Hello and welcome to the Ghibli Rewatch series of the Overly Animated Podcast, where we'll be going through every Studio Ghibli movie chronologically from the beginning. I'm Dylan Heisen, and today I'm joined by Ali Martin. Hello. And April Collins. Hi there. Yes, the Ghibli Rewatch series. Join us in re-watching or watching for the first time all the Studio Ghibli movies now that they're available for streaming for the first time on HBO Max in the United States and Netflix and most of the rest of the world. New Ghibli podcast will be up every Wednesday to go through the whole catalog chronologically at overlyanimated.com. Find all of our contact information there. I'm a Ghibli expert. Be joined by co-hosts with a variety of Ghibli experience as we go through the whole catalog. Today is Howl's Moving Castle. Very exciting, beloved movie. We're excited to talk about full spoilers for Howl's Moving Castle. Make sure you have seen this movie before you listen further. Minor spoilers for the rest of the Ghibli movies.
We'll be discussing both the subbed and dubbed versions, so whichever you have seen is fine. Time for Howl's Moving Castle, our next Yao Miyazaki movie. We're coming off of Spirited Away, and now it is 2004 when this movie is released. Howl's Moving Castle, loosely based on the 1986 novel of the same name by Diana Wynne-Jones. Miyazaki, maybe similar to Kiki, took over production not right in the beginning, so this was originally intended to be directed by...
Mamoru Hosuda, who's made a name for himself especially recently as a prominent anime director in Japan. But he didn't like the direction. Miyazaki took over. We've seen this before. So now he makes this next major project. This is coming off of Spirited Away, the biggest movie ever in Japan. Of course, the next Miyazaki movie. I'm going to be big, but this was definitely lived up for it. It is still as of now the sixth highest grossing movie ever in Japan, Howl's Moving Castle. So this is a big success in Japan. And then also this was a big success in...
internationally too, because his, you know, renown has spread after Spirited Away, and this was very successful all over the world. So, Howl's Moving Castle, yes, big fantasy movie for Miyazaki coming off of Spirited Away. A lot of people have attachments to this one who are our age. A lot of interesting things to talk about this one. Ali, what is your history with this movie, and what do you think of it?
I think I watched it for the first time just before graduating high school. And at the time, I really liked it. I still really like it. But I think about it differently now, I guess. I remember my friend who read the book, and I know nothing about the book, told me that obviously it's not the same. And she said that Sophie has more agency were her words in the book. So since then, I was like, I don't know if I like this movie as much. But I did rewatch it again a bunch of times on today. And I still really enjoy it a lot. I think Sophie's character is...
I don't know about necessary, but the way she's depicted is, I think, done very well. We're going to get into it later, but I like her a lot in terms of the female protagonist that Ghibli presents. I think she's definitely in the top 10, but I don't know if there's more than that that I can name. Animation is great. I think this was one of the ones that stood out to me that goes after Spirited Away in terms of crazy sequences that make me feel like I'm not on the earthly plane just watching them. Music is also fantastic. Yeah, I really liked it.
okay fan of howls not on the earthly plane yeah i think that sounded right to me about uh this feeling of some of these there's one scene when they're like above the earth so like literally yeah there's a few of those actually probably a few of them yeah a lot of flying and yeah okay and like port not portals but like black holes and it's weird okay we'll talk about that april what's your history with howls moving castle what do you think so i could have sworn that i had seen this previously because so this came out like just as i was getting into high school and so i think that's whenever like my whole like anime thing started to like paper off a little bit just because i was focusing on like school and everything like that and so um and I like when I started watching this I was like none of this is familiar so I might as well have been watching it for the first time um and I won't lie it took me like like I started it because I totally agree with you Ali about how like it kind of like takes you off like the earthly plane kind of thing and so like I started watching it and then like 20 minutes in I was like oh my god I'm not even paying attention anymore but I'm like fully engrossed in this movie and so and so like I just started all over again and then like that happened to me again like 40 minutes into it I was just like what is happening to me during this movie because it's not like a bad movie in any way shape or form I was just like very distracted by what was going on and what I was seeing um which I I don't know if that's a good thing or distracting is a good way to describe it though that's a good point yeah like like I even told you guys I was like this is the third time I've restarted this movie um
But I definitely liked Sophie as a character. You know, she's a really good female protagonist. I mean, I thought it was beautiful. I thought the music was like paired with it nicely. You kind of got a lot of like, like Kiki's vibes in terms of like the music, like because there's like once I don't know what the song was. But I was just like, am I watching Kiki's right now? Because I'm not like, so there's like, like, those things are definitely going for it.
I don't know if maybe I just missed some of the themes. I enjoyed the movie and I thought it was really well done, but I feel like I lost the plot and I was just like, what happened in this movie at the end of it? But we can talk more about that later. Okay, we'll talk about that. I don't think you lost it. That's the thing we'll talk about. Okay.
Yeah, Kiki, that's definitely a lot of comparisons to Kiki, another European-inspired fantasy world for Miyazaki. Similar production kind of history, maybe the sound, the look, steampunkiness maybe a little similar. So I think there's a lot of similarities. So I must have seen this pretty early on with all the Ghibli movies just because it was so prominent around that time. I don't have strong associations with Howells. I know, and I definitely want to acknowledge later on in the podcast, a lot of people I think we know do have strong associations with Howells, especially like women who were growing up around when this movie came out in America. I think it's a very prominent movie for a lot of people. For me, it wasn't one of the ones that I was super attached to with Miyazaki movies.
always had the thought, like, this is a good movie, but not necessarily as good as any of the other Miyazaki movies we've covered thus far in the Ghibli rewatch series. That's kind of my impression going into this rewatch. I would feel similarly, you know, I think rewatching it here. But I think, like... You can forget, I think, how magical this movie is. I think magical, like similar to Spirited Away, this is coming right off of Spirited Away. I don't think this movie is Spirited Away, but I think I felt similarly emotionally watching it a lot of times as I do watch Spirited Away. And that's like, for me, its biggest strength is just the, it really does capture, even if it's not as much of a complete unit as Spirited Away, I mean, what is, but it evokes the same sense of magic and these crazy emotions that I think you can feel from Miyazaki at his most magical. A few points in the middle of the movie.
I was like, you know, got a little bit, I guess, deja vu. I didn't remember these scenes from this movie because I hadn't rewatched recently. And I was just like, oh man, this scene, like, wow, I have like strong emotional associations with this scene. Like this is really evoking a lot from the past for me. And then experiencing again was a pretty strong, I think, experience. So I think that was like the best part of rewatching it now. And if you haven't watched it in a while, I think maybe you could evoke similar feelings from someone who's watched it a long time ago. My experience kind of with towels is like, I'm kind of bored in the beginning.
And then there's like an hour, which I think is like pure magic of this movie. Love it. Then the third act, which we, speaking of Kiki's, this is actually my biggest comparison to Kiki's. Mizuki sometimes has had problems with third acts. Like my least favorite part of Kiki's is the third act, the ending. I think this movie has a final act that does not make any sense. And that is what you'll frequently hear criticism of Lies of Hells is that the plot is really not there. Thank goodness. Because I was going to feel so bad if I was the only person who was like...
It's still the sixth highest grossing film in Japan, and it was apparently like a flop when it came out or something? It was definitely not a flop. This is financially successful across the board, especially in Japan. I think people did really like this, but there was some criticisms. We'll talk about that. You know, there's some people at the time when it came out who were like, this is a lot worse narratively than Miyazaki's previous movies, but mostly I think it has always had very positive reception. But, you know, I think as you get into like the Ghibli big, big fans, you'll hear a lot of like Howl's crit about the plot of this movie. So that's something we'll want to address for sure. And I don't think it's necessarily even in-depth criticism. It's just like the ending of this movie that it doesn't make sense. And if you're looking at this...
as a strong, like, narrative script base. Like, that's not what this is. It's going to be a lot more of an emotional thematic experience. And I think if you want to connect on it to mostly that level, it is, which I think I was able to watching it, and I always have been able to. I think it's there. But ultimately, you know, I think it probably, because of some of the issues plot-wise, which is, I think, shockingly, are not there for previous Mizaki movies. We can talk about that a little bit. I do think it maybe feels like a little bit of a step down from some of his previous works. But I also think it has this, like, magic, which is...
not always there for his previous movies and is particularly intense, I think, in the middle of this movie. And at the end, too. There's some great scenes at the end. It's just, you know, all tied together. You're left kind of wondering what's going on.
Yeah, it's kind of sometimes it feels like too much, but that's also how I felt about Spirited Away and I still enjoyed it. Spirited Away, I think one of the biggest differences is it retains a strong sense of logic in terms of what's happening. Quote unquote logic. Which is interesting because Spirited Away is stuff that makes, it's all random stuff that is not in depth, but it's all really tied together very tightly narratively. And then you get to Howl's and there's a lot of stuff kind of thrown at the end that does not have that same. And you look at, they're maybe not that far off when you think about it, just because it's not like, Miyazaki does not have these narratively driven movies. We can talk about this first since we're on the topic. Miyazaki's process, as far as I know,
Owls probably makes a lot more sense when you think of it like this. He does not do a script. Like he goes, he makes an image board. He just draws, he starts by drawing key images from like his, that he's inspired to draw about the story he wants to tell. He starts to flesh it out, adds the image board, and then he goes straight into storyboards. Then he starts storyboarding scenes straight from his image board. So I've always been really impressed that Miyazaki is capable of having these really narratively excellent films, at the very least narratively competent. I think it's more of a shock that it's taken this long for him to get to a movie that doesn't really make sense. Like how does he have 10 movies before this with like kind of no scripts? I think it's pretty impressive. And you know, it's a movie he takes over later in production. I think it's pretty easy to see.
see once you think of it in that sense how how it kind of arrives at uh at this point considering his creative process um but yeah i mean that's definitely something you'll um you'll hear a lot about is is nerdly but also i do want to emphasize like i do think this is a very beloved movie and i think a lot of people have strong associations with this movie loved it growing up um i think people were really into the sophie howell romance into howell as a character when they're kids i'd get to get into howell i feel like i feel like that's definitely a thing yeah like i can see people being very very into it and like i i'm i guess like one of like the memories i have this movie is like it's from three-ish years ago and i had a co-worker and for halloween she dressed up as sophie and because she's like i loved this movie growing up and i was like wow how old am i like so was she like old lady sophie yeah she was old lady sophie yes queen I'm proud of her. Yeah. That aspect, Sophie, is like an old woman for most of the movie. Definitely a prominent thing we're going to talk about. And kind of the anti-war-ness of the movie, that's another prominent thing. Let me read the, talking about the overall quality. Here's a, bringing a quote from Susan Napier. Starts negatively, gets positively heard, just citing people's reactions. This is from Susan Napier's novel Miyazaki World, which I frequently reference on the podcast. She says, admittedly, some critics in Japan and elsewhere had issues with its quality, finding it hard to understand. More recently, Shunsuke Sugita has called the movie a failure. To these critics, Miyazaki's single-minded portrait of melodrama combined with war was rough-edged work. Difficult to comprehend, awkwardly tied together, and with...
a forced and artificial happy ending on the whole she says on the whole i tend to agree with stage econo's positive assessment of how as a work more poetic than narrative stringing together a tapestry of images to create a multifaceted whole overall it remains an idiosyncratic and appealing creation ambitious and angry while offering indelible visions of solace beauty and love Accurate. So I think Susan, if you're some simple and she says, you got to look at it more poetic than narrative. It's a tapestry of images, which I think all of Miyazaki's movies are, but you might most cite this movie as a tapestry of images with so many kind of disparate, visually iconic scenes. Yeah.
Yeah, Ali, what do you think of the criticism aspect of this and the overall assessment? I mean, now, having watched it just today, I'm tempted to go with Sugita's criticism. Not that it's a failure, but that especially the happy ending feels really, like, it's cringe to me now. Like, I really enjoyed it the first time watching it when I was, like, 18. But now I'm like, this is so stupid. Like, normally I'm a fan of that kind of trope. Also, especially if it's not a hetero romance. But, like, here it feels just kind of gross. I want to know how the book went when I look at this movie. And I kind of, like, I don't have the energy to read the book. But I'm curious because I know that, like, Sophie, like, I also appreciate how...
sassy for lack of a better term she is in this and she like doesn't take anybody's garbage she's like get over yourself but apparently she's more like that in the book so i want to just read that but i do agree that it's definitely more like flower not flowery like he says poetic the narrative which i don't think it's a bad thing but you do have a point that it's like really not what we're used to with minazaki because he does like not that the narratives are like kind of shoved down your throat with like anti-war what have you but it feels less like in your face in this movie but again i don't think that's bad i just it's kind of jarring Yeah, I think that one of the most potentially hard-to-palate scenes for some people is the very end when the king's magician, Suleiman, she says, oh, I guess we shouldn't do this war anymore. Like, what changed your mind? Are you serious? Just because you had your dog stalking them and you were watching them on your Christmas? You watch a K-drama and you're like, well, I'm going to go, like, donate to charity. What? I think it feels silly. Yeah, that's it.
And also, I don't know how to feel about the turnip prince guy either. Like, everyone's in love with Sophie. Even the fire's in love with Sophie. It's weird. It's just weird. The turnip scarecrow comes to life, and he's like, oh, I'm a prince. Oh, and I'm going to end the war, too. Like, just magically, we're going to end the war. And she starts kissing everybody out of nowhere. She kisses, like, everyone, yeah. Some sort of weird deus ex machina, but it's weird. She's spreading the love, I guess. I appreciate that she's, like, grown, like, enough confidence to be, like, well, I mean, I don't know. She has, like, this nurturing characteristic throughout the movie. But it's weird. It's weird. That's all I have. Yeah.
So, I mean, it definitely seems silly looking at the movie as a narrative, but if you're going to look at it more as thematic or poetic, then I do think you can see this ending earned with the war ending and characters kind of being persuaded by seeing these scenes of love and family. I think that's probably the generous assessment for that. Personally, I don't see the anti-war aspect even potentially as one of the stronger aspects of the movie regardless, but I do think that ending definitely works a lot better if you're not viewing it strictly narratively. I wish I had known that it was like an anti-war movie before I watched it, because then I feel like everything would have made more sense. I want you to read that quote.
about Miyazaki not showing up to the movies. Okay, so let's talk about that. So let's talk about this as an anti-war movie. So Spirited Away, huge success, nominated for an Oscar, wins an Oscar, which is still the only foreign language movie to win the Best Animated Oscar. It's crazy at this time, which people don't even know Miyazaki to the extent that they do now. He's bursting onto the scene. It wins. Miyazaki is not there. He did not show up to the Oscars. Now, granted, it is very far away, but he had gone to the US before, and he did not hear it. He says, now we're in the modern period where I can actually cite interviews that are still up on the online, so that's cool. The online stuff.
Online, yeah. This is from Devin Gordon's Newsweek interview with Miyazaki, a positive pessimist. Miyazaki got asked, why didn't you show up? He says, actually, your country had just started the war against Iraq, and I had a great deal of rage about that. So I felt some hesitation about the award. In fact, I just started to make House Moving Castle, so the film is profoundly affected by the war in Iraq. That really makes me appreciate the war aspect even more, because like April said, like, I had no idea this was a war film. Like, sure, you have the propaganda in the background, but again, it's not as in your face as like Grave of the Fireflies or what's the other one? Wind Rises, something like that.
Right, so you're talking about Wind Rises, I think. I mean, it's easy. I think you want to bring in, and Napier does this in her chapter, you want to start to bring in Ponyo and Wind Rises as this kind of later Miyazaki films when you're talking about Howl's Moving Castle. Ponyo relevant because we're going to definitely have to keep in mind with that discussion, the visual over-narrative kind of aspect that he has in mind at this point in his career. Got that movie. Similar to Takahata, it definitely goes visual over-narrative later in life. I think this is a common thing that they're sharing, probably influenced by each other. But yeah, I mean, he also has these very strong anti-war sensibilities which factor into Wind Rises and definitely this movie, which Miyazaki characterizes Howl's Moving Castle.
a reaction to the Iraq war so let's like that is the greatest thing ever yeah that's just like oh why didn't you come to the Oscars because y'all started a war like that's that's like a that's a move I like it it's a great move I can't believe you did that but I hope more people do that I think it's an iconic Miyazaki move not showing up the Oscars do it talking like this this is you know now we're like we've been saying we're into curmudgeonly Miyazaki now and this is one of his biggest power moves we love it um but thinking about Howl's Moving Castle as an anti-war movie um so there's a war that frames the entire movie And I think that, you know, I, you know, you might not think of it like as this, like the whole movie is about.
like War is Bad, like Grave of the Fireflies. Like, probably that's not what he's going for, but it is a big backdrop for the film. We can bring in Susan Napier, who maybe explains some aspects of this a little better about this. Especially how Howl is, I think, largely supposed to be an anti-war character. Napier says, In his depiction of Howl as a fighter and in his magnification of the war, Miyazaki differs strikingly from the original book, though it must be acknowledged that the war is presented in a curiously offhand manner. In contrast to its charmingly detailed domestic scenes of hanging laundry or cooking breakfast, the movie gets rid of the bloody reality of war and instead offers a distanced perspective.
While the director includes his trademarked original flying machines, this time with memorably animalistic or even insect-like qualities, these machines are noticeable for their lack of any human presence. This is also true of the victims. Mizuki presents numerous aerial depictions of bombings, showing a night sky full of flames and houses on fire. These images suggest the fire bombings of Tokyo that he witnessed as a child, and also the bombing of Kobe, depicted in his partner Takahata's celebrated film Grave of the Fireflies. Unlike in Grave, however, the camera never turns earthward. We are not privy to the life and death struggles of the bomb victims, and can only presume that they occur.
The most personal aspect of War, therefore, becomes Howl's blistering anger embodied in his risky metamorphosis into a non-human creature. His non-human aspect is ironic. It is clear that he is the only participant in combat who actually cares about humanity, a compassion expressed in his lamentation to Calcifer that the other warring magicians have forgotten how to cry. Love Napier's characterization of... this movie as being very distant compared to something like Grave of the Fireflies, which I personally find to be a lot more effective as an anti-war film because we get to see the war close up. Now, Howells is not about this primarily, so he's still focusing kind of on the main aspects of the book. And in terms of like, I want to read the book to see what's different. It's just very different from what I understand, so a lot of things are going to be different, but he keeps the framework of the book and then just does completely different things with it, I think. I definitely want to read the book. I think he definitely adds in this anti-war part, which I think is not as prominent in the book. And so he's not getting up close.
personal. But yeah, Howl. And if you, yeah, I think if you go in thinking of this as anti-war, you might be able to easier to see Howl's turning into a bird as a war type thing. Like he's turning into that as he loses himself fighting against this war. I guess, is what is going for here. Like, Howell is being this anti-war presence in the midst of these warring factions. Now, personally, the biggest part of the movie that doesn't make sense to me watching it is not the, I mean, the ending, it's more annoying than, like, not nonsensical in terms of, like, they just decide to end the war. But I, like, to me, the movie never explains what Howell does when he goes through the black door. Yeah, it's a bit annoying. This is, I wish we're a little clearer, but I think it's, I think, you know, after looking back, the intent is that he's going to sabotage both sides of the war. This is kind of like what is, what Nizaki's going for here. He's just trying to fight against the war in general.
goes through the black door he goes to fight in his bird form against both sides of the war um personally i find this never really spelled out in the movie yeah we get like one really vague scene of him like supposedly in that dimension whatever it is but like it's not even two minutes long yeah you see him like interacting with the the giant blimps and stuff but you know we don't really know what he's doing or whatever yeah the wizard yeah and you have the wizards who are fighting for I do think it's interesting that in this world like wizards are completely co-opted into the war as like war fighters you know you see them like as kind of primary instruments of war I think that's an interesting concept but yeah I mean there are references to Howell being like losing like just being exhausted emotionally losing himself to his bird form and all of this kind of in the context of him fighting against the war and he those like pen names he uses they're for both sides right I just want to clarify yeah like because each side because what is it I guess they they like drafted like yeah you would that's what i thought i think my understanding is this is the we only ever see the one side of the war and he's drafted out both times on one side of the war is my okay that was my interpretation at first but i kind of like it better if it's different it doesn't really matter but yeah i think i think as far as we know the kid the suliman's king is the one who conscripts him twice as two different personalities because they don't know it's him yeah yeah i was like i thought he was like
drafted by both sides but it's possible that's up for interpretation i'm not sure that yeah after researching if that was kind of my impression um based on reading stuff about it but yeah i like that you said well were you saying that you think that a distance perspective for war is like does work better than one that like focuses on people suffering uh for me it's a movie like grave of the fireflies is much uh is much more affecting than i agree i just i i think it's just because then you like can personally like you can relate to it i guess Thinking about the fact that this came out in 2004, I mean, I was in fourth, fifth grade, so obviously I wasn't politically aware of the war with Iraq, but we grew up during 9-11, and now I'm pissed at my fifth grade self for not thinking about this, like the distance perspective that we had during that war, and it just makes me mad. Yeah, maybe it's a criticism of our distance perspective to wars and commentary on that. Yeah, that's pretty interesting. I mean, I think you think about this time period, 2004, Miyazaki adamantly against the Iraq war, but we think back, now we think back negatively on the war in Iraq. It was definitely seen as a positive thing in 2004 in the United States. It's a pretty radical movie to have one of the biggest animated films of the time, the Miyazaki's giant.
anti-Iraq war commentary like think about it like that it's pretty yeah that's pretty cool that's awesome I love it yeah you know you wish on one hand it's like I wish it was a little bit clearer the messaging and stuff I mean I think it's like there enough the war sucks kind of commentary which is you know in our current state you know we're and maybe who just we personally are as people. And at this point, like it's like, oh yeah, war is bad. But like at this, you know, most of the US watching this movie, it's like they're getting a clear anti-war theme when they're in like a pro-war mindset. So it is a little, I think, radical. Although I think it should be noted the Iraq war, I think probably unpopular outside of the United States the entire time. It's just the United States where it would be. Yeah.
And so on one hand, you kind of want it to be even a little bit more prominent to nail it down. On the other hand, it does contrast a lot or maybe at least not fit in super with a lot of these other themes that are happening, which are really interesting, which we're going to discuss next. So I do like that he left room for these other aspects of the movie, which I think are some of the best aspects of the movie. So maybe he did find the right balance as it's there and prominent enough, but also leaves room for a lot of other cool things. possible um but at the very least i would have liked what how it was doing a little clearer but once you kind of think of it like that i think a movie starts to make a little more sense like what does that mean he's just interfering with both sides like what's his plan like what he's just going out there trying to just take down as many players like he's so against the war like howl's against the war obviously but then he's like out there but what is he doing exactly when he does go out there like I don't know. He's just trying to take down the warplanes, I guess. I guess. I think chaotic good. Sure, that's chaotic good, right? I mean, I think, you know, he's trying to prevent further casualties. And potentially these, you know, there's probably a reason we don't see the ins and outs of the people fighting the war. We just see kind of these bird-like magicians. There's like that one scene where, I mean, it's not really ins and outs, but like when they're going shopping or whatever, and then the bombs drop in the ocean.
Yeah, I think that's one of the best scenes of the movie, honestly. That is really the most close we get. I'm annoyed. That's one of my favorite scenes of the movie. Yeah, so it is there. There's some stuff there. You start to see a bombing a little bit up close, and then they probably retreat to the castle. Yeah. Well, it's enemy propaganda, so I mean, I guess, yeah, everywhere is a castle. Sorry, go ahead. Everywhere is a castle. Is that a philosophical statement? Every country has a castle. I don't know.
Yeah, that's probably true. If it comes up, we can continue talking about the anti-war messaging, but I was also, I think, glad I was talking about it. And yeah, I don't know if this is a major topic, but the castle itself, obviously a big part of this movie. Oh, yeah. Visually extremely striking with the use of CG of the castle. I think we talked about how Mononoke, they get, Ghibli gets CG for the first time. It's maybe a little rough, but well integrated. Spirited away, even better integrated, still a little noticeable. CG, I think pretty, pretty well at this point, seamlessly integrated into Howl's Moving Castle. I would agree with that. Yeah.
I just love that it's a castle. I don't know how, I forgot the dub, but when Sophie first fired, or rather when Turnup introduces her to the castle, she's like, you call this a castle? And I'm like, yeah, it should just be like house moving, I don't know, weird mobile home. Even on the inside, when I watched this for the first time, I was expecting it to look legitimately like a Disney castle or a real life castle, and it's just a house inside. So I was like, why is it a castle? I don't get it. He lives in it. So it's his castle. Big enough building, I guess it's a castle. Yeah, but it's like, it looks...
But there seems like there's only one, maybe two rooms in there. You had to add a bathroom. They added a bathroom, yeah. I find the scenes with the castle to be some of the most magical scenes. Once we start getting into the part of the movie where she's exploring the different exits and the colored wheel that leads to these different parts, I think this is so engrossing at this point. Just seeing it leads to all these places. The kid puts on this old man magic disguise and you see Howl has all these personalities and stuff. Once you get to that part of the movie, I'm super in. Because we want that door. It's the Doraemon door. Doko demo door.
But like, you only get four places. Only four, yeah. I don't know, could he add more? He did, he added the pink one. Yeah. We never got to see what the other one was, which also annoyed me as a kid. The black one or the... The blue one, I think there was. I don't know what he changed the pink one from, but there were definitely four, unless I'm remembering it incorrectly and I need to watch it again in another five hours.
Yeah, you'll always be watching it. It's all the exits. The scene when he moves the castle, I love that scene. I think that's pure magic. The sequence of animation is just so good. It's incredible. And I do think this movie is stunning and stunningly animated, like one of his absolute best Miyazakis. Benefits from the modern technology, but also just gorgeous. And of course, all these movies are significantly hand-drawn, even if they incorporate computer graphics. The scene when she...
finally splashes water onto Castleford to kind of, like, destroy the castle. And then it, like, cut off the portals. I think that's great, too. All these castle scenes I'm really into in this movie. Like, where the castle falls apart, too. Oh, yeah, when she takes him, like, out and he's like, oh, like, I should be the last one to leave. And then, like, as soon as, like, he crosses the threshold, like, everything just crumbles in. I really enjoyed that scene. I don't know why. It was really, was that all CG?
I mean, I don't know. We have to go back and look. I think probably nothing's all CG except for maybe the castle, but I don't know. But it's incredibly striking visual and it walking, powered by Calcifer, who I have to say, we haven't talked enough about Calcifer to this point. I love Calcifer. I think he's an iconic Miyazaki character that I don't consider enough to be part of Miyazaki's amazing set of characters. You don't. I've never heard you bring up Calcifer before. I don't think I remembered my love of Calcifer until watching it again now. He's so great. I also will say he's better in English. That's like one of the few times. I'll probably make him sassier and stuff. Yeah, I mean, he is sassy in Japanese, but he's great in English stuff.
He's Billy Crystal. Okay. That's such a good line. Josh Hutcherson is Markle. I remember that. Oh, man. And freaking Christian Bale. Christian Bale is Howell. Wow. I can't get over that. The casting they do for these movies when they dub them is just insane to me. At this point for the modern Miyazaki movies, yeah, they're going all out. So Emily Mortimer is young Sophie. Gene Simmons, old Sophie. Should be noted in the original Japanese, Cheiko Baisho does both young and old Sophie. Yeah, she is insane.
And she sings the end credits as well. Yeah. She's really good. Really good. Yeah. I think this is one of potentially performances. Yeah. They have to, I mean, the fact that they have to separate that in most languages to two performances, I think speaks a lot. Yeah. Yeah.
Yeah. So, I mean, let's, let's, we can come back to Castle for, I guess, but how about, Sophie, I think is definitely one of the main topics I'll talk about next. And Sophie just as a protagonist who is an older, an old woman for a significant portion of this movie, I think is, I have to say, I think looking back on this movie now, assessing it, the most unique and distinctive element to me, I think of Howl's Moving Castle is the, the seamlessness of Sophie's arc as an old woman turning, she sometimes looks younger. She sometimes looks in between. It's so subtly done throughout the film. I love that. That was like, like I was fully like.
captured by that because some of the like transitions would just be so subtle like maybe she's a little bit taller or she's like got longer hair or like just just enough though but it was or her eyes that was like one of the things that like i was always like where her eyes at like what do we got going on I think we talk more about Takahata in terms of these weird distinctive animation choices. This is one of the most prominent Miyazaki ones for me is just this complete integration of young and old Sophie throughout the film. It's striking enough that she is an old woman for most of the movie. That's striking, powerful, but her changing to kind of fit the themes and emotions of the scene and as it continues kind of her journey to where she ends up at the end where she is mostly young but also retains qualities of when she was older. I think it's...
Probably, I think, I don't know, if not my favorite aspect of the movie, definitely like the most distinctive and probably the best part of the film, I think. Yeah, I agree. I love that she just like fully accepts it too. She's like, all right, I'm an old woman now. Like, she's like, my clothes finally make sense. And my attitude does too. And you have like a great from the book again about that whole thing, which is just perfect.
Yeah, let me read some Susan Napier passages on this movie's view of old age. So in general, she says, Through Sophie, Howell's Moving Castle deals on flinching with Lee with the pains of old age, an issue of huge concern in Japan, where the rapid aging of its population is viewed with alarm. At the same time, the movie uses fantasy to process fears of aging and death in an ultimately optimistic fashion. While it acknowledges the darkness of human nature, the movie's upbeat ending offers a collectivity that is diverse, loving, and supportive. The movie is a kind of valentine to the director's older colleagues, especially his many older female staff members, demonstrating that old age can be liberating rather than diminishing.
I think definitely some overall maybe themes that he's going for in his presentations of old age as he himself is definitely getting older at this time and somehow still going at it almost 20 years later currently. Is he back off of his retirement? Yeah, he's making a lot. He's making a final movie. He's doing it. Oh, man. The third final movie. I don't think he retired between Spirited Away and Howells technically, but I don't know. It's hard to keep track. But yeah, he's at least one or two retirements in at this point.
And this is not the end of it. So yeah, just the view of old age. We've talked a lot about how Miyazaki is not afraid to present old women or not, you know, old women in terms of like grandmothers and also just like middle-aged women. Like it's very radical in terms of you think of Hollywood and how it's rare to see actresses getting parts past 30 or something. Like not, you know, rare, but it falls off a lot. And Miyazaki consistently integrates non-young women into his films. And we have maybe the most striking example as his main character is partly not a young woman in this movie, however you want to think of it. And I think this is...
in some ways a culmination of this uh this themes of um his integration of older women throughout uh throughout his films and uh also just on its own a commentary on uh old age finding uh liberation in old age like this talks about yeah i think i think it's all very strikingly done i also like that if it was not at least like explicitly stated in the book in the movie it's implied that like the curse is like still kind of up to sophia and that like her attitude determines what happens with herself like when she like wants to help howl i mean i don't know if that's really a good thing she turns younger when she like acts more youthful she turns younger when she has like i don't want to say less confidence but when she's like less sure of what she wants to do or what's going on she turns old and it's like a back and forth but it's always up to her and like even the witch of the waste is like i can't break the curse like i can only cast it who knows what's going to happen vigness but like i liked how it was portrayed Yeah. Yeah. So I'll read a quote later that incorporates questioning of the curse as one of these kind of aspects of the movie that is not explained, which I think is true that the movie never really explains how we break Sophie's curse if we do at all. But I will say I'm not bothered by this lack of narrative detail in terms of the curse. Yeah, me neither. You get a thematic sense that it corresponds to her journey that she's going through and that she's either overcoming it or integrating it into herself, wherever you want to look at it, kind of through her journey. And I think that is really gorgeous. It could be both. Yeah, I think probably both in a lot of ways. And yeah, I think this is not something that needs to be explained. And you can see how...
you arrive at like, maybe there are some things that should be explained. But Mizaki often does this, that he doesn't explain things and you don't think they need to be explained. And so the line is, I think, sometimes thin. But for me, this one is firmly on the side of doesn't need to be explained. And the curse, I think, yeah, along with her, the presentation of visually of her aging and de-aging throughout the movie is one of the strongest aspects. I have another quote from Susan Napier. It's kind of an interesting commentary on age and the different aspects of the movie that leads into some...
Some more general Greek commentary, I think, on this aspect. So she says, Kotani makes the radical suggestion that Sophie's real curse was a more insidious and earlier one, to be a young girl. It is, after all, young girls who are constrained by society and expected to behave in certain ways, such as being charming or flirtatious. When we first encounter Sophie, she seems to be rejecting that role, even insisting on wearing a dowdy hat in marked contrast to the gorgeous headwear available in her shop. It is her metamorphosis into old age that allows her to reject the constraints of young femininity most definitively.
Although Miyazaki has consistently shown young girls breaking this constrained paradigm in terms of both action and attitude, his previous shoujo characters were feminine and cute. In contrast, the elderly Sophie with her protruding news, wrinkled visage, and sagging, stumpy body is decidedly not cute in the conventional meaning of the term. The director even includes a scene of her snoring by the fireside, an inconceivable image in any of his other young heroines. Even at the film's end, she retains the traits of self-reliance, compassion, and forthrightness that her metamorphosis had nurtured, symbolized by her retention of silver hair while the rest of her body regains its youth. Um, so I think that analysis at the end is kind of the, the, the broad takeaway by the end of the movie is she has, um, retains what she has learned in her journey and is kind of symbolized by her, her, her hair color change. That's a move we've seen a lot recently, I think. Yeah. Was this like, was that inspired by the, I mean, I think if you're looking for animation influences, this hair color change is probably a big one on current animation. Probably looking back to howls for that. Although, you know, this isn't old enough that it would, I'm sure there's been some other hair color change. I mean, it is now 16 years old. It's an old movie now. Yeah. That's an old movie now. Yes. Okay. It's 16. It's, it's legal to drive.
In some states, it can get married. Yeah, that too. Markle is an adult now. Oh, I loved Markle. I didn't want to bring this up, but now I have to. That girl who comes into the shop when he's disguised as the old man, I shipped them when I was a kid.
I was shipping it now watching. Not surprising. I was so sad that he has to look like an old man. I know. Maybe she'll get like an old lady costume. She'll be a witch in training. I like that they, Napier talks about like at the beginning of this quote, that's like the curse was more her being a young girl at the time. And it's like my biggest problem with the movie, maybe the book, if it's the same, is like these women are like from the beginning, they're like, oh my God, it's Howell. Oh my God, I love him. Oh, but don't go near him because he's going to take your heart. But oh my God, I love him. And it's back and forth. And I hate it. It annoyed me so much watching it for the first time. And it still annoys me now.
it's just that's like such tea to say that like young girls are constrained by societal norms and they have to behave a certain way they have to like want to get a certain guy but also like keep themselves distanced enough like it's just the worst but the way she put it is fantastic yeah i was gonna say she really like captured that like sense because i felt that as well that like you know like sophie wanted to like she wanted to be a hat maker and her sister's like oh well do what you want she's like this is what i want to do like leave me alone so was it implied that like her dad died in the war because she was like i'm sticking here because dad like the hat shop meant so much to dad so it's like oh he's dead and then she freaked out like at that bombing scene i was like is she getting like not to be that person but we're flashbacks like ptsd kind of yeah better thank you i apologize i mean possibly like i kind of i kind of got that sense that like her father wasn't like around anymore and i was also really shocked because i never picked up that the one lady was her mom and i was like i thought that was her sister she looked just like her sister until she was just like oh sophie she's like mom and i'm like what um what oh yeah yeah wait so that was that that's her sister okay so i was very confused by the family stuff so
Her sister is the one who's like, you have to do what's best for you. In the beginning. In the beginning. And her mom. And then her mom is at the end. Yeah. Even though to me they look like the same character. They look exactly the same. Are we sure it's not the sister pretending to be the mom or something? No, because the mom, you see the mom in the beginning because she comes back and she's got that really crazy hat on. I thought that was her sister too. No, that was her mom. Oh, man. Yeah, we don't spend a lot of time on her family. Like, it doesn't really, it's not important, I guess, but.
Yeah, I was a little confused by that. Yeah, and I think in some ways, to close out the old age stuff, I think in some ways it's radical commentary to say the real curse was youth, but I think it is totally fitting with this theme that I do think is very prominent in the movie of her feeling liberated by being older. So I think in that way it kind of fits. Okay, I'm looking at them side by side. I see the difference is basically the nose. The mom has a bigger nose. But they look similar? They look exactly the same. There's blonde hair, blue eyes, same pink eyeshadow. That's why I was confused. Oh, no, I'm sorry. The sister has blue eyeshadow. That's the difference. The sister is Letty, I think. I don't know what the old woman's name is. Yeah, the sister is Letty. The mom is Mrs. something or other. Mrs. something, okay. Hatter.
There you go. Oh my god, really? Are they really Hatter? Oh my God. Oh, it is. Wow. Okay. Allie brought this up. Let's talk about Howell as Miyazaki's number one heartthrob character. Did I bring that up? Was I making that up? You said you don't like in the beginning how like the girls all, you know, so I think that, so I mean, I think at its most generous, like we could, the commentary would be this movie as the, you know, we don't, I have not read, you know, not read the book. We're not analyzing the book. So we can think of that separately, but the movie, you know, it starts within this framework that a lot of these kind of fantasy movies aimed at like teenage girls doing that. There's like this heartthrob type character. And so maybe, maybe it like works in the framework of that and subverts it. Like maybe, maybe you could think of it like that.
Still, maybe. We can talk about that. But Howell himself, you know, interesting, interesting character. You know, we don't really see this type of person in Miyazaki movies, this Edward from Twilight type character. Oh, my God. See, I was waiting for somebody to talk about that because he spies on her while she sleeps.
Did he really? Somehow it's less creepy. That's the iconic Edward myth. He peeked open the curtain and she was just laying there all normal. Oh, yeah, yeah, yeah. And she was normal. So that's how you know that he knows that she's under a curse, which you're not 100% clear about. And that was the first time I realized that she's switching back and forth, too. Yeah, same. He starts to integrate it a little more, which is, yeah, it's really interesting. Okay, I don't want to, now I'm going to think of him like Edward. Do, please. Because he is not really able. You want to know, like, how old he is? That's the thing. He could be. Oh, I should say, last aspect of the, and this will come up later, but the old age thing is that the Witch of the Waste, instead of, like, treating her like a villain,
she's like revealed to be her true age is shown and she's forced to be her true age she is um treated with compassion and brought in um like you ideally would treat the elderly um so i think that's hard that has to be addressed though that's sad i think any other movie would kill her off yeah probably yeah mizaki does this sometimes i think it's very radical that she was still shady as heck throughout like even when she doesn't have magic so i didn't like her then then it's like she's just uh her her true nature is like on the surface and so she sees howl's heart and she's like i still want to have howl's heart it's not in like a conniving way but it's just that's her desire still she just is an old creep now so the reason i thought that is because uh you know like much like her it's possible howell was also being kept for a long time yeah um april what's your view on howell after watching um he was an interesting character i feel like he was all over the place which i was not like i don't know so far it's conflicting because you think about two guys and you're like who's the best none of them are great
but i don't know like you don't get a whole lot from him either i feel like just that like he doesn't like war and i'm like okay cool and then bare minimum yeah like bare minimum and like it was like the first thing they do is they're just like oh like he's here i wonder if he's in town and they're like oh well i heard he ate some girl's heart and they're like oh well i'm safer whatever yeah because i'm ugly like really yeah i hate that yeah because well so whatever like i heard like i like like heard that i was like oh so this is like going to be about like hit, like, it's gonna be, like, a Beauty and the Beast kind of thing. Like, he's gotta find his true, like, true beauty and accept others or something like that. And then, like, that was not the plot of the film at all. Stockholm Syndrome, a thing that happens here because, like, she does kind of, she is forced to work for him because she's where else to go. And then she falls in love with her, like, master or whatever. Well, and I also love, too, because he's just like, who let her on the, in the castle? And she's like, I let myself on, like. Which is also confusing to me because, like, when you're thinking about his relationship with Calcifer, how he's, like, essentially his heart. I mean, I guess it's super ending. But, like.
Wouldn't he be aware of everything that's going on in his house because he and Calcifer are connected? I don't get it. Yeah, because they're connected. And I guess he's his heart, supposedly, but I don't understand, I guess, that connection. And maybe, like, whenever he ate Calcifer, and I was like, oh, look, he's eating his own heart? Does he mean he's free? I don't know.
Yeah, I think Howell is a character that suffers a little bit because of the plot stuff in the movie. Like we've talked about, you don't really know what he's doing. But I think he's definitely this type of heartthrob type of character. He's probably a lot of people who watched when they were younger and love this movie's kind of favorite. I think you'd probably get an emotional connection to the Howell type of guy. I did relate to it whenever he was turning into green goo. Yes.
I love the line from Marco. Like, I saw him do this once when a girl dumped him. He's like, something fucks me. Yeah, that was pretty fun. Yeah, and I think Cowell's a character that is intended to come into focus kind of at the end when you get the big reveal in a super iconic scene when Sophie witnesses young Cowell capturing the shooting star. And you see that Calcifer has his heart. And so he's a character who was heartless throughout this movie. He is...
He's emotionally underdeveloped. He is, you know, I think it is, it relates to the appeal of a character like this, probably for a lot of women or like people, maybe when they're younger watching, it's like, oh, it's, you know, you reunite him with his heart and he's mysterious and now he can love and he's nurturing. That really reminds me of Twilight now that you're phrasing it that way. Yeah. And like this, you know, this framework comes from a book and it's, you know, that type of generally the book. And I'm sure the book handles it in a subversive way too, but I think Miyazaki does his own twist on stuff with the character Howell. But I do think the character comes in the focus a lot more when you realize he was, he was.
Lacking a heart, underdeveloped, I think, throughout the film. And Sophie helps him get his heart back. And that's part of their story. Don't pick that. That's like all. That's the thing. When I think about like.
Miyazaki heroines, it's like, they subvert that all the time. So I'm like, why is he doing this? And why is he making it a specifically, like, non-shoujo type character? Like, why? Why? Are you saying that it's not a typical character? Yeah, it is true. I mean, that Miyazaki does not do this type of story and it is striking that Sophie and Howell kiss twice in this movie, which has, like, never happened before in a Miyazaki. That's also because they're older. It's less PG because they're older. Yeah, and I think we've read several quotes, I think, throughout talking about romance in Miyazaki movies. He's just not interested in romantic angles of things. Yeah. But then you have this movie, so it's like, what?
But I think this movie also, like, it showcases that, like, romance isn't his thing. Yeah, that's true. It's a good point. Because he's like, y'all, like, want romance? I gave it to you. You hate it? Cool. Like, I won't do it again. He portrays it in a negative way, maybe. You know, I think it's a fairy tale type thing that he's playing into. For some reason, as he's gotten older, he's more open to this. There's a, you know, a kiss in one of his later movies, I guess, you know, getting into that big spoiler territory. But For the Wind Rises actually also features that. Oh, I thought you were talking about Ponyo. No, I don't remember if there's a kiss in Ponyo. I've seen that.
Yeah, they kiss at the end of Wind Rises. So, like, he moves in this direction. And there's, like, a ton of documentaries about the making of Wind Rises. You see him, like, kind of talk about, like, struggling with, like, oh, I guess I should make them kiss. Like, I normally do this, but I guess this is, like, the thing that is more appealing now. That's his best kiss scene, though, so that's good. He improved. Yeah, I mean, I think that's his pinnacle for this type of thing. But Sophie and Howell, when he's a bird and then she's kissing him. Yeah, that's a good one. I think the hug between them was the cutest thing. I'm just at the end during kind of that blog scene, I think, is really good. So, yeah, so neither of you are big Sophie and Howell shippers, sounds like. I'm just not a big Howell.
person like I think I was when I was younger and I do like the twist that like she saw them in the past and then he finds her in the future like oh there you are I was looking for you like you think it's an act but it's actually real and it's like oh my god Shyamalan twist but I don't know he just has like a character like you said he's not fleshed out enough in the movie to make me like really feel something for him which I think is purposeful to a certain extent but you know maybe that lessens the emotional attachment at the end to them Also because he's just a drama queen. Yeah, he gets real upset about his hair and I think it's hilarious. That's the best part of Howl, honestly. It is, but it's also the one that makes me want to date him the least. Yeah, I was like, it's a great moment, but it makes me less attracted to it because he can't be freaking out about his hair because we're going to freak out about my hair. Yeah, who's the Howl and who's the Sophie in the relationship? Oh, Jesus Christ, that's going to be the new thing. It's the new thing, yeah. Whatever, I'll take a page out of Sophie's book and just dye it gray.
I think this is Miyazaki's preeminent ship. I think this is the ship for so few. Unless you want to count Whisper the Heart as Miyazaki's ship, too. Okay, but that's a good one. It's actually good, yeah. Certainly the role of Howl as kind of a womanizer and the fangirling of the pretty guy and who actually harms them and her nurturing him back. Of course, all of those dynamics do not currently appeal to the type of people that we are. So, of course, okay.
understood but in 2004 sure I was into it I was really into it so certainly like people as kids were gonna be into this and then also I just like given given like if you could accept all that which you don't have to but if you can accept all of that as it is it is I think really well presented at the end of the movie yes yeah I just I'm not attracted to him it's hard for me he's definitely Miyazaki's like hottest guy come on Ashitaka is right there Ashitaka okay that's a good point he's my fave and also Pazu don't you love him You know, they're getting, I don't know, I wouldn't say positive. For some reason, positive now is reminding me of Josh Essertson. I don't think he did. He looks like him kind of. Yeah, right. That's something. Yeah, quickly, Markle. Yeah, Markle's great. I love Markle. Yeah, he's great. I do think Calcifer is probably my favorite character. I want to talk about him more, even though there's not a lot to talk about. He just has a lot of great one-liners. He's, I love when he becomes like a raging demon that is like threatening, but he's still kind of sweet.
I love that Sophie, she's just like, I'll pour water on you. Yeah, and she threatens, and then she follows through eventually. Like, I'm not putting up with this. That's a great, in a movie that has narrative flaws, that's a really well-seated moment after she threatens that, and then not for the purpose of getting back at him, but for the purpose of saving everyone has to pour water on him. The twist, the Shyamalan twist. I thought the timelines were the Shyamalan twist. I mean, the whole movie is kind of a Shyamalan twist in that it doesn't really make any sense, and it's just happening. It's like a fever dream he has. It's just a fever dream at the end, really, yeah.
I mean, to say that the ending doesn't make sense, I think I said before, there are iconic scenes of the ending, you know? It's like, I do think the Catching the Stars, I've seen, highly remembered. There's, you know, the castle falling apart and stuff. Like, everything's great on its own, you know, just maybe putting it together narratively, but, like, we're trying to view it poetically as discussed. But yeah, Calcifer. I'm just like, because talking about Calcifer and staying on the plot at the end, like, the castle is flying, but Howl doesn't have Calcifer, like...
as his magic heart. So how is he using magic? Calcifer opts in to power the house. He chooses to stay because that's his family now, which is the next thing to talk about. Oh, yeah. Oh. Yeah, we can get to that in a second. But yeah, Calcifer, I think, comparing it to Kiki again, he's the GG of the movie. At first I thought in English they were voiced by the same person just because they're like begrudging old men. Some similar characters, yeah. They're both very funny. And I think, well, no, in Japanese he does have a lot of good one-liners still.
I remember in Kiki, they gave him a lot of more room to add in the dub. In Kiki, they changed it a lot with the dub. Yeah, I don't know about this movie if they also changed it. But yeah, he's very sweet, yet a little bit sarcastic, yet... She likes my spark!
I want a Calcifer plushie now. I don't think that I have not. I've never seen a Calcifer. I've never have either. I've seen all the other little cute dudes, but I haven't seen Calcifer before. Like a plushie of a fire, I guess. Yeah, fire. It's probably a statue or something. Or just an actual fire. Just put googly eyes on the wood. There you go. In the Ghibli Museum, you get a ticket for the short film they show. And the ticket is one of Miyazaki's movies. And one of the ones I got was Howl and the fire. I guess I have a little Calcifer thing. Oh, you got to keep it. Nice. Yeah, you get to keep the tickets. Yeah, it's really good. Yeah, that one of the Howls is one of them. I don't know. Is there anything else to say about Markle?
he's just so cute i love that he was like i don't know he's just very precious he's not like a i mean he's not a teenager but he's not like a brat either obviously because he's working for howl i guess but he's just so adorable i love that he loves sophie and he's kind of like i guess he's like the the like opposite of sophie because he even though he's so young like he obviously has like a sense of responsibility and like respect and everything like that so just because like he i guess he manages like spells and stuff and like goes about and does business and manages the money yeah seriously wow he is like very mature for his age he's like yeah he's like super mature for his age and he's just comfortable with that and it's kind of like that's who like sophie could have been is because you know she's very much like an old woman in a young woman's body but then she's in an old woman body Yeah, he's the old man in a young man's spot. Okay. Yeah, and then he comes across very responsible. Yeah, is he a Benjamin Button situation? Maybe. Yes. But then he also has those moments where he's very much a kid. Yeah, eventually he opens up to Sophie. Yeah, he's just like, you're my mom now. It's so cute. It's good. Okay, that'll lead us into the quote. Okay, so let's talk about this as a found family at the end, because I know Allie loves found families. Yes, who does? This is one of the most iconic found families ever, I think, at the end of this movie. Oh, totally. Okay, I have a very long quote from Susan Napier. There's many aspects I think are really interesting of this. So let's read it all, or we could potentially stop and talk about things as it goes. But overall, talking about the found family presented at the...
End of Howell's by Susan Napier, she says. incorporates the very old, the Witch of the Waste, the very young, Howl's boy Princess Markle, and even a pet, the dog Heen, not to mention a magical creature, Calcifer, returning to the family because he misses its other members. Okay, I appreciate that, that it's a resistance to the Anami, I don't know how to pronounce that, of modern society. That's a good take. Yeah. Go ahead.
Okay, yeah. And the move of Cal story returning at the end is really sweet. That's right. Okay, while family issues are important and contentious around the world, it is reasonable to suggest that Japanese society has particular difficulties in this regard. As Sugita points out, the Japanese family underwent major shifts in the last two decades of the 20th century, while the divorce rate in Japan remained far lower than other industrialized countries' relations between the generations, but grew increasingly negative, leading to such phenomena as the hikikomori, young people, usually but not always male, who stayed at home with their parents but refused to interact with them or with the outside world. During this period, youth violence also rose, and the media detailed truly shocking stories of bullying and abuse by young people whose families apparently had no idea or concern.
about what they are doing. It is the state of toxicity within the family that the director is clearly attempting to combat in Howl. While Howl is hardly a textbook hikikomori, his narcissism, his lack of responsibility, and isolation at the beginning of the film suggest a socially unevolved young man. The other characters also initially seem to have little interest in family relationships, though Sophie rather perfunctorily visits his sister Leti at the beginning of the film. Mizaki emphasizes the power of family ties with the scene inserted late in the film in which Howl's young apprentice Markle asks Sophie whether they are a family. Her reply is strongly affirmative, and we see Markle clutching tightly to her skirts in a gesture that suggests both desperation and relief. Sophie's taking in of the...
The now virtually senile Witch of the Waste is also an element added by the director. Her kindness to her former enemy not only emphasized Sophie's developing maturity and compassion, but also suggests a model of acceptance and love towards infirm and elderly people. Whether Sophie is actually capable of magic herself, her ability to see the best in people, from Howell to Calcifer to the Witch, suggests a form of special talent. Yeah, that's some good tea. So at the end, referring to the empathy, I think, and compassion, she learns at the end. My main, a great commentary, I think, on Miyazaki. This is totally a Miyazaki move trying to comment on family in Japan and family relationships and gender relationships. I just want to talk about Howl as a hikikomori. Yeah, seriously. I love this take. I love it. That's the best thing I've ever seen about him because when I was younger, everyone was like really into him and I was like, I don't see the appeal and now this makes so much sense. He's a hikikomori.
I wonder to what extent this is intentional. Maybe not specifically by presenting him as that type of person. In the book, he's also, I know he's obnoxious in the book because my friend has pointed that out to me many a time. Like he's just a stupid boy. No offense to boys. Like he's just, he's obnoxious and it makes sense.
Howell specifically stays in his room and does not want to go to the meeting with Suleiman and eventually trails her. He also gets mad because he doesn't want people to go in his room. That's a classic Hikikomori move, yeah. You can't go in my room. Howell, I think, is a lot more sympathetic if you think of him as a Hikikomori. Is he? I think so. He's not a womanizing guy. He's just some nerd who has social problems. There's so much terrible stigma against Hikikomori. You know that. I think the main aspect of this is...
is uh undeveloped uh undeveloped socially which i do think is a legitimate part of the movie and i think that totally plays into that characterization so i really think that's uh that's interesting talks about how like his uncle would visit him or no if that was his uncle's actually i can't remember i thought i assumed he was like always alone except for when his uncle came to teach him magic so it's like implied that he never really got um It was never socialized properly. Yeah, I think so. I think that's what the movie's trying to talk about. And so we're commenting kind of on those types of people with Howell and how Sophie interacts with them. And she has this grand found family that at the end is together with all these many different types of people, which I do think it's a really beautiful ending with mom and dad who kiss on the castle, Howell and Sophie. That's the thing. Even if you don't really like Howell and Sophie or their dynamic or whatever, it's still a nice thing that everybody comes together. And it's like a lot of different people who were kind of at odds in the beginning. Yeah.
well it's also one of those things where like maybe if your family is broken you can find you can still find that companionship like elsewhere and yeah and not always in like the people that you expect like i thought it was very like endearing how they were calling um the witch of the waste uh grandma at the end i was like and everyone was calling her grandma too and she was like i'm grandma like grandma yeah okay i want to i love all that i want to talk about the witch of the waste and suleyman because we haven't talked about that part of the movie as much so The scene and the dog, I guess. So the scene when, this is the part of the movie when I was like, wow, I remember this. I didn't even remember this from the movie, but I'm having like these emotional kind of resonance. So when we go to the large steps and they have to walk up the steps and the Witch of the Waste cannot like do it and she's trapped and then she's like put in the chair and she's like stripped of her powers. And then also the part when, you know, Sophie, or I guess Suleiman confronts Sophie and Howell and they have these like changing landscape and they're like high up in the sky and there's like shooting stars all around. I just think it's so magical, that part. The stairs thing, like it's so iconic in my mind and has a strong emotional resonance. This is like,
like is this like big fat shaming of uh i still think i mean it's a funny scene i don't think that's a good thing to say but i was laughing at like i thought it was more of like a take of like how like like older like generation would like are lazier and so like and even like the witch of the waste is just like well how like how are you like able to get all get up all the stairs and it's like well sophie's not really an old woman like she's just she's just cursed by you so or she has a spell put on her by you but she's still like young like technically so she is that much more capable kind of thing but even though like you know she got you know up the stairs first and everything like that she still like waited behind almost and was like okay like are you coming like i think she was cheering her on yeah she was like cheering her on but negatively like oh you call yourself a witch you can't even get up the stairs like yeah i think i think probably in classic mizaki fashion it's a commentary on how the witch of the waste does magic and doesn't work for herself and so now she has to actually do like some work for herself and not just magic it and she can't do it and she's too uh you know to me definitely i think
comes across into a little bit as badly in terms of her being too fat to get up the stairs. Yeah, totally. You have to probably not think of it in that capacity for it to work. You have to think of it as that she's a capitalist who has people do things for her, and then when she has something done for herself, that she can't do it because she's too much money. yeah commentary on rich people or something like that you know like uh yeah it's it's it's it's still like an iconic aspect or part of the movie regardless I guess but yeah it's complicated feelings about that and then yeah just them confronting Suleiman I'm gonna say quickly about Suleiman um I think something that distinguishes I think that is something distinguishes Howells from uh some of Miyazaki's potentially quote-unquote better movies Suleiman is a character that is a Lady Eboshi in Mononoke or any of these or a Dola in Castle in the Sky and yet she's like just not really a person in this movie she's not really a character like this is a character that should be that type of character but there's no no effort put into her characterization in this movie I'm glad you brought that up because I don't like that that happens, but I know she's not like, is she supposed to be relevant?
Yeah. Relative to well, I mean, Izaki's making his own story here. So I think she's in more of a villainous role as the king's magician. She's also serves as like a king surrogate and a surrogate for the person starting the war. But I think in his other movies that are more potentially more complex in some aspects, this character is seen in a nuanced light, whereas here she's pretty straight villainous. Although I think you sympathize her when you learn that she's like Howell's mentor and stuff and maybe seems like a cog in the machine in her own right. But yeah, I mean, there's just a lot going on here and a lot of other characters on Sophie's and Sophie's like found family and stuff. And we don't spend time on Suleiman. Maybe instead, Witch of the Waste, maybe you could see her as that type of character this time. Yeah.
I also don't think there's really that level of complexity with her, but I think it is. Is it supposed to be Sophie though? Cause she can be both. I mean, Sophie is kind of both the shoujo protagonist and the iconic older character in the movie. So I think that kind of fits. Yeah. And so maybe there's extra weight, extra work that has to be done with Sophie's characterization. So there's less time to spend on other characters too. Maybe you can see it that way. But yeah, just which of the way we talked about, which of the way staying on board and being this, being this character. And similar to no face being part of their team after being the villain and spurred it away. I think that's kind of a move for Miyazaki. And I do think it's really interesting. I like that move when that happens, but I didn't like her period. Yeah.
I think it's done well, though. Yeah, it's like when she's stripped of, similar to No-Face, how about this? When she's stripped of the things that make her toxic, the magic that is supporting her toxicity once No-Face is in the wrong environment, once you take them away from that, they become more sympathetic, kind of harmless people. Yeah. yeah I think which which of the ways more of doing it of her own accord I guess from our perspective and hey I literally wanted to bring up Catra she got out of a toxic environment let's move on which of the ways yeah we don't really know her much of her backstory beyond that so I know how she got to this position but also I wanted to go back to Sullivan for like two seconds because we were talking about we don't know why the war ended I remember when she was talking to Sophie about how she was like I'm sad that he left me I thought he was gonna be my heir so I was like is she ending the war so like she can like course him into being the new king or something now that I'm thinking about it that's also just not so good we needed more of her but there was no time there's a notion when how it was yeah her her prodigy and i don't i didn't get the impression from the end she expected how to come back to her yeah it's possible but it also seemed like she was more accepting of that fact at the end versus like in the beginning because it seems like everyone's like just trying to get their hands on howl and but then like at the end everyone's like i just let him do whatever he wants he's gonna do it anyway yeah yeah i do think they're more accepting of that at the end uh the turnip head uh i think it's turnip head and the dub turnip in the to the sub it's both i think
I like Turnip. This is one of my favorite scenes in the movie, Quietly. Turnip helps them do the laundry. I loved that scene. It's really good. For some reason, I really love that scene. I like when he brings Sophie the umbrella. Yeah, that's good. I just don't like that he was in love with her and that she had to kiss him to break his mouth. He's very accepting right after that. Oh, she doesn't love me. Okay, I'll go into war then. If Sophie did love him, would he have not ended the war? He's really worth everything for Sophie.
Yeah, he's really respectful. It's weird. It's like, oh, Sophie goes, kisses everyone at the end, turns into another person in love with her. Okay, sure. He makes a face when she and Howl are making out, though. I mean, you know, he's allowed to make a face. Well, yeah, he loves her. He's allowed to make a face. I know. He can have a face, yeah. They're back on another man. Right in front of him, damn. He's like, I just confessed my love to you and told you I was going to end the war and you're going to kiss another man. Yeah, maybe they're being a little out of it. Yeah, get a ruler. Yeah. Is she moving into Howl's room in the castle? I don't think he's moving.
He's still, he's still, he could go putting his leather together. He's like, no, you're not coming out of my room. Yeah, no. I like it. You're still the cleaning lady first. No, that's terrible. Oh, no. Oh, no. That's terrible. Speaking of the cleaning, I mean, we talked a lot in Spirited Away how Miyazaki's in throughout this podcast. Miyazaki's themes of finding self-identity and things that are important about yourself through hard work. I think, again, with her becoming the cleaning lady, doing hard work throughout the castle, she's like finding her place, finding things about her. You know, it's not like in service of Howl or for Howl or anything. It's just like she's doing it because she wants to and it's important to her. That's kind of always what Miyazaki's going for with this type of theme. Yeah.
Yeah. And I think it's mostly successful here. I don't have, I didn't have too much issues with that watching. It's just an excuse for her to be there. And then, yeah, that's how it starts. And then she finds meaning in it and stuff and more finds meaning in the work. One scene I want to mention, speaking of scenes I love, is the, when we go to Howell's Secret Garden. Yes. And the water. It's a beautiful scene. Gorgeous. And then also like, again, with the bombing, one of the best depictions of the world, when you do see a single airship go down later, you come into where their, their sacred space and how the contrast of the violence of that and the peacefulness and drink of his garden, I think is pretty good. Yeah.
So yeah, a lot of these scenes are towards the end. So are these really good, these really great scenes towards the end? What else haven't we talked about with these scenes? We did talk about the, you said the scenes where they take the magic away from the Witch of the Waste. And then when Solomon confronts Howell and Sophie, that just like, it felt like a bad trip, but it was beautifully done. In a good way, yeah. I mean, I wanted, like, is there, were those actual words that the, like, stick figures were singing as creepy as heck? Yeah, she said the figures to try to like take away or like subdue him or something. Yeah.
Sophie helps him break out of the trap. Yeah, those are some of my favorite scenes, definitely. And then the iconic scene, not the flashback, the like, what is it? The timeline scene where she like goes into a black hole back to the future. It's just cool. Was that CG? I'm not sure. I don't know. She goes to witness the catching of the star and goes back. I thought it was like really well done. Very beautiful. I'm just confused as to how it was done.
Yeah, it's very beautiful. We could talk about this as another Miyazaki European kind of fantasy world. We've talked about that in the past. He does that a lot. There's a word for it. Europephile? No, no, no. I'll find it. And then I think we talked about the ending. I want to talk about Hisaishi score. What's the term? Tiabu. Tiabu? Yeah. What's the T for?
British culture. Oh, for like tea? Like having tea? Okay. There's a different term. When you say there's a term for it, you meant like a slang word. Okay. I'm going to look up the academic word for it. I don't know academic things. This is like slang. That was more in line, yeah. That was more in line with what you should expect. Okay, I'm going to talk about Joey Saishi's score. This is a very beloved score for Houseman and Castle. This is, I think, potentially one that people would cite among his best work. And I haven't listened to it as much. I had a lot to say about the Spirit of the Way score. That's one I've heard a lot more, but I tried to listen through it.
To note some highlights, the biggest thing for me was the reoccurring theme of Sophie and Howell's theme, or what you might identify as the main theme of the movie, depending. But it's just in many, many tracks on the soundtrack. It's part of Merry-Go-Round of Life, which is the opening that establishes a few themes throughout. It's a walk in the skies. We didn't mention the scene when she meets Howell, and magically they walk together above the city, which I think is a great one. And that plays there.
We have Sophie in Exile, Unspoken Love, The Flower Garden. I mentioned that scene. Love Under Fire, Sophie's Castle towards the end. So those are all scenes with that recurring theme to them, which I think is a great musical component. I'm a big fan of reprisals, especially when they have change in mood. It's like, I love music, man.
She actually does a lot of them, for sure. I wanted to note Salimon's spell, Returns to the Castle, which is the music that plays during this part. We're talking about when Howl and Sophie confronts or Salimon confronts and traps them and they're like through the sky and stuff. I think that's a great one. The Boy Who Swallowed a Star. Yes. Just the ending to the movie. Because everyone just remembers Merry-Go-Round, whatever. But the whole movie has a lot of great music. Yeah, and then the end credits is partly Merry-Go-Round also. It's own thing, I think, are gorgeous, too. Yeah, a lot of the music towards the end. Yeah, The Boy Who Swallowed a Star at the end, Salimon's Spell, and then all these gorgeous romance-themed ones throughout.
um it's it's a really good uh soundtrack i will say there's and it's pretty there's a lot of songs too yeah um okay is there april anything on your minds that we've not talked about owls no not really i am curious to like re-watch it now especially like everything we talked about because some things i'm like okay that kind of makes more sense or at least like now i know what to look out for in terms of like re-watching it um i'd be interested to read the book and see how it compares but i'm lazy reading it's a movie podcast reading is there yeah What is reading? Ironically, I do my most reading in preparation for this movie, but I guess I have to read the books about them. Yeah, but those are good analysis books. Heen the dog thoughts? He was a good boy. Was he, though? No. He activates the broadcast only at the end when he knows that Suleiman will see the air of the waves. That's it. That's the only time. What a good boy. The bird working for the bourgeoisie, but a dog. I like that she thinks he's howl, and then it's like, no, it's just my dog. Yeah, that's funny. Who was guiding you here?
He was good regardless. He's not the best guy. He was good, though. Yeah. All dogs are good. That's true. That's a good point. That is true. Ali, anything else from the house? Not that I can think of. Same. I mean, I don't want to say I didn't like it, but it is definitely not one of my favorites. But I think I have to watch it again as an anti-war movie because I did my rewatch before I looked at the outline. And then seeing that, I was like, oh, Lord, that makes a lot of sense. Watch this in the context of Miyazaki's pronouncements against the Iraq war. See how it comes from that lens. I'm curious. I think I'm going to like it a lot more now with the propaganda flying around. I don't know. It was good.
Yeah, I think, I mean, I, you know, this isn't the top of my list on Miyazaki movies, but I want to give this movie a to-do list. Oh, yeah. And I think that, like... Yeah, like it's not my favorite Miyazaki movie, but I can definitely like see why this would be someone's favorite movie. Totally. So like, yeah, it's not to my taste, but it's a good, it's still like a very well done movie. Yeah, I think that that checks out, right? Like even there's just so much here to potentially latch on to. And you can, especially if you can just view it from this thematic sense, which I think we view a lot of things we talk about in the podcast primary, we try to view it from a thematic sense. I think this movie is definitely enhanced if you're kind of turning off that narrative.
Yeah. And I think that, and I think that's a key. And also if you buy into the grand Sophie Howell love story, I think it's going to play a lot better too. But even without it, I mean, just Sophie's journey, I think it's such a great thing to latch onto. Yeah. The presentation of her character. So I think all in all, like I came in with a little bit of an anti-Howell bias to this whole process, this whole Ghibli rewatch. And because I had these like, oh, it doesn't make any sense. Yada, yada. You'll hear that a lot. I think I come out of it with a much greater appreciation for Howell as there's a gorgeous, very rich movie with a lot going for it. And yeah, I do think maybe it's one of the ones which I would most want to rewatch just because it's so visually striking.
So many, like, really good scenes, which I do want to see again. So I think that speaks well to it, too. It's rewatchability. Okay. Any final comments? We good on Howl's Moving Castle? We good. Yeah, Gucci. We good. We Gucci. Okay. Is that a Europe thing that we can... Oh, God. Wow, I didn't think of that. I'm still trying to find the real term for a European weeaboo, but I'm not going to be able to find it. It's not a tiaboo. I like tiaboo. No, there's another one. But honestly, I think that this one is more set in like a German, like villain. Yeah, that's the thing. There's one that... That's the like British one. I'm trying to find the overall European one.
It says Slavaboo? Oh, because Slavic. Stupid. Miyazaki went to parts of France in research for this movie. More like rural France. I do think Germany's not a bad call, but towards that side of France, yeah. So it's a scout location. Where do we know from Kiki? Sweden. Not the same part of Europe, but he went location scouting to Europe and kind of central-ish. I don't know. I think there's a lot of similarities there.
Comparingly, if you want to compare Howl's and Kigen, that's really hard because they have a lot of different great things going on. How is it comparable? It's not just that the music feels very similar. Yeah, yeah. The framing. Yeah, the framing. And also just the rich main characters, too, I think. Yeah, and they both involve magic. I don't know. Magic and witches on the brain. So this was a good rewatch. Yeah, blues and Andy watching. Yes. Okay. Every part of the movie.
Ever, of course. Yeah, people don't know what that is. They're listening to this. They're listening to the separate feed. They don't know what this is. It's fine. They'll figure it out. They'll figure it out. Let us know what you thought of Howl's and all your thoughts on it. OverlyAnimated.com. Find all the ways to contact us. Give us your thoughts on Howl's Moving Castle. Consider supporting us via Patreon at Patreon.com slash OverlyAnimated. Thanks to our patrons, especially our patrons on the podcast, Ryan. And thanks, as always, to our patrons, executive producers, Ryan, Steve Alex, patrons, you, Michael, Needle, and Phonition. The Ghibli rewatch continues as we are firmly in the...
post Spirited Away, post Howells era now, if you want to think of it like that. The next is Tales from Earthsea, Goro Miyazaki's first film. If you thought there's criticism of Howells out there, wait until we get to Tales from Earthsea, so we'll dive into that. Probably similar criticisms of the narrative being thin, but I don't know, I haven't seen it in a while, so I'm interested to see if I gain a greater appreciation for Tales from Earthsea. And then Ponyo, as mentioned, so there's...
yeah i mean we're past the ones which i have a super big attachment to so we're gonna get into some so to try to find appreciation for these later ghibli films as we continue okay um i think that's it for house moon castle thank you for listening guys we will see you next time bye