you there, you know, a lot of people are reading at least a book a month, some of them a book a week and I'm saying that you're going to be able to keep up that kind of pace, but that's why Bill Gates is a great development. But you should be at least reading two or three a year at a minimum to kind of just develop that personal side that's going to, you know, get those personal aspects.
So I think you need to develop that, you can do a lot on your own. There's courses you can take and people can do there, but a lot of that, I think just with books, you can do that on your own, but the clinical side, yeah, I would find a method kind of stick with it and just get down deeper into that process mechanism. I think that's very sound advice. I think the other thing is find somebody that'll keep you accountable to your growth and development.
If you're employed at any institution, that's really what mentoring is all about. It's not so much applying the clinical skills and helping you with those, which is also important. But somebody that will definitely meet regularly with you, talk about your development, where you're at, where you're going, re-imagining your position in the next couple of years and what you look like over a sound period of time. Let's shift a little bit to staying relevant in terms of our patients, accessing them.
How do we enhance trust using some of your research with patients by staying relevant and up to date with information and connecting with them? Yeah, I think, and again, it's just having those conversations with patients that what are just the basic concepts really getting down to what their goals and what they want to get back to and show that you're totally invested into them. I look back in my career and there was times that I maybe wasn't the best therapist because I was just worried about getting to the next patient and I knew I had to do all these exercises and I had to do these manual techniques because I had to get their spinal mobility or their core stability better. That was what I thought they needed.
Instead, just realizing they want to be able to pick up their kid as they're walking through the grocery store and really relaying back to those true personal things that the patient wants, what are their values, what are their goals, and really paying attention to those kind of things. I think early on in my career I probably got stuck more on those more superficial goals of range of motion, strength that, you know, which again we need to develop those but did it relate directly to what that patient wanted to do. And the patient did, the patient fully understood that if I was having them do this exercise that it that relates directly to that outcome that you want to accomplish so that they can see the connection because they're going to recognize again from a trust standpoint, they're going to recognize you're on their side and that everything you're doing is directed towards their benefit, their improvement, not just because I'm just another rotator cuff repair. I'm the next person that had a total knee that came in and everybody that's a total knee gets the same thing that yes, I have a patient with a total knee but I also have grandkids and I want to get back to the golf course and improve my swings so I get back with my buddies and doing specifics to that and being able to relate those things.
And again those aren't long conversations, it's just paying attention to those little details that are hugely important. Got it. Any specific recommendations on the clinical aspects of staying up to date, specific journals, specific newsletters, methods of access from being able to go right to a database or repository, you know the physicians have their sort of up to date app that they use and others instruments. What are the popular ones in PT?
Yeah, you know, I think that's a lot of clinicians, we are at universities when we're students and we get access to the library and a lot of clinicians don't recognize that being a member of the APTA, you have access to the ProQuest database and through the website so you can actually get access to pretty much every major journal. And obviously depending on your clinical area of practice, mind being primarily orthopedics, you know, yeah getting musculoskeletal science and practice, physio theory of practice, getting JSPT, reading through those as your kind of key journals is going to keep you relevant in those areas. Obviously we talk social media but just what we're doing here, podcasting. There are a lot of good physical therapy podcasts out there, you know, I can self promote the one that I get to get to be a part of, you know.
And so yeah, I mean, you know, you know, PTL, you know, we have a blast just talking to experts in what they do and again, a way to pull that information from them and tricks that they're doing and stuff that they're reading. Those are another great method to stay relevant with that information. And so again, it's finding those resources of how to do that again based on your lifestyle. That's excellent.
And you know, traditionally, we used to for back in the early days of teaching EVP about push and pull methods. And effectively, what I hear you saying is you still have to do that. It's just some of the pull methods and push methods may have changed. And podcasting is a really good example of that where you can listen to, in this case, Master Clinicians debate all things clinical.
And there's a variety of ways to do that on the leadership and management. There's almost too many choices. There's not a lot of lack of content. And fortunately, there's not a lack of free content, whether it be in YouTube videos, whether it be podcasts and the like.
And so there's a it's a really good time right now relative to staying up to the date. I want to talk to you a bit about some things that have happened during COVID relative to, you know, the profession. You know, there is without question, higher incidences right now of, you know, call it calcification, call it burnout, call it dehumanization. There is in record numbers on the nursing side shortages, you know, despite there being more opportunities become a nurse at any other given time and part right now because of how hard they're working in the work environments that they're in.
And totally, we're seeing similar things in PT, a significant number of PTs who are either for load or asked to work part time or who were terminated during COVID has not come back to the workforce for a variety of means. Reported burnout is at its all time high. What are you saying on the academic side of things that could help assuage this or give us some thoughts around this whole topic? Yeah, we're just tired right now.
I mean, there's another way to say it is. It has been an exhausting year and a half almost coming up on two here and stuff like that that we've had to deal with all this. You know, I think it's that individual, again, when it goes back to taking care of our health that we know the things that are important for our individual health that you got to get some away time, you got to have some meditation mindfulness type practice, you got to focus in on your diet, you got to focus in on getting exercise and during these moments and these times when you're going to burnout more, you got to double down even that much harder and stay that much more disciplined to them. It's going to be easier to get derailed from those practices because of the business and everything else.
And you have to almost do the reverse and become even more disciplined and more specific as far as this is my exercise time. And that's, you know, personally, I mean, during this challenge, I am more disciplined and remind myself more so my morning quiet time where I do my meditation and prayer time that I can't be here from that at all because it's too easy to get distracted and pulled away from it. And then saying, I know I haven't done it for two weeks. And I found myself early in the pandemic.
I felt I was just spinning wheels trying to figure out how I was going to get all these courses online and how we're going to deliver everything. It was just a disruption. And I realized that as I felt like, I mean, I recognize I was working more hours, but I was getting less done and I realized what I had to do was get back to my discipline practices of having my quiet time, making sure that I could exercise, making sure that my diet was, you know, online that I was getting to bed at regular time, getting up. And so really doubling down on those personal things that we know are just positive for overall health, you have to even be more disciplined and more committed to them during a difficult and challenge time because the challenging time is going to pull you away from those practices.
I mean, you're going to try to just like, I got all this to do and I have this and you have to double down even harder and stay more committed to those. Absolutely. I think the least selfish thing you can do is be selfish about your own self care. It's best for you.
And it's also best for your patients. It really is. And that is very, very good and very insightful. You know, I think that this is going to continue to be a challenge in a profession that has at least by most standards of measurement, had reimbursement, had wind, had impacted the decrease in reimbursement by about 30% in the last several years, understaffing in many, many areas.
We are seeing anecdotally a softening in the application pool at PT and we're seeing a big reduction in application pool in nursing right now. When just a few months ago, or literally maybe a year ago now, we were talking about the heroes in health care and what tremendous things to do. So we've gone from being heroes to being a burned out profession that has to share challenges. So this is going to be certainly some interesting times.
I want to ask you a couple unrelated questions before we go, but it's back to your research a little bit. Can you define for our listeners, we throw terms like therapeutic alliance around a lot. Can you define from your perspective as a clinical researcher what you mean by it? Yeah, so therapy alliance, Borden did some of the original work psychology wise again, was this idea that you have this idea of shared goals that you're working towards and a shared treatment and really the bond.
So that was this connection that you had to have was what you were going to do and the goal that it was accomplished. But that's the whole idea of the bond, this connection between each other. Really is that therapeutic alliance, therapeutic relationship, however, it's been termed different ways within that. But really it's that connection, and portions of that obviously and the neat thing about physical therapy is that part of that, and again, I know when just a side note, people talk about this whole conversation, you need to do manual therapy, not do manual therapy.
It's interesting when patients come to physical therapy, they expect to be touched. And that is a connecting point. That's part of the bond that occurs between a clinician and a patient. And patients look for that.
It's an important aspect. We can talk about all we want about what's really happening with that, what's physiologically, happens psychologically, all of those things. And I guess one thing I always stress to students or anytime I'm lecturing, that we need that hands-on component is key in our profession and not to give that up. I realize telehealth and things like that, there's challenges there and stuff.
But when possible, we do have to get our hands-on patients, because that's a communication point and that's a part of that bond development that can occur, which really will boost therapeutic alliance. So you see clinicians, they're not getting their hands-on patient, whether it's the formalized manual therapy or just that you're guiding techniques or laying a helping hand on their shoulder. We need to have that touch. So a little side kind of rant to mine there.
I think we see clinicians back away that they just do the exercises and are at a distance because they're clipboard or they're a computer. We need to physically get into that patient space because I think that's where the bonds develop, is that a patient's going to feel comfortable and safe with you in their space. And that's only going to be people that you trust. When we just look at communication distances, there's public communication distance, personal conversation distance gets a little closer, but that intimate relationship, and that's what we as clinicians do, is we create that intimate relationship by getting in close and tight.
And I think that manual therapy and those touch type of moments allow for that. And that then thus is going to develop trust as that component in that area. So it's really that bond that we create along with, again, a shared treatment and those shared goals that a patient has. Oh, that's great.
I think it's interesting that you related to patient expectation, which I think is absolutely true about the touch side of things. And it's not just in PT, by the way. There's been some interesting research around the impact of touch on everything from how much you'll tip a waitress or a waiter to your degree of confidence. Touch, in some cases, is a placebo effect, if you will.
So very, very interesting stuff. Well, last question. Then we're going to let you go. This has just been a fascinating conversation.
Tell us more about PT elevated your podcast. Yeah, no, got a great opportunity. Last year, Adrian said, we're looking to kind of move the podcast. And it's something I've always thought would be fun.
I drive 45 minutes to and from work. So I listened to lots of podcasts. So I said, well, don't look. I said, I know I should probably say no every now and then, but this is what I'm going to say yes to.
So Paul Menken and JJ Thomas also from the evidence and motion group joined me. And so we just get a chance to look for clinicians and sometimes researchers as well, but just looking for those clinical pearls, really looking at what are some things that we can all learn from, whether we've been in practice three, four years or 30 years. But what are some of these experts, these people in the trenches, doing day in and day out? And how do they look at it and see it?
And I think there's just so much wisdom to be gained from some of the things that they're doing. So yeah, it's been a great opportunity. We just got done with our first season, taking a little bit of a break to catch up on other things. And we'll start up here again, another month or two with another set of 12 podcasts and stuff, but really kind of getting into just those clinical aspects of how do we treat some of the basic kind of muscle-scale of the care that comes across most of our outpatient clinics, our hospital-based clinics, and really kind of talking to experts out in the field.
So really, it's really been fun just just just glinging those insights and wisdom from people that are in the trenches. And that was always kind of our goal is really what's that clinical aspect, you know, research on research and myself. It's interesting and stuff, but it's more important how you can use that on Monday when you see a patient and that's more of the conversations that we have. What are things that you can use on Monday with your patients, which is kind of been fun.
Now that's outstanding. And we will with the show notes as we post the podcast, we will post information not only about you, but your podcast as well. So, Corey, I can't thank you enough. Keep up with the great stuff.
Love the whole concept behind trust and therapy, alliance, anything we can do to enhance the practitioner staying relevant, all things, information overloads in spite of that. What are the tools? So thank you for distilling all that for us. And we'll catch up with you another time.
That's okay. Perhaps we'll revisit in about a year how we're all staying relevant to all things that have been in the profession of physical therapy. So thank you. That sounds great, Larry.
Thanks so much. Thanks for listening to the EIM Practice Leadership Podcast for season three. Burning questions with your host, Dr. Larry Bands.
Check out www.evidenceinmotion.com forward slash blog for more information on the podcast, guest, and the latest in the world of physical therapy, leadership, and the future of the profession.