Skip to content
Hypersocialism PLUS Frumpy Fani is back! episode artwork

Jan 2, 2026 35 min

Hypersocialism PLUS Frumpy Fani is back!

from Party Pooper Podcast Hosted by Matt Jordan

I’ll preface with this chilling news out of the new People’s Republic of NYC. The New York City Council has passed what has been called the Community Opportunity to Purchase Act (COPA) that will force private building owners to offer up their property to nonprofits and government entities before they make any private sale, effectively causing massive delays in property sales and other regulatory hurdles in the Big Apple’s housing industry.In the scenario that it is passed, NYC will have the largest COPA program in the country. The act forces landlords to offer their property to the city as well as nonprofits before the building can be sold on the public market. The lawmaker who sponsored the law, Council Member Sandy Nurse, claims that it will be a win for New Yorkers. “Corporate interests and big real estate tried their hardest to block the Community Opportunity to Purchase Act with a misinformation and fear-mongering campaign, and they failed,” Nurse said about the law’s passage, per Pix 11. “Today marks the beginning of a new social housing era in New York City… COPA levels the playing field and makes it possible to preserve and create thousands of permanently affordable homes across our city.” [emphasis mine] Keep that quote in mind as we continue. I just read a piece by Chevan Nanayakkara (CN). It is nothing short of delusional. It demonstrates the ignorance of economics that have led so many young people to embrace socialism. In this case, the writer seems to think he’s hit on a terrific hybrid of socialism and capitalism, with the government in the driver’s seat. CN argued that we ought not have Universal Basic Income (UBI). Rather, he opines, we need Universal Basic Assets (UBA). Using modern Lefty “logic” he claims we can afford to do this because we have an inexhaustible supply of money with which to do it. Then in another context he says we don’t. But no matter. He plows ahead anyway. CN is seriously blind to the absolute authoritarianism which will come from what he sees as a great idea. He also, whatever his credentials, is clueless about economic reality. This article is a political pamphlet tarted up to look like sound economics. While it does have true statements infused into the article, many assertions are blatantly untrue, the conclusions are wildly flawed, and it stinks of economic central planning. What CN proposes is socialism on steroids. Let’s talk specifics We’ll start with the author’s motivations. The real question isn’t which ideology to choose. It’s how do we use our understanding of monetary systems to build institutions that serve everyone in a pluralistic, diverse society? How do we create an economy where someone can choose a quiet, subsistence-level life without stigma, while their neighbor pursues wealth-building in competitive markets. Both can have dignity, security, and genuine opportunity? [emphasis Nanayakarra’s] What’s wrong with this quote? Well, a lot, actually. First, economics. He compares socialism to capitalism. Those are not ideologies. Conservatism or Liberalism are. The former are economic systems. Sound economics work with either ideology, if the government isn’t the major player in an economy. Sadly, too many people, including the author of the linked essay, conflate politics and economics as if they are SUPPOSED TO BE joined like Lego pieces. Also, through all of history, the system that has served everyone is free market economics. The pluralism and diversity mentioned are aspirational political concepts, and romantic notions in the modern meaning of the words - which is to say the way a man like the author sees those terms. Again, not of the business of sound economics. We’ll see in a minute what the author means with his comparison between choosing a quiet subsistence-level life as opposed wealth-building. Suffice it to say that the former provides neither dignity nor security (as the author contends), and spurns opportunity. In Nanayakkura’s utopia, the takers will have to be told, constantly that they have dignity and security. When the world around them moves forward, they will be left to beg the nanny state to give them more money or stuff. It matters not at all whether Uncle Stinky gives them cash - UBI - or the finished product - UBA - they now MUST have, to maintain their “dignity”. I will have to move along quickly. As is the case, whenever liberal pipe-dreamers spout what appears to be cool stuff, I’d have to write a book to take this article apart appropriately. So, to bolster my counterpoints with sound reason, consult Adam Smith, F.A. Hayek, Milton Friedman or Henry Hazlett. That is where you will find economic reality. Modern Monetary Theorists, like CN like to think they are smarter then those better men, because their work is so old fashioned. (The correct term is timeless.) But REAL economics, the basic realities of how we buy and sell and live our lives, are as hard and certain as gravity. Every time societies have strayed from the concepts of those four REAL economists, whether they knew their names of not, those societies have paid a heavy price. Those societies FAILED! So augment what you read here with a book. CN claims the government has no spending constraints. He says that like it’s a good thing. But the statement is only true because our currency is not a store of value. And this is the root of how economic power is abused by the central planners. This is why it is so easy for them to feed cronies and burn the taxpayers. The cronies in question are ALL the very billionaires Dems and other Lefties claim to hate…but their Democrat political betters kneel before. The federal government doesn’t “get money” from anywhere. When Congress authorizes spending, the Treasury instructs the Fed to credit bank accounts. Money is created by keystrokes. No vault. No pile of tax dollars. No Chinese credit card. This isn’t political spin, it’s operational reality. Ask Fed officials, Treasury officials, or banking system operators. The government spends first (creating money), then taxes later (destroying money). Taxation doesn’t fund spending. It removes money from the economy to control inflation and redistribute purchasing power. [emphasis mine] Again, there are too many problems here to deal with them all, but as the argument unfolds, you’ll be able to fill in a lot of blanks and skips. If you grab one of the linked books on the subject, you’ll see right through what CN is saying. And who would understand the first paragraph of the previous quote better than Biden’s chief economic advisor, Jared Bernstein. Get a load of this short clip before moving on or come back to it for a good laugh. Double click, then click. In the clip, Bernstein isn’t having a stroke. He DOES know how the system works. He just couldn’t find a way to honestly explain the way the system works without causing a mass revolt. In other words, he’s not a good liar. So he settled for looking stupid to avoid telling a whopper, or showing you honestly how much the government has rigged the system against you. Taxes used to be how the government acquired what it wanted to spend. When money was a true store of value (backed by gold), people were more conscious about their wealth and income. They had to know that what was taken from them was for good reason. There was also a time when we didn’t have our money taken automatically, before we saw our paychecks. It almost goes without saying that if you had to cut Uncle Stinky a check for many thousands of dollars every year, you’d be a lot more judicious about who you elected. Now, taxation and a constant state of inflation, steadily scraping away at your wealth, are monetary tools, which NC seems perfectly happy with. And why not. He is an Modern Monetary Theory (MMT) advocate. Just print all you want and confiscate it on the back end. And all this to do what? “Redistribute purchasing power.” Create false dignity. Before I get to the reason for CN’s… This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.streetpolitics.us

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Hypersocialism PLUS Frumpy Fani is back!

0:00 35:19

No transcript yet.

Requests help us decide what to transcribe next.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Party Pooper Podcast?

This episode is 35 minutes long.

When was this Party Pooper Podcast episode published?

This episode was published on January 2, 2026.

Can I download this Party Pooper Podcast episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.