Skip to content
In Conversation with Andrew Jaspan episode artwork

Mar 25, 2021 57 min

In Conversation with Andrew Jaspan

from Fourth Estate Hosted by 2SER

This week we have a special chat with Andrew Jaspan the founder of the Conversation. This week the Conversation turned 10 and we chatted about his memories of the start of the Conversation and Andrew's thoughts on media today. Your Host Tina Quinn.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

In Conversation with Andrew Jaspan

0:00 57:40
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

A safer Ontario means more police and prosecutors making sure my car doesn't get stolen. It means building new jails to keep criminals behind bars. And it means there's no need to worry when I play at the park. We're making every corner of Ontario safer to make all of Ontario safer.

That's how we protect Ontario. For all of us. Learn how at Ontario.ca.ca.ca. Pay for it by the Government of Ontario.

You're listening to Fourth Estate, the show where journalists talk journalism. Coming to you from Tuecieres, in Sydney on Gadigalands of the ER Nation, right across Australia on the Community Radio Network and directly to your device across the globe via podcast. My name's Tina Quinn, welcome to the program. This week we have a special one-on-one with the founder of the conversation, Andrew Jasmine.

Seeing the conversation turns 10 today, we thought it would be a good opportunity for Andrew to return to Fourth Estate and tell us all about how the conversation began and how it's going. Andrew Jasmine's career is obviously too long to go into here, but he is a former editor of The Age, The Sunday Herald, The Observer and The Scotsman. And he's also the founder of The Conversation. He is currently the editor and director of the Global Academy at Monash University.

Andrew Jasmine, welcome to Fourth Estate. Thanks very much, Tina. So as we go to Aaron Sydney, the conversation has just turned 10. Happy birthday to the conversation.

Could you tell us how the conversation came about? Because it all started when you found yourself in one of those career cross-road moments in your life. What happened and how did you come up with the idea? Thanks very much, Tina.

Sorry, I joined The Age in 2004 in October. And as my Christmas present from Fairfax, I was asked to make 50 people redundant before Christmas in 2004. And the reason for that was, same problems, all newspapers, revenues were collapsing and had to take costs out. So I really didn't like the fact that I arrived to try and reinvigorate The Age and found that I had to take people out.

But that was what I was asked to do. And as a new editor, I guess I just went along with it. And that happened pretty well every year, sometimes twice a year, redundancy rounds. And what was really happening to Catalow, sorry, short, was the specialist journalism.

Some of the very best people just walked out and took packages. And many of them just went to other newspapers or in the case of, for example, C by Follow News, who was one of our business writers, who moved to business spectator and that sort of thing. But I just saw really good people walk out. And then there was a final call, which I was part of, a 550 journalists at the very end of 2008.

And I had spent quite a bit of my time in our management group arguing against constant cost scanning. Because I said, look, at the end of the day, if you keep cutting, there'll be nothing left. And the readers will realise that any short change, there'll be a real problem for the paper. So anyway, I was kind of rewarded with being asked to go for putting those kind of arguments forward.

And I then got, I mean, during my time at The Age, I became friends with, as you do when you edit to The Age, with a court-wholes of range of interesting people. But one of them who met me on a sort of reasonably regular basis was Lynn Davis, who was the Vice Chancellor Melbourne University. And we kind of found out that the graduates of Melbourne University, the first choice of read was The Age. So there was a kind of a good match between the two.

But we had many discussions about all sorts of things, because, when he was at university, wrote his final thesis on the story of ABC, how the ABC came about and all that. And for my final thesis in the UK, I actually wrote about the BBC. But I looked at the BBC in terms of balance and partiality, etc. So we kind of, you know, just got, became, I suppose, friends.

Anyway, I left The Age, I got a call from him saying, what are you going to do next? And I said, I'm not sure. I said, well, let's meet for a coffee. And when we sort of ran through what we're going to do, and by the way, I said, there's a few things I don't want to do.

One of them is going to PR or anything like that. And I said, I don't want to write. But I also said, I didn't want to do what a lot of ex-editors did, which is kind of write this sort of stream of what's gone wrong with journalism pieces. And you've no idea how much has been written by ex-journalists about, you know, what's gone wrong.

I said to him, what I'd like to do is see if there's a different way of creating high quality information and making it widely available to the public. And he said, okay, well, good luck. I don't know how you can do that. But what I'm prepared to do is give you a desk and I'd like to introduce you to some of my smartest thinkers at the university.

And I thought, oh, God, that this is great. Not knowing where this was going to lead. Anyway, next thing is he kind of introduced me by email to 10 people. And they're all people from Earth scientists, astrophysicists, Nobel laureates, a whole range of people in different areas across the university.

And by the way, that's one of the real strengths of the university is that it covers the universe of subjects, you know, so you've got everything really there in one place. Anyway, I met them all and, you know, had long coffees and discussions. And it suddenly sort of occurred to me. I had one of those, so eureka moments, you kind of think, do they really happen or not?

But they did in my case. I suddenly thought, my goodness, these are the smart people I would love to have in my sort of virtual newsroom. Wouldn't it be great if I could just have these people writing for me? Because every single one was a really deep subject matter specialist.

You know, so I thought, wouldn't this be good? That was the first thing. The second thing is talking to Peter Doherty, who's who's an immunologist. He was just saying to me, he was really fed up doing interviews with journalists.

And I said, why is that? And he said, because at the end of every interview, I always think to myself, how badly will this interview turn out? Can you imagine that? You know, it was never a case of how good it would be.

And I thought, well, hang on, something has gone badly, badly wrong here. So I said, so what's the issue? He said, well, you know, they quote me and then put it out of context or any selectively quote me. And at the time, and I'll give you this one small example, there was a new flu strain had hit Australia.

And the chief medical officer had sort of sent out all these warnings about it. And Peter said to me, you know, with this new flu strain, if you're under the age of, let's say 10, I don't know exactly, and over the age of 70, you really should be worried. But otherwise, there's enough herd immunity and you know, we should be a real problem. Anyway, he said, next thing is, you know, he read a piece which said headline was Peter Doty says this flu strain is not a problem.

And he got a call from the chief medical officer saying, why are you contradicting my advice? And he said, well, because what they've done is locked off the beginning, which said, you know, if you're under 10 and over 70, it is a real issue. Otherwise, you know, you should be OK. So he said, look, there's an example where I give an interview and it just goes badly badly wrong and I end up getting getting it in the neck from the chief medical officer.

So he said to me, look, Andrew, I tell you what would be really good. And this was the final bit of the conversation. He said, if you could rather than sitting across the desk from me, metaphorically, if you could actually sit next to me and we could work together where I give you my knowledge, you shape it into good prose. And once you've shaped it, could you let me see any change you've done so I can make sure you haven't introduced any errors.

And then if I'm OK with it, Bingo, off we go. So that was really the secret of a new partnership between editors, professional editors and academic researchers. Dr. Wei from that wrote it all up into a 15 page proposal because I wanted to detail exactly what the proposal was, how it would work, what the website would be like.

It was going to be a digital only offering. And then I delivered all that back to Glen Davis because I was working as a consultant to him. And he said, wow, this is a very, very good idea. Let's see if we can make it work.

So the initial response in those those days must have been quite interesting. I would imagine bringing together academics and journalists. Was it hard to get the vision taken up? No, not at all.

But let me tell you what, one side sort of worked it all out. There's another bit that happened, which is talking to Glenn because I initially did that work for Melbourne University. And he said to me, look, if you don't mind, could could we involve other universities in this and not just Melbourne Uni? And I said to him, oh, that would be so much better because if it's just Melbourne University, it becomes news from Melbourne University, which in a sense, it's another form of PR because every university, as you probably know, has PRs.

A lot of them ex journalists who go in and essentially write out good stories about how well the university is doing this, that the other and new research that's doing and new appointments and all that kind of stuff. All that is frankly PR. But by bringing the whole sector, suddenly it becomes, you know, a much more believable offering because you're going for the best, rather than the best in a single university. So what Glinded was you rang up four or five of his mates on the VCs and within a very short order of time, we had Monash University.

So we had Melbourne Monash, ANU, University of Western Australia and UTS all came to the party offering 200,000 a year for three years. And we wanted three years because we wanted to proper runway to make sure we could get the idea one to establish. Then I went to the Victorian State Government and they matched that. So I'd raised three million and suddenly became six million.

Then I went to see Julia Gillard at the time as the Education Secretary in the federal government and she matched it. So they wouldn't be in nine million. And then through a contact of mine, I met somebody at Commonwealth Bank of Australia and they agreed to be our technology partner and put 850,000 a year into development. So suddenly we had $10 million and that allowed us to then build a site, recruit a team and start working.

However, to answer your question, people said to me, you know, before the launch, they said good luck with that because academics can't write or they won't write. They're hopeless in terms of deadlines. They're really sloppy. They won't stick to deadlines.

It's a nightmare. Don't bother. It's just not going to work. So that kind of level of skepticism.

Frankly, and this was based on my discussions with umpteen academics at Melbourne University and elsewhere. I become convinced that actually they did want the academic researchers, particularly those who see themselves as public intellectuals, actually see that it's part of their job, part of their role. If they're funded by taxpayers to do to teach and to do research, they'd actually like to share their knowledge more widely. The problem was, and this was this is where the conversation got off, they didn't know how to safely get their knowledge out to the wider public.

And I just came up with a way of doing that. They all bought into it. And to date, 20,000 out of the 100,000 academics in Australia have contributed to the site. So you could say, well, that's only 20%.

That's right. The 20% is a lot of people in your newsroom because they all are registered to write. And you could say 80,000 don't want to write or can't write, etc. So so that's kind of where we're up to.

But we have created a safe space for them to get their knowledge out to the public and the public really have lacked an app. So you've talked about, you've talked about it from the perspective of academics and how a lot of them actually wanted the opportunity to get their work more widely read and get their, their ideas and their research out there. What about from the side of the journalists, you know, academics and journalists, they've always operated as close to shops really before the conversation. What was the sort of reaction you got from journals?

And did you get any pushback from them? Well, just before I go into that, another issue, you know, I'd like to just mention why academics to me were a good source to go to is that I was very concerned at the time. And you've got to remember this was 2010. I kind of came up with the idea.

Even back then, I was really worried about not just a diminution of diminution of the quality, but also I was really worried about the about the sort of trust aspect of a lot of content. You know, could you actually could you actually rely on the content you were reading? In other words, did you know that this was going to be accurate or was it spinning something to you? And what I really liked about talking to academics is I never went on campus by the way after university.

I kind of went into into journalism and just never came back. And as you say, the two kind of close shops to each other. So this was my first time back, but I discovered that academics or universities have very, very strong codes of conduct around how they behave, how they operate, how they do their research. And to me, and by the way, they do peer review, you know, so there's a form of fact checking that goes on.

So to me, this was really high grade information that could be used. Whereas, you know, even amongst a lot of journalism and you'll be familiar with all the the scandals and issues, particularly the UK with phone hacking and all sorts of stuff. There was real question mark over the the morals and ethics of some journalists or some sections of journalism. So I was kind of quite happy to work with academics.

Now, to answer your question, I'd like to do it in a slightly secure this way as well, which is this that the main sort of providers of ideas and information to society between about the 12th century in Europe and the 17th and 18th was universities. They were the main sort of area. In addition to that was the church through things like the Bible and religious tracks, but universities really were the main supplies of information about astronomy, physics, mathematics, law, all those kind of areas. Then journalism kind of took over and use sharp elbows to kind of nudge academics out of the way and a sense the media or newspapers became the fourth estate, meaning, you know, that its role was not only to provide information, but also to hold those in power to to account and to scrutinize everything they did that became the role of the first state.

And then, and then what happened was that the business model of journalism, you know, since pretty well 17th and 18th century was kind of around advertising and that model slowly fell apart during the kind of early 20th century is from 1995 onwards strains began to appear and it got really bad from about, you know, 2007, eight onwards with the GFC and then reduction of advertising etc. So the in a sense, my feeling was the fourth estate was falling apart and there was an opportunity for universities to step back into the arena, becoming the providers of high quality accurate information. So I thought there was a very important new development and in a sense, the first to really move into that space was the conversation, you know, to actually in partnership with with academics, as you know, the slogan, the conversation is journalistic for academic rigor journalistic flair. So it was kind of partnership between the two, which came along in terms of the journalists that we hired.

These journalists were really, for some reason, really interested in intrigued by this idea. And they still have a very big role in terms of commissioning, discussing ideas with academics, editing, checking and then adding links where necessary choosing photographs, writing the headlines, writing the intros, you know, there's still a lot of journalism goes on. But then before it's posted, there's one final check back with the author just say, look, I want you to be happy with everything, no surprises. So I was trying to avoid the Peter Doherty issue with surprises afterwards.

And once they said, no, it's all good, the picture is good, the headlines good, it's all accurate, bingo off it went. So it was a real partnership and, you know, all the journalists working on the conversation really enjoyed the experience. We've got some brilliant, you really got some brilliant talent working for the conversation. I mean, Michelle Gratton, obviously, when she came on in 2013, that was a really brilliant addition to the lines between academic.

So with Michelle, just once you know, when I was at the age, I just got a certain rapport going, just Michelle and I just essentially just one of those situations where we got on and I really liked what she did and really highly respected everything she's done as a journalist. And she rang me up after launch and said, can I join? And it just took me a while because we don't actually hire journalists per se to write. We hire professional editors and our writers are academics.

So what I had to do was secure an academic position with for her, which I did at the University of Canberra. So she left the age and joined University of Canberra as a professor there. And her role mainly, I mean, she did do some internal teaching and lectures and so on and so forth. But mainly she just wrote for the conversation and that gave a huge profile to the University of Canberra as well because her articles amongst the best read.

She is the best fact checker in the business. Yeah. Yeah. I think she's such a stickler.

Yeah. Absolutely. And people go to her, Tina, people go to her because they know, I mean, she's famous for ringing people up late at night. So I just want to run this by you.

Can you just let me know if I've got this right or not? Now, to me, that is what high grade journalism should be about that when she puts something out, it's accurate. The person reading it knows it's accurate and people forgave her for ringing up late at night to check things. I mean, I've heard the story so many times, but, you know, that is the mark of her work.

And her stats because she's trusted, she also gets has extremely good network of contacts. I mean, they like going to because they know she'll be straight with them. Tell us about the first year after the following on from the conversation launching. As a young startup, was it smooth sailing or?

Yeah. So the first thing, Tina, which was, I mean, you know, sometimes you go in hindsight, we should understand the other. But I've been, I've spoken to too many other startups who, who kind of said that they were under capitalized and what happened is just when they seem to be about to succeed. They ran out of money, you know, because all my view is I have a very simple matrix for things that work in terms of new starts.

They need to be one, a good idea to you need to have people who can actually execute the idea and three, you need to be properly capitalized in terms of funded. So my thoughts were we had a good idea. I built a good team, I think, and we also from the very beginning, I wouldn't launch unless we got three years money. And, you know, Glenn Davis was kind of instrumental in all this, helped me secure other universities who took a punt on three years commitment.

So when you asked how to go after the first year, you know, it could could have been that we fell off, you know, the cliff after the first year because we kind of ran out of money and nobody was reading us. But that first year, I made a decision by the way not to spend anything on marketing and advertising. Instead, what we did was I kept the idea very much under wraps really close to under wraps so that when it came to the launch, I was able to get lots of free publicity. So we had loads of articles all over the place on this new idea.

And I'm trying to so the articles were only come out at a time when the site was live. So people would read it and then go, I must have a look. So we got a lot of free publicity in, you know, from the ABC, from newspapers, from all over the place. So it went, it went very well and we couldn't believe how quickly people were beginning to share our content.

So it kind of went viral very, very quickly. And we just watched every day that, you know, that the readers doubling pretty well. And that's from a low base, you know, so the first day we may be attracted, let's say, for argument's sake, a thousand readers, but the next day was two thousand. And the day after it's four thousand, you know, a day that is also kind of went on.

But also because we were working with 39 newsrooms around the country, every university, sorry, 39 universities around the country, every university was also plugging, you know, the startup, the conversation as well. So there was kind of a number of ways that we got, you know, recognition that the site had launched. So first year went very well. There was one kind of thing which I kind of wonder if I did right or wrong, which is this that after a few months of it starting because we started March and around April, May in 2011, I got an email from a guy who's organizing a big conference on the future of higher education or the future of universities, one or two at Toronto University, but it was organized by the Chronicle of Higher Education, which is kind of, you know, they're equivalent of the main sort of trade journal from the university sector.

And they asked me because it seemed a sight and the guy running up was very excited about it and said, would I come and I said, well, we launched, you know, a couple of months ago and I really need to be here and get pestering me and you know, it was offering me, you know, flights and hotels and all sorts of things. And at the end of it, because at that time, my mum lived in the UK and I thought, well, I tell you what, if I, because the conference, I think was over a weekend or something and I thought, well, maybe it's Thursday Friday, I thought, well, if I go and do two days Thursday Friday, then I can get a flight to London, see my mum and then be back in Australia, you know, on the Tuesday or whatever it was. So I kind of did that, but as a result of that, I got all because after that, I took the train down to Boston, which is a two far away and spoke to some people there and they were really interested in looking at whether they could launch. And then when I landed in London, I went to City University, which is the main journalism or one of the main journalism places to study at.

And the Vice Chancellor there was very, very keen on the idea and said to me, you know, if you decide to launch, I'd like you to, I'll supply you with some space here to be a base. So suddenly I had interest in the UK and US within months of the launch and that became quite distracting because I then ended up having to raise the money to get it going because I have to go over there and I finally got, I think, it was about eight or ten universities to put money up, which was enough to launch. And then I had to go there and leave the launch. I flew one of our best editors, one called Megan Clement out to London to actually run the launch for the first six months.

And then a similar thing happened with US where I ended up also being the CEO of the US operation because the board of directors there wanted me involved, which was mad, absolutely mad. And I wish I'd never agreed to that, but I kind of said, well, we're not going to launch on this. You know, you agree to be the CEO and editor in chief as it were. So I kind of, again, had to raise the money there.

And I spent, I mean, for example, I did a two week trip to the US, which was organized by somebody else working with the time. And he got me, he got me running around 16 foundations in Los Angeles, San Francisco, Chicago, Boston, New York, Washington, and then finally Miami for the night foundation. So I visited, I think it was 14 or 15 foundations and six of them agreed to give us money. So we, so then that secured two million to allow us to launch into the US, you know.

But in answer to your question, I think I was kind of distracted by all that. And in retrospect, I think I should have found a way to avoid that. And the way to avoid it was not to accept that flight to Toronto to go and talk about the conversation. Well, first, well, Australian start up, the international reach of the conversation is really impressive, incredibly impressive.

Was it was it part of the original vision to go international? No, absolutely not. I hadn't really thought about it. I think, and again, it's difficult to put my mind back to where we were, but I think we thought, in fact, when we launched the site, we were covering everything.

So do you remember the disaster for Kashmir and Japan? You know, we covered that out of here and we covered, you know, the UK elections out of Melbourne and we covered the American elections and anything big. That happened in any part of the world we covered. So everything was down out of Australia.

So I think we initially probably hadn't really thought it through. And I think we just thought, or I just thought, you know, we'll do everything from Australia. And then as I said to you, as a result of being lured to Toronto, I ended up, you know, because I told lots of people about it at that conference and people really intrigued and brushed out of the site. So we got lots of interest coming in.

And then suddenly when the UK launched, they said, well, you don't need now to worry about issues like the UK elections and later on Brexit and everything else because we'll do that. And by the way, we'll also do the whole of Europe out of London. And then when we did the US, you know, that meant because the UK site was covering US as well for a while. And when the US site started, they said, well, you know, you can now just focus on Europe and UK because we'll now do North America.

And so it kind of went on like that. But when I was raising money for the US site, I went to the Gates Foundation in Seattle and met, you know, really great team of people there. They were really excited about the idea. And they said they'd fund the US site, but they said, as a conditioner, funding the US site, they wanted me to also launch a site into Africa because the Gates Foundation is really interested in Africa.

And it's kind of one of their focus areas. So suddenly I was offered money to launch into Africa. So I then had to get in touch with some journalists and spoke to them and they said, oh, God, that'd be great. You know, we'd love to do it.

So that kind of happened. And in the same way, while I was raising money for the US, I met a guy called a British Russelo, who was a colleague. I'd worked with him at Liberación Paris many, many years ago. And he was in New York and came up to Boston where I was.

We met and talked about it. He said, I'd love to do this in France. So I then helped him get going to France. And I was trying to get some money from an organization called Open Society Foundation in London for the conversation.

And they said, well, you know, we'd love to help you launch a new site, you know, rather than give you money for the existing sites. So I said, OK, well, you know, where are you interested? And they said, well, the one that we're working on is Indonesia. So we talked about that and then they gave us money and we're able to launch the Indonesian sites.

And so so kind of went on. Really? From the south side. Yeah, kind of a virtuous circle, virtuous circle or but the great thing is every time.

And I think you picked up on this team every time a new conversation started that went into that part of the world and really built a new audience. So the French site is in French. There's now Spanish site. And by the way, the Spanish site was started by a guy called Miguel Castro, who was at the Gates Foundation.

So I'd met him through the Gates Foundation. And I teased Miguel because when I first went to him asking for money, he was very skeptical about the conversation. He's now the chairman of the conversation in Spain. Last time you were on for the state, you talked about your idea of a levy.

So to speak on Facebook and Google. And that idea has has been taken up, but maybe but maybe not fully. What is your view on the government's moves to make these two platforms pay for the news? And do you think it will lead to greater diversity in our media?

The short answer is I don't. Although, you know, the jury is still out. My view with the levy and just be a listener, I just want to remind what that was about. What I was saying was that Google and Facebook, and this is a terribly important point.

You probably understand it, Tina. They do not want in any way to cross the line and be seen as publishers. Because once you're a publisher, you have all sorts of responsibility around responsibility for the content, meaning you're open to defamation, libel and the rest of the publishing rules and laws, including, you know, the, the limit on the number of players that operate in each country and some support share of voice issues. So what they do is they refuse to get into funding editor directly.

But what they have done is taken out the way with all to create content. So the real issue is how do you create content? And my argument was allow Facebook and Google to continue making 6 billion a year, which they build by the way from Singapore and Ireland. So it's offshore, but force them to make a to pay a levy of say 10% of 6 billion, which is 600 million a year or it could be 20% if you wanted to 1.2 billion a year.

So they still talk out a huge amount of money, but constructing new levy, which would become an independent source of funding, particularly those areas of market failure, such as the ones I mentioned earlier, regional journalism, specialist journalism and a whole bunch of other areas and put that towards that. Because that way there was an arm's length relationship between Google and Facebook. They were not directly funding editorial. They were just paying a levy.

However, news Corp, and you've got to remember the history of Rupert Murdoch and news Corp have been hostile towards Google and Facebook for many, many years. And they largely drove the legislation in Australia. And what I fear it will do is largely benefit the big players, the established players. So because it was, I think largely drafted by news Corp for the government, it favours news Corp and favours the other big players, the nine papers and so on and so forth, or the nine network, I should say.

So my view is it's just going to reinforce a rather weak ecosystem in Australia, rather than addressing market failure and addressing market diversity. So the government has basically wasted the opportunity to rebalance the media in Australia. That would be my view. Yeah.

I don't like it. You need to understand why that happens because this government is reliant largely on support from news Corp papers and outlets, including Skye and the others. What did you find it interesting then that our Prime Minister seemingly bought the hand that I guess made him a little bit yesterday in a quite remarkable press conference. Yeah.

Well, I think what happened was he lost his temper somewhat and misspoke to use that ugly phrase. He said something he probably should do. I think he overspoke according to the government's just today. I don't know that one before.

I overspoke. Yeah. So overspoke misspoke, whatever. As a result, news Corp have gone ballistic.

And of course, what he's done is he can't bite the hand that feeds him as well, which is a news Corp because they largely support the coalition. So immediately he had to do a mere Cal burn retraction and eat humble pie or whatever else to get back on side. But my own personal feeling, and this is very much a personal feeling, is that he crossed a line in the Rubicon yesterday. And I think you'll find that news Corp support for his premiership will start to wait now and they'll begin to think, this is no longer our guy and we don't really trust him.

Although at the end of the day, news Corp will keep supporting him as long as they think that he can actually lead the Liberals or the coalition to victory the next election. When Facebook kicked all of Australia's media off the platform, what was your reaction? I think that was another ugly phrase that come to Jesus moments, for the media to just realise that how much they rely upon Facebook, huge reliance on Facebook to distribute their content. And numbers just plummeted from the moment that happened.

So that was on that side of the agenda. On the other side, you had Facebook thinking, oh my God, we've kind of overstepped and there's going to be so much hostility towards our brand. And we better repair it. Because one of the key things I haven't really mentioned to you is that Australia is being watched by the rest of the world.

What happens here could affect other jurisdictions. So they're all watching to see what happens. And they're all really hoping that the publishers would really hold their ground against Facebook and Google. But Google have very cleverly just gone around just buying people off.

Because you've got to remember that Google is one of the richest companies in the world. And if they can buy off small territory like Australia, because Australia is tiny for that. Despite taking out about five billion advertising, that's still a tiny amount compared to the European countries and so on. So I think they just had to close down, put out the fires in Australia as quickly as possible.

And just buy people off. And of course, because of the media are in a weak position, they're just all just saying, oh, thank you, Mr. Google. Thank you for the money because we really need it.

So I think it's a kind of again, a bit of a dependency culture in Australia that the media has towards Google, which is Google helps, you know, both spread our content because it gives it greater profile and brings readers back to us. But they also eat our advertising cake. So I don't think there's an elegant solution in Australia. And I think, you know, I think we'll have to come back to this again.

But what has happened in the short term is I think Google and Facebook have put out the fires in Australia so they don't spread to the rest of the world. We've already spoken about media innovation and I'd like to get your thoughts on diversity in the media landscape. The level of concentration, it's really only increased since you last on. What are your thoughts on media diversity in Australia?

I mean, we're basically essentially being left with two large players and a public broadcaster, which is largely underfunded. Do you think it's a sustainable model? It just depends on how you define sustainable. But look, when I first came to Australia, and by the way, as Mark Scott, who then went on to lead the ABC, when he was a director of Fairfax, he appointed me when I came, which I said before I came, I sort of read up quite a bit about the media market.

And I have to tell you, it is probably the most concentrated media market in the world. And with one big beast or one big player, which is News Corp, which by the way has massively grown from when I came. So first of all, they swallowed up APN papers in Queensland, which has made all of Queensland a one paper state because they've got the Korean mail and they've got everything else, you know, all the other papers in the state. But they've also grown since I came to Sky and Sky at night.

And it's got a very, apparently they've got the most popular YouTube channel now, which is going gangbusters as well. So if anything, they've increased. And there's something else has happened, which is when I came, there was News Corp and there was Fairfax. So you had two different groups and within Fairfax, the Sydney Morning Herald and the age that I ran were quite independent papers.

You know, we would lead with quite different stories. We had different political lines and all that kind of stuff. Now, the Fairfax papers essentially all merged. It's got one back office, merge back office, where all national politics, all national news, all international news, all business and many other areas are all pulled together and run out of Sydney.

And what happens is that the age is very much just a branch office, which is able to do is left alone to cover AFL stories, the opening of a new cafe or restaurant, house prices in Melbourne and bad behavior on the trams or whatever, you know, that's, that's the kind of extent. The rest of it is all just sent down the pipe from Sydney. And it's a terrible state affair. So voices have gone out, you know, the age largely has been suffered by City Morning Herald and of course, the Finn is in there as well.

So that's that's reduced the number of voices and then and then, as I say, with with channel nine or nine entertainment taking over Fairfax. That's again, reduced the independence of Fairfax. It's now just part of nine. So that's reduced channel nine or nine entertainment is chaired by Peter Costello or my liberal treasurer.

So you've got he's a very powerful influence on the whole company. Then you've got Rupert Murdoch and his his people running it as well with their own agenda. And the only sort of independent voice you've got left is the ABC and the ABC, as you said, your question is severely underfunded. I actually looked at what the BBC gets in the UK and did a pro-rata because the UK population is 63, 64 million and Australia is 25 million.

So if you take a third, you know, the ABC is probably underfunded by 50% on what it should be if you did a pro-rata with the BBC. So as you know, every year they put a standstill every year, they ask for efficiency, efficiency drives or whatever. And it really struggles. And but that said, I do think they're still doing some incredible journalism, which you wouldn't read about or view on the commercial stations.

Now, there's one last bit, sorry for the answer. But AAP, as you probably know, went bust last year because news corp and nine entertainment pulled the pin on it. And the reason they pulled the pin was that they thought, why should we be funding because they put in between them, probably about half the money? Why should we be funding an Australian wire agency that essentially is being used by our competitors and we're kind of paying mostly for it?

So they pulled the pin on that. And as a result, it was going to go bust and it was saved by some philanthropists and others. But it's a it's a much reduced service on what AAP used to be. And news corp had to have a or a force degree to a non compete clause of six months, which ran out in February this year.

And and news corp wanted to launch news wire, which is a competitor to AP. So suddenly you've got a much reduced AP with much reduced funding will be up against a mighty competitor at News Corp launching their own Y service and going to all the clients of the the remaining AP and saying, why don't you come to ask them? We'll charge you that. So if the AAP collapses, then you've got even more concentration Australia, which is which is terrible.

And that's something I worry about enormously. And it goes back to the point. Why? Because it reduces diversity of opinion across Australia.

Indeed. Having an Ex-Editor of the age and the observer on the on the on the program, I can't help but ask you about the reckoning in Canberra. Are you surprised about the revelations that are coming out? That sounds like a no.

Yeah, it's probably isn't no. I mean, look, we're all aware of that sort of slightly toxic macho culture. And it's it's just not one that I don't I mean, for example, that drinking and manic and all that I've never been to those bars, but it goes on. The use that, you know, many, many journalists are in need, created and then go back to Parliament House and because they had too much to drink, they misbehaved.

There's on top of that now a lot of drugs are used as well. You know, there's just a rather bad culture. But what's most important thing is that once you're in the precincts of the Parliament, you know, you're pretty well exempt from anything ever happening to you because you know, you can pretty well do and act as you will. So, you know, I was pretty shocked by that four corners program, which said that, you know, that Brittany Higgins and the guy we don't know his name, you know, at two in the morning turned up a Parliament and just demanded to be allowed to be let in and the security guards couldn't really stop them because the rules there are the security guards can let in, you know, people who've got passes as well.

And although they didn't physically have their passes with them, which was odd, they check their names and yes, they were registered and they could go in and you know what happened was just absolutely appalling. So in a sense, it's kind of anything goes within that place. And I don't think that's the behavior of all the media by any means, by the way, I think it was just, you know, a certain tranche of the media that that you know, they just love the whole power thing that goes on in Canberra. And I think that this has been a festering saw as it were.

And with the revelations, everyone that's coming out, you know, the layers of the onion are being peeled. And I think, well, I hope something will happen. Why say I hope is that, you know, in Scott Morrison, I don't really, and it's not just me. I think many people wonder whether he's actually, you know, got the wit to really deal with this problem firmly once and for all and just draw a line in the sand and said no more.

These stories are being driven by brave women, largely coming forward, but also by the ABC and News Corp. How do you judge the performance of the media in all of this? Look, it's a difficult question to answer because there are very, very, I mean, you can remember that the relationship between journalists in Canberra and politicians extremely close. One needs the other.

They feed off each other. You know, the politicians crave, you know, publicity, the journalists crave, you know, exclusives. So they kind of spend a lot of time buttering up each other, you know, going out for dinners and don't forget everything is paid for, you know, on your expenses. So it's not actually out of your own money.

And in the case of the ABC, I just think it's done some incredibly brave journalism, particularly through obviously the four corner stuff that's been done. And for actually, in a sense, addressing and questioning and challenging what's going on with politicians, it's ended up with Christian Porter taking out one will probably be the largest and most expensive defamation action ever taken against the ABC by the government, and particularly by its principal law officer. So, you know, it's very, very serious stuff. And, you know, it's going to be huge when it comes out and who knows where it's going to go.

But it tends to be, you know, strain in court. So the media tend to lose out in these big cases. So I just don't know how that's going to go. It's going to be very interesting.

But at the heart of it is, I guess, you know, freedom of the press to publish information, which needs to be obviously accurate. And I think they will, their case would based on veracity, you know, which is checked and we know this to be the case, but it will be challenged. But no, you're right. I mean, you know, going back to my earlier question, you know, thank God we do have an independent ABC, which is not so much in hot to the government, but you got to remember that the ABC is funded by the government, whereas the relationship in the UK is funded through license payers and who pay a license fee.

So there is a kind of an arms length relationship between the government and the BBC, whereas here is directly funded by government and the government. And if they want to, you know, penalize the ABC for acts, which it considers to be wrong. And that's happened in many times, you know, that your reward for doing something has been to either have a standstill budget or reduction. Finally, let's end on a positive note.

Where do you see the conversation in 10 years and where would you like to see the media in general? Well, the first thing is just to remind you that I left the conversation in 2017 and I started work on 2010. So I did seven years, pretty full on years doing. I was the chief fundraiser was my idea, in a sense, and I had fundraised to make it happen.

And then was the editor of it. I was also the kind of CEO. I was doing a bus tutorial roles. And then as I said to you earlier, I was helping launches in UK, US and all over the place.

So I was pretty worn out and I then decided what I was invited to move across to my team, but I'm not actually university. So I'm kind of doing just working in different areas. So I'm no longer at the conversation, but my feelings are that one, the business model, commercial model of membership will endure into the future. So I think financially it's secure to, I think there will probably be more launches.

Most of the launches, they're now the ones that I actually was involved in helping happen. There's been a bit of a standstill because of economic conditions around the world. So there's been a bit of a standstill, but I predict there'll be more of them. But I think the idea is, I mean, the readership and audience increasing every year.

The second party of question was more to do with what the rest of the media in Australia. I'd like to see the ABC properly funded. And but I only see that happening under a Labour government because I think Labour believe more in public services, which includes the ABC than the other side, which believes in the commercial delivery of information and news. So I'd like to see the ABC properly funded.

And by the way, I don't mean incrementally. I mean, like an extra 50% budget to probably cover regional, rural, Australia, specialist journalism and all the areas that commercial people don't do, including drama and entertainment. No, so not so much in drama and serious entertainment for documentaries, things like that. And in terms of the rest of the media, sadly, I think if the AAP goes past, I think that's going to be a really bad thing for Australia.

There'll be, I don't see anybody containing news, corpse ambitions to really set the agenda in Australia. And they go one step further, particularly with the Australian, which kind of defines through its columns, what is Australian, what is un-Australian, which means that the areas that they back and the areas that they're against. So I really worry about all that. I do hope that like me, more and more people will read things like I read the New York Times, Washington Post, the Guardian, the Financial Times and others.

And I hope that will continue because that does allow you to get news from other places. In terms of Australian coverage, I'm worried about the future. And I would like to see an antidote to the nine papers, nine entertainment and the news call through a better funded ABC at the very least. On that note, Andrew Jasmine, a very big thank you for joining us on Fourth Estate.

My pleasure. Thank you very much. And thank you for listening to Fourth Estate. This edition was recorded at the studios of Tuezia and heard across the country on the community radio network.

Fourth Estate is produced with the assistance of the Community Broadcasting Foundation. Thanks to the foundation for their continuing support. Make sure you subscribe to Fourth Estate on your favorite podcast app so you can hear us talk media, politics and a lot in between. We'll be back with more next week.

But in the meantime, you can stay in touch with us on Twitter. I handle this for the state. Thank you. Many thanks to my executive producer, Anthony Dockrell.

My name is Tina Gwynn. Thanks for listening.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Fourth Estate?

This episode is 57 minutes long.

When was this Fourth Estate episode published?

This episode was published on March 25, 2021.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Fourth Estate episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.