Skip to content
Identity episode artwork

Apr 5, 2024 9 min

Identity

from The Daily Vedantic Hosted by James Beshara

In this episode of The Daily Vedantic, James discusses the classic essay "Keep Your Identity Small" by philosopher and startup investor Paul Graham. Reflecting on Graham's insights, James delves into the complexities of identification and identity, exploring the limitations and costs associated with aligning ourselves too closely with particular groups or labels. Drawing parallels with Vedantic philosophy, James emphasizes the importance of affirming our boundless nature while also negating narrow identifications. Through this exploration, listeners are invited to examine where they invest their sense of self and to consider the expansive possibilities of identity beyond conventional boundaries. Tune in for a thought-provoking reflection on the nature of identity and self-realization. The Daily Vedantic is a daily podcast and YouTube channel dedicated to the timeless wisdom of the Upanishads (⁠https://www.thedailyvedantic.co⁠). Dating back to over 5,000 years ago, the source of nearly all Eastern Philosophy, and loved by Western giants from Emerson to Thoreau to Carl Jung and Alan Watts, studied daily by Joseph Campbell to Aldous Huxley to Arthur Schopenhauer and countless others, The Daily Vedantic aims to make this ancient philosophy as modern and accessible as it is simple, practical — and profound. James Beshara (⁠https://www.twitter.com/jamesbeshara⁠) is a renowned startup founder of multiple companies, a prolific startup investor in 200+ others including some of the biggest startup names on the planet, a husband and father of three little girls, and philosophy student and teacher in Los Angeles. James also co-hosts Yoga For Your Intellect (⁠https://www.YFYI.co⁠), a biweekly long-form conversational podcast with his teacher Joseph Emmett ( ⁠https://www.instagram.com/yogaforyourintellect⁠ ). James is a student of Swami Parthasarathy, the acclaimed author of Vedanta Treatise (⁠Vedanta Treatise – The Eternities⁠) and teacher at Vedanta Academy in Malavli, India. As James says often, when you’re ready for the real thing, Swami’s daily lectures are where the true wisdom and systematic discovery of the world’s oldest continually studied philosophy resides: ⁠https://www.vedantaworld.org⁠

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Identity

0:00 9:55
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

And we're back with another daily reflection on the daily Vedantic. This one is on the most personal topics we'd ever discuss. Identification and identity. I was thinking earlier today about one of my favorite essays I've ever read.

It's a great startup thinker that happens also to be philosopher and brilliant writer, Paul Graham, maybe the best startup investor ever. He invested in my company when I was 26, 25, and I got to know him and got to know all of his writings. In fact, I wanted to invest because of all of his writings. He started this incubator program called Y Combinator that it has launched some of the best companies in the world, Airbnb, Dropbox, Reddit, a lot of the best ones in the last 10, 15 years.

But he happens to write these beautiful essays on life, a little bit about startup investing, startup building here and there for sure. But I always loved his essays on life. And one of his best essays, in my opinion, is titled, Keep Your Identity Small. And it talked about how when we identify with a bunch of sports teams, identify with some denomination within a religion, identify with, he also talked about programming languages, for those that don't know, within the technical space within, especially within Silicon Valley, it can become quite violent to start rooting for one, one programming language over another.

And Paul Graham is a hell of a programmer. So this was relevant to that essay, relevant to the audience. But the synopsis of the essay was that in a world that can try to enchant you to, identifying with everything around you can tell you, you know, join our group, be a part of our group. The essay talked about the inherent cost and identifying with those groups.

When you're a Python programmer, when you're a Roman Catholic, when you are a Republican, when you are a Cowboys fan, all of these things are so limiting, you get the initial upside of a community for certain, but it comes with this infinite downside of your identity. You are now being attacked when someone says something about the Dallas Cowboys, or when they aren't winning, or when your political party doesn't look like it'll win, when your programming language isn't evolving as fast as others. When it's in jeopardy of losing its stature, the agitation we sign ourselves up for, because the seemingly innocuous placements of our identity, the world around us, and his argument was keep your identity small. Just be a programmer.

Don't be a Python programmer. Be a football fan, not a specific team, be a being advocate for the progress of your country, state or city, not aligned and identified with some political party that wants you to identify with the benefits when you do that. But you might not necessarily benefit from that. This is such a powerful essay.

It was a powerful essay for me because I was just signing myself up for all of these different identifications that were always in jeopardy. They're always being attacked within this philosophy. We're told that you come to self-realization through the affirmative or the negative and through negation or affirmation. And you actually can't in parallel intertwine the two through affirming that you are much more than what you might think you are.

The great phrase that we mentioned last episode, Tutt von Masi, that thou art, your hit. As Alan Watts would locally say, your that, which is that's what this philosophy is said for. Eight, 10,000 years who knows how long the oral tradition of this philosophy has been going. The written tradition in 2016, there was a part of the Rig Veda, a data back to 6,000 BC, 8,000 years, this concept has been put forward.

You are that which is that thou art. That's the affirmation, the affirmative. That's the opposite of what Paul Graham saying. Don't keep your identity small.

Go free in big with it. You're a fan of all NFL teams, all sports teams, all programming languages, not only every political party, but every politician. You can find identification with them all, just like you could look at someone that might be, that might be the most stressful person that you work with. You can cultivate the ability to identify with, okay, what are they going through?

That's causing maybe they're going through a divorce right now. It's making them just really difficult to work with. Maybe they, my favorite definition of evil, since there is no real concept of evil and pedanta is goodness bereft of a guide. They just might not have the right guides or the guides that you have been fortunate enough to have.

That's the affirmation, the negation perspective that is very much in the line of what Paul Graham is saying. Not just keep your identity small, but negate whittle away that identity until it's nothing. I am not a fan of a programming language. I am not just a fan of a sports team.

I am not just a cog in some manipulative political machination. I'm not these things. I'm not even my body. It is just a vehicle carrying me around.

I'm not my mind because I can observe what my mind is doing. Therefore, the eye in me is separate from these thoughts. I'm not my intellect. The part of you that is discerning what to do in a given situation.

That's judging, deciding in the midst of various preferences that your mind is presenting forth. You can walk that back to where you're not your mind. You're not your body. You're not your intellect.

All the way back to where there is no articulation, because there is no identification with just one part of the universe. There is a totality, an identification with all of it. Therefore, a partial identification is not you. That is paradoxical to take both the affirmation and the negation.

Métis nétis is the phrase in Sanskrit, not this, not this. You can negate all the way to just pure business, which negates through language itself. Or you can affirm positively through the totality. You are all of it until language fails there as well.

Or it's a mix between the two constantly. Left foot, right foot, left foot, right foot. I am not my body that's experiencing this pain, and I am so much more than just this body that will have, as it said, Nikita, that will have its window and will be taken off like an old garment. This essay from Paul is so brilliant in that it just makes us question, pushes us, provokes us to assess constantly where we're giving our identification to.

And if I were to add a Vedantic influence to this essay, and if the great stages throughout time were editing it, they'd probably say, keep your identity infinite, or keep your identity infinitesimal. But whatever you do, don't get caught in between. That is today's Reflection on the Daily Vedantic. We'll see you next time.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of The Daily Vedantic?

This episode is 9 minutes long.

When was this The Daily Vedantic episode published?

This episode was published on April 5, 2024.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this The Daily Vedantic episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.