Transcription by CastingWords Transcription by CastingWords Transcription by CastingWords Transcription by CastingWords Transcription by CastingWords Transcription by CastingWords Transcription by CastingWords Transcription by CastingWords Transcription by CastingWords Transcription by CastingWords Transcription by CastingWords Transcription by CastingWords Transcription by CastingWords Transcription by CastingWords Now the Telegraph proclaimed it would be round-breaking and they got off to an impressive start with the PM as the show's first guest. But last week, the Guardian's media columnist, Amanda Mead revealed that the Daily Telegraph's head of digital, Peter Brown, sends out an email to all News Corp staff every Monday asking them to tune in to Miranda Live. She also spoke to her, she also spoke to her, she also spoke to the show's first and foremost and she was a journalist who complained that the show is live streamed into the newsroom at Holtz Street over the loudspeakers with one journalist telling her, quote, there is no escape. Amanda Mead also reported pitifully low numbers listening on both Facebook and Twitter when she tuned in recently and she's not the only person to point out her audience numbers.
When the PM was back on the show in late January, the ABC's Matthew Doran pointed out there were only 33 people tuning in. Now I had a look today before we came into the studio to record and I actually got the time wrong and missed the show, but within an hour after it having been published, on Facebook at least, it had managed to clock up 3,800 views. And it seemed to be pretty consistent that there were 3,000 views per episode on the Facebook Live videos, but the show is over an hour long and I wondered how long someone has to watch for it to be counted as a view. Mead's article quoted from a News Corp spokesperson who said she was extremely pleased with the results from Miranda Live so far and that after 12 shows, the week per week for a month, the show had over 200,000 total streams from the Telegraph's website, 24,000 podcast downloads and 62,000 plus Facebook Live views.
Misha, Amanda Mead wrote that the show was designed to increase traffic to the Telly's website. Do you think that that is really the intention? I've got no idea. I've not listened to the show and I don't intend to.
And the reason is pretty simple. We live in an attention economy where basically there's a massive amount of media out there seeking our attention and what we have to do as media consumers is pick the media that is most likely to inform us to help us make better decisions in our lives. I know Miranda Devine's got a lot of opinions. I'm not particularly interested in them.
I'm not particularly interested in what she's got to say. I'm interested in journalism that tries to surface the facts and the information that will help me be better informed and I prefer to get my news in other ways. Great points. Well made there, Misha.
Nick, do you think that, I mean, if the intention is to drive traffic to the Telly's website, do you think that it'll work? Look, as an experiment, if Amanda Mead's numbers are correct, as an experiment so far it seems not to have. I don't know, I think that it is a very normal thing for masked heads to be seeking to leverage their high profile voices, who they have spent years grooming, to get them in front of their audiences in different ways. And it's not bad for them to experiment that way.
In fact, it's good for them to experiment that way. So far it seems this experiment hasn't worked. But it already informs you of a couple of things. One, if Turnbull has turned up on it twice, that is indicative of the power that emanates from Holt Street and the Murdoch machine.
They can call on the Prime Minister and tell him to turn up and talk to Miranda Devine in front of 15 people. That's worth us knowing, worth us recognising. The second thing that I've observed is that in the other media market I know best, which is the United States, News Limited or News Corp and Fox personalities flip back and forth between TV and print really effectively. And they're really struggling.
They're trying to do that in Australia and they're really struggling. Sky News hasn't taken off. And the way that they have pulled columnists from their masked heads and pushed them on the sky, they simply haven't taken off yet as TV stars. And I'm sure they're trying to work out why that is.
And maybe this is another experiment that ends. So far it hasn't worked. That's a really good point. And I actually wonder why Australian journalists are so much worse at that sort of, you know...
At that other media? Yeah, I don't know. Because whatever you think of, say, Sean Hannity, he is compelling on TV. And many of the people on Fox are.
And you read them in print. If you're looking at the Wall Street Journal or other News Corp masked heads in America, you see people like George Will pop up or Charles Kraut. They're really effective communicators in print. And when they're on screen, they fill the screen.
And they haven't been able to do it in Australia. That's a great point. And The Telegraph is allocating a lot of resources to make this work. So it's heavily promoting the show on The Telegraph's website.
They sent Miranda to the US to record a show with Ambassador Joe Hockey and Kerry Stokes. Do you think that we'll be talking about this show, that it'll still be on air, I don't know, in years' time? Will it make its year anniversary? If Amanda's figures are right, probably not.
Unless something happens, unless it takes off. It is a great point, actually, because Amanda's figures are quite different to the spokeswoman's figures reported, the News Corp spokeswoman. We're all really good at manipulating audience figures to suit ourselves in this business. So that's it.
You think that the News Corp spokeswoman has somewhat fudged the figures here? I don't know. I haven't seen any analysis. But it's possible, because we will always cherry-pick the best data from complex sets of data to tell our readers, our audiences, about how well we're doing.
And after all, we have those from News Corp that the Australians have been making profits from tech. Do either of you guys listen to podcasts? Yes. All the time.
This whole thing got me asking the question, do you think that there is more left-wing or progressive podcast content out there than conservative right-wing content? I don't know. I haven't looked into that. I listen to hours and hours of Dan Carlin telling me about how the world's been destroyed over thousands of years.
Oh, you listen to that one? I love Dan Carlin. He's great. And my favourite to keep you across American news, which I still do as a former correspondent, I listen to a podcast called A1, which I'm sure conservative media would say is liberal, but I would say is pretty pure straight-down-the-line analysis.
That said, it could well be that there is more. You'd know better than me. You work in that field. Yeah, I mean, it's certainly my impression that I haven't done any study or survey, but my impression is that it is more progressive.
But once again, that might just be my own fill the bubble and what I listen to. Michelle, what do you think? Well, a lot of what I listen to just doesn't even form that paradigm. I sort of feel like that whole left-right conservative-progressive distinction is sort of tired and unhelpful.
I mean, I listen to a magnificent program called Radiolab, which has got the most astonishing stories, science stories, human stories, beautifully told, This American Life, which is really storytelling-driven. I listen to something called On the Media, which does wonderful media analysis. Albeit from a very left-wing, progressive point of view, I would argue with on radio. Yeah, I can imagine you with that dart.
I can imagine you with an NPR tote bag. You might not think it's so fair, but I bet the Republican Party does. Yeah, but I would still reject, really, I mean, for me, the idea, the characterisation. I just don't think it's helpful.
I mean, what I look for is people that I can trust who I think are doing good, rigorous journalistic work if they have political views. You know, I try to be vaguely aware of them and keep them in my head, but I'm looking at the quality of evidence they're presenting. I'm looking at the quality of the production and the reporting. I'm not listening to radio and going back to Miranda Devine.
I'm not, you know, listening to other programs or reading newspapers because I want the opinions of the presenters. What I want is their work. You're all listening to Fought to State. You're with me, Olivia Roseman, and I'm speaking to Nick O'Malley and Misha Ketchel.
Towards the end of last year, the New York Times appointed their first gender editor, a journalist named Jessica Bennett, who has a track record of hard-hitting reporting on gender and sexism. Now, we don't yet have any gender editors at Australian newspapers, so I thought this might be a good opportunity to talk about whether or not we need them. Nick, do you think having a gender editor means that gender issues are siloed away? I mean, should every desk have a gender editor?
I think the New York Times should probably have a gender editor, but I don't know that Australian newspaper newsrooms should be. And I say that because the New York Times is huge and growing. It's one of the few news organisations in the world that is growing. And it's growing across the media that it uses, the countries that it operates in, and the number of staff it employs in the United States.
Newsrooms in this country are really depleted. And given how many specialist editors I have seen, or editors' roles I have seen acts over the past few years, I don't think it would be good use of scarce resources in our newsrooms. That said, we should certainly be far more proactive in ensuring that all of our coverage is done with a self-conscious concern about the issues of gender equality themselves, but also how we are considering the world. We should be aware of gender biases.
So, you know, the Sydney Morning Hill has a female editor, so I think that's more effective for us than her. a gender editor and i have reported to women most of my reporting life i think that's a good thing misha jessica bennett has said that i will know if i'm successful in this role when my job no longer has to exist do you think that's going to happen in her lifetime oh god that's a big prediction i mean i can't answer that question i think what i can say is that there are when you think of a gender editor there are two ways of thinking of the role one of which is as somebody who's covering around the same way you cover urban affairs or indigenous affairs or um health or politics now to me the idea of having somebody covering gender as around does make sense um because i think it's a massive issue in our society in the us and globally um i think the me too movement is a really big and significant story and i do think i must totally take nick's point about scarce resources and having to make difficult decisions um but i would argue if i was in that meeting i would argue that there is actually a benefit in having a gender editor as a reporting function to make sure that that massive story is well covered the second aspect of having a gender editor is if you're trying to use that role to deal with the fact that your newsroom is exactly blokes or you've got a um a culture which is not conducive to female reporting or unconscious gender bias now i'm not quite so sure whether a generator that can be a total solution to that problem i think you know what nick says absolutely right having female leaders in the newsroom is hugely important um and that change has been happening but it has been happening very slowly i mean i've been telling you that even though there are a lot of women on the news desk in the news conferences it was still an extraordinarily male culture in so many ways and there were so many ways in which sort of unconscious gender bias you'd define what stories were what the news was so i think you've got to work on both fronts you need you know reporting of gender as an issue as a breaking story and you also need policies and approaches to try to get a better gender balance in your newsroom but particularly in leadership positions yeah i mean i think i think they're both really good points and in fact emily watkins who's crikey's media reporter spoke to a few people uh last week about this issue and that idea of getting more equal newsrooms certainly was one that was uh quite widely held but i just wonder if actually even if we do get many more women into newsrooms if that necessarily solves the problem i spoke last week to journalist jane gilmore who runs the fixed project where she takes a red pen to headlines and articles written about violence against women and corrects them for when they place the blame on the victim or focus on the victim and remove all focus from the perpetrator and what was interesting about that was that many of those articles are actually written by women so i think to your second point having someone focus on on reporting through that lens on revealing the way that gender biases can pervade even among women reporters is a really good idea last week for international women's day the new york times announced overlooked which is a series of female obituaries that takes square aim at the paper's long-term disparity in gender obituaries uh nick i dare say that a historical look at the smh obituaries would probably also reveal a whole lot of men can we hope to see something similar in the pages of the smh soon i think it's a great idea the moment i saw that i thought how much i'd love to rip that off the obituaries have been fantastic the recognition at what we lost by ignoring half our population has been fantastic and the new york times has done a beautiful job of it it is harder for us just to steal ideas from the new york times now that they're operating in australia but i actually would advocate for that i certainly think we should do that i think it would go some way to redressing an entrenched imbalance which has been there for all of our history um i haven't had those discussions in the office yet it's a great idea and it's really you know there's so much there's so much great material there i'd be looking into i'd be fascinated of course the other aspect of the way that uh gender and inequality makes itself clear in the media is in sources and talent that are often overwhelmingly male is that something that either of your publications i mean i guess the conversation works a little bit differently and maybe i'll ask you a separate question after that but is that something that uh that fairfax people are aware of uh certainly on the opinion pages there's a definite decision there what about encouraging journalists to seek women as sources in their stories no one has ever put that to me apart from readers and a reader did it recently i did some stories on uh woolworths and gambling uh and in the course of my reporting a handful of prime sources appeared and they had great material and i ran the story and had some impact and that was a criticism leveled at me i responded at first saying you know you make a fair point but none of the sources that i came across in my research happened to be women and that person supplied some and you know in future i will change the sourcing but no we haven't as far as i know it hasn't been done from a neutral perspective and maybe it should be and misha so have you guys ever done an audit of contributors to the conversation uh to see the percentage of men versus women we have and actually it's interesting because one of the arguments you get um you know against really making a change into the gender balance is people say oh well we choose people on merit and you know you can't um not choose people on merit and then with these results where 75 percent of the people have merit and men we see like unconscious gender bias in there somewhere so we've we decided that the only way to deal with that is to be really conscious about um so in particular we're doing work at the moment in our science coverage and i think it's around about three percent of our um authors and we only publish academic authors are female in our science coverage and we've got a program on the moment we're trying to get back to 50 percent and what that actually means is deliberately when we've got a story we are now deliberately targeting female authors and our editors are instructed to go out and look for them um as opposed to male authors because that's the only way you're going to get around that unconscious bias and basically one of the things that happens in the media and we all know this is you end up with go-to people dialogue people people you've used before people who have built profiles and many of those profiles have been built at a time when you know men were more dominant in many of these professions in a way that you know is also problematic so the only way you're going to address that is if you actually make a conscious effort to do so now unfortunately that is all we have time for on fourth estate thank you so much for joining us and misha ketchel thank you for being on the show thank you and don't forget you can subscribe to the fourth estate podcast so you'll never miss an episode and this is my last week as host of fourth estate so can i just say it's been a pleasure to bring you the show over the past year and if you want to stay in touch you can always find me on twitter from next week you'll be in the capable hands of nino copel so make sure you tune in my name is davia rosenman and thanks for listening to fourth estate a safe for ontario means more police and prosecutors making sure my card doesn't get stolen it means building new jails to keep criminals behind bars and it means there's no need to worry when i play at the park we're making every corner of ontario safer to make all of ontario safer that's how we protect ontario for all of us learn how at ontario.ca slash safer ontario paid for by the government of ontario