I Demand a Platform With Algorithm Settings So I Can Curate My Feed
from Walter Rhein Podcast Hosted by Walter Rhein
Thanks for your support: 30% off 💙 40% off 💙 50% off 💙 60% off 💙 80% off On literally every single platform, users inevitably begin to complain about the algorithm. No matter how big and popular and powerful a platform becomes, the audience invariably begins to flee because they become disgusted with the content that turns up in their feed. Everybody claims that we’re living in a “capitalist” nation. The whole point of capitalism is that the marketplace listens to the demands of the consumers. If that’s the case, why hasn’t there been a rush to launch a platform with an algorithm control panel? We’ve all seen how frustrating it is to navigate the menus of streaming services. Within the first few minutes of operating any platform, it’s clear that certain products are promoted at the expense of all the others. This is seen in the way the same five movies appear over and over no matter whether you select “drama,” “comedy,” or “thriller.” More than once I’ve wished that we had a “never show me this selection again” button. That would spare me from having to scroll past the same display over and over and over. The menus of streaming services are so bad, that I often use third party options like JustWatch to discover what’s available. Essentially, I’d prefer a spreadsheet that simply lists the title, director, year of release, and actors. Sometimes I’ll reference the box office lists of past years. When you do that, you’ll find that there are many films that apparently have been removed from the catalog and are not available anywhere. The movies that have been taken out of circulation are the ones I most want to see, but if you rely entirely on the platform algorithm, you’ll never know they exist. You’ll be too inundated by the latest offering of Chris Pratt or Mark Wahlberg. It’s as if malicious entities don’t want us to know any other actors ever existed. Speaking of Mark Wahlberg, I’d also like a tool that allows me to block any film that features him. In addition to the fact that he has no talent, he also went to jail for assaulting a man back in 1988. I’d prefer to watch the performances of other people. In fact, there’s a laundry list of actors who I have no interest in watching. When their films are pushed on my feed, it’s a waste of my time. I’ve been discussing the concept of algorithm settings in the context of movies, but it can be applied to the entire internet and how we consume our news. I would very much like a platform that allows me to curate the information I’m scrolling through. I do not want some malicious form of AI to censor information. I’m perfectly capable of adjusting my settings until I get the information I’m looking for. I’ve done this in academic research. We have those tools at the library. Why shouldn’t we have those tools on the internet as well? I used to rely on a feature called Google Alerts. You could set a topic and then you’d get an email from Google whenever a story appeared on that topic. When I lived in Peru, I set a Google alert with the name of my home town. You could set an alert for something like “cold fusion” to keep up to date on any breakthroughs. Google alerts are convenient, but the human race requires the opposite. I’d very much like to have a tool that allowed me to block any news featuring the name “Kardashian.” Every single time that name is presented before my eyes, it represents a waste of technology. Once again, there’s a whole laundry list of names I don’t want to see. Some people will argue that offering this kind of feed curation will put “everyone in a bubble.” Frankly, I think that’s an absurd argument. The fact of the matter is that we’re living in a bubble now. Decent content is buried and slop is jammed down our throats. Human beings are intelligent. If we allow human beings the tools they need to educate themselves, they’ll use them. The fact that we don’t have feed curation, and that nobody is even talking about it, strikes me as nefarious. I go back to the famous quote from Steve Jobs about how he didn’t want to put windows on buildings because then the people would just “screw things up.” Okay, but what if there’s a fire and you need to get out? Also, Jobs’ quote contains the inherent assumption that his way of viewing the world is perfect and should never be questioned. Yeah, I have a big problem with that. I don’t want to be condemned to scroll through a list of Steve Jobs’ favorite movies. I have my own tastes and interests. The purpose of my life is not to allow hostile software to brainwash me into a Steve Jobs clone. At this point, everyone knows that screens are toxic. Responsible parents limit the screen time of their children. As a parent myself, I would like some more powerful entity to step in and protect me. Socially, we’ve seen a decline in cognitive capacity along with an increase in depression and other mental health issues. Maybe we can attribute that to toxic feeds which deprive us of choice. They’re like narcissistic abusers. They offer a bad suggestion, then they wear you down by refusing to even entertain the idea of doing anything else. Why can’t I put in my own settings for a search on a streaming service? I want a film released between 1980 and 1985 with practical effects featuring Jeff Bridges. In fact, I want to simply see a list of every film Brian Cox made in his entire career and where those films are available. I also want these same options for writing platforms. I want to do searches for topics. Why should I be content with a single feed? I want multiple feeds. I want a humor feed. I want an academic feed. I want a news feed. When I sit down at my computer, I want it to feel like the cockpit of the Millennium Falcon. I want to feel like Cypher looking at the Matrix. I would like more control over the content I consume. “Block” and “Mute” aren’t enough. I need a feed that is an ally not an enemy, and the only possible way for that to be achieved is if the platform allows me access to the control panel. Heck, there should even be a feature where other users can select to see my feed. We are currently living through an era of censorship. The only reason we haven’t taken to the streets to protest is because the malicious forces that oppress us have been very clever about hiding the extent to which they’ve limited our choices. This generation literally has no concept of the extent of information that’s being hidden from them. There are viewpoints that are never given the time of day that could dramatically improve the quality of our life. It’s time that we started making noise. Platforms that pat you on the head and say, “Don’t worry about it, we’ll curate your feed,” do not have your best interests in mind. They’re controlling you. They’re censoring the keys to your liberation in an attempt to keep you passive and incarcerated. We need to break out of this abusive relationship. We need to start demanding control of our feeds. We need to demand access to effective tools that allow us to practice critical reasoning rather than passive media consumption. I want settings, otherwise we’re all just spam in a can. I know there are beautiful things out there in the world, I just don’t get them in my feed. The problem isn’t the feed. The problem is that we’ve all been deprived of choice. The first platform that recognizes this need will take over the world. What we have now is control. I’m asking for freedom. Thanks for your support: 30% off 💙 40% off 💙 50% off 💙 60% off 💙 80% off I'd Rather Be Writing is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber. Get full access to I'd Rather Be Writing at walterrhein.substack.com/subscribe
Embed this episode
No transcript yet.