Hi, I'm Solana Pine. I'm the director of video at the New York Times. For years, my team has made videos that bring you closer to big news moments, videos by Times journalists that have the expertise to help you understand what's going on. Now, we're bringing those videos to you in the Watch tab in the New York Times app.
It's a dedicated video feed where you know you can trust what you're seeing. All the videos there are free for anyone to watch. You don't have to be a subscriber. Download the New York Times app to start watching.
I'm Mr. Klum. This is the Ezra Klum Show. Before I get to the conversation, a quick announcement.
I'm going to be taking a month off the show to rest to read, to think, we're going to have great SSO's while I'm gone and I'll be back in early September. There are these lines in Last White Man, most in Hamid's beautiful new book, but I keep coming back to it. And they have nothing really to do with the central plot of the book, the one that is getting all the headlines and reviews and commentary, this mysterious, inexorable darkening of everyone's skin in an unnamed town in an unknown country. But in this part, Hamid is describing the father of the main character, Anders.
And Anders' father is sick, and he is dying. And Hamid writes of him, quote, standing was hard enough, and he ignored his pain for it was part of him now, constant, not remotely bearable, but also not avoidable, and so put up with like a nasty sibling. There are people I love right now who are in a lot of pain these days, and nothing I've read gave me more access to them or felt like it did than this book. The Last White Man is a bit of a heavy-handed title for a story with a very light touch.
I don't really think it's about what it claims to be about. I don't think race is the center of this book. I think losses and the question of what truly we'll miss when it is lost to us, as everything will be from our health to our loved ones to one day, our own lives. And what is thinking about loss and imagining how we might react to it?
What does that tell us about what should matter to us now? Hamid is an award-winning novelist. He's supposed to be in the horror and London and New York, and his books have this strange quality of feeling like parables. He often seems in them to be tweaking the conditions of our world, to try to ask what moral or political assumptions prove most fragile.
What do we take for granted today that our descendants might wonder how we ever believed, how we believe in such myths or participated in such injustice? We're responding to such idiocy or something so tissue paper-thin. That's a good question. As always, my email is Rapuncho at nytimes.com.
Most in Hamid, welcome to the show. Thank you. The new book revolves very much around this idea of whiteness. And whiteness is one of these ideas, these concepts, that is a little maddening to try to get your hands around, and changes very dramatically, I think, depending on who describes it.
So how would you describe it? If one of your kids asks you, what is whiteness? What does it mean? What does it give you?
What would you say? I think that I'd probably stop by saying it's something that's been imagined into existence. So it's unclear to me if there's really such a thing as whiteness. I think that whiteness is one of these imaginary categories.
But once it's imagined into existence, it does all kinds of stuff, and it operates in the world. And it means that some people imagine themselves as belonging to a group that's white, and others not. And it means that other people also, I think, react to that. It's a strange, I guess, imaginary game that I would tell, I was supposed to tell my kids.
But the game is very real when it gets played. So I've heard you say the two things happen to you personally, after 9-11. One is that you put on a bunch of muscle, got a lot taller, became more intimidating, at least the way other people saw you. And I don't want to blow up your spot here, but you don't seem that intimidating, and gigantic here on our Zoom.
But the other is that you lost your whiteness. And that was a whole other thing to grapple with. Tell me about that experience. Well, I went to elite American universities, and I lived in mostly in the Bay Area, the northeast.
I was living in New York City, so very cosmopolitan enclaves. And I had a well-paying job. And so discrimination was for me mainly sort of an annoyance. It wasn't something that I considered as particularly important in my life.
I was aware of it, but it didn't bother me too much in how I live my life. And then, suddenly, after 9-11, I found that I'm being pulled out of lines at the airport. And given enhanced security, I was once pulled off an aircraft from the tarmac. I would fly into JFK and at immigration, they'd put you in a room for a few hours, and you'd wait for somebody, and then they'd ask you all kinds of questions about combat training.
I'd get onto a bus, you know, on the weekend, a bit unshaven, with a backpack, and people would look uncomfortable, and sometimes they would change their seats. And suddenly, I felt I was this object of suspicion or even threat. And I experienced that really as a profound sense of loss. I wanted things to go back to how they were pre-9-11, but time passed.
I began to ask myself if I hadn't been complicit in something, and if it was maybe a mistake to want to go back. Tell me about some of the subtleties of what you noticed that you lost, because it's interesting. I mean, you're not categorically in the way people construct those categories, white. So to say you lost whiteness, to say you lost as you're suggesting an ability to move through society, what were some of the subtleties of that, beyond airports, beyond trains?
What happened as the way people understood you changed? Well, as a brown guy with a Muslim sounding name, I certainly wasn't white. But when I think about how race works in people's lives, in my life, I've been able to get the job I wanted and go to universities I wanted, and mostly date the people I wanted. Life hadn't felt particularly constrained.
What changed was the idea that there was something attaching itself to me and to my kind in a way that was limiting. Suddenly, the idea of being able to travel easily of my parents visiting me in America, of imagining to live this existence between different cultures and different countries, became much more difficult to imagine. I moved to London somewhere in 2001, and my first trip back to the US a couple of months later, it was like an entirely different country. I remember strange things would happen in the sense of conversations with people's families, about terrorism and Muslims, and you're not that kind.
It was strange because it was as though my category of person, which while not white, was not particularly important, and so therefore not really deserving of much attention and allowed to pass, had become a category that was deserving of more attention, and given certain values. And I was picking up on strangenesses, my own reluctance when I was traveling to the world, and non-coastal parts of America, rural parts of America, to tell people where I was quote unquote from, the idea of going down to the hotel bar, or hotel restaurant, and some, you know, more from my mind, remote part of America, suddenly being kind of more of a choice, you know, should I do this? And the stories of so many friends, you know, somebody waking up and having the FBI bang on their door or somebody not being allowed to board a flight to the country or people breaking up relationships coming to an end. It was there, I guess, in the whole ether.
It was all around. I wonder if this is at least one possible definition of this kind of whiteness, one that people who have it, including very much me, probably underrated some importance, but I want to try it on you, that this kind of whiteness is the absence of limiting or prejudicial assumptions about you as you move through the world. I think that's right. I mean, maybe not a complete absence.
But it's an, I guess it's an idea that you are the default setting, that you are what is human, that to be you is to sort of come across as normal in a way. And of course, you could be dangerous, you could be, you know, threatening, you could be many things. But the starting assumption is human. And I think what begins to happen as you move away from that is having to overcome assumptions that in some ways you are not normal.
You are not human. You don't get the benefit of the doubt. And in that sense, whiteness is the invention of whiteness. So this category of whiteness is perhaps more rooted in needing to have another category.
In other words, if you didn't need for there to be people who didn't have the category of human, you wouldn't need whiteness as a subcategory that meant human. What is a relationship between Unibok, the last white man, and that post 9-11 experience you had? So the novel begins with a young man named Anders, who thinks of himself as white. And he wakes up one morning and he's dark.
But when he'd gone to bed the night before, he hadn't been. And I think in some senses that experience of suddenly occupying a different racial category was perhaps imaginatively born in my own experience of feeling something strange happen to my own category. I mean, there's a way to describe the book as I suppose grounded in my own experience. You know, there's an aspect of the novel which is to say, this is partly my story.
That's something that just happened to me. But I think there's another way of thinking about writing. You know, a large part of writing is trying to imagine being other people. You know, at least for me, a huge reason why I'm drawn to fiction is to, in a sense, play make-belief, like a little kid when you pretend being a pirate or an astronaut.
And it's something I've always been drawn to doing. And so my journey into the character of Anders and the other characters in the book wasn't only, or perhaps even primarily, a journey into my own experience of what happened to me. But it was that experience giving me, I guess, an opening to give myself permission to imagine these characters in a world where their whiteness is starting to disappear. Because I thought this is a phenomenon that is really important.
I mean, it impacts so many things. Whiteness and the reactions to whether it's being lost. And it's a reassertion that I wanted to get into it with characters who were white and who weren't in a sense, brown skinned, you know, Muslim named men experiencing what I experienced. And I do want to note for people who maybe hear the title and think they know what the book is about, you never say where the story is happening, but I very much read it as not happening in America.
Anders and Una, the names felt Scandinavian to me. It feels European to me. Maybe that's a wrong assumption. You can correct it if it is.
But if it's not, why do you decide to place the book outside of the United States, given the central dialogue of whiteness that we've had here in the past couple of years? It's really interesting because the way the book is designed, and we can speak more about that, but I very much think of novels, and particularly my novels as kind of half novels. They are words that are then imagined by readers into an experience, which includes the way people look and what a place is like and what conversations people are having. In a sense, I think that film and television, as the dominant mastery produced storytelling forms, already give us worlds that look like the world and sound like the world.
And so the novel might perhaps usually do something else. And so I try to write novels that are full of gaps and that, for example, don't rely particularly on dialogue. They don't rely on physical description too much and that allow the reader to animate them. And in that process, with this book, the reader is given a choice, I suppose, in terms of where they want this to occur.
And you just said that when you read it, it felt like it wasn't set in America. But many people who read it have said to me that it felt like it was set in America. And I think the choice as to whether it's set in America or not set in America is really left up to the reader's own sort of imaginative stance and how you want to read it. I didn't intend it as being either of or not of America.
I wanted to leave that choice to the reader, but I would say that I've had some people say what you just said in America, saying that this doesn't feel like it's set in America, but I probably had more say that it feels like it was set in America. So it's interesting. People read it differently. That's actually a good segue maybe to reading a bit of it.
And you mentioned there the way it's written, the kind of imaginative space in it. It's written with very, very little direct dialogue. It's a beautiful, formalistic book. The kind of book that's imprinted on the way I thought for a little while, I'll be thinking in the rhythm of your writing, which is a little bit weird.
Do you mind reading the first few paragraphs of the novel? Sure. One morning Anders, a white man, woke up to find he had turned a deep and undeniable brown. This dawned upon him gradually and then suddenly, first as a sense as he reached for his phone, that the early light was doing something strange to the color of his forearm.
Subsequently, and with a start, as a momentary conviction that there was somebody else in bed with him, male, darker. But this, terrifying though it was, was surely impossible. And he was reassured that the other moved as he moved was in fact not a person, not a separate person, but it was just him, Anders, causing a wave of relief. For if the idea that someone else was there was only imagined, then of course the notion that he had changed color was a trick too, an optical illusion, or a mental artifact, born in the slippery halfway place between dreams and wakefulness.
Except that by now he had his phone in his hands and he reversed the camera, and he saw that the face looking back at him was not his at all. Anders gambled out of his bed and began to rush to his bathroom, but calming himself. He forced his gate to slow, to become more deliberate, measured, and whether he did this to assert his control over the situation, to compel reality to return through sheer strength of mind, or because running would have frightened him more, made him forever into prey being pursued. He did not know.
The bathroom was shabbily but comfortably familiar, the cracks in the tiles, the dirt and the grouting, the street of dried toothpaste drips. The interior of the medicine cabinet was visible, the mirror door skew, and Anders raised his hand and swung his reflection into place before his eyes. It was not that of an Anders he recognized. It was overtaken by emotion, not so much shock or sorrow, though those things were there too, but above all the face replacing his, filled him with anger, or rather more than anger, an unexpected, murderous rage.
He wanted to kill the colored man who confronted him here in his home, to extinguish the life animating this other's body, to leave nothing standing but himself as he was before. And he slammed the side of his fist into the face, cracking it slightly, and causing the whole fitting, cabinet, mirror and all, to skew, like a painting after an earthquake has passed. Anders stood, the pain in his hand, muted by the intensity that had seized him, and he felt himself trembling, our vibration so faint as barely to be perceptible, but then stronger, like a dangerous winter chill, like freezing outdoors, unsheltered, and it drove him back to his bed, and under his sheets, and he laid there for a long while, hiding, willing this day, just begun, please, please, not to begin. So right at the beginning there is almost a beat for beat reference to the beginning of Franz Kafka's The Metamorphosis.
Tell me a little bit about that reference for you. I've always been really drawn to early mid-20th century modernist writers in writing. I think that I'm not sure what it was initially, whether it was just the formal games they played, the way they tried to bend reality could think about how novels were built. What I'm talking about, you know, writers like Paul Head was born here, and Calvino, Camus, Virginia Woolf, and of course Kafka.
But I think in retrospect, I mean, the period that they were writing in was remarkably similar to our own. So you had a time of warfare, you had a time of intensifying ethnic, racial conflict and polarization, you had technological leaps happening, and you had a sense that modernity and the future had gone off the rails, things were no longer headed in the direction that we had hoped. And so these writers, I think, started to think about how literature could respond, like how do you rebuild an awful? What do you do with it?
What do we do with the way that reality is constructed through oral storytelling and through written storytelling? And so I've always been, I guess, attracted to that in a sense in a conversation with that particular project. And Kafka's book, in particular, I mean Kafka's story, I guess, is of enormous significance, the idea that you can do this with fiction. But what felt interesting to me about the metamorphosis was it felt almost like it wasn't a magical transformation, but it was instead something that was inspired by a technological moment, but it felt that it was right for the moment in which it found itself occurring.
And it seemed to me that that was the right feeling for this, that it's not a genie or the spirit of Adrize's grandmother, that transforms him. It's something else. It's something about the particular cultural, scientific, technological, sociological place. And so yeah, that was my way in.
Tell me a bit about that technological moment idea. So what is the technological moment as you understand it that Kafka is writing from? And then what's yours? How would you describe the technological moment inspiring this book for you?
So when Kafka's writing, the Industrial Revolution has, in a sense, already come to fruition. So it begins in Britain, but in Germany, Austria, and the part of the world where Kafka finds himself, it comes a bit later. And by the early 20th century, people are doing all sorts of jobs that have expanded productivity by breaking down tasks into smaller subtasks. And part of the reaction people are having to this is a sense of alienation, a sense that, you know, what is the connection between what I do and meaning?
And alongside that is we are seeing the rise of new kinds of animosities, or perhaps the re-emphasis on old kinds of animosities. And so in a world where people are being alienated by the workplace, that alienation is then seized upon, I think, politically, to be redirected towards, most obviously towards the Jews of Central Europe at that time, and as an outgroup. And I think in the metaphors we're seeing this, we're seeing both one's individual feeling of being made not human or less than human in a particular economic environment, and also the current willingness or ability to redirect our gaze towards other people and to make them not human. And that's the backdrop, I suppose, for the Metamorphosis.
Today, I think, again, there are things happening, but there are slightly different nature, although the willingness to redirect them towards hatred towards other groups is perhaps maintained or rekindled. But the difference is, I think in our current technological cultural moment, what's happening is that, you know, as we merge with our screens, and we spend almost one of time staring into our screens and doing things with them, we're encountering a sort of machine culture that is, by its very nature, sort of sorting-based. A huge amount of our cultural activity now is sorting things. Do I like this or not like this?
Do I follow this person or not follow this person? Is this person like me or not like me? And if I identify a meaningful aspect of their identity, which is not like me, the person is fundamentally in some way opposed to me and in conflict with me. And what we have to do for a lot of people is to separate form or even worse, you know, extinguish the people who are not like us.
And so in the last white man, I guess, the move that I'm making slightly different from the move that Kafka's making, Kafka, Kafka makes a move that shows us how one person can cease to feel human. And one person can suddenly be looked at by others as not human. I think what I'm trying to do is slightly different in the sense that what I'm engaged in is a project which removes the possibility of a particular kind of sorting mechanism. In other words, if you can't tell what race somebody is, you removed from a machine lens on people and you kind of deal with them as people.
And what happens if that's just upon you and what occurs in such a world? I think that point about us living in a nature of technological sorting is really profound. And as you said, it's something else occurred to me, which is that the first run of, I think you're heavily talking about social media technologies, about identity technologies online about the way we spend our time and having given to us now digitally. Round one was sorting and round two has been prediction, both in terms of all the algorithms predicting what we like and in that way, shading what we end up liking, but also in the sense of the political campaigns that unleash their algorithms on huge amounts of consumer data to figure out how to do that.
And so I think that's a very important concept of consumer data to figure out who we're going to vote for, the advertising campaigns that are sorting us into this kind of consumer, that kind of consumer. And there's an interesting way in which the lived economic reality of endless prediction conflicts with what we tell children, sometimes tell ourselves, which is that we're all individuals, we're all special. You can't judge people by their group or their appearance because you'll get it wrong. We can tell people that all we want, but as we build an economy that is increasingly oriented around pumping money towards companies that predict what we are going to do based on a fairly limited amount of data about who we are.
Or really sending the opposite cultural message in, I suspect, a much more credible way. I think that's right. And I think that for me, one thing which is very interesting is when we talk about going from sorting to prediction, which I think is correct, that is something that's happening. We tend to imagine that predicting is an observational activity.
In other words, that technology is allowing us to see where we might go as individuals and to predict. But I think that prediction is actually much more perniciously a behavior modification activity. In other words, making us into more predictable beings. And that I think is by far the greater danger.
In other words, if we want to be able to predict people, partly we need to do the model what they do. But partly we would want them to be predictable. They should be inclined towards doing certain things. And so if you take somebody with a sorting mechanism, if you give them information that plays upon humans in eight sense of prioritizing the information about threats, economic threats, racial threats, we prioritize that information.
What begins to happen is it's not just that the way we were going to behave remains unchanged. The way we are going to behave also changes, and it changes in predictable ways. So it isn't simply the case that machines are better able to understand humans. It is also the case that machines are making human beings more like machines, that we are trying to rewrite our programming in such a way that we can be predicted.
And for me, that's the more frightening aspect of the shift from sorting to prediction. That brings up something for me that I noticed when doing preface episode, which is that as far as I can tell, you have no social media presence at all. Tell me about that. Yeah, I guess I was also a little bit suspicious of it.
And perhaps even more than suspicious of it, I was suspicious of myself in relationship to it. So I tried to stay off social media. And then some years ago, my agent and my editor said, look, you've got a book coming out. You should really consider having a social media presence and getting on Facebook and Twitter.
And so I opened these accounts. And very quickly, I observed the hooks of the thing. I observed how I was interested in how many people were following me and how popular a particular comic was. And I felt sort of the addictive nature.
Anybody who's sort of smokes cigarettes or had any other kind of addiction in their lives will know that feeling of being hooked on a thing. And also I felt very quickly I began to observe its effects on me, the kind of self-promotional side of myself that it unleashed and the performative nature of what it was. And I became pretty uncomfortable with it pretty fast. And so after a few months, I got off.
It wasn't something that I was innately, I guess, inclined towards. And having tried it, I thought it brought out much of the worst in me. So not something I wanted to pursue. It strikes me there's a little bit of an odd intersection here, which is, I think what is addicting to people about social media is that it is a way of manipulating status.
And we are all very, very conscious of our standing in the community. And so too is our parents so too is race so too is the way we look to others. And the way the thought experiment or the central change happens in the book is that nothing is changing to our knowledge, except pigmentation. Whatever basket of qualities that somebody might think that race applies to, there's no evidence of that basket of qualities is changing.
Your lineage isn't changing, your parents aren't changing who you are isn't changing, but your skin changes. And particularly because it's happening to different people at different moments, this is rolling out over time in the world of the book, it changes your status and your ability to move through the world differently than it does to other people because of what is happening and whether or not they think it'll happen to them. Tell me a little bit about that. What is the difference if there is one of changing pigmentation and changing race?
So in the novel, what happens is that the characters appearance changes and it's not quite clear to us exactly how it's changed. We know that people look different and we know that their skin is darker. But you're absolutely right that nothing else changes beyond appearance, at least at first. But quickly it becomes clear that appearance is more than skin deep.
So Anders tries to, at first, not have it happen. He's sort of hoping that he's imagining this. And then he's hoping that Una, who's the first person who sees him, will tell him that, well, you know, you've changed a bit, but you're still the same and she doesn't do that. She says you look like a completely different person, a different kind of person, in fact.
And then he goes to work and he works in a gym and he's a much-liked guy. And he tries to be himself. And what he discovers is that trying to be yourself just doesn't work. When you have to try to be yourself, you're incredibly self-conscious.
And so he's feeling awkward trying to be himself. It doesn't feel natural to him. So he tries to be like other people. He tries to look around him at his fellow gym-goers, at his clients, at the customers of his gym, and most of them are white.
And he tries to be like them. And he tries to enact, in a sense, what he is seeing as whiteness. He tries to perform whiteness. But he's unable to do that.
And increasingly he's feeling awkward. He's feeling a loss of confidence. He's feeling different in nature. And as another progresses, what becomes clear to him is while it began with a change in his appearance, human beings are relational beings.
You know, we're social animals. And when our relationships with others change, we change. And so he can't help it. He is changed by the experience, even if the only thing that initially changes his appearance.
Hi, this is Ashley. I live in San Francisco with my boyfriend. We would love to officially share a many-year time subscription with separate logins. We both love cooking, loving in the kitchen, but in the 30-minute and under-efficient dinner early.
I want a sheet pan meal. He is a elaborate. He wants to get into the storytelling. I want to be able to save my easy meals and check off the ones that I've completed.
And I think him having his own profile would be great. Ashley, we heard you. It's why we created the New York Times family subscription to get your own login. And Mr.
elaborate gets his. Plus room for two others. Find out more at nytimes.com.com. You have a lovely line on this rewrite quote.
Ander said that he was not sure. He was the same person. He had begun by feeling that under the surface it was still him. Who else could have paid?
But it was not that simple. And the way people act around you, it changes what you are, who you are. I want to go in on that idea that we are relational for a moment. You've had some experiences with this.
As you said, I've always noticed that even just when I travel to another country, I spent some time in the horror where you live. I didn't quite feel like myself there. I felt like someone else just due to my own lack of cultural knowledge and my own reserve. What does it say about ourselves and their stability that we present so differently in different contexts?
Well, I think that ourselves are partly fictional. So one of the interesting things to me about novels relates to this, which is to say we are learning that the ancient mystics were probably vital along, which is that what we think of as reality is not entirely real. And in a physical sense, the color red or blue, we imagine that these colors exist, but they don't actually exist. Red and blue are the ways in which our brains tell us that an object is reflecting light of certain frequencies.
And it's a representative system in the same way that there are dolphins. But the word dolphin doesn't really exist. We've invented that word. It's an imaginary thing that we've agreed to share in our imagining.
And in a similar way, I think the creation of self and the creation of personality and who we think we are, but particularly self is a narrative act. We sort of tell a story about ourselves to create ourself. And oftentimes, we'll behave in a way that reveals that our story is at least partly inaccurate or partly fictitious. So we'll do something nasty and we think that we're nice people.
And we'll say, you know, I wasn't myself. But what happened was we are, of course, still ourselves to the extent that we can be a self. But ourself briefly didn't correspond to the story that we tell about ourselves. And the narrative that we have of the constitutes ourselves was destabilized.
And when we go to a place where we aren't known and where the cues are different and where we are getting different sorts of signals, I think that the feeling that the story of self that we tell becomes quite fictitious to us. It feels like it's a made up story. And so I think that this way of generating self through stories about ourselves is hugely important. It's also what is interesting about written fiction because when we enter into written fiction, something weird is going on.
You know, we are there and we are still ourselves and we're reading this book. So many of us are drawn to it. There's something appealing about it. We like it.
Because though, acknowledging the somewhat fictional nature of the self is a relief. We're sort of like, phew, okay, let me complain, make believe that. So I suppose that's not to say that there is no such thing as the self. But it is to say that the self is a much more slippery idea than we often give it credit for, which has enormous potential.
It has enormous potential for us, you know, as a species as people and also enormous potential for us as artists and people who make stories. Are you much of a meditator? You know, I've tried meditation. I'm pretty bad at it.
I'm somebody who certainly appreciates the need to meditate. There was a while where I was doing it quite regularly. I can't say that I've been doing it much lately. But I learned quite a bit.
I learned about the incessant thinking that's going on, like how I'm just like a thought-producing engine and how you can let bots go and, you know, more thoughts will come. It was interesting to, I guess, have that vantage point on myself. And I probably should try to meditate more, but it's not something that is part of my daily practice. I mean, for me sitting by myself in a room with the intention to write is, I guess, my daily practice.
I've just always found it telling both personally because I do meditate quite a bit and then more spiritually and globally. It's a telling bit about the human experience that there is such an important and popular practice. And I think you might add to meditation all kinds of other things that take us out of the self from rock climbing to great art to watching television, I think, to sex, that we are so drugs that we are so often as people desperate from a respite, from being who we are, right, from feeling the constant meta-pressure of being ourselves. And there is some sense that there is a mode of existence, which maybe you can only tap for a couple minutes at a time that doesn't feel like that, that goes behind it.
The performance is exhausting, right? Like the performance of self is exhausting. And the performance of most of us are like, you know, being us is tiring. It can be fun, but it's also tiring.
Like speaking is fun, but it can be tiring. Sometimes you want to shut up and just like listen, right? What would somebody else say? What does the wind say?
And I think that that's exactly right. That we do long for a cessation of performance and some other mode of existence and of transcendence. And I think these are really important questions because partly one of the problems that we're facing is change is accelerating and we are feeling overwhelmed by the accelerating pace of change. And our traditional modes of dealing with that, which would be, you know, family networks or folk stories or, you know, religious practices are for various reasons being degraded.
You know, the families are being dispersed across distance. Folk stories are sort of being lost. Religion is often defaulting into an in-out group sorting mechanism and is less preoccupied in a way with these questions. And so I think the questions don't go away.
It's not the case that we get to just say, well, you know, we're not going to think about these quote unquote spiritual matters. The questions remain. And if they are not dealt with, what happens is incredible anxiety, a sense of real dis-ease sets him. We need to find a way to talk about this stuff and engage with this stuff.
And what I'm very attracted to and I think it exists in many different forms and many different ways of discourse and practices is how do you begin to have these conversations in a way that allows everybody away in? That isn't, you know, specific to a Muslim or a Christian or a Buddhist entry point and isn't specific to a Pakistani or American or whatever cultural reference scheme. Like how do you talk about, how do you talk about these things in a way that's open to everyone? And you know, part of the response to that for me is literature.
I think that it is possible to engage with these things in the form of literature. I mean, I guess the heart of this book, The Last White Man, in a sense, is there's a meditation on loss? You know, so I'm using about loss. What is it to lose something?
And how do we explore that? And can we create dignity around the idea of somebody losing something, even if the thing being lost is not something that we wish to dignify? And to me, that's very interesting because it's a fundamental question that we face as human society today. In a real way, the core of the book for me was a character of Unizmother, who I think really dramatizes that question.
She's this woman. She has very little, her husband has died long ago, her money is always on the verge of running out. She's in physical pain. She doesn't present in society in a way that would give her status.
And amidst all that loss and her own life turning out in a way that is so distant from what she might have hoped, in a way where it's so hard to remain the hero of your own grand narrative, she gets something from her whiteness, from her sense of belonging to, I guess, a history and a people and a class. It's really central to her. It powers her and really then destabilizes her as it begins to go around her ultimately for her. What does she get from whiteness, would you say?
And then what does she also lose from it? Well, I think that Unizmother was living a life that she thought of as a good life. And then around the time that Una and her brother, Una's brother are young teenagers, Una's mother loses her husband, her children's father. And suddenly she arrives in a world where chaos is entered and where economically things are less secure and where at a fundamental level, her belief that the universe was just and good and gave good things to good people was overwhelmed and undermined.
And she's groping and her son begins to take on various addictions and he dies shortly before the novel begins. And she's now lost her son and she's lost her husband. And she sees the world as a world that is taking things from her, that's stealing things from her. She doesn't think of it as fair or benign at all.
She thinks of it as in a sense a kind of rapacious world of theft. And in such a world, she needs something else. She needs a different view and something to belong to and also something to protect. And so she does begin to identify with a notion of whiteness that is under threat, that is being overrun and overwhelmed.
And that affords her the opportunity to, in a sense, once again, play a kind of heroic role as somebody who is leaning with the strength of her character and her will against the injustice being perpetrated to her tribe, to a group, to this group of white people that she feels part of. Una is very disturbed by her mother's beliefs and her mother's leanings. But on the other hand, she worries that if she were to take this away from her mother, to lose this, what would be left? It doesn't have anything else to hold on to.
And I think that this idea of, I guess, transferring our narrative onto the group that we belong to, that we imagine that we belong to and making that into a heroic narrative is a very powerful response we have to these times. And it's a potentially dangerous response because if we do it in such a way that is inherently exclusionary and inherently about setting up our groups in sort of war of one group against the other, it takes us into a terrible place. But I want to hold on another piece of this because it's something I think the book is very attentive to. We talk about what people gain from whiteness or belonging in the dominant group in any hierarchy.
But what is lost from it? And I don't mean when she loses her whiteness. I mean, when that is a bulwark, when that is a pillar of her identity, something she's clinging to, even as so much else in her life falls apart. What is lost from pulling your identity from that kind of source?
I think that the aspect of ourselves that has to do a kind of violence, emotional violence to others to generate a belief in the group to which we wish to belong is a huge loss. I mean, if you think about, for example, slavery in America, it's obvious that slavery is a horrific institution towards the enslaved. But it should also be obvious that in many ways it is a horrific institution towards those who enslave. It may give certain material comfort, et cetera.
But what does it do to a human being, to be a person who lives among your own blood relatives, people that share a father with you, perhaps, who are actually your slaves, who can be whipped, who can be subjected to unspeakable atrocities. What possibility is there for any kind of human decency in that environment? It's hard to say this, but I guess without trying to draw an equivalence between the experience of the enslaved and of the enslaved, it is still important to point out how horrific it is to the humanity of the enslaved to enslaved. But the racial construct, for example, in America, of whiteness, to take people of European descent and people entered into whiteness in different ways in America, saw that all migrants of Europe were immediately thought of as white.
It is an enormously destructive act to build a foundation upon, because it does such a violence to our ability to think of what human beings are. Once we commit to foreclosing from others the opportunity to be fully human, what do we have left to build upon? I think very little. So while the attraction that Una's mother has to an entity built upon this notion of whiteness is understandable for me and something that she feels very powerfully, it is also a deeply weak and impoverished and fundamentally unstable foundation for her to try to build upon.
This is dangerous ground on which to tread, but I want to try and talk about the ways we still do this today and that many people who might safely have heard that and think, well, yeah, what they were doing in the period of slavery was obviously porn and immoral and damaged the spiritual lives of the enslaver as well as wrecking the lives of the enslaved. But that was then. I heard you give a talk or do an interview, I guess, with an honest peak of air. And something you said there was that people interview will come to think we are barbaric today for enforcing the limits of geography on people's lives.
As slaveholders were for enforcing birth hierarchies 150 years ago. Can you talk about that? Well, when I was writing the novel exit, I was thinking about migration and how it's sort of a fundamental human feature. Animals migrate and when food supplies are scarce, when other animals are contesting for place, when the climate changes, animals move and people move for all of those reasons and more.
And none of us are indigenous to where we live. There's a movement that brought us there, even those of us who live in Africa, where the earliest homosapiens have been found, are like the descendants of people who wandered elsewhere and sort of move back. So wherever we are, in a sense, we are migrants. And up until quite recently, this idea of the nation state with such impermeable borders and passports and this entire mechanism didn't exist.
And of course, there were tribes that wouldn't let other tribes live among them. There were wars and all kinds of things. But the human record is of movement, incredible amounts of movement. And what we're seeing today is an attempt to really stop that movement on a sort of industrial scale.
And I think that while I fully understand and can empathize with the idea that, well, if we let everybody come, it will change everything. And we can't do that. I can understand that. And there needs to be some navigation of how do we manage this tussle of what those who wish to move and those who do not wish to move to where they are, how do we manage the balance between those two things.
But what I think is very stark is that it cannot be that the moral right is simply to say that people must move. They are criminally they move. They should be criminalized if they move. Because in a world where there will be, I think, enormous flows of people due to climate change and environmental disruption, but also wars and other things.
If we say to people that they just can't move, we're in a sense handing out death sentences to millions and millions of our fellow human beings. If you can't leave us a country where there's a war underway and where people of your particular group are being killed, or if you can't leave a country where there's enormous starvation and crops have failed, we are basically deciding that these people now need to die. And for me, that decision should be revealed in its correct moral complexion, which is to say it isn't the person who wishes to move who is the criminal here. If somebody is drowning, we can help them and we don't.
It's not the person who droughts that is the criminal here. And so again, while I don't want to draw a direct parallel between the idea of having people be massacred in their country or starve to death and not allowing them to move with the institution of slavery in the United States, what I do want to do is to say that there is something wrong about a moral outlook that says that those people who wish to move are the ones who are wrong, that those people are morally the inferior position, that we with our laws preventing them are morally in a superior position. To me, that is completely suspect. And I think given how many people it affects and hundreds of millions of people it could affect is a human catastrophe in the coming century, which we really have to reckon with.
And to your point about the way it affects the morality of those who are preventing the movement, I think in America about the political discourse or what got called the caravan a couple of years ago. And the broad political discourse about refugees, Donald Trump during the 2016 campaign, he would get up on stages and read this parable of the snake talking about Syrian refugees, which he was saying that we let them in and they will eventually bite us because a snake is a snake. And in order to maintain a sense of ourselves as moral beings, as we do not allow people fleeing murder and starvation and climate crisis, which we of course have quite profound hand in, as we made it hard for Afghans who helped us in Afghanistan to come here, we have to turn them into threats because we don't turn them into threats that our own immorality becomes too clear. That's exactly right.
I think that that is the pernicious nature of this thing, that we imagine that on a sort of racial foundation, it might be possible to build a sort of heroic narrative for ourselves. But it is impossible. The harm that we perpetrate upon ourselves is incredibly deep. And it isn't even just a sort of psychic sort of spiritual harm.
It's not just that by denying people their humanity, by putting them into racial categories and giving property rights over certain racial categories or by putting them in national categories and denying geographic rights to those of people of particular categories. It's not that those things in and of themselves are the way in which we harm ourselves, that we have become bad people in quotes. It's that we then commit ourselves towards a heroic narrative which reinforces this thing. In other words, if slavery is good, then anything in the service of that becomes good.
And increasingly horrific belief systems become good. If the denial of people, the ability to move is good, well then those who stop you at the border must be good. If there are people who try to help you from crossing the border must be bad. We should try to stop those from helping people.
And then if somebody is trying to give water to somebody who is in the desert and has no water, well that person is our criminal. If somebody provides water to the person to give the water, that person is a criminal. If somebody shelters the person who provides the water, that person is a criminal. We very quickly live in societies that are completely driven with a kind of police state like mentality and this horrible essence that takes human generosity and kindness and effectively criminalizes those things and makes them into weaknesses and vulnerabilities.
That path I think is incredibly limiting for people who live in such a society. I see this is really a central concern of your books in general, which is how do we and why do we tell stories and create fictions that deny our fundamental equality? Be those fictions borders as an exit West, be they the moral and otherwise weight of pigmentation as in the last white man. And so I guess I want to ask you about the other side of it.
Why do you think we do it? Not what would happen if we couldn't. If portals opened up as an exit West, then they'd border somewhat irrelevant. If something happened to end difference by pigmentation, what do you think it is in the human animal that leads us to try and deny our equality, to try to find ways to justify that denial over and over and over again?
Well, I think there is an innate, I guess, fewfulness in the organism, homo-sapings. We're scared of stuff. And rightly so. If your ancestors saw that flash of orange in the forest and they thought that is a tiger, they were likely to pass on their genes and the ones who thought that's nothing to worry about probably got eaten by tigers and so were less likely.
So we're predisposed to treat threatening information as a more significant type of information. But as we made larger and larger societies and came together in larger and larger groups, it became important for us to figure out how to do that and to in a sense disarm, to a certain extent, the ease with which we can view each other as threats. And so we build complex civilizations that somehow manage to reduce our sense of each other as being threats to allow us to live together in large numbers. And so as an animal, we can kind of go either way at any point.
We can either begin to subscribe to narratives that are once again, reemphasizing the inherent threat that we pose to each other just by virtue of being different. And whenever we do that, we see the rise of pretty horrific stuff. And this tends to happen when empires break apart or when empires are in their decline. And to the extent that you think of America as the dominant force of recent years and perhaps the best dominant these days than it was recently, we're in a historical moment that looks a bit like some of the periods of waning empire of the past.
At such times, we do see, I think, the rise of these fear narratives. But it isn't inevitable. I don't think that we have to give in to a kind of fear narrative based view. I think that while human beings are innately predisposed towards threat narratives and to seeing each other as threats have encouraged to do so, they also can clearly subscribe to different kinds of narratives that allow many different sorts of people to live together.
And there's a narrative choice that we face. And so I would view it not as some pessimistic, oh well, people are always going to descend into barbaric infighting. I think it becomes how do we manage to continue to push forward the human ability to craft narratives that allow people who seem different from each other to not give in to a threat narrative and instead find a way to live among each other. You said once, quote, I've come to the belief that pessimism is a deeply conservative and reactionary position.
It tends to lead towards deference, towards a strong and powerful, towards powerlessness and a kind of surrender. Tell me a bit about how you came to that belief and how you try to animate it. Well, I think that what I've been seeing in my life, I guess, is that when I was younger, it felt to me that the world narrative seemed more optimistic, that technology would make things better. Poverty would diminish, racism would go down, inequality would become less pronounced.
And it was possible to believe in these things. I mean, I was probably quite naive to buy in fully, but at some basic level of thought, you know, things are going to get better. There are going to be horrible things that happen. There will be wars, there will be massacres, there will be famines, but over time, things are going to progress in a good direction.
And then, you know, maybe it was my 30th birthday in 2001, maybe it was a new economic paradigm, it was lots of things. It has become increasingly difficult for me to maintain that sense of just innate optimism in the last 20 or so years. And it strikes me that it's becoming difficult for many people to maintain a kind of optimistic narrative. And alongside that, what I see is that there are so many people, not just in the US, I mean all over the world, who are, in a sense, being drawn towards narratives that are founded on pessimism.
So if we can't go forward to a better place, we should look back to the past to give us a direction of travel. And then we begin to fetishize our past. And we talk about, you know, Britain before migrants arrived as Brexit and America when it was a more white place, you know, as some of the animating stuff of current US politics. But also, you know, the golden age of Islam or sort of imagined Hindu paradise for Hindus and India or glory days of Russian might, including Russia and similar things, you know, China or in Brazil and Turkey.
This is too widespread. The current rise of narratives that are fundamentally pessimistic because they're fundamentally nostalgic. And I think that as we are losing our ability to imagine sort of a better collective future, what is our response to that? What can we do?
And it seems to me that beginning to imagine and articulate possible optimism, possibly optimistic futures has to be part of the response. That, you know, if fear of migration is an animating political thought, they can't just be that we say, well, okay, well, we're going to stop migration. This is not going to be a problem. Like we're just going to shut it down for all the reasons that we've already discussed.
It has to also be, well, what if we go into that fear? Let's imagine a world where migration really does take on these supposedly cataclysmic levels. Can something better be born if we don't commit to the search for optimism, not a naive optimism, but the search for optimism. We've basically abandoned the field to those who peddle pessimism and all over the world, and I think that pessimistic peddling is dominant right now.
You described, I think, really well, one kind of pessimism, which is an astalgic pessimism, a pessimism of the past. I think the circles I travel in and of particular appeal to me personally is what I've come to think of as like a pessimistic realism, sort of a pessimism that either is or poses as a kind of realism. It's an essentializing way of thinking about the world and the deficiencies of human beings or the institutional problems in political systems or, you know, the inevitability of catastrophic climate change. But that one has a real currency among intellectual and policy maker classes in a way that astalgic pessimism doesn't.
I think many people can hear your description of pessimism and think, I don't do that. I don't think the past was better. But they nevertheless, I think, rate, as I often do, more convincing, arguments about how the future will be better either. And so I'm curious for you about the practice, the discipline of trying to be able to imagine and articulate better futures, even as you try to be realistic about the present.
Well, I think that it's always worth interrogating, you know, why we do stuff. And if you take, for example, a kind of pessimistic acceptance, which is not longing for the past, but a sense that the things that one wishes for, a more inclusive society, a less racist society, a more equal society are slipping away for complicated reasons and nothing can be done. The environment is just going to go to part in that sort of it. The other part of it though is that it is incredibly difficult to reckon with this feeling of defeat, of loss.
It isn't. I seem to be losing out. The world is going the wrong direction. How do I, you know, how do I survive this?
Like, how do I deal with my profound sense of despair at the situation? And human life, I think, is a good parallel. So of course we're all going to get older. Of course we're all going to die.
What is our stance in relation to that? So, you know, it would be ridiculous to say, well, this is never going to happen to me. I feel like there's a way out of this. I'm going to eat something or get an injection or something will happen and it's going to save me.
I think that seems, you know, I can understand the appeal, but it seems profoundly misguided as far as I can see. But also to say, you know what, I'm going to get old. Nothing to be done. Let's just carry on.
It's an interesting response, right? You know, it's entirely possible that we do learn something, that there is some wisdom. And in the book, for example, there's the character of Andrews's father who's ill and who is dying. And whose mission in a way is to try to somehow pass on to his son how you die well.
You know, what could this mean? What is it to do this thing? And in a sense, that is a, I think, I mean, Andrews's father has all sorts of views that I might not disagree with. But in that particular attempt to pass on to his son something of meaning and something of wisdom from the old and from those near mortality to those who are young, there is an activity there.
And that's something that the elders of every tribe throughout human history have done towards the young in their tribe forever. We, I think, should consider that. And what kind of optimism does that mean? It's not the optimism of I will live forever.
It's the optimism of I have something of value yet to give. And it is meaningful for me to pass that on. And so I suppose, you know, what I would come to on this is that the reaction of a kind of pessimistic acceptance to me feels like it is less than what could be hopeful. It is possible to drive a more than that.
And I think that, you know, as a writer and as an artist and also as a father and as a human being, it isn't what's understandable to me. It isn't appealing to me. I think that's very beautifully said. And it brings up for me something you said in a talk you gave that if we build a society, run on self-interest, then we're vulnerable to the fact that the self ends.
And so you build a society unbelievably terrified of ending. Can you talk a bit about, because I think it's actually very important in the book too, about that relationship and your thought between our fear of the inevitable ends, we and those we love will face and our political fears? Yeah, I think, you know, within every philosophical religious, you know, spiritual tradition, there are these modes of thinking that are about achieving a degree of transcendence. And you know, in the tradition that I grew up in within the Muslim tradition, there is, of course, Sufi literature and Sufi poetry above all.
And the Sufi is in a sense, believe that love has a transcendent potential, that the self can be transcendent. And many of Sufi poems are told as love stories between two people or the love of Moth for the flame of a candle. And our metaphor is in a way for love for the divine or love for the universe. And within them, in a sense, what is being explored is the idea that if you feel strongly enough for something outside yourself, the tyranny of the self can be reduced.
And the mortal experience of being a human being can be made more tolerable. Now what that means in terms of life today and confronting this sort of situation of a capitalistic economy, which is entirely self driven and which continues to emphasize the self and reinforce the self and cuts the self off from other connections and therefore makes us completely terrified because we're so in a sense self invested that we've have an almost a historical level of fear of our mortality, unprecedented perhaps. I think that the antidotes to that lie in a sense in other attachments. So whether that is, you know, a grandparent's love for a grandchild, which means that you get to be optimistic about this child learning to write a bicycle in three or four years time, even though you know that in three or four years time, you'll be that much closer to your own learning.
Or it's a kind of generational link, affection, which is that, you know, just for our species, that you are engaged in something which you feel meaningfully helps people go forward. Whatever that activity is, whatever that practice is, you know, volunteering someplace or doing some kind of research you think is important or writing stories or whatever it is. I think finding some way to connect to what is beyond ourselves becomes important. Now that need of course can be misdirected.
So I can misdirect that need towards, you know, my group perpetrating some kind of blood path against another group. But you know, that isn't the only or I think even the dominant mode that needs to be expressed. I think it's interesting now, you know, as a globally connected human civilization to start thinking about, you know, how do we express these ancient wisdom that exists in every tradition in contemporary ways that are open to all. And I think that the arts are one of the places where this can happen, that you can explore these sorts of things, you know, in many ways, the last white man, you know, for me is a kind of Sufi novel, you know, it is about love and it is about transcendence and it's about in the sense a death of something, of this idea of whiteness, but also of something being born and something being born in the context of four people who are bound together, you know, with love.
And that has a lot of potential. So that's I guess what my intonation is to look at these things. I think that is a lovely place to come to a close. So always our final question on the show.
What are three books you'd recommend to the audience? So three books I would recommend and I tend to read pretty widely from a historical standpoint. I would recommend Tony Morrison's Beloved as a book that I think many people have read and certainly when I was in my 20s and we're reading, but still not just one of the most beautifully hauntingly written novels of the last century, but also just formally such a sophisticated way of thinking about how do you use sentences? How do you build a novel to respond to this completely horrific predicament of in a sense America's reckoning with its racial and particularly its slavery past?
So masterpiece. Morrison was a mentor for you. She taught you, she elevated you to read your whole school. What did you learn from her?
What was she like if you're able to condense that for us? I began my first novel in a long fiction workshop with Tony Morrison and she I think did expect to get an entire draft of a novel. She was probably hoping for 40 or 50 pages, but she very generously read the whole thing that managed to get with her pages of handwritten notes on the back. This is probably my most prized writing possession with something I keep in my study.
And she had a number of incredible capacities. One was that she read very well. So she could read the back of a cornflick box and you'd think this is the best thing you've ever heard. She read as well as she wrote, which is if you've read her writing really pretty astounding.
And in that process I think what she taught was how important it is to write with your years. We imagine that the written form is a form that we read with our eyes. And for many of us those who have sighted it is of course something to read with your eyes. But I think the processing of it, the sort of neural circuitry is connected to our hearing systems, our oral systems.
And so learning to write with your ears was one thing which I certainly took away. But the lesson I tell people the most is that she used to say that you should keep your reader half heartbeat ahead of the action of your novels. And they shouldn't know what's coming next. But when it happens it should feel inevitable.
I mean that's the kind of work that I think she taught the writers were fortunate enough to study with her to think about doing. And I guess one more thing I would say is that when you have writers of that caliber who make the decision to teach, one thing that they are doing is they are giving each and every one of their students the permission to imagine that they could be writers. And I think if it weren't for writers like Donnie Morrison, Joyce Caroloats, others who taught me, I probably wouldn't be in all this today because I wouldn't have really believed that I could be one. And when writers of that incredible caliber take you seriously are generous with you, you can begin to imagine things.
And so it's very potent, let's say I guess, in how people's imaginations can be shaped by others. Their ability to give themselves permission to do stuff can be shaped by others. I love that. So I think that for me, Jorge Luis Borges is somebody that people really should read now if they're thinking about our particular technological moment and how fiction can respond.
You know, a book like A Fixie on this or any really collection of short stories. What Borges is doing is he is creating this world of representation, of mirrors, of forking narratives. I mean, it's almost inconceivable that, you know, he's writing three quarters of a century ago before computers. Because Borges is for me, in a sense, the most technologically current writer I can possibly think of, the way in which there are forking paths of narratives, the ways in which we are reflected, the ways in which we are retelling the story of what we are, the way we perceive things differently.
Borges is somebody that I think everybody should read. I guess the third narrative, third story book that I would suggest is I think it's very worthwhile to read Gilgamesh. And Gilgamesh is important because Gilgamesh is a Sumerian epic from thousands of years ago. And it's worth reading alongside works like the Odyssey or even like the Bible because there's almost this kind of separation that has been made in our shared cultural history.
I think that those moves are really impoverished us. I think if you go back and read Gilgamesh, what's very interesting about it is how deeply in conversation it is with works like the Odyssey and with sacred texts like the Bible. But also how we have imagined into existence partitions in our literary history, which are as profound as and enabling of some of our racial constructs. That if you were to go back and read Gilgamesh and read it alongside some of these other foundational works, it's a very, in a sense, hope-inducing experience because it's easy to recognize that actually there really is this shared cultural history that we imagine that we have sprung forth from different strands of humanity.
In fact, going back thousands of years, those strands were so mixed for so long that surely they can be mixed now as we live together in the 21st century.