Skip to content
I'm Scared and Angry. What Should I Do? episode artwork

Mar 22, 2016

I'm Scared and Angry. What Should I Do?

from Blog and Talks - Deokwun Sunim Hosted by Deokwun Sunim

After service last Sunday several people approached me and expressed to me roughly the same concern and asked me essentially the same question. I would like to share their concern and question with you because I think they are more commonly shared than we realize. I will do my best to provide food for thought for those who are carrying these concerns and questions and who are struggling to reconcile them. Though there is much in Buddhism to help you address them, Buddhism leaves the resolution of the concerns and the answers to the question up to you. The first concern was about the current state of the political climate in this country. The ugliness, which is real and palpable, gives rise to equally real and palpable fear. For many, on both sides of the political spectrum, the potential outcome of the fall election is terrifying. We will talk about this at a later time. The second is the deep concern expressed about the state of affairs in the Middle East and especially the threat caused by ISIL or ISIS, as it sometimes called. The concern here is the unchecked advance of ISIL and the barbaric way in which they have advanced their agenda. Here is a typical example of what was expressed and asked of me: I am worried about how I’m feeling I feel I’m becoming islamophobic. This isn't like me. I don’t know what to do. On the one hand I know, as a Buddhist, that I shouldn’t feel this way, but I feel myself drifting in that direction. I am feeling scared and angry. Sometime I feel a sense of hate. I feel we should be doing to stop them. What am I suppose to do about all of this as a Buddhist? If you share any of these concerns and are asking yourself the same question you must be really struggling. You may feel as if the Buddhist teachings on suffering and compassion cannot be reconciled with the atrocities you hear about. You may be deeply troubled by the inability to reconcile your beliefs with you fear, hatred, and anger. So let’s take time today to explore your concerns and questions to see if there isn't some way to help you deal with the dilemma you are facing. First, recognize that the fear you experience is real. It is a powerful, present experience. But, your Buddhist beliefs tell you that all experiences are temporary and will soon pass. They are not permanent. Yet, current circumstances may be making you fearful a lot so that it feels more like a permanent state of affairs. The truth is, the fear will eventually fade. Remember the Buddha teaches us that all of our experiences are like a bubble, a mist, a fog. Maybe that isn’t enough this time. Perhaps that is because understanding impermanence intellectually doesn’t seem to help with the emotions the fear prompts. This fear is most likely prompting feelings of anger and maybe even hatred. These emotions seem to be demanding some action to satisfy them. Somehow we think that acting on the hatred and fear will give us power over not just our fear, but the people and circumstances also. Deep down we may feel the need for someone to pay not just for their actions, but for causing our own fear, anger, and hatred. You want someone to be blamed and to be held accountable. You forget that only you choose fear. Nobody causes it. The same is true of your anger and hatred; again, easy to intellectualize but very hard to accept. After all, people like ISIL who do the evil things they do must be the cause. The reality is they are not. Those emotions are yours and yours alone. Sometimes I think that these teachings are too abstract for us when confronted with something like ISIL. The other truth, though, is that, as the Buddha teaches, “hatred never ends through hatred. By non-hatred does it end. This is an ancient truth.” Shantideva, in “The Way of The Bodhisattva,” deals at length with anger and summarizes the implications for anger this way: “No evil is there similar to anger. All the good works gathered in a thousand ages, a single flash of anger shatters them all.” You may be sitting there thinking, “this is all well and good, but people like ISIL need to be dealt with.. Don’t we have an obligation to alleviate suffering and these brutes are certainly causing terrible suffering”. There is. No question. Their actions are evil from our point-of-view. However, they think their actions are necessary as a way to deal with their fear, hatred, and anger about what the West has done to their way of life. The see their fear, anger, and hatred just as legitimate as yours. Both sides are convinced of their righteousness. The question for a Buddhist is whether our righteous fear, anger, and hatred give us permission to answer violence with violence? To help answer that question let’s consider what the Buddha says about violence. Of all the actions that the Buddha says result in immediate karmic retribution none is more immediate than killing and violence. What he is pointing out is that no matter what action we take there are karmic consequences. It's just that killing and violence have immediate and long lasting consequences. He makes violence the number one cause of karmic retribution just as he makes Respect All Life the very first moral precept. It is the foundation for all moral behavior. In the Culakammavibangha Sutra. (The Shorter Discourse on Action) the, Buddha says::: Some man or woman kills a living being and is murderous, bloody-handed, given to blows and violence, merciless, to living beings, who is given to injuring beings with the hand, with a clod, with a stick, with a knife, who is of an angry and irritable character, who is hostile, angry, and resentful, and who displays anger, hate, resentment and bitterness, because of performing and undertaking such action, on the dissolution of the body, after death, appears in a state of deprivation, in an unhappy destination, in perdition, or instead comes back as a human, then wherever they are born they are short lived. This seems a fairly unequivocal warning. If you engage in violence then there will be immediate consequences. Still, when extreme rhetoric or extreme behavior confronts us, this warning fades into the background. Our need to satisfy our sense of outrage becomes more important. The question still remains, though, what to do about not just the extremes we see, but what do we do with our reaction? One of the remarkable things about Buddhism is that, while it doesn’t foist a solution on you, it does present you with possible outcomes and then leaves it to you to make your own decision. The warning you just heard from Buddha is one such example. Shantideva in his work, “The Way of the Bodhisattva”, takes a different approach and reaches the same result. He holds up a mirror so we can take a close look at what we see in our reflection. As he holds up the mirror to our fear, anger, and hatred he describes what he sees us thinking and saying: I will utterly destroy the sustenance of this my enemy My foe has no other purpose than to destroy me Pain, humiliation, insults, or rebukes We don’t want them for ourselves, our those we love For those we do not like the opposite is true. I think he accurately describes what many of us think, say, and wish at times. We want retaliation and revenge. We want them to suffer just like they are causing others to suffer because if they do suffer like that then we get satisfaction. When Shantideva holds up the mirror to those thoughts he asks us: If unhappiness befalls your enemies why should this be a cause for your rejoicing? And if your hostile wishes were to bring them harm, again, what cause of joy is this For you? “Why then I would be satisfied” Are these your thoughts? Is anything more ruinous than that? There is no reason for our rage. It is like blaming the fire for being hot. Notice he doesn’t tell you what to do. He only asks the questions. He remains true to the Buddhist way by leaving the decision up to you. No matter what course of action you choose don’t forget that there will be karmic consequences. Those you cannot avoid. There are many of you are probably still not satisfied with what you’ve heard. You want to know if there are any historical examples you can look to that demonstrate a violent response to violence by Buddhists has been seen as acceptable if not down right encouraged. Unfortunately, there are. Let’s look at just a few examples. In the Cakkavatti-Sihanada Sutra the ruler, Dalhanemi, asks for advice on what makes an enlightened ruler and loving defender. In one piece of advice the Buddha tells him that non-violence is always the best response, but Dalhameni could nevertheless; Establish guard, ward, and protection for your own household, your troops, Your nobles and vassals, Brahmins and householders, town and country folk, Ascetics, and for beasts and birds. Dalhameni is also instructed on the law of karma. In the Maha-Vamsa Chroncile which includes the period of roughly the years 101-77 BC of the Sri Lankan Buddhist tradition, the monks justify the king, Dutthagamani’s, action against the Tamil people who are seeking to replace Buddhism. They argue that the war is in defense of the Buddhism and therefore permissible. Then, in a moment of twisted Buddhist logic, argue that is also permissible because the Tamils do not have the “Right View” and therefore are no different than beasts. They issued this proclamation after he had defeated The Tamils: By this deed there is no obstruction to thy way to heaven. Unbelievers and men of evil they were, no more esteemed Than the beats. But as for thee, thou wilt bring glory to The religion of the Buddha in many ways. Therefore cast away care from they heart. In China one of the Four Protectors of Buddhism who is often represented by a statute place at the temple entrance, is Vaisravana who is said to assure victory in battle. In 58I, also in China, the rule Wen-Ti took the bodhisattva vows and announced, before he waged war to “spread Buddhism”, that the weapons of war have become like incense and flowers. Then there is this from the Thai monk Kittivuddhu, during the Viet Nam war: Let us determine to kill all communists and clean the slate in Thailand. Anyone who commits to join this movement must kill communists. The one who kills them will acquire great merit. If Thais do not kill them they will kill us. Of course, he never picked up a gun. Even the Tibetans, often seen as the most peaceful of all Buddhists, say that the first action taken in response to violence must be one of non-violence, but if it cannot be avoided their Arya-Satyaha-Parivarta Sutra says the violence must be only for the protection of the people, not come from anger, and must not destroy the infrastructure necessary to maintain sentient beings after the conflict is over. I can hear some of you thinking, “Wait. What happened to love and compassion for all beings? Isn’t that the real answer?” When you think about how you would answer that question consider what Shantideva says: Although one must never feel compassion for those who, through defilement, bring down their own perdition, what purpose does your anger serve? How you resolve your fear, anger, or hatred is up to you. Non-violence is always best and only carries wholesome karmic consequences. If you choose otherwise, then the karmic consequences are different. The Buddha says: You will not find a spot in the world Not in the sky Not in the ocean Not inside a mountain cave Where you will be free from your evil karma. This is all the advice and direction you will get from Buddhism on how to deal with fear, anger, hatred and answering with violence for violence. You always get to choose your own path through this difficult choice. The Buddha said we are our own refuge. We, and only we, get to decide. Only we are responsible for our choices, hard as they may be to make sometimes. Because this is how the Buddha Way works, we will never be able to blame someone else for our decisions. Choose what your wisdom tells you is the right path. Let me leave you with one last thought. It comes from Zen Master Ryokan who wrote almost 200 years ago: What was right yesterday is wrong today. what is right today, how do you not know it was not wrong yesterday? There is no right or wrong. No predicting gain or loss. Only when you are neither wise nor foolish Can you be called one who has attained the way. In one thousand years How can I live up to the true path even for a single day.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

I'm Scared and Angry. What Should I Do?

No transcript yet.

Requests help us decide what to transcribe next.

Frequently asked questions

When was this Blog and Talks - Deokwun Sunim episode published?

This episode was published on March 22, 2016.

Can I download this Blog and Talks - Deokwun Sunim episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.