Skip to content
ICYMI - My Decade-Long Payment App Feud episode artwork

Jun 24, 2026 45 min

ICYMI - My Decade-Long Payment App Feud

from Slate Daily Feed

On today’s episode, in collaboration with No Such Thing, host Kate Lindsay is joined by Manny Fidel, Noah Friedman, and Devan Joseph to talk about payment apps, and how they’ve changed the way we think about money. Plus, Kate reveals her own payment app predicament, and, with the help of the boys and a handful of experts, brings an unspoken, decade-long Venmo feud to a close. This podcast is produced by Vic Whitley-Berry, Daisy Rosario, and Kate Lindsay, with help from No Such Thing.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

ICYMI - My Decade-Long Payment App Feud

0:00 45:15
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Now more than ever, quality matters, but so does price. At Marshall's, you don't have to choose. You can get the good stuff for less, the stuff that lasts, because there's no point in tightening your belt. It's just going to break when you do. Get the good stuff in store at Marshall's today.

Hey, it's Adam Wild and Jack's, hosts of the Adam Wild and Jack's show. What does it feel like to have a better laptop like the Dell XBS powered by Intel Core? With a premium design that's thin and light, it feels smooth. Very smooth. For a better feel in your hands and less weight on your shoulders.

With a responsive touch screen, it feels fast and precise. For better scrolling, zooming and swiping, so everything just flows. And with a long lasting battery life, it feels like nonstop energy. For a better way to work without being near a charger, charger, charger. Built for those who want better, the Dell XBS built for you.

Hey, I'm Kate Lindsay, and you're listening to ICYMI, Slate's podcast about internet culture. And today's episode is a collaboration with the podcast, No Such Thing. I have been friends with the host for a while. One of the hosts, Noah, is actually my brother-in-law. And today, they are helping me solve a Venmo conundrum.

We should just introduce ourselves. So I'm Kate Lindsay, the host of ICYMI, Slate's podcast about internet culture, also known as the Lady from the Kids Menu episode, I believe. I'm not that fine. Yeah, yeah. That's why you know to hour out of your day.

I am Manny, co-host of the No Such Thing podcast, the award-winning No Such Thing podcast. Yeah, the awards. I'm Noah. And I'm Devin, also co-host, the award-winning No Such Thing podcast. You've also ended up on, because I've sent them to you, like, there'll be these slideshows on TikTok.

Podcast I listened to you to be more intellectually curious. They'll be roundups. And you guys are always on it. They put us up for that? Yeah, because I'm scrolling to look for mine.

That's pissed off. That's fucking guys again. Get me. Yeah, so that's that people I know you from there as well. Well, so we're here today.

Because we found, you know, I've been, I guess, frequently on this podcast. Manny's been on ICYMI and that there is some overlap when it comes to sort of solving dumb arguments and a lot of dumb arguments can happen on or about the internet. And I thought it would be really great opportunity to explore a issue, a weird etiquette internet issue that has plagued me for close to 10 years, right? Nine years right now. And it has to do with Venmo.

And so I'll just take you back. It's May 2017. I live in Bushwick. So that's it. 10 is one time.

It's not far from where we are right now. And I live in an apartment with two other roommates and one of them has a birthday and we go to the bar for her birthday. And I guess I was feeling like Daddy Warbucks or something because I was like, everyone ordered drinks and specifically they ordered like oysters, which I don't eat. And I think I just, I think it was to avoid the tension I knew was coming of like, no one has put a card down and we are going out to pay for this. And so I was just like, oh, and then I went ahead and Venmo'd everyone $18.

That's what it came out to split. So it's not bad. Even leave between the whole thing. Yeah, I didn't even get into my thoughts behind that. But I just did it.

I was even $18. Even though I didn't have a oyster and everyone fulfilled it. How many people were we talking here? I would say it was around eight to 10. Oh, okay.

So a big group. Sizable. Yeah. Yeah. And every single one I got all their Venmo's there and I sent all the requests and then, you know, it all went how it's supposed to go except for one person who I will not name on the podcast who by all accounts is a perfectly normal nice person.

They to this day have not answered my request for $18 and I'm looking at it right now and still it appears I used the canoe emoji as a way to sort of symbol oysters. Interesting. Yeah. That's all it says. And then it was like a cancel or remind and it still says I request $18 from on May 30th, 2017.

I was coming up with a name for them. Yeah. Susan. Susan. All right.

Susan, I was $18. And now $27. Someone look up how much I would be now $30. That's all I guess. Not too much in just markup.

You know, 2017. I bet that's $20. Okay. We can literally do this $18 in it would have been May. I'm going to say $30.

I'm going to say $23. Yeah. I'm 26. Oh, got it. Got it.

So now I was hoping to see the CPI inflation calculator on the US Bureau of Labor Statistics website. $18 in May 2017 is now worth $24.65 in the crisis. I prices right rules. I went $23. Yeah.

Yeah. And that's pretty big. If anything, it's an investment that I've made. Yeah. Yeah.

I'm assuming it's going to make its way back. Yeah. So that is the question because every time I open it up and you know, I know this I've having received requests many times before I know it's the same with Susan. Every time either of us are opening up them, we are seeing that. And the problem is I would say around year two is I think when I passed a normal amount of time to do anything about it.

Yeah. Year two. I would say two months. I guess the thing is it's just like it would have been crazy. It's still been crazy in year two.

But now like, yeah, we're in year nine. Yeah. But now I think you've crested over a waiver. Now it's like, you know, I'm not. Yeah.

The thing is because the problem is notifications, like if I could just sort of quietly erase it, I would. No matter what, if I remind her, obviously, it'll say like Kate has canceled this. I'm really notified someone that I can't. I believe it does. Maybe I'm going to test it now.

But yeah. And then she'll know the other way. She'll know when she opens it up and see, but like, I don't know why I'm like. I don't I'm not the one who was 18. I need it.

I mean, it's 24 now. So maybe I do. I that's like one cocktail somewhere. I know. I know probably the same bar.

So so that's that's just always been in the back of my mind is like with Venmo specifically, it's like what it makes things it makes it so easy to pay people back, but it also makes it so easy not to pay people because you just don't have to there's they don't have enforcers. Right. It's not a bank. Yeah. Which is of course something I would have them to.

And so I don't know if you have you guys ever been in this? What are your thoughts? Well, is there any chance that Susan has divested themselves from Venmo? This is true. Like can do they have a public profile?

Can you see if they're still exactly clicking on their name? Maybe Susan's right after this was like, I'm actually a cashoff girl. Make and payments as recently as May 3rd. Oh, oh, public. Public ones.

Yeah. So I guess that's rude. Do diligence here. Is there any possible way she could not could have not seen your request? Not if she's using it.

So if you go into the app when you're looking at going to go pay someone back, so like friends of my husband has requested Wi-Fi money for me, which is crazy because we do have a shared card. So we'll pick it up. But but that's at the top. Yeah, so then we're right underneath. Yep.

She was seeing that unless she just has a long list of people she's not paying back. I mean, I know this. She's just a bit. I got that down. Okay.

So she definitely sees the request when she's in the Venmo app. Yeah. And she uses Venmo. She's using it. She's using it.

I guess my thing would be I wonder if for her, it similarly feels insane to just like randomly pay you back nine years later. But she ignored it. Right. Why in the first place to ignore it is what I'm curious about. Maybe she feels like she doesn't.

Do you remember her eating the ocean? Well, I have a problem because now we're like 10 years old. I'm like, did you eat at the it's like I and she's just like, I'm not paying for this. I didn't eat it. Right.

That I wonder. But then you can just decline if that like one time someone then requested me the wrong amount and I just declined it and then I sent them the correct number. Yeah. And that was the end. How much difference?

20 something bucks. It was a big group dinner and we didn't do it evenly. We like had to look at the receipt. Yeah, there's something that happened. There's something misunderstanding her and I that lives on in this app.

You don't see this person. No, no. You ever seen him since then? No. Yeah.

I believe they moved. They fled the state. Hugeative sounds right there on the run. When we come back, how small is too small to Venmo and what happens to the money you let sit in your Venmo account? Hey folks, this is Freddy.

I'm Will. I'm Anthony from the hit Dungeons and Dragons podcast Dungeons and Daddies. That's us. What does it feel like to have a better laptop like the Dell XPS powered by Intel Core? With a premium design that's didn't like if you're smooth.

Very smooth. What the response of touch screen feels fast and precise. Hey, with long lasting battery life, it feels like nonstop energy with a laptop there can keep it up. Built for those who want better. The Dell XPS built for you.

Now more than ever, quality matters. But so does Price. At Marshall's, you don't have to choose. You can get the good stuff for less. The stuff that lasts because there's no point in tightening your belt.

If it's just going to break when you do, get the good stuff in store at Marshall's today. For most of the history of professional sports, there was a wall between the game and gambling. Then suddenly it was everywhere. But that wasn't supposed to include the players themselves. Understood the big bet.

Find us on CBC Listen or wherever you get your podcasts. I feel like the idea, because they have requests from her. And she's like, I don't want to pay that. I didn't eat the oysters or whatever. But then I feel like pre Venmo, you would say that.

But there's something same with how what part of full has done and maybe attending. It's like, there's now the etiquette where it's like, I just want to say anything and that's fine. And so I wanted to talk about the ways that we think Venmo and money being so digital has maybe changed our relationship with money. Do we remember how we dealt with money pre Venmo? Because I'm curious if people who felt a certain stinginess with money pre Venmo feel differently.

I don't know, because it's not physical. Pre Venmo, there was definitely a lot more you were paying for our own thing, but at the restaurant. Yeah, it's money to get out. I got the burger, the fries and the beer, put that on a separate check and I'll pay for it. Yeah.

And then not too long before that, I wasn't paying for anything because I was like, yeah, in high time. Yeah. So we grew up in a world where you could easily pay people back for stuff. I'm realizing though, this was still a bit of an issue even because I was in college the first year at least pre Venmo and we did have an issue with someone who whenever we would order Chinese food or pizza, this was still like a cash economy. And so it was like everyone threw in cash and this one person always would reach for the food and go, I don't have cash, I'll pay you back.

And then never to be heard from again. And it became like a routine thing. And I remember you were forced to in person, not me up for someone else, was like, cause I think she suggested ordering food or something. Yeah. And basically someone would do like you need to pay the time.

Like you have not paid for any of it. Or you're not touching it. Right. Right. And so it was awkward, but I won't say, it doesn't seem like Venmo solved that awkwardness.

It's just made us be able to be more avoidant. Yes. Cause I feel like there were a few restaurants, I remember in high school, like back half high school when you could start driving. So you go to restaurants by yourself with your friends. One place we'd go Applebee's they'd have like half price, appetizers after like 10 or 11 o'clock.

And they would not do separate checks there. So you had that cash and I remember always these like one or two friends who they would always not give enough money. Cause you'd be like, you owe this much, you owe this much, you owe this much. And then you count the money and be like, we're short. And you'd be like, yeah.

Then you'd have to go through after the restaurant, but in a moment they'd be like, okay, we still need three more dollars. Yes. And it's like it was annoying. And in high school you might have to leave the premises. But it was like, we're not leaving here until we figure out how much we owe.

Yeah. Because we have to hand the money to the person before we walk out. Yep. Settling up was a. Yeah.

Feeling of being like, who's math is wrong? Yes. Cause then somebody has something to pay for more. So maybe we understand. We're really dating ourselves.

I know. I understand the problem these apps are trying to solve for. But there's also, so before we sat down to record, we collected a bunch of other questions because obviously we have our own pretty comments that I was curious to hear what other people had. And you also spoke to some etiquette and financial experts about things like Veno etiquette and best practices. And I guess like a broad question I want to start with is like, I didn't even think about this, but like, are there some Venmo best practices that we should all just be doing no matter what to like?

I don't know, necessarily what that would be. Yeah. It seems like the introduction of Venmo and Venmo like apps have created like somewhat new behaviors in us. Where? Yeah, exactly.

Like before Venmo, it was, you know, it was a team game at the dinner table trying to figure out who owes what and putting up the correct amount of cash. And now that Venmo's here, it's usually one person's putting their card down and then then going everyone else. But depending on who the person is, the check is split evenly or they're really looking at the receipt or some people don't mind if you, if they just cover it and they don't really mind when they get paid back. Yeah. Some people are doing it like on the Uber ride home.

Yeah. Yeah, it's created these like kind of new behaviors out of us, I think. Yeah. I know one of the questions we had is, is there like a minimum amount that you're like, at what point is it like, all right, like, because I think sometimes if I'm buying someone a coffee, I'm not going to Venmo them for it. But then sometimes you get hit with the coffee Venmo.

Oh, yeah. A little bit like, so I'm curious if anyone who spoke to you had some thoughts about that. Yeah. So I talked to someone who writes about etiquette for a living. My name is Lizzie Post and I am a co-president at the Emily Post Institute.

And I'm also Emily Post's great, great granddaughter. You guys noticed Emily Post's situation? Is this just like an etiquette person? Yeah, like a famous, yeah. Like a bold, bold, bold.

I like this idea of like, I am the descendant of the politest person in the world. And I asked her, what is the minimum amount you should be Venmo requesting someone for? I feel like for me, and I try to keep my ranges on the lower side because I just think it's silly to walk around assuming that everybody operates in spaces of like 50 and $100, but, or where $25 wouldn't make a big deal to them, you know, be a big deal to them. And so I would say $10 or less starts to be like, I could let that slide, but you know, there are some people for whom that might not be slideable and giving gas prices and grocery prices, which are such necessities in our lives these days. I feel like it's worth respecting it.

But you're right. If someone was like, hey, like, if my sister sent me a Venmo request for $2 to pay her back for the coffee, she bought me her something. You can't even get a coffee for $2. I don't want to say it. But like, that's- Maybe a water.

Okay, love and comrade. Okay, like that. This is similar to past episodes where I've been on where it's like, well, I like when they're agreeing with me. Yeah, yeah. I think $10, I was like, yeah.

It's like single digits, you're wasting everyone's time. Right. I have to, like, you know how like some places won't let you pay with a credit card below a certain amount. Yeah, exactly. She's not like involved with this institution in.

I also feel like very seldom am I hanging out with someone for whom I wouldn't just buy coffee or a beer or whatever. Yeah, exactly. Because that basically won beer. Exactly. I'll either see you again and get me that time.

Or if it's every time I'm seeing you, I'm buying you one beer and never getting one back, then that's probably not going to happen that many more time. Yeah, exactly. But I've definitely been hit with like a $6 Venmo request for like a secata at a bar once. No. And I was like, okay.

Yeah. But I didn't, I felt like I couldn't. I know that person too well. Then that would become like, oh, you're saying no when you technically owe him six bucks. Yeah, it's not wrong.

It's just frowned upon. Yeah. And like I don't like I will give someone if someone covers me for something that's like five or six bucks, I'll send them five or six bucks. And then I'm about getting requested. Yeah, I would never question it myself.

Yeah. If you want to go out of your way and it's less than time I don't need it. Yeah. Cool. I'm not going to reject you.

Exactly. That's fair. You send it back to them. Yeah, I was a gift. I dare you.

But I'm not I'm not going in the app to say, you know, $4 for a water. And then speaking of the idea of like, I don't want it feels like if the interaction is too small or the amount of money is too small, it's not worth the mechanisms. And while I also think about that kind of in terms of because so then it was basically like you're like an escrow or whatever. Escrow. Yeah.

That's where I was growing. Escrow. Escrow. I'm going to say it proudly. Yeah.

And escrow when I'm proud. Yeah. And so I'll usually let it like pile up in there a little bit. Oh, how much money you can leave in there? Well, I'm not crazy.

Like, you know, obviously like rent or something I put right back like into my into the account. But I don't know, like, you know, a few group dinners and whatever. And then I'll be like, and this is more like now I'm like mental illness because I'm just like, oh, I can't do it. If I'm a, if I'm like still expecting money, it's like all of it. Yeah.

And then I want to move it. But I heard through, I don't know, like it's like through the grapevine, I can't remember who to attribute this to. It's fine. If you're leaving, you shouldn't be leaving money in your memo account because they're doing something with it. I guess it's not really protected is what people are worried about.

Yeah. But like what are they? I just, I, it seems like perhaps you did speak to someone. Okay. I'm curious, like, because that is just a question I've always thought about when I'm letting it kind of, you know, I never let it get more than like, I'm kind of gross with it.

It goes up. I remember after the baby shower, everyone paid us back. I just left that in there until I've depleted. Yeah. It's like over a thousand dollars.

And it's like free money when you, someone requests you and it's like, oh, you want to take it right out of your, your thing and it's like, well, yeah, I, that was free then. Yeah. Yeah. I do get that. Yeah.

But I'm getting, I'm getting the vibe that perhaps I'm incorrect in this belief. Yeah. So I'm going to talk to Beth who is a financial planner and asked her this question. I am Beth Pinsker. I'm a columnist at MarketWatch.

I'm a certified financial planner. The thing about leaving money in Venmo is one is it protected. Is it FDIC insured? Can somebody access it? Do you have consumer protections on it?

It's in a bank. Nothing bad can happen to that money and you're only liable for $50 worth of fraud ever. If any, like if you can prove that there's fraud, you're not going to be responsible for it. The second thing is it's not going to earn any interest then. Yeah.

So if it's a significant balance, you're losing money as it sits there and you don't want to do that. The best practices go back to the old thing. The thing I tell my kids number one is do not pay for things on your credit card or Venmo or whatever payment method you're going to choose and collect cash from your friends. And think that that's a good idea. You have the cash from them and you pay the bill.

What happens is that cash disappears between the time that you get it and the bill gets due. And so when it comes time to pay for that hundred dollars that you front it everybody on your credit card, you don't have it anymore and then you're in debt. And it's just a slippery slope and a bad way to go about doing things. So I'm like, pay your portion of it. People and payment systems at restaurants and stores and whatever are sophisticated enough now to split the bill.

You can pay for your own share, even put a tip on right there with your card swipe tap, whatever you need to do and don't accumulate the balance of everybody else. Very interesting. But I will say yes, restaurants have the capability. No, no, but they don't like to do it. They make it very clear.

They do not want to do it. And I don't I'm a people, please. Yeah. Yeah. Same.

Plus there's the restaurant, you know, the awkwardness of them not wanting to do it. You know, everyone has these credit cards where they get all the cash, everyone. They're now too many people want to pay for the whole thing and go through the venoma process because they get perks from the car. And that's what I asked for. As you were saying, yeah, you think about it, but then you're spending that money, right?

You know, you I put down $500. You guys give me that money, but I'm not thinking that $500 goes that I got in your mind. You're not putting out money aside. You're thinking, Oh, I just got $500 now. No, no, you didn't.

And the question if you are always paying, putting your card down and getting miles and then you go on vacation, do they have to come with you? All your friends. It seems only right. Yeah. Yeah, both.

For covering your mileage. Yeah, like they really contributed to it at the small plate's natural line. Yeah. Restaurant. So yeah, don't leave your money in your Venmo account because it's not protected.

Yeah, that's a bad reason probably. Venmo went underwater. Yeah, exactly. You were gonna get your money. It's not insured.

And like the wow air stops just doing the middle of it. We're gonna be spirit airlines. Yeah, you're stranded, yeah. You're just like, because they can do that. They can just stop being an airline.

And I forget that Venmo can just stop being a Venmo. Yeah, and then your money's gone. When we come back, we answer your questions about digital money etiquette. And my Venmo saga comes to a close. Hey folks, this is Freddy.

I'm Will. I'm Anthony from the hit Dungeons and Dragons podcast Dungeons and Daddies. That's us. What does it feel like to have a better laptop like the Dell XPS powered by Intel Core? With a premium design that's thin and light, if you're smooth, very smooth.

What the response of touchscreen it feels fast and precise. And with long lasting battery life, it feels like nonstop energy with a laptop there can keep it up. Built for those who want better. The Dell XPS, built for you. Now more than ever, quality matters.

But so does price. At Marshall's, you don't have to choose. You can get the good stuff for less. And stuff that lasts because there's no point in typing your belt. If it's just going to break when you do, get the good stuff in store at Marshall's today.

Well, I know that you guys also collected some anecdotes or stories from listeners. I'm curious what issues they've run into with this. All right, so this first one is about a listener talking about their friends who always happens to Venmo the wrong amount of money. Yeah. I have been friends with one of my closest friends for 13 years now.

And the entire time I've known her, she's like one of the richest people I know. Like her parents are multi-millionaires. Like she's currently buying an apartment with like a million dollars and her parents are giving her like $700,000 in cash. She's always wearing like designers. She's a Europe five times a year.

But she has this very frustrating trait that any single time we go out to dinner and you put your card down, she's Venmo's youth is wrong amount. Like, and it's not like, oh, like she owes me $40 and she's giving me $20. It's like she owes me $40 and she's giving me $36, which is just close enough where you're like, maybe she's extremely bad at math. But this is always the case. Like other friends of mine have voiced how she never pays them back the right amount.

But it's never an amount that's like worth pressing over. But I realize it's like always the richest person you know who's like the stingiest of Venmoian youth back. And like maybe this is like not even a question of money and more of a question of confrontation. But if you're in a situation where you've known someone for 13 years and every single time they've done one of you for 13 years, they've been like you slightly less than you are owed. Like do you say something or do you just into these and have to accept the fact that the person is just gonna fight you even though they're literally a multi-millionaire and you come from very little money and like are in so much in loan debt versus this person who like is always in $500 in.

Great question. My initial reaction is that maybe this person is looking at what they purchased on the receipt. But not including tax intake. That would be my thing is like I think you should do. I think you should do.

Gotta add the table because I think something we've, okay well I have lots of thoughts about this. First off, I think it's pretty implicit in my friend. We're not necessarily saying this, but the most securely employed person because we all work in somewhat creative media fields. So that's never all of us at once. The most securely employed person puts on their card.

We don't like voice it. Interesting. But like or like there's like a few of us and we'll kind of alternate. Like we don't want to make the response to every single time but it's like we're not gonna ask the person who like was laid off a few months ago and his job hunting to put on their card. Just cause it's like yeah you don't wanna shoulder it.

So it's interesting like that is not her, this rich friend's impulse but I do think it speaks to this phenomenon of the more money you have. The people tend to be scrugy or with it. There's a scarcity mindset that like weirdly seems to increase when you have more. And I know and I don't wanna step on some research you might have done but I know that like when you look at like charitable giving people from lower income households tend to give more in proportion to their own income than a rich person does. And there's a sort of sneakiness to I guess capitalism that just makes you even when you have money you just become more fearful of losing.

Yeah, Beth had an interesting take on this. I think it's a matter of that mental accounting that's going on. If you are always coming at it at a place from deficit, a $20 deficit isn't gonna matter to you. It's gonna make no difference if you have a $20 deficit or a $40 deficit. You're still just deficit to you.

And so you sort of lose sense of the scale. If you are in an abundance situation, you know how much you have and you wanna hold onto that and so you're a lot more careful about it. Or maybe they got that way, not the people who are living off their parents but if they have a nice job, they got that way because they were careful and smart about this. And when you're careful and smart about things, you pay what things cost, you don't pay more. And if somebody owes you money, you get it back from them.

You're just a responsible, there's no negativity to it. It's just a responsible thing to do. I think there's negativity. Yeah. Yeah, I mean, it tracks but I mean quite literally I'm like at what cost because I'm, it's hard for me to believe in the instance of the sort of the listener who called in.

Like it's hard for me to not think of her friend as a certain type of person because of this. But the one thing that makes it, that still snags for me is what she pointed out of like, it's not wildly off, it's like a little bit off. Which means I think there's some calculation going wrong. And I think the way to try to address that is like at the table, figure out who owes what. And like, you know, it's like, we all need to agree on what we all owe.

Or you've got to request that request. Yes, we have to have a conversation with them. Everyone doesn't want to have it. Just beat them to the punch and request it because they're not going to dispute that. If it's only that $4 difference.

And if they do, at the very least, you can hear the mouth like, maybe they'll have to explain them. Maybe they've been right the whole time. Yeah, I'm not, we're going to get a call from her. I'm a multi-millionaire at my friend. Yeah, because there's only a verbal agreement of how much the person knows, right?

It wasn't that they were declining a request and then sending a new card. No, no, they were just Venmoing. They were wrong amounts. And then come out and buy for you $36 instead of $40. I see.

Yeah, but over time it ends up. Yeah, and I think it's, you know, it's not going to end up in any situation. It's because it's like, they don't want to be looking like they're begging for a $4 difference, but like, you know, $4.12 a year starts to add up. Yeah. Whereas this person, this money doesn't mean anything to her.

She's got $5.99 either one. Yeah, it's like, oh, I'm 30, $6.40. It's all the same to me. Yeah. What should the listener do?

Oh, right. I don't know. I think I request, I think I have a specific request. Request it ahead of time. Then it could, then you'll see how they respond to that.

Or they'll find it. They seem to be quibble with that. And then call back. Yeah, call back. I got at least forced conversation.

Yeah. Yeah. I'll know good luck. Yeah. Don't know my job.

Yeah. Actually, our one doesn't do it by so. I don't know why you noticed this. But I mean, my other way of solving it, and I think this is a larger issue of mine that I believe the next question will get into, it's like, just split the bill. Everyone owes the same.

But I sense perhaps for some people, it's not that easy. So this is an email that we got, the listener wants to remain anonymous. So we had somebody record a voicemail for. Like an an actor's a player. Here's a money etiquette situation my wife and I were in a few summers ago.

A friend of ours set up a birthday vacation for his wife, invited a large friend group to go to an all-inclusive in Aruba. For context, my wife and I have a pretty standard middle-class income. So the vacation was a big financial decision for us. Another important detail is this particular friend group is one that has a lot more disposable income than we do, compared to us, high rollers, if you will. At some point, the ladies of the group decided we should go off the resort to a fancy restaurant for the host's birthday celebration.

My wife and I brought like $200 cash, thinking we'd eat light and help cover the cost of the birthday girl's meal. At dinner, the couples that we didn't know well quickly started spending rather extravagantly, ordering exotic appetizers and really expensive cocktails. The restaurant had a zul tequila on the menu, $50 per drink, and others started ordering this too. My wife and I don't drink much, and when we do, it certainly isn't $50 per shot kind of stuff, so we stuck with soft drinks. Then the bill came.

It was thousands of dollars. There were 15 plus tequila alone, plus other spirits. One of the couples we don't know tells everyone we're going to split the check evenly. No one else seemed to mind. Obviously, my wife and I needed to have a sidebar, since we were a few hundred dollars short of what was being asked.

After stalling as much as we could, waiting for someone else to say something, my wife spoke up and said, we only ordered $70 worth of food. We were happy to contribute to the tip and cover a little more, but we didn't bring near enough cash to cover $50 drinks. This did not go over well with the two couples we didn't know and definitely changed the mood with them for the rest of the trip. While I would not change how we handled this situation, I'm wondering what's the etiquette in this situation? I can't really imagine a solution that isn't at least as awkward as what we did.

Thanks for reading my short story and thanks for the hours of edutainment you provide, Mitch. Well, immediately that story is really a take from my earlier suggestion, which is just what the bill. But I think, I think it's just a scale. It's a scale. This is a stream.

This is an egregious situation. Because I think if you are just, let's just let the bill people, which I do think in most cases is the best way to go. You do have to be thoughtful of if that, because there are times where it doesn't make sense. Because for me, I don't like when we go, because everywhere you go out to dinner, at least in Brooklyn, you're getting, it's like, we do things a little differently. We do things a little late and wine.

And so you need to split it. Even if I don't really like seafood, so I didn't have any of the scallops or whatever, I don't care. I'm not going to go like scallops for scallop with someone when it comes to breaking it down, just split it. And I find the people who really unnecessarily itemize their venmos to be not in the spirit of friendship, which is that maybe I didn't eat the scallops this time, but maybe next time I'll order, I don't know, pork, and you don't eat pork. Everyone has to be slited at every meal in a way now.

No, it's just, you know, they don't all even out, because people continue to get dinner together. And even though technically the right, it feels really, it just ruins the vibe at the end of the meal to suddenly be like, all right, I had a little bit of this thing, but the idea of accidentally covering even a little bit of your bite disgust me. And so I'm itemizing the bill. It's like I don't like that, but this is crazy. I can understand their concern, because of course it does suck to be the person that has to like, but the bad mood on the table.

Of course, this isn't such an egregious case. I think they did the right thing to speak up. I'm normally of the mind of like, I'm okay, if I have to pay $15, $20 more than I should be paying, it means we can just knock this out right here and there. It's basically a convenience box. Now maybe that's also easy for me to say because I'm ordering a bunch of drinks and stuff.

And I'm probably not the one that's paying more than this. Wait, yeah. Think about it certain ways. Though this, but this specific issue is so egregious. It's like, okay, I'm doing the same thing as I'm in this situation.

Oh, you're speaking out for sure. Like you're saying it does depend on if everyone's sharing plate. It doesn't sound like they were. It's like, get your own thing. And like they said, it's like, all right, they had $70 a food.

They brought $200 in cash. So that's already obviously way more than that. They sound like they were willing to part with that. Yeah. We're talking at such extreme scale here that no one could have accounted for this.

Now the friends who felt like, you know, they dampened the situation. Those are bad people. Yeah, that's, that's not. Don't make someone feel a bad. And just like not aware of just like, not everyone's fucking building here.

That's really what it is. You don't have to love it. I do wonder what they did to make them, like if the vibe was just different. Or if they were like, oh, we're, I also think that made it so known. As they said, they've been doing a lot of drinking go too.

So they probably by the end of the day they're not in the right mindset to be reasonable. They're really good. And I think often why I'm like, just split the bill, like you're all fine. I have to do, I can bring out the calculator app. I will say too, someone who doesn't drink, I think you guys are, when we go out, like, you are always like, well, they haven't been drink.

So he should go up on him. You're just like, let's just split it. Yeah, yeah. But it is annoying if people are going out and getting a bunch of drinks. Because drinks are expensive.

Yeah, very expensive. Like the food thing is one thing. Because it's like, I think it's like, we can all, if you just because you didn't eat something, you had the opportunity and you decided not to, it's like, well, I'm not going to drink your drink. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Yeah, so it's like, even, you know, these are $50 drinks.

Yeah, yeah. $20 cocktails. Yeah, it starts to go out. Me and Manny both have three cocktails each. Yeah.

That's more than any food we're getting. Easily. Yeah. Yeah. I think the default of just all splitting it, like you have to, it needs to be within the margins of like everyone about did the same thing.

Exactly. And I don't know the idea of going to this, ordering that really expensive alcohol without like saying something without being like, are we cool to get this. And then the weird reaction, there's. I wonder if they, you know, I imagine these people are always splitting the bill because it sounds like they're really well off. Yeah.

I wonder if they didn't even notice that the couple in question weren't really eating stuff or drinking the drinks. I know I was going to do more pessimistic. I was like, I think they were all like, I think you were like, oh, they weren't the same after this. I actually think this is them being like, they were always like, like them doing this to you was the beginning of them being like, like, they changed it. Yeah.

Whatever. I don't know them. I did ask Lizzie how she would approach the situation. Firstly, I think they're great for speaking up. They are also then in the situation where they're dealing with people who've had 15 shots of expensive tequila.

So those people probably aren't in their right mind when they're assessing the situation. I keep saying like, stay strong. No confidently that it is OK for you to have spoken up in the situation. That as no matter how the we can't control other people's behavior and how they react, but letting them know that, listen, we weren't a part of the tequila. And I think that this is terrible sample language right now.

But we didn't order any of the tequila. So we're happy to chip in on the rest of the bill, but we'd like to not chip in on that. Or we won't be chipping in on that. It's not like you're asking these people for the permission. You know what I mean?

That's a really great point. I think a lot of you ask for permission to say, can we saying, hey, here's what we are going to contribute. It's quite a shift. It's a power move for sure. But I think it's an important power move on this one, given the extravagance of the bill.

Yeah, there's no non-awkward way out of that situation. But they chose, I think, the least awkward way. Because it would have been terrible if they put their visa down and then the other later was like, hey, we're going to need some money back and contribute all this. And there's no actually good argument against it. Yeah, exactly.

If you're one of the drinking side, you're mad that they're not paying for you. You can't really argue it with any logic. Aside from what we should just all share, especially when it wasn't discussed. Exactly. And Lizzie brought that up as she said, if you're going to be in big group situations, it's awkward to talk about it at the end.

But talk about it in the beginning. It's going to be a little bit awkward with me. That's awkward once you all spent the money. Hey, are we all going to split? What are we going to do?

Because if we're going to change the number one mark? Yeah. We had something very vague at the beginning. Like, OK, we're going to split this. Then someone's ordering something crazy.

And then even if you're the one outside of it, you could be like, oh, I don't like this a little much. Like, do we make me go for the cosmigo something else? I heard the cosmigo's this excellent thing. Well, I always like to bring things back to me. Which is, you'll remember that I began this episode with my own predicament.

Which I think it may be not to this extreme in terms of it being a decade long simmering unanswered question. But you know, this idea of what if someone isn't paying you back on Venmo? Like, when do you give it up? Since I've done so much emotional labor with us over the 10 year, I outsourced this to you. And I said, please find out what I should do about this person.

Or the idea of someone who's not paying you back over Venmo. I'm curious what you found. I mean, at some point, I think she could clear it. But I do think that's a good notice to clear things more quickly. Either bump that request up a second time within a week.

And if you don't get anything back by the following week, then just clear cancel the request. If you don't care about getting the money back. You know what I mean? OK, we're going to try to convince her to cancel it on the recording as we're going to do it. Oh, do it.

Do it. Be brave, be brave, girl, be brave. Girl power. She kind of got me. She's like, maybe a week.

I'm like, what am I? I'm like, I'm like, what am I? Yeah. OK, so I have emotionally adjusted to this that I will be canceling. Yeah.

Oh my god. So I'm opening it up now. Can you count me down now? Yes. Ready?

Five, four, three, two, cancel. I'm getting the. It's turning it's canceled. I got the guy who canceled the request. I got the guy who was the guy who I was the guy who went on the phone.

And then I'll play with him or the Instagram. And then my husband requested me for Wi-Fi. Wow. So how do you feel? Later.

I wonder what she's going to think when she opens her. Oh my god. All right, we'll see. We'll see if I'm. Yeah, you're going to have to do an update.

Yeah. If you guys send you the money afterwards. By the time it's coming down. Yeah. I know.

Well, technically I should tell her she owes me $24. Yeah, yeah. I'm going to talk about me. Ever. Because I've been doing a lot of fun.

Yeah. I'm going to talk about that. Okay. That's the show. Thank you so much to Manny, Noah and Devin for joining us and to the whole Kaleidoscope team for their studio production.

For those curious, I still have not heard anything from the person who I canceled my Venera Quest 2, but isn't that kind of a character? We'll be back in your feed on Saturday. So definitely subscribe. That way you never miss an episode. Leave us a rating and a review and Apple or Spotify and tell your friends about us.

To see all the visuals referenced in today's episode, you can follow us on Instagram at Icymy. And you can always drop us a note at icmyatlate.com. Icymy is produced by Vicklyberry and me, Kate Lindsey. Daisy Rosario is our senior supervising producer. Mia Lobel is Lacey's executive producer of podcasts.

And Hilary Fry is Lacey Editor-in-Chief. See you online or answering my decade-old Venera Quest. Hey folks, this is Freddy.

I'm Will. I'm Anthony from the hit Dungeons and Dragons podcast Dungeons and Daddies. That's us. What does it feel like to have a better laptop like a Dell XPS powered by Intel Core? With a premium design that's been in life, it feels smooth.

Very smooth. With a responsive touch screen, it feels fast and precise. And with long lasting battery life, it feels like nonstop energy with a laptop building keyboard. Built for those who want better. The Dell XPS.

Built for you.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Slate Daily Feed?

This episode is 45 minutes long.

When was this Slate Daily Feed episode published?

This episode was published on June 24, 2026.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Slate Daily Feed episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.