Skip to content
In Conversation With Laura Tingle episode artwork

Jun 10, 2021 48 min

In Conversation With Laura Tingle

from Fourth Estate Hosted by 2SER

In this edition we have a special chat with Laura Tingle about the ABC, that Australian editorial and the state of the political debate. Your host Tina Quinn.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

In Conversation With Laura Tingle

0:00 48:14
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Whether life serves you an ace or an unexpected backhand the high protein yogurt Oico's pro is there to feed your strength and help You turn every challenge into a smash Oico's pro helps build strong muscles and support muscle recovery with high protein and contains no added sugar Because true strength isn't about being able to take the hits. It's about being able to bounce back Oico's pro feed your strength Visit Oico's.ca for more details Hello and welcome back to Fourth Estate the show where journalists talk journalism Coming to you from Tuezia in Sydney on Gadigalands of the ER nation right across Australia on the community radio network and directly to your device across the globe via Podcast I'm Tina Quinn. It's good to have you company in this special edition of Fourth Estate We were joined in studio by one of Australia's most respected journalists Laura Tingle Laura's four decades in media began at Fairfax's the Australian financial review in 1981 and has included Longstance at Rupert Murdoch's the Australian as well as the Sydney Morning Herald and the age She's now best known to audiences as 730's chief political correspondent on the ABC the author of four quarterly essays her latest the high road What Australia can learn from New Zealand was published by Black Inc late last year our discussion was fairly wide ranging We talked about the plight of journalists navigating social media how Australia's for the status going at keeping the government to account and where the public Broadcasters should be held to a higher standard than their counterparts in the private sector first So we began by discussing this week's editorial in the Australian Which took aim at both Sally neighbor the executive producer of ABC's four corners and Louise Milligan the program star investigative journalist The most dangerous enemy of the journalist is bad lazy deceitful journalism set the odds that piece of wisdom is a sentiment that many Journalists would no doubt agree with although many disagreed with its target I asked Laura about the Oz's piece as well as her thoughts on the overall editorial direction that the paper and its own A news corp is now taking Laura Tingle welcome to Fourth Estate. Thanks, Tina So being a journalist at the ABC it normally means you have to have a pretty fix into survive So I'd be interested in getting your thoughts on the editorial in Tuesday's edition of the Australian Was it just more of the rough and tumble or are we seeing something a bit darker here?

Do you think it's certainly escalating? I don't know about the editorial in the Australian particular But I mean you look at the coverage day to day and everybody at the Australian is taking turns to have a shot and most of its pretty tedious and basically fairly breathtaking given the position of news limited in Australia But it's it is what it is and it's not gonna stop so you just got to get on with it But did you not think this this week's editorial in the Oz on Louise Milligan and Sally neighbor was particularly grubby? I mean there wasn't even a byline attribution to the piece It was basically the Oz putting out this editorial and saying this is our stance This is the Australian stance on the ABC and these two women I mean Sally neighbor and Louise Milligan seem to be the favorite focus for the Oz when it comes to attacking the ABC They sort of hit for those two women. It seems, you know, especially in recent weeks quite relentless Well, it is relentless and it goes right back to the beginning of the Canberra bubble story and And without doubt the Australian has been sort of campaigning on this for the whole period to personalize it the way they have While at the same time which I find a bit gobsmacking that they are setting up these stories where sort of four corners is at war with the ABC management who The Australian loves to hate almost as much or possibly more and so this is a bit of a tone of a well, you know They're standing up for something and I mean Whatever angle you want to take on the ABC and Sally neighbor and Louise Milligan if you're at the Australian is fine It's all fair game and I just find it perplexing that they have nothing better to do than I mean they must have four or five people whose main job these days is to just attack the ABC and Seriously, the ABC has lots of flaws It should be held up for scrutiny all those things But I mean we heard in estimates the other day that somebody in the government is monitoring what people like on the Twitter or something I don't know and Twitter.

Yeah, and I mean it's the same sort of thing. It's just got really ridiculous Hmm. Maybe that's a job title at the moment going sort of the ABC writer at the Oz or the ABC critic at the Oz You know, there's plenty of people filling the job. Yeah, yeah, so and even even columnists who aren't usually in the fray I mean, I know this Robert Gottliebson was writing something about the ABC, you know It's just it's just got quite frenzied Well the political heat around the ABC and the government has really been as hot as it is right now with Chris reporting I'm pulling out of the defamation case and a settlement done and dusted is there a chance to think for a reset or is this sort of the new normal?

Do you think what are we trying to reset here? I mean you don't want to be I mean I'm not ABC management, but in terms of news and journalism. We're not here to be friends of the government all the opposition of the day Whoever that is it's like when people say you know, you don't seem to like the prime minister or the opposition later or whatever You go, well, that's not my job And so you know if they are if they are going to continue this there's not much the ABC can do about it and other than you know try to be you know professional and do journalism and I Don't know that it will be reset. You know, they the government is full of ideological warriors There are a lot of people involved in this who are desperate to make a name for themselves and to suck up to the prime minister So you know one of the ways you can do that at the moment is yelling at the ABC very loudly and making a name for yourself there I mean, it's quite transparent to me that that's what's going on and if that's the best they can do, you know, good luck with the job prospects You know, it's not a great people have made their names on much sort of smaller things I think that Ron would be shipping the tax commissioner back in the 80s You know, it's a good platform to get noticed, but is it particularly edifying for the people involved?

I don't think so I notice how you know, you mentioned that you know, you don't seem to like the prime You know that criticism of all you don't seem to like the prime minister. Well, it's not my job to do so I mean Lee sales for instance, so you know very close colleague of yours It seems to be getting it from both sides at the moment, which I think is proof that she's actually doing her job You know, it's either that her and the ABC in a war against the coalition or you've got the left who if Anthony Albenese is on the program And she really you know gives him the hard questions Oh, well, you're just you're sucking up to the PM. You know, you know, you're so anti like, you know And it's not her job to really cozy up to either of those two people. No, it's I mean it's sort of hilarious sometimes I mean I get it as well that she cops and absolutely outrageous quantity of stuff But you know often you'll get you know one tweet saying, you know, Ellen P.

Stuge You know and the other one will be saying, you know, Labor Stuge and you know, it'll be about exactly the same piece of information So like Twitter does Twitter isn't good, but it is out there and I mean people's sort of lack of understanding of you know What journalist's job is sometimes and they're one-eyedness, you know I mean people are entitled to their views But they are so one-eyed and they see a sort of conspiracy or a strategy or a prejudice in something You know, they attribute these sort of evil evil Intense to what journalists do and you know that the ABC's been bought off by you know, it's idle There's a new limit of people that's gone to the dogs and all that sort of stuff It's just terrible and I think the way she's been treated isn't really just abominable I mean, okay, you can sort of not agree with something that somebody has done But the sort of vitriol that is dished out to lead from both sides is just gobsmacking and he just it's just like Haven't you got lives? I mean shouldn't you be sort of thinking about the underlying issues are here rather than just talking about the journos? I mean seriously, I mean, I think that culture has sort of come up because of the way the media has become Splinted by the way news limited campaigns so aggressively now Around the world and so it sort of left everybody else open to it, but seriously What do they think is going to be achieved here? No, it's just madness.

Well, it's funny So poppers don't seem to be that popular these days anymore, but I feel like we created yeah I own so that's quite right. I think in reality. Yeah, absolutely Well, let's turn to social media again The ABC is in the firing line you mentioned Senate estimates this week the managing director Has been in Senate estimates this week and it's been drilled on the social media likes of some of its high profile journalists and personalities Do you think it's a bit much for the MPs to be obsessing about what you know the ABC peeps are saying and liking on social media or is Do you think this is an important part of being seen to be impartial? Well, I think it's it's been changing, you know, you know When I joined Twitter, I think I don't know 10 years ago.

It was sort of quite jolly and good fun and you know But it's just become I mean I more or less day off Twitter now, you know, I'll tweet a column. I'll tweet You know sort of David wrote cartoons because I think he's a good cartoonist. I'll tweet articles that I think are interesting But I don't interact with it anymore because it's just an absolute hiding to nothing and of course I've got into trouble for a couple of my tweets anyway They may have been all judged, but I I just think Monitoring what people are liking when there are satirical websites. I mean, I just think that it's just got bonkers, you know I mean, yes I mean my view of tweeting now is you know, you don't want to do anything that brings the ABC into dispute And there was one notable one I tweeted which I you know in anger about what's happening to my colleagues And that wasn't not a good thing because apart from the else it reflected badly on ABC But I just think when you're starting to sort of basically say you're not allowed to like, you know, a funny joke on Twitter I mean, this is supposed to be the liberal party.

This is supposed to be the party of free speech and individual rights Give me a break. Well, I mean, I was gonna ask about that I mean it must work you that you know, people that are often crying most loudly about the ABC and what it's journalists are getting up to on social media Are also often the ones pushing for freedom of speech rights I mean, can you can you be supporting Craig Kelly's right to post one minute conspiracy theories and things that completely go against Public health advice science, but then attacking ABC journal is a next because they like something from the chaser. Mm. Yeah.

Well, I'd say no, but Revolution Again, oh, yeah, no, I won't. No, the ABC does not I mean, I'm Getting into trouble suggests I've got into some terrible journal I've been reminded of my obligations under the social media policy and you know, and I feel I've got to stick with them Do you think though that as the ABC, you know, it's it's a public broadcaster. It's a publicly funded institution Do you think that ABC journalists deserve to be held to a higher standard of account than saying they counterparts within the private sector of the media? Well, having spent 40 years of my career in print in private sector including 10 years of news a little I can say that ABC journalists are held to a higher standard and much higher standard You know, the number of people who have to clear what I do here is so much higher than it was You know in sort of more recent years of print where they've lost editors and sub editors and all that sort of stuff We are held to a higher standard if there's a complaint to the ABC.

It's officially followed up There's an inquiry, you know, all those things. It's it's much more accountable than private sector media organizations. It should it be? Yes, of course Taxpayers money.

Mm-hmm. Let's change tack a little on the topic of social media should ABC employees even be on there It's a charge space and one often, you know, quite free of any nuance or balance It's more often than not deeply partisan and also just quite a misogynistic playground for trolls Why be there if if ABC employees deserted these platforms? Do you think it would be such a bad thing? Well, it depends what deserting it means, you know, do you uh, I mean, should you not be saying anything about anything?

Should you be not expressing an opinion on social media is the issue here? I think I mean, should I not be? You know telling people who follow me on twitter that my columns here and they can find it here Or that you know, there's a story is broken, you know, because a lot of people rely on twitter for their news and they might not actually follow you know, ABC News tweets, but they might follow me and You know, so does it become a question that by Highlighting some stories and not other stories. I'm, you know, showing my bias Or is it just that I happen to remember to tweet that one?

There's a bit more of my haphazard approach. Uh, should we be there commenting their own voices? I think it's now increasingly difficult to do that as I said, I'm not really on twitter very much anymore Um, but you know, the really big dilemmas I have with twitter now that sometimes I'll open it up every couple of days And there'll be some thread going on that my name's sort of somehow got involved in and I literally have no idea what they're talking about I'm up on Twitter and saying Laura Tingle is trending. Yeah, and um, I don't know what it's about And it's often somebody's just linked me in that some said or look at this Laura Tingle or something But sometimes there's some discussion going on where somebody is claiming that you have said something Which just isn't true.

Um, and I mean one of them was that uh, I had a joke with Lee sales at the beginning of 2019 There was an opinion poll out and she said something like you know, Laura Have you ever seen a government cut with such bad poll numbers come back in an election and I said no And I'd still say that because no, I hadn't and but you know, we both laughed because you know, you don't give one one word answers But this was subsequently taken up as and represented as something that I said on the eve of the federal election And you know, and it's part of this narrative. That's particularly run by jared hinderson Which once again, I only find out about from other people but um that you know that I predicted quote You know that label was going to win and all the stuff when you look at what the quote is what I actually said was most people seem to think labors going Which was true including cabinet ministers Um, and uh, the coalition were very surprised that they wanted The coalition was very surprised at one other than about two or three people in the last day And so I was I wasn't expressing a view. I was saying what I was reporting that most people in politics Anyway, so I've got off the track here, but you know, it is it is tricky and I think Some people are just getting off it anyway because it's not good for their mental health Others are sort of taking it a fine stance of saying why shouldn't I be on it? Why shouldn't I be allowed to be on it?

Am I going to actually be bullied off it by the trolls? Do you think just on mental health grounds? It's getting harder to justify the need and the importance of being on social media. Yeah, yeah I mean, I can't see that um, you know, it's that substantial and need to be on twitter Basically, I said don't do it.

I don't do facebook Um, I was encouraged when I saw the financial review that one stage they sort of went through this big frenzy Oh, you should all be on, you know facebook linked in twitter blah blah, um, and so I sort of set up pages and stuff but the abuse there is actually worse Because it's not limited to 240 characters. So I put up pictures of my cat on instagram now and that's about it I don't really get into the social media stuff too much. Mm. You mentioned that you've had a 40 year career in media You started at the AFR the Australian financial review in 1981.

Was it? Yeah, and 10 years you did it news limited And that was with the Australian Tell us a bit about news limited in those days and what how is it for you to now to now see what's happening with the Oz And the daily telegraph and the daily telegraph was always quite tabloidy and but the Oz was held up as a much, you know Great beacon of journalism. Yeah. Well, it if we're really going back with it, there'd have been the great Juno strike of 1980 just before I joined the effects and that created a lot of bitterness in the ranks But there was always a view which looked like it from outside and which was the case on the inside Which was that the Australian always had a bit of a chip on its shoulder that people didn't take it seriously post The dismissal which was the first time.

Um, my rock was sort of seem to be really activist. Um, yeah in politics and uh, so The sort of view of the Australian tended to be that you know that people at the herald the age would ever all of it stuck up and they thought they were great and No, all that stuff, but it was and it still had a conservative agenda that it was more a conservative economic agenda rather than a social agenda Uh similar to the political parties at the time really if you look at the little party under Malcolm Fraser Yeah, you know it was economically quite conservative, but socially not as much Yeah, um and but this is the 80s that I was there and the 90s so label was in power And everybody was talking about you know economic reform in those days But um, you know, there were sort of these patches of even more radical reform from from the coalition under John Howard at one stage as opposition leader and then john houston was fight back So it was it was a conservative agenda, but it was it was not sort of this feral, you know obsessive pursuit of people and at issues as it's become and it was regarded as a paper of record and That was something that was very important to us I think I mean I suppose that in some ways is a reflection of the changing times would the Australian that I worked for exist in the current day and I think the answer to that is no because In that time for example, you know, there wasn't the internet until quite right towards the end of my time at the uh the Australian So you would be reporting stuff that people would be seeing for the first time you know at the budget Or you know some fascinating productivity commission speech or reporter or speech by a minister Or something the prime minister of the day had said as news That you would be reading for the first time and you'd be running it as a very straight story about this is what happened Now because of the nature of the news cycle changing You know the working presumption on all news discs is that everybody sort of knows the basics now so you always try to push the story forward So, you know, you probably wouldn't exist in that sense, but it is it is still extraordinary to sort of see what it's become But I look at it in in the context of News around as a news called around the world. Um, and what's happening with fox news and and what's happening in the uk Just part of part of a picture in a recent quarterly essay you wrote the high road You eloquently spoke of about leadership and what australia could learn from New Zealand Australian and New Zealanders share many similarities, but in many ways we're moving in quite different directions Yes, we you know, we drive on the same side of the road and have the union jack on our flag But in many ways, you know, whereas different as violet crumbles and pineapple chunks Why the differences and what do you think we could learn from our key wick cousins? Well, the title was sort of half ironic because I think there are things we can learn from New Zealand But there are also things that I was saying Here are some lessons we sort of we just avoided I think the things we can learn from them is that we all get stuck in our own boxes of thinking that there is only one way Things can happen and New Zealand is so similar, but the debates, you know It's just like a bit of an altered state in a parallel universe in the way they conduct their politics Uh, and you look at why that is now.

I think there's a whole range of reasons It is a small place everybody in New Zealand knows everybody has found it Um, and it doesn't have states Uh, but you know that and when they moved to the mmp system of electing people Just one of those things mixed member proportion Freudian senior moment thing where whenever I say mmpa, I mean it's the answer But anyway, it's the same system as Germany, right and the ACT more or less Uh, but what it's meant is that it's almost impossible for the major parties to form the government in their own right So they have to negotiate they have to form coalitions And that just completely changes the nature of the political discussion So it encourages a lot more compromise and discussion and yes and and that went on Yeah, I think um all of those things and Everybody here poo poo when it happened because I said this will be the end of reform that no big reforms will happen Which I think is a really terrible misunderstanding of why they went to mmp it was because New Zealand took this you know that the high road, you know approach of you know, really uber radical reform Right through the 80s and 90s and the electorate just went whoa, no Um or bro or something they they just said, you know, you've burnt us here You didn't tell us you were going to do this and both sides did it So it was actually a reflection of the fact that New Zealand had gone too far on reforms And how do you judge that? Well one the public wasn't up to it But two a lot of the reforms just caused such havoc and didn't reap the rewards that I was supposed to reap And you know communities were literally destroyed overnight as a result and you know, New Zealand is still paying the price for that as is New Zealand politics New Zealand is currently operating on the high road and we're not Why do you think that is besides some of the you know, the points that you've just made is it because Do you think what they're doing socially also has plays into that? You know, they have a treaty with their indigenous people for instance or is it that you know, you mentioned what news what's happened with news Corp, not just here but in the uk in the u.s Do you think that because their media is not a shouty? Not as you know, and it doesn't have any major ownership from news Corp.

Do you think that plays into it? I mean, it can't just be the pineapple chunks. Yeah, no, I think you know, the structural reasons, you know, certainly the way The parliament is now made up but without a doubt the fact that our mood ock isn't there does change it I mean, there are some shock jocks in New Zealand But I mean, it's quite an interesting place because all the major cities have their own newspapers You know, there's much more diversity of newspapers there So it's not just like there's no national newspaper I think I quote Helen Clark in the USA sort of saying when she went to an airport lounge in cesis, Australia and she just laughs Because the Australian has become this, you know, unifying vehicle for and even when I was there, you know The power of the Australian wasn't because we necessarily broke the best stories or whatever. No, we did break stories But our power was that in a newsroom in Bunbury or Cairns or whatever The news director who knew that they had to sort of cover the national news the only thing that they saw was the Australian So that was its voice there in New Zealand.

You've got this diversity, you know, the New Zealand Herald, the Dominion The news all those other newspapers and they're very different So instead of New Zealand at owning, you know, all of the tabloids right around the country and being the only organization in town That does make it different. So that's big And if you look at something like the Treaty of Waitangi Tribunal and the way they've gone with the relationships First Nations people versus us that that was sort of this moment in time, which we could have had as well But politics is so different and I quoted Jim Bulger who was a conservative Prime Minister at the National, National, what's it called and he was asked well, why did you do this? You know because it was a matter of contention within his own party and he said well because it was the you know It's New Zealand's honor was at stake and I don't know that you but can you just imagine anybody in Australia saying that? I mean it is different it was you know It was about the country in the crown, the Treaty of Waitangi, but and it is more complicated in Australia and all those things But it was a moment of leadership and it was in the 90s and and it was done and everybody now thinks it was a great idea But it was not without immense controversy at the time or subsequently so but now you see Maori really integrated into New Zealand's cultural life and into its identity in a really fabulous way Look, I think many would agree that it's it's really such a missed opportunity for us here Moving on a little bit.

You've been covering the political bank now for four decades Many people are now of the view that our politics is at an all-time low So do you think that do you think that as well or are we suffering from a short-term memory or even sort of rose-tinted version of the past really? I mean for instance the sports routes effect during the Keating government was a pretty unadifying and ridiculous spectacle if you really look back at it I think it's really all that different do you think or well? I think they're different in a few ways one of them is that you know, there are always sports routes or slash funds I mean they're going back into eternity. They're just one of those things of politics I think they've become more blatant and much larger But I suppose I always tend to things look at things in a structural or systemic way and you go Well, are we getting better policy outcomes?

People actually interested in policy outcomes There's always politics involved in any decision that's made but I reckon it's now 80 or 90 politics and 10% policy whereas in the Hawke and Keating years which is when I was just I came in the tail end of the Fraser government So I don't know that much about it, but the arguments were about policy And the arguments were about pros and cons of policy First in the politics second and I think you know, we're now in a position where it's basically all political operatives in Parliament House You know, there are very few matters of principle that are ever really discussed the politics comes first And I'm not saying that's just about the coalition either really I think both parties have lost their way about who they are which is partly because of changing times and changing social structures So they're flailing around trying to find points of difference And I think also you can't underestimate it sounds a bit dull But once the reform agenda had sort of been sort of more or less completed on the economic side as it then was Politicians were sort of going, oh, actually, it's not we don't have any levers to pull, you know So they started in the Howard era getting into areas which are traditionally state areas, you know Health education to a much greater extent than they previously had infrastructure That sort of downgraded the apparent role of the states And it also meant the sort of scope for boondoggling if you like was much greater because you know You could go around and announce a new hospital or whatever during election campaign stuff that states used to do So I think on all of those counts, it's structurally changed and none of it is for the better There is a budget seem to really show a problem with the media coverage a huge budget deficit, basically But no plan for way to growth or climate change or really the future was really future looking in any way So in short, it was an eye-wateringly expensive document But completely stuck in the short-term news and electoral cycle. It seemed really geared towards short-term pleasure The media didn't really seem to know what to do with the budget. Was it good news or was it a waste opportunity? Do you think?

Well, I think it was a wasted opportunity Having said that my sort of lack of confidence in the government making really good decisions about where you're just trying spending met I think like a lot of people I was a bit torn about it I mean, I don't think they can cut back spending at this stage All that much I think we're sort of in this hiatus where having listened to this sort of diatribe about debt and deficits for so long The entire political sort of structure doesn't exactly know where it's going to land next You know, what's what should be the formula for what you're looking for? That's sort of let the government off a hook a bit more than it should have and I think as you say They're all these areas overall there wasn't a lot of things that you mean for example the aged care package Which was obviously a really big spend of course That much money possibly more on aged care because they haven't spent it in the last 10 years and you know They just we have to catch up But I mean that to me is an interesting I'm sort of going diverting from a moment The fact that they actually ended up saying look we couldn't put any more money into it Because we're physically incapable of finding the people and resources to staff a massive expansion in aged care is a fairly terrible indictment of the last 10 years I think so, you know, I wouldn't Want them to have not sort of committed to spending that money in aged care But things like climate change and and and wages. I mean, this is very old fashioned of me But I suppose my view is you know, we've got to this point where everybody's saying well monetary policy is rich the end of its limits Fiscal policy will just be ourselves stupid and you know, there's not much more we can do there If you actually think that you know the underlying structural problem in the in the economy is low inflation and low wages growth I think there's got to be a questioning of both sides But well, what are you going to do about it? You know at some point in the same way they had to address dead deficits They're going to have to say we're going to actually have to take a more assertive position on doing something about low wages Whether that's intervening in national wages cases or you know doing a bit more than they're already doing on aged care wages And the idea that the government might actually promote support Encourage higher wages growth.

I mean I asked both sides about this and they just look at you blankly and go Oh, well, you know much a matter much a matter to me. It's sort of a little bit obvious You know that that's where it's going to have to go But anyway, that's just me when we last spoke You said that you felt that it was you felt the current government's approach when it came to the economy and And how it played you know fiscal policy to the masses was very much that of an undergraduate university club view of commies and capitalists, you know, it's fairly quaint, but it doesn't show much sophistication when it comes to the actual issues Do you still believe that? I think that we're at one of those tipping points you come to every few decades in economics where whether it was sort of post-written woods When it was a rise of monetarism in the 70s and 80s where the fashion of the day no longer fits And without a doubt that is happening, you know people are rethinking stuff around the world, you know the IMF the OECD You know that they're rethinking all of those sort of rules about you know what was good and what wasn't good You know, they're no longer appropriate in this in this particular era Either because of the impacts of the pandemic or because of the shift in sort of economic power to China Whatever it is, you know, they're gonna have to rethink the way they approach setting economic policy and we are nowhere near having that discussion in Australia Absolutely nowhere near it and it has to be one where you you know you try to work out what you want to do And then you have to persuade people about it and we're having a discussion that's sort of like five years ago Whereas I'm concerned so I don't know that there's anybody on either side who's really in that space yet In many ways this term of the Morrison government the third term of the coalition government is the most crisis-driven and scandal-planked government Very some memory from you know, Morrison's holiday to Hawaii during the bushfires to rots around grants to vaccine rollouts and the mess our hk sector Brittany Higgins as you just mentioned There's there's no national program for quarantine facilities at the moment There's been no shortage of material for journalists to cover but still the PM and the government are doing very well in the polls Does this show the lack of impact the media now has because people are Are the largely disengaged or do you think the pandemic's rewriting the script because it's all feeling very teflan at the moment No matter what this government does. Well, the polls have actually we've also got looking at polls because you know It's a bit embarrassing.

I'm the US election in 2016. So maybe I'll throw it all out and out and out polling here Yeah, to some extent, but I think there've been a couple of things I think people are completely disengaged and completely cynical So, you know, if you write rightly so do you think? Yeah, probably I think people should be engaged But you know if you write a story saying the government has been biting the heads off chooks You know people just sort of tend to say yeah, well, that'd be right I mean you can't shock people anymore about how bad politics is So that makes it hard to have any impact And of course, you know the figures on where people get their news now are really sort of quite staggering You know the number of people who only get it via Facebook or Twitter or some other Platform who don't actually watch the news or current affairs And I think if you look at the reach of sky news after dark into regional Australia Which I think is one of the really interesting sort of largely untold stories on free-to-air television I was thinking about that when you when you were talking about the odds and the fact that in terms of rural towns Yeah, it was one of the few papers that yeah, yeah, the few national papers I thought sky after dark they're moving into some more regional areas for free to air really yeah And it's cheap for the real ores and everybody's happy but Yeah, no, I think you know it is a problem. The media is fractured People aren't interested in all the fights.

They just want to know what's happening And I but I think if there's a positive that should come out of the pandemic it is that you know, it's it's made people You know desperately keen to find out what's going on again So, you know, if you talk to anybody in in nalban or victoria, you know during a lockdown last year It was a ritual that everybody just watched the dan andris press conference Which might explain the sort of you know whole you know Dafication of Dan thing because he'd stand there and just answer questions to run out of questions Which I think is an admirable thing whether you like the answers or not. So The global pandemic does change things, but I don't think that the government is tifflin Coated I think it's interesting the last news poll shows that the federal government was and certainly it's got marasins ratings were falling as a result of Victorian lockdown so it shows that people are distinguishing a little bit You know the victorian polls are also sort of being hit because people are really angry about you know The business is closing down but this they are they can see this is the bit and I'm angry about victoria about and this is a bit I'm angry with Scott Morrison the government about so you know It's it's it's still hard to see given the seats that the government has to lose and they've has to win around the country You know how how a change comes about because there isn't that sort of sense of mood for change and The whole thing about stability and times of crisis and all those sorts of things But I don't think you can sort of just presume that people aren't you know aren't registering and I mean I I'm sort of quite the dangers of anecdotal things But I ran into a woman who I sort of served me in a shop for years and years who volunteer that she was a coalition voter and ex military and things and you know It's one of those sort of Michael A them and John Howard handshake moment things where she just she was saying Oh, I just can't believe how bad the government is on how bad Morrison is she didn't say the promise how bad Morrison is on handling this vaccination all out And I said I will you know it's not something to begin to well or something and she said and why have we all got to have AstraZeneca when he had Pfizer and you know It's those really and that comes out a lot you know People notice that he got Pfizer and they can't get it and you know We get sort of so obsessed about the big things in politics itself and it's something like that which really gets under people's skin because it's something really identifiable That they can go well wait a minute if it's good enough for him not me Interesting interesting. Do you worry that the media has lost the power to shift the debate and shift the narrative at all? No, I think our job is to inform people and for them to demand answers and often people aren't out there demanding answers except yelling at General Santuetown's Ted But I mean I'm philosophical about it.

I mean I suppose my view is newspaper started as pamphlets And you know and they were they all like the Australian Only promoting different sort of arguments the idea that we're all just incredibly balanced and papers of record is quite a new invention And I suppose I am actually encouraged Maybe it's my optimistic streak, but you know, yes It's bad that you get the fragmentation of media if a story takes off, you know Often the media doesn't all jump on board and pursue it as they should but at the same time We've got such a diversity of outlets now of varying quality that even if What people the means to media aren't covering something it's usually out there And I can think of lots of examples of that and why isn't the mainstream media covering it? Well, it's not through any conspiratorial silence There's only so many minutes in a program and there are some things that you've got to cover and it's harder to break out and do other things But so I'm incredibly grateful and relieved that there is so much scrutiny being put on Politicians of whatever persuasion. It's not as organized as once was it's much more hidden miss And I think the fact that the you know the institutions have gotten like the public service Sort of much less than they were Makes it harder to cover these things, but they are being covered and I think that's a good thing Who do you think is doing a really good job at the moment in terms of when you look at some of the broadsheets or the You know, pretty media broadcast. Who do you think?

Uh, ABC's side of course. I think the Guardian website has really come into its own My colleague Lenore Taylor has lifted that I mean it was good anyway, but um and I think the blog format works Really really well for them and they do go off and do the investigations You know, they put the resources into into chasing stories. So I think that's great I think the scene on herald has really come back, you know from a from a fairly low point of a year ago They've got a lot of good people on board and they've become a really good newspaper again I think krikey's really lifted its game in the last 12 or 18 months and a pete fray And you know, I like the long-form style of the set-a-day paper and the monthly. So yeah, I think all of those, you know, good things to look at Lastly while we've been unpacking some of the biggest issues facing the country and our media You still obviously believe in the profession of journalism.

What message do you have for young journalists starting out? I'll just do it. You know Just go for it and have a work for Nike and just do it. I'm sorry.

Sorry. Sorry. I didn't realize what I said. Oh my god I wasn't a subliminal plug.

I don't even know I think that's a good um yeah, yeah, yeah, you know, I just I Suppose it's you know, remember what it is that you're trying to do I mean I used to be asked to talk to groups of university students doing journalism and it became a bit of a sort of running joke actually because Somebody would sort of eat me on to say something say how many of you want to be anchor people and like 80% of them And it was sort of like they want to be famous, you know, the thing to do is to actually be going what am I here for? I'm actually here to tell a story Let my readers viewers whatever make up their own mind They might disagree with what I'm saying but I want to give them some information And I want to give them a framework for thinking about the information because I think the role of journalists has changed a lot because we're bombarded with information now But most of us don't have time to actually absorb it So I think the job of journalism is actually to undertake to understand what the issue is And right from that perspective, not just say, you know dog bites man It's just say, you know, well, what's the context for this dog biting the man I mean that that is where the value is and I don't think collectively we spend enough time actually Apprising ourselves of the you know the background of a story the history of an issue and and reporting on it from it Informed perspective Laura Tingle, thank you so much for joining us in Fourth Estate My pleasure And thank you for listening to Fourth Estate This edition was recorded out the studios of Tua CR and heard across the country on the community radio network Fourth Estate is produced with the assistance of the community broadcasting foundation Thanks to the foundation for their continuing support Make sure you subscribe to Fourth Estate on your favorite podcast app So you can hear us talk media, politics and a lot in between We'll be back with more next week of course but in the meantime you can stay in touch with us on Twitter I'll handle this Fourth Estate, are you? A big thanks as always to my executive producer Anthony Dockrell My name's Nina Quinn, you can catch us next week on Fourth Estate

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Fourth Estate?

This episode is 48 minutes long.

When was this Fourth Estate episode published?

This episode was published on June 10, 2021.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Fourth Estate episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.