EPISODE · May 18, 2026 · 4 MIN
I Told You to Smile
from The Darkive — Scary Stories, Horror Fiction, and Creepypastas · host Craig Groshek
What begins as a strange late-night knocking at the door quickly spirals into a waking nightmare when a terrified narrator discovers the word “smile” written repeatedly across his bedroom window in the dead of winter. After police dismiss the incident as stress-induced paranoia, he sets up a camera in his bedroom hoping to prove that something is inside the house with him. What the footage captures is far worse than he could have imagined: a pale, emaciated figure crawling out from beneath his bed in the middle of the night, silently watching him sleep with a grotesque grin stretched across its face. And by the time the recording ends, one horrifying truth becomes impossible to ignore—the thing never actually left. FEATURED STORY:"I Told You to Smile" by Robert CherryPerformed by Sky Fortinski Produced by Craig Groshek🔑 Support Us and Listen Ad-Free (Become a Patron Today):https://www.chillingtalesfordarknights.com/join-now/🔊 Listen to More of our Podcasts:Chilling Tales for Dark Nights | Spotify • Apple PodcastsScary Stories Told in the Dark | Spotify • Apple PodcastsHorror Hill | Spotify • Apple PodcastsDrew Blood's Dark Tales | Spotify • Apple PodcastsFear From the Heartland | Spotify • Apple Podcasts🎬 Other Places to Watch:Rumble • YouTube
Embed this episode
NOW PLAYING
I Told You to Smile
No transcript for this episode yet
Similar Episodes
No similar episodes found.
Similar Podcasts
No similar podcasts found.