This is the Value Investor podcast with Tracy Rinek, All Things Value All the Time. Welcome back, Value Investors. Did any of you get a chance to watch the Berkshire annual meeting on May 6th, 2023? It just happened.
As promised, I said I would do a podcast on what was talked about. As we always do, right? How can we not talk about what happens at the Berkshire annual meeting? Warm up in Charlie Munger took questions for over five hours.
I have to admit a couple of times I was kind of tuning out. I was doing some other things. I was surfing on the internet. I was not paying that much attention.
I watched a college softball game while it was all going on. Then they kept going and going and going. They didn't really make that much news this time. I was trying to figure out why that was and why maybe I was so bored as well.
The questions are curated ahead of time. Nothing is really spontaneous. Becky read off some questions from people. Becky Quick of CNBC.
She read off some questions from people who wrote in or emailed in. Then there were shareholders in the actual venue who were picked and were reading off their questions. We even had to wait until the second half of the session. They go a couple hours and they did take a lunch break.
Then they went a couple more hours. We didn't even find out anything about their oil investments, which is one of my more interesting areas that I have interest in. Nobody even asked a question about accidental or chevron. In fact, I don't think they even asked about chevron at all throughout the thing.
It was mainly about accidental and what they were doing with the investment. It did make some news saying that they were not going to buy them out. They were not going to acquire the entire company of accidental. That's the ticker OXY, by the way.
He also made some news by declaring that Apple was the best business that they owned. I think they own a 5.6% stake in it now. People had questions afterwards, at least I did, if it's the best business you own, why did you buy more or why aren't you buying more? But Berkshire currently has 130 billion in cash sitting in hand.
He did talk about how their investing income would rise this year, expected to rise to about $5 billion from 50 million simply because of the rising yields. They are able to invest the cash into the rising, the treasuries, and they're able to make more money for shareholders through that. This only compounds his problem of having too much cash, which I've complained about many times on the podcast over the years. It is less than it used to be because they did buy the big stake in chevron and accidental over the last 18 months to two years now.
That's diluted a bit of it, but they're also getting big dividend payouts from those. They don't pay a dividend themselves. Buffett did describe the one-time Berkshire paid a dividend. I think he said it was 1967.
They paid $0.10 a share and he called it the biggest mistake that they've made. Those of you thinking, oh, maybe we might get a dividend, you're not going to get a dividend. They are doing share buyback though with some of the money, but really they just have tremendous amount of cash sitting there. Berkshire Hathaway itself is trading at about 17 times forward earnings.
I own it in the insider trader right now, not the value investor, but the insider trader, because some insiders have been buying in there earlier this year. We bought it. It is a safety play right now. It's why it's a little bit expensive.
It's not really a value stack here. For those value investors that are out there who want a value stack, but you don't necessarily want to buy Berkshire because it's not really cheap here, what if you created your own Berkshire Hathaway? I was thinking about this as I was listening to him speak. In the great period, they had several of the CEOs of course come on CNBC and talk about their individual businesses within Berkshire.
You always have to remember that those are also carefully picked by the company who gets to speak and who doesn't. It is a limited amount of time. They do own a lot of companies. It's not like everyone could speak even if they wanted to in that hour in between for the lunch break.
They did have the Benjamin Morris CEO and the CCO and then they had a new company that also just talked about the fun of being bought out by Berkshire Hathaway and going to these annual meetings and all that stuff. I just thought it was interesting that it was Cs and Benjamin Moore, the paint company that were the two designated speakers. Buffett also did say something just overall about the business as a group. You did say that many of the business segments had too much inventory on hand heading into this year and a lot of other companies are trying to get rid of that excess inventory.
They're in the process of doing that. We don't know to what extent that means, but we've heard the same refrain from retailers, from just a whole host of some manufacturing companies. A lot of people got caught as they continued to slow and the consumer pulled back on certain items. What if you did want to create your own Berkshire Hathaway?
They're not talking about the equity portfolio because you can already do that. You can go in there, you can go into the financial filings, you can see what stocks Berkshire Hathaway owns. You can buy the stocks that he owns, but the equity portfolio is a small part of the overall business. Someone actually asked at the meeting about the size of Apple in the overall portfolio and that it was this huge chunk of the business and Buffett had to correct him.
It's a big chunk of the equity portfolio. It's something like 35 or 40 percent of the equity portfolio. That's the stocks that he owns. So it is heavily weighted in that portfolio, but as a percentage of the overall business, it's not the biggest position.
It's among the top four, but it's not an overwhelming size. He mentioned that they own a railroad. That railroad is huge in BNSF. You've got to separate the two.
There is the equity portfolio, but everybody just thinks as Berkshire, it's those stocks. It's Apple, Chevron, accidental, but they own a ton of other companies, as many of you know. What if you tried to recreate that aspect of the company without actually buying Berkshire and you wanted to create your own mini Berkshire Hathaway? I picked out five different areas, industries that I know Berkshire has businesses in.
I look up what it is that they have and I matched it up as best as I could with a publicly traded company that you too could own to get similar exposure to these businesses as Berkshire. Now there's many more than just five areas I could have gone down. Maybe I'll mention a couple more at the end that you could look at if you're thinking of trying to develop your own conglomerate in your own portfolio. But let's start with these five because I think these are the interesting ones.
Okay, so the first one I've already mentioned, as Buffett mentioned, they own a railroad. They own Burlington, Northern, Santa Fe, BNSF. And those in the Chicago area, no BNSF quite well because they actually operate one of the suburban metro lines here, or at least the metro operates on BNSF's railroad lines. But when you're out there waiting for the train, you can actually see on the sides of the cars.
It actually says BNSF on the sides of the cars here in Chicago. It is one of his largest and his favorite businesses. He loves businesses with moats. Railroad have a wide moat.
Nobody's really building a new railroad. There's a few passenger rails that are going up, like the one down in Florida. But it's mostly on the bright side. It's a done deal and you're stuck with these legacy railroads.
He bought one of them. But one you could buy that I've always liked is Union Pacific to your UNP. It is trading at 17.8 times. So it's not super cheap.
It's not super expensive. Year to date, down 3.3% on Union Pacific. Estimates are being cut though over the last week and over the last 30 days. So they're expected to make 11.34, but that's up only a penny over last year when they made 11.33.
So not really seeing a big dip in the earnings year over year, but not any big gains. 2024 is looking a little bit better right now. Up 7.1% to 12.14%. But it's a little early to be looking at 2024.
This is X number three hold and it does pay dividend yielding 2.6%. So that's something you'll get if you create your own mini-birchure that you don't get in bircure is dividends because a lot of these types of companies do pay dividends. So that's Union Pacific, UNP. And why is the reason I like it?
They are out on the West Coast, but they also own the hubs along the Mexico border. So anything coming up out of Mexico goes through those hubs. And I love that exposure. So that's why Union Pacific's always been one of my favorites.
Okay, let's switch over to one of Buffett's other favorites types of businesses. And it's not a consumer side. He owns a lot of different consumer businesses. And this is in the furniture.
Remember he bought Nebraska furniture market, but they also own Jordans in New England and the Northeast, Star in Texas and RC Wiley in Utah. And I didn't realize that combining all of these, it's about a $2 billion business in furniture. So there are a lot of smaller furniture companies because it is a very bifurcated market. And some became dominant in certain parts of the country, as you can see with Buffett's own investments, right?
They're like in certain parts of the country. These names started 100 years ago or something and then grew in their own home grown markets and now own bircure had the way. But one that I've always kind of seen as like a in the same vein as that is Haverty furniture. Ticker H as in Harry, V as in Victor, T as in Tom, H V T.
They have a hundred showrooms now in 16 southern and Midwestern states. They were founded in 1885. This is the type of business. But if it would like if he was buying more on the furniture side, it's a small cap, 413 million market cap.
It has only one estimate. So it's lightly covered on the street. But because as it went estimate, we do have a sex rank. It is actually number four cell right here.
And that's because those estimates are on the way down. Somethings expected to be down 23% this year as the furniture sales really slow off those pandemic highs. So expected to make 390 this year versus 507 last year. They saw sales in the first quarter down 5.9% and their comps were down 6.7.
None of this is surprising. They are still delivering, but kind of winding down on the deliveries now of the pandemic booming times, which included last year, the housing market is slowed on the sales side. And that means there's people who are need new furniture. You will buy new furniture when you buy new house.
So less home sales, less furniture sales overall. But they have no outstanding debt. They have 127 million in cash. They do pay a dividend.
Their shareholder friendly dividend is now yielding 4.3% because here to date these years are down 15%. So a lot of the furniture stocks of sunk here might be an interesting play as these get cheaper because they do have good balance sheets. Many of these kind of smaller furniture companies do have the good balance sheets. But I like Haverty for its dominance and its markets and this pristine balance sheet, its ticker HBT.
Then switching over to still staying on the consumer, but the candy side. So C's Candy CEO was featured on CNBC and they talked about having volumes back to pre-pandemic levels now. They're still seeing strong sales online, which happened during the pandemic more than in the stores. And that has kind of remained.
They haven't lost that after the reopening. So those buyer's behaviors have kind of stayed the same. But what do you buy if you want a C's Candy? There's not a lot that's like a total peer that's publicly traded.
Well, you can buy Hershey's. They're much bigger. 56 billion market cap ticker H, S, Y, Hs and Harry. S is in Sam Y as in younger, wise and younger.
And Hershey's classic chocolate play, Candy Play and who doesn't like that? Everybody does. People have been piling into these shares. They're up 18.5% year to date.
They're at five year highs. Earnings are on the increase of 11% expected here in 2023 to 946 from 850 last year. So I'm liking all of that. But you're going to pay the price.
P is now 29 times because everybody's like, oh, this is recessionary proof. We're still going to need chocolate. It's still affordable. Everybody's going to keep buying all of this at this candy.
So it's a little pricey for me here. I'd be cautious on it here of like chasing this. But as I said, it has a great five year chart. So they've been doing something right the last couple of years.
It does pay a dividend, yielding 1.5%. And then staying on the consumer side, I headed in the back of my mind, doesn't puff it on like some kind of jewelry store or something. And sure enough, yes, Melsberg diamonds. We've seen these ads on TV, at least I have.
It was acquired by Berkshire Hathaway all the way back in 1996. So what can we get that's similar to Helsberg diamonds? Well, of course, Signa Jewelers, one of their competitors. I think they're SIG.
They are cheap. They have a PE right now of 6.2 and earnings though, expected to be down 5.3% this fiscal year, but just at $11.18 versus 11.80 last year. That's not too bad given everybody's saying doom and gloom. And maybe it'll get worse as the year goes on.
If a recession does come, you tend to cut back on things like jewelry. But right now, consumer holding up pretty good and the wedding market remains strong. Coming out of the pandemic, a lot of weddings and engagements even postponed. But now those are happening.
People are buying. This is one maybe to keep on your watch list. What's happening with the shares? They're up 2.7% year to date over five years though, up 83% versus the S&P 500 up just 51%.
Does pay a dividend yielding 1.3% so that nice little added bonus. And like I said, it is cheap at just six times. So jewelry is looking pretty cheap. And then for my fifth choice, I did go with the home or real estate brokerage.
And maybe many people don't even know that Berkshire Hathaway owns this, but it's called Berkshire Hathaway Home Services. It is their real estate brokerage. They have agents. You can sell your house through Berkshire Hathaway basically.
But taking a look at some of its competitors that are publicly traded, the scene is not too good. So I'm not surprised that we did not see Berkshire Hathaway CEOs on the halftime show on CNBC. That's not who I would wheel out either. I looked at Compass, ticker C OMP, and their earnings are bouncing back from 2022.
So they lost $1.40 in 2022 as the housing market really sank on those higher mortgage rates, remember. So these companies make money when you sell or buy a house. And so they were getting hammered last year, not as bad this year as things have stabilized and expected to lose just $0.53 this year. That is up 62%.
And then a better picture again in 2024, but still a loss of $0.26. So not really liking all the losses there. It is a ZAC number four sell. I also took a look at Redfin.
That's one of the bigger names. Redfin used to have the iBying business member last year. They got out of it, but they took a big loss. So last year, they lost $3.11 and $3.11 last year.
This year expected to only lose $1.52. They did get rid of the iBying business, like I said, and they've taken those losses and those lumps, but they're out of that. So they're much more traditional brokerage with a data business too. A lot of their data is people depend on their data for a lot that's going on in the housing market.
So, but much more traditional home brokerage type of business. But you're still not getting just like with Compass. You're still not seeing any PE because you're still getting the loss. I also expect a loss for 2024 of $0.92.
What do these shares look like? It's been pretty brutal two years. So Compass shares two years down 85%, Redfin down 83, but maybe that's a buying opportunity, right? So year to date, people have been buying Redfin.
It's up 132% year to date over the last year. So that's going back to last May. So over the last year, those shares are still down 16%, but those bottom feeders have jumped in this year and year to date, they're up 132% because they saw it was oversold there. Compass, not quite as dramatic.
Last two years, as I mentioned, down 85%, one year, it's still down 51%, but year to date up, but only 11%. So people a little more bullish on Redfin or willing to trade it more than they are on Compass, which is less known out there. If you haven't bought and sold a house where Compass is in your market, then you might not be as familiar with them. So you're not willing to take any chances there, but a lot more traders aware of Redfin or Zillow and willing to trade those stocks a lot more than some of these other more pure play brokerage type stocks.
So some lessons from Berkshire Hathaway and what we take away from this is that really Berkshire Hathaway, the stock operates like an index fund almost with a bunch of cash on the side and it has its manager, it's kind of like an actively managed index fund or ETF, so to speak, with a whole bunch of businesses in there plus the equity side and then the cash. But you might not want to just buy the whole kitten kaboodle. I know I don't own it in my own personal portfolio any longer because I didn't like what was being done with some of the investments and the big cash sitting on hands. But this way, if you want to go out and buy similar companies, you can create your own types of portfolios and pick and choose what kind of businesses you want in there.
So if you don't like energy, you don't have to buy it in your own. You can just leave that portion out. If you like the railroad, you can buy that. It's just a lot easier to create your own in some ways.
You also will get the dividend with a lot of these companies with their Hathaway and I really do kind of like that dividend or at least that little dividend boost in their returns every year and or they want the income, they're going to live off the income. So Berkshire Hathaway doesn't work for them. But remember, you still want to keep your value principles intact too. You don't want to just rush out and buy companies that are similar to what Berkshire Hathaway owns just because it's similar to what they own.
So there were a lot of questions about Apple really above it monger. And as I mentioned earlier in the podcast, he did say that he considered Apple to be the best business that they own. But then the bigger question follow up to that is why aren't they buying more? They own, I think, is a 5.6% position.
He has 130 billion in cash sitting there. He could buy money more shares. He's actually sold some in the last couple of years, I think just basically to like not have it be 50% of the equity portfolio at one point. So but why not buy more now when it's not close to 50%.
But some of the key to that, the reasoning behind that may be in the valuation. It's trading at 28 times on a PE level. Its peg is 2.3. That's not cheap.
And his cheap price to book is 44. That's nowhere close to any kind of value. Price to cash flow is 25. That's not a value.
Price to sales. That's an important tech, you know, fundamental and it's 7.1. That's nowhere close to value. So really Apple is quite overvalued and Buffett, you know, does still have the discipline and the patience.
And if it's overvalued, yeah, he's going to continue to hold on to it. He loves the business, but he bought in cheaper. So they got in cheap. They got big gains.
But there's no real reason for value investors now to be adding to Apple at this point. At this level, he has the cash. If it gets cheaper, you can always add later. But now he will be disciplined.
He will have patience. So for those of you who are thinking of setting up your own portfolio, keep that in mind that even Buffett has patience with even some of his current holdings that he doesn't add to if he believes that they're not cheap. And notice what he is doing with Occidental and Chevron. But certainly with Occidental, they have been adding to that position when the stock is sold off.
When it's gotten much cheaper again this year, here in 2023, they jovin again with several more buys. So he's willing to be disciplined and patient for a long time as we know. And as a value investor, you should be too. So keep that in mind with any kind of portfolio you are making and any kind of positions you're adding that if you don't like the price or you think it's overpriced, you don't have to buy it.
You can wait and your patience is usually rewarded. So it's hard to have the patience. That's maybe Buffett's best quality and the thing that makes him such a great investor. It's that he is willing to wait around.
So let me recap those stocks again that you could buy to create kind of your own mini Berkshire Hathaway. Oh, and I was going to mention a few other companies that I didn't get to in the five stocks. So I mentioned Benjamin Moore earlier. That's the paint company you could buy Sherwin Williams, for instance, but it's not that cheaper here.
But that's one of the largest paint companies in the world and one of Benjamin Moore's big competitors. You could buy that if you wanted to own your own paint company separate. I kind of lament that Berkshire Hathaway owns Benjamin Moore because the CEO was on CNBC and he talked about explosive growth. That's the word he used overseas as they expand their overseas business.
So, but we're not seeing any of that if you own Berkshire Hathaway. Some of these companies are just small in the overall portfolio. So even if you have something real good happening with one of them, like a Benjamin Moore perhaps or C's Candy, it's kind of dwarfed by what's happening with the bigger companies in the portfolio like a BNSF or even the Apple position. And that can be good or bad if something bad is happening or we don't know what's happening at Berkshire Hathaway home services.
But given these other real estate brokerages, it's probably nothing real good right now. But that's kind of hidden in the business. And but the good times can also be hidden in this kind of business as well. So that's why it's hard owning the big conglomerate or an ETF that has a big few big weighted, weighted stocks or positions in it.
Other things kind of get lost in the shuffle. And that's why you might want to own some of these individual positions. So I mentioned the paint, a couple of other things. They own auto dealerships.
Buffett did mention that in passing. And so you could own one of the publicly traded auto dealerships. I think he said they own 80. They own 80 dealerships now.
But you could own lithium motors, LAD is the ticker. You could own a Penske. That's one of my favorites. And the value investor PAG is the ticker there.
There's a couple others. You know who they are. We talked about them on the podcast, but that's another business that they own. I thought about trying to find a business that was equivalent to Dairy Queen, one of my favorite companies that they own.
But there's no real ice cream maker that's publicly traded, I'm afraid. But any of the really strong consumer restaurant chains could probably fill in for Dairy Queen, something like a Chipotle, CMG, but it's not cheap by any means for value investors. Most of us have stayed out of it for that reason because it's never been cheap. But you can look around at some of the restaurant chains that are all doing quite well here as well.
We don't really know how well Dairy Queen is doing. But that's again, one of the negatives of being inside this big conglomerate. So keep those in mind. Okay.
So now I'm going to recap the stacks that were on the list. So there's Union Pacific, UNP, there's Haverty, that's the furniture company, HS and Harry, V is in Victor, T is in Tom, HBT. Also pays that nice dividend over 4%. Hershey's ticker HSY, it's been on a real run, but it's not cheap.
Unitulars is cheap six times ticker S-I-G, S-I-G-S-S-G-S-S-G. And then we had a couple of the brokerages. They don't have good zacks ranked right now. They have negative earnings, but some traders are in Redfin, ticker RD-FN.
And then we had the lesser known Compass, COM, he is the ticker there, COM is a married P as in Paul. And as always, I'm keeping abreast of what's happening in the value scene with Mr. Buffett. And oh, he did have a big announcement about the intelligent investor.
I should do a show on that one coming up soon because they are doing a new version of Intelligent Investor. And he was talking with the publisher about it, so he's probably going to do another new forward to the book. But yes, they are finally updating it after nearly 20 years after the last version. So no ETA, he didn't say when, but it's probably going to be pretty soon.
They're going to be putting that out. So that's good news because I know many of you complained about the old examples, even from like 2005 in that book. And it would be nice to have some examples from like the great financial crisis and even from recently from the pandemic included in that book. So that's big news.
Ben Graham is a little bible of how to be a value investor is going to be having a new edition soon. So as always, you need to subscribe so you get these breaking bulletins on these important things. You can get us on Apple, you can get us on Spotify, we're on Amazon Music, we're just about anywhere. You can get podcasts, but be sure to get us somewhere and I'll see you again next week with some more value stacks.
This material is being provided for informational purposes only and nothing herein constitutes investment legal accounting or tax advice or a recommendation of a high sell or hold a security. Do not act or rely upon the information and advice given in this podcast without seeking the services of competent professional legal tax or accounting counsel. The publication and distribution of this podcast is not intended to create any information contained herein does not constitute an attorney-client relationship. No recommendation or advice is being given as to whether any investment or strategy is suitable for a particular investor.
It should not be assumed that any investment in securities, companies, sectors, and market downside described were or will be profitable. All information is current as to the date herein and subject to change without notice. Any views or opinions expressed may not reflect those of Saxon Design Research as a whole.