Skip to content
In Conversation With Gabrielle Chan episode artwork

Sep 2, 2021 38 min

In Conversation With Gabrielle Chan

from Fourth Estate Hosted by 2SER

This week Gabrielle Chan spoke with Tina Quinn about her new book Why you should give a f*ck about farming.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

In Conversation With Gabrielle Chan

0:00 38:43
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Hello and welcome back to Fourth Estate, the show where journalists talk journalism. Coming to you from Tewa Siar in Sydney on Gadigal lands of the ER nation, right across Australia on the community radio network and directly to your device across the globe via podcast. My name is Tina Quinn, it's a pleasure as always to have you come. Today we have a special one-on-one with journalist Gabrielle Chan.

Gabrielle's nearly 40-year career has included long stints at the Australian, the Delhi Telegraph, the ABC, and now as the rural and regional editor for Guardian Australia. The daughter of a Singaporean migrant, Gabrielle was working in the Canberra Press Gallery in 1996 when she met and decided to marry a sheep and wheat farmer. Moving to the small town of Hardin-Maram-Bara, which has a population of 2000, has greatly informed her perspective and her work. She chartered the economic and cultural divide between the city and the country in the book rusted off why country Australia is fed up.

Now she has a new book, Why We Should Give and F About Farming, discussing just that. Gabrielle Chan, welcome to Fourth Estate. Thanks, Tina. So your latest book starts with a basic question, should we care about farming?

All right, well here's a Dorothy Dix question, has the time come that we do care? Yes, I think the time has come and let me just put it into some context because I think historically farmers in Australia have been, in a sense, over-rewarded during the Protection Era. And then as the deregulation era rolled out, I think we've been throwing that many people excess baggage off the bus. We're now at a point where we've landed with the world worried about climate change, and we really need to think about how we're going to manage food production in a changing landscape, in a changing climate.

Well, Gabrielle, you're a gentleman, a very good and experienced one at that. How did you find yourself at this point running about? I'm not really about farms and what we put on our plates. Well, I have never expected to.

I came from a city upbringing, a suburban Sydney upbringing, into a media world, writing about politics. And it was only that I fell in love with the farmer of the book that I really started thinking about this stuff. But I quickly learned that you can pull the thread of a farm and work out to try and work out how the system works. And you're really taken into foundational philosophical questions about the way we want to organise our communities, the way we want to, how we value food, how we value landscape, how we integrate the whole show in order to feed a population with healthy food.

And it surprised me, actually, how many different directions it went into. And it was quite challenging, actually, to rein it in. While the general public does care about food production, it's mainly at a basic and consumer facing level. Are my eggs catering?

Do my veggies look fresh and are they cheap? You, though, want us to think much more deeply about this. What are we missing about our food when we walk down our shopping aisles? So the research coming out of the United States is really around the way we have changed how we think of food.

So the younger generation, the millennial generation, my children's generation, are really thinking about food in a different way. And that is to not only to sustain themselves, but also to signal their values. So you get these food tribes now happening around the world where people identify with a certain cohort based on what they eat. And so you've got carnivores and vegetarians and vegans and paleos and gluten-free and all these different ways of expressing your food tribe and going deep into whatever the rules of the tribe are.

So you've got that happening on one side. And then on the other side, you've got farmers who are also fracturing. We're seeing a lot of angst between, say, what we think of as conventional farming and, say, regenerative farming or organic farming or biodynamic farming. There's as many different farmer tribes as there are food tribes.

And somehow we have to ameliorate climate in this whole show and also feed populations in other countries that are as lucky as us. So I guess I wanted to just really look at the whole thing and say, how could we re-imagine a farming system that would do what we need it to do? And first, we need to work out what that is we need to do. We obviously need it to feed us.

We obviously need it to look after land. And we don't often think of farmers in that way. We think of them as solely food growers. We might want it to increase biodiversity or turn around the declining biodiversity.

So all of these things come at a cost and it's not covered in the price of food. So we're going to have to have a deeper think about this. Well, as we all know, and you reported on this at the beginning of your career and covered it in the intervening decades, all can keep it open up the economy and it's all been a miracle if you talk to the economists. But changes on that scale, of course, could never be all positive.

The pain that our manufacturing sector went through has been talked about many times already. But what it did to our farmers hasn't really been discussed. So while Australia was moving to a service-based economy, what was really happening to them? What was happening to farmers?

Well, I think there were a lot of protections in place for farmers that came out of Australia's white history of wanting to export as much as we possibly can, initially to the mother country, but then also to create income, export income for Australia. And I think when the reforms started happening really in the late 70s, early 80s, and particularly as you say under the Hawk Keating Government, there was this idea that you just fling open the curtains and pull down the ramparts and you get rid of all the boards and co-ops. And a lot of that was very clunky. A lot of those bureaucracies, there was very small farmers, they were kind of hanging over from Solge Setlable Ox.

They hang over from all this very controlled government regulation. And somewhere in that arc of deregulation from that 80s onwards, we threw out all this excess baggage. But I question now whether we're throwing out too much. Like how do we decide who gets to say control land?

Because one of the trends I see, apart from the fact that the climate is not priced into the price of food right now, the other big trend is this kind of scaling up that really started happening in that reform area, era to bigger and bigger farms. ABS is quite clear that they say the best managers are on large farms. They're sort of 2080 rule, I think, a much bigger proportion than in the 70s is produced income, earned and land controlled by these bigger, larger farmers. And so I think there's room for some thinking around how we want that to happen.

Because I think of the corollary and supermarket sector. So when I was a kid in the 70s, there were lots of different supermarkets and things. Now we've settled into the duopoly. So I think we need to think about this because it's sort of controlling land and having these great tracks of land that Australia has.

We just need to think about it more carefully because it goes to leverage and it goes to questions of power. And I think they're really important in any democracy. So, you know, and we've touched on a little bit of this of how you came to care about this issue and farming. I'd be interested to know because obviously when you started with what was then used limited in 1983, and you worked into the 90s with the Australian and then I know you went overseas for a number of years, and then you returned and worked in the Canberra Press Gallery covering federal politics.

But then of course you met your now husband who you refer to as the farmer, which I love. And moved to this very small town of Hadamaran Bora, you know, population 2000. And coming from someone who'd always lived in metropolitan cities and traveled around the world and had this really big, quite worldly existence. Do you think if you hadn't made that sea change in your life to this really small farming community, you would have had the perspective to write about how these small communities, what a crucial role they play in the much bigger fabric of our society.

Oh, God, no, I don't think so. I don't think so. I think, you know, everyone, perspective is everything, right? So when farming underwrites your life, it becomes very personal.

As any industry does, you know, I'm very, I'm keenly interested in what happens in media and the disruption that's happened in media. And I should actually say that, you know, farming isn't the only industry that has been disrupted over the last couple of decades. There's lots of industries that have been disrupted. We've seen that pretty much the death of the majority of the manufacturing sector, you know, the people that lost jobs out of the car factories, media's been disrupted.

Lots of industries have changed massively. But I guess the difficulty for me for farming is that we see really contradictory messages. So that is, you know, we have to, it's a moral imperative to feed the world. We often hear this from politicians.

We have to grow more because we have to feed the world because we can't let the world start. But at the same time, we're told, you know, food is just like any other product. It's just like the lamp on your desk or the whatever the widget is that you sell or a lipstick. It's just, it's a product that is simply created by the producers.

And, you know, it shouldn't be thought of as any different that producers should stand on their own two feet. And it's like any other business. But we know that food is not that. We know that we can't live without food.

We know that there are certain things in life that humans can't do without. So I think the kind of angst and the contradictions in the sector, it really stemmed from that basic fact that, you know, you have to care about farming because you eat. And as the world moves on climate change and changes its own regulations, its trade agreements, its tariffs around things like carbon emissions. We have no choice but to think about how we want to manage this massive landscape with these very ancient soils.

And who's going to be on that land? Who's going to be taking care of it? And it's a really important conversation to include the indigenous custodians and indigenous farmers, indigenous rangers. Like they're doing a massive job in parts of Australia that are difficult.

And so that sort of conversation about how the economics covers that sort of really important job, I think, has to be thought of. Now I will give the government a tick in that they recently pushed out the medium term funding for indigenous ranger programs. And I think that's a big step forward because these things are natural systems. You can't turn them around.

But you know, and farms are similar. You know, often here's a remember back to SBC days, you know, and when the first iteration of the Murray Darling Basin plan came out, they said, oh, citrus isn't paying. So you know, you've got to go into dairy. I think it was at the time.

So people started ripping out citrus trees. And you know, there was this conversation as if you, well, you pivot from citrus to dairy and then you might pivot back. But like those trees take years and years and years to grow. It's like turning the Titanic in some of these fun natural systems.

So you know, we have to be aware of that and think more long term about these sorts of policy issues. You're listening to Fourth Estate on the Community Radio Network. And my guest is Gabrielle Chan. Let's turn out some climate change, which you've just mentioned.

We have a perfect storm coming towards the farming sector. So as you know, we've spoken about it as the increased demand. Let's assume we will need to eat in the future, right? And increased pressure on production.

So the problem is all the political discussion in Australia. So far has been about how our electricity is made or we will be forced to buy electric cars. You know, we barely started talking about how we're going to feed ourselves. Can you unpack just some of the problems we're going to be facing soon?

Bear in mind, Australia produces more than exports, more than half of what we produce. So we do punch above our weight in terms of what we grow food. That's also fiber as well, I should add. So it's not as big as some people might suggest, but we do produce a lot of food.

But the thing is we're part of an interdependent global supply chain. So if we grow the wheat on the farm and the wheat goes to Indonesia to be made into noodles and then comes back to Australia to the supermarket shelf, is that an Australian product or is that an Indonesian product? So some of the interdependencies have to be recognised. The other thing I think that we missed and we have this debate for a short, sharp time at the beginning of the pandemic when the supermarket shelf's cleared.

And that was the government reassuring people that we produce a lot of food. There's no need to hoard. And I get that imperative that they had to calm the population down because we all temporarily lost our ship together. But it negates to mention there are lots of dependencies in the farming sector that require imports, like most of our fuel is imported.

All of the widgets in our shed pretty much the header, the tractors, all of that stuff comes in from overseas. A lot of the parts that we require, there's lots of interdependencies, not only in the farming system, but when you get to the food retail end, you know, they say the tetrapact that the milk goes in. I mean, I might produce a lot of milk. I don't actually produce milk, but say I produce a lot of milk.

I can't get it to you, Tina, in your city apartment because we don't produce a tetrapact. So I think we have to have a bit more of a sophisticated debate. And those sorts of products like the tetrapact or the canned for the tuna, you know, 20, 30 years ago, we just said, well, manufacturing is now thing, you know, comparative advantage says we should be just producing what we do really well and really cheaply and we should just outsource the rest to the rest of the world. Well, some things, as we've discovered in the pandemic, don't work like that.

So remember at the beginning of the pandemic where we had the shortage of hand sanitizer and masks and PPE? Well, that was because we let that manufacturing sector go in those products. And there's not easy answers in the sense that how does a government intervene for a particular thing, you know, down the track? Will we sometime in the next 30 years need PPE?

Like no one, you know, it would have been hard to answer that question in terms of intervening in a specific industry, but surely we're bright enough to have a deep think about, okay, so what are the big sectors that we really need to cover our back sides with? What are the things that we should have a measure of independence on and then go from there? You know, there are lots of smart reports, lots of things that have been written that are just languishing in bottom drawers and we don't implement the recommendations. We've had 43 or so reports into the Murray-Darling Basin and managing that massive water resource that is so important to both our food production and people's lives and animals' lives, environmental condition.

But we just don't put it together and follow through. The political processes has this kind of, I don't know, charts at the last minute after the reports have been written, after the recommendations have been unveiled, it sort of goes into this black hole of silence. May production is also key discussion here, but also it provokes an instant culture war about identity and that's before we even start about our growing export markets. What do you think needs to change them?

Well, we have to think about the trade-offs, right? So right now there's a discussion about farming systems and I think most people would have seen the increasing number of articles about regenerative agriculture and while the definition is different in different people's eyes, I think there is a growing recognition that animals as part of a mixed farming system are quite handy because they produce poo and poo and proper stock management can sometimes help increase carbon levels, but of course they also, animals also produce methane. So there's big debates happening in the farming sector about what the trade-offs are and I think some of the evidence that's coming out now is that straight cropping on cropping every year means that you are mining some of the good stuff in your soil unless you're putting it back. So can we have a debate about meat that extends into what the trade-offs are in a farming system?

Usually we can't, it's just like if you, the stereotypical responses are well, climate's changing, therefore you've got to cut out or meet out of your diet. I mean, there is an argument for quality meat over just scale, but all of these things are currently being thought about by scientists as well as economists and I think we've got to get some of the nuance of those trade-offs in a land management system across to the public and that's what I'm hoping the book will do. Political class and policy makers aren't really out of the starting blocks only at this are they? There's a few sort of nascent programs that give me heart.

So David Littleproud is working on a biodiversity scheme as currently in a pilot form where they're trying to work out a system to verify increases in biodiversity so that farmers may end up getting some sort of payment either from a private market or the taxpayer in return for increases in environmental condition, whether it's habitat or tree coverage or, and that already happens in some of the emissions reduction schemes. But there's all these kind of sporadic hot spotter programs that don't connect it together and I think the interesting thing will be how we can connect those systems together because we're already seeing them happening overseas. The United Kingdom is already thinking about how they're going to sashay, well they've already sashayed out of the EU, the European Union, and they're going to change, the UK is going to change their production subsidies for agriculture towards a model that rewards environmental services. So, you know, some water quality or ground cover or tree planting or hedgerows.

And that sort of thing is happening around the world as governments work out, you know, the economic signals that they want to send have to be in line with their national goals and the big national goal of obviously leading up to the next climate talks is around how to ameliorate climate change. And you cannot leave the farm sector out of that debate. It's a really important one and it's a debate that every country is having right now. I think it'll be very interesting to see what comes of the next conference in Glasgow.

From writing this book, do you get a feel for how identity plates might possibly look in the future? Yeah, I do. I think possibly we will see a decline in where already seeing a decline in net consumption in western countries, but that doesn't really tell the story of net prices have gone through the roof because there is global demand for me. So as those economies change, you know, we're going to see changes in what consumers want to eat.

I am hoping that there will be a better short, medium and long supply chain resilience and diversity. I think what was interesting for me out of the start of the pandemic when the shelves emptied was the run on little producers in my area. You know, you couldn't get flour in your local supermarket. And so the artisan wheat producer down the road that might be selling, you know, different varieties of flour or organic flour, they were run over and that happened.

I talked to Small World Bakery down in South Australia. They had the same thing happen. They got all these customers, new customers coming in saying, actually, I'll be honest, I want to buy it locally now because I can't get it from my big duopoly supermarket. So I'm hoping there will be more resilience and diversity in those supply chains.

And from the farmer end, I think the future farmer will be someone who not only produces food and or fibre, but also has a market for environmental services in order to turn around some of the verifiable measures in their ecosystem. And they will be selling those services to either a private sector market like a big global company that wants to offset their emissions or whether it be part of a government program. I think that's yet to settle. But I think there's a lot of energy in the sector.

Often in this kind of current environment, there's a lot of angst and a lot of anxiety given that the massive changes that we're seeing to economies to in the pandemic and to, you know, global trade disruptions and climate change and all these things. But it doesn't really reflect the energy, particularly amongst younger food producers that I see that is really kind of positive and trying to work out where the opportunities are going to come. And the farming sector has been quite nimble in some parts of it. And I think that will continue.

As ill equipped as us consumers are to understand and navigate the coming debates about the nature of our farms, journalists in the same token are they're also not really ready to have that discussion either. What's your message, your quick primer to both the general public but also to journalists? Well, to go beyond the kind of cartoonish stereotype of how the debate happens, which is mostly, we have a debate, media debate on one side that is only about agriculture and debate on the other side about environment as if the two, as if farming isn't nested in environment. And just thinking more deeply, the need to think more deeply about, you know, the true cost of food.

So not accepting the kind of economic paradigms that we've grown up with, certainly I have, I'm mid-fifties now. This reforms have been happening since the 80s. What we're seeing is governments having to reimagine economies. Who would have ever thought that the current federal government, the people that bought you the debt and deficit disaster would owe this much money.

Like we are reinventing systems as they happen and to try to think more broadly and deeply that you know, you don't accept some of these things, you ask the questions and that's what I was trying to do with the book. Like I'm not an economist, but I'm just asking questions. Like how is this going to work for food? Like if the board is shut down, how is this going to work?

If China turns off, you know, puts a 70% tariff or whatever it was on on Bali, how is this going to work? And I think that's what media needs that questioning and not to accept the status quo and not to kind of live wholly within the realms of power brokers, but get out into the landscape and talk to communities and see how it's affecting them. Your last book, Rust Enough, My Country, Australia is fed up. So are you really looking at the main street of your own rural community that you yourself live in and give voice to those, you know, to your residents that didn't really have a lobby group in Canberra?

What are the sort of discussions that you're having with people within your own community, within the farming community? Did they feel properly represented the issues that they're forcing? Did they feel that they're being properly represented by the media? I think there's great frustration with the media as it sort of falls into the tribes that I talked about in food and farming.

And there is a real hunger also for new sources of information. But as well, there is a kind of weariness. And I guess the conversations that I have is to try and convince people to remain engaged with the political debate and the media debate, because it's when people step outside of that, I think that, you know, you lower the gene pool and they're looking and remaining in these kind of conversations and diversity, economic diversity, cultural diversity, they're the sorts of things we need if we're going to push through to the other side, whatever the other side of normalness. And you know, it's happening that people do think deeply and more deeply than you think in little towns like mine.

But I just would urge everyone to remain engaged because as much as a drive-through up a wall and make sure you have televisions, it's really important that we're involved because that's what a democracy is. Of course, can't let you go without asking about Sky Rural and its expansion to free to add television in regional areas. Are you noticing a shift in conversation within your own community? How do you view it?

I view it with, I guess, I'm watching it to see whether it changes the political debate, particularly the after-to-sky after-dark. I can often get Sky on my television reception more easily than I can get the ABC sometimes, you know, depending on the weather. And I think for people who probably don't have the streaming platforms, either have the connectivity or the capacity for technology to get that massive range of streaming platforms that is now available to us. I think it has the capacity, and Shoddy Media has the capacity to change the debate a lot.

And so I'll be watching, I guess, to see how that rolls out in the main street. I mean, there is also a bit of diversity. Like I've just been appointed a role in regional leadership with the Guardian, and even though the Guardian started here in the Australian version in 2012 from the UK, Guardian, you know, I think there is a lot of people who feel that rural and regional media is really important. We lost at the beginning of our pandemic, hardened my local town, the local paper, one of the local papers moved back and is now in a digital for version only, and that has implications, particularly for older populations who really want that hard copy.

But the media landscape is changing massively, and we don't really know how that's going to play out, but it's worth watching. And I think you'll see new players start up, not just, you know, I call Sky a new player in the regional sense because you can get it for free now, and you used to have to pay for it. But there will be other new players that are rolling out, and I'm hoping that the diversity remains because, as Rupert Murdoch said, on the four corners last week, he abours a monopoly. I don't know if you're saying that, Tony, she was a monopoly.

So I would say the same thing for rural Australia. We can't have one or two new sources. We have to be able to see local, regional and national news in our towns and regions. And I think diversity is more important than ever, and any control by any outlet, I think, can be a dangerous thing.

Maybe he meant that he abours any other monopoly, besides design. Possibly. Possibly. I do before at the television, but...

Oh, don't worry. I think it was the forehead around the country. Finally, climate change is a topic that one can very quickly find themselves bogged down and depressed in. Do you see a positive way forward for our farms and our farmers?

Yeah. I was talking before about the kind of energy in the sector when you go to rural workshops or field days in farming, and increasingly, like the flavour of the day, soil has always been important, but I've noticed more soil workshops rolling out often from private organisations. But the only generation of farming is really keen and excited about possibilities and you know, you're seeing people changing, moving... The example often used is Brown Brothers, who moved, bought a winery down in Tazzy to, I guess, prepare for changes that were coming to their Victorian operations as the...

Where that moved south for them. So, you know, there are silver linings. You just have to... I think that you just have to be really attentive to the changes.

And I think that... I guess what's disappointed me most about the political debate, particularly amongst the majority of rural and regional representation, is not describing that story of climate change honestly and accurately. And you know, if we can't expect leaders to describe that, and there are notable standouts, but if we can't expect leaders to describe that, honestly and accurately, then it makes it really hard for communities to prepare. And I guess the thing that came out of Rustadoff was that I discovered that a lot of communities are ahead of leadership in parliament.

And that's happening, but I still don't think that should let rural representatives off Scott Free. They do have to have an important role to play, and I hope they see their way clear to do that. Gabrielle Chan, thank you so much for joining us in Fourth Estate. Thanks, Tina.

Pleasure. And thank you for listening to Fourth Estate. This edition was recorded at the studios of Tuezia and heard across the country on the community radio network. Fourth Estate is produced with the assistance of the Community Broadcasting Foundation.

A big thanks to the foundation for their continuing support. Make sure you subscribe to Fourth Estate on your favourite podcast app, so you can hear us talk media, politics and a lot in between. We'll be back with more next week, of course, but in the meantime, you can stay in touch with us on Twitter. Our handle is Fourth Estate AU.

A big thanks as always to my executive producer, Anthony Dockrell. My name's Tina Quinn. Please do stay well and stay safe and catch us next week on Fourth Estate.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Fourth Estate?

This episode is 38 minutes long.

When was this Fourth Estate episode published?

This episode was published on September 2, 2021.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Fourth Estate episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.